SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 105
Vocational Education & Training
Are students prepared for information fluency?


                  Mersini Moreleli-Cacouris
      Dept. of Library Science and Information Systems
           Alexander TEI of Thessaloniki, Greece
 The preparation of independent individuals, who can

      think critically and creatively
      act as informed and responsible professionals and citizens
      develop their aesthetic awareness

   The acquisition of knowledge and skills, that will enable
     them to:
      to adopt and apply them to any environment
      to enhance them continuously


   The development of a lifelong relationship with learning
―… [any academic institution‘s] purpose is not to transfer
knowledge but to create environments and experiences that
bring students to discover and construct knowledge for
themselves, to make students members of communities of
learners that make discoveries and solve problems. The college
aims, in fact, to create a series of ever more powerful learning
environments‖ (Barr & Tagg, 1995)
―Critical thinking is not a new concept or concern in academic
institutions. On the contrary, it has long been a major objective
of higher education. However, the need to "cover the subject"
has assumed precedence for some instructors, and many
concentrate more on delivering facts and subject content than
on instilling methodological or analytical skills. With a virtually
unmanageable but still growing level of information now
available on most topics, it is time for students to return to the
most important aspect of learning: mastering thinking skills
requisite to proper use of the information at their disposal.‖
(Engeldinger, 1988)
Vocational Education & Training (VET)    EU, CEDEFOP


Technical and Vocational Education and    UNESCO
Training (TVET)
Technical and Further Education (TAFE) or Australia

Vocational and Technical Education (VTE)

Further Education                        United Kingdom

Career and Technical Education (CTE)     USA
Aimed at imparting skills for the labor market, at a sub-professional
level

 Most diverse education sector, delivered in both the classroom and
the workplace, and organized in a variety of ways internationally

A cornerstone is the apprenticeship – combining formal education
with on-the-job experience – but also delivered in schools and
tertiary educational institutions (Karmel, 2010, p. 229)
Institutional arrangements of vocational education complex
(with industry playing an important role)

Approach to teaching and learning distinctive (and contested)

Expectations by the community demanding, with it being seen as the
education sector best positioned to deal with social disadvantage and
addressing issues of equity in many countries (VET offering second-
chance education)

The VET sector is the least understood and most poorly defined
education sector, facing also a status and image problem
… for far too long, Career and Technical Education has been
the neglected stepchild of education reform. That neglect has to
stop

… the need to re-imagine and remake career and technical
education is urgent

CTE has an enormous, if often overlooked impact on
students, school systems, and our ability to prosper as a nation
(Duncan, 2011)
Education Ministers of 31 European countries adopted the
Copenhagen Declaration on enhanced European cooperation in vocational
education and training (2002)

The Declaration (now known as the ‗Copenhagen Process‘) gives a
mandate to the European Commission to develop concrete actions in
the fields of transparency, recognition and quality in vocational
education and training (McBride, 2005)
   Explicit interest and investment in improving VET in the member
    states

   Emphasis on dual role of VET
    ◦ support of economic growth
    ◦ promotion of social cohesion by improving the employment and
      career prospects of everyone, from the most highly skilled to those
      with low levels of qualification (Bridge, 2010)
   Problems with quality of VET

   Diversity in responsibility for VET development, management and

    policy strategies at the national level

   EU Initiative to act as the coordinator of national initiatives and

    provide a comprehensive and convergent view, to complement and

    support national policies
Demand for new skills

Existing knowledge and competencies to be

   Widened

   Complemented                      through VET programs

   Upgraded
   A Cedefop publication


   A policy report evaluating progress achieved in European policy-
    making in the field since the beginning of the Copenhagen process


   Projects into the future how the new policy framework, Europe 2020,
    will underpin continuing reform in vocational education and training
    and lifelong learning in the next decade
Category 1: Mission
Category 2: Goals and Objectives
Category 3: Planning
Category 4: Administrative and Institutional Support
Category 5: Articulation with the Curriculum
Category 6: Collaboration
Category 7: Pedagogy
Category 8: Staffing
Category 9: Outreach
Category 10: Assessment/Evaluation (ACRL. Best practices, 2003)
A.   Institutional/Strategic Planning
     Documentation and policy issues

B.   Operational/Administrative Planning
     Leadership, Cooperation, Financial, Curricular, Marketing issues

C.   Implementation/Curriculum Planning and Development
     Information Literacy Programs, Staff involved, Assessment and
     evaluation methods (CAUL, 2004)
   OECD reviews the ways education supports integration of
    young people into the labor market

   Need for more and better data on the structure of VET in
    various countries

   Need for identification of ―best practices‖, i.e. models of where
    VET systems and the labor market work together to meet needs
    of students and employers (Gurría, 2007)
   Combine technical skills with problem-solving capabilities and
    communication and management skills

   Ensure that all TEIs focus on providing their students with flexible
    and transferable skills and competencies (OECD, for the knowledge
    society, 2011)
   Encourage employers to specify competencies for employment

   Encourage educational institutions to design programs to develop
    these competencies in students

   Ensure that students know what competencies they need in order to
    become employable

   Set up a qualifications framework to make transfers across fields of
    study and institutions more flexible

   Facilitate the assessment and recognition of prior learning
Australia
   In 1995 implementation of national framework for credit transfer
    between vocational and higher education systems
   In March 2007, country‘s elite institutions, signed a credit-transfer
    agreement permitting full transfer of credits among them
Great Britain
 England
   Credit-transfer arrangements in the form of regional articulation
    agreements involving just a few institutions
    Scotland and Wales
   Have nearly full credit-transferability within their borders
New Zealand

   Emphasis in credit-transferability has been to promote credit transfers
    within the higher-education system

USA
   Flexibility and openness cornerstone of postsecondary education system
   All states have tried to find ways to promote credit transfer between
    two- and four-year systems
   Transferability across state lines or between public and private
    institutions (whether in- or out-of-state) largely conducted ad hoc
Specific occupational skills needed - in professional, managerial
and technical jobs, in expanding fields such as health care, as well
as in traditional trades like electricians

Two projects:
◦ Learning for jobs—initial VET     www.oecd.org/edu/learningforjobs
◦ Skills beyond School— postsecondary level

(OECD. Policy reviews, 2010)
   Cross-country survey on adult skills (in 2011, results in 2013)
   Identify current skills of the labor force, and establish a benchmark
   Understand ways skills are acquired, enhanced or lost
   Coverage of general competencies
    ◦    Literacy
    ◦   Numeracy
    ◦   Ability to solve problems in technology-rich environments
   Will measure skills and competencies needed for individuals to
    participate in society and for economies to prosper
   Will help governments better understand how education and training
    systems can nurture these skills (PIAAC, 2008)
   Cross-country survey on adult skills (in 2011, results in 2013)
   Identify current skills of the labor force, and establish a benchmark
   Understand ways skills are acquired, enhanced or lost
   Coverage of general competencies
    ◦    Literacy
    ◦   Numeracy
    ◦   Ability to solve problems in technology-rich environments
   Will measure skills and competencies needed for individuals to
    participate in society and for economies to prosper
   Will help governments better understand how education and training
    systems can nurture these skills (PIAAC, 2008)
   Communication in mother tongue
   learning to learn
   communication in foreign languages
   social and civic competences
   competences in maths, science, technology
   sense of initiative and entrepreneurship
   digital competencies
   cultural awareness and expression (Bridge to the future, 2010)
   Computer literacy
   Information Technology (IT)/ Electronic Information Literacy
    (EIT)
   Library literacy
   Media literacy
   Network literacy/ Internet Literacy/ Hyper-Literacy
    Digital Literacy/ Digital Information Literacy (Bowden, 2001)
The skills and abilities for location, critical reception, assessment

and use of information and media in individuals‘ professional

and personal lives
Information fluency is achieved when computing skills

are combined with a knowledge of information, including

its many forms and sources, and critical thinking skills
(Associated Colleges of the South, 2007)
Ability [of individuals] to define problems in terms of their

information needs, and to apply a systematic approach to

search, locate, apply, and synthesize the information and evaluate

the entire process in terms of effectiveness and efficiency
(Business dictionary, 2009)
Information literate people will demonstrate an awareness of
how they gather, use, manage, synthesize and create information
and data in an ethical manner and will have the information skills
to do so effectively   (Sconul, 2011)
‗information literate people are those who have learned

how to learn because they know how knowledge is organized,

how to find information, and how to use information in a way

that others can learn from them‘ (Ford, 1991)
1.   define information literacy within the higher literacies and
     its importance to student performance, lifelong learning,
     and active citizenship;
2.   design one or more models for information literacy
     development appropriate to formal and informal learning
     environments throughout people's lifetimes; and
3.   determine implications for the continuing education and
     development of teachers
   emergence of the Information Age offers great challenges

   information expanding at unprecedented rate, rapid strides in
    technology for storing, organizing, and accessing the ever growing
    tidal wave of information

   …large components of which are only available to people with money
    and/or acceptable institutional affiliations

    shift in how we should teach and learn, how we should live and work
    in the 21st century

   3Rs alone – reading, writing, and arithmetic – no longer represent basic
    literacy skills needed by all to achieve educational and workplace
    success in this new millennium (ALA Final report, 1989)
   Need for information literacy skills great in today's work
    environment

   Efforts to "manage" knowledge increasingly necessary to keep a
    strategic advantage within a global market

   Business leaders calling for information literate workers (Breivik,
    2005)
Few executives yet know how to ask:
   What information do I need to do my job?
   When do I need it?
   In what form?
   And from whom should I be getting it?

