SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 52
Baixar para ler offline
State Trends
rizonA ColorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illinois indiAnA MAin
ississippi nevAdA new York oreGon pennsYlvAniA texAs utAh virGini
AshinGton ArizonA ColorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illino
ndiAnA MAine Mississippi nevAdA new York oreGon pennsYlvAniA texA
tAh virGiniA wAshinGton ArizonA ColorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAr
eorGiA illinois indiAnA MAine Mississippi nevAdA new York oreGo
ennsYlvAniA texAs utAh virGiniA wAshinGton ArizonA ColorAd
onneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illinois indiAnA MAine Mississippi nevAd
ew York oreGon pennsYlvAniA texAs utAh virGiniA wAshinGton Arizon
olorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illinois indiAnA MAine Mississipp
evAdA new York oreGon pennsYlvAniA texAs utAh virGiniA wAshinGto
rizonA ColorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illinois indiAnA MAin
ississippi nevAdA new York oreGon pennsYlvAniA texAs utAh virGini
AshinGton ArizonA ColorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illino
ndiAnA          Legislative Victories from 2005 to 2010
         Removing Youth from the Adult Criminal Justice System
The Campaign for Youth Justice (CFYJ) is a national organization dedicated to ending the
practice of prosecuting, sentencing, and incarcerating youth under the age of 18 in the adult
criminal justice system. CFYJ dedicates this report to the thousands of young people and their
families across the country who have been harmed by laws and policies of the criminal justice
system; the Governors, State Legislators, State Officials, and Local Officials who championed
these reforms; and the continuing efforts of individuals and organizations who are leading
efforts to return youth to the juvenile justice system, including:


Action for Children North Carolina                 Mississippi Youth Justice Project
Baltimore Algebra Project                          MS-ACLU
Children’s Action Alliance                         NAACP
Citizens for Juvenile Justice                      Nebraska Coalition for the Fair Sentencing of Youth
Colorado Criminal Defense Bar                      Nevada ACLU
Colorado Juvenile Defenders Coalition              New York Governor’s Children’s Cabinet Advisory
Columbia Legal Services                            Board
Connecticut Juvenile Justice Alliance              New York Center for Juvenile Justice
Delaware Center for Justice                        Partnership for Safety and Justice
Delaware Collaboration for Youth                   Raise the Bar campaign
Families and Allies of Virginia’s Youth (FAVY)     Rhode Island Kids Count
Families and Friends of Louisiana’s Incarcerated   Rhode Island ACLU
Children                                           Southern Poverty Law Center
Illinois Juvenile Justice Initiative               Team Child
Indiana Juvenile Justice Task Force, Inc.          The Embracing Project
Injustice Project                                  Voices for Children in Nebraska
Just Kids Partnership                              Washington Coalition for the Just Treatment of Youth
JustChildren                                       Wisconsin Council on Children & Families
Juvenile Justice Project of Louisiana              Wyoming Kids Count
Mississippi Coalition for the Prevention of        Youth Justice Project
Schoolhouse to Jailhouse
Contents

A Letter From Liz Ryan, CEO of the Campaign For Youth Justice ......................................2

Overview.......................................................................................................................6

Understanding the Consequences of Trying Youth as Adults............................................8
    Teen Brains Are Not Fully Developed ...........................................................................................................................9
    Most Youth in the Adult System Are Convicted of Minor Crimes................................................................................... 13
    Youth Are Often Housed in Adult Jails and Prisons ..................................................................................................... 15
    Prosecuting Youth in the Adult System Leads to More Crime, Not Less ........................................................................ 17
    Youth Have Lifelong Barriers to Employment ............................................................................................................. 18
    Youth of Color Are Disproportionately Impacted by These Policies .............................................................................. 19


Four Trends to Watch ...................................................................................................20
    States and Local Jurisdictions Remove Youth from Adult Jails and Prisons ..................................................................24
    States Raise the Age of Juvenile Court Jurisdiction .....................................................................................................29
    States Change Transfer Laws to Keep More Youth in Juvenile Court ............................................................................33
    States Rethink Sentencing Laws for Youth .................................................................................................................. 41


Recommendations for Policymakers ............................................................................44
A Letter from Liz Ryan




                             “Children have an extraordinary
                                capacity for rehabilitation.”
                             – California State Senator Leland Yee

2
S   temming from one family’s individual case,
    we launched the Campaign for Youth Justice
(CFYJ) five years ago to respond to a crisis through-
                                                        the stigma of an adult criminal conviction. They
                                                        may have difficulty finding a job or getting a col-
                                                        lege degree to help them turn their lives around.
out the country: an estimated 250,000 youth under       We also know these laws have had a disproportion-
18 are prosecuted in the adult criminal justice sys-    ate impact on youth of color.
tem every year.
                                                      The consequences of an adult conviction aren’t mi-
A spike in youth crime during the 1980s and 1990s     nor; they are serious, long-term, life-threatening,
prompted state policymakers to expand laws to put and in some cases, deadly. However, awareness
more children in adult court, implement mandatory of the problem is not enough. Policymakers and
sentencing policies for certain crimes, and lower     the public must have viable alternative solutions.
the age at which a child could be prosecuted as       This report, State Trends: Legislative Changes
an adult. State policymakers                                               from 2005-2010 Removing
believed their efforts would                                               Youth from the Adult Criminal
improve public safety and                                                  Justice System, provides some
deter future crime. However,                                               initial answers by examining
studies across the nation have              State Trends                   innovative strategies states are
consistently concluded that                                                using to remove and protect
state laws prosecuting youth              demonstrates a                   youth in the adult criminal jus-
in adult court are ineffective                                             tice system.
at deterring crime and reduc-            “turning tide” in
ing recidivism.                                                            State Trends demonstrates
                                        how our country                    a “turning tide” in how our
Four years ago we issued                                                   country handles youth. In the
our first national report, The            handles youth.                   not-so-distant past, politicians
Consequences Aren’t Minor,                                                 have had their careers ruined
documenting the multiple                                                   by a “soft on crime” image.
unintended consequences of                                                 Fortunately, the politics around
these laws. With the help of the National Council youth crime are changing. State policymakers ap-
on Crime and Delinquency and the Justice Policy pear less wedded to “tough on crime” policies,
Institute, we analyzed all of the available research choosing to substitute them with policies that are
and conducted interviews with dozens of incarcer- “smart on crime.” Given the breadth and scope of
ated youth in adult jails and prisons in states all the changes, these trends are not short-term anom-
over the country.                                     alies but evidence of a long-term restructuring of
                                                      the juvenile justice system.
We found that youth tried as adults face the same
punishments as adults. They can be placed in adult
                                                      In the past five years, 15 states have changed
jails pre- and post-trial, sentenced to serve time in
                                                      their state laws, with at least nine additional states
adult prisons, or be placed on adult probation with
                                                      with active policy reform efforts underway. These
few to no rehabilitative services. Youth also are
                                                      changes are occurring in all regions of the country
subject to the same sentencing guidelines as adults
                                                      spearheaded by state and local officials of both ma-
and may receive mandatory minimum sentences in-
                                                      jor parties and supported by a bipartisan group of
cluding life without parole. The only consequence
                                                      governors.
that youth cannot receive is the death penalty.

When youth leave jail or prison, are on probation,      As a society, we still have a long way to go to meet
or have completed their adult sentences, they carry     the original promise of the juvenile court which



                                                                                                               3
was founded in Chicago over 100 years ago. Our          rather than approaches that harm youth and de-
    legal system recognizes a mandate to rehabilitate       crease public safety. These reforms draw a higher
    youth with an approach that is different than adults,   “return on investment,” reduce wasteful spending,
    but we have never fully lived up to it. Today, all 50   and cost less over the long term. According to a
    states and the District of Columbia, as well as the     senior researcher at the Urban Institute, returning
    federal government have two distinct systems for        youth to juvenile court jurisdiction will result in a
    dealing with adults and youth. While the majority       $3 savings benefit for every $1 spent.
    of youth arrested for criminal acts are prosecuted in
    state juvenile justice systems, far too many youth      We applaud these efforts to “turn the tide,” and we
    are still handled by the adult criminal justice sys-    challenge federal, state and local policymakers to
    tem – to the detriment of public safety, these youth    transform this tide into a wave of reform across the
    and our society.                                        country.

