SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 61
Download to read offline
HEALTHY SCHOOLS
                      ARCH 730; Fall 2012
                      The Environmental Psychology of Health & Well‐Being
                      Wescoe 1007 Thurs 7:10 9:00pm
                               1007 Thurs 7:10‐9:00pm
                      Instructor: Keith Diaz Moore, PhD, AIA
                      Guest Lecturer: Marcel Harmon, PhD, PE, LEED‐AP O+M




GENUINE  |  PROGRESSIVE  |  ADVOCATES
Tonight’s Topics
School / Community Reciprocal Relationships and their 
impact on student / teacher health and well‐being.
impact on student / teacher health and well‐being
  • School Impacts on Community
  • Community Impacts on School
  • Transportation / Walkability
    Transportation / Walkability
Interior Environmental Impacts
  • Acoustics
  • Indoor Air Quality (IAQ)
       d      i    li (    )
  • Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort
  • Lighting / Views
  • Food Environment
Exterior Environmental Impacts
  • Playgrounds
Some Background
Why Environmental Health Matters in Schools
 • Children spend 30‐50 hours per week in and around school 
   facilities, on the bus, after school programs/events, etc.
   f ili i         h b      f      h l          /
 • The majority of that time is spent indoors
 • The average age of school facilities in the U S is 42 years
   The average age of school facilities in the U.S. is 42 years.
Some Background
Why Environmental Health Matters in Schools
 • Maintenance (infrastructure and 
   staffing), upgrades and 
   additions/renovations are often 
   deferred because of initial cost and 
   school district limited budgets.
Some Background
Why Environmental Health Matters in Schools
• Our mental machinery and physiologies evolved for exterior 
  environmental input, while growing up, learning and living in small 
                l        hl              l          dl             ll
  communities.
• Children's’ immature and developing physiologies and mental 
  Children s immature and developing physiologies and mental
  machinery are more susceptible to disruption from poor 
  environmental conditions.
Some Background
 Why Evolutionary Theory Matters to Healthy Schools
Wilson, D. S. (2011) The Neighborhood Project: Using Evolution to Improve My City, 
 One Block at a Time. Hachette Book Group, New York, NY.
 O Bl k           Ti    H h     B kG         N Y k NY
Binghamton Neighborhood Project (BNP): Science Based Solutions to Real World 
  Problems in Our Community ‐ http://bnp.binghamton.edu/.
EVOS – Evolutionary Studies Program at Binghamton University ‐
  http://evolution.binghamton.edu/evos/. 


Wilson’s epiphany: Darwin’s theory won’t fully 
prove itself until it improves the quality of human 
life in a practical sense.
School Impacts on Community
Lindsey‐Steiner Elementary, Portales, NM
School Impacts on Community
Lindsey‐Steiner Elementary, Portales, NM
Community Impacts on School
Surrounding Air Quality
USA Today Special Report: The Smokestack Effect ‐ Toxicity and 
  America s Schools
  America’s Schools
• http://content.usatoday.com/news/nation/environment/smok
  estack/index
• Used EPA model to track path of industrial pollution and 
  mapped the locations of almost 128,000 schools to determine 
  the locations of toxic chemicals outside.
  the locations of toxic chemicals outside
Community Impacts on School
Hurley Elementary, Hurley, NM                                                  Train Tracks




Impacts
• Railroad Tracks – noise and fumes
  Railroad Tracks  noise and fumes
• Poverty
• Area Air Quality
    • National Rank of 67th percentile (85,947 of 127,809 schools have worse air.)
    • Sulfuric acid most responsible for toxicity outside this school.
    • Chino Mines Co., Hurley, New Mexico
    • Phelps Dodge Tyrone Inc., Tyrone, New Mexico
Community Impacts on School
  Baca/Dlo'ay azhi Community School, Prewitt, NM
                                                                                  Bar

                                                             Baca




Impacts
• Proximity to bar
• Area Air Quality
  • National Rank of 59th percentile (75,175 of 127,809 schools have worse air.
  • Manganese and manganese compounds (50%) and cobalt and cobalt 
     compounds (46%) most responsible for the toxicity outside this school
  • Tri‐State Generation & Transmission ‐ Escalante St, Prewitt, New Mexico
Community Impacts on School
  Woodlawn Elementary, Lawrence, KS                                         Train Tracks




                                                                                           ICL Plant
                                                                                           ICL Plant




Impacts
• Train Tracks – not the 
  same issue as at Hurley 
  same issue as at Hurley
  for sound/fumes, but a 
  walkability issue.
• Area Air Quality
    • National Rank of 47th percentile (59,823 of 127,809 schools have worse air)
                           h

    • Manganese compounds (38%), Sulfuric acid (35%) and Lead/lead compounds (16%)
    • Lawrence Energy Center, Lawrence, Kansas
    • Schlumberger Technology Corp Lawrence Product Center, Lawrence, Kansas
       Schlumberger Technology Corp Lawrence Product Center, Lawrence, Kansas
    • Griffin Wheel Co Kansas City Plant, Kansas City, Kansas
    • Nearman Creek Power Station, Kansas City, Kansas
Transportation / Walkability
Baca/Dlo'ay azhi Community School, Prewitt, NM