    Fewer still ask:
   What new tasks can I tackle now that I have all this data?
   Which old tasks should I abandon?
   Which tasks should I do differently? (Drucker, 1992)
   In ascending order of complexity

   simple information skills – using a single information tool, e.g. a
    library catalog
   compound information skills – combining simple information
    skills/tools, e.g. preparing a bibliography by searching several
    databases
   complex/integrated information skills – making use of a variety
    of information networks, evaluating and repackaging
    information (Tuckett, 2001)
International Initiatives
… recognizes information literacy as ―a basic human right in the

digital world‖ as it empowers individuals ―in all walks of life to

seek, evaluate, use and create information effectively to achieve

their personal, social, occupational and educational goals”

(Alexandria proclamation, 2005)
   The creation of an Information Society is key to social, cultural and
    economic development of nations and communities, institutions and
    individuals in the 21st century and beyond.
   Information Literacy encompasses knowledge of one‘s information concerns
    and needs, and the ability to identify, locate, evaluate, organize and effectively
    create, use and communicate information to address issues or problems at
    hand; it is a prerequisite for participating effectively in the Information
    Society, and is part of the basic human right of life long learning
   Information Literacy, in conjunction with access to essential information and
    effective use of information and communication technologies, plays a leading
    role in reducing the inequities within and among countries and peoples, and
    in promoting tolerance and mutual understanding through information use in
    multicultural and multilingual contexts
   Governments should develop strong interdisciplinary programs to promote
    Information Literacy nationwide as a necessary step in closing the digital
    divide through the creation of an information literate citizenry, an effective
    civil society and a competitive workforce
   Information Literacy is a concern to all sectors of society and should be
    tailored by each to its specific needs and context
   Information Literacy should be an integral part of Education for All, which
    can contribute critically to the achievement of the United Nations
    Millennium Development Goals, and respect for the Universal Declaration of
    Human Rights
National Initiatives
―Rather than merely possessing data, we must also learn the
skills necessary to acquire, collate, and evaluate information for
any situation

This new type of literacy also requires competency with
communication technologies, including computers and mobile
devices that can help in our day-to-day decision making

National Information Literacy Awareness Month highlights the
need for all Americans to be adept in the skills necessary to
effectively navigate the Information Age‖ (Obama, 2009)
―Over the past decade, we have seen a crisis of authenticity
emerge. We now live in a world where anyone can publish an
opinion or perspective, whether true or not, and have that
opinion amplified within the information marketplace. At the
same time, Americans have unprecedented access to the diverse
and independent sources of information, as well as institutions
such as libraries and universities, that can help separate truth
from fiction and signal from noise‖ (Obama, 2009)
NOW, THEREFORE, I, BARACK OBAMA, President of the United
States of America, by virtue of the authority vested in me by the
Constitution and the laws of the United States, do hereby proclaim
October 2009 as National Information Literacy Awareness Month. I
call upon the people of the United States to recognize the important role
information plays in our daily lives, and appreciate the need for a greater
understanding of its impact
Both Associations foster lifelong learning and take initiatives to ensure that
  students at all educational levels prepared to meet challenges of 21st
  century

For both Associations Information Literacy skills are necessary for student
  success

Goals
 Promote the idea of Information Literacy
 Ensure the adequate preparation of trainers


Actions
 Committee on collaboration of university and K-12 librarians for the
  benefit of their constituencies (BluePrint, 1998)
Goals
 Achieve seamless continuation of AASL standards for IL to ACRL
  standards of IL
 Promote information literacy standards competency for higher
  education
 Develop specific information literacy performance indicators and
  measurable outcomes for education students
 Encourage ALISE members to include modules on IL in their
  programs
 Develop relationships with local school boards to create and promote
  information literacy programs for school librarians' continuing
  education
Students and Information Literacy
   Plagiarism is going social
   Legitimate educational sites are more popular than cheat sites
   15% of content matches, come directly from sites that promote
    and benefit from academic dishonesty
   Wikipedia is the most popular site for matched content
   Educators with the knowledge and tools can address the
    growing problem (Plagiarism and Web, 2011)
The top eight matched sites, along with their given category, are:
1) en.wikipedia.org - Encyclopedia
2) answers.yahoo.com – News & Portal
3) www.answers.com - Social & Content Sharing
4) www.slideshare.net - Social & Content Sharing
5) www.oppapers.com - Cheat Sites & Paper Mills
6) www.scribd.com - Social & Content Sharing
7) www.coursehero.com - Homework & Academic
8) www.medlibrary.org - Homework & Academic (Plagiarism and Web, 2011)
Head, Alison & Michael B. Eisenberg (2009). How College
 Students Seek Information in the Digital Age. The Information
 School, University of Washington.


  Project information literacy
  1. Progress report, no. 1: ―Lessons Learned‖ |

(http://projectinfolit.org/pdfs/PIL_Fall2009_Year1Report_12_2009.pdf)
The research group conducted research among 27,666 students of
     6 American universities, in April and May 2009
     2,318 responses were collected

Harvard University
Illinois State University
University of Washington
Chaffey Community College (CA)
Shoreline Community College (WA)
Volunteer State Community College (TN) (Head & Eisenberg, 2009)
   In general findings reveal that most students are not aware of the abundance
    of resources available to them

   Whether doing research for a course or for personal reasons almost all
    students developed a search strategy based on a limited number of common
    sources of information— close at hand, tried and true. Almost all of them
    relied at first on suggested readings and Google, for course research, or
    Google and Widipedia for addressing issues arising in their everyday lives

   The majority of students did not indicate any variations in frequency or order
    of use of these sources, regardless of their information goals or despite the
    plethora of other electronic sources or personal assistance existing (Head &
    Eisenberg, 2009)
   A significant number of students, when conducting research and
    finding information, leveraged scholarly sources and public
    Internet sites and favored brevity, consensus, and currency


   Findings indicate that students conceptualize research, especially
    information seeking, as a competency learned by rote, rather than as an
    opportunity to learn, develop, or expand upon an information-gathering
    strategy which leverages the wide range of resources available to them in
    the digital age (Head & Eisenberg, 2009)
Recommendation by researchers:

Students should be given course-related research assignments that
encourage the collection, analysis, and synthesis of
multiple viewpoints from a variety of sources, so the transfer of information
literacy and critical thinking competencies may be more actively called
up, practiced, and learned by students (Head & Eisenberg, 2009)
   Cannot read a citation
   Have difficulties in using a call number to locate a book on the shelf
   Do not know how to evaluate/think critically about sources
   Wikipedia their main/only source
   Little research experience beyond Google
   Have difficulties in selecting a proper research topic
   Have difficulties in identifying appropriate key words for searching
   Ignore plagiarism problems
   Information literacy not included in learning outcomes/assessment

   No experience with libraries-lack of school libraries

   Lack of resources or access to them

   Lack of professionals to educate them-librarians

   Untrained teachers or with dated research abilities

   Information Literary not among high priority skills
Information Literacy in
   Higher education
Association of College and Research Libraries, ACRL (2000).
Information literacy competency standards for higher education.

