2. Synopsis
Synopsis
The material in this presentation is designed to encourage students to think
about synopsis. The idea behind synoptic questions is to assess students’
understanding of the general principles on which so much of the subject
depends, which is much more important than simple recall of knowledge.
This presentation supports the article ‘Tales from the museum’ by Henry McGhie
in the April 2014 issue of Biological Sciences Review. The presentation is based
on three different exercises; these may be used independently.
The questions and the accompanying mark schemes are available as a separate
Word document.
3. Synopsis
Synopsis is about
• understanding the principles
Taking diffusion as an example, all specifications consider this
topic relatively early in the AS course. An understanding of
diffusion is essential to the understanding of a number of
topics considered later in the course.
Diffusion
Nerve impulses
Gas exchange
Digestion
4. Synopsis
Enzymes
?
Synopsis is about
• understanding the principles
Another such topic is enzymes. Students might wish to think
about specific enzymes that link to different aspects of
physiology.
?
?
6. Synopsis
What are these principles?
• Diffusion
• Enzymes
• Polymerisation, condensation and hydrolysis
• Osmosis
• Active transport
• Respiration and ATP
• Size and surface-area-to-volume ratio
• Natural selection
• How science works …
?
7. Synopsis
Synopsis is like a
birthday present.
You may not recognise
the wrapping paper but
you know exactly what
is inside.
8. Synopsis
You may not be familiar
with the context but you
should know all about the
principles on which the
question is based.
You may know nothing
about snails…but the
question may be asking you
about selection or
respiration.
Synopsis is about
• relating the principles to new contexts
9. Synopsis
You may know nothing
about possums…but the
question is asking you
about ‘how science works’
and surface-area-to-volume
ratios
You may not be familiar
with the context but you
should know all about the
principles on which the
question is based.
Synopsis is about
• relating the principles to new contexts
10. Synopsis
• Brush-tail possums are
mammals that are native to
Australia.
• They were introduced to New
Zealand mainly in the years
1890 to 1900.
• The total number of possums
released was between 200
and 300.
• Possums are now widespread
in New Zealand and, in
suitable habitats, reach
population densities of up to
30 animals per hectare.
Possums
11. Synopsis
Location Latitude Total length/mm Tail length/mm
Auckland 36°37’ 786 321
Hawke’s Bay 39°43’ 787 322
Wairurapa 40°54’ 780 297
Orongorongo Valley 41°22’ 789 328
Nelson 41°55’ 831 356
Taramakau River 42°45’ 840 n/a
Lengths of male possums from
different parts of New Zealand
12. Synopsis
1(a) The measurements in the table were obtained from
labels attached to museum skins. It would not be reliable
to measure the actual skins. Suggest why. (2 marks)
The process of preparation is likely to lead to a change in length
of the actual skin;
May be stretched/may shrink (as it dries);
13. Synopsis
1(b) Suggest why all the data were collected from
animals of one sex. (2 marks)
Ensures that the data will be comparable;
Because sex is likely to influence size;
14. Synopsis
2 How would you expect mean annual temperature to
vary with latitude? (1 mark)
Mean annual temperature should decrease with latitude;
15. Synopsis
3 The scientists who collected the data in the table
predicted that body size would be positively correlated
with latitude.
(a) Suggest why larger body size would be an advantage
to a possum further south. (3 marks)
17. Synopsis
3 The scientists who collected the data in the table
predicted that body size would be positively correlated
with latitude.
(a) Suggest why larger body size would be an advantage
to a possum further south. (3 marks)
A larger animal would have a smaller surface-area-to-volume
ratio;
Would lose less heat;
In colder conditions;
18. Synopsis
Evaluate means judge the worth of something.
• Look for ways in which the data support the prediction.
• Now write the word but
• And look for ways in which the prediction is not supported by
the data.
3 The scientists who collected the data in the table
predicted that body size would be positively correlated
with latitude.
(b) Use the data in the table to evaluate this prediction.
(3 marks)
19. Synopsis
Location Latitude Total length/mm Tail length/mm
Auckland 36°37’ 786 321
Hawke’s Bay 39°43’ 787 322
Wairurapa 40°54’ 780 297
Orongorongo Valley 41°22’ 789 328
Nelson 41°55’ 831 356
Taramakau River 42°45’ 840 n/a
Lengths of male possums from
different parts of New Zealand
20. Synopsis
There is a positive correlation between total length and
latitude/total length increases with latitude;
(but)
If tail length is subtracted from total length;
There is little/no correlation between body length and latitude;
Other factors/factors such as altitude may also affect mean
temperature; 3 max
3 (b) Use the data in the table to evaluate this
prediction. (3 marks)
21. Synopsis
You may know nothing
about peregrines or
sparrowhawks…but the
question is asking you about
‘how science works’ and
food chains and food webs
You may not be familiar with
the context but you should
know all about the principles
on which the question is based.
