SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 170
Baixar para ler offline
A2 Economics
Microeconomics
  Course Companion
       2009
2



Introduction to the A2 Microeconomics Study Companion
Welcome to this 2008-09 edition of the Tutor2u A2 microeconomics study companion. The edition
has been revised throughout and seeks to provide a comprehensive coverage of some of the key
ideas in the A2 business economics courses together with coverage of environmental market failure
issues and aspects of labour market economics.
The digital version of this study companion contains many links to selected online resources such as
recent news articles from recommended newspapers and magazine. And also to the Tutor2u
economics blog so that when you click on such a link, you will be guaranteed to be taken to the latest
blog features written after this study companion was completed.
This study companion is designed as a complement to your studies in A2 Economics and should not
be regarded as a substitute for taking effective notes in your lessons. Points raised and issues
covered in class analysis and discussion invariably go beyond the confines of this guide. And with
Economics being the subject that it is, events and new economic policy debates will inevitably
surface over the next twelve months that take you into new and exciting territory.
Economics is a dynamic subject, the issues change from day to day and there is a wealth of
comment and analysis in the broadsheet newspapers, magazines and journals that you can delve
into. The more reading you manage on the main issues of the day the wider will be your appreciation
of the theory and practice of economics.
Further resources including online tests and revision notes are available from the Tutor2u virtual
learning environment (VLE) at http://vle.tutor2u.net Check to see if your school or college has a
subscription to this resource and EconoMax Tutor2u‘s digital magazine for Economics.
I acknowledge the help given in the preparation of this study companion by my own students and I
also acknowledge some of the ideas and arguments put forward in articles written by Bob Nutter, Jim
Riley, Liz Veal and Mark Johnston – some of my fellow writers for the EconoMax digital magazine
from which a small number of articles have been adapted as mini case studies.
Good luck with your studies

Geoff Riley

This study companion follows the AQA syllabus and chapters are grouped into five main sectors:

   1. The Firm: Objectives, Costs and Revenues
   2. Competitive Markets
   3. Concentrated Markets
   4. The Labour Market

   5. Government Intervention in the Market




                              http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
3




Contents
1.     Production in the Short and the Long Run .................................................................................. 4
2.     How can we calculate the costs of a firm? .................................................................................. 8
3.     Long Run Costs: Economies and Diseconomies of Scale ........................................................ 13
4.     Business Revenues ................................................................................................................... 23
5.     Profits ......................................................................................................................................... 26
6.     What Objectives Do Firms Have? ............................................................................................. 34
7.     Divorce between Ownership and Control .................................................................................. 38
8.     Technological Change, Costs and Supply in the Long-run ....................................................... 42
9.     The Growth of Firms .................................................................................................................. 45
10. Perfect Competition ................................................................................................................... 51
11. Monopolistic Competition........................................................................................................... 59
12. The Model of Monopoly ............................................................................................................. 62
13. Barriers to Entry and Exit in Markets ......................................................................................... 65
14. Price Discrimination ................................................................................................................... 69
15. Monopoly and Economic Efficiency ........................................................................................... 76
16. Collusive and Non-Collusive Oligopoly ..................................................................................... 84
17. Oligopoly and Game Theory ...................................................................................................... 90
18. Contestable Markets .................................................................................................................. 97
19. Monopsony Power in Product Markets.................................................................................... 101
20. Consumer and Producer Surplus ............................................................................................ 103
21. Price Takers and Price Makers – Pricing Power ..................................................................... 106
22. Competition Policy and Regulation.......................................................................................... 111
23. Privatisation and Deregulation ................................................................................................. 116
24. The Labour Market................................................................................................................... 124
25. Monopsony in the Labour Market ............................................................................................ 137
26. Discrimination in the Labour Market ........................................................................................ 139
27. Trade Unions in the Labour Market ......................................................................................... 142
28. The Distribution of Income and Wealth ................................................................................... 146
29. Market Failure - Externalities ................................................................................................... 153
30. Carbon Emissions Trading and the Stern Review .................................................................. 159
31. Cost Benefit Analysis ............................................................................................................... 165




                                           http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
4




   1. Production in the Short and the Long Run

We take it for granted that goods and services will be available for us to buy as and when we need
them. But production and supplying to the market is often a complicated business.
Production Functions

The production function elates the quantity of factor inputs to the volume of outputs that result.
We make use of three measures of production and productivity.
   o   Total product means total output. In most manufacturing industries such as motor vehicles,
       motor homes and DVD players, it is straightforward to measure production from labour and
       capital inputs. But in many service or knowledge-based industries, where the output is less
       ―tangible‖ or perhaps ‗weightless‘ we find it harder to measure productivity.
   o   Average product measures output per-worker-employed or output-per-unit of capital.

   o   Marginal product is the change in output from increasing the number of workers used by one
       person, or by adding one more machine to the production process in the short run.




The length of time required for the long run varies from sector to sector. In the nuclear power industry
  for example, it can take many years to commission new nuclear power plant and capacity. This is
       something the UK government has to consider as it reviews our future sources of energy.


Short Run Production Function

The short run is a time period where at least one factor of production is in fixed supply - it
cannot be changed. We normally assume that the quantity of plant and machinery is fixed and that
production can be altered through changing variable inputs such as labour, raw materials and
energy.
The time periods used in economics must differ from one industry to another. The short-run for the
electricity generation industry or telecommunications differs from magazine publishing and local
sandwich bars. If you are starting out in business this autumn with a new venture selling sandwiches
and coffees to office workers, how long is your short run? And how long is your long run? (!!). The


                            http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
5


long run could be as short as a few days – enough time to lease a new van and a sandwich making
machine!


Diminishing Returns

In the short run, the law of diminishing returns states that as we add more units of a variable input
to fixed amounts of land and capital, the change in total output will at first rise and then fall.
Diminishing returns to labour occurs when marginal product of labour starts to fall. This means that
total output will be increasing at a decreasing rate.

What happens to marginal product is linked directly to the productivity of each extra worker. Beyond
a certain point new workers will not have as much capital to work with so – it becomes diluted
among a larger workforce. As a result, the marginal productivity tends to fall – this is the principle of
diminishing returns. An example is shown below. We assume that there is a fixed supply of capital
(20 units) available in the production process to which extra units of labour are added.

       Initially the marginal product is rising – e.g. the 4th worker adds 26 to output and the 5th worker
       adds 28.

       It peaks when the sixth worked is employed when the marginal product is 29.

       Marginal product then starts to fall. At this point production demonstrates diminishing returns.

The Law of Diminishing Returns
  Capital Input     Labour Input      Total Output    Marginal Product      Average Product of Labour
            20                  1                 5                                                     5
            20                  2               16                     11                               8
            20                  3               30                     14                              10
            20                  4               56                     26                              14
            20                  5               85                     28                              17
            20                  6              114                     29                              19
            20                  7              140                     26                              20
            20                  8              160                     20                              20
            20                  9              171                     11                              19
            20                 10              180                      9                              18




                             http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
6




      Total
      Output    Slope of the curve gives the                                                        (Q)
      (Q)       marginal product of labour


                                                           Diminishing returns are apparent
                                                           here – total output is rising but at a
                                                           decreasing rate




                                                                              Units of Labour Employed (L)
Average product rises as long as the marginal product is greater than the average – for example
when the seventh worker is added the marginal gain in output is 26 and this drags the average up
from 19 to 20 units. Once marginal product is below the average as it is with the ninth worker
employed (where marginal product is only 11) then the average must decline.
This is an important example of the relationship between marginal and average values that we will
return to later on when studying costs and revenues.
Criticisms of the Law of Diminishing Returns

How realistic is this assumption of diminishing returns? Surely ambitious and successful businesses
will do their level best to avoid such a problem emerging?
It is now widely recognised that the effects of globalisation and the ability of trans-national
corporations to source their inputs from more than one country and engage in transfers of
business technology, makes diminishing returns less relevant. Many businesses are multi-plant
meaning that they operate factories in different locations – can switch output to meet changing
demand.
A rise in productivity and the production function

In the following diagram we trace the effects of a rise in the productivity of the labour force at each
level of employment.

       If average productivity rises, then the production curve shifts upwards.

       Diminishing returns are still assumed to exist in this diagram as shown by the shape of the
       production curve, but total output is higher for each number of people employed.

       If productivity rises, for a given level of wages, this will cause a fall in the unit labour costs of
       production.
Other things remaining the same, there is an inverse relationship between productivity and cost.
This is an important relationship for businesses to understand when they are seeking efficiency gains
as a means of boosting profits.
Long Run Production - Returns to Scale

In the long run, all factors of production are variable. How the output of a business responds to a
change in factor inputs is called returns to scale.

Numerical example of long run returns to scale

                               http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
7



Units of      Units of       Total         % Change in         % Change in      Returns to Scale
Capital       Labour         Output          Inputs              Output
20            150            3000
40            300            7500               100                 150            Increasing
60            450            12000              50                   60            Increasing
80            600            16000              33                   33             Constant
100           750            18000              25                   13            Decreasing

       In our example when we double the factor inputs from (150L + 20K) to (300L + 40K) then the
       percentage change in output is 150% - there are increasing returns to scale.

       In contrast, when the scale of production is changed from (600L + 80K0 to (750L + 100K)
       then the percentage change in output (13%) is less than the change in inputs (25%) implying
       a situation of decreasing returns to scale.

       Increasing returns to scale occur when the % change in output > % change in inputs

       Decreasing returns to scale occur when the % change in output < % change in inputs

       Constant returns to scale occur when the % change in output = % change in inputs
The nature of the returns to scale affects the shape of a business‘s long run average cost curve.




                           http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
8



   2. How can we calculate the costs of a firm?

In this chapter we look at production costs. In the short run, because at least one factor of
production is fixed, output can be increased only by adding more variable factors.

Fixed costs

Fixed costs do not vary directly with the level of output

Examples of fixed costs include the rental costs of buildings; the costs of leasing or purchasing
capital equipment such as plant and machinery; the annual business rate charged by local
authorities; the costs of full-time contracted salaried staff; the costs of meeting interest payments on
loans; the depreciation of fixed capital (due solely to age) and also the costs of business insurance.
Fixed costs are the overhead costs of a business.

Key points:
    Total fixed costs         (TFC)          these remain constant as output increases

    Average fixed cost        (AFC) =        total fixed costs divided by output
Average fixed costs must fall continuously as output increases because total fixed costs are
being spread over a higher level of production. In industries where the ratio of fixed to variable costs
is extremely high, there is great scope for a business to exploit lower fixed costs per unit if it can
produce at a big enough size. Consider the Sony PS3 or the new iPhone where the fixed costs of
developing the product are enormous, but these costs can be divided by millions of individual units
sold across the world. Successful product launches and huge volume sales can make a huge
difference to the average total costs of production.
Please note! A change in fixed costs has no effect on marginal costs. Marginal costs relate only to
variable costs!
Variable Costs

Variable costs are costs that vary directly with output.
Examples of variable costs include the costs of raw materials and components, the wages of part-
time staff or employees paid by the hour, the costs of electricity and gas and the depreciation of
capital inputs due to wear and tear. Average variable cost (AVC) = total variable costs (TVC) /output
(Q)
Average Total Cost (ATC or AC)

       Average total cost is the cost per unit produced

       Average total cost (ATC) = total cost (TC) / output (Q)
Marginal Cost

Marginal cost is the change in total costs from increasing output by one extra unit.
The marginal cost of supplying an extra unit of output is linked with the marginal productivity of
labour. The law of diminishing returns implies that marginal cost will rise as output increases.
Eventually, rising marginal cost will lead to a rise in average total cost. This happens when the rise in
AVC is greater than the fall in AFC as output (Q) increases.
A numerical example of short run costs is shown in the table below. Fixed costs are assumed to be
constant at £200. Variable costs increase as more output is produced.


                             http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
9



  Output  Total Fixed        Total Variable       Total Cost    Average Cost                 Marginal Cost
     (Q) Costs (TFC)          Costs (TVC)                         Per Unit             (the change in total
                                                                                      cost from a one unit
                                                                                         change in output)

                                               (TC= TFC +       (AC = TC/Q)
                                                  TVC)
        0           200                    0              200
      50            200                 100               300                   6                        2
     100            200                 180               400                   4                        2
     150            200                 230               450                   3                        1
     200            200                 260               460               2.3                        0.2
     250            200                 280               465             1.86                         0.1
     300            200                 290               480               1.6                        0.3
     350            200                 325               525               1.5                        0.9
     400            200                 400               600               1.5                        1.5
     450            200                 610               810               1.8                        4.2
     500            200                 750              1050               2.1                        4.8

       In our example, average cost per unit is minimised at a range of output - 350 and 400 units.

       Thereafter, because the marginal cost of production exceeds the previous average, so the
       average cost rises (for example the marginal cost of each extra unit between 450 and 500 is
       4.8 and this increase in output has the effect of raising the cost per unit from 1.8 to 2.1).


An example of fixed and variable costs in equation format

If for example, the short-run total costs of a firm are given by the formula
SRTC = $(10 000 + 5X2) where X is the level of output.

       The firm‘s total fixed costs are $10,000

       The firm‘s average fixed costs are $10,000 / X

       If the level of output produced is 50 units, total costs will be $10,000 + $2,500 = $12,500


The Shape of Short Run Cost Curves

When diminishing returns set in (beyond output Q1) the marginal cost curve starts to rise. Average
total cost continues to fall until output Q2 where the rise in average variable cost equates with the fall
in average fixed cost. Output Q2 is the lowest point of the ATC curve for this business in the short
run. This is known as the output of productive efficiency.




                             http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
10



                If marginal cost is below average cost then average must be falling. Even if MC is rising, AC falls
                if MC <AC. For this reason, MC curve intersects the AC curve at the lowest point of the AC
                curve. Diminishing returns starts to occur when marginal cost starts to rise.

        Costs
                                                                                 Marginal Cost
                                                                                 (MC)
                                                                                                      Average Total
                                                                                                      Cost (ATC)




                                                                                                      Average
                                                                                                      Variable Cost
                                                                                                      (AVC)




                                                                                          Average Fixed
                                                                                          Cost (AFC)

                      Q1                                                Q2                                  Output (Q)


Key point: The marginal cost curve must intersect the average curves at their minimum levels


A change in variable costs

A rise in the variable costs of production – perhaps due to a rise in oil and gas prices or a rise in the
national minimum wage - leads to an upward shift both in marginal and average total cost. The firm is
not able to supply as much output at the same price. The effect is that of an inward shift in the supply
curve of a business in a competitive market.




                               http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
11




      Costs                                                     MC2                   AC2
                                                                      Marginal Cost
                                                                      (MC1)
                                                                                        Average Total
                                                                                        Cost (ATC1)




                                                                                        Average
                                                                                        Variable Cost
                                                                                        (AVC1)
                  AVC2




                                                                                             Output (Q)


An increase in fixed costs has no effect on the variable costs of production. This means that only the
average total cost curve shifts. There is no change on the marginal cost curve leading to no change
in the profit maximising price and output of a business. The effects of an increase in the fixed or
overhead costs of a business are shown in the diagram below.


      Costs
                                                                       MC
                                                                                 AC2 (after rise
                                                                                 in fixed costs)



                                                                                  AC1




                                                                                             Output (Q)


Suggestions for background reading on changes in business costs

Cadbury‘s plans to increase prices (BBC news, February 2008)
Dry cleaners facing rising costs (BBC news, June 2008)

Grain prices are squeezing bakers (BBC news, April 2008)

                            http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
12


Milk costs hit Stilton producers (BBC news, July 2007)




                            http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
13




   3. Long Run Costs: Economies and Diseconomies of Scale

Economies of Scale

       Economies of scale are the cost advantages from expanding the scale of production in
       the long run. The effect is to reduce average costs over a range of output.

       These lower costs represent an improvement in productive efficiency and can also give a
       business a competitive advantage in the market-place. They lead to lower prices and higher
       profits – a positive sum game for producers and consumers.

       We make no distinction between fixed and variable costs in the long run because all factors
       of production can be varied. As long as the long run average total cost (LRAC) is declining,
       economies of scale are being exploited.

    Long Run Output (Units)                 Total Costs (£s)       Long Run Average Cost (£ per unit)
              1000                               12000                            12
              2000                               20000                            10
              5000                               45000                             9
              10000                              80000                             8
              20000                             144000                            7.2
              50000                             330000                            6.6
             100000                             640000                            6.4
             500000                            3000000                             6


Returns to scale and costs in the long run

The table below shows how changes in the scale of production can, if increasing returns to scale
are exploited, lead to lower long run average costs.

                            Factor Inputs                      Production                Costs

                      (K)           (La)            (L)                 (Q)             (TC)      (TC/Q)

                  Capital          Land         Labour              Output      Total Cost       Average
                                                                                                    Cost

Scale A                 5              3             4                 100             3256         32.6

Scale B                10              6             8                 300             6512         21.7

Scale C                15              9            12                 500             9768         19.5

Costs: Assume the cost of each unit of capital = £600, Land = £80 and Labour = £200

Because the % change in output exceeds the % change in factor inputs used, then, although total
costs rise, the average cost per unit falls as the business expands from scale A to B to C.