Retrieved from
http://www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/acrl/standards/informationlitera
cycompetency.cfm
Information Competencies for Higher Education


Standard I. The information competent student determines
the nature and extent of the information needed

Standard II. The information competent student accesses
needed information effectively and efficiently

Standard III. The information competent student evaluates
information and sources critically and incorporates selected
information into his or her knowledge base and value system.
Information Competencies for Higher Education


Standard IV. The information competent student, individually
or as a member of a group, uses information effectively to
accomplish a specific purpose

Standard V. The information competent student understands
many of the economic, legal, and social issues surrounding the
use of information and accesses and uses information ethically
and legally
I. The information competent student determines the
nature and extent of the information needed

POSSIBLE LEARNING OBJECTIVES/OUTCOMES |

                    ―Students will be able to …‖
• confer with the instructor and participate in class and work
  group discussions to identify a research topic or information
  need
• develop a thesis statement and formulate research questions
• explore background sources (encyclopedias, chronologies,
  handbooks, etc.) to increase familiarity with the topic
• review and revise the information need to achieve a
   manageable focus
I. The information competent student determines the
nature and extent of the information needed

POSSIBLE LEARNING OBJECTIVES/OUTCOMES

                    ―Students will be able to …‖
• identify key concepts and words that describe the research
  topic
• recognize that knowledge is organized into disciplines that
   influence the way in which information is accessed
• identify the purpose and audience of potential resources
  (e.g., popular versus scholarly, current versus historical)
• differentiate between primary and secondary sources,
   recognizing how their use and importance vary with each
   discipline
I. The information competent student determines the
nature and extent of the information needed
POSSIBLE LEARNING OBJECTIVES/OUTCOMES |

                   ―Students will be able to …‖
• recognize that information may need to be constructed
  using raw data from primary sources
• broaden the information seeking process beyond local
  resources when necessary by using resources at other
  locations or utilizing interlibrary loan services
• describe criteria used to make information decisions and
  choices
II. The information competent student accesses
              needed information effectively and efficiently


EXAMPLE (Maughan, 2010)

FROM STANDARD TO . . . .OBJECTIVE/OUTCOME TO . . . .            LEARNING ACTIVITIES

Standard II               Students will be able to identify    Students will be directed to the
                          and use controlled vocabulary        Library website and told to search
                          and terms specific to the discipline for books on a given topic.
                                                               They will be asked to report their
                                                               results and indicate the type of
                                                               search they performed and the
                                                               words they searched
Australian and New Zealand Information Literacy Framework:
    principles, standards and practice. 2n ed. Ed. By Alan
    Bundy. Adelaide: Australian and New Zealand Institute for
    Information Literacy, 2004.
Standard 1. The information literate person recognises the need for information and
   determines the nature and extent of the information needed
Standard 2. The information literate person finds needed information effectively and efficiently
Standard 3. The information literate person critically evaluates information and the
   information seeking process
Standard 4. The information literate person manages information collected or generated
Standard 5. The information literate person applies prior and new information to construct
   new concepts or create new understandings
Standard 6. The information literate person uses information with understanding and
   acknowledges cultural, ethical, economic, legal, and social issues surrounding the use of
   information
Society of College, National and University Libraries, SCONUL.
(2011). The Seven Pillars of Information Literacy. SCONUL Working
Group on Information Literacy

Accessed:
http://www.sconul.ac.uk/groups/information_literacy/publications/coremo
del.pdf
Management of Information Literacy
A mission statement for information literacy should be established by

educational authorities to ensure compatibility among various

institutions and adherence to international standards

Individual educational institutions might adopt this to specific needs

and conditions
Wartburg College. Vogel Library, Iowa
http://library.wartburg.edu/infolit/GenEdEvaulation2005.pdf

Vogel Library‘s mission is to educate information-literate
lifelong learners
   We believe that information literacy is so fundamental that it is an
    integral part of the academic experience in and out of the classroom
   We believe course-integrated instruction connected with a real
    academic need is more effective than stand-alone information literacy
    courses or disconnected tours and library orientations
   We believe in a planned curriculum with distinct, sequenced
    information literacy content that allows practice and reinforcement
    without duplication
   We believe that our information literacy instruction and any
    subsequent activity must help to achieve a faculty member‘s course
    objectives
   We believe that professors and students must be guided toward the
    understanding that the librarians‘ goals are interconnected with their
    own course goals and curricular needs

   Above all, we emphasize the teaching of concepts over skills as a
    means to achieve our information literacy mission of educating
    information-literate lifelong learners
   …of the mission of Library Services is to provide "instruction to promote
    information literacy and life-long learning"
   Students graduating from Austin Community College should be prepared to
    apply the information skills they learn as students to all aspects of their lives
    as citizens, family members, employees, and professionals
   Information literate students have transferable skills from their formal
    education they can use throughout life and as a means toward continued
    learning (http://library.austincc.edu/help/infolit/InfoLit-Overview.php )
   The mission of Palomar College Library/Media Center is to collaborate
    with all disciplines to empower and teach students to find, evaluate, and
    use information effectively

   We will collect, organize, and maintain information in all its formats to
    support the intellectual growth of students and the professional needs
    of our faculty (http://www.palomar.edu/library/libmission.htm)
We will strive to promote information literacy across campus with the purpose
of enhancing the pursuit of knowledge in all disciplines, requiring students to
think critically, and strengthening life-long learning skills. We will strive to
educate students, faculty, and other campus personnel to understand all
aspects of information literacy, including organization of information into
knowledge, and evaluation of all information in all forms. We will provide
resources and services in an environment that fosters independent thinking,
helping students to become confident in their skills to be used in their
professional and personal lives
(http://legacy.owensboro.kctcs.edu/library/infoliteracy.htm)
Factors to be considered
   Level and Educational goals of program
   Desired learning outcomes
   Adaptation of existing standards
    ◦ Tailored to the needs and background of recipients
    ◦ Content
    ◦ Teaching strategies: focus on learning, pedagogical
      issues, application of new technologies
    ◦ Assessment methods
Sections to be included
1. Introduction—definition of IL/IF, scope
2. History of similar efforts in institution
3. Goals and objectives of program
4. Body of the plan
5. Oversight
6. Methods of assessment
7. Timeline for implementation
8. Marketing plan (Burkhardt, 2005)
   Centre of expertise to support the development of VET and evidence
    based policy making

   Provides advice, research, analysis, information, stimulates European
    cooperation and common learning

   Works closely with the European
    Commission, governments, representatives of employers and trade
    unions, as well as with researchers and practitioners

   Cedefop shares its expertise through electronic and hard-copy
    publications, conferences and working groups
The mission of OECD is to promote policies that will improve
the economic and social well-being of people around the world
Education among its topics
   Pre school and school
   Higher education and adult learning
   Education, economy and society
   Human Capital
   Research and knowledge management
   The international organization responsible for drawing up and
    overseeing international labor standards.

   United Nations agency that brings together representatives of
    governments, employers and workers to jointly shape policies
    and programs promoting Decent Work for all

   Topic: Skills, knowledge and employability
The Center works to improve
 The engagement
 Achievement, and
 Transition of high school and postsecondary CTE students
Through technical assistance to
 States
 Professional development for CTE practitioners, and
 Dissemination of knowledge derived from scientifically based research
The largest national education association dedicated to the
advancement of education that prepares youth and adults for
careers
   The Foundation strives to help people achieve their potential by

    expanding access to and success in education beyond high school


   Tuning USA launches faculty-led process that will involve students and
    employers in linking college degrees to workplace relevance and
    students‘ mastery of agreed-upon learning objectives
Agencies (Information Literacy)
   Strengthening education systems
   Entrepreneurship Education
   Education should encompass both academic knowledge and practical skills to
    prepare young people for responsible citizenship and the world of work
   Fostering entrepreneurship attitudes and skills in secondary schools raises
    awareness of career opportunities, as well as of ways young people can
    contribute to the development and prosperity of their communities. It helps
    reduce youth vulnerability, social marginalization and poverty


   Themes: Information and Media Literacy
   Information Literacy Section (2002-     )

   Primary purpose to foster international cooperation in the
    development of information skills education in all types of libraries

   Action Plan, 2011-2012
    • Long-term strategy to implement and adapt concepts and programs of IL
    • Core curriculum within the National Information Society Policy
      Framework
    • Set of indicators to assess IL of population
Founding Members

   Australian and New Zealand Institute for Information Literacy (ANZIIL)
                         http://www.anziil.org/

   European Network on Information Literacy (EnIL) (European Union)
                http://www.ceris.cnr.it/Basili/EnIL/index.html

   National Forum on Information Literacy/NFIL (United States)
    http://www.infolit.org

   NORDINFOlit (Scandinavia)     http://www.nordinfolit.org

   SCONUL Advisory Committee on Information Literacy (United Kingdom)
    http://www.sconul.ac.uk/groups/information_literacy
Mission
   to promote information literacy at home and abroad
   to provide programmatic research and training activities to a broad
    spectrum of constituencies
Mission
    Dedicated to playing leadership role in assisting individuals and institutions in
    integrating information literacy throughout the full spectrum of the educational
    process

Goals
   Prepare librarians to become effective teachers of information literacy programs
   Support librarians and other educators and administrators in playing leadership
    roles in the development and implementation of information literacy programs
   Forge new relationships throughout the educational community to work towards
    information literacy curriculum development
   Offer opportunities for growth and development in the changing field of
    information literacy
ACRL Information Literacy website, The ACRL Information
Literacy Coordinating Committee's gateway to resources on
information literacy

http://www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/acrl/issues/infolit/index.cfm
http://www.ala.org/apps/primo/public/search.cfm