    We hope that policymakers will greatly expand
    upon the reforms profiled in this report, especially    Liz Ryan
    as they have broad public support and make fiscal
    sense in these challenging economic times. These        CEO of the Campaign For Youth Justice
    policy reforms draw on the public’s support of in-
    vestment in rehabilitation and treatment of youth,




4
How a Youth Ends Up in the Adult Justice System
  Age of Juvenile Court Jurisdiction                                       Transfer and Waiver Provisions
  These laws determine the age of adulthood for criminal jus-              These laws allow young people to be prosecuted in adult
  tice purposes. They effectively remove certain age groups                courts if they are accused of committing certain crimes.
  from the juvenile court control for all infractions, whether             A variety of mechanisms exist by which a youth can be
  violent or nonviolent, and place them within the adult court             transferred to adult court. Most states have transfer pro-
  jurisdiction. Thirteen states have defined the age of juve-              visions, but they vary in how much authority they allow
  nile court jurisdiction as below the generally accepted age              judges and prosecutors to exercise.
  of 18 years old.



  Judicial Waiver                                                                           Prosecutorial Waiver
  Almost all states have judicial waiv-                                                     These laws grant prosecutors discre-
  er provisions which is the most tra-                                                      tion to file cases against young people
  ditional and common transfer and                                                          in either juvenile or adult court. Such
  waiver provision. Under judicial                                                          provisions are also known as “concur-
  waiver laws, the case originates in                                                       rent jurisdiction,” “prosecutorial dis-
  juvenile court. Under certain cir-                                                        cretion,” or “direct file.” Fifteen states
  cumstances, the juvenile court judge                                                      have concurrent jurisdiction provi-
  has the authority to waive juvenile                                                       sions.
  court jurisdiction and transfer the
  case to criminal court. State statutes
  vary in how much guidance they
  provide judges on the criteria used in                                                    Reverse Waiver
  determining if a youth’s case should                                                      This is a mechanism to allow youth
  be transferred. Some states call the                                                      whose cases are being prosecuted in
  process “certification,” “remand,”                                                        adult court to be transferred back down
  or “bind over for criminal prosecu-                                                       to the juvenile court system under cer-
  tion.” Others “transfer” or “decline                                                      tain circumstances. Half of the states
  jurisdiction.”                                                                            have reverse waiver provisions.



  Statutory or
                                                                                            “Once an Adult, Always
  Legislative Exclusion
                                                                                            an Adult”
  These laws exclude certain youth
  from juvenile court jurisdiction en-                                                      These laws require youth who have
  tirely by requiring particular types                                                      been tried as adults to be prosecuted
  of cases to originate in criminal                                                         automatically in adult courts for any
  rather than juvenile court. More                                                          subsequent offenses. Two-thirds of the
  than half of the states have statutory                                                    states have such provisions, but most
  exclusion laws on the books.                                                              require the youth to have been convict-
                                                                                            ed in the initial criminal prosecution.



  Blended Sentencing
  These laws allow juvenile or adult courts to choose between juvenile and adult correctional sanctions in sentencing certain
  youth. Courts often will combine a juvenile sentence with a suspended adult sentence, which allows the youth to remain in
  the juvenile justice system as long as he or she is well-behaved. Half of the states have laws allowing blended sentencing
  in some cases.


Source: Campaign for Youth Justice, National Center for Juvenile Justice
                                                                                                                                         5
Overview




                “Without question, youth must be held
               accountable for their actions, but justice
               should not be driven by fads or politics.”
                      – Congressman George Miller
6
I  n the rush to crack down on youth crime in the
   1980s and 1990s, many states enacted harsh
laws making it easier for youth to be prosecuted in
                                                         Defender Center and the Na-
                                                         tional Conference of State
                                                         Legislatures.4 The legisla-
adult criminal courts. Every state allows youth to       tive scan identified 15 states
be prosecuted as adults by one of several mecha-         that have changed their state
nisms such that an estimated 250,000 children are        laws, in four categories.
prosecuted, sentenced, or incarcerated as adults
each year in the United States.1 In more than half
of the states, there is no lower age limit on who can    Trend 1
be prosecuted as an adult. This means that in these      Four states (Colorado,
states very young children, even a 7-year-old, can       Maine, Virginia and Penn-
be prosecuted as adults. 2                               sylvania) have passed laws
                                                         limiting the ability to house
When youth are tried in adult courts, they often         youth in adult jails and pris-
face the same sentencing guidelines as adult of-         ons.
fenders. In the majority of cases a juvenile court
judge has not had an opportunity to evaluate the
circumstances of the case before a youth is pros-
ecuted as an adult, and adult criminal court judges      Trend 2
often have very little discretion in the type of sen-    Three states (Connecticut,
tence they can impose on a youth convicted in the        Illinois, and Mississippi)
adult system. Incarcerating children in the adult        have expanded their juve-
system puts them at higher risk of abuse, injury,        nile court jurisdiction so that
and death while they are in the system, and makes        older youth who previously would be automatically
it more likely that they will reoffend once they get     tried as adults are not prosecuted in adult criminal
out.                                                     court.

At the time the laws were passed, few policymak-
ers understood these consequences. Now they do.          Trend 3
Politics has caught up with public opinion and now       Ten states (Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Del-
seems to reflect what 90% of Americans believe –         aware, Illinois, Indiana, Nevada, Utah, Virginia
that rehabilitative services and treatment for incar-    and Washington) have changed their transfer laws
cerated youth can prevent future crimes.3                making it more likely that youth will stay in the
                                                         juvenile justice system.
State Trends: Legislative Changes from 2005 to
2010 Removing Youth from the Adult Criminal Jus-
tice System provides state policymakers, the media,      Trend 4
the public, and advocates for reform with the lat-       Four states (Colorado, Georgia, Texas, and Wash-
est information about youth in the adult criminal        ington) have all changed their mandatory minimum
justice system. The first half of this report explains   sentencing laws to take into account the develop-
the dangers to youth, public safety, and the overall     mental differences between youth and adults.
prosperity of our economy and future generations.
The second half of the report looks at legislative
reforms aimed at removing youth from the crimi-
nal justice system by examining state juvenile jus-
tice legislation compiled by the National Juvenile




                                                                                                                7
Understanding the Consequences
    of Trying Youth as Adults




                                     “When a kid commits a crime, society
                                        shouldn’t give up on that kid.”
                                          – Congressman Chris Murphy

8
Teen Brains Are Not Fully Developed

A     s any parent knows, teenagers are works in
      progress. They do not have the same abilities
as adults to make sound judgments in complex sit-
                                                         specific arrest rates we can see that youth is a time
                                                         characterized by delinquency that then sharply
                                                         drops off. In fact, engaging in delinquent activi-
uations, to control their impulses, or to plan effec-    ties is a normal part of the adolescent experience.
tively for the long term. Recent brain science has       Almost all of the readers of this report will likely
been able to demonstrate why it is that adolescents      be able to recall participating in an activity during
act the way they do.                                     their adolescence that violates at least one criminal
                                                         law today. It is also true that for the vast majority
What science tells us is that the brain architecture     of readers, these activities were temporary and did
is constructed through a process that starts before      not indicate that they would become lifelong of-
birth and continues into adulthood. During adoles-       fenders.
cence, the brain undergoes dramatic changes to the
structure and function of the brain impacting the        The upside of this brain research is that the rapid
way youth process and react to information. The          growth and development happening in adolescent
region of the brain that is the last to develop is the   brains make them highly elastic and malleable
one that controls many of the abilities that govern      to change. The relationships made and behaviors
goal-oriented, “rational” decision-making, such as       learned during this crucial developmental stage
long-term planning, impulse control, insight, and        are hard-wired into the brain architecture and help
judgment.                                                determine long-term life outcomes. When young
                                                         people hit a rough patch, guidance from respon-
The downside to these brain changes is that this         sible adults and developmentally appropriate pro-
means that youth are particularly vulnerable to          grams, services, and punishment can get them back
making the kinds of poor decisions that get them         on track.
involved in the justice system. By examining age-
                                                         The juvenile justice system is based on this science
                                                         and provides troubled adolescents with mentors,
                                                         education, and the guidance to help most of them
                                                         mature into responsible adults. In contrast, ware-
                                                         housing minors in the adult system ensures that they
                                                         will not have guidance from responsible adults or
                                                         have access to age-appropriate programs, services
                                                         and punishment to help build positive change into
                                                         their brains during this crucial developmental pe-
                                                         riod. Instead, they will face the reality of having a
                                                         permanent criminal record and the increased likeli-
                                                         hood of becoming career criminals. This is not the
                                                         outcome we want for America’s children.




