SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 8
Baixar para ler offline
Ideavibes WhitepaperPRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING
                          FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT
Practical Crowdsourcing for Civic Engagement




                                      Tuesday June 7, 2011




Practical Crowdsourcing
for Civic Engagement
PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING
FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT


Table of Contents
Engaging the Citizen Diaspora .................................................................................................................................................................... 3

Crowdsourcing & Civic Behaviour.............................................................................................................................................................. 3
      Low voter participation ................................................................................................................................................................................................3

      High social media activity .......................................................................................................................................................................................... 4

The Best of Both Worlds............................................................................................................................................................................... 5
      Offline Engagement ......................................................................................................................................................................................................5

       Online Engagement ......................................................................................................................................................................................................5

Practical Applications of Crowdsourcing for Civic Engagement ........................................................................................................ 5
      Crowdsource to Solve Problems ...............................................................................................................................................................................6

      Crowdsource to Get the Job Done ...........................................................................................................................................................................6

      Crowdsource to Increase Participation ...................................................................................................................................................................6

      Crowdsource to be More Transparent .....................................................................................................................................................................6

      Crowdsource to spur change .....................................................................................................................................................................................7

Benefits of Crowdsourcing ........................................................................................................................................................................... 7
      Long-Lived.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................7

      Budget-Friendly .............................................................................................................................................................................................................7

      Immediate .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................7

      Transparent .....................................................................................................................................................................................................................7

The Crowd is Talking. Are You Listening? ................................................................................................................................................ 8
PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING
                                                                           FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT


      “...social media has demonstrated its capacity to compel social movements and create large-
       scale change quickly.”                                    - Citizen Engagement Laboratory (Berkley1)




Engaging the Citizen Diaspora
Civic engagement is challenging to accomplish in a society                                  from individual voluntarism to organizational involvement to
where individuals no longer congregate around a few common                                  electoral participation...Civic engagement encompasses a range
public spaces, such as a town hall or church. It is ever more                               of specific activities such as working in a soup kitchen, serv-
difficult for governments, citizen-focused organizations and                                 ing on a neighbourhood [sic] association, writing a letter to an
elected representatives to reach constituents who divide their                              elected official or voting.”2
discretionary time between a wide variety of specific social                                 Civic participation is critical to involving citizens in learning about,
groups, various sports and hobbies, travel and more. But, social                            contributing to, supporting or improving issues that affect them,
media does provide a cost-effective and efficient tool to reach                              such as decisions about public spaces, large public expenditures,
this citizen diaspora.                                                                      solving problems in communities, and accomplishing tasks
Through social media, individuals expand their social networks                              through volunteerism. Crowdsourcing compliments these goals
globally while bringing the entire world closer to them—mak-                                by providing organizations and governments with a means of
ing it a smaller, more accessible place. By taking advantage of                             engaging individual awareness and input on a large scale. It builds
the underpinnings of social media behaviour and Open Source                                 upon citizens’ natural inclinations towards creativity, competition
principles, crowdsourcing harnesses the ideas of large, disparate                           and involvement to generate powerful ideas and solutions.
groups of people (citizens) to gather input and create awareness                            Crowdsourcing is particularly relevant for civic engagement
that leads to change.                                                                       efforts because it bridges the divide between two current
In this paper, I will demonstrate how of crowdsourcing can be                               phenomena in civic behaviour: low voter participation and high
employed to build participation in citizen engagement campaigns                             social media activity.

Crowdsourcing & Civic Behaviour                                                             Low voter participation
Reality talent shows and websites that enable viewer-audience                               Voter turnout in the most recent Canadian federal election and
voting have proven that individuals are naturally driven to give                            the United States presidential elections saw a slight increase
their input when they can see the immediate results of their                                over previous elections. Both campaigns engaged more social
contributions. Voting is a proven way of enabling participation                             media elements than ever before, which may have contributed
and it is a yardstick of civic engagement—it is also a key compo-                           to the slight lift in participation. Yet, the number of voters is still
nent in many crowdsourcing activities.                                                      too low: the 2011 Canadian federal election saw a voter turnout
                                                                                            of 61.4%3, and the 2008 American presidential election saw
The American Psychological Association has defined civic                                     a turnout of 63.7%4. With nearly 40% of the population not
engagement as, “Individual and collective actions designed                                  voting, the outcome of these elections does not necessarily
to identify and address issues of public concern.” The kinds of                             represent the overall wishes of an entire population.
activities that comprise civic engagement “can take many forms,




1.   “Using Social Media to Organize Social Movements: A Look at Citizen Engagement Laboratory”. http://www.triplepundit.com/2011/05/social-media-citizen-engagement-laboratory/
2.   American Psychological Association. “Civic Engagement” webpage as of 03-05-11: http://www.apa.org/education/undergrad/civic-engagement.aspx
3.   http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canadavotes2011/story/2011/05/03/cv-election-voter-turnout-1029.html, CBC News, ‘Voter turnout inches up to 61.4%’, May 3rd 2011.
4.   http://www.census.gov/prod/2010pubs/p20-562.pdf, US Census Bureau, Voting and Registration in the Election of November 2008, May 2010



                                                                                                                                                                        IDEAVIBES | 3
PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING
   FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT


   High social media activity
   The number of people using social media websites grows daily,                                similar interests, or who work in the same industry. Canadians in
   including an increasing number of adults. Social media usage                                 particular spend a great deal of time online—more than people
   data from May 2011 collected by Ad Age indicates that nearly                                 from 11 other countries (including the U.S. and U.K.), according
   36% of male Facebook users and more than 27% of female                                       to a 2011 comScore survey:
   Facebook users fall between the ages of 30 and 54.5
   These individuals are using Facebook, LinkedIn and Twitter
   to connect with family members, friends, people who share



    “The study found that Canadians spent an average of 43.5 hours online in the fourth quarter of 2010, nearly double the average of
   23.1 hours surfed by the 11 countries surveyed… The study also tracked Canadians’ social networking, with Facebook (seven per cent),
                       Twitter (11 per cent) and LinkedIn (35 per cent) all claiming significant increases in unique visitors.”6



   Consider these additional statistics regarding social media use in 20107:


   TWITTER                                                  FACEBOOK                                                          VIDEOS & PHOTOS
   25 billion: number of tweets sent                        600 million: people on Facebook at                                2 billion: number of videos watched per
   on Twitter in 2010                                       the end of 2010                                                   day on YouTube
   100 million: new accounts added                          250 million: new people on Facebook                               5 billion: photos hosted by Flickr
   on Twitter in 2010                                       in 2010                                                           (September 2010)
   175 million: people on Twitter                           30 billion: pieces of content (links,                             3000+: photos uploaded per minute
   as of September 2010                                     notes, photos, etc.) shared on Facebook                           to Flickr
                                                            per month                                                         3+ billion: photos uploaded per month
                                                            70%: share of Facebook’s user base                                to Facebook
                                                            located outside the United States
                                                            20 million: number of Facebook apps
                                                            installed each day



   Given these numbers, it is certain that citizens can be—and                                  must be embraced and used to connect with and reach out
   should be engaged with online, and that social media activity                                to citizens.



