SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 26
Designing on PurposeSchwartz Center Speaker Series Donald M. Berwick, MD President and CEO Institute for Healthcare Improvement September 17, 2009
Designing on Purpose Integrate what? Integrate why? Begin with an exploration of purpose. Then seek designs capable of achieving that purpose.
The IOM Roundtable “Overuse, Underuse, and Misuse” Quality Is… “The degree to which health services for individuals and populations increase the likelihood of desired health outcomes and are consistent with current professional knowledge.”
The Woods Hole Meeting - 2002
“New Rules” for Health Care Care based on continuous healing relationships Customization based on patient needs and values The patient as the source of control Shared knowledge and the free flow of information Evidence-based decision making
“New Rules” for Health Care Safety as a system property The need for transparency Anticipation of needs Continuous decrease in waste Cooperation
“They give me exactly the help I need and want exactly when I need and want it.”  (John Wasson Modification…) “They give me exactly the help I need and want exactly when and how I need and want it.”  IHI Measure of Patient-Centeredness
Deepening the Definition “The needs of the patient come first.” (Mayo Clinic) “Nothing about me without me.” (Diane Plamping) “Every patient is the only patient.” (Art Berarducci)
My Proposed Working Definition Patient-Centeredness: “The experience (to the extent the informed, individual patient desires it) of transparency, individualization, recognition, respect, dignity, and choice in all matters, without exception, related to one’s person, circumstances, and relationships in health care.”
Eliot Freidson: Profession of Medicine A profession is a work group that reserves to itself the authority to judge the quality of its own work. Granted by society in return for an assumption of: Altruism Specialized Expertise Self-Regulation
The “Triple Aim” Population Health Experience of Care Per Capita Cost 11
Defining “Health” The Extent to Which the  Body Can Heal Itself
A Question What do you want?
A Question What do you really want?
A Question What do you really, really want?
Try This… Integrative Medicine is health care that offers you the best shot at getting what you really, really want.
Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center
Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize
Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones
Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care
Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care Maximize Healing Influences outside Care
Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care Maximize Healing Influences outside Care Rely on Sophisticated, Disciplined Evidence
Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care Maximize Healing Influences outside Care Rely on Sophisticated, Disciplined Evidence Use All Relevant Capacities – Waste Nothing
Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care Maximize Healing Influences outside Care Rely on Sophisticated, Disciplined Evidence Use All Relevant Capacities – Waste Nothing Connect Helping Influences with Each Other
Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care Maximize Healing Influences outside Care Rely on Sophisticated, Disciplined Evidence Use All Relevant Capacities – Waste Nothing Connect Helping Influences with Each Other
Defining “Health” The Extent to Which the  Body Can Heal Itself

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

What Referring Physicians Want - Gelb Consulting
What Referring Physicians Want - Gelb ConsultingWhat Referring Physicians Want - Gelb Consulting
What Referring Physicians Want - Gelb ConsultingEndeavor Management
 
The Clinician's Role in Developing a Patient Experience Strategy
The Clinician's Role in Developing a Patient Experience StrategyThe Clinician's Role in Developing a Patient Experience Strategy
The Clinician's Role in Developing a Patient Experience StrategyRenown Health
 
Improving patients' experiences
Improving patients' experiencesImproving patients' experiences
Improving patients' experiencesminu2
 
Prioritizing Patient Experience in Healthcare
Prioritizing Patient Experience in HealthcarePrioritizing Patient Experience in Healthcare
Prioritizing Patient Experience in HealthcareQuality Reviews Inc
 
Importance of Measuring Patient Satisfaction
Importance of Measuring Patient SatisfactionImportance of Measuring Patient Satisfaction
Importance of Measuring Patient SatisfactionZonkaFeedback
 
Medical Service Disruption: Retail Clinics
Medical Service Disruption: Retail ClinicsMedical Service Disruption: Retail Clinics
Medical Service Disruption: Retail ClinicsTacara
 
10 Must Know Techniques for Managing Physician Relations in Today's Digital W...
10 Must Know Techniques for Managing Physician Relations in Today's Digital W...10 Must Know Techniques for Managing Physician Relations in Today's Digital W...
10 Must Know Techniques for Managing Physician Relations in Today's Digital W...Endeavor Management
 
Scaling Innovation in Academic Medical Centers
Scaling Innovation in Academic Medical CentersScaling Innovation in Academic Medical Centers
Scaling Innovation in Academic Medical CentersMaulik Majmudar
 