                                                                                                                 9
Moving Youth into the Adult System Costs States Millions:
                                   Lessons from Rhode Island

       With the current financial crisis, states across the     Children are not little adults, and
       country are exploring ways to decrease the costs         a criminal justice system that is
       of the justice system. According to the Pew Center       designed for adults does not work
       on the States, state correctional costs quadrupled       for youth.
       over the past two decades and now top $50 billion
       a year, consuming one in every 15 general fund           Rhode Island is a state that recently
       dollars.5 When state policymakers have conversa-         experimented with moving 17-year-
       tions about reforms to either the juvenile or adult      olds into their adult system as a way to
       criminal justice system, an issue that often gets for-   close a budget shortfall in 2007. 7 It took
       gotten is youth in the adult system. Some states see     only a couple of months for the state to
       the juvenile and adult systems as interchangeable        realize that it would cost much more to keep youth
       and seek to consolidate the two systems in an ef-        safe in the adult system, and the legislature quickly
       fort to save money. This is a very costly mistake for    repealed the law.8 Rhode Island now stands as a
       states as each high-risk youth diverted from a life      powerful example to other states that consolidat-
       of crime saves society nearly $5.7 million in costs      ing or otherwise moving more youth into the adult
       over a lifetime.6                                        system is a bad idea.




10
The Juvenile Justice System
Demands More Than the Adult Justice System


The adult system is typically thought to be more punishment-oriented than the juvenile system,
but the minor crimes that youth commit mean that the majority of youth are only given an adult pro-
bation sentence as well as a lifelong adult criminal record that makes it hard for them to get jobs in the future.
In contrast, the juvenile justice system holds youth accountable for their crimes by placing more requirements on
youth and their families. The juvenile justice system often requires that youth attend school, pay community and
victim restitution, and receive the counseling, mentoring, and training they need to turn their lives around. The adult
justice system completely fails those youth who would benefit from the services of the juvenile system by letting
them “slip through the cracks.”



  Comparison of Requirements between the Adult and Juvenile System in North Carolina


                                        In the Juvenile System                        In the Adult System

  Parent                       • Parent/guardian must be involved.           • Parent/guardian need not be notified.
  Involvement                  • Youth released from detention center        • Youth can make bail and leave county
                                 only to parent/guardian. Youth have           jail on own recognizance.
                                 no right to pretrial release, no right to
                                 bond.

  Education                    • Youth must attend school or get a GED.      • No education requirement.

  Age-Appropriate              • Youth receive assessments, have             • Services not required or, often, never
                                 frequent contact with court counselors,       even offered.
  Services,                      and report regularly for rehabilitative
  Treatment, and                 services.                                   • Those offered are intended for adults
  Punishment                                                                   and therefore are not developmentally
                               • Youth and families often receive court-       appropriate for youth.
                                 ordered evidence-based therapies:
                                 counseling, training, mentoring,
                                 tutoring, and parenting skills.

                               • Youth with mental health and substance
                                 abuse issues receive intensive services.

                               • Regular contact with court counselors.


Source: Action for Children North Carolina




                                                                                                                          11
Youth Arrests, 2009

                                                                                            { Only 5% of
                                                      Murder and nonnegligent
                                                       manslaughter – 0.1%

     100%
        100%

                                                      Rape and other sex offenses* – 0.8%
                 Aggravated Assault 2.6%
                      Robbery 1.7%
     95%95%




                       Drug Crimes**
                             8.9%
                                                                                              youth are
                                                                                              arrested for
                        Other assaults
                             11.6%
                                                                                              the crimes
                                                                                              of homicide,
                                                                                              rape, robbery,
                    Property Crimes***
               (e.g., burglary, larceny, vandalism)
                                                                                              or aggravated
                             28.1%
                                                                                              assault.


                     Disorderly Conduct
                             8.0%




                                                                                              * Includes Forcible rape and other sex
                                                                                              offenses except prostitution
                                                                                              ** Drug Abuse Violations
                  All other offenses****                                                      *** Property crimes are offenses
                                                                                              of burglary, larceny-theft, motor
                             21.1%                                                            vehicle theft, arson, vandalism,
                                                                                              stolen property (buying, receiving,
                                                                                              possessing)
                                                                                              **** Also includes forgery and
                                                                                              counterfeiting, fraud, embezzlement,
                                                                                              gambling, suspicion, offenses against
                                                                                              the family and children, prostitution
                                                                                              and commercialized vice, driving
                                                                                              under the influence, drunkenness, and
                   Status Offenses*****                                                       vagrancy, weapons offenses but does
                                                                                              not include traffic offenses
               (e.g., runaways, curfew violations,                                            ***** Status offenses include
                          liquor laws)                                                        runaways, curfew and loitering law
                                                                                              violations, liquor laws
                             17.2%
                                                                                              Source: Federal Bureau of
                                                                                              Investigation, Crime in the United
      0% 0%                                                                                   States, 2009




12
Most Youth in the Adult System
                                                           Are Convicted of Minor Crimes

A    ny mention of juvenile crime tends to evoke
     images that perpetuate three specific myths
about youth. First, newspaper and television cover-
                                                                                                                    Second, there is a perception that juvenile crime is
                                                                                                                    on the rise. In reality, youth crime has been going
                                                                                                                    down for many years and is now at historic lows.
age of youth crime tends to involve stories focused                                                                 The number of adults arrested between 1999 and
on gangs or murder leading to a distorted view of                                                                   2008 increased 3.4%, whereas the number of juve-
the nature of juvenile crime. Youth who have been                                                                   niles arrested dropped a staggering 15.7% during
arrested for violent crimes are rare and only ac-                                                                   that same time frame.10
count for about 5% of all juveniles arrested each
year.9 Drugs, burglary, theft, and other property                                                                   Third, there is a perception that youth commit the ma-
crimes are among the more common reasons teens                                                                      jority of crime in the nation. The truth is that adults
are prosecuted in adult courts.                                                                                     commit the majority of crime in America. In 2008,




                                                           Juvenile Crime Has Been Declining for Years

                                             10000
          Juvenile Arrest Rates by Offense




                                              7500




                                              5000




                                             2500




                                                0
                                                    1990   1991   1992   1993   1994   1995   1996   1997   1998   1999   2000   2001   2002   2003   2004   2005   2006   2007   2008




  * Violent crime index includes murder & nonnegligent manslaughter, forcible rape, robbery, and aggravated assault.
  ** Property crime index includes burglary, larceny-theft, motor vehicle theft, and arson.
  Source: National Center for Juvenile Justice; OJJDP Statistical Briefing Book




                                                                                                                                                                                         13
only 12% of violent crime and 18% of property crime                              even youth who receive the most serious sanction
     nationwide were attributed to youth.11 According to                              – a sentence of imprisonment in an adult prison – are
     the FBI, youth under age 18 accounted for 15% of all                             not the serious offenders that one may imagine. The
     arrests.12                                                                       majority of youth held in adult prisons are not given
                                                                                      extreme sentences such as life without parole, and
     These three misperceptions apply equally to youth in                             95% of youth will be released back to their com-
     the adult justice system. The overwhelming majority                              munities before their 25th birthday.14 Unfortunately,
     of youth who enter the adult court are not there for                             by virtue of being prosecuted in the adult system
     serious, violent crimes. Despite the fact that many of                           these youth are less likely to get an education or
     the state laws were intended to prosecute the most                               skills training, and their adult conviction will make
     serious offenders, most youth who are tried in adult                             it harder for them to get jobs.
     courts are there for nonviolent offenses.13 A signifi-
     cant proportion of youth, in some states the major-
     ity, only receive a sentence of probation. However,




             Age-Specific Arrest Rates Rise Sharply During Youth Then Drop Off

                                               Youth                                                Adults
                          3000

                                                                                                   Violent Crime Index                  Murder
                                                                                                   Aggravated Assault                   Robbery
                                                                                                   Property Index

                          2250
     Arrest Rates, 2001




                          1500




                           750




                            0
                           12 & under 13-14   15   16   17   18   19   20   21   22      23   24     25-29   30-34   35-39   40-44   45-49   50-54   55-59   60-64

                                                                                 Age

       Source: Adapted from OJJDP Statistical Briefing Book




14
Youth Are Often Housed in
                         Adult Jails and Prisons

O    ne of the most serious consequences of adult
     court prosecution is that youth can be housed
in adult jails and prisons. On any given night in
                                                            If detained pre-trial, two-thirds of youth
                                                          prosecuted as adults are held in adult jails.
America, 10,000 children are held in adult jails
and prisons.15 State laws vary widely as to whether
youth can be housed in adult facilities.