Synopsis is about
• relating the principles to new contexts
Eggs and pesticides
22. Synopsis
Egg shell
thickness
index
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980
Date
1 Organochlorine insecticides in common use to treat crops
2 Organochlorine insecticides used to treat seeds
3 Partial ban and reduced use of organochlorine insecticides
2.0
1.6
1.2
0.8
Peregrine
Sparrowhawk
1 2 3
23. Synopsis
The eggs are museum specimens/valuable/cannot be
replaced;
The index does not involve breaking them/measuring the
thickness involves breaking them;
1 The egg shell thickness index was calculated from the
formula:
thickness index = mass of egg shell (mg)
length × breadth of egg (mm)
(a) Suggest why this index was used rather than
measuring the actual thickness of the egg shell. (2 marks)
24. Synopsis
1 The egg shell thickness index was calculated from the
formula:
thickness index = mass of egg shell (mg)
length × breadth of egg (mm)
(b) The mass of the egg shell was divided by its length ×
breadth. Explain why it was necessary to divide by the
length × breadth. (1 mark)
The mass of the egg shell will depend on the size of the
egg/length × breadth gives a measure of the egg size;
25. Synopsis
2 Both the peregrine and the sparrowhawk feed on
birds. Use your knowledge of food chains and food webs
to explain:
(a) how organochlorine insecticides used to treat seeds
enter the tissues of a sparrowhawk (1 mark)
(b) why the concentration of organochlorine insecticide
in the tissues of a peregrine falcon is much higher than
the concentration on the seeds (2 marks)
26. Synopsis
The food chains involved in this question
Seeds Wood pigeon Peregrine falcon
Seeds Chaffinch Sparrowhawk
27. Synopsis
(Transfer through the food chain) via an intermediate seed-
eating bird/appropriate example;
2 Both the peregrine and the sparrowhawk feed on
birds. Use your knowledge of food chains and food webs
to explain:
(a) how organochlorine insecticides used to treat seeds
enter the tissues of a sparrowhawk (1 mark)
28. Synopsis
Insecticide taken up by primary consumer/example from
part (a) and accumulates/not broken down in tissues;
Primary consumer eats many seeds so higher concentration in
its tissues;
Process repeated in secondary consumer; max 2
2 Both the peregrine and the sparrowhawk feed on
birds. Use your knowledge of food chains and food webs
to explain:
(b) why the concentration of organochlorine insecticide
in the tissues of a peregrine falcon is much higher than
the concentration on the seeds (2 marks)
29. Synopsis
3 In a scientific paper published in 1977, the biologist
R. K. Murton pointed out that many biologists assumed
egg shell thinning was harmful. They considered that if
a population lays eggs with thin shells and at the same
time is declining, there must be a causal relationship.
(a) Suggest how egg shell thinning may lead to lower
breeding success. (1 mark)
Eggs with thinner shells are more likely to be broken
(during incubation).
30. Synopsis
(b) Explain why a decline in number of birds may not
necessarily be caused by egg shell thinning. (2 marks)
Another factor may be involved;
Which might be linked to both decline in birds and egg-shell
thinning;
31. Synopsis
You may know nothing
about tigers…but the
question is asking you
about selection,
mitochondria and DNA.
You may not be familiar with
the context but you should
know all about the principles on
which the question is based.
Synopsis is about
• relating the principles to new contexts
Tigers
32. Synopsis
1 Preservation of genetic variability in rare or
endangered species may help them to survive. Use your
knowledge of natural selection to explain why. (2 marks)
Some forms may be at an advantage/be better adapted;
If there is a change in the environment of the organism;
33. Synopsis
2 In order to assess tiger genetic variation, it was
important that samples were taken from tigers that
originally came from different geographical areas.
Explain why it was important that these tigers did not
come from the same geographical area. (2 marks)
If they came from the same area they would be more likely to
be genetically similar;
Because they might be related/might be adapted to similar
conditions/might have had the same ancestors;
We need to know about all tigers; max 2
34. Synopsis
3 The mutation rate in mtDNA is faster than that in
nuclear DNA because of differences in the DNA repair
systems. Suggest how these differences could result in
a slower mutation rate in nuclear DNA. (2 marks)
Mutations in nuclear DNA may be removed/repaired (by the
repair system);
System only found in nucleus/not found in mitochondria;
35. Synopsis
4 If a tiger was born in a zoo, it may be useful to know
the origin of the female parent if its mtDNA is to be
studied. Explain why. (2 marks)
37. Synopsis
This will tell you the geographical origin of its mtDNA;
Because it is inherited from its mother;
4 If a tiger was born in a zoo, it may be useful to know
the origin of the female parent if its mtDNA is to be
studied. Explain why. (2 marks)
38. Synopsis
5 Suppose there were five sites on an mtDNA molecule
where it could be cut by the restriction enzyme. How
many pieces of DNA would result? Explain your answer.