A care coordination handout
A care coordination handoutA care coordination handout
A care coordination handoutchandice2
 
Daniel Jackson, UCB
Daniel Jackson, UCBDaniel Jackson, UCB
Daniel Jackson, UCBGoPrezi
 
10 Ways To Enhance Patient Experience
10 Ways To Enhance Patient Experience10 Ways To Enhance Patient Experience
10 Ways To Enhance Patient ExperienceTitan Web Agency
 
Experience Led Care Presentation Linked In
Experience Led Care Presentation Linked InExperience Led Care Presentation Linked In
Experience Led Care Presentation Linked InGeorginacraigassociates
 
The State of Consumer Healthcare: A Study of Patient Experience
The State of Consumer Healthcare: A Study of Patient ExperienceThe State of Consumer Healthcare: A Study of Patient Experience
The State of Consumer Healthcare: A Study of Patient ExperienceProphet
 
Build Physician Relationships that Drive Business Results; Part 2
Build Physician Relationships that Drive Business Results; Part 2Build Physician Relationships that Drive Business Results; Part 2
Build Physician Relationships that Drive Business Results; Part 2Renown Health
 
Webinar: Too Old to Practice: Should There Be a Cut-Off Age for Physicians?
Webinar: Too Old to Practice: Should There Be a Cut-Off Age for Physicians?Webinar: Too Old to Practice: Should There Be a Cut-Off Age for Physicians?
Webinar: Too Old to Practice: Should There Be a Cut-Off Age for Physicians?Douglas Backstrom, MBA
 

Mais procurados (20)

What Referring Physicians Want - Gelb Consulting
What Referring Physicians Want - Gelb ConsultingWhat Referring Physicians Want - Gelb Consulting
What Referring Physicians Want - Gelb Consulting
 
The Clinician's Role in Developing a Patient Experience Strategy
The Clinician's Role in Developing a Patient Experience StrategyThe Clinician's Role in Developing a Patient Experience Strategy
The Clinician's Role in Developing a Patient Experience Strategy
 
Improving patients' experiences
Improving patients' experiencesImproving patients' experiences
Improving patients' experiences
 
Prioritizing Patient Experience in Healthcare
Prioritizing Patient Experience in HealthcarePrioritizing Patient Experience in Healthcare
Prioritizing Patient Experience in Healthcare
 
Importance of Measuring Patient Satisfaction
Importance of Measuring Patient SatisfactionImportance of Measuring Patient Satisfaction
Importance of Measuring Patient Satisfaction
 
Q-ROUNDING
Q-ROUNDINGQ-ROUNDING
Q-ROUNDING
 
20150826-AST1-Agenda
20150826-AST1-Agenda20150826-AST1-Agenda
20150826-AST1-Agenda
 
Medical Service Disruption: Retail Clinics
Medical Service Disruption: Retail ClinicsMedical Service Disruption: Retail Clinics
Medical Service Disruption: Retail Clinics
 
Health Economics and Burden of Disease Breakout Report
Health Economics and Burden of Disease Breakout ReportHealth Economics and Burden of Disease Breakout Report
Health Economics and Burden of Disease Breakout Report
 
Defining a global patient experience for your health system
Defining a global patient experience for your health systemDefining a global patient experience for your health system
Defining a global patient experience for your health system
 
10 Must Know Techniques for Managing Physician Relations in Today's Digital W...
10 Must Know Techniques for Managing Physician Relations in Today's Digital W...10 Must Know Techniques for Managing Physician Relations in Today's Digital W...
10 Must Know Techniques for Managing Physician Relations in Today's Digital W...
 
Scaling Innovation in Academic Medical Centers
Scaling Innovation in Academic Medical CentersScaling Innovation in Academic Medical Centers
Scaling Innovation in Academic Medical Centers
 
A care coordination handout
A care coordination handoutA care coordination handout
A care coordination handout
 
Daniel Jackson, UCB
Daniel Jackson, UCBDaniel Jackson, UCB
Daniel Jackson, UCB
 
10 Ways To Enhance Patient Experience
10 Ways To Enhance Patient Experience10 Ways To Enhance Patient Experience
10 Ways To Enhance Patient Experience
 
Patient Shared Decision Making
Patient Shared Decision MakingPatient Shared Decision Making
Patient Shared Decision Making
 