• Long Bus Rides – Pros/Cons
• Long Teacher / Staff Commutes
Transportation / Walkability
Lindsey‐Steiner Elementary School, Portales, NM
Transportation / Walkability
Edward Gonzales Elementary School, Albuquerque, NM
School / Community
New York Elementary, Lawrence, KS
School / Community
Langston Hughes Elementary, Lawrence, KS
School / Community
Compare / Contrast
New York                                         Langston Hughes
• Current Enrollment: 174 students
  Current Enrollment: 174 students               • Current Enrollment: 475 students
                                                   Current Enrollment: 475 students
• 77.05% low SES                                 • 12.10% low SES
• 1.64% ELL                                      • 5.40% ELL
• 12.57% Disabilities                            • 6.05% Disabilities
• 0.23 miles from downtown                       • 1.15 miles to nearest retail/grocery
• Embedded in an established neighborhood        • Edge of newer neighborhood
• Approx. Weighted Avg. Facility Age: 50 yrs     • Approx. Weighted Avg. Facility Age: 13 yrs 
  National Rank of 49th percentile (62,218 of 
• N ti     l R k f 49         til (62 218 f        National Rank OF 73rd percentile (93,621 of 
                                                 • N ti    l R k OF 73            til (93 621 f
  127,809 schools have worse air); polluters:      127,809 schools have worse air)
  • Lawrence Energy Center, Lawrence,              • Lawrence Energy Center, Lawrence, 
     Kansas                                           Kansas
  • Schlumberger Technology Corp                   • Schlumberger Technology Corp 
     Lawrence Product Center, Lawrence,               Lawrence Product Center, Lawrence, 
     Kansas                                           Kansas
  • Griffin Wheel Co Kansas City Plant, 
     Kansas City, Kansas
  • Nearman Creek Power Station, Kansas 
     City, Kansas
Facility / Site Impacts
General Impacts
 • A study of Chicago and Washington, DC schools found that better school 
   facilities can add 3 to 4 percentage points to a school s standardized test scores, 
   facilities can add 3 to 4 percentage points to a school’s standardized test scores,
   even after controlling for demographic factors.
                   Schneider, Mark. “Public School Facilities and Teaching: Washington, DC and 
                   Chicago,” November 2002. A Report Prepared for the Neighborhood Capital 
                   Budget Group (NCBG). Available at: http://www.ncbg.org/press/press111302.htm. 
                   B d tG        (NCBG) A il bl t htt //              b      /    /      111302 ht


 • Based on actual improvements in design in green schools and based on a very 
   substantial data set on productivity and test performance of healthier, more 
                            p          y         p                       ,
   comfortable study and learning environments, a 3‐5% improvement in learning 
   ability and test scores in green schools appears reasonable and conservative.
                   Kats, G. 2006 Greening America’s Schools: Costs and Benefits. Capital E. www.cap‐
                   e.com. 
                   e com
Interior Environment
Acoustics
Julian Treasure: Why architects need to use their ears
• http://www.ted.com/talks/julian_treasure_why_architects_need_to_use_their_ears.h
   tml
Interior Environment
Acoustics
 American National Standards Institute (ANSI) S12.60‐2002, Acoustical Performance Criteria, 
 Design Requirements and Guidelines for Schools standard
 • The American Speech‐Language‐Hearing Association (ASHA) endorses the endorses the 
   ANSI standard and recommends the following criteria for classroom acoustics:
      • Unoccupied classroom levels must not exceed 35 dBA
      • The signal‐to‐noise ratio (the difference between the teacher's voice and the
         The signal to noise ratio (the difference between the teacher s voice and the 
         background noise) should be at least +15 dB at the child's ears.
      • Unoccupied classroom reverberation must not surpass 0.6 seconds in smaller 
         classrooms or 0.7 seconds in larger rooms.

 You can access the standard at the following (2) websites:
 • http://www.asha.org/public/hearing/American‐National‐Standard‐on‐Classroom‐Acoustics/
 • http://acousticalsociety.org/about_acoustics/acoustics_of_classrooms

 Impacts
 • Intelligibility, understanding and learning
 • Focus and concentration
 • S
   Stress 
 • Voice strain
 • Privacy
Interior Environment
     Acoustics

V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM
                   g
2010 CEFPI James D. MacConnell Award Finalist




                                                BUILDING DATA
                                                418,000 s.f.
                                                2,350 Students
                                                $
                                                $120 M Construction
                                                $11.5M FF&E + Tech
                                                7 Academies
Interior Environment
    Acoustics                                       V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM




                                                                                       ANSI/ASA S12.60‐
                                                                                           /
                                                                                       2010  Sound 
                                                                                       Measurements
Analysis:  ANSI/ASA S12.60‐2010 PERMITS GREATEST WEIGHTED SOUND LEVEL OF 35 DB FOR CORE LEARNING SPACES LESS
THAN 10,000 GSF AND 40 DB FOR CORE LEARNING SPACES GREATER THAN 10,000 GSF .  THE LARGE CORE LEARNING AREAS
ARE SUBSTANTIALLY OVER THE PERMITTED TOLERANCES, AND THE HVAC IS SPECIFICALLY SCHEDULED “OFF” WHEN THESE
CLASSROOMS ARE OCCUPIED.
Interior Environment
Acoustics
            High ceiling spaces without lay‐in ceilings
             • Described as noisy, with decreased audibility
             • Supported by instantaneous sound level measurements
             • Some of these spaces set to “unoccupied” in BAS 
               system during class periods to minimize distracting 
               noise
                  i
             • But data loggers demonstrated that this could result in 
               a less thermally comfortable space
             • These spaces may require:
               These spaces may require:
                  • Addition of sound absorbing surfaces
                  • T&B
                  • Duct acoustic liners or other HVAC sound control
                    Duct acoustic liners or other HVAC sound control 
                    methods




            V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM
Interior Environment
   Acoustics
                                Q19: Average Intelligibility Rating
7.00


6.00
                   5.36       5.36                  5.36
                                         5.17                                 5.17       5.17
5.00    4.75


4.00                                                              3.86
                                                                                                   Mean

3.00


2.00


1.00
       Cordley   Hillcrest   Kennedy   New York   Pinckney     Sunset Hill   Group 1   Langston 
                                                                                        Hughes




                                                             Lawrence, KS School District
Interior Environment
 Acoustics & Spatial Restrictions
Survey Quotes:
• Kennedy (Early Childhood Special Ed): “There are four of us sharing ‘office’ space which 
  we make phone calls and also connected to a therapy space ‐‐ it can be very 
  overwhelming at times and difficult to concentrate on all of the paperwork that we are 
  required to do.
  required to do.”
• New York (Resource Room): “I share a resource room and at times we have four 
  different groups being taught in this space. It gets distracting for all students and staff at 
  times like this.”