(2 marks)
Five;
Because mtDNA is circular;
39. Synopsis
6 A polymorphic site is a site on a DNA molecule where
the sequence of bases is different in different animals.
(a) A particular restriction enzyme may cut the DNA
from one leopard but not from another at a particular
site. Explain why. (3 marks)
Sequence of bases is different;
Only a specific sequence fits/binds;
With active site of a particular enzyme;
There are three examples here: amylase in the digestive system, acetylcholinesterase in the nervous system and carbonic anhydrase in red blood cells. Obviously, there are other possibilities.
Identifying and understanding these principles is essential if a candidate is to be able to answer synoptic questions effectively. Such a list may be achieved by brain-storming. This slide provides a starting point.
A second aspect of synoptic questions is that they often relate to applying the principles to new situations. A bit like a birthday present in some ways. You know exactly what it is going to be but the wrapping paper is unfamiliar.
So, there could be, for example, a question about snails…but it isn’t really about snails. it is actually about a familiar principle such as selection or respiration.
Identifying the principles involved is the all-important first step in answering synoptic questions.
Armed with this tip we will look at the first of the exercises.
This exercise is about possums…or is it? Look at the individual questions carefully and you can see that it is really a question about ‘how science works’ and surface-area-to-volume ratios.
Students may know nothing about possums. This is not a problem as all the information required will be supplied in the question. Since this is not an examination question, there is a little more information that is strictly necessary here.
This slide is simply a summary of the data provided in the question. Students may need assistance with the concept of latitude, although there is an explanation on the accompanying question sheet.
Question 1 links possums and ‘how science works’. Allow 1 mark for the idea of change in length and a second for a specific, more detailed answer. The second point on its own is worth 2 marks.
This is a straightforward question but it should establish the principles required to answer question 3.
Question 3 relates to the important principle that the larger an animal, the smaller its surface-area-to-volume ratio (see next slide).
This slide, based on cubes of different side length, should remind students of the principle. Although this is basic, in examinations candidates make frequent errors. In particular they do not always appreciate that
the larger an animal, the smaller its surface-area-to-volume ratio
it is surface-area-to-volume ratio, not surface area
Once the principle has been established, this question should be straightforward.
This question requires evaluation so should be approached in what is effectively a standard way.
This slide is a summary of the data provided in the question.
The first marking point should be straightforward but the second and third are intentionally more challenging.
Again, this exercise may look as though it is about an unfamiliar topic — birds of prey and their eggs…but, is it? Look at the individual questions carefully and you can see that it is really a question about ‘how science works’ and food chains and food webs.
This slide is simply a copy of the graph shown on the question sheet.
Question 1(a) requires the application of a little common sense and an appreciation of the value of museum specimens.
The answer to question 1(b) might be expressed in a variety of ways. It is testing an understanding of the denominator in the expression.
Many A-level candidates have a simplistic view of food chains and rarely progress beyond ‘grass, rabbit, fox’. It may be worth looking at two possible food chains that may relate to this question. The actual species do not matter but students do need to go further than ‘bird’ and will hopefully appreciate that not all birds are ‘sparrows’. This slide shows two examples relevant to this question.
A straightforward question but elementary errors may occur.
This question tests the principle of bioaccumulation. Points 1 and 2 could be answered in terms of secondary consumer and primary consumer.
Although this is a ‘suggest’ question, this is the most likely answer.
The last question in this section tests another important principle, namely that correlation does not necessarily mean causation. However, It requires students to go a little further than simply stating this principle. Accept an example of another factor provided there is a plausible link with both egg-shell thinning and the decline in population.
Once again, the starting point for this (more challenging) question is to identify the familiar.
Although there are other reasonable suggestions that might be made about the advantages of genetic variability, the question requires students to link this to natural selection.
Question 2 and its mark scheme
Note that this question requires students to explain the slower rate in nuclear DNA. It should be more straightforward this way.
To answer this question, students may need to be reminded of the way in which mtDNA is inherited. This is summarised in slide 36.
Students need to appreciate that the cytoplasm in the zygote comes from the female gamete. It will contain mitochondria.
Question 4 and its mark scheme.
Provided students have taken on board the fact that mtDNA is circular, they should appreciate that there will be as many pieces as there are cleavage sites. A diagram may help.
The key here is to note the mark allocation. 3 marks gives an idea of the depth of answer required.
Slides 40 and 41 cover question 6 (b)
Slides 40 and 41 cover question 6 (b). Note that in this question the term allele should be used. Gene is not acceptable in this context.