Although federal law requires that youth in the ju-
venile justice system be removed from adult jails
or be sight-and-sound separated from other adults,
these protections do not apply to youth prosecuted
in the adult criminal justice system.16 In fact, many
youth who are held in adult jails have not even
been convicted. Research shows that many never
will. As many as one-half of these youth will be
sent back to the juvenile justice system or will not
be convicted. Yet, most of these youth will have
spent at least one month in an adult jail, and one in
five of these youth will have spent over six months
in an adult jail.17                                             Source: Jailing Juveniles, Campaign for Youth Justice



While in adult jails or prisons, most youth are de-     Youth are also in extreme danger when held in
nied educational and rehabilitative services that are   adult facilities. Staff in adult facilities face a di-
necessary for their stage in development. A survey      lemma: they can house youth in the general adult
of adult facilities found that 40% of jails provided    population where they are at substantial risk of
no educational services at all, only 11% provided       physical and sexual abuse, or they can house youth
special education services, and a mere 7% provid-       in segregated settings in which isolation can cause
ed vocational training.18 This lack of education in-    or exacerbate mental health problems.
creases the difficulty that youth will have once they
return to their communities.




                        “When you take juveniles and put them in adult jails,
                                   they learn to be better adult criminals.”
                               – New Hampshire State Representative Mary Walz
                                                                                                                        15
According to Sheriff Gabe Morgan
         Youth Under 18 in Adult Prisons, 2009                                                         of Newport News, Virginia:

                                                                                                           The average 14-year-old is a
                                                                                                           “guppy in the ocean” of an
                                                                                                           adult facility. The law does not
                                                                                                           protect the juveniles; it says
                                                                                                           they are adults and treats them
                                                                                                           as such. Often they are placed
                                                                                                           in isolation for their protec-
                                                                                                           tion, usually 23 ½ hours alone.
                                                                                                           Around age 17, we put [the
                                                                                                           youth] in the young head popu-
                                                                                                           lation, a special unit where all
                                                                                                           the youth are put together, and
                                                                                                           the 13- and 14-year-olds nor-
                                                                                                           mally fall prey there as well.19

                                                                                                       Youth who are held in adult facili-
                                                                                                       ties are at the greatest risk of sexual
                                                                                                       victimization. The National Prison
                                                                                                       Rape Elimination Commission
                                                                                                       found that “more than any other
                                                                                                       group of incarcerated persons,
                                                                                                       youth incarcerated with adults are
                                                                                                       probably at the highest risk for sex-
                                                                                                       ual abuse.” 20

                                                                                                       Keeping youth away from other
                                                                                                       adult inmates is no solution either.
                                                                                                       Isolation has devastating conse-
                                                                                                       quences for youth – these conditions
                                                                                                       can cause anxiety, paranoia, and ex-
                                                                                                       acerbate existing mental disorders
                                                                                                       and put youth at risk of suicide. In
     * Prisons and jails form one integrated system. Data include total jail and prison populations.   fact, youth housed in adult jails are
     ** Counts include those held in privately-operated facilities.
                                                                                                       36 times more likely to commit sui-
     Source: Bureau of Justice Statistics                                                              cide than are youth housed in juve-
                                                                                                       nile detention facilities.21




16
16
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice
Campaign for Youth Justice

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Destaque

Youth justice in 2011 12
Youth justice in 2011 12Youth justice in 2011 12
Youth justice in 2011 12camillacomcare
 
Youth Justice and Mental Health E20
Youth Justice and Mental Health E20 Youth Justice and Mental Health E20
Youth Justice and Mental Health E20 Sophie40
 
2012-05-29 Youth Justice Seminar
2012-05-29 Youth Justice Seminar2012-05-29 Youth Justice Seminar
2012-05-29 Youth Justice SeminarUNESCO Centre NI
 
Youth Justice Reinvestment
Youth Justice ReinvestmentYouth Justice Reinvestment
Youth Justice ReinvestmentKim McGill
 
Court in the Act, A Regular Magazine for the Entire Youth Justice Community
Court in the Act, A Regular Magazine for the Entire Youth Justice CommunityCourt in the Act, A Regular Magazine for the Entire Youth Justice Community
Court in the Act, A Regular Magazine for the Entire Youth Justice CommunityHAQ: Centre for Child Rights
 
2014 Youth Justice Coalition FREE LA High School Graduation
2014 Youth Justice Coalition FREE LA High School Graduation2014 Youth Justice Coalition FREE LA High School Graduation
2014 Youth Justice Coalition FREE LA High School GraduationKim McGill
 
Moving Forward - Implementing a new way of working for youth justice - Chris ...
Moving Forward - Implementing a new way of working for youth justice - Chris ...Moving Forward - Implementing a new way of working for youth justice - Chris ...
Moving Forward - Implementing a new way of working for youth justice - Chris ...robine
 
Youth Justice System 2
Youth Justice System 2Youth Justice System 2
Youth Justice System 2drama_queen_11
 
BYC at Youth Justice Convention 2014
BYC at Youth Justice Convention 2014BYC at Youth Justice Convention 2014
BYC at Youth Justice Convention 2014nacro_programmes
 
Tony O'Donovan, Irish Youth Justice Service. Restraint Reduction Conference K...
Tony O'Donovan, Irish Youth Justice Service. Restraint Reduction Conference K...Tony O'Donovan, Irish Youth Justice Service. Restraint Reduction Conference K...
Tony O'Donovan, Irish Youth Justice Service. Restraint Reduction Conference K...Restraint Reduction Network
 
FItzroy-Community-Food-Centre-Project-Plan-Final
FItzroy-Community-Food-Centre-Project-Plan-FinalFItzroy-Community-Food-Centre-Project-Plan-Final
FItzroy-Community-Food-Centre-Project-Plan-FinalCultivating Community
 
Immigrant Youth Justice League, 2009-2012, Chicago, IL.
Immigrant Youth Justice League, 2009-2012, Chicago, IL.Immigrant Youth Justice League, 2009-2012, Chicago, IL.
Immigrant Youth Justice League, 2009-2012, Chicago, IL.ImmigrantYouth JusticeLeague
 
Afasic Cymru Voice for Life and Youth Justice Board Training_Report 2015
Afasic Cymru Voice for Life and Youth Justice Board Training_Report 2015Afasic Cymru Voice for Life and Youth Justice Board Training_Report 2015
Afasic Cymru Voice for Life and Youth Justice Board Training_Report 2015Gabriella Simak
 

Destaque (13)

Youth justice in 2011 12
Youth justice in 2011 12Youth justice in 2011 12
Youth justice in 2011 12
 
Youth Justice and Mental Health E20
Youth Justice and Mental Health E20 Youth Justice and Mental Health E20
Youth Justice and Mental Health E20
 
2012-05-29 Youth Justice Seminar
2012-05-29 Youth Justice Seminar2012-05-29 Youth Justice Seminar
2012-05-29 Youth Justice Seminar
 
Youth Justice Reinvestment
Youth Justice ReinvestmentYouth Justice Reinvestment
Youth Justice Reinvestment
 
Court in the Act, A Regular Magazine for the Entire Youth Justice Community
Court in the Act, A Regular Magazine for the Entire Youth Justice CommunityCourt in the Act, A Regular Magazine for the Entire Youth Justice Community
Court in the Act, A Regular Magazine for the Entire Youth Justice Community
 
2014 Youth Justice Coalition FREE LA High School Graduation
2014 Youth Justice Coalition FREE LA High School Graduation2014 Youth Justice Coalition FREE LA High School Graduation
2014 Youth Justice Coalition FREE LA High School Graduation
 
Moving Forward - Implementing a new way of working for youth justice - Chris ...
Moving Forward - Implementing a new way of working for youth justice - Chris ...Moving Forward - Implementing a new way of working for youth justice - Chris ...
Moving Forward - Implementing a new way of working for youth justice - Chris ...
 
Youth Justice System 2
Youth Justice System 2Youth Justice System 2
Youth Justice System 2
 
BYC at Youth Justice Convention 2014
BYC at Youth Justice Convention 2014BYC at Youth Justice Convention 2014
BYC at Youth Justice Convention 2014
 
Tony O'Donovan, Irish Youth Justice Service. Restraint Reduction Conference K...
Tony O'Donovan, Irish Youth Justice Service. Restraint Reduction Conference K...Tony O'Donovan, Irish Youth Justice Service. Restraint Reduction Conference K...
Tony O'Donovan, Irish Youth Justice Service. Restraint Reduction Conference K...
 