   5 Carmichael, Matt. The Demographics of Social Media. AdAgeBlogs, May16, 2011: http://adage.com/article/adagestat/demographics-facebook-linkedin-myspace-twitter/227569/
   6 Barber, Michael. Survey finds Canadians spending more time online than those in other countries. The Vancouver Sun, March 9, 2011: http://www.vancouversun.com/news/Survey+finds+
      Canadians+spending+more+time+online+than+those+other+countries/4408671/story.html
   7. Coleman, Rebecca. State of the Union: Social Networking, citing Royal Pingdom blog post, Internet 2010 in numbers: http://www.rebeccacoleman.ca/2011/02/04/social-media/
      state-of-the-union-social-networking-2/


4 | IDEAVIBES
PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING
                                                                             FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT


The Best of Both Worlds                                                                        Online Engagement

In order to improve citizen engagement, elected representatives                                The Internet has made way for new civic engagement opportu-
and civic organizations must combine tried-and-true traditional                                nities. As Nicol Tuner-Lee notes9:
methods of campaigning with more innovative approaches that                                    “The Internet has become the new platform for freedom
reflect these changes in citizen behaviour. Barack Obama’s cam-                                 of speech, and the expression of civic ideas. With more than
paign during the 2008 US presidential election was one of the                                  66 percent of Americans online, virtual micro-communities,
first large-scale political campaigns to do this—I’ll discuss that                              or niche web portals, have made it easier for people to deliber-
campaign later in this paper.                                                                  ately seek out and sustain relationships with those who share
Organizations, government agencies and governments can                                         similar interests, opinions, and backgrounds. Citizens can pick
engage with their audience through a number of offline and                                      and choose both the online destination where they want to
online mediums.                                                                                share, and the preferred format to communicate their opinions
                                                                                               whether through a blog, video, podcast, or tweet. Before the
Offline Engagement                                                                              Internet, these ideas were shared at community town hall and
                                                                                               block club meetings.”
The Pew Internet & American Life Project conducted a study called
The Current State of Civic Engagement in America, which outlines                               According to research by the Pew Internet & American Life Project,
some of the various offline methods that citizens use to contact                                citizens are using these online methods to communicate with
politicians at various levels8:                                                                their local leaders:
•     Contact a government official in person, by phone or by letter                            •      Send an email to a government official
•     Sign a paper petition                                                                    •      Sign a petition online
•     Send a letter to the editor through the mail                                             •      Email a letter to the editor
•     Make a political contribution in person, by phone or through                             •      Make a political contribution on the Internet
      the mail                                                                                 •      Communicate with a civic/political group by email, text
•     Communicate with a civic/political group by face-to-face                                        messaging, instant messaging, using the group’s website or
      meetings, print letter or newsletter or telephone                                               using a social networking site
Some of the offline methods that politicians use to reach out to
citizens include:                                                                              Practical Applications of Crowdsourcing
•     Door-to-door canvassing                                                                  for Civic Engagement
•     Mass mail-outs or flyer drop-offs                                                         Author Jeff Howe was one of the first people to coin the term,
•     Town hall meetings, in-person Q & A sessions, public debates                             crowdsourcing. The practice applies Open Source principles to
                                                                                               fields outside of software by taking a task traditionally per-
•     Interviews                                                                               formed by one person and outsourcing it to a large group of
These tactics represent traditional offline activities that are still                           people. Crowdsourcing is like an open call for ideas.
important elements of citizen engagement, particularly among                                   Crowdsourcing can engage audiences in projects, challenges and
the over-40 voter population.                                                                  decisions. It gathers the collective wisdom of large numbers of




8. Pew Internet & American Life Project. The Current State of Civic Engagement in America, 2009: http://pewinternet.org/Reports/2009/15--The-Internet-and-Civic-Engagement/2--
   The-Current-State-of-Civic-Engagement-in-America.aspx?r=1
9. Tuner-Lee, Nicol. The Challenge of Increasing Civic Engagement in the Digital Age. The Future of Digital Communications: Policy Perspectives: http://twcresearchprogram.com/pdf/
   TWC%20Policy_Turner-Lee.pdf



                                                                                                                                                                               IDEAVIBES | 5
PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING
   FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT


   people to arrive at outcomes and conclusions that are more accu-                                members of the crowd’s own networks involved. Through
   rate than, or otherwise superior to, the wisdom of any individual.                              increased participation, the impact of a crowdsourcing cam-
   James Surowiecki, in his 2004 book, The Wisdom of Crowds: Why                                   paign becomes stronger. It can also be used to solve issues in
   the Many Are Smarter Than the Few and How Collective Wisdom                                     a very cost-effective way compared to hiring market research
   Shapes Business, Economies, Societies and Nations, acknowledges                                 firms, or in concert with traditional market research. Tapping
   that not all crowds are wise—for example, a crazed mob.                                         the wisdom of the crowd brings new ideas to the table very
                                                                                                   rapidly and at low cost. It also attracts experts who can offer
   He identifies these four attributes of a wise crowd:                                             their services, expertise and advice to help get the job done in
     i. Diversity of opinion—each contributor/source has private                                   the way citizens want it done.
        information or interpretation of the topic                                                 Crowdsource to Increase Participation
     ii. Independence—contributors’ opinions are not determined by
         those of others                                                                           Crowdsourcing is very accessible and makes it easier for indi-
                                                                                                   vidual citizens to be heard, because posting an idea or voting
     iii. Decentralization—contributors can specialize by drawing on                               for an idea is very easy to do. Even busy individuals who are not
          local knowledge                                                                          able to participate in community organizations or attend interest
     iv. Aggregation—a mechanism is in place to gather private                                     group meetings can have a voice through crowdsourcing. It is
         judgements into a collective decision                                                     also a viable tool to engage younger citizens who have grown
   Effective crowdsourcing leverages these attributes to gain                                      up with the Internet and social media as an integral part of their
   more accurate insights into problems and solutions than can                                     day-to-day lives.
   be achieved through discussions with individuals or small local                                 Barack Obama’s 2008 federal election campaign in the United
   groups. These are some ways that you can engage a crowd to                                      States offers one of the greatest examples to date of using social
   achieve civic engagement goals:                                                                 media and online collaboration to foster greater participation:
   Crowdsource to Solve Problems                                                                   “Most recently, the 2008 election demonstrated how the
                                                                                                   Internet could drive public opinion and voter participation.
   Crowdsourcing is frequently used as a problem-solving tool and                                  President Barack Obama’s campaign used online tools and
   can therefore be a tool to improve results-oriented civic engage-                               social networks in a way that contributed to his victory as
   ment. For example, some cities and communities have em-                                         the first African American President of the United States.
   braced crowdsourcing as a means of incorporating residents into                                 The Obama campaign used the Internet to raise half a billion
   decision making and getting them to help solve problems. Civic                                  dollars, the largest amount of contributions to a political op-
   leaders may be hesitant to use social media tools because they                                  eration ever received through online donations. His website,
   are afraid they will be used as centres rather than remaining fo-                               MyBarackObama.com, gathered thousands of e-mail address-
   cused on the task at hand. Crowdsourcing is ideal for overcom-                                  es and, in turn, nurtured a vast base of national volunteers
   ing this concern because it can be highly specific. For example, it                              supporting the campaign’s field tactics.”10
   can be used to have citizens first vote to determine the highest
   priority problem to solve, then to have them vote on solutions to                               Crowdsource to Be More Transparent
   the problem—including solutions that they and others post.                                      Today’s consumers demand transparency from major corpora-
   Crowdsource to Get the Job Done                                                                 tions, governments and elected officials. Taxpayers want to
                                                                                                   know where their dollars are being spent and to ensure that
   Crowdsourcing relies on social media behaviour (such as                                         public funds are not being wasted. They also want to be includ-
   sharing and liking) to build awareness among and get the                                        ed in the decision-making process. Transparency is also critical


   10 Tuner-Lee, Nicol. The Challenge of Increasing Civic Engagement in the Digital Age. The Future of Digital Communications: Policy Perspectives: http://twcresearchprogram.com/pdf/
      TWC%20Policy_Turner-Lee.pdf