Experience Led Care Presentation Linked In
Experience Led Care Presentation Linked InExperience Led Care Presentation Linked In
Experience Led Care Presentation Linked In
 
The State of Consumer Healthcare: A Study of Patient Experience
The State of Consumer Healthcare: A Study of Patient ExperienceThe State of Consumer Healthcare: A Study of Patient Experience
The State of Consumer Healthcare: A Study of Patient Experience
 
Build Physician Relationships that Drive Business Results; Part 2
Build Physician Relationships that Drive Business Results; Part 2Build Physician Relationships that Drive Business Results; Part 2
Build Physician Relationships that Drive Business Results; Part 2
 
Webinar: Too Old to Practice: Should There Be a Cut-Off Age for Physicians?
Webinar: Too Old to Practice: Should There Be a Cut-Off Age for Physicians?Webinar: Too Old to Practice: Should There Be a Cut-Off Age for Physicians?
Webinar: Too Old to Practice: Should There Be a Cut-Off Age for Physicians?
 

Semelhante a "Patient-Centeredness and Patient Safety: How Are They Interconnected?" Don Berwick, MD

Better Knowledge. Better Health? Making Research Relevant, Accessible, and P...
Better Knowledge. Better Health?  Making Research Relevant, Accessible, and P...Better Knowledge. Better Health?  Making Research Relevant, Accessible, and P...
Better Knowledge. Better Health? Making Research Relevant, Accessible, and P...Marie Ennis-O'Connor
 
Family Centered Care Framework
Family Centered Care FrameworkFamily Centered Care Framework
Family Centered Care FrameworkMegan Espinoza
 
Consumer Attitudes About Comparative Effectiveness
Consumer Attitudes About Comparative EffectivenessConsumer Attitudes About Comparative Effectiveness
Consumer Attitudes About Comparative EffectivenessMSL
 
Jocelyn Cornwell: How can organisations support patients to lead quality impr...
Jocelyn Cornwell: How can organisations support patients to lead quality impr...Jocelyn Cornwell: How can organisations support patients to lead quality impr...
Jocelyn Cornwell: How can organisations support patients to lead quality impr...The King's Fund
 
Transform Healthcare, Tap Into A Great Low Cost Resource
Transform Healthcare, Tap Into A Great Low Cost ResourceTransform Healthcare, Tap Into A Great Low Cost Resource
Transform Healthcare, Tap Into A Great Low Cost Resourcedandelt
 
Team-Building Leadership Essay Examples
Team-Building Leadership Essay ExamplesTeam-Building Leadership Essay Examples
Team-Building Leadership Essay ExamplesJessica Deakin
 
HXR 2016: Designing Within a Hospital System: Challenges and Strategies
HXR 2016: Designing Within a Hospital System: Challenges and StrategiesHXR 2016: Designing Within a Hospital System: Challenges and Strategies
HXR 2016: Designing Within a Hospital System: Challenges and StrategiesHxRefactored
 
IoT, Big Data Healthcare Summit Western Canada - Connecting With Technology -...
IoT, Big Data Healthcare Summit Western Canada - Connecting With Technology -...IoT, Big Data Healthcare Summit Western Canada - Connecting With Technology -...
IoT, Big Data Healthcare Summit Western Canada - Connecting With Technology -...Ingunn Grip Fjær
 
Putting Patients First
Putting Patients FirstPutting Patients First
Putting Patients FirstBrian Ahier
 
Nsp—The Opportunity
Nsp—The OpportunityNsp—The Opportunity
Nsp—The OpportunityMary Born, ND
 
Holistic healing or spiritualism? pt 2
Holistic healing or spiritualism? pt 2Holistic healing or spiritualism? pt 2
Holistic healing or spiritualism? pt 2i ALERT
 
Doing change sustainably
Doing change sustainablyDoing change sustainably
Doing change sustainablyHelen Bevan
 
Advancing Effective Communicationcommunication, Cultural...
Advancing Effective Communicationcommunication, Cultural...Advancing Effective Communicationcommunication, Cultural...
Advancing Effective Communicationcommunication, Cultural...Beth Johnson
 

Semelhante a "Patient-Centeredness and Patient Safety: How Are They Interconnected?" Don Berwick, MD (20)

Better Knowledge. Better Health? Making Research Relevant, Accessible, and P...
Better Knowledge. Better Health?  Making Research Relevant, Accessible, and P...Better Knowledge. Better Health?  Making Research Relevant, Accessible, and P...
Better Knowledge. Better Health? Making Research Relevant, Accessible, and P...
 