Promote & share peer-reviewed instructional materials
created by librarians to teach people about
discovering, accessing and evaluating information in
networked environments
http://ants.wetpaint.com
   International Journal of Vocational and Technical Education
   Journal of Education and Work
   Journal of Career and Technical Education
    (former title: Journal of Vocational and Technical Education)
   Journal of Vocational Education Research
   Journal of Vocational Education & Training
    http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals/titles/13636820.asp
   Vocational Education Journal
   Vocational Training: European Journal (information, full text some issues
    www.cedefop.eu.int/publications.asp
   Vocations and Learning                http://www.springerlink.com/content/120916/
   Communications in Information Literacy
    http://www.comminfolit.org/index.php/cil         (open access)
   Journal of Information Literacy
    http://jil.lboro.ac.uk/ojs/index.php/JIL/index   (open access)

   College & Research Libraries
   Community & Junior College Libraries
   Journal of Academic Librarianship
   Research Strategies                              (ceased publication)
   School Library Media Quarterly
   Necessity for improved and attractive VET
   Development of policies and strategies to advance lifelong learning
    opportunities for all at all levels
   Promote the creation of a new culture in educational
    institutions, which will support student involvement in the educational
    process
   Consensus on student learning outcomes
   Information literacy skills more important for VET
    students, considering their lower economic and social background
   Advocate, at various levels and to important stakeholders, the benefits
    of Information Literacy
   Associate Information Literacy skills with accreditation, assessment
    and employability
   Prepare, with selective faculty members, examples of course integrated
    information literacy programs
―International practice shows that, for successful development of an

IL education system, it is necessary to set unified state-level

standards, evaluation tools, and methodology. These components

could promote cooperation between the actors of IL and the

education system‖ (Krumina, 2011)
   Need for research to estimate information fluency of students
    ◦ Under-prepared students have little natural curiosity to explore ambiguous
      ideas that make them uncomfortable
    ◦ People who are less skilled at a task tend to overestimate their skill levels
    ◦ Less skilled people have difficulty recognizing that others have better skills
      than they do
    ◦ Although training helps improve skills, the less skilled are less likely to seek
      such training (Dunning-Kruger, 1999)

   Understand what students do to accomplish assignments

   Assist students progress from summarizing what they found to
    analysis and interpretation
   Establish a National Forum to serve as the National Focal Point for
    Information Literacy programs provided to every educational sector.
    Application of web 2.0 technologies will facilitate participation and
    communication.

   Establish a National Resource Center, which will include exemplary online
    tutorials, surveys, current news etc.

   Encourage faculty enhancement of own information literacy skills and
    involvement in IL programs

   Establish a Teaching & Learning Center, staffed with education
    experts, information technology professionals, discipline specialists and
    information scientists to support the development of information literacy
    programs

…it also backs the case for investing in education, even when other
areas of public spending are under pressure. ―Education is an essential
investment for responding to the changes in technology and
demographics that are re-shaping labor markets‖ (Gurría, 2010)
―Information should not be seen as mere capital to be accumulated,
bought, and sold, but instead, it should be seen as a means to
empower all people to make our world a better place… Without the
ability to command information, students will not only find themselves
left out of the information economy, they will find themselves unable
to have a voice in our society‖ (Swanson, 2005)

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

WSIS10 Reporting GESCI: A review of trends, gaps and priorities
WSIS10 Reporting GESCI: A review of trends, gaps and prioritiesWSIS10 Reporting GESCI: A review of trends, gaps and priorities
WSIS10 Reporting GESCI: A review of trends, gaps and prioritiesDr Lendy Spires
 
The educational sector within an ICT structured economy
The educational sector within an ICT structured economyThe educational sector within an ICT structured economy
The educational sector within an ICT structured economyMatthew Montebello
 
Challenges & Enablers of e-Learning Policy Implementation in Vocational Colle...
Challenges & Enablers of e-Learning Policy Implementation in Vocational Colle...Challenges & Enablers of e-Learning Policy Implementation in Vocational Colle...
Challenges & Enablers of e-Learning Policy Implementation in Vocational Colle...Gabriel Konayuma
 
Competency based education and training in technical
Competency based education and training in technical Competency based education and training in technical
Competency based education and training in technical Alexander Decker
 
Teachers’ perceptions on challenges faced by rural secondary schools in the i...
Teachers’ perceptions on challenges faced by rural secondary schools in the i...Teachers’ perceptions on challenges faced by rural secondary schools in the i...
Teachers’ perceptions on challenges faced by rural secondary schools in the i...Premier Publishers
 
eSkwela end of-project booklet - 2 pages per sheet
eSkwela end of-project booklet - 2 pages per sheeteSkwela end of-project booklet - 2 pages per sheet
eSkwela end of-project booklet - 2 pages per sheetMel Tan
 
Assessing the effect of information and communication technology on enhancing
Assessing the effect of information and communication technology on enhancingAssessing the effect of information and communication technology on enhancing
Assessing the effect of information and communication technology on enhancingIAEME Publication
 
Factors affecting school admin choices in adopting ict tools
Factors affecting school admin choices in adopting ict toolsFactors affecting school admin choices in adopting ict tools
Factors affecting school admin choices in adopting ict toolssyaabdulrahman
 
Successful implementation of tpack in teacher
Successful implementation of tpack in teacherSuccessful implementation of tpack in teacher
Successful implementation of tpack in teacherIJITE
 
Presentation: Higher Education in Pakistan: An ICT Integration Viewpoint
Presentation: Higher Education in Pakistan: An ICT Integration ViewpointPresentation: Higher Education in Pakistan: An ICT Integration Viewpoint
Presentation: Higher Education in Pakistan: An ICT Integration ViewpointZaffar Ahmed Shaikh
 
Powerpoint representation for professional studies
Powerpoint representation for professional studiesPowerpoint representation for professional studies
Powerpoint representation for professional studiesJoey Yona
 

Mais procurados (14)

WSIS10 Reporting GESCI: A review of trends, gaps and priorities
WSIS10 Reporting GESCI: A review of trends, gaps and prioritiesWSIS10 Reporting GESCI: A review of trends, gaps and priorities
WSIS10 Reporting GESCI: A review of trends, gaps and priorities
 
The educational sector within an ICT structured economy
The educational sector within an ICT structured economyThe educational sector within an ICT structured economy
The educational sector within an ICT structured economy
 
ICTs in education for people with disabilities
ICTs in education for people with disabilitiesICTs in education for people with disabilities
ICTs in education for people with disabilities
 
Challenges & Enablers of e-Learning Policy Implementation in Vocational Colle...
Challenges & Enablers of e-Learning Policy Implementation in Vocational Colle...Challenges & Enablers of e-Learning Policy Implementation in Vocational Colle...
Challenges & Enablers of e-Learning Policy Implementation in Vocational Colle...
 
Competency based education and training in technical
Competency based education and training in technical Competency based education and training in technical
Competency based education and training in technical
 
Teachers’ perceptions on challenges faced by rural secondary schools in the i...
Teachers’ perceptions on challenges faced by rural secondary schools in the i...Teachers’ perceptions on challenges faced by rural secondary schools in the i...
Teachers’ perceptions on challenges faced by rural secondary schools in the i...
 
eSkwela end of-project booklet - 2 pages per sheet
eSkwela end of-project booklet - 2 pages per sheeteSkwela end of-project booklet - 2 pages per sheet
eSkwela end of-project booklet - 2 pages per sheet
 
Assessing the effect of information and communication technology on enhancing
Assessing the effect of information and communication technology on enhancingAssessing the effect of information and communication technology on enhancing
Assessing the effect of information and communication technology on enhancing
 
Factors affecting school admin choices in adopting ict tools
Factors affecting school admin choices in adopting ict toolsFactors affecting school admin choices in adopting ict tools
Factors affecting school admin choices in adopting ict tools
 
Successful implementation of tpack in teacher
Successful implementation of tpack in teacherSuccessful implementation of tpack in teacher
Successful implementation of tpack in teacher
 
Academic ranking and Quality assurance in Online education
Academic ranking and Quality assurance in Online educationAcademic ranking and Quality assurance in Online education
Academic ranking and Quality assurance in Online education
 
Presentation: Higher Education in Pakistan: An ICT Integration Viewpoint
Presentation: Higher Education in Pakistan: An ICT Integration ViewpointPresentation: Higher Education in Pakistan: An ICT Integration Viewpoint
Presentation: Higher Education in Pakistan: An ICT Integration Viewpoint
 