6 | IDEAVIBES
PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING
                                                                             FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT


to good governance—another quality that citizens demand from                                    time as new ideas, comments and people become engaged in
major corporations and our governing bodies.                                                    the conversation. Once off the ground, crowdsourcing cam-
Crowdsourcing can be used to improve access to information;                                     paigns become crowd-driven. As long as there is crowd engage-
it can ensure that information is timely, accurate, complete and                                ment and interest, the campaign will live.
relevant to citizen inquiries; it can disseminate messages very                                 Budget-Friendly
quickly to large audiences; and, it makes it possible to incorpo-
rate citizens in the decision making process. Some organizations                                Crowdsourcing uses networks of people and social media tools
use crowdsourcing as a customer feedback tool—the same                                          to spread the word about campaigns, projects and ideas. This
concept can be applied to civic life as well, giving citizens easy                              makes it possible to create a far-reaching effort that stretches
access to the lines of communication and empowering them to                                     campaign dollars. It can also be used to improve the return on
contribute by giving them a voice.                                                              investment of traditional campaigns. By bringing people’s atten-
                                                                                                tion to crowdsourcing campaigns in offline engagement activi-
Crowdsource to Spur Change                                                                      ties (for example, calls to action to “go online and vote for the
Crowdsourcing has applications far beyond the campaign mo-                                      change you want” printed on campaign pamphlets or referenced
ment: it can be used in everyday activities to continually engage                               in TV ads), the value and ROI of traditional engagement tools
with citizens and address real-time issues. Crowdsourcing gath-                                 can be increased.
ers a wealth of information, ideas and opinions that leaders and                                Immediate
citizens never used to have access to. As Diana Scearce writes:
                                                                                                While door-to-door and telephone campaigns provide represen-
“Throughout history, social change has been possible only
                                                                                                tatives with immediate feedback from citizens, these methods
through the contributions and dedication of many citizens.
                                                                                                by necessity reach only a small percentage of the population.
Today’s network-centric engagement builds on existing know-
                                                                                                Combining these activities with crowdsourcing provides govern-
how, drawing in particular on grassroots community organizing
                                                                                                ments and politicians with a more complete picture of opinions
and the open-source software movement.”11
                                                                                                and preferences. Crowdsourcing campaigns can deliver a broad
Crowdsourcing can be used to engage individuals and grassroots                                  understanding of general opinions very quickly—information
community organizations in meaningful change at any time.                                       that can be leveraged during walk-abouts and phone campaigns
                                                                                                to dig deeper into citizens’ opinions and to validate crowdsourc-
Benefits of Crowdsourcing                                                                        ing campaign findings one-on-one.

In addition to the capabilities discussed above, crowdsourcing                                  Transparent
offers a number of benefits over traditional methods of civic
                                                                                                As discussed earlier in this paper, crowdsourcing provides
engagement, including:
                                                                                                citizens with a new kind of transparency into government. It
Long-Lived                                                                                      does so by enagling greater access to information and decision-
                                                                                                making processes, as well as providing a platform for citizens to
Crowdsourcing has a longer lifespan than traditional campaigns,                                 participate in those processes.
which tend to die out when the budget is spent and/or resources
are reassigned. Crowdsourcing, on the other hand, evolves over




11. Scearce, Diana. Connected Citizens: The Power, Peril and Potential of Networks. Crowdsourcing.org, 2011: http://www.crowdsourcing.org/document/
    connected-citizens-the-power-peril-and-potential-of-networks-/3490




                                                                                                                                                         IDEAVIBES | 7
PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING
   FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT


   The Crowd is Talking, Are You Listening?
   Everyday, citizens are having conversations about their govern-                              information that would otherwise be too costly or otherwise
   ment and its decisions. Being able to tap into those conversa-                               unfeasible to gather. Able to reach a more diverse citizen base
   tions and gather meaningful opinions that can be used for                                    than traditional methods of civic engagement, crowdsourcing
   decision-making is critical to the effectiveness of governments,                             can provide equally valuable input and direction and can be used
   civic organizations and elected officials. Crowdsourcing—and                                  to enhance the value of traditional tools. Perhaps most impor-
   other social media—are tools that ignite conversations and turn                              tantly, crowdsourcing expands the reach of a message or idea to
   bystanders into active participants in government.                                           networks beyond one’s immediate crowd.
   Crowdsourcing is a key component in the digital democracy—                                   Ideavibes™ has developed the first hosted Crowd Engagement
   a social reality in which “the divide between media [message]                                Platform™ that is designed to allow governments, civic organiza-
   producers and consumers has dissolved and citizen [produced]                                 tions and elected representatives to frame engagement in a way
   media rules… While before citizens had to rally for mainstream                               that creates greater citizen engagement. It is also the first platform
   media attention to catch the ears of politicians, now it is easier                           that delivers the power to create crowdsourcing or crowdfund-
   than ever before for citizens to launch awareness campaigns and                              ing campaigns from a single, easy to use control panel. For more
   get their message heard by the masses.”12                                                    information, visit www.ideavibes.com and www.fundchange.com.
   Through its participatory nature, crowdsourcing gives govern-
   ments and elected representatives useful insights and valuable




   12. Campbell, Lisa. Dotmocracy: Crowdsourcing, mashups and social change: http://www.mobilerevolutions.org/Dotmocracy.pdf




8 | IDEAVIBES

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

The Role of Design As a Critical Friend to Voluntary Community Sector - Warwi...
The Role of Design As a Critical Friend to Voluntary Community Sector - Warwi...The Role of Design As a Critical Friend to Voluntary Community Sector - Warwi...
The Role of Design As a Critical Friend to Voluntary Community Sector - Warwi...ServDes
 
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens Multimedia Report
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens   Multimedia ReportRecentering Democracy Around Citizens   Multimedia Report
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens Multimedia ReportMatt Leighninger
 
3 12 2008 Myths & Realities Of Democratic Trustee Governance Of Public Commun...
3 12 2008 Myths & Realities Of Democratic Trustee Governance Of Public Commun...3 12 2008 Myths & Realities Of Democratic Trustee Governance Of Public Commun...
3 12 2008 Myths & Realities Of Democratic Trustee Governance Of Public Commun...michelletscott
 
The Next Form of Democracy - The Future of Public Participation
The Next Form of Democracy - The Future of Public ParticipationThe Next Form of Democracy - The Future of Public Participation
The Next Form of Democracy - The Future of Public ParticipationMatt Leighninger
 
Beyond the Town Hall - Engaging Broad Audiences of Citizens
Beyond the Town Hall - Engaging Broad Audiences of CitizensBeyond the Town Hall - Engaging Broad Audiences of Citizens
Beyond the Town Hall - Engaging Broad Audiences of CitizensMatt Leighninger
 
Notes in Psychology: The Digital Marketplace
Notes in Psychology: The Digital MarketplaceNotes in Psychology: The Digital Marketplace
Notes in Psychology: The Digital MarketplaceAhmad Hamdan
 
Expanded Presentation | Civic Shift: Action-Learning Lab for Systematic Civic...
Expanded Presentation | Civic Shift: Action-Learning Lab for Systematic Civic...Expanded Presentation | Civic Shift: Action-Learning Lab for Systematic Civic...
Expanded Presentation | Civic Shift: Action-Learning Lab for Systematic Civic...Leadership Learning Community
 
Arnstein ladder of participation
 Arnstein  ladder of participation Arnstein  ladder of participation
Arnstein ladder of participationSolomon Adetokunbo
 
Social Media and Civic Engagement
Social Media and Civic EngagementSocial Media and Civic Engagement
Social Media and Civic Engagementrheannmcbride
 
Community involvement
Community involvementCommunity involvement
Community involvementTim Curtis
 
Community Hub Development_April 2013
Community Hub Development_April 2013Community Hub Development_April 2013
Community Hub Development_April 2013Michael W. Andrews
 
