SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 2
Disney's 'John Carter': Why did it fail?




By now, the arguments seeking to explain Disney's "John Carter" debacle have flown so
fast they've almost contradicted themselves.

The Taylor Kitsch-starring science-fiction epic, which grossed just $30.6 million this
weekend on a budget of more than $250 million, should have played more heavily to the
sci-fi crowd, one argument went (the film didn't go to Comic-con and dropped "Mars"
from its title). Or maybe it was the opposite -- Disney should have made the film look and
feel more accessible. Those indecipherable creatures in its billboards and its television
spots emphasizing the arcana of Barsoom battles didn't exactly scream an all-ages
must-see.

The truth is that both sides are a little right. Disney could have played harder to the base
and potentially made the film work -- presuming, of course, that the budget and
expectations were commensurately modest from the outset.

Or, having made an absurdly expensive movie, it could have tried to figure out better
ways to bring everyone along. As it was, viewership came in at ratio of 3:2 in favor of
those over the age of 25 -- not exactly the youthful audience a studio wants in this and-
the-teenagers-shall-lead-them era of movie consumption.

Needless to say, Disney marketers were also working with a film that didn't exactly blow
anyone away. Directed by Andrew Stanton, "John Carter" was panned on many fan
blogs and garnered a measly 48% positive on Movie Review Intelligence, drawing poor
reviews even from those who tend to give duds a pass.

But although there's plenty of blame to go around on both the creative and marketing
sides, there's another factor: the source material itself. Disney could have made a better
movie and sold it more persuasively to a skeptical public. But it was dealing with a
stacked deck from the start.


"John Carter" is based primarily on "A Princess of Mars," the first in Edgar Rice
Burroughs' early 20th century 11-volume series of Barsoom novels. It's a touchstone
work of science fiction -- so touchstone that many viewers don't know what it is.

More to the point, it's an epic, which can be a tough sell no matter the studio or
marketing strategy. In today's climate, big action-adventure movies work, but they're not
usually epics -- more like movies based on a very simple concept (like, cars that turn into
robots that fight each other).

Actually, "John Carter" is even tougher material than a typical epic, because it's the
beginning of an epic -- not a film conceived as a stand-alone, self-contained piece, a la
"Avatar."

The irony in all this is that "John Carter" follows in the tradition (and indeed, its source
material helped inspire) the most successful science-fiction epic in the history of cinema,
"Star Wars," with both movies featuring interplanetary combat and sprawling fictional
universes, and also marrying spectacle with identifiable heroes.

Disney and Stanton didn't come within a galaxy of fashioning "Star Wars" from
Burroughs' work. But it's not clear that today's "Transformers"-ready multiplex audience
would have been hugely open to it even if they had.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Destaque

The 4 Myths About Millennials & The Keys to Their Success
The 4 Myths About Millennials & The Keys to Their SuccessThe 4 Myths About Millennials & The Keys to Their Success
The 4 Myths About Millennials & The Keys to Their SuccessMichael E. Parker
 
A2 cahier d´activité
A2   cahier d´activitéA2   cahier d´activité
A2 cahier d´activitéyshiru
 
Assign 1: Genre & subgenres
Assign 1: Genre & subgenresAssign 1: Genre & subgenres
Assign 1: Genre & subgenrestwbsmediaconnell
 
Logistics Management System
Logistics Management SystemLogistics Management System
Logistics Management Systemexaactsolution
 
Retina 5 retinal detachment 09.06.16 - dr.k.n.jha
Retina 5  retinal detachment  09.06.16 - dr.k.n.jhaRetina 5  retinal detachment  09.06.16 - dr.k.n.jha
Retina 5 retinal detachment 09.06.16 - dr.k.n.jhaophthalmgmcri
 
Foda telecomunicaciones en mexico
Foda telecomunicaciones en mexicoFoda telecomunicaciones en mexico
Foda telecomunicaciones en mexicod3car
 
Presentation DB Schenker
Presentation DB SchenkerPresentation DB Schenker
Presentation DB SchenkerMartinHIBMAN
 

Destaque (12)

The 4 Myths About Millennials & The Keys to Their Success
The 4 Myths About Millennials & The Keys to Their SuccessThe 4 Myths About Millennials & The Keys to Their Success
The 4 Myths About Millennials & The Keys to Their Success
 
Mi presentación
Mi presentación Mi presentación
Mi presentación
 
PresentPublish
PresentPublishPresentPublish
PresentPublish
 
Narrative - Scene 3 - roof top
Narrative - Scene 3 - roof topNarrative - Scene 3 - roof top
Narrative - Scene 3 - roof top
 