Powerpoint representation for professional studies
Powerpoint representation for professional studiesPowerpoint representation for professional studies
Powerpoint representation for professional studies
 
Literasi 21
Literasi 21Literasi 21
Literasi 21
 

Semelhante a Vocationaleducationtraining 110609080939 Phpapp02

Vocational education & training
Vocational education & trainingVocational education & training
Vocational education & trainingEmpatic Project
 
Education for an Innovative Society
Education for an Innovative SocietyEducation for an Innovative Society
Education for an Innovative Societymaymayli
 
E Learning Presentation
E Learning PresentationE Learning Presentation
E Learning PresentationLBG
 
ISTE Standards-UNESCO ICT CFT whitepaper Jan 2015
ISTE Standards-UNESCO ICT CFT whitepaper Jan 2015ISTE Standards-UNESCO ICT CFT whitepaper Jan 2015
ISTE Standards-UNESCO ICT CFT whitepaper Jan 2015Carolyn Sykora
 
MAPEH technology initiatives
MAPEH technology initiativesMAPEH technology initiatives
MAPEH technology initiativesRia Buccat
 
MAPEH: technology initiatives
MAPEH: technology initiativesMAPEH: technology initiatives
MAPEH: technology initiativesRia Buccat
 
Directions for education sector reform
Directions for education sector reformDirections for education sector reform
Directions for education sector reformMohamed Bouanane
 
FOR PPT AND SCRIPT ON INTERNATIONAL PRESENTATION.docx
FOR PPT AND SCRIPT ON INTERNATIONAL PRESENTATION.docxFOR PPT AND SCRIPT ON INTERNATIONAL PRESENTATION.docx
FOR PPT AND SCRIPT ON INTERNATIONAL PRESENTATION.docxEDWINCFUEGO
 
How do we know if an Education Reform is Successful?
How do we know if an Education Reform is Successful?How do we know if an Education Reform is Successful?
How do we know if an Education Reform is Successful?CITE
 
Integrating ict as an integral teaching and learning tool into pre
Integrating ict as an integral teaching and learning tool into preIntegrating ict as an integral teaching and learning tool into pre
Integrating ict as an integral teaching and learning tool into presyed ahmed
 
Library Conference DoE talk
Library Conference DoE talkLibrary Conference DoE talk
Library Conference DoE talkMaggie Verster
 
Elearning And Pedagogy
Elearning And PedagogyElearning And Pedagogy
Elearning And Pedagogyruqayya
 
E-Learning and Pedagogy (2005)
E-Learning and Pedagogy (2005)E-Learning and Pedagogy (2005)
E-Learning and Pedagogy (2005)Wolfgang Greller
 
Challenges for innovation and educational change in low resourced settings: A...
Challenges for innovation and educational change in low resourced settings: A...Challenges for innovation and educational change in low resourced settings: A...
Challenges for innovation and educational change in low resourced settings: A...Beck Pitt
 
Chapter one effective use of information technology in education
Chapter one  effective use of information technology in education Chapter one  effective use of information technology in education
Chapter one effective use of information technology in education Abraham Rimven Pharm MHA PHD
 

Semelhante a Vocationaleducationtraining 110609080939 Phpapp02 (20)

Vocational education & training
Vocational education & trainingVocational education & training
Vocational education & training
 
Prof ass 1 final draft 1
Prof ass 1 final draft 1Prof ass 1 final draft 1
Prof ass 1 final draft 1
 
Unesco ict competency framework for teachers by pratima nayak
Unesco ict competency framework for teachers by pratima nayakUnesco ict competency framework for teachers by pratima nayak
Unesco ict competency framework for teachers by pratima nayak
 
Education for an Innovative Society
Education for an Innovative SocietyEducation for an Innovative Society
Education for an Innovative Society
 
E Learning Presentation
E Learning PresentationE Learning Presentation
E Learning Presentation
 
ISTE Standards-UNESCO ICT CFT whitepaper Jan 2015
ISTE Standards-UNESCO ICT CFT whitepaper Jan 2015ISTE Standards-UNESCO ICT CFT whitepaper Jan 2015
ISTE Standards-UNESCO ICT CFT whitepaper Jan 2015
 
MAPEH technology initiatives
MAPEH technology initiativesMAPEH technology initiatives
MAPEH technology initiatives
 
MAPEH: technology initiatives
MAPEH: technology initiativesMAPEH: technology initiatives
MAPEH: technology initiatives
 
Directions for education sector reform
Directions for education sector reformDirections for education sector reform
Directions for education sector reform
 
FOR PPT AND SCRIPT ON INTERNATIONAL PRESENTATION.docx
FOR PPT AND SCRIPT ON INTERNATIONAL PRESENTATION.docxFOR PPT AND SCRIPT ON INTERNATIONAL PRESENTATION.docx
FOR PPT AND SCRIPT ON INTERNATIONAL PRESENTATION.docx
 
How do we know if an Education Reform is Successful?
How do we know if an Education Reform is Successful?How do we know if an Education Reform is Successful?
How do we know if an Education Reform is Successful?
 
Assignment no 1
Assignment no 1Assignment no 1
Assignment no 1
 
Integrating ict as an integral teaching and learning tool into pre
Integrating ict as an integral teaching and learning tool into preIntegrating ict as an integral teaching and learning tool into pre
Integrating ict as an integral teaching and learning tool into pre
 
Library Conference DoE talk
Library Conference DoE talkLibrary Conference DoE talk
Library Conference DoE talk
 
Elearning And Pedagogy
Elearning And PedagogyElearning And Pedagogy
Elearning And Pedagogy
 
E-Learning and Pedagogy (2005)
E-Learning and Pedagogy (2005)E-Learning and Pedagogy (2005)
E-Learning and Pedagogy (2005)
 
EMERGING TRENDS IN TVET
EMERGING TRENDS IN TVETEMERGING TRENDS IN TVET
EMERGING TRENDS IN TVET
 
Challenges for innovation and educational change in low resourced settings: A...
Challenges for innovation and educational change in low resourced settings: A...Challenges for innovation and educational change in low resourced settings: A...
Challenges for innovation and educational change in low resourced settings: A...
 
Chapter one effective use of information technology in education
Chapter one  effective use of information technology in education Chapter one  effective use of information technology in education
Chapter one effective use of information technology in education
 