                                                       Lawrence, KS School District
Interior Environment
    Acoustics & Spatial Restrictions

                                                          2               2
                                                                      2
                                                              2                       2
                                                    2

                                                                              1
                                                           2
                                                                  2
                                                                                  3       2       Approximate location of small 
                                                                                              #
                                                                                                  group activities plus the # of 
                                                                                                  students engaged in those 
                                                                                                   t d t           d i th
                                                                                                  activities.



Sunset Hill 5th Grade Classroom
Sunset Hill 5 Grade Classroom
• This 5th grade classroom has 28 desks; at the time of the observations there were 25 students present. This 
  classroom provides an example of the crowding that occurs in the district’s elementary schools, particularly 
  the upper grades. 
• The desks end up taking up the vast majority of the floor area and t makes it difficult to find enough space to 
  work in small groups (and still maintain some level of separation between the small groups).
• Exacerbates noise and thermal comfort issues, negatively impacting focus/concentration.

                                                                          Lawrence, KS School District
Interior Environment
Indoor Air Quality (IAQ)
• Schools with high IAQ total scores and a high Healthy Greenness School Index 
  (GSI) were more likely to have high student attendance rates (36% and 22% 
  respectively). 
• Schools with well maintained air filters were also 42% more likely to have good 
  4th grade academic performance. 
                  Lin, S., C. Kielb, A. Orsini & N. Muscatiello The Evaluation of Green School Building 
                  Attributes and Their Effect on the Health and Performance of Students and 
                  Teachers in New York State. Final Project Report ‐ Proposal Number: #147 funded 
                  by the US Green Building Council. 
                  http://www.usgbc.org/ShowFile.aspx?DocumentID 8627. 
                  http://www.usgbc.org/ShowFile.aspx?DocumentID=8627.

• An analysis of two school districts in Illinois found that student attendance rose 
  by 5% after incorporating cost effective indoor air quality improvements.
                  Illinois Healthy Schools Campaign, “Apparently Size Doesn’t Matter: Two Illinois School 
                  Illi i H lth S h l C           i “A         tl Si D      ’t M tt T Illi i S h l
                  Districts Show Successful IAQ Management.” School Health Watch, Summer 2003. 
                  http://healthyschoolscampaign.org/news/newsletter/2003‐summer_HSC‐
                  newsletter.pdf. Also see: US Environmental Protection Agency. “IAQ Tools for Schools,” 
                  December 2000 (Second Edition). Available at: http://www.epa.gov/iaq/schools/. 
Interior Environment
 Indoor Air Quality (IAQ)
Landscaping Impacts IAQ

                                    Increased Cleaning & Poorer IAQ




             VE/Defer Landscaping




                                    V. Sue Cleveland High School, 
                                    Rio Rancho, NM
Interior Environment
   Indoor Air Quality
                                Q 17: Average Air Quality Rating
7.00
7 00


6.00
                                                                                       5.25
5.00                                     4.67
                                                    4.43        4.43
                                                                            3.97
4.00    3.75       3.72       3.76
                                                                                                 Mean

3.00


2.00


1.00
       Cordley   Hillcrest   Kennedy   New York   Pinckney   Sunset Hill   Group 1   Langston 
                                                                                      Hughes




                                                             Lawrence, KS School District
Interior Environment
 Indoor Air Quality

ASHRAE Design Standard for Schools
           g
• CO2 maximum of 1,000 ppm, and not exceeding the outdoor concentration by 
  more than about 650 ppm when the exterior outdoor CO2 concentration is 380 
  ppm.
• Based on studies linking CO2 levels above these limits to drowsiness, lethargy, poor 
  concentration, respiratory ailments, headaches, and other negative health impacts. 
• These negative impacts are not necessarily a direct result of the CO2 levels found 
  indoors (typically less than 5000 ppm), but the higher pollution rates in general that 
  occur as a result of not having enough outside air, or adequate ventilation.
• ASHRAE ventilation requirements are intended to provide enough fresh air to dilute 
  interior pollutants, and the CO2 levels end up being a good way to measure if you 
  interior pollutants and the CO2 levels end up being a good way to measure if you
  have adequate ventilation inside your buildings.




                                                    Lawrence, KS School District
Interior Environment
 Indoor Air Quality




           4,000                      4,000




           3,000                      3,000
  CO PPM




                             CO PPM
           2,000                      2,000
   O2




                              O2




           1,000                      1,000




              0                          0
                   Kennedy                    Langston Hughes
Interior Environments
Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort

                    • Activity Levels
                      Activity Levels
                    • Clothing Insulative
                      Properties




• Air Temperature                           • Air Movement / 
• Mean Radiant                                Velocity
                                              Velocit
  Temperature                               • Relative Humidity
Interior Environments
Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort
Limitations
• ASHRAE Standard 55 2004 and the ISO 7730 Standard for Moderate
  ASHRAE Standard 55‐2004 and the ISO 7730 Standard for Moderate 
  Thermal Environments are based on experimental studies of adults, 
  not children. 
• New ‘adaptive’ models of thermal comfort have not been incorporated 
  New  adaptive models of thermal comfort have not been incorporated
  into school HVAC systems standards. Student metabolic rates vary as 
  they move between rooms or activities.
• HVAC system design focuses almost exclusively on the thermal and
  HVAC system design focuses almost exclusively on the thermal and 
  humidity specifications as directed by building codes. Internal mixing, 
  air velocities, and vertical temperature gradients are rarely addressed.