                             http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
14




Increasing Returns to Scale
Much of the new thinking in economics focuses on the increasing returns available to a company
growing in size in the long run.
An example of this is the computer software business. The overhead costs of developing new
software programs such as Microsoft Vista or computer games such as Halo 3 are huge - often
running into hundreds of millions of dollars - but the marginal cost of producing one extra copy for
sale is close to zero, perhaps just a few cents or pennies. If a company can establish itself in the
market in providing a piece of software, positive feedback from consumers will expand the installed
customer base, raise demand and encourage the firm to increase production. Because the marginal
cost is so low, the extra output reduces average costs creating economies of size.

Lower costs normally mean higher profits and increasing financial returns for the shareholders. What
is true for software developers is also important for telecoms companies, transport operators and
music distributors. We find across so many different markets that a high percentage of costs are fixed
the higher is demand and output, the lower will be the average cost of production.


Long Run Average Cost Curve
The LRAC curve (also known as the „envelope curve‟) is usually drawn on the assumption of their
being an infinite number of plant sizes – hence its smooth appearance in the next diagram below.
The points of tangency between LRAC and SRAC curves do not occur at the minimum points of the
SRAC curves except at the point where the minimum efficient scale (MES) is achieved.
If LRAC is falling when output is increasing then the firm is experiencing economies of scale. For
example a doubling of factor inputs might lead to a more than doubling of output.
Conversely, When LRAC eventually starts to rise, the firm experiences diseconomies of scale, and,
If LRAC is constant, then the firm is experiencing constant returns to scale



  Costs
                                 SRAC1



                                                                                              SRAC3
                                                                   SRAC2



   AC1                                                                                         LRAC




   AC2

   AC3




                  Q1                     Q2                Q3                    Output (Q)




                            http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
15


There are many different types of economy of scale. Depending on the characteristics of an industry
or market, some are more important than others.
Internal economies of scale (IEoS)

Internal economies of scale come from the long term growth of the firm itself. Examples include:

   1. Technical economies of scale: (these relate to aspects of the production process itself):
           a. Expensive capital inputs: Large-scale businesses can afford to invest in specialist
              capital machinery. For example, a supermarket might invest in database technology
              that improves stock control and reduces transportation and distribution costs. Highly
              expensive fixed units of capital are common in nearly every mass manufacturing
              production process.
           b. Specialization of the workforce: Larger firms can split the production processes into
              separate tasks to boost productivity. Examples include the use of division of labour
              in the mass production of motor vehicles and in manufacturing electronic products.
           c. The law of increased dimensions (or the “container principle”) This is linked to the
              cubic law where doubling the height and width of a tanker or building leads to a more
              than proportionate increase in the cubic capacity – the application of this law opens up
              the possibility of scale economies in distribution and freight industries and also in
              travel and leisure sectors with the emergence of super-cruisers such as P&O‘s
              Ventura. Consider the new generation of super-tankers and the development of
              enormous passenger aircraft such as the Airbus 280 which is capable of carrying well
              over 500 passengers on long haul flights. The law of increased dimensions is also
              important in the energy sectors and in industries such as office rental and
              warehousing. Amazon UK for example has invested in several huge warehouses at its
              central distribution points – capable of storing hundreds of thousands of items.
           d. Learning by doing: There is growing evidence that industries learn-by-doing! The
              average costs of production decline in real terms as a result of production experience
              as businesses cut waste and find the most productive means of producing output on a
              bigger scale. Evidence across a wide range of industries into so-called ―progress
              ratios‖, or ―experience curves‖ or ―learning curve effects‖, indicate that unit
              manufacturing costs typically fall by between 70% and 90% with each doubling of
              cumulative output. Businesses that expand their scale can achieve significant
              learning economies of scale.




                            http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
16



               Cost

(Per unit of output)




                                                                  Economies of Scale

                                              A

                                                                     B
                                                                           LRAC1


                           Learning
                                              C                            LRAC2
                           economies


                                                                                   Output

2. Monopsony power: A large firm can purchase its factor inputs in bulk at discounted prices
   if it has monopsony (buying) power. A good example would be the ability of the electricity
   generators to negotiate lower prices when finalizing coal and gas supply contracts. The
   national food retailers have monopsony power when purchasing their supplies from farmers
   and wine growers and in completing supply contracts from food processing businesses. Other
   controversial examples of the use of monopsony power include the prices paid by coffee
   roasters and other middle men to coffee producers in some of the poorest parts of the world.
3. Managerial economies of scale: This is a form of division of labour where firms can
   employ specialists to supervise production systems. Better management; increased
   investment in human resources and the use of specialist equipment, such as networked
   computers can improve communication, raise productivity and thereby reduce unit costs.
4. Financial economies of scale: Larger firms are usually rated by the financial markets to be
   more „credit worthy‟ and have access to credit with favourable rates of borrowing. In
   contrast, smaller firms often pay higher rates of interest on overdrafts and loans. Businesses
   quoted on the stock market can normally raise new financial capital more cheaply through the
   sale of equities to the capital market.
5. Network economies of scale: (Please note: This type of economy of scale is linked more to
   the growth of demand for a product – but it is still worth understanding and applying.) There is
   growing interest in the concept of a network economy. Some networks and services have
   huge potential for economies of scale. That is, as they are more widely used (or adopted),
   they become more valuable to the business that provides them. We can identify networks
   economies in areas such as online auctions and air transport networks. The marginal
   cost of adding one more user to the network is close to zero, but the resulting financial
   benefits may be huge because each new user to the network can then interact, trade with all
   of the existing members or parts of the network. The rapid expansion of e-commerce is a
   great example of the exploitation of network economies of scale. EBay is a classic example of
   exploiting network economies of scale as part of its operations.




                        http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
17




                                    The container principle at work!
Economies of scale – the effects on price, output and profits for a profit maximizing firm
Scale economies allow a supplier to move from SRAC1 to SRAC2. A profit maximising producer will
produce at a higher output (Q2) and charge a lower price (P2) as a result – but the total abnormal
profit is also much higher (compare the two shaded regions).
Both consumer and producer surplus (welfare) has increased – there has been an improvement in
economic welfare and economic efficiency – the key is whether cost savings are passed onto
consumers!

                       MC1
  Costs
                                                    Profit at Price P1

                                                    Profit at Price P2
    P1                          SRAC1


                                                                                                 SRAC2


    P2                                                                   MC2




                                                                         AR
                                                                         (Demand)

                                            MR


                      Q1             Q2
                                                                                    Output (Q)



External economies of scale (EEoS)
External economies of scale occur outside of a firm but within an industry. For example
investment in a better transportation network servicing an industry will resulting in a decrease in

                             http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
18


costs for a company working within that industry, thus external economies of scale have been
achieved. Another example is the development of research and development facilities in local
universities that several businesses in an area can benefit from. Likewise, the relocation of
component suppliers and other support businesses close to the centre of manufacturing are also
an external cost saving.
Agglomeration economies may also result resulting from the clustering of similar businesses in a
distinct geographical location be it software businesses in Silicon Valley or investment banks in the
City of London.


Economies of Scale – The Importance of Market Demand
The market structure of an industry is affected by the extent of economies of scale available to
individual suppliers and by the total size of market demand. In many industries, it is possible for
smaller firms to make a profit because the cost disadvantages they face are relatively small. Or
because product differentiation allows a business to charge a price premium to consumers which
more than covers their higher costs.

A good example is the retail market for furniture. The industry has some major players in each of its
different segments (e.g. flat-pack and designer furniture) including the Swedish giant IKEA. However,
much of the market is taken by smaller-scale suppliers with consumers willing to pay higher prices for
bespoke furniture owing to the low price elasticity of demand for high-quality, hand crafted furniture
products. Small-scale manufacturers can therefore extract the consumer surplus that is present
when demand is estimated to have a low elasticity of demand.
Economies of Scope
These are different from economies of scale! Economies of scope occur where it is cheaper to
produce a range of products rather than specialize in just a handful of products. And they can be
exploited when a business owns a resource that can be used more than once in different ways!
For example, in the increasingly competitive world of postal services and business logistics, the main
service providers such as Royal Mail, UK Mail, Deutsche Post and the international parcel carriers
including TNT, UPS, and FedEx are broadening the range of their services and making more better
use of their existing collection, sorting and distribution networks to reduce costs and earn higher
profits from higher-profit-margin and fast growing markets.
A company‘s management structure, administration systems and marketing departments are
capable of carrying out these functions for more than one product.
Expanding the product range to exploit the value of existing brands is a good way of exploiting
economies of scope. Perhaps a good example of ―brand extension‖ is the Easy Group under the
control of Stelios where the distinctive Easy Group business model has been applied (with varying
degrees of success) to a wide range of markets – easy Pizza, easy Cinema, easy Car rental, easy
Bus and easy Hotel to name just a handful! Procter and Gamble is the largest consumer household
products maker in the world. Its brands include Crest, Duracell, Gillette, Pantene, and Tide, to name
just a few. Twenty four of its brands make over $1 billion in sales annually.
Another example of an economy of scope might be a restaurant that has catering facilities and uses
it for multiple occasions – as a coffee shop during the day and as a supper-bar and jazz room in the
evenings. Or a computing business can use its network and databases for many different uses.

Case Study: Investment in Sports Grounds
Hotels are a hot topic at sports venues. The owners of these venues are looking for ways to make
better return on their assets. The solution is to explore new business opportunities, invest in
extensive modernisation and spend cash on large-scale redevelopment schemes.


                            http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
19


Capacity utilisation is an important challenge facing a sporting venue. There are only so many
cricket matches, grand prix races or rugby games that draw spectators.
By adding purpose-built conference, banqueting and leisure facilities, sports venues can tap into a
different customer base. A hotel facility can attract demand from businesses looking for corporate
hospitality and conferences. Having a hotel also allows a venue to access consumer spending on
short breaks – one of the fastest growing segments of the leisure industry. Most of the planned
hotels will be branded (e.g. Holiday Inn, Marriott) which allows the venue to benefit from a trusted
hotel name and gets access to established distribution channels.

                                                                                        Source: Business Cafe

Minimum Efficient Scale (MES)
The minimum efficient scale (MES) is the scale of production where the internal economies of
scale have been fully exploited. The MES corresponds to the lowest point on the long run
average cost curve and is also known as an output range over which a business achieves
productive efficiency.

The MES is not a single output level – more likely we describe the minimum efficient scale as
comprising a range of outputs where the firm achieves constant returns to scale and has reached
the lowest feasible cost per unit.



      Costs

   Revenues




                                                                                                  LRAC




                   Increasing return to scale – economies of                        Decreasing returns –
                              scale - falling LRAC                                 diseconomies of scale




                                                               MES      Q2                     Output (Q)


The MES depends on the nature of costs of production in a specific sector or industry.
   1. In industries where the ratio of fixed to variable costs is high, there is plenty of scope for
      reducing unit cost by increasing the scale of output. This is likely to result in a concentrated
      market structure (e.g. an oligopoly, a duopoly or a monopoly) – indeed economies of scale
      may act as a barrier to entry because existing firms have achieved cost advantages and
      they then can force prices down in the event of new businesses coming in!
   2. In contrast, there might be only limited opportunities for scale economies such that the MES
      turns out to be a small % of market demand. It is likely that the market will be competitive
      with many suppliers able to achieve the MES. An example might be a large number of hotels
      in a city centre or a cluster of restaurants in a town. Much depends on how we define the
      market!



                                http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
20


   3. With a natural monopoly, the long run average cost curve continues to fall over a huge
      range of output, suggesting that there may be room for perhaps one or two suppliers to fully
      exploit all of the available economies of scale when meeting market demand.
Diseconomies of scale

Diseconomies are the result of decreasing returns to scale.
The potential diseconomies of scale a firm may experience relate to:
   1. Control – monitoring the productivity and the quality of output from thousands of employees
      in big corporations is imperfect and costly – this links to the concept of the principal-agent
      problem – how best can managers assess the performance of their workforce when each of
      the stakeholders may have a different objective or motivation which can lead to stakeholder
      conflict?
   2. Co-ordination - it can be difficult to co-ordinate complicated production processes across
      several plants in different locations and countries. Achieving efficient flows of information in
      large businesses is expensive as is the cost of managing supply contracts with hundreds of
      suppliers at different points of an industry‘s supply chain.
   3. Co-operation - workers in large firms may develop a sense of alienation and loss of morale.
      If they do not consider themselves to be an integral part of the business, their productivity
      may fall leading to wastage of factor inputs and higher costs. Traditionally this has been seen
      as a problem experienced by the larger state sector businesses, examples being the Royal
      Mail and the Firefighters, the result being a poor and costly industrial relations performance.
      However, the problem is not concentrated solely in such industries. A good recent example of
      a bitter industrial relations dispute was between Gate Gourmet and its workers.
Avoiding diseconomies of scale

A number of economists are skeptical about diseconomies of scale. They believe that proper
management techniques and appropriate incentives can do much to reduce the risk of industrial
strife. Here are three of the reasons to doubt the persistence of diseconomies of scale:
   1. Developments in human resource management (HRM). HRM is a horrible phrase to
      describe improvements that a business might make to procedures involving worker
      recruitment, training, promotion, retention and support of faculty and staff. This becomes
      critical to a business when the skilled workers it needs are in short supply. Recruitment and
      retention of the most productive and effective employees makes a sizeable difference to
      corporate performance in the long run.
   2. Performance related pay schemes (PRP) can provide financial incentives for the workforce
      leading to an improvement in industrial relations and higher productivity. Another aim of PRP
      is for businesses to reward and hang onto their most efficient workers. The John Lewis
      Partnership is often cited as an example of how a business can empower its employees by
      giving them a stake in the financial success of the organization.
   3. Increasingly companies are engaging in out-sourcing of manufacturing and distribution as
      they seek to supply to ever-distant markets. Out-sourcing is a tried and tested way of reducing
      costs whilst retaining control over production although there may be a price to pay in terms of
      the impact on the job security of workers whose functions might be outsourced overseas.
Case Study: Amazon – Economies of Scale and Scope




                           http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
21




Increased dimensions: Firstly, the company invested in enormous warehouses to stock its inventory
of books, DVDs, computer peripherals. This allows it to benefit from the law of increased dimension.
Buying power: Amazon has significant monopsony power when it purchases books directly from
publishers, thereby bypassing its reliance on wholesalers and giving it a higher profit margin.
Learning by doing and first-mover advantage: Amazon is benefiting from learning by doing having
been one of the first major players in the online retail sector. The unit costs of production tend to
decline in real terms as a result of production experience as businesses cut waste and find the most
productive means of producing output on a bigger scale
Pre-Orders - Amazon use a pre-order system for customers which allows it to capture early demand
and improve stock (or inventory) forecasting.
Less invested capital: As an online retailer, Amazon avoids the need for retail stores – one
advantage is that it has lower invested capital in the business and it frees up resources for customer
fulfillment and investment in new technology – Amazon distributes to over 200 countries.
Shifting stock at speed: Amazon has a much faster stock velocity – measured by the number of
weeks an item remains in stock. For Amazon this is half that of a physical store – and the benefit is a
reduction in obsolescence loss (the value of unsold stock is estimated to decline by 30% per year)
Economies of scale help to give Amazon a significant cost advantage. The business is also looking
to create economies of scope from marketing and broadening the range of products available
through the Amazon brand. Among the innovative business ideas under development we can
identify:

       Merchants@/Marketplace which gives independent (third party) sellers the opportunity to sell
       their products through the Amazon platform

       Amazon Enterprise Solutions – where Amazon provides e-commerce technology for a range
       of partners such as Marks and Spencer, Lacoste, Mothercare and Timex

       CreateSpace – a new self-publishing platform for books, music and video

       Amazon Kindle – a portable reader that wirelessly downloads books, blogs, magazines and
       newspapers to a high-resolution electronic paper display that looks and reads like real paper,

Amazon now sells nearly one fifth of the books bought in the UK each year.


Suggestions for further reading on economies of scale and scope

                            http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
22


Consoles look to hit their stride (BBC news, July 2008)

Cost headache for games developers (BBC news, December 2007)
Economies of scale in printing (Tutor2u economics blog, March 2008)

GM installs world's biggest rooftop solar panels (Guardian, July 2008)
How world's biggest ship is delivering our Christmas - all the way from China (Guardian)

Mobile web reaches critical mass (BBC news, July 2008)
Salad production on a massive scale (BBC news, June 2008)




                            http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
23




   4. Business Revenues

Revenue (or turnover) is the income generated from the sale of output in product markets.
             o   Average Revenue (AR) = Price per unit = total revenue / output

             o   Marginal Revenue (MR) = the change in revenue from selling one extra unit of output

The table below shows the demand for a product where there is a downward sloping demand curve.