Mp 4 cidadania
Mp 4 cidadaniaMp 4 cidadania
Mp 4 cidadaniaLuis Pedro
 
Mp 2012 13_cidadania
Mp 2012 13_cidadaniaMp 2012 13_cidadania
Mp 2012 13_cidadaniaLuis Pedro
 
October 2010 ICMA Civic Engagement Presentation
October 2010 ICMA Civic Engagement PresentationOctober 2010 ICMA Civic Engagement Presentation
October 2010 ICMA Civic Engagement Presentationmikehuggins
 
Reimagining Local Government slides
Reimagining Local Government slidesReimagining Local Government slides
Reimagining Local Government slidesMatt Leighninger
 
‘New Digital Repertoires for Social Justice, Politics, and Culture?: Explori...
‘New Digital Repertoires for Social Justice, Politics, and Culture?:  Explori...‘New Digital Repertoires for Social Justice, Politics, and Culture?:  Explori...
‘New Digital Repertoires for Social Justice, Politics, and Culture?: Explori...University of Sydney
 
Creating Spaces for Change
Creating Spaces for ChangeCreating Spaces for Change
Creating Spaces for ChangeNatalie Aflalo
 
Achieving sustainable community development projects through community partic...
Achieving sustainable community development projects through community partic...Achieving sustainable community development projects through community partic...
Achieving sustainable community development projects through community partic...Alexander Decker
 

Mais procurados (20)

The Role of Design As a Critical Friend to Voluntary Community Sector - Warwi...
The Role of Design As a Critical Friend to Voluntary Community Sector - Warwi...The Role of Design As a Critical Friend to Voluntary Community Sector - Warwi...
The Role of Design As a Critical Friend to Voluntary Community Sector - Warwi...
 
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens Multimedia Report
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens   Multimedia ReportRecentering Democracy Around Citizens   Multimedia Report
Recentering Democracy Around Citizens Multimedia Report
 
3 12 2008 Myths & Realities Of Democratic Trustee Governance Of Public Commun...
3 12 2008 Myths & Realities Of Democratic Trustee Governance Of Public Commun...3 12 2008 Myths & Realities Of Democratic Trustee Governance Of Public Commun...
3 12 2008 Myths & Realities Of Democratic Trustee Governance Of Public Commun...
 
The Next Form of Democracy - The Future of Public Participation
The Next Form of Democracy - The Future of Public ParticipationThe Next Form of Democracy - The Future of Public Participation
The Next Form of Democracy - The Future of Public Participation
 
Beyond the Town Hall - Engaging Broad Audiences of Citizens
Beyond the Town Hall - Engaging Broad Audiences of CitizensBeyond the Town Hall - Engaging Broad Audiences of Citizens
Beyond the Town Hall - Engaging Broad Audiences of Citizens
 
Notes in Psychology: The Digital Marketplace
Notes in Psychology: The Digital MarketplaceNotes in Psychology: The Digital Marketplace
Notes in Psychology: The Digital Marketplace
 
Expanded Presentation | Civic Shift: Action-Learning Lab for Systematic Civic...
Expanded Presentation | Civic Shift: Action-Learning Lab for Systematic Civic...Expanded Presentation | Civic Shift: Action-Learning Lab for Systematic Civic...
Expanded Presentation | Civic Shift: Action-Learning Lab for Systematic Civic...
 
Arnstein ladder of participation
 Arnstein  ladder of participation Arnstein  ladder of participation
Arnstein ladder of participation
 
Rural Minnesota Journal: The Power of Invitation
Rural Minnesota Journal: The Power of InvitationRural Minnesota Journal: The Power of Invitation
Rural Minnesota Journal: The Power of Invitation
 
Social Media and Civic Engagement
Social Media and Civic EngagementSocial Media and Civic Engagement
Social Media and Civic Engagement
 
Community involvement
Community involvementCommunity involvement
Community involvement
 
America speaks legacy_print
America speaks legacy_printAmerica speaks legacy_print
America speaks legacy_print
 
Community Hub Development_April 2013
Community Hub Development_April 2013Community Hub Development_April 2013
Community Hub Development_April 2013
 
Mp 4 cidadania
Mp 4 cidadaniaMp 4 cidadania
Mp 4 cidadania
 
Mp 2012 13_cidadania
Mp 2012 13_cidadaniaMp 2012 13_cidadania
Mp 2012 13_cidadania
 
October 2010 ICMA Civic Engagement Presentation
October 2010 ICMA Civic Engagement PresentationOctober 2010 ICMA Civic Engagement Presentation
October 2010 ICMA Civic Engagement Presentation
 
Reimagining Local Government slides
Reimagining Local Government slidesReimagining Local Government slides
Reimagining Local Government slides
 
‘New Digital Repertoires for Social Justice, Politics, and Culture?: Explori...
‘New Digital Repertoires for Social Justice, Politics, and Culture?:  Explori...‘New Digital Repertoires for Social Justice, Politics, and Culture?:  Explori...
‘New Digital Repertoires for Social Justice, Politics, and Culture?: Explori...
 
Creating Spaces for Change
Creating Spaces for ChangeCreating Spaces for Change
Creating Spaces for Change
 
Achieving sustainable community development projects through community partic...
Achieving sustainable community development projects through community partic...Achieving sustainable community development projects through community partic...
Achieving sustainable community development projects through community partic...
 

Semelhante a Ideavibes whitepaper practical crowdsourcing for civic engagement_v02-1

2016 Connecticut Civic Health Index
2016 Connecticut Civic Health Index2016 Connecticut Civic Health Index
2016 Connecticut Civic Health IndexEveryday Democracy
 
The Participatory Irrigation Management Policy
The Participatory Irrigation Management PolicyThe Participatory Irrigation Management Policy
The Participatory Irrigation Management PolicyMichelle Johnson
 
Impact of social media of electoral process adeoye oludotun
Impact of social media of electoral process   adeoye oludotunImpact of social media of electoral process   adeoye oludotun
Impact of social media of electoral process adeoye oludotunDotun Adeoye
 
Impact of social media of electoral process adeoye oludotun
Impact of social media of electoral process   adeoye oludotunImpact of social media of electoral process   adeoye oludotun
Impact of social media of electoral process adeoye oludotunDotun Adeoye
 
Civic Engagement Presentation
Civic Engagement PresentationCivic Engagement Presentation
Civic Engagement Presentationnatcon7
 
History Of Social Relations In India
History Of Social Relations In IndiaHistory Of Social Relations In India
History Of Social Relations In IndiaPatricia Medina
 
What Is Civic Engagement
What Is Civic EngagementWhat Is Civic Engagement
What Is Civic EngagementMarisela Stone
 
Part 1 deep dive; the future role of civil society
Part 1 deep dive; the future role of civil societyPart 1 deep dive; the future role of civil society
Part 1 deep dive; the future role of civil societyKarel Eramuri
 
youth civic engagement in social media
youth civic engagement in social mediayouth civic engagement in social media
youth civic engagement in social mediaDelta-prosjektet
 
Volunteer collaboration: are we ready to harness the power of the people?, Br...
Volunteer collaboration: are we ready to harness the power of the people?, Br...Volunteer collaboration: are we ready to harness the power of the people?, Br...
Volunteer collaboration: are we ready to harness the power of the people?, Br...COOPERACION 2.0 2009
 
Media Influence On The Media
Media Influence On The MediaMedia Influence On The Media
Media Influence On The MediaMichelle Madero
 
Engaging citizens in Government
Engaging citizens in GovernmentEngaging citizens in Government
Engaging citizens in GovernmentAlban Martin
 
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-Helferich
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-HelferichA-Collective-Effort-Harrison-Helferich
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-HelferichSamantha Helferich
 