FItzroy-Community-Food-Centre-Project-Plan-Final
FItzroy-Community-Food-Centre-Project-Plan-FinalFItzroy-Community-Food-Centre-Project-Plan-Final
FItzroy-Community-Food-Centre-Project-Plan-Final
 
Immigrant Youth Justice League, 2009-2012, Chicago, IL.
Immigrant Youth Justice League, 2009-2012, Chicago, IL.Immigrant Youth Justice League, 2009-2012, Chicago, IL.
Immigrant Youth Justice League, 2009-2012, Chicago, IL.
 
Afasic Cymru Voice for Life and Youth Justice Board Training_Report 2015
Afasic Cymru Voice for Life and Youth Justice Board Training_Report 2015Afasic Cymru Voice for Life and Youth Justice Board Training_Report 2015
Afasic Cymru Voice for Life and Youth Justice Board Training_Report 2015
 

Semelhante a Campaign for Youth Justice

Juvenile Justice And The Criminal Justice System
Juvenile Justice And The Criminal Justice SystemJuvenile Justice And The Criminal Justice System
Juvenile Justice And The Criminal Justice SystemToya Shamberger
 
An Overview of Juvenile Justice in the United States(HOAFPGe.docx
An Overview of Juvenile Justice in the United States(HOAFPGe.docxAn Overview of Juvenile Justice in the United States(HOAFPGe.docx
An Overview of Juvenile Justice in the United States(HOAFPGe.docxgalerussel59292
 
Running head JUVENILE JUSTICE .docx
Running head JUVENILE JUSTICE                                   .docxRunning head JUVENILE JUSTICE                                   .docx
Running head JUVENILE JUSTICE .docxcowinhelen
 
Juvenile Justice Systems
Juvenile Justice SystemsJuvenile Justice Systems
Juvenile Justice SystemsSheila Guy
 

Semelhante a Campaign for Youth Justice (7)

Juvenile Justice And The Criminal Justice System
Juvenile Justice And The Criminal Justice SystemJuvenile Justice And The Criminal Justice System
Juvenile Justice And The Criminal Justice System
 
Essay On Juvenile Justice
Essay On Juvenile JusticeEssay On Juvenile Justice
Essay On Juvenile Justice
 
Juvenile Justice
Juvenile JusticeJuvenile Justice
Juvenile Justice
 
An Overview of Juvenile Justice in the United States(HOAFPGe.docx
An Overview of Juvenile Justice in the United States(HOAFPGe.docxAn Overview of Juvenile Justice in the United States(HOAFPGe.docx
An Overview of Juvenile Justice in the United States(HOAFPGe.docx
 
Running head JUVENILE JUSTICE .docx
Running head JUVENILE JUSTICE                                   .docxRunning head JUVENILE JUSTICE                                   .docx
Running head JUVENILE JUSTICE .docx
 
Framework to evaluate5 13a-12
Framework to evaluate5 13a-12Framework to evaluate5 13a-12
Framework to evaluate5 13a-12
 
Juvenile Justice Systems
Juvenile Justice SystemsJuvenile Justice Systems
Juvenile Justice Systems
 

Mais de Zoely Mamizaka

Savoir etre savoir vivre savoir aimer
Savoir etre savoir vivre savoir aimerSavoir etre savoir vivre savoir aimer
Savoir etre savoir vivre savoir aimerZoely Mamizaka
 
Moments de réflexion
Moments de réflexion Moments de réflexion
Moments de réflexion Zoely Mamizaka
 
Madagascar country brief - States in Transition - IDASA
Madagascar country brief - States in Transition - IDASAMadagascar country brief - States in Transition - IDASA
Madagascar country brief - States in Transition - IDASAZoely Mamizaka
 
Regime constitutionnel - Liberté économique et paix en Afrique Gbongue - Kouadio
Regime constitutionnel - Liberté économique et paix en Afrique Gbongue - KouadioRegime constitutionnel - Liberté économique et paix en Afrique Gbongue - Kouadio
Regime constitutionnel - Liberté économique et paix en Afrique Gbongue - KouadioZoely Mamizaka
 
Un régime parlementaire pour l'Afrique JP Feldman
Un régime parlementaire pour l'Afrique JP FeldmanUn régime parlementaire pour l'Afrique JP Feldman
Un régime parlementaire pour l'Afrique JP FeldmanZoely Mamizaka
 
Exigeons la dignite Amnesty International
Exigeons la dignite Amnesty InternationalExigeons la dignite Amnesty International
Exigeons la dignite Amnesty InternationalZoely Mamizaka
 
Le kit Max et Lili de la gentillesse - Psychologies.com
Le kit Max et Lili de la gentillesse - Psychologies.comLe kit Max et Lili de la gentillesse - Psychologies.com
Le kit Max et Lili de la gentillesse - Psychologies.comZoely Mamizaka
 
Keeping track - UNEP : From Rio to Rio+20 (1992-2012)
Keeping track - UNEP : From Rio to Rio+20 (1992-2012) Keeping track - UNEP : From Rio to Rio+20 (1992-2012)
Keeping track - UNEP : From Rio to Rio+20 (1992-2012) Zoely Mamizaka
 
Global Humanitarian Assistance Report 2011
Global Humanitarian Assistance Report 2011Global Humanitarian Assistance Report 2011
Global Humanitarian Assistance Report 2011Zoely Mamizaka
 
World Alzheimer Report 2011 - ADI
World Alzheimer Report 2011 - ADIWorld Alzheimer Report 2011 - ADI
World Alzheimer Report 2011 - ADIZoely Mamizaka
 
Actu Programme Holistique de Conservation des Forets via goodplanet
Actu Programme Holistique de Conservation des Forets via goodplanetActu Programme Holistique de Conservation des Forets via goodplanet
Actu Programme Holistique de Conservation des Forets via goodplanetZoely Mamizaka
 

Mais de Zoely Mamizaka (20)

Tantra chinois
Tantra chinoisTantra chinois
Tantra chinois
 
Vive le printemps
Vive le printempsVive le printemps
Vive le printemps
 
A méditer
A méditerA méditer
A méditer
 
Hommes
HommesHommes
Hommes
 
Femmes formidables
Femmes formidablesFemmes formidables
Femmes formidables
 
Savoir etre savoir vivre savoir aimer
Savoir etre savoir vivre savoir aimerSavoir etre savoir vivre savoir aimer
Savoir etre savoir vivre savoir aimer
 
Moments de réflexion
Moments de réflexion Moments de réflexion
Moments de réflexion
 
La balance
La balanceLa balance
La balance
 
Madagascar country brief - States in Transition - IDASA
Madagascar country brief - States in Transition - IDASAMadagascar country brief - States in Transition - IDASA
Madagascar country brief - States in Transition - IDASA
 
Regime constitutionnel - Liberté économique et paix en Afrique Gbongue - Kouadio
Regime constitutionnel - Liberté économique et paix en Afrique Gbongue - KouadioRegime constitutionnel - Liberté économique et paix en Afrique Gbongue - Kouadio
Regime constitutionnel - Liberté économique et paix en Afrique Gbongue - Kouadio
 
Un régime parlementaire pour l'Afrique JP Feldman
Un régime parlementaire pour l'Afrique JP FeldmanUn régime parlementaire pour l'Afrique JP Feldman
Un régime parlementaire pour l'Afrique JP Feldman
 
Exigeons la dignite Amnesty International
Exigeons la dignite Amnesty InternationalExigeons la dignite Amnesty International
Exigeons la dignite Amnesty International
 
Manuel femmes 1960
Manuel femmes 1960Manuel femmes 1960
Manuel femmes 1960
 
Le kit Max et Lili de la gentillesse - Psychologies.com
Le kit Max et Lili de la gentillesse - Psychologies.comLe kit Max et Lili de la gentillesse - Psychologies.com
Le kit Max et Lili de la gentillesse - Psychologies.com
 
Keeping track - UNEP : From Rio to Rio+20 (1992-2012)
Keeping track - UNEP : From Rio to Rio+20 (1992-2012) Keeping track - UNEP : From Rio to Rio+20 (1992-2012)
Keeping track - UNEP : From Rio to Rio+20 (1992-2012)
 
Annonces fracassantes
Annonces fracassantesAnnonces fracassantes
Annonces fracassantes
 
Mon twournal
Mon twournalMon twournal
Mon twournal
 
Global Humanitarian Assistance Report 2011
Global Humanitarian Assistance Report 2011Global Humanitarian Assistance Report 2011
Global Humanitarian Assistance Report 2011
 
World Alzheimer Report 2011 - ADI
World Alzheimer Report 2011 - ADIWorld Alzheimer Report 2011 - ADI
World Alzheimer Report 2011 - ADI
 