                                Committee to Review and Assess the Health and 
                                Committee to Review and Assess the Health and
                                Productivity Benefits of Green Schools (National 
                                Research Council, 2006:65‐66)
Interior Environments
Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort
   Personal Control
   Increased tenant environmental control have been found to 
   I       dt     t    i      t l    t lh      b    f   dt
   provide average measured workforce productivity gains of:
   • 7.1% with lighting control
     7.1% with lighting control 
   • 1.8% with ventilation control
   • 1.2% with thermal control




Kats, G., L. Alevantis, A. Berman, E. Mills, and J. Perlman, 2003. 
The Costs and Financial Benefits of Green Building: A Report to 
California’s Sustainable Building Task Force. 
Interior Environments
Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort
V. Sue Cleveland High School Survey Responses
• Teachers, Staff and Administrators: Spaces are only thermally
   Teachers, Staff and Administrators: Spaces are only thermally 
   acceptable (ASHRAE definition) during the fall (ranges from 66% ‐ 75% 
   for other three seasons)
• Students: Not thermally acceptable during any season (ranges from
  Students: Not thermally acceptable during any season (ranges from  
  32% ‐ 51% for all four seasons).
Interior Environments
Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort
V. Sue Cleveland Benefits of Personal Control
• Surveys focus groups and interviews: Expressed strong
  Surveys, focus groups and interviews: Expressed strong 
  appreciation of and desire for local temperature control .
• Productivity increases with increasing personal control over 
  temperature and ventilation.
  temperat re and entilation
• Having control mitigates some of the negative perceptions 
  associated with non‐optimal HVAC system performance
    • “being able to monitor my own classroom temperature 
      … is GREAT!!!”
Interior Environments
Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort
V. Sue Cleveland Correlation Between Temperature Control and 
Thermal Comfort Ratings
Thermal Comfort Ratings
• Spearman’s Rho test: found a positive correlation between adult 
  temperature control effectiveness ratings and their thermal 
  comfort ratings.
  comfort ratings
• Contributing factor for the more positive adult thermal comfort 
  ratings.
Interior Environments
Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort

Clothing Variability
       g           y
Interior Environments
  Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort
   Clothing Variability          Signage



                                                Computers


                                                      T‐Shirt Logos



Messages using images, 
graphics, text, student               Flat 
generated videos displaying / 
                            /         Screens
promoting desired behavior

Spread using existing school
Spread using existing school 
means or others – be 
creative and relevant to your                        Smart Phones
audience
Interior Environments
Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort

                             Q 13: Average Thermal Comfort Rating
7.00


6.00


5.00                                                 4.80
                                                                 4.57

                   3.93        3.95                                          4.07
                                          3.92
4.00    3.75
                                                                                                  Mean
                                                                                                  M
                                                                                        3.17
3.00


2.00


1.00
       Cordley   Hillcrest    Kennedy   New York   Pinckney   Sunset Hill   Group 1   Langston 
                                                                                       Hughes
Interior Environments
 Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort




       New York Classroom                    Sunset Hill Classroom                Pinckney Classroom




       New York Classroom                     New York Classroom

Closure of Blinds: Frequently observed that blinds were closed in the down position, allowing heat 
gain to still occur in the occupied zone as well as creating a source of horizontal band glare (direct and 
reflected). Closing blinds in the up position minimizes this as well as throws additional light up and 
into the space (if blinds not completely closed). District should consider an education initiative to 
change how people close their blinds.
Interior Environments
  Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort
Clothing Layering
• Layering of clothing is a district‐wide approach. 
• Students from low SES families own less clothing limiting their ability to layer New York has clothing
   Students from low SES families own less clothing, limiting their ability to layer. New York has clothing 
   available for these students to use. 
• Source of inequity between those schools with high percentages of low SES families and those without:
      • Kennedy Survey Comment: “When students have to wear jackets/sweaters etc., many students only 
         have one coat. That is it. They can t or don t bring layers. It is hard to teach in a cold classroom with 
         have one coat That is it They can't or don't bring layers It is hard to teach in a cold classroom with
         students in coats.” 
      • Langston Hughes Survey Comment: Related comment that they have to call parents to bring additional 
         layers – something that many parents at the east schools can’t do.




       Cordley Clothing Observed: 9/14/2012                     Pinckney Clothing Observed: 8/27/2012
Interior Environments
 Lighting / Views

   Compared to little or no daylighting, 
   classrooms with appropriate 
   daylighting may increase the rate of 
   student learning by:
   student learning by:
   • 20% in math
   • 26% in reading


Heschong Mahone Group. 1999. Daylighting in Schools: 
An Investigation into the Relationship Between Daylight 
and Human Performance. Report submitted to Pacific Gas 
and Electric. http://www.h‐m‐g.com. 
Interior Environments
Lighting / Views
                                      Communication, Education & Buy‐In




Edward Gonzales Elementary School 
                                     Edward Gonzales Elementary 
Classroom
                                     School, Albuquerque, NM
Interior Environments
 Lighting / Views




Edward Gonzales: 
Window Size/Placement: 
Impact on Performance 
and Social Conflicts
Interior Environments
 Lighting / Views
V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM
• Lack of Adequate Daylighting Control
  Lack of Adequate Daylighting
• South Facing Windows and Some East/West 
  Windows: Shades with relatively high openness 
  value.
  value
• Remaining Windows: No shades, curtains or blinds
• No Other Means of Daylight Control
Interior Environments
 Lighting / Views
V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM
                                                                             Percentage 
                               Survey Question                               of Teacher
                                                                             Responses
      Reflected images of the windows/skylights appear on my work 
      surface, PC monitor, and/or on the smart board/white board/chalk 
          f                     d/      h        b d/ h b d/ h lk
      board.                                                                        49%
      Windows/skylights create glare in my field of vision as I work.               37%
      Direct sunlight falls on my work surface, PC monitor, and/or on the 
      smart board/white board/chalk board, washing it out and making 
               b d/ hi b d/ h lk b d              hi i          d ki
      it difficult to see what I’m working on.                                      47%
                                                                             Percentage
      Top three reasons for closing blinds/shades (or covering windows 
                                                                                 o
                                                                                 of 
                 with paper for those without blinds/shades)
                  ih        f h         ih    bli d / h d )
                                                                             Responses
      Direct sunlight falling on my work surface, PC monitor, and/or on 
      the smart board/white board/chalk board                                       42%
                                      y              ,           ,    /
      Reflection of the windows on my work surface, PC monitor, and/or 
      on the smart board/white board/chalk board                                    24%
      Distracting Views
                                                                                    22%
Interior Environments
 Lighting / Views
V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM
• E i
   Estimated quantitative impacts from lack of adequate 
            d       i i i         f    l k f d
   daylighting control