Mision
Mision Mision
Mision
 
A2 cahier d´activité
A2   cahier d´activitéA2   cahier d´activité
A2 cahier d´activité
 
Assign 1: Genre & subgenres
Assign 1: Genre & subgenresAssign 1: Genre & subgenres
Assign 1: Genre & subgenres
 
Logistics Management System
Logistics Management SystemLogistics Management System
Logistics Management System
 
Retina 5 retinal detachment 09.06.16 - dr.k.n.jha
Retina 5  retinal detachment  09.06.16 - dr.k.n.jhaRetina 5  retinal detachment  09.06.16 - dr.k.n.jha
Retina 5 retinal detachment 09.06.16 - dr.k.n.jha
 
Alter ego + A2 2015 (Vol4 de 5)
Alter ego + A2 2015 (Vol4 de 5)Alter ego + A2 2015 (Vol4 de 5)
Alter ego + A2 2015 (Vol4 de 5)
 
Foda telecomunicaciones en mexico
Foda telecomunicaciones en mexicoFoda telecomunicaciones en mexico
Foda telecomunicaciones en mexico
 
Presentation DB Schenker
Presentation DB SchenkerPresentation DB Schenker
Presentation DB Schenker
 

Mais de South Sefton College

Film analysis of_blue_is_the_warmest_col
Film analysis of_blue_is_the_warmest_colFilm analysis of_blue_is_the_warmest_col
Film analysis of_blue_is_the_warmest_colSouth Sefton College
 
Ethnicity and race intro to film studies
Ethnicity and race intro to film studiesEthnicity and race intro to film studies
Ethnicity and race intro to film studiesSouth Sefton College
 
Lesbian and gay cinema intro to film studies
Lesbian and gay cinema intro to film studiesLesbian and gay cinema intro to film studies
Lesbian and gay cinema intro to film studiesSouth Sefton College
 
50 shades of grey good until it's not
50 shades of grey good until it's not50 shades of grey good until it's not
50 shades of grey good until it's notSouth Sefton College
 
Projecting h itler representations of adolf hitler in english language gilms
Projecting h itler   representations of adolf hitler in english language gilms Projecting h itler   representations of adolf hitler in english language gilms
Projecting h itler representations of adolf hitler in english language gilms South Sefton College
 
Downfall and beyond hitler films from germany
Downfall and beyond   hitler films from germanyDownfall and beyond   hitler films from germany
Downfall and beyond hitler films from germanySouth Sefton College
 
Erin Heath - Theories of Film Spectatorship
Erin Heath - Theories of Film SpectatorshipErin Heath - Theories of Film Spectatorship
Erin Heath - Theories of Film SpectatorshipSouth Sefton College
 
People painted over_whitewashing_of_minority_actors_in_recent_film-_and _tele...
People painted over_whitewashing_of_minority_actors_in_recent_film-_and _tele...People painted over_whitewashing_of_minority_actors_in_recent_film-_and _tele...
People painted over_whitewashing_of_minority_actors_in_recent_film-_and _tele...South Sefton College
 
Perception of mental illness based upon its portrayal in film
Perception of mental illness based upon its portrayal in filmPerception of mental illness based upon its portrayal in film
Perception of mental illness based upon its portrayal in filmSouth Sefton College
 
Lesson 8 past papers and first drafts
Lesson 8   past papers and first draftsLesson 8   past papers and first drafts
Lesson 8 past papers and first draftsSouth Sefton College
 

Mais de South Sefton College (20)

Fellowship handout
Fellowship handoutFellowship handout
Fellowship handout
 
Film analysis of_blue_is_the_warmest_col
Film analysis of_blue_is_the_warmest_colFilm analysis of_blue_is_the_warmest_col
Film analysis of_blue_is_the_warmest_col
 
Ethnicity and race intro to film studies
Ethnicity and race intro to film studiesEthnicity and race intro to film studies
Ethnicity and race intro to film studies
 
Lesbian and gay cinema intro to film studies
Lesbian and gay cinema intro to film studiesLesbian and gay cinema intro to film studies
Lesbian and gay cinema intro to film studies
 
50 shades of grey good until it's not
50 shades of grey good until it's not50 shades of grey good until it's not
50 shades of grey good until it's not
 
Projecting h itler representations of adolf hitler in english language gilms
Projecting h itler   representations of adolf hitler in english language gilms Projecting h itler   representations of adolf hitler in english language gilms
Projecting h itler representations of adolf hitler in english language gilms
 
Downfall and beyond hitler films from germany
Downfall and beyond   hitler films from germanyDownfall and beyond   hitler films from germany
Downfall and beyond hitler films from germany
 