Actu Programme Holistique de Conservation des Forets via goodplanet
Actu Programme Holistique de Conservation des Forets via goodplanetActu Programme Holistique de Conservation des Forets via goodplanet
Actu Programme Holistique de Conservation des Forets via goodplanet
 

Último

57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdfGerald Furnkranz
 
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsQuiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsnaxymaxyy
 
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012ankitnayak356677
 
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest2
 
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkcomplaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkbhavenpr
 
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdfFIRST INDIA
 
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeRohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeAbdulGhani778830
 
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkManipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkbhavenpr
 
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming TrendExperience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming TrendFabwelt
 
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.NaveedKhaskheli1
 

Último (10)

57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
57 Bidens Annihilation Nation Policy.pdf
 
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the roundsQuiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
Quiz for Heritage Indian including all the rounds
 
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
VIP Girls Available Call or WhatsApp 9711199012
 
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global NewsIndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
IndiaWest: Your Trusted Source for Today's Global News
 
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfkcomplaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
complaint-ECI-PM-media-1-Chandru.pdfra;;prfk
 
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
16042024_First India Newspaper Jaipur.pdf
 
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for JusticeRohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
Rohan Jaitley: Central Gov't Standing Counsel for Justice
 
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpkManipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
Manipur-Book-Final-2-compressed.pdfsal'rpk
 
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming TrendExperience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
Experience the Future of the Web3 Gaming Trend
 
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
Global Terrorism and its types and prevention ppt.
 