  Estimated Teacher/Staff Annual Productivity 
  Delta Due to Lack of Adequate Daylighting
  Control                                           ‐$169,457
                                                    ‐$169 457
  Estimated Impact of Glare on Student Math 
  Scores                                               ‐1.50%
  Estimated Impact of Glare on Student Reading 
  Scores                                              ‐‐0.91%
Interior Environments
Lighting / Views
Lawrence, KS School District – Available Daylight




  Deerfield, Broken Arrow                                      Cordley, Hillcrest, Kennedy, 
                                   Langston Hughes,            New York, Hillcrest, Sunset Hill, 
                                   Prairie Park, Quail Run, 
                                   P i i P k Q il R            Schwegler, Woodlawn
                                                               S h    l W dl
                                   Sunflower


                            Potential 20% delta in math scores
                            Potential 26% delta in reading scores
Interior Environments
Food Environment
Some Important Factors Associated w/ Lunch (and Breakfast to a Lesser Extent)
• School provided meals (and weekend assistance programs) often provide a
  School provided meals (and weekend assistance programs) often provide a 
  significant portion of low SES student nutritional needs.
• Breakfast and lunch are important for keeping kids fueled (mentally and 
  physically) for the school day.
  physically) for the school day.
• Provide time to eat calmly instead of inhaling food.  Avoid diverting additional 
  blood from the brain and potentially making students drowsier after lunch 
  (though many variables are at play here – see Kanarek 1997 and Smith & Maben 
  1992).
• The social/cultural importance of, or “ritual” associated with, meals (part of our 
  social “glue”) vs. the limited time, highly structured/scheduled nature of most 
  school lunches.
    h ll h

              Kanarek, R. (1997) Psychological Effects of Snacks and Altered Meal Frequency. British Journal of 
              Nutrition 77, Suppl. 1:S105‐S120.

              Smith, A. and A. Maben (1992) Effects of Sleep Deprivation, Lunch, and Personality on 
              Performance, Mood, and Cardiovascular Function. Physiology & Behavior 54:967‐972.
Interior Environments
    Food Environment ‐ Gymacafetorium Issues




Sunset Hill Gym as Cafeteria
• Smallest “cafeteria” out of the (6) Group 1 schools; completely filled with tables and serving line during 
                                   ( )      p          ;      p     y                          g           g
  lunch; tables must be stored in closet space outside the gym.
• Cramped quarters in general typically result in greater sound levels, though the staging of students is such 
  that (1) row of tables  during each wave is mostly empty; this combined with the music generally keeps 
  the sound levels as low, if not lower than the other (6) Group 1 schools.
• Some of the adults wear earplugs during lunch, and I was offered some to wear. Though Sunset Hill wasn’t 
  the loudest of the (6) schools, at least on the days I visited. Kennedy was probably the loudest. This raises 
  the question – if the adults think they need earplugs, then are the students at risk to hearing damage or 
  additional psychological stress from the noise?
Interior Environments
 Food Environment ‐ Gymacafetorium Issues
                                                    Kennedy Cafeteria as Cafeteria
                                                    •H i
                                                      Having a separate cafeteria from the gym relieves 
                                                                            f    i f     h          li
                                                      general stress relative to scheduling compared to 
                                                      schools with gymacafeterias and gymacafetoriums.
                                                    • (15) round tables + (2) rectangular tables – round 
                                                      tables are used first and was told that they are more 
                                                      tables are used first and was told that they are more
                                                      popular with the students.




Round Tables Vs. Rectangular Tables
• R
  Round Table Pros: Easier to interact with all of those at the table and you feel you’re 
       d T bl P      E i t i t        t ith ll f th       t th t bl     d     f l     ’
  eating with a smaller group.
• Round Table Cons: Takes up more space, therefore more difficult to use in the smaller 
  cafeterias and gymacafetoriums; because they potentially encourage interaction more 
  than rectangular tables, may add to the noise level and make it more difficult for 
  students to focus on eating their lunch; this is exacerbated by short time available to 
  eat.
Interior Environments
       Food Environment ‐ Gymacafetorium Issues
       Total Lunch Period / No. of Sections                      Total Lunch Period / No. of Students
8.00                                                      0.40
7.00                                       Cordley                                                Cordley
                                                          0.35
6.00                                       Hillcrest                                              Hillcrest
                                                          0.30
5.00                                       Kennedy        0.25                                    Kennedy
4.00                                       New York       0.20                                    New York
3.00                                       Pinckney       0.15                                    Pinckney
2.00                                       Sunset Hill    0.10                                    Sunset Hill
1.00                                       Broken Arrow   0.05                                    Broken Arrow
0.00                                                      0.00
                                           Deerfield                                              Deerfield
                                           Quail Run                                              Quail Run
                                           Schwegler                                              Schwegler


                                    Total Lunch Period / School Sq. Ft.
                         3.50E‐03
                                                                            Cordley
                         3.00E‐03
                                                                            Hillcrest
                         2.50E 03
                         2 50E‐03
                                                                            Kennedy
                         2.00E‐03                                           New York