   Price per unit          Quantity Demanded               Total Revenue           Marginal Revenue
(average revenue)                 (Qd)                      (TR) (PxQ)                   (MR)
        £s                         units                          £s                       £s
        400                         220                        88000
        370                         340                        125800                     315
        340                         460                        156400                     255
        310                         580                        179800                     195
        280                         700                        196000                     135
        250                         820                        205000                      75
        220                         940                        206800                      15
        190                        1060                        201400                     -45



Average and Marginal Revenue

In our example in the table above, as price per unit falls, demand expands and total revenue rises
although because average revenue falls as more units are sold, this causes marginal revenue to
decline. Eventually marginal revenue becomes negative, a further fall in price (e.g. from £220 to
£190) causes total revenue to fall.
Because the price per unit is declining, total revenue is rising at a decreasing rate and will eventually
reach a maximum (see the next paragraph).


Elasticity of Demand and Total Revenue

When a firm faces a perfectly elastic demand curve, then average revenue = marginal revenue (i.e.
extra units of output can all be sold at the ruling market price).
However, most businesses face a downward sloping demand curve! And because the price per unit
must be cut to sell extra units, therefore MR lies below AR. In fact he MR curve will fall at twice the
rate of the AR curve. You don’t have to prove this for the exams – but it is worth remembering that
the marginal revenue curve has twice the slope of the AR curve!
Maximum total revenue occurs where marginal revenue is zero: no more revenue can be achieved
from producing an extra unit of output. This point is directly underneath the mid-point of a linear
demand curve.




                              http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
24



    Revenue                                            Total revenue is
                                                       maximised when
                                                           MR = 0




                                                                                               Total Revenue
                                                                                                    (TR)




                      Ped >1 for a price
                        fall along this               Price elasticity of
                         length of AR                demand = 1 at this
                                                           output


                                                                                     Average Revenue
                Marginal Revenue                                                       (Demand) AR
                      (MR)

                                                                                                       Output (Q)




Total revenue is shown by the area underneath the firm‘s demand curve (average revenue curve).


         Total revenue (TR) refers to the amount of money received by a firm from selling a given
         level of output and is found by multiplying price (P) by output ie number of units sold


 Costs

                                                            Total revenue at price P1 where marginal
                                                            revenue is zero
   P2



                                                            A rise in price to P2 causes a reduction in total
   P1                                                       revenue




                                                                              Average revenue AR



                                                  Total revenue at price P2




                    Q2                     Q1      Marginal revenue MR                          Output (Q)




Suggestions for further reading on business revenues

Carmakers tackle profit problems (BBC news, July 2008)
                                   http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
25


Revenue fears hit Vodafone shares (BBC news, July 2008)
Price elasticity of demand and total revenue (Bryn Jones Online, You Tube video)




                           http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
26



   5. Profits

The Nature of Profit
Profit measures the return to risk when committing scarce resources to a market or industry.
Entrepreneurs take risks for which they require an adequate expected rate of return. The higher
the market risk and the longer they expect to have to wait to earn a positive return, the greater will be
the minimum required return that an entrepreneur is likely to demand.
1. Normal profit - is the minimum level of profit required to keep factors of production in their
   current use in the long run. Normal profits reflect the opportunity cost of using funds to
   finance a business. If you decide to put £200,000 of your personal savings into a new business,
   those funds could have earned a low-risk rate of return by being saved in a bank or building
   society deposit account. You might therefore use the rate of interest on that £200,000 as the
   minimum rate of return that you need to make from your investment in order to keep going in the
   long run!
Of course we are ignoring here differences in risk and also the non-financial benefits of running and
building your own business or investing funds in someone else‘s project.
Because we treat normal profit as an opportunity cost of investing financial capital in a business,
we normally include an estimate for normal profit in the average total cost curve, thus, if the firm
covers its ATC (where AR meets AC) then it is making normal profits.
2. Sub-normal profit - is any profit less than normal profit (where price < average total cost)
3. Abnormal profit - is any profit achieved in excess of normal profit - also known as
   supernormal profit. A firm earns supernormal profit when its profit is above that required to keep
   its resources in their present use in the long run. When firms are making abnormal profits, there is
   an incentive for other producers to enter a market to try to acquire some of this profit. Abnormal
   profit persists in the long run in imperfectly competitive markets such as oligopoly and
   monopoly where firms can successfully block the entry of new firms. We will come to this later
   when we consider barriers to entry in monopoly.

Case Study: Sub-normal profits drive mortgage lenders out of the market – for now

What is happening in the UK mortgage market? Rarely a day goes by without news of another
mortgage lender reassessing the risk of their housing loans and deciding to pull the plug on some of
their mortgage products. Following on from the Northern Rock which has virtually stopped lending at
all and wants to shift a sizeable portion of its mortgage book onto others, the Co-operative Bank,
Lehman Brothers and First Direct have all announced that they are withdrawing two-year fixed rate
mortgage products for the time being.

All of this is one of the direct results of the credit crunch. The lenders are spinning this as a way of
providing better service-levels to their existing customers but the reality is that the supply of finance
in the wholesale money markets has been badly squeezed and this is now feeding through to the
retail market for housing loans. It is costing the mortgage lenders more to borrow funds and their
profit margins have been squeezed to a level where sub-normal profits are being made. Little wonder
that some of the major players are effectively exiting the market by withdrawing some mortgage
products from sale. Only when conditions improve will they consider a return.
                                                           Source: Tutor2u Economics Blog, April 2008



Calculating economic profit

Consider the following example:

                             http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
27


The table shows data for an owner-managed firm for a particular year.

       Total revenue £320,000
       Raw material costs £30,000
       Wages and salaries £85,000
       Interest paid on bank loan £30,000
       Salary that the owner could have earned elsewhere £32,000
       Interest forgone on owner's capital invested in the business £20,000
In a simple accounting sense, the business has total revenue of £320,000 and costs of £145,000
giving an accounting profit of £175,000. But the firm‘s profit according to an economist should take
into account the opportunity cost of the capital invested in the business and the income that the
owner could have earned elsewhere. Taking these two items into account we find that the economic
profit is £123,000.

Profit maximisation
                  Profits are maximised when marginal revenue = marginal cost

Price Per Unit      Demand /          Total            Marginal           Total      Marginal      Profit
      (£)            Output          Revenue           Revenue            Cost        Cost          (£)
                     (units)           (£)               (£)               (£)         (£)
      50               33              1650                               2000                     -350
      48               39              1872                37             2120          20         -248
      46               45              2070                33             2222          17         -152
      44               51              2244                29             2312          15          -68
      42               57              2394                25             2384          12           10
      40               63              2520                21             2444          10           76
      38               69              2622                17             2480           6          142
      36               75              2700                13             2534           9          166
      34               81              2754                9              2612          13          142

Consider the example in the table above. As price per unit (average revenue) declines, so demand
expands. Total revenue rises but at a decreasing rate (as shown by column 4 – marginal revenue).
Initially the firm is making a loss because total cost exceeds total revenue. The firm moves into profit
at an output level of 57 units. Thereafter profit is increasing because the marginal revenue from
selling units is greater than the marginal cost of producing them. Consider the rise in output from 69
to 75 units. The MR is £13 per unit, whereas marginal cost is £9 per unit. Profits increase from £142
to £166.
But once marginal cost is greater than marginal revenue, total profits are falling. Indeed the
firm makes a loss if it increases output to 93 units.




                             http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
28



   Revenue
                                                                                    Marginal Cost
   And Cost




                Profits are
                increasing when
                MR > MC



                                                        Profits are
                                                        decreasing when
                                                        MR < MC




                                             Q1                 Marginal Revenue                               Output (Q)


As long as marginal revenue is greater than marginal cost, total profits will be increasing (or losses
decreasing). The profit maximisation output occurs when marginal revenue = marginal cost.
In the next diagram we introduce average revenue and average cost curves into the diagram so that,
having found the profit maximising output (where MR=MC), we can then find (i) the profit maximising
price (using the demand curve) and then (ii) the cost per unit.

       The difference between price and average cost marks the profit margin per unit of output.

       Total profit is shown by the shaded area and equals the profit margin multiplied by output

     Costs

   Revenue                                   Supernormal profits at
                                             Price P1 and output Q1


                                                                      Normal profit at Q2 where                SRAC
                                                                      AR = AC
        P1
                                                                                            SRMC




       AC1

      AC2


                                                                                         AR
                                                                                         (Demand)




                                                  Q1                           Q2
                                                           MR                                     Output (Q)




The short run supply decision - the shut-down point

The theory of the firm assumes that a business needs to make at least normal profit in the long run to
justify remaining in an industry but this is not a strict requirement when the firm will continue to
produce as long as total revenue covers total variable costs or put another way, so long as price per

                                  http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
29


unit > or equal to average variable cost (AR = AVC). This is sometimes referred to as the shut-
down price.
The reason for this is as follows. A business‘s fixed costs must be paid regardless of the level of
output. If we make an assumption that these costs are sunk costs (i.e. they cannot be recovered if
the firm shuts down) then the loss per unit would be greater if the firm were to shut down, provided
variable costs are covered.

                                                                       MC                       ATC
      Costs,                       P1 is below average variable cost
    Revenues


                                                                                               AVC
                                         A
         AC1




                                             B
          P2
          P1
                                             C




                                                                                   AR

                                                                            MR


                                         Q1                                       Output (Q)



Consider the cost and revenue curves facing a business in the short run in the diagram above.
    Average revenue (AR) and marginal revenue curves (MR) lies below average cost across the
       full range of output, so whatever output produced, the business faces making a loss.
    At P1 and Q1 (where marginal revenue equals marginal cost), the firm would shut down as
       price is less than AVC. The loss per unit of producing is vertical distance AC.
    If the firm shuts down production the loss per unit will equal the fixed cost per unit AB.
    In the short-run, provided that the price is greater than or equal to P2, the business can justify
       continuing to produce in the short run.

Northern Foods decides to mothball a factory

Northern Foods, which supplies Marks and Spencer, is to mothball a factory making ready-meals
because it is no longer economical. They said that, whilst the plant had been profitable in recent
years it was no longer generating enough money to give an adequate return to shareholders. Some
analysts have argued that the decision might be due to the effects of the monopsony power of Marks
and Spencer which has demanded discounts of up to 6% from its top suppliers including Northern
Foods.
                                                           Source: Adapted from news reports, May 2008



Deriving the Firm‟s Supply Curve in the Short Run

       In the short run, the supply curve for a business operating in a competitive market is the
       marginal cost curve above average variable cost.

                            http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
30


         In the long run, a firm must make a normal profit, so when price = average total cost, this is
         the break-even point. It will therefore shut down at any price below this in the long run.

         As a result the long run supply curve will be the marginal cost curve above average total
         cost.

The concept of a ‗supply curve‘ is inappropriate when dealing with monopoly because a monopoly is
a price-maker, not a ―passive‖ price-taker, and can thus select the price and output combination on
the demand curve so as to maximise profits where marginal revenue = marginal cost.


Changes in demand and the profit maximising price and output
A change in demand and/or production costs will lead to a change in the profit maximising price and
output. In exams you may often be asked to analyse how changes in demand and costs affect the
equilibrium output for a business. Make sure that you are confident in drawing these diagrams and
you can produce them quickly and accurately under exam conditions.
In the diagram below we see the effects of an outward shift of demand from AR1 to AR2 (assuming
that short run costs of production remain unchanged). The increase in demand causes a rise in the
market price from P1 to P2 (consumers are now willing and able to buy more at a given price
perhaps because of a rise in their real incomes or a fall in interest rates which has increased their
purchasing power) and an expansion of supply (the shift in AR and MR is a signal to firms to move
along their marginal cost curve and raise output). Total profits have increased.


         A rise in demand (a shift in AR and MR) causes an expansion of supply, a higher profit maximising
         price and an increase in supernormal profits


                                                              Profit Max at Price P2
 Costs
                                                              Profit Max at Price P1




   P2                                                                                                           AC

   P1                                                                                    MC




  AC1
  AC2
                                                                                                  AR2

                                                                                       AR1
                                                                                       (Demand)

                                                                  MR2

                                           Q1      Q2
                                                        MR1                                        Output (Q)




                                 http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
31




Wiseman dairies hit by profits blow

Shares in Robert Wiseman, Scotland‘s biggest milk supplier, have taken a hit following news of lower
profits. Operating profits were reported as falling by 16% after a £6.1m fine levied by the Office for
Fair Trading for alleged price fixing. The company is also suffering from the effects of higher energy,
packaging and distribution costs caused by the rising world price of oil. A third factor is a slump in
the market price of cream. The company has found that it cannot always pass on higher input prices
to customers, partly because of pre-existing milk delivery contracts with some of the major
supermarkets.

                                                        Source: Adapted from news reports, May 2008



The Functions of Profit in a Market Economy

Profits serve a variety of purposes to businesses in a market-based economic system
   1. Finance for investment Retained profits are source of finance for companies undertaking
      investment projects. The alternatives such as issuing new shares (equity) or bonds may not
      be attractive depending on the state of the financial markets especially in the aftermath of the
      credit crunch.
   2. Market entry: Rising profits send signals to other producers within a market. When the
      existing firms are earning supernormal profits, this signals that profitable entry may be
      possible. In contestable markets, we would see a rise in market supply and lower prices. But
      in a monopoly, the dominant firm(s) may be able to protect their position through barriers to
      entry.
   3. Demand for factor resources: Scarce factor resources tend to flow where the expected rate
      of return or profit is highest. In an industry where demand is strong more land, labour and
      capital are then committed to that sector. Equally in a recession, national output, employment,
      incomes and investment all fall leading to a squeeze on profit margins and attempts by
      businesses large and small to cut costs and preserve their market position. In a flexible labour
      market, a fall in demand can quickly lead to a reduction in investment and cut-backs in labour
      demand.
   4. Signals about the health of the economy: The profits made by businesses throughout the
      economy provide important signals about the health of the macroeconomy. Rising profits
      might reflect improvements in supply-side performance (e.g. higher productivity or lower costs
      through innovation). Strong profits are also the result of high levels of demand from domestic
      and overseas markets. In contrast, a string of profit warnings from businesses could be a lead
      indicator of a macroeconomic downturn.




                            http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
32



                                  Net Profit for Manufacturing and Service Businesses
                                       Net percentage rate of return on capital employed, seasonally adjusted
                     22.0                                                                                                   22.0


                     20.0                                                                                                   20.0


                     18.0                                                         Services                                  18.0


                     16.0                                                                                                   16.0


                     14.0
Rate of return (%)




                                                                                                                            14.0


                     12.0                                                         Manufacturing                             12.0


                     10.0                                                                                                   10.0


                      8.0                                                                                                    8.0


                      6.0                                                                                                    6.0


                      4.0                                                                                                    4.0


                      2.0                                                                                                    2.0
                            90   91   92   93   94   95   96    97   98   99    00   01   02    03   04   05    06   07

                                                                                                          Source: Reuters EcoWin




Steps to higher profits

In an ideal world, running a business would be easy! You come up with an innovative idea, create a
new product or service so popular you can‘t stop people from buying it. Word spreads and, before
you know it, sales and profits are growing. In reality, few businesses are able to sit back and watch
the profits roll in. Creating and increasing profitability depends on doing a hundred little things better
than the existing competition. So what are the best ways for a business to increase its profitability?


Method 1: Grow the “Top Line”

Every business and every market is different. But for most businesses, the best long-term way to
improve profitability is to increase sales (also known as ―turnover‖). This is for four main reasons:
                     1. If a business has a high gross profit margin, every extra sale is profitable. Once your
                        turnover reaches the break-even level then each additional sale adds to profits.
                     2. Acquiring new customers is made easier by greater market presence and reputation. As
                        you grow, unit costs are reduced through economies of scale.
                     3. If your customers tend to be loyal, the value of each new customer lays not just in the
                        immediate sale, but in future sales as well. The cost of selling to existing customers is
                        always lower than the cost of acquiring new customers.
                     4. Defending a market share against competitors is easier than defending high profit margins.



                                                http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
33


Many businesses operate in what are called “low growth” markets - where expansion only comes
by taking a bigger share of the available demand. Low growth markets tend to be in markets where
income elasticity of demand is low, so that as the real incomes of consumers increase, there is
little positive effect on market demand.


Method 2: Keep Costs under Control
If a business has a low gross profit margin, reducing direct costs increases the profit on each sale.
Eliminating overheads has an immediate impact on profit. Every business can increase profitability by
reducing hidden costs. Hidden costs include the costs of employing inappropriate people since poor
recruitment can lead to lower quality, increased training costs and ultimately redundancy costs.


Suggestions for further reading on profits

A selection of recent news articles on the profitability of businesses in different markets and
industries and how changes in demand and costs affect prices and profits.

Dominos delivers stronger profits (BBC news, July 2008)
Fuel costs eat into Fedex profit (BBC news, March 2008)
Grand Theft Auto IV set to break all records (BBC news, April 2008)
Gregg‘s warns of increased costs (BBC news, March 2008)
Higher oil prices see BP‘s profits surge (Guardian, July 2008)
Pubs close as beer sales fall (BBC news, July 2008)

Ryanair slashes fares to boost demand and fill airline capacity (Guardian, August 2008)
Should the British pub get a government subsidy? (BBC news, July 2008)
Silverjet calls in administrators (BBC news, June 2008)
Supporters count the cost of following a Premiership footie club (Tutor2u blog, March 2008)
Weak dollar boosts Nike profits (BBC news, March 2008)
Wolseley hit by housing slowdown (BBC news, July 2008)




                             http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
34




   6. What Objectives Do Firms Have?


In this chapter we consider a range of different
business objectives – much depends on the
ownership and control of a business and the type of
market in which it operates.