Paper
PaperPaper
Paper
 

Vocationaleducationtraining 110609080939 Phpapp02

  • 1. Vocational Education & Training Are students prepared for information fluency? Mersini Moreleli-Cacouris Dept. of Library Science and Information Systems Alexander TEI of Thessaloniki, Greece
  • 2.  The preparation of independent individuals, who can  think critically and creatively  act as informed and responsible professionals and citizens  develop their aesthetic awareness  The acquisition of knowledge and skills, that will enable them to:  to adopt and apply them to any environment  to enhance them continuously  The development of a lifelong relationship with learning
  • 3. ―… [any academic institution‘s] purpose is not to transfer knowledge but to create environments and experiences that bring students to discover and construct knowledge for themselves, to make students members of communities of learners that make discoveries and solve problems. The college aims, in fact, to create a series of ever more powerful learning environments‖ (Barr & Tagg, 1995)
  • 4. ―Critical thinking is not a new concept or concern in academic institutions. On the contrary, it has long been a major objective of higher education. However, the need to "cover the subject" has assumed precedence for some instructors, and many concentrate more on delivering facts and subject content than on instilling methodological or analytical skills. With a virtually unmanageable but still growing level of information now available on most topics, it is time for students to return to the most important aspect of learning: mastering thinking skills requisite to proper use of the information at their disposal.‖ (Engeldinger, 1988)
  • 5.
  • 6. Vocational Education & Training (VET) EU, CEDEFOP  Technical and Vocational Education and UNESCO Training (TVET) Technical and Further Education (TAFE) or Australia  Vocational and Technical Education (VTE) Further Education United Kingdom Career and Technical Education (CTE) USA
  • 7. Aimed at imparting skills for the labor market, at a sub-professional level Most diverse education sector, delivered in both the classroom and the workplace, and organized in a variety of ways internationally A cornerstone is the apprenticeship – combining formal education with on-the-job experience – but also delivered in schools and tertiary educational institutions (Karmel, 2010, p. 229)
  • 8. Institutional arrangements of vocational education complex (with industry playing an important role) Approach to teaching and learning distinctive (and contested) Expectations by the community demanding, with it being seen as the education sector best positioned to deal with social disadvantage and addressing issues of equity in many countries (VET offering second- chance education) The VET sector is the least understood and most poorly defined education sector, facing also a status and image problem
  • 9. … for far too long, Career and Technical Education has been the neglected stepchild of education reform. That neglect has to stop … the need to re-imagine and remake career and technical education is urgent CTE has an enormous, if often overlooked impact on students, school systems, and our ability to prosper as a nation (Duncan, 2011)
  • 10. Education Ministers of 31 European countries adopted the Copenhagen Declaration on enhanced European cooperation in vocational education and training (2002) The Declaration (now known as the ‗Copenhagen Process‘) gives a mandate to the European Commission to develop concrete actions in the fields of transparency, recognition and quality in vocational education and training (McBride, 2005)
  • 11. Explicit interest and investment in improving VET in the member states  Emphasis on dual role of VET ◦ support of economic growth ◦ promotion of social cohesion by improving the employment and career prospects of everyone, from the most highly skilled to those with low levels of qualification (Bridge, 2010)
  • 12. Problems with quality of VET  Diversity in responsibility for VET development, management and policy strategies at the national level  EU Initiative to act as the coordinator of national initiatives and provide a comprehensive and convergent view, to complement and support national policies
  • 13. Demand for new skills Existing knowledge and competencies to be  Widened  Complemented through VET programs  Upgraded
  • 14. A Cedefop publication  A policy report evaluating progress achieved in European policy- making in the field since the beginning of the Copenhagen process  Projects into the future how the new policy framework, Europe 2020, will underpin continuing reform in vocational education and training and lifelong learning in the next decade
  • 15. Category 1: Mission Category 2: Goals and Objectives Category 3: Planning Category 4: Administrative and Institutional Support Category 5: Articulation with the Curriculum Category 6: Collaboration Category 7: Pedagogy Category 8: Staffing Category 9: Outreach Category 10: Assessment/Evaluation (ACRL. Best practices, 2003)
  • 16. A. Institutional/Strategic Planning Documentation and policy issues B. Operational/Administrative Planning Leadership, Cooperation, Financial, Curricular, Marketing issues C. Implementation/Curriculum Planning and Development Information Literacy Programs, Staff involved, Assessment and evaluation methods (CAUL, 2004)
  • 17. OECD reviews the ways education supports integration of young people into the labor market  Need for more and better data on the structure of VET in various countries  Need for identification of ―best practices‖, i.e. models of where VET systems and the labor market work together to meet needs of students and employers (Gurría, 2007)
  • 18. Combine technical skills with problem-solving capabilities and communication and management skills  Ensure that all TEIs focus on providing their students with flexible and transferable skills and competencies (OECD, for the knowledge society, 2011)
  • 19. Encourage employers to specify competencies for employment  Encourage educational institutions to design programs to develop these competencies in students  Ensure that students know what competencies they need in order to become employable  Set up a qualifications framework to make transfers across fields of study and institutions more flexible  Facilitate the assessment and recognition of prior learning
  • 20. Australia  In 1995 implementation of national framework for credit transfer between vocational and higher education systems  In March 2007, country‘s elite institutions, signed a credit-transfer agreement permitting full transfer of credits among them Great Britain England  Credit-transfer arrangements in the form of regional articulation agreements involving just a few institutions Scotland and Wales  Have nearly full credit-transferability within their borders
  • 21. New Zealand  Emphasis in credit-transferability has been to promote credit transfers within the higher-education system USA  Flexibility and openness cornerstone of postsecondary education system  All states have tried to find ways to promote credit transfer between two- and four-year systems  Transferability across state lines or between public and private institutions (whether in- or out-of-state) largely conducted ad hoc
  • 22. Specific occupational skills needed - in professional, managerial and technical jobs, in expanding fields such as health care, as well as in traditional trades like electricians Two projects: ◦ Learning for jobs—initial VET www.oecd.org/edu/learningforjobs ◦ Skills beyond School— postsecondary level (OECD. Policy reviews, 2010)
  • 23. Cross-country survey on adult skills (in 2011, results in 2013)  Identify current skills of the labor force, and establish a benchmark  Understand ways skills are acquired, enhanced or lost  Coverage of general competencies ◦ Literacy ◦ Numeracy ◦ Ability to solve problems in technology-rich environments  Will measure skills and competencies needed for individuals to participate in society and for economies to prosper  Will help governments better understand how education and training systems can nurture these skills (PIAAC, 2008)
  • 24. Cross-country survey on adult skills (in 2011, results in 2013)  Identify current skills of the labor force, and establish a benchmark  Understand ways skills are acquired, enhanced or lost  Coverage of general competencies ◦ Literacy ◦ Numeracy ◦ Ability to solve problems in technology-rich environments  Will measure skills and competencies needed for individuals to participate in society and for economies to prosper  Will help governments better understand how education and training systems can nurture these skills (PIAAC, 2008)
  • 25. Communication in mother tongue  learning to learn  communication in foreign languages  social and civic competences  competences in maths, science, technology  sense of initiative and entrepreneurship  digital competencies  cultural awareness and expression (Bridge to the future, 2010)
  • 26. Computer literacy  Information Technology (IT)/ Electronic Information Literacy (EIT)  Library literacy  Media literacy  Network literacy/ Internet Literacy/ Hyper-Literacy  Digital Literacy/ Digital Information Literacy (Bowden, 2001)
  • 27. The skills and abilities for location, critical reception, assessment and use of information and media in individuals‘ professional and personal lives
  • 28. Information fluency is achieved when computing skills are combined with a knowledge of information, including its many forms and sources, and critical thinking skills (Associated Colleges of the South, 2007)
  • 29. Ability [of individuals] to define problems in terms of their information needs, and to apply a systematic approach to search, locate, apply, and synthesize the information and evaluate the entire process in terms of effectiveness and efficiency (Business dictionary, 2009)
  • 30. Information literate people will demonstrate an awareness of how they gather, use, manage, synthesize and create information and data in an ethical manner and will have the information skills to do so effectively (Sconul, 2011)
  • 31. ‗information literate people are those who have learned how to learn because they know how knowledge is organized, how to find information, and how to use information in a way that others can learn from them‘ (Ford, 1991)
  • 32. 1. define information literacy within the higher literacies and its importance to student performance, lifelong learning, and active citizenship; 2. design one or more models for information literacy development appropriate to formal and informal learning environments throughout people's lifetimes; and 3. determine implications for the continuing education and development of teachers
  • 33. emergence of the Information Age offers great challenges  information expanding at unprecedented rate, rapid strides in technology for storing, organizing, and accessing the ever growing tidal wave of information  …large components of which are only available to people with money and/or acceptable institutional affiliations  shift in how we should teach and learn, how we should live and work in the 21st century  3Rs alone – reading, writing, and arithmetic – no longer represent basic literacy skills needed by all to achieve educational and workplace success in this new millennium (ALA Final report, 1989)
  • 34. Need for information literacy skills great in today's work environment  Efforts to "manage" knowledge increasingly necessary to keep a strategic advantage within a global market  Business leaders calling for information literate workers (Breivik, 2005)
  • 35. Few executives yet know how to ask:  What information do I need to do my job?  When do I need it?  In what form?  And from whom should I be getting it? Fewer still ask:  What new tasks can I tackle now that I have all this data?  Which old tasks should I abandon?  Which tasks should I do differently? (Drucker, 1992)
  • 36. In ascending order of complexity  simple information skills – using a single information tool, e.g. a library catalog  compound information skills – combining simple information skills/tools, e.g. preparing a bibliography by searching several databases  complex/integrated information skills – making use of a variety of information networks, evaluating and repackaging information (Tuckett, 2001)