                         1.50E‐03                                           Pinckney
                                                                            Sunset Hill
                         1.00E‐03
                                                                            Broken Arrow
                         5.00E‐04
                         5 00E 04
                                                                            Deerfield
                         0.00E+00                                           Quail Run
                                                                            Schwegler
                                                                            Sunflower
Interior Environments
 Food Environment ‐ Gymacafetorium Issues
 Some of the gyms can get loud during lunch, though most schools take measures to deal with 
 that with varying success levels. Use of music seemed to have the greatest impact, particularly 
 that with varying success levels Use of music seemed to have the greatest impact particularly
 the way it was done at Sunset Hill.
    • Pinckney: Hand bell to ring to get everyone to quiet down (as well as mark points along 
       lunch timeline).
    • Hill
       Hillcrest: ?
               t ?
    • Kennedy: Turned one bank of lights off/on and raised hands to signal students to quiet 
       down, though volume quickly ratcheted back up; principal eventually did a quick ring of 
       the alarm to quiet students.
    • Sunset Hill: Played music (light jazz), but not constantly. Played at least once during each 
       “wave” of students to help provide them a few minutes of “down time” to focus on eating 
       (no talking); seemed pretty effective at keeping the students quiet during that time –
       probably the most effective method among the (6) schools observed. However even here 
       a large amount of food is wasted.
    • New York: ?
    • Cordley: Played music (piano “elevator” music) constantly.; seemed less effective than 
       Sunset Hill, but more effective than other schools.
       Sunset Hill, but more effective than other schools.
Exterior Environment
Playgrounds – Lindsey Steiner Elementary, Portales, NM




Playground Considerations
• Proper landscaping 
• Minimum #/types of equipment
• Larger open areas for running playing
   Larger open areas for running, playing 
   ball/sports and generally blowing off steam
• Shaded areas
• Exterior drinking fountains
• Separate younger/older playgrounds NA
   Separate younger/older playgrounds NA
Exterior Environment
Playgrounds – Hurley Elementary, Hurley, NM




Playground Considerations
• Proper landscaping 
• Minimum #/types of equipment
• Larger open areas for running, playing
   Larger open areas for running, playing 
   ball/sports and generally blowing off steam
• Shaded areas
• Exterior drinking fountains
• Separate younger/older playgrounds
   Separate younger/older playgrounds

According to the secretary, students are in daily 
with bumps, bruises, cuts, stickers, etc.
Exterior Environment
Playgrounds – Edward Gonzales Elementary, Albuquerque, NM




Playground Considerations
• Proper landscaping 
• Minimum #/types of equipment
• LLarger open areas for running, playing 
                      f        i   l i
   ball/sports and generally blowing off steam
• Shaded areas
• Exterior drinking fountains
• SSeparate younger/older playgrounds
                     / ld    l       d
More than 200 injuries significant enough to report to the Nurse’s office are logged 
every month, and School Nurses estimate 90% of injuries are playground‐related. 
Exterior Environment
Playgrounds – Hillcrest Elementary, Lawrence, KS




Playground Considerations
• Proper landscaping 
• Minimum #/types of equipment
• Larger open areas for running playing
   Larger open areas for running, playing 
   ball/sports and generally blowing off steam
• Shaded areas
• Exterior drinking fountains
• Separate younger/older playgrounds
   Separate younger/older playgrounds
Maintenance costs associated with elaborate playgrounds
References
 American National Standards Institute (ANSI) S12.60‐2002, Acoustical Performance Criteria, 
   Design Requirements and Guidelines for Schools standard 
   http://www.asha.org/public/hearing/American‐National‐Standard‐on‐Classroom‐Acoustics/
   http://acousticalsociety.org/about_acoustics/acoustics_of_classrooms  
   http://acousticalsociety org/about acoustics/acoustics of classrooms
 Committee to Review and Assess the Health and Productivity Benefits of Green Schools 
   (National Research Council, 2006:65‐66).
 Heschong Mahone Group. 1999. Daylighting in Schools: An Investigation into the Relationship 
   Between Daylight and Human Performance. Report submitted to Pacific Gas and Electric. 
   http://www.h‐m‐g.com. 
 Illinois Healthy Schools Campaign, “Apparently Size Doesn’t Matter: Two Illinois School Districts 
     Show Successful IAQ Management. School Health Watch Summer 2003
     Show Successful IAQ Management ” School Health Watch, Summer 2003. 
     http://healthyschoolscampaign.org/news/newsletter/2003‐summer_HSC‐newsletter.pdf. 
     Also see: US Environmental Protection Agency. “IAQ Tools for Schools,” December 2000 
     (Second Edition). Available at: http://www.epa.gov/iaq/schools/. 
 Kanarek, R. (1997) Psychological Effects of Snacks and Altered Meal Frequency. British Journal 
 K     k R (1997) P h l i l Eff t f S k               d Alt d M l F             B iti h J     l
   of Nutrition 77, Suppl. 1:S105‐S120.
 Kats, G. 2006 Greening America’s Schools: Costs and Benefits. Capital E. www.cap‐e.com. 
 Kats, G., L. Alevantis, A. Berman, E. Mills, and J. Perlman, 2003. The Costs and Financial 
 Kats, G., L. Alevantis, A. Berman, E. Mills, and J. Perlman, 2003. The Costs and Financial
   Benefits of Green Building: A Report to California’s Sustainable Building Task Force. 
References
 Lin, S., C. Kielb, A. Orsini & N. Muscatiello The Evaluation of Green School Building Attributes 
    and Their Effect on the Health and Performance of Students and Teachers in New York State. 
    Final Project Report ‐ Proposal Number: #147 funded by the US Green Building Council. 
    http://www.usgbc.org/ShowFile.aspx?DocumentID=8627. 
    http://www usgbc org/ShowFile aspx?DocumentID=8627
 Schneider, Mark. “Public School Facilities and Teaching: Washington, DC and Chicago,” 
   November 2002. A Report Prepared for the Neighborhood Capital Budget Group (NCBG). 
   Available at: http://www.ncbg.org/press/press111302.htm.  
 Smith, A. and A. Maben (1992) Effects of Sleep Deprivation, Lunch, and Personality on 
   Performance, Mood, and Cardiovascular Function. Physiology & Behavior 54:967‐972
 Treasure, J. Why architects need to use their ears. TED Talk 
    http://www.ted.com/talks/julian_treasure_why_architects_need_to_use_their_ears.html
    http://www ted com/talks/julian treasure why architects need to use their ears html
 USA Today Special Report: The Smokestack Effect ‐ Toxicity and America’s Schools 
   http://content.usatoday.com/news/nation/environment/smokestack/index
 Why Environmental Health Matters in Schools ‐ EPA Webinar: 10/17/2012 ‐
  https://esbuildings.webex.com/mw0307l/mywebex/default.do?siteurl=esbuildings.
 Wilson, D. S. (2011) The Neighborhood Project: Using Evolution to Improve My City, One Block 
   at a Time. Hachette Book Group, New York, NY.
 Wilson, D. S., D. Tumminelli O Briena and A. Sesmac (2009) Human Prosociality From an 
 Wilson D S D Tumminelli O'Briena and A Sesmac (2009) Human Prosociality From an
   Evolutionary Perspective: Variation and Correlations at a City‐Wide Scale. Evolution and 
   Human Behavior 30:190–200.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Adding the "Where" to the "When"
Adding the "Where" to the "When"Adding the "Where" to the "When"
Adding the "Where" to the "When"Raffi Krikorian
 