Profit maximisation

The traditional theory of the firm tends to assume that
businesses possess sufficient information, market
power and motivation to set prices or their products
that maximise profits. This assumption is now
criticised by economists who have studied the
organisation and objectives of modern-day
corporations.


Why might a business depart from profit maximisation?

There are numerous possible explanations. Some relate o the lack of accurate information
required to undertake profit maximising behaviour. Others concentrate on the alternative objectives
of businesses. We start first with the effects of imperfect information.

It might be hard for a business to pinpoint precisely their profit maximising output, as they cannot
accurately calculate marginal revenue and marginal costs. Often the day-to-day pricing decisions of
businesses are taken on the basis of ―estimated demand conditions.‖
Secondly, most modern businesses are multi-product firms operating in a range of separate
markets across countries and continents – as a result the volume of information that they have to
handle can be vast. And they must keep track of the ever-changing preferences of consumers. The
idea that there is a neat, single profit maximising price is redundant.


Behavioural Theories of the Firm
Behavioural economists believe that modern corporations are complex organizations made up
various stakeholders. Stakeholders are defined as any groups who have a vested interest in the
activity of a business. Examples might include:
       o   Employees within a business
       o   Managers employed by the firm

       o   Shareholders – people who have an equity stake in a business
       o   Customers in the market
       o   The local community

       o   The government and it‘s agencies including local government
Each of these groups is likely to have different objectives or goals at points in time. The dominant
group at any moment can give greater emphasis to their own objectives – for example price and


                             http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
35


output decisions may be taken at local level by managers – with shareholders taking only a distant
and imperfectly informed view of the company‘s performance and strategy.
If firms are likely to move away from pure profit maximising behaviour, what are the alternatives?
   1. Satisficing behaviour involves the owners setting minimum acceptable levels of
      achievement in terms of business revenue and profit.
   2. Sales Revenue Maximisation
The objective of maximising sales revenue rather than profits was initially developed by the work of
William Baumol (1959). His research focused on the behaviour of manager-controlled businesses.
Baumol argued that annual salaries and other perks might be closely correlated with total sales
revenue rather than profits. Companies geared towards maximising revenue are likely to make
frequent and extensive use of price discrimination (or yield management) as a means of extracting
extra revenue and profit from consumers.
   3. Managerial Satisfaction model
An alternative view was put forward by Oliver Williamson (1981), who developed the concept of
managerial satisfaction (or managerial utility). This can be enhanced by raising sales revenue.


 Costs
                                                     Profit Max at Price P1

                                                     Revenue Max at Price P2


                                                                                                    AC

    P1                                                                          MC

    P2




  AC1
  AC2



                                                                              AR (Demand)




                                     Q1    Q2                                          Output (Q)
                                                MR



Price and output differs if the firm changes its objective from profit to revenue maximisation.
Assuming that the firm‘s costs remain the same, a firm will choose a lower price and supply a higher
output when sales revenue maximisation is the main objective.

The profit maximising price is P2 at output Q2 whilst the revenue maximising price is P1 at output
Q1.
A change in the objectives of the business has an effect on welfare and in particular the balance
between consumer and producer surplus. Consumer surplus is higher with sales revenue
maximisation because output is higher and price is lower.




                            http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
36




Cadbury abandons its profit target
Cadbury Schweppes Plc, the manufacturer of Dairy Milk chocolate has decided to scrap its
profitability target in the wake of a sharp increase in the costs of their raw materials. Three years ago
Cadbury announced targets for annual improvements in profit margins ranging from 0.5 to 0.75%.
But the rising price of oil-based raw materials and the world market price of cocoa and sugar have
conspired to make meeting this target impossible. Prospects for profits have also been adversely
affected by the hot summer which has hit demand for chocolate and the unplanned recall of several
high profile products because of fears of salmonella poisoning. The business is a major global
presence in the confectionery market with an estimated ten per cent world market share. In June
2007, Cadbury announced that it planned to cut its workforce by 15%. The reorganisation will cost
Cadbury about £450m in a one-off charge.

                            Adapted from Tutor2u blog, November 2006 and news reports, June 2007



Social Entrepreneurs – “not just for profit” businesses

Underneath the surface of an economy dominated by corporate giants, a new breed of business is
flourishing, where profit is not always the bottom line; these are entrepreneurs operating for a social
purpose and not just for profit. A social enterprise is a business that has social objectives whose
surpluses are reinvested for that purpose in the business or the community, rather than being driven
by the need to seek profit to satisfy investors. Rather than maximise shareholder value and distribute
dividends, a social enterprise is looking to achieve social and environmental aims over the long term.
Examples include

   o   Café Direct                                           o   Fifteen Foundation (Jamie Oliver)
   o   Fair Trade                                            o   Housing Associations
   o   Traidcraft                                            o   Micro-credit developed by the
   o   Divine Chocolate                                          Grameen Bank and its founder, the
   o   The Eden Project                                          Nobel-Prize winner Muhammad Yu


 Social Entrepreneurship

 An example from India

 Devi Prasad Shetty strives to make sophisticated health care in India available to all irrespective of
 their economic situation or geographic location. He founded the Narayana Hrudayalaya Hospital in
 Bangalore in 2001 and co-founded the Asia Heart Foundation. In addition, Shetty has built a
 network of 39 telemedicine centres to reach out to patients in remote rural areas. Together, the
 network of hospitals performs 32 heart surgeries a day. Almost half the patients are children and
 babies. Sixty percent of the treatments are provided below cost or for free.
 And one from the UK

 The 2008 Independent Social Entrepreneur of the Year award went to Belu Water, a bottled water
 company that donates all of its profits to global clean water projects. The company uses carbon-
 neutral packaging in the form of a compostable bottle made from corn. Belu is the first carbon-
 neutral product being stocked at Tesco. The bottles look like ordinary bottles and can be recycled
 with plastics or commercially composted back to soil in just eight weeks. Among its clean water
 projects, Belu has installed hand pumps and wells for 20,000 people in India and Mali, and it is
 also working on a rubbish-muncher to clean up the Thames. The company has a pledge that each
 bottle of mineral water sold will translate as clean water for one person for one month.


                             http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
37


                                                  Source: Adapted from news reports, January 2008

See Young, Gifted and not for Profit (BBC radio 4 In Business) and also the economic impact of
the Eden project. Other good sites include: Schwab Foundation for Social Entrepreneurship


Not for Profit Businesses

These are charities, community organisations that are run on commercial lines e.g. Network Rail:
Network Rail
   o   Took over the rail network in October 2002
   o   Stated purpose is to deliver a safe, reliable and efficient railway for Britain.
   o   It is a company limited by guarantee – whose debts are secured by the government
   o   Network Rail is a private company operating as a commercial business and regulated by
       the Office of Rail Regulation
   o   Network Rail is a "not-for-dividend" company, which means that all of its profits are invested
       in the railway network.
   o   Train operating companies pay Network Rail for use of the rail infrastructure


Businesses required to main a loss-making service on social grounds

A good example here is the Royal Mail which is required to maintain a universal national postal
delivery service throughout the UK for a uniform price. Household mail makes a loss, cross-
subsidised by business mail – although this market is shrinking for the Royal Mail because of the
introduction of fresh competition from Jan 2006. The Post Office Ltd is a subsidiary of the Royal
Mail Group plc – it runs substantial losses on the network or rural post offices and has been under
great pressure to close hundreds of offices to stem losses.


Suggestions for further reading on business objectives and business ownership

Australian expansion proves a move too far for Starbucks (Tutor2u blog, July 2008)
Founder of bottled water company honoured for work in Third World (Independent, Jan 2008)
How business embraced charity (The Observer, June 2008)
Making profit with a conscience (BBC news, March 2008)
Motivated by change (Independent, July 2004)
Mysterious death of the petrol station (VVC news, March 2008)
Network Rail announces pre-tax profit of £1.6bn (BBC news, June 2008)
Ryanair flies into the path of an economic storm (Tutor2u blog, July 2008)
Sony predicts TV and game profits (BBC news, June 2008)
Survival challenge for social enterprises (Guardian, July 2008)
Wind farm co-op raises thousands (BBC news, July 2008)




                           http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
38




   7. Divorce between Ownership and Control

Ownership and control
The owners of a private sector company normally elect a board of directors to control the
business‘s resources for them. However, when the owner sells shares, or takes out a loan or bond
to raise finance, they may sacrifice some of their control. Other shareholders can exercise their
voting rights, and providers of loans often have some control (security) over the assets of the
business.
This may lead to a degree of conflict between them as these different stakeholders may have
different objectives. The flow chart below attempts to show the divorce between ownership and
control.


                Principals:

                Shareholders                                 OWNERSHIP



                Control Mechanisms:

                Pressures from the stock market
                and from hedge funds and private
                investors

                Regular meetings with
                shareholders (e.g. the AGM)

                Scrutiny in the financial press

                Performance related pay (to
                provide incentives)


                                                               CONTROL
                Agents:

                Board of Directors

                Senior Management




The Principal Agent Problem

How do the owners of a large business know that the managers they have employed and who are
making the key day-to-day decisions operate with the aim of maximising shareholder value in both
the short term and the long run?
This lack of information is known as the principal-agent problem or ―agency problem‖. In other
words, one person, the principal, employs an agent (e.g. a sales or finance manager) to perform
tasks on his behalf but he or she cannot ensure that the agent always performs them in precisely
the way the principal would like. The decisions and the performance of the agent are both
impossible and expensive to monitor and the incentives of the agent may differ from those of
the principal. The principal agent problem is illustrated in the flow chart above.

                              http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion
A2 Microeconomics Course Companion

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Wage Determination and the Allocation of Labor
Wage Determination and the Allocation of LaborWage Determination and the Allocation of Labor
Wage Determination and the Allocation of Laborecogeeeeeks
 
Chap 23, Measuring a Nation’s Income.ppt
Chap 23, Measuring a Nation’s Income.pptChap 23, Measuring a Nation’s Income.ppt
Chap 23, Measuring a Nation’s Income.pptmusanif shah
 
Supply side policies
Supply side policiesSupply side policies
Supply side policiesmattbentley34
 
tutor2u Economics Strong Foundations
tutor2u Economics Strong Foundationstutor2u Economics Strong Foundations
tutor2u Economics Strong Foundationstutor2u
 
AS Macro Revision: Monetary Policy and Exchange Rates
AS Macro Revision: Monetary Policy and Exchange RatesAS Macro Revision: Monetary Policy and Exchange Rates
AS Macro Revision: Monetary Policy and Exchange Ratestutor2u
 
Macro economic policy debates
Macro economic policy debatesMacro economic policy debates
Macro economic policy debatesÄngel Rözi Rozi
 
Macro-Economic Policy
Macro-Economic PolicyMacro-Economic Policy
Macro-Economic Policymattbentley34
 
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflation
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and DeflationAS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflation
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflationtutor2u
 
Macroeconomics slide
Macroeconomics slideMacroeconomics slide
Macroeconomics slideThao Nguyen
 
Indirect Taxes & Subsidies
Indirect Taxes & SubsidiesIndirect Taxes & Subsidies
Indirect Taxes & Subsidiesmattbentley34
 
Conflicts between Macro-Objectives
Conflicts between Macro-ObjectivesConflicts between Macro-Objectives
Conflicts between Macro-Objectivesmattbentley34
 
Transmission Mechanism of Monetary Policy
Transmission Mechanism of Monetary PolicyTransmission Mechanism of Monetary Policy
Transmission Mechanism of Monetary PolicyAmandiNiwarthanaWeer
 
Topic 6 - Unemployment & Inflation
Topic 6 - Unemployment & InflationTopic 6 - Unemployment & Inflation
Topic 6 - Unemployment & InflationFatin Nazihah Aziz
 
Tutor2u - Production, Productivity and Costs
Tutor2u - Production, Productivity and CostsTutor2u - Production, Productivity and Costs
Tutor2u - Production, Productivity and Coststutor2u
 
Economics - Price mechanism
Economics - Price mechanismEconomics - Price mechanism
Economics - Price mechanismOnline
 
Key Diagrams and Glossary for Unit 1 Micro
Key Diagrams and Glossary for Unit 1 MicroKey Diagrams and Glossary for Unit 1 Micro
Key Diagrams and Glossary for Unit 1 Microtutor2u
 

Mais procurados (20)

Wage Determination and the Allocation of Labor
Wage Determination and the Allocation of LaborWage Determination and the Allocation of Labor
Wage Determination and the Allocation of Labor
 
Chap 23, Measuring a Nation’s Income.ppt
Chap 23, Measuring a Nation’s Income.pptChap 23, Measuring a Nation’s Income.ppt
Chap 23, Measuring a Nation’s Income.ppt
 
Supply side policies
Supply side policiesSupply side policies
Supply side policies
 
tutor2u Economics Strong Foundations
tutor2u Economics Strong Foundationstutor2u Economics Strong Foundations
tutor2u Economics Strong Foundations
 
Chapter 9
Chapter 9Chapter 9
Chapter 9
 
AS Macro Revision: Monetary Policy and Exchange Rates
AS Macro Revision: Monetary Policy and Exchange RatesAS Macro Revision: Monetary Policy and Exchange Rates
AS Macro Revision: Monetary Policy and Exchange Rates
 
Macro economic policy debates
Macro economic policy debatesMacro economic policy debates
Macro economic policy debates
 
Macro-Economic Policy
Macro-Economic PolicyMacro-Economic Policy
Macro-Economic Policy
 
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflation
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and DeflationAS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflation
AS Macro Revision: Inflation and Deflation
 
Macroeconomics slide
Macroeconomics slideMacroeconomics slide
Macroeconomics slide
 
Indirect Taxes & Subsidies
Indirect Taxes & SubsidiesIndirect Taxes & Subsidies
Indirect Taxes & Subsidies
 
Conflicts between Macro-Objectives
Conflicts between Macro-ObjectivesConflicts between Macro-Objectives
Conflicts between Macro-Objectives
 
Transmission Mechanism of Monetary Policy
Transmission Mechanism of Monetary PolicyTransmission Mechanism of Monetary Policy
Transmission Mechanism of Monetary Policy
 
Topic 6 - Unemployment & Inflation
Topic 6 - Unemployment & InflationTopic 6 - Unemployment & Inflation
Topic 6 - Unemployment & Inflation
 
Monetary policy
Monetary policyMonetary policy
Monetary policy
 
Unemployment
UnemploymentUnemployment
Unemployment
 
Tutor2u - Production, Productivity and Costs
Tutor2u - Production, Productivity and CostsTutor2u - Production, Productivity and Costs
Tutor2u - Production, Productivity and Costs
 
Economics - Price mechanism
Economics - Price mechanismEconomics - Price mechanism
Economics - Price mechanism
 
Key Diagrams and Glossary for Unit 1 Micro
Key Diagrams and Glossary for Unit 1 MicroKey Diagrams and Glossary for Unit 1 Micro
Key Diagrams and Glossary for Unit 1 Micro
 
Business Cycle
Business CycleBusiness Cycle
Business Cycle
 

Destaque

Improving your Economics Exam Score
Improving your Economics Exam ScoreImproving your Economics Exam Score
Improving your Economics Exam ScoreEton College
 
Unit 3: Multiple Choice Questions
Unit 3: Multiple Choice QuestionsUnit 3: Multiple Choice Questions
Unit 3: Multiple Choice Questionsmattbentley34
 
Indian Physical Environment"Class - 11"
Indian Physical Environment"Class - 11"Indian Physical Environment"Class - 11"
Indian Physical Environment"Class - 11"Saurabh Singh Negi
 
Unit one AQA A Psychology Attachmet Key Studies to know
Unit one AQA A Psychology Attachmet Key Studies to knowUnit one AQA A Psychology Attachmet Key Studies to know
Unit one AQA A Psychology Attachmet Key Studies to knowacdefg
 
The World in 2025 - Future Agenda (2016)
The World in 2025 - Future Agenda (2016)The World in 2025 - Future Agenda (2016)
The World in 2025 - Future Agenda (2016)Future Agenda
 
A2 Micro Unit 3 Revision Advice
A2 Micro Unit 3 Revision AdviceA2 Micro Unit 3 Revision Advice
A2 Micro Unit 3 Revision AdviceEton College
 
Revision Webinar - Business Profits
Revision Webinar - Business ProfitsRevision Webinar - Business Profits
Revision Webinar - Business Profitstutor2u
 
Tutor2u A2 Macroeconomics Glossary
Tutor2u A2 Macroeconomics GlossaryTutor2u A2 Macroeconomics Glossary
Tutor2u A2 Macroeconomics Glossarytutor2u
 
Computer fundamentals-series1-e book
Computer fundamentals-series1-e bookComputer fundamentals-series1-e book
Computer fundamentals-series1-e bookRamil Demabogte
 