Family Centered Care Framework
Family Centered Care FrameworkFamily Centered Care Framework
Family Centered Care Framework
 
Consumer Attitudes About Comparative Effectiveness
Consumer Attitudes About Comparative EffectivenessConsumer Attitudes About Comparative Effectiveness
Consumer Attitudes About Comparative Effectiveness
 
Jocelyn Cornwell: How can organisations support patients to lead quality impr...
Jocelyn Cornwell: How can organisations support patients to lead quality impr...Jocelyn Cornwell: How can organisations support patients to lead quality impr...
Jocelyn Cornwell: How can organisations support patients to lead quality impr...
 
Principles of Navigation
Principles of NavigationPrinciples of Navigation
Principles of Navigation
 
Transform Healthcare, Tap Into A Great Low Cost Resource
Transform Healthcare, Tap Into A Great Low Cost ResourceTransform Healthcare, Tap Into A Great Low Cost Resource
Transform Healthcare, Tap Into A Great Low Cost Resource
 
Quality of life experiences No.1
Quality of life experiences No.1Quality of life experiences No.1
Quality of life experiences No.1
 
Health Information and Consumer-Centred Care
Health Information and Consumer-Centred CareHealth Information and Consumer-Centred Care
Health Information and Consumer-Centred Care
 
Team-Building Leadership Essay Examples
Team-Building Leadership Essay ExamplesTeam-Building Leadership Essay Examples
Team-Building Leadership Essay Examples
 
HXR 2016: Designing Within a Hospital System: Challenges and Strategies
HXR 2016: Designing Within a Hospital System: Challenges and StrategiesHXR 2016: Designing Within a Hospital System: Challenges and Strategies
HXR 2016: Designing Within a Hospital System: Challenges and Strategies
 
Learning Health Care Systems
Learning Health Care SystemsLearning Health Care Systems
Learning Health Care Systems
 
Johnson, lorraine cue 6.4.12 final final
Johnson, lorraine   cue 6.4.12 final finalJohnson, lorraine   cue 6.4.12 final final
Johnson, lorraine cue 6.4.12 final final
 
IoT, Big Data Healthcare Summit Western Canada - Connecting With Technology -...
IoT, Big Data Healthcare Summit Western Canada - Connecting With Technology -...IoT, Big Data Healthcare Summit Western Canada - Connecting With Technology -...
IoT, Big Data Healthcare Summit Western Canada - Connecting With Technology -...
 
Putting Patients First
Putting Patients FirstPutting Patients First
Putting Patients First
 
Health Care Essay
Health Care EssayHealth Care Essay
Health Care Essay
 
P4 Medicine May 2011
P4 Medicine May 2011P4 Medicine May 2011
P4 Medicine May 2011
 
Nsp—The Opportunity
Nsp—The OpportunityNsp—The Opportunity
Nsp—The Opportunity
 
Holistic healing or spiritualism? pt 2
Holistic healing or spiritualism? pt 2Holistic healing or spiritualism? pt 2
Holistic healing or spiritualism? pt 2
 
Doing change sustainably
Doing change sustainablyDoing change sustainably
Doing change sustainably
 
Advancing Effective Communicationcommunication, Cultural...
Advancing Effective Communicationcommunication, Cultural...Advancing Effective Communicationcommunication, Cultural...
Advancing Effective Communicationcommunication, Cultural...
 

"Patient-Centeredness and Patient Safety: How Are They Interconnected?" Don Berwick, MD