Leading edge of democracy - IAP2 Australasia Leadership Forum
Leading edge of democracy - IAP2 Australasia Leadership ForumLeading edge of democracy - IAP2 Australasia Leadership Forum
Leading edge of democracy - IAP2 Australasia Leadership ForumMatt Leighninger
 
S.Cuers Qld Planner 2006
S.Cuers Qld Planner 2006 S.Cuers Qld Planner 2006
S.Cuers Qld Planner 2006 Simone Cuers
 
Peace Building Through Community Involvement
Peace Building Through Community InvolvementPeace Building Through Community Involvement
Peace Building Through Community InvolvementDawn Robertson
 

Semelhante a Ideavibes whitepaper practical crowdsourcing for civic engagement_v02-1 (20)

2016 Connecticut Civic Health Index
2016 Connecticut Civic Health Index2016 Connecticut Civic Health Index
2016 Connecticut Civic Health Index
 
ISOCARP Democratic Urbanism
ISOCARP Democratic UrbanismISOCARP Democratic Urbanism
ISOCARP Democratic Urbanism
 
The Participatory Irrigation Management Policy
The Participatory Irrigation Management PolicyThe Participatory Irrigation Management Policy
The Participatory Irrigation Management Policy
 
Impact of social media of electoral process adeoye oludotun
Impact of social media of electoral process   adeoye oludotunImpact of social media of electoral process   adeoye oludotun
Impact of social media of electoral process adeoye oludotun
 
Impact of social media of electoral process adeoye oludotun
Impact of social media of electoral process   adeoye oludotunImpact of social media of electoral process   adeoye oludotun
Impact of social media of electoral process adeoye oludotun
 
social-media-plan-uwwa
social-media-plan-uwwasocial-media-plan-uwwa
social-media-plan-uwwa
 
Civic Engagement Presentation
Civic Engagement PresentationCivic Engagement Presentation
Civic Engagement Presentation
 
History Of Social Relations In India
History Of Social Relations In IndiaHistory Of Social Relations In India
History Of Social Relations In India
 
Health For All: A global perspective
Health For All: A global perspectiveHealth For All: A global perspective
Health For All: A global perspective
 
Essay On Role Of Media
Essay On Role Of MediaEssay On Role Of Media
Essay On Role Of Media
 
What Is Civic Engagement
What Is Civic EngagementWhat Is Civic Engagement
What Is Civic Engagement
 
Part 1 deep dive; the future role of civil society
Part 1 deep dive; the future role of civil societyPart 1 deep dive; the future role of civil society
Part 1 deep dive; the future role of civil society
 
youth civic engagement in social media
youth civic engagement in social mediayouth civic engagement in social media
youth civic engagement in social media
 
Volunteer collaboration: are we ready to harness the power of the people?, Br...
Volunteer collaboration: are we ready to harness the power of the people?, Br...Volunteer collaboration: are we ready to harness the power of the people?, Br...
Volunteer collaboration: are we ready to harness the power of the people?, Br...
 
Media Influence On The Media
Media Influence On The MediaMedia Influence On The Media
Media Influence On The Media
 
Engaging citizens in Government
Engaging citizens in GovernmentEngaging citizens in Government
Engaging citizens in Government
 
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-Helferich
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-HelferichA-Collective-Effort-Harrison-Helferich
A-Collective-Effort-Harrison-Helferich
 
Leading edge of democracy - IAP2 Australasia Leadership Forum
Leading edge of democracy - IAP2 Australasia Leadership ForumLeading edge of democracy - IAP2 Australasia Leadership Forum
Leading edge of democracy - IAP2 Australasia Leadership Forum
 
S.Cuers Qld Planner 2006
S.Cuers Qld Planner 2006 S.Cuers Qld Planner 2006
S.Cuers Qld Planner 2006
 
Peace Building Through Community Involvement
Peace Building Through Community InvolvementPeace Building Through Community Involvement
Peace Building Through Community Involvement
 

Mais de Ideavibes | Paul Dombowsky

Ideavibes_Fed-Reserve-NC-Crowdfunding-July192012
Ideavibes_Fed-Reserve-NC-Crowdfunding-July192012Ideavibes_Fed-Reserve-NC-Crowdfunding-July192012
Ideavibes_Fed-Reserve-NC-Crowdfunding-July192012Ideavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Ideavibes and Urban Resilience - Crowdsourcing for Citizen Engagement and Ope...
Ideavibes and Urban Resilience - Crowdsourcing for Citizen Engagement and Ope...Ideavibes and Urban Resilience - Crowdsourcing for Citizen Engagement and Ope...
Ideavibes and Urban Resilience - Crowdsourcing for Citizen Engagement and Ope...Ideavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Calgary Workshop - Social Media, Fundchange and Koodonation
Calgary Workshop - Social Media, Fundchange and KoodonationCalgary Workshop - Social Media, Fundchange and Koodonation
Calgary Workshop - Social Media, Fundchange and KoodonationIdeavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Ideavibes Presentation in Vancouver on Crowdsourcing & Citizen Engagement wit...
Ideavibes Presentation in Vancouver on Crowdsourcing & Citizen Engagement wit...Ideavibes Presentation in Vancouver on Crowdsourcing & Citizen Engagement wit...
Ideavibes Presentation in Vancouver on Crowdsourcing & Citizen Engagement wit...Ideavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Fundchange Koodonation Social Media for Charities and Non-Profits
Fundchange Koodonation Social Media for Charities and Non-ProfitsFundchange Koodonation Social Media for Charities and Non-Profits
Fundchange Koodonation Social Media for Charities and Non-ProfitsIdeavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Social Product Management Presentation - TPMA - Jan31/12
Social Product Management Presentation - TPMA - Jan31/12Social Product Management Presentation - TPMA - Jan31/12
Social Product Management Presentation - TPMA - Jan31/12Ideavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Ideavibes Presentation at 2012 Online Research Methods Conference - London
Ideavibes Presentation at 2012 Online Research Methods Conference - LondonIdeavibes Presentation at 2012 Online Research Methods Conference - London
Ideavibes Presentation at 2012 Online Research Methods Conference - LondonIdeavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Fundchange and Koodonation Workshop Slides - Nov 23, 2011
Fundchange and Koodonation Workshop Slides - Nov 23, 2011Fundchange and Koodonation Workshop Slides - Nov 23, 2011
Fundchange and Koodonation Workshop Slides - Nov 23, 2011Ideavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Social Product Development Primer from PDMA2011
Social Product Development Primer from PDMA2011Social Product Development Primer from PDMA2011
Social Product Development Primer from PDMA2011Ideavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Ideavibes Presentation on Crowdfunding and Fundchange - June 23/11
Ideavibes Presentation on Crowdfunding and Fundchange - June 23/11Ideavibes Presentation on Crowdfunding and Fundchange - June 23/11
Ideavibes Presentation on Crowdfunding and Fundchange - June 23/11Ideavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Ideavibes London Crowdsourcing - Crowdfunding - Citizen Engagement Workshop
Ideavibes London Crowdsourcing - Crowdfunding - Citizen Engagement WorkshopIdeavibes London Crowdsourcing - Crowdfunding - Citizen Engagement Workshop
Ideavibes London Crowdsourcing - Crowdfunding - Citizen Engagement WorkshopIdeavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing for Product Managers 05/31/11
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing for Product Managers 05/31/11Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing for Product Managers 05/31/11
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing for Product Managers 05/31/11Ideavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing and Civic or Citizen Engagement
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing and Civic or Citizen EngagementIdeavibes - Crowdsourcing and Civic or Citizen Engagement
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing and Civic or Citizen EngagementIdeavibes | Paul Dombowsky
 

Mais de Ideavibes | Paul Dombowsky (20)

Ideavibes_Fed-Reserve-NC-Crowdfunding-July192012
Ideavibes_Fed-Reserve-NC-Crowdfunding-July192012Ideavibes_Fed-Reserve-NC-Crowdfunding-July192012
Ideavibes_Fed-Reserve-NC-Crowdfunding-July192012
 
Ideavibes-Pres-Newmarket_0712
Ideavibes-Pres-Newmarket_0712Ideavibes-Pres-Newmarket_0712
Ideavibes-Pres-Newmarket_0712
 
Ideavibes ws nc-07182012
Ideavibes ws nc-07182012Ideavibes ws nc-07182012
Ideavibes ws nc-07182012
 
Ideavibes and Urban Resilience - Crowdsourcing for Citizen Engagement and Ope...
Ideavibes and Urban Resilience - Crowdsourcing for Citizen Engagement and Ope...Ideavibes and Urban Resilience - Crowdsourcing for Citizen Engagement and Ope...
Ideavibes and Urban Resilience - Crowdsourcing for Citizen Engagement and Ope...
 