Revision Webinar - Business Costs
Revision Webinar - Business CostsRevision Webinar - Business Costs
Revision Webinar - Business Coststutor2u
 
Unit one memory AQA A psychology Memory
Unit one memory AQA A psychology MemoryUnit one memory AQA A psychology Memory
Unit one memory AQA A psychology Memoryacdefg
 
Research methods revision for AS AQA A Psychology 2014+
Research methods revision for AS AQA A Psychology 2014+Research methods revision for AS AQA A Psychology 2014+
Research methods revision for AS AQA A Psychology 2014+acdefg
 
Geography Fundamentals" Class - 12" NCERT
Geography Fundamentals" Class - 12" NCERTGeography Fundamentals" Class - 12" NCERT
Geography Fundamentals" Class - 12" NCERTSaurabh Singh Negi
 
Ftth development manual part1 (1)
Ftth development manual part1 (1)Ftth development manual part1 (1)
Ftth development manual part1 (1)Igors Cardoso
 
AS Micro Markets and Market Failure Key Term Glossary
AS Micro Markets and Market Failure Key Term GlossaryAS Micro Markets and Market Failure Key Term Glossary
AS Micro Markets and Market Failure Key Term GlossaryEton College
 
Revision Webinar: Business Objectives
Revision Webinar: Business ObjectivesRevision Webinar: Business Objectives
Revision Webinar: Business Objectivestutor2u
 

Destaque (20)

Ncert agro
Ncert agroNcert agro
Ncert agro
 
Green Stem Guidebook - interactive
Green Stem Guidebook - interactiveGreen Stem Guidebook - interactive
Green Stem Guidebook - interactive
 
Theme 3: Economics
Theme 3: EconomicsTheme 3: Economics
Theme 3: Economics
 
Improving your Economics Exam Score
Improving your Economics Exam ScoreImproving your Economics Exam Score
Improving your Economics Exam Score
 
Unit 3: Multiple Choice Questions
Unit 3: Multiple Choice QuestionsUnit 3: Multiple Choice Questions
Unit 3: Multiple Choice Questions
 
Indian Physical Environment"Class - 11"
Indian Physical Environment"Class - 11"Indian Physical Environment"Class - 11"
Indian Physical Environment"Class - 11"
 
Unit one AQA A Psychology Attachmet Key Studies to know
Unit one AQA A Psychology Attachmet Key Studies to knowUnit one AQA A Psychology Attachmet Key Studies to know
Unit one AQA A Psychology Attachmet Key Studies to know
 
The World in 2025 - Future Agenda (2016)
The World in 2025 - Future Agenda (2016)The World in 2025 - Future Agenda (2016)
The World in 2025 - Future Agenda (2016)
 
A2 Micro Unit 3 Revision Advice
A2 Micro Unit 3 Revision AdviceA2 Micro Unit 3 Revision Advice
A2 Micro Unit 3 Revision Advice
 
Revision Webinar - Business Profits
Revision Webinar - Business ProfitsRevision Webinar - Business Profits
Revision Webinar - Business Profits
 
Tutor2u A2 Macroeconomics Glossary
Tutor2u A2 Macroeconomics GlossaryTutor2u A2 Macroeconomics Glossary
Tutor2u A2 Macroeconomics Glossary
 
Computer fundamentals-series1-e book
Computer fundamentals-series1-e bookComputer fundamentals-series1-e book
Computer fundamentals-series1-e book
 
Revision Webinar - Business Costs
Revision Webinar - Business CostsRevision Webinar - Business Costs
Revision Webinar - Business Costs
 
Unit one memory AQA A psychology Memory
Unit one memory AQA A psychology MemoryUnit one memory AQA A psychology Memory
Unit one memory AQA A psychology Memory
 
Research methods revision for AS AQA A Psychology 2014+
Research methods revision for AS AQA A Psychology 2014+Research methods revision for AS AQA A Psychology 2014+
Research methods revision for AS AQA A Psychology 2014+
 
Geography Fundamentals" Class - 12" NCERT
Geography Fundamentals" Class - 12" NCERTGeography Fundamentals" Class - 12" NCERT
Geography Fundamentals" Class - 12" NCERT
 
Ftth development manual part1 (1)
Ftth development manual part1 (1)Ftth development manual part1 (1)
Ftth development manual part1 (1)
 
Political law (2007 2013)
Political law (2007 2013)Political law (2007 2013)
Political law (2007 2013)
 
AS Micro Markets and Market Failure Key Term Glossary
AS Micro Markets and Market Failure Key Term GlossaryAS Micro Markets and Market Failure Key Term Glossary
AS Micro Markets and Market Failure Key Term Glossary
 
Revision Webinar: Business Objectives
Revision Webinar: Business ObjectivesRevision Webinar: Business Objectives
Revision Webinar: Business Objectives
 

Semelhante a A2 Microeconomics Course Companion

A2 microeconomics course companion
A2 microeconomics course companionA2 microeconomics course companion
A2 microeconomics course companionMatthew Bentley
 
Principles of Economics 5th Edition Gans Solutions Manual
Principles of Economics 5th Edition Gans Solutions ManualPrinciples of Economics 5th Edition Gans Solutions Manual
Principles of Economics 5th Edition Gans Solutions ManualGordonlANA
 
Economies and diseconomies of scale 2
Economies and diseconomies of scale 2Economies and diseconomies of scale 2
Economies and diseconomies of scale 2Janak Secktoo
 
Economies & diseconomies of scale
Economies & diseconomies of scaleEconomies & diseconomies of scale
Economies & diseconomies of scaleShivesh Ranjan
 
Bridgeton Industries Cost Analysis
Bridgeton Industries Cost AnalysisBridgeton Industries Cost Analysis
Bridgeton Industries Cost AnalysisCandace Garcia
 
Contrast The Significance Of The Term Lead Time In The...
Contrast The Significance Of The Term Lead Time In The...Contrast The Significance Of The Term Lead Time In The...
Contrast The Significance Of The Term Lead Time In The...Kimberly Jones
 
An Analysis of Working Capital Management at BHEL
An Analysis of Working Capital Management at BHELAn Analysis of Working Capital Management at BHEL
An Analysis of Working Capital Management at BHELSmitha Thippeswamy
 
Activity Analysis Report - Production
Activity Analysis Report - ProductionActivity Analysis Report - Production
Activity Analysis Report - ProductionMuhammad Hossain
 
Managerial_Economics (4).pdf
Managerial_Economics (4).pdfManagerial_Economics (4).pdf
Managerial_Economics (4).pdfAbhishekModak17
 
An Assignment On Ratio Analysis
An Assignment On  Ratio AnalysisAn Assignment On  Ratio Analysis
An Assignment On Ratio AnalysisDon Dooley
 
Economies of scale report
Economies of scale reportEconomies of scale report
Economies of scale reportMuneeb Ijaz
 
Energy Efficiency: An Investment Opportunity
Energy Efficiency: An Investment OpportunityEnergy Efficiency: An Investment Opportunity
Energy Efficiency: An Investment OpportunityMarianneSalama
 
MICROECONOMICS-PPT examples.pptx
MICROECONOMICS-PPT examples.pptxMICROECONOMICS-PPT examples.pptx
MICROECONOMICS-PPT examples.pptxMarcAndreiRivera
 

Semelhante a A2 Microeconomics Course Companion (20)

A2 microeconomics course companion
A2 microeconomics course companionA2 microeconomics course companion
A2 microeconomics course companion
 
ISS_5
ISS_5ISS_5
ISS_5
 
Principles of Economics 5th Edition Gans Solutions Manual
Principles of Economics 5th Edition Gans Solutions ManualPrinciples of Economics 5th Edition Gans Solutions Manual
Principles of Economics 5th Edition Gans Solutions Manual
 
Economies and diseconomies of scale 2
Economies and diseconomies of scale 2Economies and diseconomies of scale 2
Economies and diseconomies of scale 2
 
Economies & diseconomies of scale
Economies & diseconomies of scaleEconomies & diseconomies of scale
Economies & diseconomies of scale
 
Bridgeton Industries Cost Analysis
Bridgeton Industries Cost AnalysisBridgeton Industries Cost Analysis
Bridgeton Industries Cost Analysis
 
Contrast The Significance Of The Term Lead Time In The...
Contrast The Significance Of The Term Lead Time In The...Contrast The Significance Of The Term Lead Time In The...
Contrast The Significance Of The Term Lead Time In The...
 
Chapter 22 the costs of production
Chapter 22 the costs of productionChapter 22 the costs of production
Chapter 22 the costs of production
 
Case Study Starbucks
Case Study StarbucksCase Study Starbucks
Case Study Starbucks
 
An Analysis of Working Capital Management at BHEL
An Analysis of Working Capital Management at BHELAn Analysis of Working Capital Management at BHEL
An Analysis of Working Capital Management at BHEL
 
Chapter 10.pptx
Chapter 10.pptxChapter 10.pptx
Chapter 10.pptx
 
Activity Analysis Report - Production
Activity Analysis Report - ProductionActivity Analysis Report - Production
Activity Analysis Report - Production
 
Managerial_Economics (4).pdf
Managerial_Economics (4).pdfManagerial_Economics (4).pdf
Managerial_Economics (4).pdf
 
Conference Plan
Conference PlanConference Plan
Conference Plan
 
An Assignment On Ratio Analysis
An Assignment On  Ratio AnalysisAn Assignment On  Ratio Analysis
An Assignment On Ratio Analysis
 
New Business Plan
New Business PlanNew Business Plan
New Business Plan
 
Economies of scale report
Economies of scale reportEconomies of scale report
Economies of scale report
 
Unit-7.pdf
Unit-7.pdfUnit-7.pdf
Unit-7.pdf
 
Energy Efficiency: An Investment Opportunity
Energy Efficiency: An Investment OpportunityEnergy Efficiency: An Investment Opportunity
Energy Efficiency: An Investment Opportunity
 
MICROECONOMICS-PPT examples.pptx
MICROECONOMICS-PPT examples.pptxMICROECONOMICS-PPT examples.pptx
MICROECONOMICS-PPT examples.pptx
 

Mais de mattbentley34

Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problemSlide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problemmattbentley34
 
Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019mattbentley34
 
Behavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key termsBehavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key termsmattbentley34
 
Behavioural economics extra resources
Behavioural economics   extra resourcesBehavioural economics   extra resources
Behavioural economics extra resourcesmattbentley34
 
Behavioural economics
Behavioural economicsBehavioural economics
Behavioural economicsmattbentley34
 
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)mattbentley34
 
The labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determinationThe labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determinationmattbentley34
 
Specimen paper insert
Specimen paper insertSpecimen paper insert
Specimen paper insertmattbentley34
 
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-plannerAQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-plannermattbentley34
 
The Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explainedThe Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explainedmattbentley34
 
Model answers nationalism
Model answers nationalismModel answers nationalism
Model answers nationalismmattbentley34
 
Edexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam adviceEdexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam advicemattbentley34
 
Model answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & RacialismModel answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & Racialismmattbentley34
 
Voting systems in elections
Voting systems in electionsVoting systems in elections
Voting systems in electionsmattbentley34
 
Political representation and democracy
Political representation and democracyPolitical representation and democracy
Political representation and democracymattbentley34
 
Political participation
Political participationPolitical participation
Political participationmattbentley34
 
Political ideologies
Political ideologiesPolitical ideologies
Political ideologiesmattbentley34
 

Mais de mattbentley34 (20)

Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problemSlide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
Slide 1 1mm - the basic economic problem
 
Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019Why study economics 2019
Why study economics 2019
 
Behavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key termsBehavioural economics key terms
Behavioural economics key terms
 
Behavioural economics extra resources
Behavioural economics   extra resourcesBehavioural economics   extra resources
Behavioural economics extra resources
 
Behavioural economics
Behavioural economicsBehavioural economics
Behavioural economics
 
Jan 13
Jan 13Jan 13
Jan 13
 
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
Edexcel practice paper 1 (b)
 
The labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determinationThe labour market wage determination
The labour market wage determination
 
Specimen paper insert
Specimen paper insertSpecimen paper insert
Specimen paper insert
 
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-plannerAQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
AQA - pecan-pie-ajim-planner
 
The Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explainedThe Multiplier effect explained
The Multiplier effect explained
 
Economic review
Economic reviewEconomic review
Economic review
 
Model answers nationalism
Model answers nationalismModel answers nationalism
Model answers nationalism
 
Edexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam adviceEdexcel A level economics exam advice
Edexcel A level economics exam advice
 
Monetary policy
Monetary policyMonetary policy
Monetary policy
 
Model answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & RacialismModel answers nationalism & Racialism
Model answers nationalism & Racialism
 
Voting systems in elections
Voting systems in electionsVoting systems in elections
Voting systems in elections
 
Political representation and democracy
Political representation and democracyPolitical representation and democracy
Political representation and democracy
 
Political participation
Political participationPolitical participation
Political participation
 
Political ideologies
Political ideologiesPolitical ideologies
Political ideologies
 