  • 1. Designing on PurposeSchwartz Center Speaker Series Donald M. Berwick, MD President and CEO Institute for Healthcare Improvement September 17, 2009
  • 2. Designing on Purpose Integrate what? Integrate why? Begin with an exploration of purpose. Then seek designs capable of achieving that purpose.
  • 3. The IOM Roundtable “Overuse, Underuse, and Misuse” Quality Is… “The degree to which health services for individuals and populations increase the likelihood of desired health outcomes and are consistent with current professional knowledge.”
  • 4. The Woods Hole Meeting - 2002
  • 5. “New Rules” for Health Care Care based on continuous healing relationships Customization based on patient needs and values The patient as the source of control Shared knowledge and the free flow of information Evidence-based decision making
  • 6. “New Rules” for Health Care Safety as a system property The need for transparency Anticipation of needs Continuous decrease in waste Cooperation
  • 7. “They give me exactly the help I need and want exactly when I need and want it.” (John Wasson Modification…) “They give me exactly the help I need and want exactly when and how I need and want it.” IHI Measure of Patient-Centeredness
  • 8. Deepening the Definition “The needs of the patient come first.” (Mayo Clinic) “Nothing about me without me.” (Diane Plamping) “Every patient is the only patient.” (Art Berarducci)
  • 9. My Proposed Working Definition Patient-Centeredness: “The experience (to the extent the informed, individual patient desires it) of transparency, individualization, recognition, respect, dignity, and choice in all matters, without exception, related to one’s person, circumstances, and relationships in health care.”
  • 10. Eliot Freidson: Profession of Medicine A profession is a work group that reserves to itself the authority to judge the quality of its own work. Granted by society in return for an assumption of: Altruism Specialized Expertise Self-Regulation
  • 11. The “Triple Aim” Population Health Experience of Care Per Capita Cost 11
  • 12. Defining “Health” The Extent to Which the Body Can Heal Itself
  • 13. A Question What do you want?
  • 14. A Question What do you really want?
  • 15. A Question What do you really, really want?
  • 16. Try This… Integrative Medicine is health care that offers you the best shot at getting what you really, really want.
  • 17. Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center
  • 18. Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize
  • 19. Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones
  • 20. Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care
  • 21. Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care Maximize Healing Influences outside Care
  • 22. Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care Maximize Healing Influences outside Care Rely on Sophisticated, Disciplined Evidence
  • 23. Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care Maximize Healing Influences outside Care Rely on Sophisticated, Disciplined Evidence Use All Relevant Capacities – Waste Nothing
  • 24. Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care Maximize Healing Influences outside Care Rely on Sophisticated, Disciplined Evidence Use All Relevant Capacities – Waste Nothing Connect Helping Influences with Each Other
  • 25. Design of Integrative Care Place the Patient at the Center Individualize Welcome Family and Loved Ones Maximize Healing Influences within Care Maximize Healing Influences outside Care Rely on Sophisticated, Disciplined Evidence Use All Relevant Capacities – Waste Nothing Connect Helping Influences with Each Other
  • 26. Defining “Health” The Extent to Which the Body Can Heal Itself

Notas do Editor

  1. Harvey Fineberg’s mentioning the WHO definition of health.
  2. The designs ought to return to the needs of the patient (person) as the first priority. Habits of practice do not matter. Needs matter.
  3. Ralph Snyderman showed how much possibility there is for individualization. This is, by the way, if we take full advantage of the knowledge, the death knell of insurance – actuarial financing – of care. What generates “moral hazard” in an insurance system is a key lever for efficiency and effectiveness in a science-based, individually focused system of care and healing.
  4. Normalize experience. Never, never, never separate a person from the loving community from which that person draws energy, self-esteem, solace, and wisdom.
  5. Nutrition, air, noise.For my knee – weight, shoes, cement.
  6. For my knee – I can use an elliptical exerciser, but not a treadmill. My choice of shoe is crucial, and a properly build orthotic is even more crucial. I can skate ski, but not downhill ski. I cannot run, but I can bicycle. When I walk on the sidewalk, I need to keep my right footfall to the right of the camber.
  7. This is the most difficult change of all. Harvey argued for rigor and evidence behind our choices. However, illuminating the functioning of an integrative system of care requires forms of evidence and approaches to learning that are less developed and less honored today than canonical experimental designs founded on Fisherian inference rules. Here are three examples:In integrative care, each individual is an informative experiment of size one, and continuous. Rigorous measurement and evaluation need to be applied to individual learning cycles, not just to groups;In integrative care, the aim of evaluative research is to reduce the “Number Needed to Treat” to exactly 1. That requires individual evidence and research not normally embraced by study sections, peer-reviewed journals, or promotion committees.In integrative care, appropriate knowledge is usually gathered by study and graphing over time, not in cross-sectional, either-or comparisons.This is a major challenge to the IOM and to the academic community at large.
  8. Getting the individual more involved in the development and management of their own personal health plan.Exploration of internal, reflective process. Illness is part of the story of someone’s life. E.g., What is the metaphor of this in your life. Thde capacity to look within.
  9. Ralph Snyderman mentioned the Health Navigator function.