Calgary Workshop - Social Media, Fundchange and Koodonation
Calgary Workshop - Social Media, Fundchange and KoodonationCalgary Workshop - Social Media, Fundchange and Koodonation
Calgary Workshop - Social Media, Fundchange and Koodonation
 
Fundchange koodonation vic-april202012
Fundchange koodonation vic-april202012Fundchange koodonation vic-april202012
Fundchange koodonation vic-april202012
 
Ideavibes Presentation in Vancouver on Crowdsourcing & Citizen Engagement wit...
Ideavibes Presentation in Vancouver on Crowdsourcing & Citizen Engagement wit...Ideavibes Presentation in Vancouver on Crowdsourcing & Citizen Engagement wit...
Ideavibes Presentation in Vancouver on Crowdsourcing & Citizen Engagement wit...
 
Fundchange Koodonation Social Media for Charities and Non-Profits
Fundchange Koodonation Social Media for Charities and Non-ProfitsFundchange Koodonation Social Media for Charities and Non-Profits
Fundchange Koodonation Social Media for Charities and Non-Profits
 
Fundchange koodonation-artez 02152012
Fundchange koodonation-artez 02152012Fundchange koodonation-artez 02152012
Fundchange koodonation-artez 02152012
 
Social Product Management Presentation - TPMA - Jan31/12
Social Product Management Presentation - TPMA - Jan31/12Social Product Management Presentation - TPMA - Jan31/12
Social Product Management Presentation - TPMA - Jan31/12
 
Ideavibes Presentation at 2012 Online Research Methods Conference - London
Ideavibes Presentation at 2012 Online Research Methods Conference - LondonIdeavibes Presentation at 2012 Online Research Methods Conference - London
Ideavibes Presentation at 2012 Online Research Methods Conference - London
 
Ideavibes Presentation to RSA London
Ideavibes Presentation to RSA LondonIdeavibes Presentation to RSA London
Ideavibes Presentation to RSA London
 
Fundchange and Koodonation Workshop Slides - Nov 23, 2011
Fundchange and Koodonation Workshop Slides - Nov 23, 2011Fundchange and Koodonation Workshop Slides - Nov 23, 2011
Fundchange and Koodonation Workshop Slides - Nov 23, 2011
 
Ideavibes Citizen Engagement Pres - Nov 2011
Ideavibes Citizen Engagement Pres - Nov 2011Ideavibes Citizen Engagement Pres - Nov 2011
Ideavibes Citizen Engagement Pres - Nov 2011
 
Social Product Development Primer from PDMA2011
Social Product Development Primer from PDMA2011Social Product Development Primer from PDMA2011
Social Product Development Primer from PDMA2011
 
Ideavibes Presentation on Crowdfunding and Fundchange - June 23/11
Ideavibes Presentation on Crowdfunding and Fundchange - June 23/11Ideavibes Presentation on Crowdfunding and Fundchange - June 23/11
Ideavibes Presentation on Crowdfunding and Fundchange - June 23/11
 
Ideavibes London Crowdsourcing - Crowdfunding - Citizen Engagement Workshop
Ideavibes London Crowdsourcing - Crowdfunding - Citizen Engagement WorkshopIdeavibes London Crowdsourcing - Crowdfunding - Citizen Engagement Workshop
Ideavibes London Crowdsourcing - Crowdfunding - Citizen Engagement Workshop
 
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing for Product Managers 05/31/11
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing for Product Managers 05/31/11Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing for Product Managers 05/31/11
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing for Product Managers 05/31/11
 
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing and Civic or Citizen Engagement
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing and Civic or Citizen EngagementIdeavibes - Crowdsourcing and Civic or Citizen Engagement
Ideavibes - Crowdsourcing and Civic or Citizen Engagement
 
Ideavibes Crowdsourcing and Civic Engagement
Ideavibes Crowdsourcing and Civic EngagementIdeavibes Crowdsourcing and Civic Engagement
Ideavibes Crowdsourcing and Civic Engagement
 