A2 Microeconomics Course Companion

  • 1. A2 Economics Microeconomics Course Companion 2009
  • 2. 2 Introduction to the A2 Microeconomics Study Companion Welcome to this 2008-09 edition of the Tutor2u A2 microeconomics study companion. The edition has been revised throughout and seeks to provide a comprehensive coverage of some of the key ideas in the A2 business economics courses together with coverage of environmental market failure issues and aspects of labour market economics. The digital version of this study companion contains many links to selected online resources such as recent news articles from recommended newspapers and magazine. And also to the Tutor2u economics blog so that when you click on such a link, you will be guaranteed to be taken to the latest blog features written after this study companion was completed. This study companion is designed as a complement to your studies in A2 Economics and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking effective notes in your lessons. Points raised and issues covered in class analysis and discussion invariably go beyond the confines of this guide. And with Economics being the subject that it is, events and new economic policy debates will inevitably surface over the next twelve months that take you into new and exciting territory. Economics is a dynamic subject, the issues change from day to day and there is a wealth of comment and analysis in the broadsheet newspapers, magazines and journals that you can delve into. The more reading you manage on the main issues of the day the wider will be your appreciation of the theory and practice of economics. Further resources including online tests and revision notes are available from the Tutor2u virtual learning environment (VLE) at http://vle.tutor2u.net Check to see if your school or college has a subscription to this resource and EconoMax Tutor2u‘s digital magazine for Economics. I acknowledge the help given in the preparation of this study companion by my own students and I also acknowledge some of the ideas and arguments put forward in articles written by Bob Nutter, Jim Riley, Liz Veal and Mark Johnston – some of my fellow writers for the EconoMax digital magazine from which a small number of articles have been adapted as mini case studies. Good luck with your studies Geoff Riley This study companion follows the AQA syllabus and chapters are grouped into five main sectors: 1. The Firm: Objectives, Costs and Revenues 2. Competitive Markets 3. Concentrated Markets 4. The Labour Market 5. Government Intervention in the Market http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 3. 3 Contents 1. Production in the Short and the Long Run .................................................................................. 4 2. How can we calculate the costs of a firm? .................................................................................. 8 3. Long Run Costs: Economies and Diseconomies of Scale ........................................................ 13 4. Business Revenues ................................................................................................................... 23 5. Profits ......................................................................................................................................... 26 6. What Objectives Do Firms Have? ............................................................................................. 34 7. Divorce between Ownership and Control .................................................................................. 38 8. Technological Change, Costs and Supply in the Long-run ....................................................... 42 9. The Growth of Firms .................................................................................................................. 45 10. Perfect Competition ................................................................................................................... 51 11. Monopolistic Competition........................................................................................................... 59 12. The Model of Monopoly ............................................................................................................. 62 13. Barriers to Entry and Exit in Markets ......................................................................................... 65 14. Price Discrimination ................................................................................................................... 69 15. Monopoly and Economic Efficiency ........................................................................................... 76 16. Collusive and Non-Collusive Oligopoly ..................................................................................... 84 17. Oligopoly and Game Theory ...................................................................................................... 90 18. Contestable Markets .................................................................................................................. 97 19. Monopsony Power in Product Markets.................................................................................... 101 20. Consumer and Producer Surplus ............................................................................................ 103 21. Price Takers and Price Makers – Pricing Power ..................................................................... 106 22. Competition Policy and Regulation.......................................................................................... 111 23. Privatisation and Deregulation ................................................................................................. 116 24. The Labour Market................................................................................................................... 124 25. Monopsony in the Labour Market ............................................................................................ 137 26. Discrimination in the Labour Market ........................................................................................ 139 27. Trade Unions in the Labour Market ......................................................................................... 142 28. The Distribution of Income and Wealth ................................................................................... 146 29. Market Failure - Externalities ................................................................................................... 153 30. Carbon Emissions Trading and the Stern Review .................................................................. 159 31. Cost Benefit Analysis ............................................................................................................... 165 http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 4. 4 1. Production in the Short and the Long Run We take it for granted that goods and services will be available for us to buy as and when we need them. But production and supplying to the market is often a complicated business. Production Functions The production function elates the quantity of factor inputs to the volume of outputs that result. We make use of three measures of production and productivity. o Total product means total output. In most manufacturing industries such as motor vehicles, motor homes and DVD players, it is straightforward to measure production from labour and capital inputs. But in many service or knowledge-based industries, where the output is less ―tangible‖ or perhaps ‗weightless‘ we find it harder to measure productivity. o Average product measures output per-worker-employed or output-per-unit of capital. o Marginal product is the change in output from increasing the number of workers used by one person, or by adding one more machine to the production process in the short run. The length of time required for the long run varies from sector to sector. In the nuclear power industry for example, it can take many years to commission new nuclear power plant and capacity. This is something the UK government has to consider as it reviews our future sources of energy. Short Run Production Function The short run is a time period where at least one factor of production is in fixed supply - it cannot be changed. We normally assume that the quantity of plant and machinery is fixed and that production can be altered through changing variable inputs such as labour, raw materials and energy. The time periods used in economics must differ from one industry to another. The short-run for the electricity generation industry or telecommunications differs from magazine publishing and local sandwich bars. If you are starting out in business this autumn with a new venture selling sandwiches and coffees to office workers, how long is your short run? And how long is your long run? (!!). The http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 5. 5 long run could be as short as a few days – enough time to lease a new van and a sandwich making machine! Diminishing Returns In the short run, the law of diminishing returns states that as we add more units of a variable input to fixed amounts of land and capital, the change in total output will at first rise and then fall. Diminishing returns to labour occurs when marginal product of labour starts to fall. This means that total output will be increasing at a decreasing rate. What happens to marginal product is linked directly to the productivity of each extra worker. Beyond a certain point new workers will not have as much capital to work with so – it becomes diluted among a larger workforce. As a result, the marginal productivity tends to fall – this is the principle of diminishing returns. An example is shown below. We assume that there is a fixed supply of capital (20 units) available in the production process to which extra units of labour are added. Initially the marginal product is rising – e.g. the 4th worker adds 26 to output and the 5th worker adds 28. It peaks when the sixth worked is employed when the marginal product is 29. Marginal product then starts to fall. At this point production demonstrates diminishing returns. The Law of Diminishing Returns Capital Input Labour Input Total Output Marginal Product Average Product of Labour 20 1 5 5 20 2 16 11 8 20 3 30 14 10 20 4 56 26 14 20 5 85 28 17 20 6 114 29 19 20 7 140 26 20 20 8 160 20 20 20 9 171 11 19 20 10 180 9 18 http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 6. 6 Total Output Slope of the curve gives the (Q) (Q) marginal product of labour Diminishing returns are apparent here – total output is rising but at a decreasing rate Units of Labour Employed (L) Average product rises as long as the marginal product is greater than the average – for example when the seventh worker is added the marginal gain in output is 26 and this drags the average up from 19 to 20 units. Once marginal product is below the average as it is with the ninth worker employed (where marginal product is only 11) then the average must decline. This is an important example of the relationship between marginal and average values that we will return to later on when studying costs and revenues. Criticisms of the Law of Diminishing Returns How realistic is this assumption of diminishing returns? Surely ambitious and successful businesses will do their level best to avoid such a problem emerging? It is now widely recognised that the effects of globalisation and the ability of trans-national corporations to source their inputs from more than one country and engage in transfers of business technology, makes diminishing returns less relevant. Many businesses are multi-plant meaning that they operate factories in different locations – can switch output to meet changing demand. A rise in productivity and the production function In the following diagram we trace the effects of a rise in the productivity of the labour force at each level of employment. If average productivity rises, then the production curve shifts upwards. Diminishing returns are still assumed to exist in this diagram as shown by the shape of the production curve, but total output is higher for each number of people employed. If productivity rises, for a given level of wages, this will cause a fall in the unit labour costs of production. Other things remaining the same, there is an inverse relationship between productivity and cost. This is an important relationship for businesses to understand when they are seeking efficiency gains as a means of boosting profits. Long Run Production - Returns to Scale In the long run, all factors of production are variable. How the output of a business responds to a change in factor inputs is called returns to scale. Numerical example of long run returns to scale http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 7. 7 Units of Units of Total % Change in % Change in Returns to Scale Capital Labour Output Inputs Output 20 150 3000 40 300 7500 100 150 Increasing 60 450 12000 50 60 Increasing 80 600 16000 33 33 Constant 100 750 18000 25 13 Decreasing In our example when we double the factor inputs from (150L + 20K) to (300L + 40K) then the percentage change in output is 150% - there are increasing returns to scale. In contrast, when the scale of production is changed from (600L + 80K0 to (750L + 100K) then the percentage change in output (13%) is less than the change in inputs (25%) implying a situation of decreasing returns to scale. Increasing returns to scale occur when the % change in output > % change in inputs Decreasing returns to scale occur when the % change in output < % change in inputs Constant returns to scale occur when the % change in output = % change in inputs The nature of the returns to scale affects the shape of a business‘s long run average cost curve. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 8. 8 2. How can we calculate the costs of a firm? In this chapter we look at production costs. In the short run, because at least one factor of production is fixed, output can be increased only by adding more variable factors. Fixed costs Fixed costs do not vary directly with the level of output Examples of fixed costs include the rental costs of buildings; the costs of leasing or purchasing capital equipment such as plant and machinery; the annual business rate charged by local authorities; the costs of full-time contracted salaried staff; the costs of meeting interest payments on loans; the depreciation of fixed capital (due solely to age) and also the costs of business insurance. Fixed costs are the overhead costs of a business. Key points:  Total fixed costs (TFC) these remain constant as output increases  Average fixed cost (AFC) = total fixed costs divided by output Average fixed costs must fall continuously as output increases because total fixed costs are being spread over a higher level of production. In industries where the ratio of fixed to variable costs is extremely high, there is great scope for a business to exploit lower fixed costs per unit if it can produce at a big enough size. Consider the Sony PS3 or the new iPhone where the fixed costs of developing the product are enormous, but these costs can be divided by millions of individual units sold across the world. Successful product launches and huge volume sales can make a huge difference to the average total costs of production. Please note! A change in fixed costs has no effect on marginal costs. Marginal costs relate only to variable costs! Variable Costs Variable costs are costs that vary directly with output. Examples of variable costs include the costs of raw materials and components, the wages of part- time staff or employees paid by the hour, the costs of electricity and gas and the depreciation of capital inputs due to wear and tear. Average variable cost (AVC) = total variable costs (TVC) /output (Q) Average Total Cost (ATC or AC) Average total cost is the cost per unit produced Average total cost (ATC) = total cost (TC) / output (Q) Marginal Cost Marginal cost is the change in total costs from increasing output by one extra unit. The marginal cost of supplying an extra unit of output is linked with the marginal productivity of labour. The law of diminishing returns implies that marginal cost will rise as output increases. Eventually, rising marginal cost will lead to a rise in average total cost. This happens when the rise in AVC is greater than the fall in AFC as output (Q) increases. A numerical example of short run costs is shown in the table below. Fixed costs are assumed to be constant at £200. Variable costs increase as more output is produced. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 9. 9 Output Total Fixed Total Variable Total Cost Average Cost Marginal Cost (Q) Costs (TFC) Costs (TVC) Per Unit (the change in total cost from a one unit change in output) (TC= TFC + (AC = TC/Q) TVC) 0 200 0 200 50 200 100 300 6 2 100 200 180 400 4 2 150 200 230 450 3 1 200 200 260 460 2.3 0.2 250 200 280 465 1.86 0.1 300 200 290 480 1.6 0.3 350 200 325 525 1.5 0.9 400 200 400 600 1.5 1.5 450 200 610 810 1.8 4.2 500 200 750 1050 2.1 4.8 In our example, average cost per unit is minimised at a range of output - 350 and 400 units. Thereafter, because the marginal cost of production exceeds the previous average, so the average cost rises (for example the marginal cost of each extra unit between 450 and 500 is 4.8 and this increase in output has the effect of raising the cost per unit from 1.8 to 2.1). An example of fixed and variable costs in equation format If for example, the short-run total costs of a firm are given by the formula SRTC = $(10 000 + 5X2) where X is the level of output. The firm‘s total fixed costs are $10,000 The firm‘s average fixed costs are $10,000 / X If the level of output produced is 50 units, total costs will be $10,000 + $2,500 = $12,500 The Shape of Short Run Cost Curves When diminishing returns set in (beyond output Q1) the marginal cost curve starts to rise. Average total cost continues to fall until output Q2 where the rise in average variable cost equates with the fall in average fixed cost. Output Q2 is the lowest point of the ATC curve for this business in the short run. This is known as the output of productive efficiency. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 10. 10 If marginal cost is below average cost then average must be falling. Even if MC is rising, AC falls if MC <AC. For this reason, MC curve intersects the AC curve at the lowest point of the AC curve. Diminishing returns starts to occur when marginal cost starts to rise. Costs Marginal Cost (MC) Average Total Cost (ATC) Average Variable Cost (AVC) Average Fixed Cost (AFC) Q1 Q2 Output (Q) Key point: The marginal cost curve must intersect the average curves at their minimum levels A change in variable costs A rise in the variable costs of production – perhaps due to a rise in oil and gas prices or a rise in the national minimum wage - leads to an upward shift both in marginal and average total cost. The firm is not able to supply as much output at the same price. The effect is that of an inward shift in the supply curve of a business in a competitive market. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 11. 11 Costs MC2 AC2 Marginal Cost (MC1) Average Total Cost (ATC1) Average Variable Cost (AVC1) AVC2 Output (Q) An increase in fixed costs has no effect on the variable costs of production. This means that only the average total cost curve shifts. There is no change on the marginal cost curve leading to no change in the profit maximising price and output of a business. The effects of an increase in the fixed or overhead costs of a business are shown in the diagram below. Costs MC AC2 (after rise in fixed costs) AC1 Output (Q) Suggestions for background reading on changes in business costs Cadbury‘s plans to increase prices (BBC news, February 2008) Dry cleaners facing rising costs (BBC news, June 2008) Grain prices are squeezing bakers (BBC news, April 2008) http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 12. 12 Milk costs hit Stilton producers (BBC news, July 2007) http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 13. 13 3. Long Run Costs: Economies and Diseconomies of Scale Economies of Scale Economies of scale are the cost advantages from expanding the scale of production in the long run. The effect is to reduce average costs over a range of output. These lower costs represent an improvement in productive efficiency and can also give a business a competitive advantage in the market-place. They lead to lower prices and higher profits – a positive sum game for producers and consumers. We make no distinction between fixed and variable costs in the long run because all factors of production can be varied. As long as the long run average total cost (LRAC) is declining, economies of scale are being exploited. Long Run Output (Units) Total Costs (£s) Long Run Average Cost (£ per unit) 1000 12000 12 2000 20000 10 5000 45000 9 10000 80000 8 20000 144000 7.2 50000 330000 6.6 100000 640000 6.4 500000 3000000 6 Returns to scale and costs in the long run The table below shows how changes in the scale of production can, if increasing returns to scale are exploited, lead to lower long run average costs. Factor Inputs Production Costs (K) (La) (L) (Q) (TC) (TC/Q) Capital Land Labour Output Total Cost Average Cost Scale A 5 3 4 100 3256 32.6 Scale B 10 6 8 300 6512 21.7 Scale C 15 9 12 500 9768 19.5 Costs: Assume the cost of each unit of capital = £600, Land = £80 and Labour = £200 Because the % change in output exceeds the % change in factor inputs used, then, although total costs rise, the average cost per unit falls as the business expands from scale A to B to C. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 14. 14 Increasing Returns to Scale Much of the new thinking in economics focuses on the increasing returns available to a company growing in size in the long run. An example of this is the computer software business. The overhead costs of developing new software programs such as Microsoft Vista or computer games such as Halo 3 are huge - often running into hundreds of millions of dollars - but the marginal cost of producing one extra copy for sale is close to zero, perhaps just a few cents or pennies. If a company can establish itself in the market in providing a piece of software, positive feedback from consumers will expand the installed customer base, raise demand and encourage the firm to increase production. Because the marginal cost is so low, the extra output reduces average costs creating economies of size. Lower costs normally mean higher profits and increasing financial returns for the shareholders. What is true for software developers is also important for telecoms companies, transport operators and music distributors. We find across so many different markets that a high percentage of costs are fixed the higher is demand and output, the lower will be the average cost of production. Long Run Average Cost Curve The LRAC curve (also known as the „envelope curve‟) is usually drawn on the assumption of their being an infinite number of plant sizes – hence its smooth appearance in the next diagram below. The points of tangency between LRAC and SRAC curves do not occur at the minimum points of the SRAC curves except at the point where the minimum efficient scale (MES) is achieved. If LRAC is falling when output is increasing then the firm is experiencing economies of scale. For example a doubling of factor inputs might lead to a more than doubling of output. Conversely, When LRAC eventually starts to rise, the firm experiences diseconomies of scale, and, If LRAC is constant, then the firm is experiencing constant returns to scale Costs SRAC1 SRAC3 SRAC2 AC1 LRAC AC2 AC3 Q1 Q2 Q3 Output (Q) http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 15. 