Campaign for Youth Justice

  • 1. State Trends rizonA ColorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illinois indiAnA MAin ississippi nevAdA new York oreGon pennsYlvAniA texAs utAh virGini AshinGton ArizonA ColorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illino ndiAnA MAine Mississippi nevAdA new York oreGon pennsYlvAniA texA tAh virGiniA wAshinGton ArizonA ColorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAr eorGiA illinois indiAnA MAine Mississippi nevAdA new York oreGo ennsYlvAniA texAs utAh virGiniA wAshinGton ArizonA ColorAd onneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illinois indiAnA MAine Mississippi nevAd ew York oreGon pennsYlvAniA texAs utAh virGiniA wAshinGton Arizon olorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illinois indiAnA MAine Mississipp evAdA new York oreGon pennsYlvAniA texAs utAh virGiniA wAshinGto rizonA ColorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illinois indiAnA MAin ississippi nevAdA new York oreGon pennsYlvAniA texAs utAh virGini AshinGton ArizonA ColorAdo ConneCtiCut delAwAre GeorGiA illino ndiAnA Legislative Victories from 2005 to 2010 Removing Youth from the Adult Criminal Justice System
  • 2. The Campaign for Youth Justice (CFYJ) is a national organization dedicated to ending the practice of prosecuting, sentencing, and incarcerating youth under the age of 18 in the adult criminal justice system. CFYJ dedicates this report to the thousands of young people and their families across the country who have been harmed by laws and policies of the criminal justice system; the Governors, State Legislators, State Officials, and Local Officials who championed these reforms; and the continuing efforts of individuals and organizations who are leading efforts to return youth to the juvenile justice system, including: Action for Children North Carolina Mississippi Youth Justice Project Baltimore Algebra Project MS-ACLU Children’s Action Alliance NAACP Citizens for Juvenile Justice Nebraska Coalition for the Fair Sentencing of Youth Colorado Criminal Defense Bar Nevada ACLU Colorado Juvenile Defenders Coalition New York Governor’s Children’s Cabinet Advisory Columbia Legal Services Board Connecticut Juvenile Justice Alliance New York Center for Juvenile Justice Delaware Center for Justice Partnership for Safety and Justice Delaware Collaboration for Youth Raise the Bar campaign Families and Allies of Virginia’s Youth (FAVY) Rhode Island Kids Count Families and Friends of Louisiana’s Incarcerated Rhode Island ACLU Children Southern Poverty Law Center Illinois Juvenile Justice Initiative Team Child Indiana Juvenile Justice Task Force, Inc. The Embracing Project Injustice Project Voices for Children in Nebraska Just Kids Partnership Washington Coalition for the Just Treatment of Youth JustChildren Wisconsin Council on Children & Families Juvenile Justice Project of Louisiana Wyoming Kids Count Mississippi Coalition for the Prevention of Youth Justice Project Schoolhouse to Jailhouse
  • 3. Contents A Letter From Liz Ryan, CEO of the Campaign For Youth Justice ......................................2 Overview.......................................................................................................................6 Understanding the Consequences of Trying Youth as Adults............................................8 Teen Brains Are Not Fully Developed ...........................................................................................................................9 Most Youth in the Adult System Are Convicted of Minor Crimes................................................................................... 13 Youth Are Often Housed in Adult Jails and Prisons ..................................................................................................... 15 Prosecuting Youth in the Adult System Leads to More Crime, Not Less ........................................................................ 17 Youth Have Lifelong Barriers to Employment ............................................................................................................. 18 Youth of Color Are Disproportionately Impacted by These Policies .............................................................................. 19 Four Trends to Watch ...................................................................................................20 States and Local Jurisdictions Remove Youth from Adult Jails and Prisons ..................................................................24 States Raise the Age of Juvenile Court Jurisdiction .....................................................................................................29 States Change Transfer Laws to Keep More Youth in Juvenile Court ............................................................................33 States Rethink Sentencing Laws for Youth .................................................................................................................. 41 Recommendations for Policymakers ............................................................................44
  • 4. A Letter from Liz Ryan “Children have an extraordinary capacity for rehabilitation.” – California State Senator Leland Yee 2
  • 5. S temming from one family’s individual case, we launched the Campaign for Youth Justice (CFYJ) five years ago to respond to a crisis through- the stigma of an adult criminal conviction. They may have difficulty finding a job or getting a col- lege degree to help them turn their lives around. out the country: an estimated 250,000 youth under We also know these laws have had a disproportion- 18 are prosecuted in the adult criminal justice sys- ate impact on youth of color. tem every year. The consequences of an adult conviction aren’t mi- A spike in youth crime during the 1980s and 1990s nor; they are serious, long-term, life-threatening, prompted state policymakers to expand laws to put and in some cases, deadly. However, awareness more children in adult court, implement mandatory of the problem is not enough. Policymakers and sentencing policies for certain crimes, and lower the public must have viable alternative solutions. the age at which a child could be prosecuted as This report, State Trends: Legislative Changes an adult. State policymakers from 2005-2010 Removing believed their efforts would Youth from the Adult Criminal improve public safety and Justice System, provides some deter future crime. However, initial answers by examining studies across the nation have State Trends innovative strategies states are consistently concluded that using to remove and protect state laws prosecuting youth demonstrates a youth in the adult criminal jus- in adult court are ineffective tice system. at deterring crime and reduc- “turning tide” in ing recidivism. State Trends demonstrates how our country a “turning tide” in how our Four years ago we issued country handles youth. In the our first national report, The handles youth. not-so-distant past, politicians Consequences Aren’t Minor, have had their careers ruined documenting the multiple by a “soft on crime” image. unintended consequences of Fortunately, the politics around these laws. With the help of the National Council youth crime are changing. State policymakers ap- on Crime and Delinquency and the Justice Policy pear less wedded to “tough on crime” policies, Institute, we analyzed all of the available research choosing to substitute them with policies that are and conducted interviews with dozens of incarcer- “smart on crime.” Given the breadth and scope of ated youth in adult jails and prisons in states all the changes, these trends are not short-term anom- over the country. alies but evidence of a long-term restructuring of the juvenile justice system. We found that youth tried as adults face the same punishments as adults. They can be placed in adult In the past five years, 15 states have changed jails pre- and post-trial, sentenced to serve time in their state laws, with at least nine additional states adult prisons, or be placed on adult probation with with active policy reform efforts underway. These few to no rehabilitative services. Youth also are changes are occurring in all regions of the country subject to the same sentencing guidelines as adults spearheaded by state and local officials of both ma- and may receive mandatory minimum sentences in- jor parties and supported by a bipartisan group of cluding life without parole. The only consequence governors. that youth cannot receive is the death penalty. When youth leave jail or prison, are on probation, As a society, we still have a long way to go to meet or have completed their adult sentences, they carry the original promise of the juvenile court which 3
  • 6. was founded in Chicago over 100 years ago. Our rather than approaches that harm youth and de- legal system recognizes a mandate to rehabilitate crease public safety. These reforms draw a higher youth with an approach that is different than adults, “return on investment,” reduce wasteful spending, but we have never fully lived up to it. Today, all 50 and cost less over the long term. According to a states and the District of Columbia, as well as the senior researcher at the Urban Institute, returning federal government have two distinct systems for youth to juvenile court jurisdiction will result in a dealing with adults and youth. While the majority $3 savings benefit for every $1 spent. of youth arrested for criminal acts are prosecuted in state juvenile justice systems, far too many youth We applaud these efforts to “turn the tide,” and we are still handled by the adult criminal justice sys- challenge federal, state and local policymakers to tem – to the detriment of public safety, these youth transform this tide into a wave of reform across the and our society. country. We hope that policymakers will greatly expand upon the reforms profiled in this report, especially Liz Ryan as they have broad public support and make fiscal sense in these challenging economic times. These CEO of the Campaign For Youth Justice policy reforms draw on the public’s support of in- vestment in rehabilitation and treatment of youth, 4
  • 7. How a Youth Ends Up in the Adult Justice System Age of Juvenile Court Jurisdiction Transfer and Waiver Provisions These laws determine the age of adulthood for criminal jus- These laws allow young people to be prosecuted in adult tice purposes. They effectively remove certain age groups courts if they are accused of committing certain crimes. from the juvenile court control for all infractions, whether A variety of mechanisms exist by which a youth can be violent or nonviolent, and place them within the adult court transferred to adult court. Most states have transfer pro- jurisdiction. Thirteen states have defined the age of juve- visions, but they vary in how much authority they allow nile court jurisdiction as below the generally accepted age judges and prosecutors to exercise. of 18 years old. Judicial Waiver Prosecutorial Waiver Almost all states have judicial waiv- These laws grant prosecutors discre- er provisions which is the most tra- tion to file cases against young people ditional and common transfer and in either juvenile or adult court. Such waiver provision. Under judicial provisions are also known as “concur- waiver laws, the case originates in rent jurisdiction,” “prosecutorial dis- juvenile court. Under certain cir- cretion,” or “direct file.” Fifteen states cumstances, the juvenile court judge have concurrent jurisdiction provi- has the authority to waive juvenile sions. court jurisdiction and transfer the case to criminal court. State statutes vary in how much guidance they provide judges on the criteria used in Reverse Waiver determining if a youth’s case should This is a mechanism to allow youth be transferred. Some states call the whose cases are being prosecuted in process “certification,” “remand,” adult court to be transferred back down or “bind over for criminal prosecu- to the juvenile court system under cer- tion.” Others “transfer” or “decline tain circumstances. Half of the states jurisdiction.” have reverse waiver provisions. Statutory or “Once an Adult, Always Legislative Exclusion an Adult” These laws exclude certain youth from juvenile court jurisdiction en- These laws require youth who have tirely by requiring particular types been tried as adults to be prosecuted of cases to originate in criminal automatically in adult courts for any rather than juvenile court. More subsequent offenses. Two-thirds of the than half of the states have statutory states have such provisions, but most exclusion laws on the books. require the youth to have been convict- ed in the initial criminal prosecution. Blended Sentencing These laws allow juvenile or adult courts to choose between juvenile and adult correctional sanctions in sentencing certain youth. Courts often will combine a juvenile sentence with a suspended adult sentence, which allows the youth to remain in the juvenile justice system as long as he or she is well-behaved. Half of the states have laws allowing blended sentencing in some cases. Source: Campaign for Youth Justice, National Center for Juvenile Justice 5
  • 8. Overview “Without question, youth must be held accountable for their actions, but justice should not be driven by fads or politics.” – Congressman George Miller 6
  • 9. I n the rush to crack down on youth crime in the 1980s and 1990s, many states enacted harsh laws making it easier for youth to be prosecuted in Defender Center and the Na- tional Conference of State Legislatures.4 The legisla- adult criminal courts. Every state allows youth to tive scan identified 15 states be prosecuted as adults by one of several mecha- that have changed their state nisms such that an estimated 250,000 children are laws, in four categories. prosecuted, sentenced, or incarcerated as adults each year in the United States.1 In more than half of the states, there is no lower age limit on who can Trend 1 be prosecuted as an adult. This means that in these Four states (Colorado, states very young children, even a 7-year-old, can Maine, Virginia and Penn- be prosecuted as adults. 2 sylvania) have passed laws limiting the ability to house When youth are tried in adult courts, they often youth in adult jails and pris- face the same sentencing guidelines as adult of- ons. fenders. In the majority of cases a juvenile court judge has not had an opportunity to evaluate the circumstances of the case before a youth is pros- ecuted as an adult, and adult criminal court judges Trend 2 often have very little discretion in the type of sen- Three states (Connecticut, tence they can impose on a youth convicted in the Illinois, and Mississippi) adult system. Incarcerating children in the adult have expanded their juve- system puts them at higher risk of abuse, injury, nile court jurisdiction so that and death while they are in the system, and makes older youth who previously would be automatically it more likely that they will reoffend once they get tried as adults are not prosecuted in adult criminal out. court. At the time the laws were passed, few policymak- ers understood these consequences. Now they do. Trend 3 Politics has caught up with public opinion and now Ten states (Arizona, Colorado, Connecticut, Del- seems to reflect what 90% of Americans believe – aware, Illinois, Indiana, Nevada, Utah, Virginia that rehabilitative services and treatment for incar- and Washington) have changed their transfer laws cerated youth can prevent future crimes.3 making it more likely that youth will stay in the juvenile justice system. State Trends: Legislative Changes from 2005 to 2010 Removing Youth from the Adult Criminal Jus- tice System provides state policymakers, the media, Trend 4 the public, and advocates for reform with the lat- Four states (Colorado, Georgia, Texas, and Wash- est information about youth in the adult criminal ington) have all changed their mandatory minimum justice system. The first half of this report explains sentencing laws to take into account the develop- the dangers to youth, public safety, and the overall mental differences between youth and adults. prosperity of our economy and future generations. The second half of the report looks at legislative reforms aimed at removing youth from the crimi- nal justice system by examining state juvenile jus- tice legislation compiled by the National Juvenile 7