Ideavibes whitepaper practical crowdsourcing for civic engagement_v02-1

  • 1. Ideavibes WhitepaperPRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT Practical Crowdsourcing for Civic Engagement Tuesday June 7, 2011 Practical Crowdsourcing for Civic Engagement
  • 2. PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT Table of Contents Engaging the Citizen Diaspora .................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Crowdsourcing & Civic Behaviour.............................................................................................................................................................. 3 Low voter participation ................................................................................................................................................................................................3 High social media activity .......................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 The Best of Both Worlds............................................................................................................................................................................... 5 Offline Engagement ......................................................................................................................................................................................................5 Online Engagement ......................................................................................................................................................................................................5 Practical Applications of Crowdsourcing for Civic Engagement ........................................................................................................ 5 Crowdsource to Solve Problems ...............................................................................................................................................................................6 Crowdsource to Get the Job Done ...........................................................................................................................................................................6 Crowdsource to Increase Participation ...................................................................................................................................................................6 Crowdsource to be More Transparent .....................................................................................................................................................................6 Crowdsource to spur change .....................................................................................................................................................................................7 Benefits of Crowdsourcing ........................................................................................................................................................................... 7 Long-Lived.......................................................................................................................................................................................................................7 Budget-Friendly .............................................................................................................................................................................................................7 Immediate .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................7 Transparent .....................................................................................................................................................................................................................7 The Crowd is Talking. Are You Listening? ................................................................................................................................................ 8
  • 3. PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT “...social media has demonstrated its capacity to compel social movements and create large- scale change quickly.” - Citizen Engagement Laboratory (Berkley1) Engaging the Citizen Diaspora Civic engagement is challenging to accomplish in a society from individual voluntarism to organizational involvement to where individuals no longer congregate around a few common electoral participation...Civic engagement encompasses a range public spaces, such as a town hall or church. It is ever more of specific activities such as working in a soup kitchen, serv- difficult for governments, citizen-focused organizations and ing on a neighbourhood [sic] association, writing a letter to an elected representatives to reach constituents who divide their elected official or voting.”2 discretionary time between a wide variety of specific social Civic participation is critical to involving citizens in learning about, groups, various sports and hobbies, travel and more. But, social contributing to, supporting or improving issues that affect them, media does provide a cost-effective and efficient tool to reach such as decisions about public spaces, large public expenditures, this citizen diaspora. solving problems in communities, and accomplishing tasks Through social media, individuals expand their social networks through volunteerism. Crowdsourcing compliments these goals globally while bringing the entire world closer to them—mak- by providing organizations and governments with a means of ing it a smaller, more accessible place. By taking advantage of engaging individual awareness and input on a large scale. It builds the underpinnings of social media behaviour and Open Source upon citizens’ natural inclinations towards creativity, competition principles, crowdsourcing harnesses the ideas of large, disparate and involvement to generate powerful ideas and solutions. groups of people (citizens) to gather input and create awareness Crowdsourcing is particularly relevant for civic engagement that leads to change. efforts because it bridges the divide between two current In this paper, I will demonstrate how of crowdsourcing can be phenomena in civic behaviour: low voter participation and high employed to build participation in citizen engagement campaigns social media activity. Crowdsourcing & Civic Behaviour Low voter participation Reality talent shows and websites that enable viewer-audience Voter turnout in the most recent Canadian federal election and voting have proven that individuals are naturally driven to give the United States presidential elections saw a slight increase their input when they can see the immediate results of their over previous elections. Both campaigns engaged more social contributions. Voting is a proven way of enabling participation media elements than ever before, which may have contributed and it is a yardstick of civic engagement—it is also a key compo- to the slight lift in participation. Yet, the number of voters is still nent in many crowdsourcing activities. too low: the 2011 Canadian federal election saw a voter turnout of 61.4%3, and the 2008 American presidential election saw The American Psychological Association has defined civic a turnout of 63.7%4. With nearly 40% of the population not engagement as, “Individual and collective actions designed voting, the outcome of these elections does not necessarily to identify and address issues of public concern.” The kinds of represent the overall wishes of an entire population. activities that comprise civic engagement “can take many forms, 1. “Using Social Media to Organize Social Movements: A Look at Citizen Engagement Laboratory”. http://www.triplepundit.com/2011/05/social-media-citizen-engagement-laboratory/ 2. American Psychological Association. “Civic Engagement” webpage as of 03-05-11: http://www.apa.org/education/undergrad/civic-engagement.aspx 3. http://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/canadavotes2011/story/2011/05/03/cv-election-voter-turnout-1029.html, CBC News, ‘Voter turnout inches up to 61.4%’, May 3rd 2011. 4. http://www.census.gov/prod/2010pubs/p20-562.pdf, US Census Bureau, Voting and Registration in the Election of November 2008, May 2010 IDEAVIBES | 3
  • 4. PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT High social media activity The number of people using social media websites grows daily, similar interests, or who work in the same industry. Canadians in including an increasing number of adults. Social media usage particular spend a great deal of time online—more than people data from May 2011 collected by Ad Age indicates that nearly from 11 other countries (including the U.S. and U.K.), according 36% of male Facebook users and more than 27% of female to a 2011 comScore survey: Facebook users fall between the ages of 30 and 54.5 These individuals are using Facebook, LinkedIn and Twitter to connect with family members, friends, people who share “The study found that Canadians spent an average of 43.5 hours online in the fourth quarter of 2010, nearly double the average of 23.1 hours surfed by the 11 countries surveyed… The study also tracked Canadians’ social networking, with Facebook (seven per cent), Twitter (11 per cent) and LinkedIn (35 per cent) all claiming significant increases in unique visitors.”6 Consider these additional statistics regarding social media use in 20107: TWITTER FACEBOOK VIDEOS & PHOTOS 25 billion: number of tweets sent 600 million: people on Facebook at 2 billion: number of videos watched per on Twitter in 2010 the end of 2010 day on YouTube 100 million: new accounts added 250 million: new people on Facebook 5 billion: photos hosted by Flickr on Twitter in 2010 in 2010 (September 2010) 175 million: people on Twitter 30 billion: pieces of content (links, 3000+: photos uploaded per minute as of September 2010 notes, photos, etc.) shared on Facebook to Flickr per month 3+ billion: photos uploaded per month 70%: share of Facebook’s user base to Facebook located outside the United States 20 million: number of Facebook apps installed each day Given these numbers, it is certain that citizens can be—and must be embraced and used to connect with and reach out should be engaged with online, and that social media activity to citizens. 5 Carmichael, Matt. The Demographics of Social Media. AdAgeBlogs, May16, 2011: http://adage.com/article/adagestat/demographics-facebook-linkedin-myspace-twitter/227569/ 6 Barber, Michael. Survey finds Canadians spending more time online than those in other countries. The Vancouver Sun, March 9, 2011: http://www.vancouversun.com/news/Survey+finds+ Canadians+spending+more+time+online+than+those+other+countries/4408671/story.html 7. Coleman, Rebecca. State of the Union: Social Networking, citing Royal Pingdom blog post, Internet 2010 in numbers: http://www.rebeccacoleman.ca/2011/02/04/social-media/ state-of-the-union-social-networking-2/ 4 | IDEAVIBES