15 There are many different types of economy of scale. Depending on the characteristics of an industry or market, some are more important than others. Internal economies of scale (IEoS) Internal economies of scale come from the long term growth of the firm itself. Examples include: 1. Technical economies of scale: (these relate to aspects of the production process itself): a. Expensive capital inputs: Large-scale businesses can afford to invest in specialist capital machinery. For example, a supermarket might invest in database technology that improves stock control and reduces transportation and distribution costs. Highly expensive fixed units of capital are common in nearly every mass manufacturing production process. b. Specialization of the workforce: Larger firms can split the production processes into separate tasks to boost productivity. Examples include the use of division of labour in the mass production of motor vehicles and in manufacturing electronic products. c. The law of increased dimensions (or the “container principle”) This is linked to the cubic law where doubling the height and width of a tanker or building leads to a more than proportionate increase in the cubic capacity – the application of this law opens up the possibility of scale economies in distribution and freight industries and also in travel and leisure sectors with the emergence of super-cruisers such as P&O‘s Ventura. Consider the new generation of super-tankers and the development of enormous passenger aircraft such as the Airbus 280 which is capable of carrying well over 500 passengers on long haul flights. The law of increased dimensions is also important in the energy sectors and in industries such as office rental and warehousing. Amazon UK for example has invested in several huge warehouses at its central distribution points – capable of storing hundreds of thousands of items. d. Learning by doing: There is growing evidence that industries learn-by-doing! The average costs of production decline in real terms as a result of production experience as businesses cut waste and find the most productive means of producing output on a bigger scale. Evidence across a wide range of industries into so-called ―progress ratios‖, or ―experience curves‖ or ―learning curve effects‖, indicate that unit manufacturing costs typically fall by between 70% and 90% with each doubling of cumulative output. Businesses that expand their scale can achieve significant learning economies of scale. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 16. 16 Cost (Per unit of output) Economies of Scale A B LRAC1 Learning C LRAC2 economies Output 2. Monopsony power: A large firm can purchase its factor inputs in bulk at discounted prices if it has monopsony (buying) power. A good example would be the ability of the electricity generators to negotiate lower prices when finalizing coal and gas supply contracts. The national food retailers have monopsony power when purchasing their supplies from farmers and wine growers and in completing supply contracts from food processing businesses. Other controversial examples of the use of monopsony power include the prices paid by coffee roasters and other middle men to coffee producers in some of the poorest parts of the world. 3. Managerial economies of scale: This is a form of division of labour where firms can employ specialists to supervise production systems. Better management; increased investment in human resources and the use of specialist equipment, such as networked computers can improve communication, raise productivity and thereby reduce unit costs. 4. Financial economies of scale: Larger firms are usually rated by the financial markets to be more „credit worthy‟ and have access to credit with favourable rates of borrowing. In contrast, smaller firms often pay higher rates of interest on overdrafts and loans. Businesses quoted on the stock market can normally raise new financial capital more cheaply through the sale of equities to the capital market. 5. Network economies of scale: (Please note: This type of economy of scale is linked more to the growth of demand for a product – but it is still worth understanding and applying.) There is growing interest in the concept of a network economy. Some networks and services have huge potential for economies of scale. That is, as they are more widely used (or adopted), they become more valuable to the business that provides them. We can identify networks economies in areas such as online auctions and air transport networks. The marginal cost of adding one more user to the network is close to zero, but the resulting financial benefits may be huge because each new user to the network can then interact, trade with all of the existing members or parts of the network. The rapid expansion of e-commerce is a great example of the exploitation of network economies of scale. EBay is a classic example of exploiting network economies of scale as part of its operations. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 17. 17 The container principle at work! Economies of scale – the effects on price, output and profits for a profit maximizing firm Scale economies allow a supplier to move from SRAC1 to SRAC2. A profit maximising producer will produce at a higher output (Q2) and charge a lower price (P2) as a result – but the total abnormal profit is also much higher (compare the two shaded regions). Both consumer and producer surplus (welfare) has increased – there has been an improvement in economic welfare and economic efficiency – the key is whether cost savings are passed onto consumers! MC1 Costs Profit at Price P1 Profit at Price P2 P1 SRAC1 SRAC2 P2 MC2 AR (Demand) MR Q1 Q2 Output (Q) External economies of scale (EEoS) External economies of scale occur outside of a firm but within an industry. For example investment in a better transportation network servicing an industry will resulting in a decrease in http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 18. 18 costs for a company working within that industry, thus external economies of scale have been achieved. Another example is the development of research and development facilities in local universities that several businesses in an area can benefit from. Likewise, the relocation of component suppliers and other support businesses close to the centre of manufacturing are also an external cost saving. Agglomeration economies may also result resulting from the clustering of similar businesses in a distinct geographical location be it software businesses in Silicon Valley or investment banks in the City of London. Economies of Scale – The Importance of Market Demand The market structure of an industry is affected by the extent of economies of scale available to individual suppliers and by the total size of market demand. In many industries, it is possible for smaller firms to make a profit because the cost disadvantages they face are relatively small. Or because product differentiation allows a business to charge a price premium to consumers which more than covers their higher costs. A good example is the retail market for furniture. The industry has some major players in each of its different segments (e.g. flat-pack and designer furniture) including the Swedish giant IKEA. However, much of the market is taken by smaller-scale suppliers with consumers willing to pay higher prices for bespoke furniture owing to the low price elasticity of demand for high-quality, hand crafted furniture products. Small-scale manufacturers can therefore extract the consumer surplus that is present when demand is estimated to have a low elasticity of demand. Economies of Scope These are different from economies of scale! Economies of scope occur where it is cheaper to produce a range of products rather than specialize in just a handful of products. And they can be exploited when a business owns a resource that can be used more than once in different ways! For example, in the increasingly competitive world of postal services and business logistics, the main service providers such as Royal Mail, UK Mail, Deutsche Post and the international parcel carriers including TNT, UPS, and FedEx are broadening the range of their services and making more better use of their existing collection, sorting and distribution networks to reduce costs and earn higher profits from higher-profit-margin and fast growing markets. A company‘s management structure, administration systems and marketing departments are capable of carrying out these functions for more than one product. Expanding the product range to exploit the value of existing brands is a good way of exploiting economies of scope. Perhaps a good example of ―brand extension‖ is the Easy Group under the control of Stelios where the distinctive Easy Group business model has been applied (with varying degrees of success) to a wide range of markets – easy Pizza, easy Cinema, easy Car rental, easy Bus and easy Hotel to name just a handful! Procter and Gamble is the largest consumer household products maker in the world. Its brands include Crest, Duracell, Gillette, Pantene, and Tide, to name just a few. Twenty four of its brands make over $1 billion in sales annually. Another example of an economy of scope might be a restaurant that has catering facilities and uses it for multiple occasions – as a coffee shop during the day and as a supper-bar and jazz room in the evenings. Or a computing business can use its network and databases for many different uses. Case Study: Investment in Sports Grounds Hotels are a hot topic at sports venues. The owners of these venues are looking for ways to make better return on their assets. The solution is to explore new business opportunities, invest in extensive modernisation and spend cash on large-scale redevelopment schemes. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 19. 19 Capacity utilisation is an important challenge facing a sporting venue. There are only so many cricket matches, grand prix races or rugby games that draw spectators. By adding purpose-built conference, banqueting and leisure facilities, sports venues can tap into a different customer base. A hotel facility can attract demand from businesses looking for corporate hospitality and conferences. Having a hotel also allows a venue to access consumer spending on short breaks – one of the fastest growing segments of the leisure industry. Most of the planned hotels will be branded (e.g. Holiday Inn, Marriott) which allows the venue to benefit from a trusted hotel name and gets access to established distribution channels. Source: Business Cafe Minimum Efficient Scale (MES) The minimum efficient scale (MES) is the scale of production where the internal economies of scale have been fully exploited. The MES corresponds to the lowest point on the long run average cost curve and is also known as an output range over which a business achieves productive efficiency. The MES is not a single output level – more likely we describe the minimum efficient scale as comprising a range of outputs where the firm achieves constant returns to scale and has reached the lowest feasible cost per unit. Costs Revenues LRAC Increasing return to scale – economies of Decreasing returns – scale - falling LRAC diseconomies of scale MES Q2 Output (Q) The MES depends on the nature of costs of production in a specific sector or industry. 1. In industries where the ratio of fixed to variable costs is high, there is plenty of scope for reducing unit cost by increasing the scale of output. This is likely to result in a concentrated market structure (e.g. an oligopoly, a duopoly or a monopoly) – indeed economies of scale may act as a barrier to entry because existing firms have achieved cost advantages and they then can force prices down in the event of new businesses coming in! 2. In contrast, there might be only limited opportunities for scale economies such that the MES turns out to be a small % of market demand. It is likely that the market will be competitive with many suppliers able to achieve the MES. An example might be a large number of hotels in a city centre or a cluster of restaurants in a town. Much depends on how we define the market! http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 20. 20 3. With a natural monopoly, the long run average cost curve continues to fall over a huge range of output, suggesting that there may be room for perhaps one or two suppliers to fully exploit all of the available economies of scale when meeting market demand. Diseconomies of scale Diseconomies are the result of decreasing returns to scale. The potential diseconomies of scale a firm may experience relate to: 1. Control – monitoring the productivity and the quality of output from thousands of employees in big corporations is imperfect and costly – this links to the concept of the principal-agent problem – how best can managers assess the performance of their workforce when each of the stakeholders may have a different objective or motivation which can lead to stakeholder conflict? 2. Co-ordination - it can be difficult to co-ordinate complicated production processes across several plants in different locations and countries. Achieving efficient flows of information in large businesses is expensive as is the cost of managing supply contracts with hundreds of suppliers at different points of an industry‘s supply chain. 3. Co-operation - workers in large firms may develop a sense of alienation and loss of morale. If they do not consider themselves to be an integral part of the business, their productivity may fall leading to wastage of factor inputs and higher costs. Traditionally this has been seen as a problem experienced by the larger state sector businesses, examples being the Royal Mail and the Firefighters, the result being a poor and costly industrial relations performance. However, the problem is not concentrated solely in such industries. A good recent example of a bitter industrial relations dispute was between Gate Gourmet and its workers. Avoiding diseconomies of scale A number of economists are skeptical about diseconomies of scale. They believe that proper management techniques and appropriate incentives can do much to reduce the risk of industrial strife. Here are three of the reasons to doubt the persistence of diseconomies of scale: 1. Developments in human resource management (HRM). HRM is a horrible phrase to describe improvements that a business might make to procedures involving worker recruitment, training, promotion, retention and support of faculty and staff. This becomes critical to a business when the skilled workers it needs are in short supply. Recruitment and retention of the most productive and effective employees makes a sizeable difference to corporate performance in the long run. 2. Performance related pay schemes (PRP) can provide financial incentives for the workforce leading to an improvement in industrial relations and higher productivity. Another aim of PRP is for businesses to reward and hang onto their most efficient workers. The John Lewis Partnership is often cited as an example of how a business can empower its employees by giving them a stake in the financial success of the organization. 3. Increasingly companies are engaging in out-sourcing of manufacturing and distribution as they seek to supply to ever-distant markets. Out-sourcing is a tried and tested way of reducing costs whilst retaining control over production although there may be a price to pay in terms of the impact on the job security of workers whose functions might be outsourced overseas. Case Study: Amazon – Economies of Scale and Scope http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 21. 21 Increased dimensions: Firstly, the company invested in enormous warehouses to stock its inventory of books, DVDs, computer peripherals. This allows it to benefit from the law of increased dimension. Buying power: Amazon has significant monopsony power when it purchases books directly from publishers, thereby bypassing its reliance on wholesalers and giving it a higher profit margin. Learning by doing and first-mover advantage: Amazon is benefiting from learning by doing having been one of the first major players in the online retail sector. The unit costs of production tend to decline in real terms as a result of production experience as businesses cut waste and find the most productive means of producing output on a bigger scale Pre-Orders - Amazon use a pre-order system for customers which allows it to capture early demand and improve stock (or inventory) forecasting. Less invested capital: As an online retailer, Amazon avoids the need for retail stores – one advantage is that it has lower invested capital in the business and it frees up resources for customer fulfillment and investment in new technology – Amazon distributes to over 200 countries. Shifting stock at speed: Amazon has a much faster stock velocity – measured by the number of weeks an item remains in stock. For Amazon this is half that of a physical store – and the benefit is a reduction in obsolescence loss (the value of unsold stock is estimated to decline by 30% per year) Economies of scale help to give Amazon a significant cost advantage. The business is also looking to create economies of scope from marketing and broadening the range of products available through the Amazon brand. Among the innovative business ideas under development we can identify: Merchants@/Marketplace which gives independent (third party) sellers the opportunity to sell their products through the Amazon platform Amazon Enterprise Solutions – where Amazon provides e-commerce technology for a range of partners such as Marks and Spencer, Lacoste, Mothercare and Timex CreateSpace – a new self-publishing platform for books, music and video Amazon Kindle – a portable reader that wirelessly downloads books, blogs, magazines and newspapers to a high-resolution electronic paper display that looks and reads like real paper, Amazon now sells nearly one fifth of the books bought in the UK each year. Suggestions for further reading on economies of scale and scope http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 22. 22 Consoles look to hit their stride (BBC news, July 2008) Cost headache for games developers (BBC news, December 2007) Economies of scale in printing (Tutor2u economics blog, March 2008) GM installs world's biggest rooftop solar panels (Guardian, July 2008) How world's biggest ship is delivering our Christmas - all the way from China (Guardian) Mobile web reaches critical mass (BBC news, July 2008) Salad production on a massive scale (BBC news, June 2008) http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 23. 23 4. Business Revenues Revenue (or turnover) is the income generated from the sale of output in product markets. o Average Revenue (AR) = Price per unit = total revenue / output o Marginal Revenue (MR) = the change in revenue from selling one extra unit of output The table below shows the demand for a product where there is a downward sloping demand curve. Price per unit Quantity Demanded Total Revenue Marginal Revenue (average revenue) (Qd) (TR) (PxQ) (MR) £s units £s £s 400 220 88000 370 340 125800 315 340 460 156400 255 310 580 179800 195 280 700 196000 135 250 820 205000 75 220 940 206800 15 190 1060 201400 -45 Average and Marginal Revenue In our example in the table above, as price per unit falls, demand expands and total revenue rises although because average revenue falls as more units are sold, this causes marginal revenue to decline. Eventually marginal revenue becomes negative, a further fall in price (e.g. from £220 to £190) causes total revenue to fall. Because the price per unit is declining, total revenue is rising at a decreasing rate and will eventually reach a maximum (see the next paragraph). Elasticity of Demand and Total Revenue When a firm faces a perfectly elastic demand curve, then average revenue = marginal revenue (i.e. extra units of output can all be sold at the ruling market price). However, most businesses face a downward sloping demand curve! And because the price per unit must be cut to sell extra units, therefore MR lies below AR. In fact he MR curve will fall at twice the rate of the AR curve. You don’t have to prove this for the exams – but it is worth remembering that the marginal revenue curve has twice the slope of the AR curve! Maximum total revenue occurs where marginal revenue is zero: no more revenue can be achieved from producing an extra unit of output. This point is directly underneath the mid-point of a linear demand curve. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 24. 24 Revenue Total revenue is maximised when MR = 0 Total Revenue (TR) Ped >1 for a price fall along this Price elasticity of length of AR demand = 1 at this output Average Revenue Marginal Revenue (Demand) AR (MR) Output (Q) Total revenue is shown by the area underneath the firm‘s demand curve (average revenue curve). Total revenue (TR) refers to the amount of money received by a firm from selling a given level of output and is found by multiplying price (P) by output ie number of units sold Costs Total revenue at price P1 where marginal revenue is zero P2 A rise in price to P2 causes a reduction in total P1 revenue Average revenue AR Total revenue at price P2 Q2 Q1 Marginal revenue MR Output (Q) Suggestions for further reading on business revenues Carmakers tackle profit problems (BBC news, July 2008) http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 25. 25 Revenue fears hit Vodafone shares (BBC news, July 2008) Price elasticity of demand and total revenue (Bryn Jones Online, You Tube video) http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 26. 26 5. Profits The Nature of Profit Profit measures the return to risk when committing scarce resources to a market or industry. Entrepreneurs take risks for which they require an adequate expected rate of return. The higher the market risk and the longer they expect to have to wait to earn a positive return, the greater will be the minimum required return that an entrepreneur is likely to demand. 1. Normal profit - is the minimum level of profit required to keep factors of production in their current use in the long run. Normal profits reflect the opportunity cost of using funds to finance a business. If you decide to put £200,000 of your personal savings into a new business, those funds could have earned a low-risk rate of return by being saved in a bank or building society deposit account. You might therefore use the rate of interest on that £200,000 as the minimum rate of return that you need to make from your investment in order to keep going in the long run! Of course we are ignoring here differences in risk and also the non-financial benefits of running and building your own business or investing funds in someone else‘s project. Because we treat normal profit as an opportunity cost of investing financial capital in a business, we normally include an estimate for normal profit in the average total cost curve, thus, if the firm covers its ATC (where AR meets AC) then it is making normal profits. 2. Sub-normal profit - is any profit less than normal profit (where price < average total cost) 3. Abnormal profit - is any profit achieved in excess of normal profit - also known as supernormal profit. A firm earns supernormal profit when its profit is above that required to keep its resources in their present use in the long run. When firms are making abnormal profits, there is an incentive for other producers to enter a market to try to acquire some of this profit. Abnormal profit persists in the long run in imperfectly competitive markets such as oligopoly and monopoly where firms can successfully block the entry of new firms. We will come to this later when we consider barriers to entry in monopoly. Case Study: Sub-normal profits drive mortgage lenders out of the market – for now What is happening in the UK mortgage market? Rarely a day goes by without news of another mortgage lender reassessing the risk of their housing loans and deciding to pull the plug on some of their mortgage products. Following on from the Northern Rock which has virtually stopped lending at all and wants to shift a sizeable portion of its mortgage book onto others, the Co-operative Bank, Lehman Brothers and First Direct have all announced that they are withdrawing two-year fixed rate mortgage products for the time being. All of this is one of the direct results of the credit crunch. The lenders are spinning this as a way of providing better service-levels to their existing customers but the reality is that the supply of finance in the wholesale money markets has been badly squeezed and this is now feeding through to the retail market for housing loans. It is costing the mortgage lenders more to borrow funds and their profit margins have been squeezed to a level where sub-normal profits are being made. Little wonder that some of the major players are effectively exiting the market by withdrawing some mortgage products from sale. Only when conditions improve will they consider a return. Source: Tutor2u Economics Blog, April 2008 Calculating economic profit Consider the following example: http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 27. 