  • 38. … recognizes information literacy as ―a basic human right in the digital world‖ as it empowers individuals ―in all walks of life to seek, evaluate, use and create information effectively to achieve their personal, social, occupational and educational goals” (Alexandria proclamation, 2005)
  • 39. The creation of an Information Society is key to social, cultural and economic development of nations and communities, institutions and individuals in the 21st century and beyond.  Information Literacy encompasses knowledge of one‘s information concerns and needs, and the ability to identify, locate, evaluate, organize and effectively create, use and communicate information to address issues or problems at hand; it is a prerequisite for participating effectively in the Information Society, and is part of the basic human right of life long learning  Information Literacy, in conjunction with access to essential information and effective use of information and communication technologies, plays a leading role in reducing the inequities within and among countries and peoples, and in promoting tolerance and mutual understanding through information use in multicultural and multilingual contexts
  • 40. Governments should develop strong interdisciplinary programs to promote Information Literacy nationwide as a necessary step in closing the digital divide through the creation of an information literate citizenry, an effective civil society and a competitive workforce  Information Literacy is a concern to all sectors of society and should be tailored by each to its specific needs and context  Information Literacy should be an integral part of Education for All, which can contribute critically to the achievement of the United Nations Millennium Development Goals, and respect for the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
  • 42.
  • 43. ―Rather than merely possessing data, we must also learn the skills necessary to acquire, collate, and evaluate information for any situation This new type of literacy also requires competency with communication technologies, including computers and mobile devices that can help in our day-to-day decision making National Information Literacy Awareness Month highlights the need for all Americans to be adept in the skills necessary to effectively navigate the Information Age‖ (Obama, 2009)
  • 44. ―Over the past decade, we have seen a crisis of authenticity emerge. We now live in a world where anyone can publish an opinion or perspective, whether true or not, and have that opinion amplified within the information marketplace. At the same time, Americans have unprecedented access to the diverse and independent sources of information, as well as institutions such as libraries and universities, that can help separate truth from fiction and signal from noise‖ (Obama, 2009)
  • 45. NOW, THEREFORE, I, BARACK OBAMA, President of the United States of America, by virtue of the authority vested in me by the Constitution and the laws of the United States, do hereby proclaim October 2009 as National Information Literacy Awareness Month. I call upon the people of the United States to recognize the important role information plays in our daily lives, and appreciate the need for a greater understanding of its impact
  • 46. Both Associations foster lifelong learning and take initiatives to ensure that students at all educational levels prepared to meet challenges of 21st century For both Associations Information Literacy skills are necessary for student success Goals  Promote the idea of Information Literacy  Ensure the adequate preparation of trainers Actions  Committee on collaboration of university and K-12 librarians for the benefit of their constituencies (BluePrint, 1998)
  • 47. Goals  Achieve seamless continuation of AASL standards for IL to ACRL standards of IL  Promote information literacy standards competency for higher education  Develop specific information literacy performance indicators and measurable outcomes for education students  Encourage ALISE members to include modules on IL in their programs  Develop relationships with local school boards to create and promote information literacy programs for school librarians' continuing education
  • 49. Plagiarism is going social  Legitimate educational sites are more popular than cheat sites  15% of content matches, come directly from sites that promote and benefit from academic dishonesty  Wikipedia is the most popular site for matched content  Educators with the knowledge and tools can address the growing problem (Plagiarism and Web, 2011)
  • 50. The top eight matched sites, along with their given category, are: 1) en.wikipedia.org - Encyclopedia 2) answers.yahoo.com – News & Portal 3) www.answers.com - Social & Content Sharing 4) www.slideshare.net - Social & Content Sharing 5) www.oppapers.com - Cheat Sites & Paper Mills 6) www.scribd.com - Social & Content Sharing 7) www.coursehero.com - Homework & Academic 8) www.medlibrary.org - Homework & Academic (Plagiarism and Web, 2011)
  • 51. Head, Alison & Michael B. Eisenberg (2009). How College Students Seek Information in the Digital Age. The Information School, University of Washington. Project information literacy 1. Progress report, no. 1: ―Lessons Learned‖ | (http://projectinfolit.org/pdfs/PIL_Fall2009_Year1Report_12_2009.pdf)
  • 52. The research group conducted research among 27,666 students of 6 American universities, in April and May 2009 2,318 responses were collected Harvard University Illinois State University University of Washington Chaffey Community College (CA) Shoreline Community College (WA) Volunteer State Community College (TN) (Head & Eisenberg, 2009)
  • 53. In general findings reveal that most students are not aware of the abundance of resources available to them  Whether doing research for a course or for personal reasons almost all students developed a search strategy based on a limited number of common sources of information— close at hand, tried and true. Almost all of them relied at first on suggested readings and Google, for course research, or Google and Widipedia for addressing issues arising in their everyday lives  The majority of students did not indicate any variations in frequency or order of use of these sources, regardless of their information goals or despite the plethora of other electronic sources or personal assistance existing (Head & Eisenberg, 2009)
  • 54. A significant number of students, when conducting research and finding information, leveraged scholarly sources and public Internet sites and favored brevity, consensus, and currency  Findings indicate that students conceptualize research, especially information seeking, as a competency learned by rote, rather than as an opportunity to learn, develop, or expand upon an information-gathering strategy which leverages the wide range of resources available to them in the digital age (Head & Eisenberg, 2009)
  • 55. Recommendation by researchers: Students should be given course-related research assignments that encourage the collection, analysis, and synthesis of multiple viewpoints from a variety of sources, so the transfer of information literacy and critical thinking competencies may be more actively called up, practiced, and learned by students (Head & Eisenberg, 2009)
  • 56. Cannot read a citation  Have difficulties in using a call number to locate a book on the shelf  Do not know how to evaluate/think critically about sources  Wikipedia their main/only source  Little research experience beyond Google  Have difficulties in selecting a proper research topic  Have difficulties in identifying appropriate key words for searching  Ignore plagiarism problems
  • 57. Information literacy not included in learning outcomes/assessment  No experience with libraries-lack of school libraries  Lack of resources or access to them  Lack of professionals to educate them-librarians  Untrained teachers or with dated research abilities  Information Literary not among high priority skills
  • 58. Information Literacy in Higher education
  • 59. Association of College and Research Libraries, ACRL (2000). Information literacy competency standards for higher education. Retrieved from http://www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/acrl/standards/informationlitera cycompetency.cfm
  • 60. Information Competencies for Higher Education Standard I. The information competent student determines the nature and extent of the information needed Standard II. The information competent student accesses needed information effectively and efficiently Standard III. The information competent student evaluates information and sources critically and incorporates selected information into his or her knowledge base and value system.
  • 61. Information Competencies for Higher Education Standard IV. The information competent student, individually or as a member of a group, uses information effectively to accomplish a specific purpose Standard V. The information competent student understands many of the economic, legal, and social issues surrounding the use of information and accesses and uses information ethically and legally
  • 62. I. The information competent student determines the nature and extent of the information needed POSSIBLE LEARNING OBJECTIVES/OUTCOMES | ―Students will be able to …‖ • confer with the instructor and participate in class and work group discussions to identify a research topic or information need • develop a thesis statement and formulate research questions • explore background sources (encyclopedias, chronologies, handbooks, etc.) to increase familiarity with the topic • review and revise the information need to achieve a manageable focus
  • 63. I. The information competent student determines the nature and extent of the information needed POSSIBLE LEARNING OBJECTIVES/OUTCOMES ―Students will be able to …‖ • identify key concepts and words that describe the research topic • recognize that knowledge is organized into disciplines that influence the way in which information is accessed • identify the purpose and audience of potential resources (e.g., popular versus scholarly, current versus historical) • differentiate between primary and secondary sources, recognizing how their use and importance vary with each discipline
  • 64. I. The information competent student determines the nature and extent of the information needed POSSIBLE LEARNING OBJECTIVES/OUTCOMES | ―Students will be able to …‖ • recognize that information may need to be constructed using raw data from primary sources • broaden the information seeking process beyond local resources when necessary by using resources at other locations or utilizing interlibrary loan services • describe criteria used to make information decisions and choices
  • 65. II. The information competent student accesses needed information effectively and efficiently EXAMPLE (Maughan, 2010) FROM STANDARD TO . . . .OBJECTIVE/OUTCOME TO . . . . LEARNING ACTIVITIES Standard II Students will be able to identify Students will be directed to the and use controlled vocabulary Library website and told to search and terms specific to the discipline for books on a given topic. They will be asked to report their results and indicate the type of search they performed and the words they searched
  • 66. Australian and New Zealand Information Literacy Framework: principles, standards and practice. 2n ed. Ed. By Alan Bundy. Adelaide: Australian and New Zealand Institute for Information Literacy, 2004.
  • 67. Standard 1. The information literate person recognises the need for information and determines the nature and extent of the information needed Standard 2. The information literate person finds needed information effectively and efficiently Standard 3. The information literate person critically evaluates information and the information seeking process Standard 4. The information literate person manages information collected or generated Standard 5. The information literate person applies prior and new information to construct new concepts or create new understandings Standard 6. The information literate person uses information with understanding and acknowledges cultural, ethical, economic, legal, and social issues surrounding the use of information