  • 5. PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT The Best of Both Worlds Online Engagement In order to improve citizen engagement, elected representatives The Internet has made way for new civic engagement opportu- and civic organizations must combine tried-and-true traditional nities. As Nicol Tuner-Lee notes9: methods of campaigning with more innovative approaches that “The Internet has become the new platform for freedom reflect these changes in citizen behaviour. Barack Obama’s cam- of speech, and the expression of civic ideas. With more than paign during the 2008 US presidential election was one of the 66 percent of Americans online, virtual micro-communities, first large-scale political campaigns to do this—I’ll discuss that or niche web portals, have made it easier for people to deliber- campaign later in this paper. ately seek out and sustain relationships with those who share Organizations, government agencies and governments can similar interests, opinions, and backgrounds. Citizens can pick engage with their audience through a number of offline and and choose both the online destination where they want to online mediums. share, and the preferred format to communicate their opinions whether through a blog, video, podcast, or tweet. Before the Offline Engagement Internet, these ideas were shared at community town hall and block club meetings.” The Pew Internet & American Life Project conducted a study called The Current State of Civic Engagement in America, which outlines According to research by the Pew Internet & American Life Project, some of the various offline methods that citizens use to contact citizens are using these online methods to communicate with politicians at various levels8: their local leaders: • Contact a government official in person, by phone or by letter • Send an email to a government official • Sign a paper petition • Sign a petition online • Send a letter to the editor through the mail • Email a letter to the editor • Make a political contribution in person, by phone or through • Make a political contribution on the Internet the mail • Communicate with a civic/political group by email, text • Communicate with a civic/political group by face-to-face messaging, instant messaging, using the group’s website or meetings, print letter or newsletter or telephone using a social networking site Some of the offline methods that politicians use to reach out to citizens include: Practical Applications of Crowdsourcing • Door-to-door canvassing for Civic Engagement • Mass mail-outs or flyer drop-offs Author Jeff Howe was one of the first people to coin the term, • Town hall meetings, in-person Q & A sessions, public debates crowdsourcing. The practice applies Open Source principles to fields outside of software by taking a task traditionally per- • Interviews formed by one person and outsourcing it to a large group of These tactics represent traditional offline activities that are still people. Crowdsourcing is like an open call for ideas. important elements of citizen engagement, particularly among Crowdsourcing can engage audiences in projects, challenges and the over-40 voter population. decisions. It gathers the collective wisdom of large numbers of 8. Pew Internet & American Life Project. The Current State of Civic Engagement in America, 2009: http://pewinternet.org/Reports/2009/15--The-Internet-and-Civic-Engagement/2-- The-Current-State-of-Civic-Engagement-in-America.aspx?r=1 9. Tuner-Lee, Nicol. The Challenge of Increasing Civic Engagement in the Digital Age. The Future of Digital Communications: Policy Perspectives: http://twcresearchprogram.com/pdf/ TWC%20Policy_Turner-Lee.pdf IDEAVIBES | 5
  • 6. PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT people to arrive at outcomes and conclusions that are more accu- members of the crowd’s own networks involved. Through rate than, or otherwise superior to, the wisdom of any individual. increased participation, the impact of a crowdsourcing cam- James Surowiecki, in his 2004 book, The Wisdom of Crowds: Why paign becomes stronger. It can also be used to solve issues in the Many Are Smarter Than the Few and How Collective Wisdom a very cost-effective way compared to hiring market research Shapes Business, Economies, Societies and Nations, acknowledges firms, or in concert with traditional market research. Tapping that not all crowds are wise—for example, a crazed mob. the wisdom of the crowd brings new ideas to the table very rapidly and at low cost. It also attracts experts who can offer He identifies these four attributes of a wise crowd: their services, expertise and advice to help get the job done in i. Diversity of opinion—each contributor/source has private the way citizens want it done. information or interpretation of the topic Crowdsource to Increase Participation ii. Independence—contributors’ opinions are not determined by those of others Crowdsourcing is very accessible and makes it easier for indi- vidual citizens to be heard, because posting an idea or voting iii. Decentralization—contributors can specialize by drawing on for an idea is very easy to do. Even busy individuals who are not local knowledge able to participate in community organizations or attend interest iv. Aggregation—a mechanism is in place to gather private group meetings can have a voice through crowdsourcing. It is judgements into a collective decision also a viable tool to engage younger citizens who have grown Effective crowdsourcing leverages these attributes to gain up with the Internet and social media as an integral part of their more accurate insights into problems and solutions than can day-to-day lives. be achieved through discussions with individuals or small local Barack Obama’s 2008 federal election campaign in the United groups. These are some ways that you can engage a crowd to States offers one of the greatest examples to date of using social achieve civic engagement goals: media and online collaboration to foster greater participation: Crowdsource to Solve Problems “Most recently, the 2008 election demonstrated how the Internet could drive public opinion and voter participation. Crowdsourcing is frequently used as a problem-solving tool and President Barack Obama’s campaign used online tools and can therefore be a tool to improve results-oriented civic engage- social networks in a way that contributed to his victory as ment. For example, some cities and communities have em- the first African American President of the United States. braced crowdsourcing as a means of incorporating residents into The Obama campaign used the Internet to raise half a billion decision making and getting them to help solve problems. Civic dollars, the largest amount of contributions to a political op- leaders may be hesitant to use social media tools because they eration ever received through online donations. His website, are afraid they will be used as centres rather than remaining fo- MyBarackObama.com, gathered thousands of e-mail address- cused on the task at hand. Crowdsourcing is ideal for overcom- es and, in turn, nurtured a vast base of national volunteers ing this concern because it can be highly specific. For example, it supporting the campaign’s field tactics.”10 can be used to have citizens first vote to determine the highest priority problem to solve, then to have them vote on solutions to Crowdsource to Be More Transparent the problem—including solutions that they and others post. Today’s consumers demand transparency from major corpora- Crowdsource to Get the Job Done tions, governments and elected officials. Taxpayers want to know where their dollars are being spent and to ensure that Crowdsourcing relies on social media behaviour (such as public funds are not being wasted. They also want to be includ- sharing and liking) to build awareness among and get the ed in the decision-making process. Transparency is also critical 10 Tuner-Lee, Nicol. The Challenge of Increasing Civic Engagement in the Digital Age. The Future of Digital Communications: Policy Perspectives: http://twcresearchprogram.com/pdf/ TWC%20Policy_Turner-Lee.pdf 6 | IDEAVIBES
  • 7. PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT to good governance—another quality that citizens demand from time as new ideas, comments and people become engaged in major corporations and our governing bodies. the conversation. Once off the ground, crowdsourcing cam- Crowdsourcing can be used to improve access to information; paigns become crowd-driven. As long as there is crowd engage- it can ensure that information is timely, accurate, complete and ment and interest, the campaign will live. relevant to citizen inquiries; it can disseminate messages very Budget-Friendly quickly to large audiences; and, it makes it possible to incorpo- rate citizens in the decision making process. Some organizations Crowdsourcing uses networks of people and social media tools use crowdsourcing as a customer feedback tool—the same to spread the word about campaigns, projects and ideas. This concept can be applied to civic life as well, giving citizens easy makes it possible to create a far-reaching effort that stretches access to the lines of communication and empowering them to campaign dollars. It can also be used to improve the return on contribute by giving them a voice. investment of traditional campaigns. By bringing people’s atten- tion to crowdsourcing campaigns in offline engagement activi- Crowdsource to Spur Change ties (for example, calls to action to “go online and vote for the Crowdsourcing has applications far beyond the campaign mo- change you want” printed on campaign pamphlets or referenced ment: it can be used in everyday activities to continually engage in TV ads), the value and ROI of traditional engagement tools with citizens and address real-time issues. Crowdsourcing gath- can be increased. ers a wealth of information, ideas and opinions that leaders and Immediate citizens never used to have access to. As Diana Scearce writes: While door-to-door and telephone campaigns provide represen- “Throughout history, social change has been possible only tatives with immediate feedback from citizens, these methods through the contributions and dedication of many citizens. by necessity reach only a small percentage of the population. Today’s network-centric engagement builds on existing know- Combining these activities with crowdsourcing provides govern- how, drawing in particular on grassroots community organizing ments and politicians with a more complete picture of opinions and the open-source software movement.”11 and preferences. Crowdsourcing campaigns can deliver a broad Crowdsourcing can be used to engage individuals and grassroots understanding of general opinions very quickly—information community organizations in meaningful change at any time. that can be leveraged during walk-abouts and phone campaigns to dig deeper into citizens’ opinions and to validate crowdsourc- Benefits of Crowdsourcing ing campaign findings one-on-one. In addition to the capabilities discussed above, crowdsourcing Transparent offers a number of benefits over traditional methods of civic As discussed earlier in this paper, crowdsourcing provides engagement, including: citizens with a new kind of transparency into government. It Long-Lived does so by enagling greater access to information and decision- making processes, as well as providing a platform for citizens to Crowdsourcing has a longer lifespan than traditional campaigns, participate in those processes. which tend to die out when the budget is spent and/or resources are reassigned. Crowdsourcing, on the other hand, evolves over 11. Scearce, Diana. Connected Citizens: The Power, Peril and Potential of Networks. Crowdsourcing.org, 2011: http://www.crowdsourcing.org/document/ connected-citizens-the-power-peril-and-potential-of-networks-/3490 IDEAVIBES | 7
  • 8. PRACTICAL CROWDSOURCING FOR CIVIC ENGAGEMENT The Crowd is Talking, Are You Listening? Everyday, citizens are having conversations about their govern- information that would otherwise be too costly or otherwise ment and its decisions. Being able to tap into those conversa- unfeasible to gather. Able to reach a more diverse citizen base tions and gather meaningful opinions that can be used for than traditional methods of civic engagement, crowdsourcing decision-making is critical to the effectiveness of governments, can provide equally valuable input and direction and can be used civic organizations and elected officials. Crowdsourcing—and to enhance the value of traditional tools. Perhaps most impor- other social media—are tools that ignite conversations and turn tantly, crowdsourcing expands the reach of a message or idea to bystanders into active participants in government. networks beyond one’s immediate crowd. Crowdsourcing is a key component in the digital democracy— Ideavibes™ has developed the first hosted Crowd Engagement a social reality in which “the divide between media [message] Platform™ that is designed to allow governments, civic organiza- producers and consumers has dissolved and citizen [produced] tions and elected representatives to frame engagement in a way media rules… While before citizens had to rally for mainstream that creates greater citizen engagement. It is also the first platform media attention to catch the ears of politicians, now it is easier that delivers the power to create crowdsourcing or crowdfund- than ever before for citizens to launch awareness campaigns and ing campaigns from a single, easy to use control panel. For more get their message heard by the masses.”12 information, visit www.ideavibes.com and www.fundchange.com. Through its participatory nature, crowdsourcing gives govern- ments and elected representatives useful insights and valuable 12. Campbell, Lisa. Dotmocracy: Crowdsourcing, mashups and social change: http://www.mobilerevolutions.org/Dotmocracy.pdf 8 | IDEAVIBES