27 The table shows data for an owner-managed firm for a particular year. Total revenue £320,000 Raw material costs £30,000 Wages and salaries £85,000 Interest paid on bank loan £30,000 Salary that the owner could have earned elsewhere £32,000 Interest forgone on owner's capital invested in the business £20,000 In a simple accounting sense, the business has total revenue of £320,000 and costs of £145,000 giving an accounting profit of £175,000. But the firm‘s profit according to an economist should take into account the opportunity cost of the capital invested in the business and the income that the owner could have earned elsewhere. Taking these two items into account we find that the economic profit is £123,000. Profit maximisation Profits are maximised when marginal revenue = marginal cost Price Per Unit Demand / Total Marginal Total Marginal Profit (£) Output Revenue Revenue Cost Cost (£) (units) (£) (£) (£) (£) 50 33 1650 2000 -350 48 39 1872 37 2120 20 -248 46 45 2070 33 2222 17 -152 44 51 2244 29 2312 15 -68 42 57 2394 25 2384 12 10 40 63 2520 21 2444 10 76 38 69 2622 17 2480 6 142 36 75 2700 13 2534 9 166 34 81 2754 9 2612 13 142 Consider the example in the table above. As price per unit (average revenue) declines, so demand expands. Total revenue rises but at a decreasing rate (as shown by column 4 – marginal revenue). Initially the firm is making a loss because total cost exceeds total revenue. The firm moves into profit at an output level of 57 units. Thereafter profit is increasing because the marginal revenue from selling units is greater than the marginal cost of producing them. Consider the rise in output from 69 to 75 units. The MR is £13 per unit, whereas marginal cost is £9 per unit. Profits increase from £142 to £166. But once marginal cost is greater than marginal revenue, total profits are falling. Indeed the firm makes a loss if it increases output to 93 units. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 28. 28 Revenue Marginal Cost And Cost Profits are increasing when MR > MC Profits are decreasing when MR < MC Q1 Marginal Revenue Output (Q) As long as marginal revenue is greater than marginal cost, total profits will be increasing (or losses decreasing). The profit maximisation output occurs when marginal revenue = marginal cost. In the next diagram we introduce average revenue and average cost curves into the diagram so that, having found the profit maximising output (where MR=MC), we can then find (i) the profit maximising price (using the demand curve) and then (ii) the cost per unit. The difference between price and average cost marks the profit margin per unit of output. Total profit is shown by the shaded area and equals the profit margin multiplied by output Costs Revenue Supernormal profits at Price P1 and output Q1 Normal profit at Q2 where SRAC AR = AC P1 SRMC AC1 AC2 AR (Demand) Q1 Q2 MR Output (Q) The short run supply decision - the shut-down point The theory of the firm assumes that a business needs to make at least normal profit in the long run to justify remaining in an industry but this is not a strict requirement when the firm will continue to produce as long as total revenue covers total variable costs or put another way, so long as price per http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 29. 29 unit > or equal to average variable cost (AR = AVC). This is sometimes referred to as the shut- down price. The reason for this is as follows. A business‘s fixed costs must be paid regardless of the level of output. If we make an assumption that these costs are sunk costs (i.e. they cannot be recovered if the firm shuts down) then the loss per unit would be greater if the firm were to shut down, provided variable costs are covered. MC ATC Costs, P1 is below average variable cost Revenues AVC A AC1 B P2 P1 C AR MR Q1 Output (Q) Consider the cost and revenue curves facing a business in the short run in the diagram above.  Average revenue (AR) and marginal revenue curves (MR) lies below average cost across the full range of output, so whatever output produced, the business faces making a loss.  At P1 and Q1 (where marginal revenue equals marginal cost), the firm would shut down as price is less than AVC. The loss per unit of producing is vertical distance AC.  If the firm shuts down production the loss per unit will equal the fixed cost per unit AB.  In the short-run, provided that the price is greater than or equal to P2, the business can justify continuing to produce in the short run. Northern Foods decides to mothball a factory Northern Foods, which supplies Marks and Spencer, is to mothball a factory making ready-meals because it is no longer economical. They said that, whilst the plant had been profitable in recent years it was no longer generating enough money to give an adequate return to shareholders. Some analysts have argued that the decision might be due to the effects of the monopsony power of Marks and Spencer which has demanded discounts of up to 6% from its top suppliers including Northern Foods. Source: Adapted from news reports, May 2008 Deriving the Firm‟s Supply Curve in the Short Run In the short run, the supply curve for a business operating in a competitive market is the marginal cost curve above average variable cost. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 30. 30 In the long run, a firm must make a normal profit, so when price = average total cost, this is the break-even point. It will therefore shut down at any price below this in the long run. As a result the long run supply curve will be the marginal cost curve above average total cost. The concept of a ‗supply curve‘ is inappropriate when dealing with monopoly because a monopoly is a price-maker, not a ―passive‖ price-taker, and can thus select the price and output combination on the demand curve so as to maximise profits where marginal revenue = marginal cost. Changes in demand and the profit maximising price and output A change in demand and/or production costs will lead to a change in the profit maximising price and output. In exams you may often be asked to analyse how changes in demand and costs affect the equilibrium output for a business. Make sure that you are confident in drawing these diagrams and you can produce them quickly and accurately under exam conditions. In the diagram below we see the effects of an outward shift of demand from AR1 to AR2 (assuming that short run costs of production remain unchanged). The increase in demand causes a rise in the market price from P1 to P2 (consumers are now willing and able to buy more at a given price perhaps because of a rise in their real incomes or a fall in interest rates which has increased their purchasing power) and an expansion of supply (the shift in AR and MR is a signal to firms to move along their marginal cost curve and raise output). Total profits have increased. A rise in demand (a shift in AR and MR) causes an expansion of supply, a higher profit maximising price and an increase in supernormal profits Profit Max at Price P2 Costs Profit Max at Price P1 P2 AC P1 MC AC1 AC2 AR2 AR1 (Demand) MR2 Q1 Q2 MR1 Output (Q) http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 31. 31 Wiseman dairies hit by profits blow Shares in Robert Wiseman, Scotland‘s biggest milk supplier, have taken a hit following news of lower profits. Operating profits were reported as falling by 16% after a £6.1m fine levied by the Office for Fair Trading for alleged price fixing. The company is also suffering from the effects of higher energy, packaging and distribution costs caused by the rising world price of oil. A third factor is a slump in the market price of cream. The company has found that it cannot always pass on higher input prices to customers, partly because of pre-existing milk delivery contracts with some of the major supermarkets. Source: Adapted from news reports, May 2008 The Functions of Profit in a Market Economy Profits serve a variety of purposes to businesses in a market-based economic system 1. Finance for investment Retained profits are source of finance for companies undertaking investment projects. The alternatives such as issuing new shares (equity) or bonds may not be attractive depending on the state of the financial markets especially in the aftermath of the credit crunch. 2. Market entry: Rising profits send signals to other producers within a market. When the existing firms are earning supernormal profits, this signals that profitable entry may be possible. In contestable markets, we would see a rise in market supply and lower prices. But in a monopoly, the dominant firm(s) may be able to protect their position through barriers to entry. 3. Demand for factor resources: Scarce factor resources tend to flow where the expected rate of return or profit is highest. In an industry where demand is strong more land, labour and capital are then committed to that sector. Equally in a recession, national output, employment, incomes and investment all fall leading to a squeeze on profit margins and attempts by businesses large and small to cut costs and preserve their market position. In a flexible labour market, a fall in demand can quickly lead to a reduction in investment and cut-backs in labour demand. 4. Signals about the health of the economy: The profits made by businesses throughout the economy provide important signals about the health of the macroeconomy. Rising profits might reflect improvements in supply-side performance (e.g. higher productivity or lower costs through innovation). Strong profits are also the result of high levels of demand from domestic and overseas markets. In contrast, a string of profit warnings from businesses could be a lead indicator of a macroeconomic downturn. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 32. 32 Net Profit for Manufacturing and Service Businesses Net percentage rate of return on capital employed, seasonally adjusted 22.0 22.0 20.0 20.0 18.0 Services 18.0 16.0 16.0 14.0 Rate of return (%) 14.0 12.0 Manufacturing 12.0 10.0 10.0 8.0 8.0 6.0 6.0 4.0 4.0 2.0 2.0 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 Source: Reuters EcoWin Steps to higher profits In an ideal world, running a business would be easy! You come up with an innovative idea, create a new product or service so popular you can‘t stop people from buying it. Word spreads and, before you know it, sales and profits are growing. In reality, few businesses are able to sit back and watch the profits roll in. Creating and increasing profitability depends on doing a hundred little things better than the existing competition. So what are the best ways for a business to increase its profitability? Method 1: Grow the “Top Line” Every business and every market is different. But for most businesses, the best long-term way to improve profitability is to increase sales (also known as ―turnover‖). This is for four main reasons: 1. If a business has a high gross profit margin, every extra sale is profitable. Once your turnover reaches the break-even level then each additional sale adds to profits. 2. Acquiring new customers is made easier by greater market presence and reputation. As you grow, unit costs are reduced through economies of scale. 3. If your customers tend to be loyal, the value of each new customer lays not just in the immediate sale, but in future sales as well. The cost of selling to existing customers is always lower than the cost of acquiring new customers. 4. Defending a market share against competitors is easier than defending high profit margins. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 33. 33 Many businesses operate in what are called “low growth” markets - where expansion only comes by taking a bigger share of the available demand. Low growth markets tend to be in markets where income elasticity of demand is low, so that as the real incomes of consumers increase, there is little positive effect on market demand. Method 2: Keep Costs under Control If a business has a low gross profit margin, reducing direct costs increases the profit on each sale. Eliminating overheads has an immediate impact on profit. Every business can increase profitability by reducing hidden costs. Hidden costs include the costs of employing inappropriate people since poor recruitment can lead to lower quality, increased training costs and ultimately redundancy costs. Suggestions for further reading on profits A selection of recent news articles on the profitability of businesses in different markets and industries and how changes in demand and costs affect prices and profits. Dominos delivers stronger profits (BBC news, July 2008) Fuel costs eat into Fedex profit (BBC news, March 2008) Grand Theft Auto IV set to break all records (BBC news, April 2008) Gregg‘s warns of increased costs (BBC news, March 2008) Higher oil prices see BP‘s profits surge (Guardian, July 2008) Pubs close as beer sales fall (BBC news, July 2008) Ryanair slashes fares to boost demand and fill airline capacity (Guardian, August 2008) Should the British pub get a government subsidy? (BBC news, July 2008) Silverjet calls in administrators (BBC news, June 2008) Supporters count the cost of following a Premiership footie club (Tutor2u blog, March 2008) Weak dollar boosts Nike profits (BBC news, March 2008) Wolseley hit by housing slowdown (BBC news, July 2008) http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 34. 34 6. What Objectives Do Firms Have? In this chapter we consider a range of different business objectives – much depends on the ownership and control of a business and the type of market in which it operates. Profit maximisation The traditional theory of the firm tends to assume that businesses possess sufficient information, market power and motivation to set prices or their products that maximise profits. This assumption is now criticised by economists who have studied the organisation and objectives of modern-day corporations. Why might a business depart from profit maximisation? There are numerous possible explanations. Some relate o the lack of accurate information required to undertake profit maximising behaviour. Others concentrate on the alternative objectives of businesses. We start first with the effects of imperfect information. It might be hard for a business to pinpoint precisely their profit maximising output, as they cannot accurately calculate marginal revenue and marginal costs. Often the day-to-day pricing decisions of businesses are taken on the basis of ―estimated demand conditions.‖ Secondly, most modern businesses are multi-product firms operating in a range of separate markets across countries and continents – as a result the volume of information that they have to handle can be vast. And they must keep track of the ever-changing preferences of consumers. The idea that there is a neat, single profit maximising price is redundant. Behavioural Theories of the Firm Behavioural economists believe that modern corporations are complex organizations made up various stakeholders. Stakeholders are defined as any groups who have a vested interest in the activity of a business. Examples might include: o Employees within a business o Managers employed by the firm o Shareholders – people who have an equity stake in a business o Customers in the market o The local community o The government and it‘s agencies including local government Each of these groups is likely to have different objectives or goals at points in time. The dominant group at any moment can give greater emphasis to their own objectives – for example price and http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 35. 35 output decisions may be taken at local level by managers – with shareholders taking only a distant and imperfectly informed view of the company‘s performance and strategy. If firms are likely to move away from pure profit maximising behaviour, what are the alternatives? 1. Satisficing behaviour involves the owners setting minimum acceptable levels of achievement in terms of business revenue and profit. 2. Sales Revenue Maximisation The objective of maximising sales revenue rather than profits was initially developed by the work of William Baumol (1959). His research focused on the behaviour of manager-controlled businesses. Baumol argued that annual salaries and other perks might be closely correlated with total sales revenue rather than profits. Companies geared towards maximising revenue are likely to make frequent and extensive use of price discrimination (or yield management) as a means of extracting extra revenue and profit from consumers. 3. Managerial Satisfaction model An alternative view was put forward by Oliver Williamson (1981), who developed the concept of managerial satisfaction (or managerial utility). This can be enhanced by raising sales revenue. Costs Profit Max at Price P1 Revenue Max at Price P2 AC P1 MC P2 AC1 AC2 AR (Demand) Q1 Q2 Output (Q) MR Price and output differs if the firm changes its objective from profit to revenue maximisation. Assuming that the firm‘s costs remain the same, a firm will choose a lower price and supply a higher output when sales revenue maximisation is the main objective. The profit maximising price is P2 at output Q2 whilst the revenue maximising price is P1 at output Q1. A change in the objectives of the business has an effect on welfare and in particular the balance between consumer and producer surplus. Consumer surplus is higher with sales revenue maximisation because output is higher and price is lower. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 36. 36 Cadbury abandons its profit target Cadbury Schweppes Plc, the manufacturer of Dairy Milk chocolate has decided to scrap its profitability target in the wake of a sharp increase in the costs of their raw materials. Three years ago Cadbury announced targets for annual improvements in profit margins ranging from 0.5 to 0.75%. But the rising price of oil-based raw materials and the world market price of cocoa and sugar have conspired to make meeting this target impossible. Prospects for profits have also been adversely affected by the hot summer which has hit demand for chocolate and the unplanned recall of several high profile products because of fears of salmonella poisoning. The business is a major global presence in the confectionery market with an estimated ten per cent world market share. In June 2007, Cadbury announced that it planned to cut its workforce by 15%. The reorganisation will cost Cadbury about £450m in a one-off charge. Adapted from Tutor2u blog, November 2006 and news reports, June 2007 Social Entrepreneurs – “not just for profit” businesses Underneath the surface of an economy dominated by corporate giants, a new breed of business is flourishing, where profit is not always the bottom line; these are entrepreneurs operating for a social purpose and not just for profit. A social enterprise is a business that has social objectives whose surpluses are reinvested for that purpose in the business or the community, rather than being driven by the need to seek profit to satisfy investors. Rather than maximise shareholder value and distribute dividends, a social enterprise is looking to achieve social and environmental aims over the long term. Examples include o Café Direct o Fifteen Foundation (Jamie Oliver) o Fair Trade o Housing Associations o Traidcraft o Micro-credit developed by the o Divine Chocolate Grameen Bank and its founder, the o The Eden Project Nobel-Prize winner Muhammad Yu Social Entrepreneurship An example from India Devi Prasad Shetty strives to make sophisticated health care in India available to all irrespective of their economic situation or geographic location. He founded the Narayana Hrudayalaya Hospital in Bangalore in 2001 and co-founded the Asia Heart Foundation. In addition, Shetty has built a network of 39 telemedicine centres to reach out to patients in remote rural areas. Together, the network of hospitals performs 32 heart surgeries a day. Almost half the patients are children and babies. Sixty percent of the treatments are provided below cost or for free. And one from the UK The 2008 Independent Social Entrepreneur of the Year award went to Belu Water, a bottled water company that donates all of its profits to global clean water projects. The company uses carbon- neutral packaging in the form of a compostable bottle made from corn. Belu is the first carbon- neutral product being stocked at Tesco. The bottles look like ordinary bottles and can be recycled with plastics or commercially composted back to soil in just eight weeks. Among its clean water projects, Belu has installed hand pumps and wells for 20,000 people in India and Mali, and it is also working on a rubbish-muncher to clean up the Thames. The company has a pledge that each bottle of mineral water sold will translate as clean water for one person for one month. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 37. 37 Source: Adapted from news reports, January 2008 See Young, Gifted and not for Profit (BBC radio 4 In Business) and also the economic impact of the Eden project. Other good sites include: Schwab Foundation for Social Entrepreneurship Not for Profit Businesses These are charities, community organisations that are run on commercial lines e.g. Network Rail: Network Rail o Took over the rail network in October 2002 o Stated purpose is to deliver a safe, reliable and efficient railway for Britain. o It is a company limited by guarantee – whose debts are secured by the government o Network Rail is a private company operating as a commercial business and regulated by the Office of Rail Regulation o Network Rail is a "not-for-dividend" company, which means that all of its profits are invested in the railway network. o Train operating companies pay Network Rail for use of the rail infrastructure Businesses required to main a loss-making service on social grounds A good example here is the Royal Mail which is required to maintain a universal national postal delivery service throughout the UK for a uniform price. Household mail makes a loss, cross- subsidised by business mail – although this market is shrinking for the Royal Mail because of the introduction of fresh competition from Jan 2006. The Post Office Ltd is a subsidiary of the Royal Mail Group plc – it runs substantial losses on the network or rural post offices and has been under great pressure to close hundreds of offices to stem losses. Suggestions for further reading on business objectives and business ownership Australian expansion proves a move too far for Starbucks (Tutor2u blog, July 2008) Founder of bottled water company honoured for work in Third World (Independent, Jan 2008) How business embraced charity (The Observer, June 2008) Making profit with a conscience (BBC news, March 2008) Motivated by change (Independent, July 2004) Mysterious death of the petrol station (VVC news, March 2008) Network Rail announces pre-tax profit of £1.6bn (BBC news, June 2008) Ryanair flies into the path of an economic storm (Tutor2u blog, July 2008) Sony predicts TV and game profits (BBC news, June 2008) Survival challenge for social enterprises (Guardian, July 2008) Wind farm co-op raises thousands (BBC news, July 2008) http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/
  • 38. 38 7. Divorce between Ownership and Control Ownership and control The owners of a private sector company normally elect a board of directors to control the business‘s resources for them. However, when the owner sells shares, or takes out a loan or bond to raise finance, they may sacrifice some of their control. Other shareholders can exercise their voting rights, and providers of loans often have some control (security) over the assets of the business. This may lead to a degree of conflict between them as these different stakeholders may have different objectives. The flow chart below attempts to show the divorce between ownership and control. Principals: Shareholders OWNERSHIP Control Mechanisms: Pressures from the stock market and from hedge funds and private investors Regular meetings with shareholders (e.g. the AGM) Scrutiny in the financial press Performance related pay (to provide incentives) CONTROL Agents: Board of Directors Senior Management The Principal Agent Problem How do the owners of a large business know that the managers they have employed and who are making the key day-to-day decisions operate with the aim of maximising shareholder value in both the short term and the long run? This lack of information is known as the principal-agent problem or ―agency problem‖. In other words, one person, the principal, employs an agent (e.g. a sales or finance manager) to perform tasks on his behalf but he or she cannot ensure that the agent always performs them in precisely the way the principal would like. The decisions and the performance of the agent are both impossible and expensive to monitor and the incentives of the agent may differ from those of the principal. The principal agent problem is illustrated in the flow chart above. http://www.tutor2u.net/blog/index.php/economics/