  • 68. Society of College, National and University Libraries, SCONUL. (2011). The Seven Pillars of Information Literacy. SCONUL Working Group on Information Literacy Accessed: http://www.sconul.ac.uk/groups/information_literacy/publications/coremo del.pdf
  • 69.
  • 71. A mission statement for information literacy should be established by educational authorities to ensure compatibility among various institutions and adherence to international standards Individual educational institutions might adopt this to specific needs and conditions
  • 72. Wartburg College. Vogel Library, Iowa http://library.wartburg.edu/infolit/GenEdEvaulation2005.pdf Vogel Library‘s mission is to educate information-literate lifelong learners
  • 73. We believe that information literacy is so fundamental that it is an integral part of the academic experience in and out of the classroom  We believe course-integrated instruction connected with a real academic need is more effective than stand-alone information literacy courses or disconnected tours and library orientations  We believe in a planned curriculum with distinct, sequenced information literacy content that allows practice and reinforcement without duplication  We believe that our information literacy instruction and any subsequent activity must help to achieve a faculty member‘s course objectives
  • 74. We believe that professors and students must be guided toward the understanding that the librarians‘ goals are interconnected with their own course goals and curricular needs  Above all, we emphasize the teaching of concepts over skills as a means to achieve our information literacy mission of educating information-literate lifelong learners
  • 75.
  • 76. …of the mission of Library Services is to provide "instruction to promote information literacy and life-long learning"  Students graduating from Austin Community College should be prepared to apply the information skills they learn as students to all aspects of their lives as citizens, family members, employees, and professionals  Information literate students have transferable skills from their formal education they can use throughout life and as a means toward continued learning (http://library.austincc.edu/help/infolit/InfoLit-Overview.php )
  • 77. The mission of Palomar College Library/Media Center is to collaborate with all disciplines to empower and teach students to find, evaluate, and use information effectively  We will collect, organize, and maintain information in all its formats to support the intellectual growth of students and the professional needs of our faculty (http://www.palomar.edu/library/libmission.htm)
  • 78. We will strive to promote information literacy across campus with the purpose of enhancing the pursuit of knowledge in all disciplines, requiring students to think critically, and strengthening life-long learning skills. We will strive to educate students, faculty, and other campus personnel to understand all aspects of information literacy, including organization of information into knowledge, and evaluation of all information in all forms. We will provide resources and services in an environment that fosters independent thinking, helping students to become confident in their skills to be used in their professional and personal lives (http://legacy.owensboro.kctcs.edu/library/infoliteracy.htm)
  • 79. Factors to be considered  Level and Educational goals of program  Desired learning outcomes  Adaptation of existing standards ◦ Tailored to the needs and background of recipients ◦ Content ◦ Teaching strategies: focus on learning, pedagogical issues, application of new technologies ◦ Assessment methods
  • 80. Sections to be included 1. Introduction—definition of IL/IF, scope 2. History of similar efforts in institution 3. Goals and objectives of program 4. Body of the plan 5. Oversight 6. Methods of assessment 7. Timeline for implementation 8. Marketing plan (Burkhardt, 2005)
  • 81.
  • 82. Centre of expertise to support the development of VET and evidence based policy making  Provides advice, research, analysis, information, stimulates European cooperation and common learning  Works closely with the European Commission, governments, representatives of employers and trade unions, as well as with researchers and practitioners  Cedefop shares its expertise through electronic and hard-copy publications, conferences and working groups
  • 83. The mission of OECD is to promote policies that will improve the economic and social well-being of people around the world Education among its topics Pre school and school Higher education and adult learning Education, economy and society Human Capital Research and knowledge management
  • 84. The international organization responsible for drawing up and overseeing international labor standards.  United Nations agency that brings together representatives of governments, employers and workers to jointly shape policies and programs promoting Decent Work for all  Topic: Skills, knowledge and employability
  • 85. The Center works to improve  The engagement  Achievement, and  Transition of high school and postsecondary CTE students Through technical assistance to  States  Professional development for CTE practitioners, and  Dissemination of knowledge derived from scientifically based research
  • 86. The largest national education association dedicated to the advancement of education that prepares youth and adults for careers
  • 87. The Foundation strives to help people achieve their potential by expanding access to and success in education beyond high school  Tuning USA launches faculty-led process that will involve students and employers in linking college degrees to workplace relevance and students‘ mastery of agreed-upon learning objectives
  • 89. Strengthening education systems  Entrepreneurship Education  Education should encompass both academic knowledge and practical skills to prepare young people for responsible citizenship and the world of work  Fostering entrepreneurship attitudes and skills in secondary schools raises awareness of career opportunities, as well as of ways young people can contribute to the development and prosperity of their communities. It helps reduce youth vulnerability, social marginalization and poverty  Themes: Information and Media Literacy
  • 90. Information Literacy Section (2002- )  Primary purpose to foster international cooperation in the development of information skills education in all types of libraries  Action Plan, 2011-2012 • Long-term strategy to implement and adapt concepts and programs of IL • Core curriculum within the National Information Society Policy Framework • Set of indicators to assess IL of population
  • 91. Founding Members  Australian and New Zealand Institute for Information Literacy (ANZIIL) http://www.anziil.org/  European Network on Information Literacy (EnIL) (European Union) http://www.ceris.cnr.it/Basili/EnIL/index.html  National Forum on Information Literacy/NFIL (United States) http://www.infolit.org  NORDINFOlit (Scandinavia) http://www.nordinfolit.org  SCONUL Advisory Committee on Information Literacy (United Kingdom) http://www.sconul.ac.uk/groups/information_literacy
  • 92. Mission  to promote information literacy at home and abroad  to provide programmatic research and training activities to a broad spectrum of constituencies
  • 93. Mission Dedicated to playing leadership role in assisting individuals and institutions in integrating information literacy throughout the full spectrum of the educational process Goals  Prepare librarians to become effective teachers of information literacy programs  Support librarians and other educators and administrators in playing leadership roles in the development and implementation of information literacy programs  Forge new relationships throughout the educational community to work towards information literacy curriculum development  Offer opportunities for growth and development in the changing field of information literacy
  • 94. ACRL Information Literacy website, The ACRL Information Literacy Coordinating Committee's gateway to resources on information literacy http://www.ala.org/ala/mgrps/divs/acrl/issues/infolit/index.cfm
  • 95. http://www.ala.org/apps/primo/public/search.cfm Promote & share peer-reviewed instructional materials created by librarians to teach people about discovering, accessing and evaluating information in networked environments
  • 97. International Journal of Vocational and Technical Education  Journal of Education and Work  Journal of Career and Technical Education (former title: Journal of Vocational and Technical Education)  Journal of Vocational Education Research  Journal of Vocational Education & Training http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals/titles/13636820.asp  Vocational Education Journal  Vocational Training: European Journal (information, full text some issues www.cedefop.eu.int/publications.asp  Vocations and Learning http://www.springerlink.com/content/120916/
  • 98. Communications in Information Literacy http://www.comminfolit.org/index.php/cil (open access)  Journal of Information Literacy http://jil.lboro.ac.uk/ojs/index.php/JIL/index (open access)  College & Research Libraries  Community & Junior College Libraries  Journal of Academic Librarianship  Research Strategies (ceased publication)  School Library Media Quarterly
  • 99. Necessity for improved and attractive VET  Development of policies and strategies to advance lifelong learning opportunities for all at all levels  Promote the creation of a new culture in educational institutions, which will support student involvement in the educational process  Consensus on student learning outcomes
  • 100. Information literacy skills more important for VET students, considering their lower economic and social background  Advocate, at various levels and to important stakeholders, the benefits of Information Literacy  Associate Information Literacy skills with accreditation, assessment and employability  Prepare, with selective faculty members, examples of course integrated information literacy programs
  • 101. ―International practice shows that, for successful development of an IL education system, it is necessary to set unified state-level standards, evaluation tools, and methodology. These components could promote cooperation between the actors of IL and the education system‖ (Krumina, 2011)
  • 102. Need for research to estimate information fluency of students ◦ Under-prepared students have little natural curiosity to explore ambiguous ideas that make them uncomfortable ◦ People who are less skilled at a task tend to overestimate their skill levels ◦ Less skilled people have difficulty recognizing that others have better skills than they do ◦ Although training helps improve skills, the less skilled are less likely to seek such training (Dunning-Kruger, 1999)  Understand what students do to accomplish assignments  Assist students progress from summarizing what they found to analysis and interpretation
  • 103. Establish a National Forum to serve as the National Focal Point for Information Literacy programs provided to every educational sector. Application of web 2.0 technologies will facilitate participation and communication.  Establish a National Resource Center, which will include exemplary online tutorials, surveys, current news etc.  Encourage faculty enhancement of own information literacy skills and involvement in IL programs  Establish a Teaching & Learning Center, staffed with education experts, information technology professionals, discipline specialists and information scientists to support the development of information literacy programs 
  • 104. …it also backs the case for investing in education, even when other areas of public spending are under pressure. ―Education is an essential investment for responding to the changes in technology and demographics that are re-shaping labor markets‖ (Gurría, 2010)
  • 105. ―Information should not be seen as mere capital to be accumulated, bought, and sold, but instead, it should be seen as a means to empower all people to make our world a better place… Without the ability to command information, students will not only find themselves left out of the information economy, they will find themselves unable to have a voice in our society‖ (Swanson, 2005)