  • 10. Understanding the Consequences of Trying Youth as Adults “When a kid commits a crime, society shouldn’t give up on that kid.” – Congressman Chris Murphy 8
  • 11. Teen Brains Are Not Fully Developed A s any parent knows, teenagers are works in progress. They do not have the same abilities as adults to make sound judgments in complex sit- specific arrest rates we can see that youth is a time characterized by delinquency that then sharply drops off. In fact, engaging in delinquent activi- uations, to control their impulses, or to plan effec- ties is a normal part of the adolescent experience. tively for the long term. Recent brain science has Almost all of the readers of this report will likely been able to demonstrate why it is that adolescents be able to recall participating in an activity during act the way they do. their adolescence that violates at least one criminal law today. It is also true that for the vast majority What science tells us is that the brain architecture of readers, these activities were temporary and did is constructed through a process that starts before not indicate that they would become lifelong of- birth and continues into adulthood. During adoles- fenders. cence, the brain undergoes dramatic changes to the structure and function of the brain impacting the The upside of this brain research is that the rapid way youth process and react to information. The growth and development happening in adolescent region of the brain that is the last to develop is the brains make them highly elastic and malleable one that controls many of the abilities that govern to change. The relationships made and behaviors goal-oriented, “rational” decision-making, such as learned during this crucial developmental stage long-term planning, impulse control, insight, and are hard-wired into the brain architecture and help judgment. determine long-term life outcomes. When young people hit a rough patch, guidance from respon- The downside to these brain changes is that this sible adults and developmentally appropriate pro- means that youth are particularly vulnerable to grams, services, and punishment can get them back making the kinds of poor decisions that get them on track. involved in the justice system. By examining age- The juvenile justice system is based on this science and provides troubled adolescents with mentors, education, and the guidance to help most of them mature into responsible adults. In contrast, ware- housing minors in the adult system ensures that they will not have guidance from responsible adults or have access to age-appropriate programs, services and punishment to help build positive change into their brains during this crucial developmental pe- riod. Instead, they will face the reality of having a permanent criminal record and the increased likeli- hood of becoming career criminals. This is not the outcome we want for America’s children. 9
  • 12. Moving Youth into the Adult System Costs States Millions: Lessons from Rhode Island With the current financial crisis, states across the Children are not little adults, and country are exploring ways to decrease the costs a criminal justice system that is of the justice system. According to the Pew Center designed for adults does not work on the States, state correctional costs quadrupled for youth. over the past two decades and now top $50 billion a year, consuming one in every 15 general fund Rhode Island is a state that recently dollars.5 When state policymakers have conversa- experimented with moving 17-year- tions about reforms to either the juvenile or adult olds into their adult system as a way to criminal justice system, an issue that often gets for- close a budget shortfall in 2007. 7 It took gotten is youth in the adult system. Some states see only a couple of months for the state to the juvenile and adult systems as interchangeable realize that it would cost much more to keep youth and seek to consolidate the two systems in an ef- safe in the adult system, and the legislature quickly fort to save money. This is a very costly mistake for repealed the law.8 Rhode Island now stands as a states as each high-risk youth diverted from a life powerful example to other states that consolidat- of crime saves society nearly $5.7 million in costs ing or otherwise moving more youth into the adult over a lifetime.6 system is a bad idea. 10
  • 13. The Juvenile Justice System Demands More Than the Adult Justice System The adult system is typically thought to be more punishment-oriented than the juvenile system, but the minor crimes that youth commit mean that the majority of youth are only given an adult pro- bation sentence as well as a lifelong adult criminal record that makes it hard for them to get jobs in the future. In contrast, the juvenile justice system holds youth accountable for their crimes by placing more requirements on youth and their families. The juvenile justice system often requires that youth attend school, pay community and victim restitution, and receive the counseling, mentoring, and training they need to turn their lives around. The adult justice system completely fails those youth who would benefit from the services of the juvenile system by letting them “slip through the cracks.” Comparison of Requirements between the Adult and Juvenile System in North Carolina In the Juvenile System In the Adult System Parent • Parent/guardian must be involved. • Parent/guardian need not be notified. Involvement • Youth released from detention center • Youth can make bail and leave county only to parent/guardian. Youth have jail on own recognizance. no right to pretrial release, no right to bond. Education • Youth must attend school or get a GED. • No education requirement. Age-Appropriate • Youth receive assessments, have • Services not required or, often, never frequent contact with court counselors, even offered. Services, and report regularly for rehabilitative Treatment, and services. • Those offered are intended for adults Punishment and therefore are not developmentally • Youth and families often receive court- appropriate for youth. ordered evidence-based therapies: counseling, training, mentoring, tutoring, and parenting skills. • Youth with mental health and substance abuse issues receive intensive services. • Regular contact with court counselors. Source: Action for Children North Carolina 11
  • 14. Youth Arrests, 2009 { Only 5% of Murder and nonnegligent manslaughter – 0.1% 100% 100% Rape and other sex offenses* – 0.8% Aggravated Assault 2.6% Robbery 1.7% 95%95% Drug Crimes** 8.9% youth are arrested for Other assaults 11.6% the crimes of homicide, rape, robbery, Property Crimes*** (e.g., burglary, larceny, vandalism) or aggravated 28.1% assault. Disorderly Conduct 8.0% * Includes Forcible rape and other sex offenses except prostitution ** Drug Abuse Violations All other offenses**** *** Property crimes are offenses of burglary, larceny-theft, motor 21.1% vehicle theft, arson, vandalism, stolen property (buying, receiving, possessing) **** Also includes forgery and counterfeiting, fraud, embezzlement, gambling, suspicion, offenses against the family and children, prostitution and commercialized vice, driving under the influence, drunkenness, and Status Offenses***** vagrancy, weapons offenses but does not include traffic offenses (e.g., runaways, curfew violations, ***** Status offenses include liquor laws) runaways, curfew and loitering law violations, liquor laws 17.2% Source: Federal Bureau of Investigation, Crime in the United 0% 0% States, 2009 12
  • 15. Most Youth in the Adult System Are Convicted of Minor Crimes A ny mention of juvenile crime tends to evoke images that perpetuate three specific myths about youth. First, newspaper and television cover- Second, there is a perception that juvenile crime is on the rise. In reality, youth crime has been going down for many years and is now at historic lows. age of youth crime tends to involve stories focused The number of adults arrested between 1999 and on gangs or murder leading to a distorted view of 2008 increased 3.4%, whereas the number of juve- the nature of juvenile crime. Youth who have been niles arrested dropped a staggering 15.7% during arrested for violent crimes are rare and only ac- that same time frame.10 count for about 5% of all juveniles arrested each year.9 Drugs, burglary, theft, and other property Third, there is a perception that youth commit the ma- crimes are among the more common reasons teens jority of crime in the nation. The truth is that adults are prosecuted in adult courts. commit the majority of crime in America. In 2008, Juvenile Crime Has Been Declining for Years 10000 Juvenile Arrest Rates by Offense 7500 5000 2500 0 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 * Violent crime index includes murder & nonnegligent manslaughter, forcible rape, robbery, and aggravated assault. ** Property crime index includes burglary, larceny-theft, motor vehicle theft, and arson. Source: National Center for Juvenile Justice; OJJDP Statistical Briefing Book 13
  • 16. only 12% of violent crime and 18% of property crime even youth who receive the most serious sanction nationwide were attributed to youth.11 According to – a sentence of imprisonment in an adult prison – are the FBI, youth under age 18 accounted for 15% of all not the serious offenders that one may imagine. The arrests.12 majority of youth held in adult prisons are not given extreme sentences such as life without parole, and These three misperceptions apply equally to youth in 95% of youth will be released back to their com- the adult justice system. The overwhelming majority munities before their 25th birthday.14 Unfortunately, of youth who enter the adult court are not there for by virtue of being prosecuted in the adult system serious, violent crimes. Despite the fact that many of these youth are less likely to get an education or the state laws were intended to prosecute the most skills training, and their adult conviction will make serious offenders, most youth who are tried in adult it harder for them to get jobs. courts are there for nonviolent offenses.13 A signifi- cant proportion of youth, in some states the major- ity, only receive a sentence of probation. However, Age-Specific Arrest Rates Rise Sharply During Youth Then Drop Off Youth Adults 3000 Violent Crime Index Murder Aggravated Assault Robbery Property Index 2250 Arrest Rates, 2001 1500 750 0 12 & under 13-14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25-29 30-34 35-39 40-44 45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 Age Source: Adapted from OJJDP Statistical Briefing Book 14
  • 17. Youth Are Often Housed in Adult Jails and Prisons O ne of the most serious consequences of adult court prosecution is that youth can be housed in adult jails and prisons. On any given night in If detained pre-trial, two-thirds of youth prosecuted as adults are held in adult jails. America, 10,000 children are held in adult jails and prisons.15 State laws vary widely as to whether youth can be housed in adult facilities. Although federal law requires that youth in the ju- venile justice system be removed from adult jails or be sight-and-sound separated from other adults, these protections do not apply to youth prosecuted in the adult criminal justice system.16 In fact, many youth who are held in adult jails have not even been convicted. Research shows that many never will. As many as one-half of these youth will be sent back to the juvenile justice system or will not be convicted. Yet, most of these youth will have spent at least one month in an adult jail, and one in five of these youth will have spent over six months in an adult jail.17 Source: Jailing Juveniles, Campaign for Youth Justice While in adult jails or prisons, most youth are de- Youth are also in extreme danger when held in nied educational and rehabilitative services that are adult facilities. Staff in adult facilities face a di- necessary for their stage in development. A survey lemma: they can house youth in the general adult of adult facilities found that 40% of jails provided population where they are at substantial risk of no educational services at all, only 11% provided physical and sexual abuse, or they can house youth special education services, and a mere 7% provid- in segregated settings in which isolation can cause ed vocational training.18 This lack of education in- or exacerbate mental health problems. creases the difficulty that youth will have once they return to their communities. “When you take juveniles and put them in adult jails, they learn to be better adult criminals.” – New Hampshire State Representative Mary Walz 15
  • 18. According to Sheriff Gabe Morgan Youth Under 18 in Adult Prisons, 2009 of Newport News, Virginia: The average 14-year-old is a “guppy in the ocean” of an adult facility. The law does not protect the juveniles; it says they are adults and treats them as such. Often they are placed in isolation for their protec- tion, usually 23 ½ hours alone. Around age 17, we put [the youth] in the young head popu- lation, a special unit where all the youth are put together, and the 13- and 14-year-olds nor- mally fall prey there as well.19 Youth who are held in adult facili- ties are at the greatest risk of sexual victimization. The National Prison Rape Elimination Commission found that “more than any other group of incarcerated persons, youth incarcerated with adults are probably at the highest risk for sex- ual abuse.” 20 Keeping youth away from other adult inmates is no solution either. Isolation has devastating conse- quences for youth – these conditions can cause anxiety, paranoia, and ex- acerbate existing mental disorders and put youth at risk of suicide. In * Prisons and jails form one integrated system. Data include total jail and prison populations. fact, youth housed in adult jails are ** Counts include those held in privately-operated facilities. 36 times more likely to commit sui- Source: Bureau of Justice Statistics cide than are youth housed in juve- nile detention facilities.21 16 16