El hombre el clima y la arquitectura versión mejorada sofiaaa.ppt [modo de co...
El hombre el clima y la arquitectura versión mejorada sofiaaa.ppt [modo de co...El hombre el clima y la arquitectura versión mejorada sofiaaa.ppt [modo de co...
El hombre el clima y la arquitectura versión mejorada sofiaaa.ppt [modo de co...Gabriel Buda
 
Nine Tips for Effective Wayfinding
Nine Tips for Effective WayfindingNine Tips for Effective Wayfinding
Nine Tips for Effective WayfindingMlicki
 
Post-Occupancy Evaluation (POE) Methodologies for School Facilities
Post-Occupancy Evaluation (POE) Methodologies for School FacilitiesPost-Occupancy Evaluation (POE) Methodologies for School Facilities
Post-Occupancy Evaluation (POE) Methodologies for School FacilitiesMarcel Harmon
 
The Art & Signs of Wayfinding & Signage Design
The Art & Signs of Wayfinding & Signage DesignThe Art & Signs of Wayfinding & Signage Design
The Art & Signs of Wayfinding & Signage DesignAcacia Wayfinding
 
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resources
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental ResourcesMonahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resources
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resourcesgabriellebastien
 
Functional Dimension
Functional DimensionFunctional Dimension
Functional DimensionTareq Zarouni
 
Kindergarten design focusing on creating healthy and comfortable
Kindergarten design focusing on creating healthy and comfortableKindergarten design focusing on creating healthy and comfortable
Kindergarten design focusing on creating healthy and comfortableSiham EL-Saadi
 
Ecopsychology Presentation
Ecopsychology PresentationEcopsychology Presentation
Ecopsychology PresentationSimon Leonard
 
Human Behavior effect on the Environment
Human Behavior effect on the EnvironmentHuman Behavior effect on the Environment
Human Behavior effect on the EnvironmentSusan Mckee
 
Information Wayfinding: The Future of Search
Information Wayfinding: The Future of SearchInformation Wayfinding: The Future of Search
Information Wayfinding: The Future of SearchTyler Tate
 
Let's Google My Audience - Privacy is for Losers!
Let's Google My Audience - Privacy is for Losers!Let's Google My Audience - Privacy is for Losers!
Let's Google My Audience - Privacy is for Losers!Cain Ransbottyn
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Wayfinding
WayfindingWayfinding
Wayfinding
 
Adding the "Where" to the "When"
Adding the "Where" to the "When"Adding the "Where" to the "When"
Adding the "Where" to the "When"
 
El hombre el clima y la arquitectura versión mejorada sofiaaa.ppt [modo de co...
El hombre el clima y la arquitectura versión mejorada sofiaaa.ppt [modo de co...El hombre el clima y la arquitectura versión mejorada sofiaaa.ppt [modo de co...
El hombre el clima y la arquitectura versión mejorada sofiaaa.ppt [modo de co...
 
Nine Tips for Effective Wayfinding
Nine Tips for Effective WayfindingNine Tips for Effective Wayfinding
Nine Tips for Effective Wayfinding
 
Post-Occupancy Evaluation (POE) Methodologies for School Facilities
Post-Occupancy Evaluation (POE) Methodologies for School FacilitiesPost-Occupancy Evaluation (POE) Methodologies for School Facilities
Post-Occupancy Evaluation (POE) Methodologies for School Facilities
 
The Art & Signs of Wayfinding & Signage Design
The Art & Signs of Wayfinding & Signage DesignThe Art & Signs of Wayfinding & Signage Design
The Art & Signs of Wayfinding & Signage Design
 
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resources
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental ResourcesMonahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resources
Monahan - Perception & Interaction With Environmental Resources
 
Functional Dimension
Functional DimensionFunctional Dimension
Functional Dimension
 
Kindergarten design focusing on creating healthy and comfortable
Kindergarten design focusing on creating healthy and comfortableKindergarten design focusing on creating healthy and comfortable
Kindergarten design focusing on creating healthy and comfortable
 
Ecopsychology Presentation
Ecopsychology PresentationEcopsychology Presentation
Ecopsychology Presentation
 
Ecopsychology
EcopsychologyEcopsychology
Ecopsychology
 
Evolving Wayfinding to Digital
Evolving Wayfinding to DigitalEvolving Wayfinding to Digital
Evolving Wayfinding to Digital
 
Wayfinding
WayfindingWayfinding
Wayfinding
 
Human Behavior effect on the Environment
Human Behavior effect on the EnvironmentHuman Behavior effect on the Environment
Human Behavior effect on the Environment
 
Information Wayfinding: The Future of Search
Information Wayfinding: The Future of SearchInformation Wayfinding: The Future of Search
Information Wayfinding: The Future of Search
 
Let's Google My Audience - Privacy is for Losers!
Let's Google My Audience - Privacy is for Losers!Let's Google My Audience - Privacy is for Losers!
Let's Google My Audience - Privacy is for Losers!
 