Bruno gantz on playing hitler
Bruno gantz on playing hitlerBruno gantz on playing hitler
Bruno gantz on playing hitler
 
The dangers of portraying hitler
The dangers of portraying hitlerThe dangers of portraying hitler
The dangers of portraying hitler
 
Erin Heath - Theories of Film Spectatorship
Erin Heath - Theories of Film SpectatorshipErin Heath - Theories of Film Spectatorship
Erin Heath - Theories of Film Spectatorship
 
Oakley theory filmspectator
Oakley theory filmspectatorOakley theory filmspectator
Oakley theory filmspectator
 
Artefacts of disability
Artefacts of disabilityArtefacts of disability
Artefacts of disability
 
Disney's disabled characters
Disney's disabled charactersDisney's disabled characters
Disney's disabled characters
 
People painted over_whitewashing_of_minority_actors_in_recent_film-_and _tele...
People painted over_whitewashing_of_minority_actors_in_recent_film-_and _tele...People painted over_whitewashing_of_minority_actors_in_recent_film-_and _tele...
People painted over_whitewashing_of_minority_actors_in_recent_film-_and _tele...
 
Perception of mental illness based upon its portrayal in film
Perception of mental illness based upon its portrayal in filmPerception of mental illness based upon its portrayal in film
Perception of mental illness based upon its portrayal in film
 
Lesson 17 women and aco (ob)
Lesson 17 women and aco (ob)Lesson 17 women and aco (ob)
Lesson 17 women and aco (ob)
 
Assimilation 2015
Assimilation 2015Assimilation 2015
Assimilation 2015
 
Spr homework
Spr homeworkSpr homework
Spr homework
 
Film politics and ideology
Film politics and ideologyFilm politics and ideology
Film politics and ideology
 
Lesson 8 past papers and first drafts
Lesson 8   past papers and first draftsLesson 8   past papers and first drafts
Lesson 8 past papers and first drafts
 

Why did john carter fail

  • 1. Disney's 'John Carter': Why did it fail? By now, the arguments seeking to explain Disney's "John Carter" debacle have flown so fast they've almost contradicted themselves. The Taylor Kitsch-starring science-fiction epic, which grossed just $30.6 million this weekend on a budget of more than $250 million, should have played more heavily to the sci-fi crowd, one argument went (the film didn't go to Comic-con and dropped "Mars" from its title). Or maybe it was the opposite -- Disney should have made the film look and feel more accessible. Those indecipherable creatures in its billboards and its television spots emphasizing the arcana of Barsoom battles didn't exactly scream an all-ages must-see. The truth is that both sides are a little right. Disney could have played harder to the base and potentially made the film work -- presuming, of course, that the budget and expectations were commensurately modest from the outset. Or, having made an absurdly expensive movie, it could have tried to figure out better ways to bring everyone along. As it was, viewership came in at ratio of 3:2 in favor of those over the age of 25 -- not exactly the youthful audience a studio wants in this and- the-teenagers-shall-lead-them era of movie consumption. Needless to say, Disney marketers were also working with a film that didn't exactly blow anyone away. Directed by Andrew Stanton, "John Carter" was panned on many fan blogs and garnered a measly 48% positive on Movie Review Intelligence, drawing poor reviews even from those who tend to give duds a pass. But although there's plenty of blame to go around on both the creative and marketing sides, there's another factor: the source material itself. Disney could have made a better
  • 2. movie and sold it more persuasively to a skeptical public. But it was dealing with a stacked deck from the start. "John Carter" is based primarily on "A Princess of Mars," the first in Edgar Rice Burroughs' early 20th century 11-volume series of Barsoom novels. It's a touchstone work of science fiction -- so touchstone that many viewers don't know what it is. More to the point, it's an epic, which can be a tough sell no matter the studio or marketing strategy. In today's climate, big action-adventure movies work, but they're not usually epics -- more like movies based on a very simple concept (like, cars that turn into robots that fight each other). Actually, "John Carter" is even tougher material than a typical epic, because it's the beginning of an epic -- not a film conceived as a stand-alone, self-contained piece, a la "Avatar." The irony in all this is that "John Carter" follows in the tradition (and indeed, its source material helped inspire) the most successful science-fiction epic in the history of cinema, "Star Wars," with both movies featuring interplanetary combat and sprawling fictional universes, and also marrying spectacle with identifiable heroes. Disney and Stanton didn't come within a galaxy of fashioning "Star Wars" from Burroughs' work. But it's not clear that today's "Transformers"-ready multiplex audience would have been hugely open to it even if they had.