Similar to Healthy Schools Lecture

Critical Importance of Well-Maintained Facilities - Thurnau
Critical Importance of Well-Maintained Facilities - ThurnauCritical Importance of Well-Maintained Facilities - Thurnau
Critical Importance of Well-Maintained Facilities - ThurnauMeg Thompson
 
Creative Solutions for Today's Educational Facilities' Needs - Kobet
Creative Solutions for Today's Educational Facilities' Needs - KobetCreative Solutions for Today's Educational Facilities' Needs - Kobet
Creative Solutions for Today's Educational Facilities' Needs - KobetMeg Thompson
 
Open Course Library presentation, AMATYC 2013
Open Course Library presentation, AMATYC 2013Open Course Library presentation, AMATYC 2013
Open Course Library presentation, AMATYC 2013David Lippman
 
Bachelors degree by age 18
Bachelors degree by age 18Bachelors degree by age 18
Bachelors degree by age 18Woody Robertson
 
OCWC Global Conference 2013: Assessing the Educational Value of OER
OCWC Global Conference 2013: Assessing the Educational Value of OEROCWC Global Conference 2013: Assessing the Educational Value of OER
OCWC Global Conference 2013: Assessing the Educational Value of OERThe Open Education Consortium
 
CannonDesign Science and Technology
CannonDesign Science and TechnologyCannonDesign Science and Technology
CannonDesign Science and TechnologyDaniel Niewoehner
 
Counternarratives and HBCU Student Success - NASPA 3.24.15
Counternarratives and HBCU Student Success - NASPA 3.24.15Counternarratives and HBCU Student Success - NASPA 3.24.15
Counternarratives and HBCU Student Success - NASPA 3.24.15saUGA411
 
Value Of OER_ VSS_09
Value Of OER_ VSS_09Value Of OER_ VSS_09
Value Of OER_ VSS_09trowenhorst
 
A Roadmap from High School to Engineering Colleges
A Roadmap from High School to Engineering CollegesA Roadmap from High School to Engineering Colleges
A Roadmap from High School to Engineering CollegesNAFCareerAcads
 
Community College Consortium OER Panel eLearning 2013
Community College Consortium OER Panel eLearning 2013Community College Consortium OER Panel eLearning 2013
Community College Consortium OER Panel eLearning 2013Una Daly
 

Similar to Healthy Schools Lecture (20)

Critical Importance of Well-Maintained Facilities - Thurnau
Critical Importance of Well-Maintained Facilities - ThurnauCritical Importance of Well-Maintained Facilities - Thurnau
Critical Importance of Well-Maintained Facilities - Thurnau
 
Creative Solutions for Today's Educational Facilities' Needs - Kobet
Creative Solutions for Today's Educational Facilities' Needs - KobetCreative Solutions for Today's Educational Facilities' Needs - Kobet
Creative Solutions for Today's Educational Facilities' Needs - Kobet
 
Open edppt final
Open edppt finalOpen edppt final
Open edppt final
 
501 Ceu L Idcec 8 21 09
501 Ceu L Idcec 8 21 09501 Ceu L Idcec 8 21 09
501 Ceu L Idcec 8 21 09
 
Open Course Library presentation, AMATYC 2013
Open Course Library presentation, AMATYC 2013Open Course Library presentation, AMATYC 2013
Open Course Library presentation, AMATYC 2013
 
CCIH 2012 Conference, Breakout 4, Molly Krans, Student Project Session, CBPR ...
CCIH 2012 Conference, Breakout 4, Molly Krans, Student Project Session, CBPR ...CCIH 2012 Conference, Breakout 4, Molly Krans, Student Project Session, CBPR ...
CCIH 2012 Conference, Breakout 4, Molly Krans, Student Project Session, CBPR ...
 
August 2016 Member Meeting on Education
August 2016 Member Meeting on EducationAugust 2016 Member Meeting on Education
August 2016 Member Meeting on Education
 
Dwc Ellie 92408a
Dwc Ellie 92408aDwc Ellie 92408a
Dwc Ellie 92408a
 
Bachelors degree by age 18
Bachelors degree by age 18Bachelors degree by age 18
Bachelors degree by age 18
 
Dennis Small
Dennis SmallDennis Small
Dennis Small
 
WPU Scholarship Day 2013
WPU Scholarship Day 2013WPU Scholarship Day 2013
WPU Scholarship Day 2013
 
OCWC Global Conference 2013: Assessing the Educational Value of OER
OCWC Global Conference 2013: Assessing the Educational Value of OEROCWC Global Conference 2013: Assessing the Educational Value of OER
OCWC Global Conference 2013: Assessing the Educational Value of OER
 
A
AA
A
 
Transportation Awareness After School Presentation
Transportation Awareness After School PresentationTransportation Awareness After School Presentation
Transportation Awareness After School Presentation
 
CannonDesign Science and Technology
CannonDesign Science and TechnologyCannonDesign Science and Technology
CannonDesign Science and Technology
 
Counternarratives and HBCU Student Success - NASPA 3.24.15
Counternarratives and HBCU Student Success - NASPA 3.24.15Counternarratives and HBCU Student Success - NASPA 3.24.15
Counternarratives and HBCU Student Success - NASPA 3.24.15
 
Value Of OER_ VSS_09
Value Of OER_ VSS_09Value Of OER_ VSS_09
Value Of OER_ VSS_09
 
Schoolyard Habitats: How to Guide - Part 7, Appendix
Schoolyard Habitats: How to Guide - Part 7, AppendixSchoolyard Habitats: How to Guide - Part 7, Appendix
Schoolyard Habitats: How to Guide - Part 7, Appendix
 
A Roadmap from High School to Engineering Colleges
A Roadmap from High School to Engineering CollegesA Roadmap from High School to Engineering Colleges
A Roadmap from High School to Engineering Colleges
 
Community College Consortium OER Panel eLearning 2013
Community College Consortium OER Panel eLearning 2013Community College Consortium OER Panel eLearning 2013
Community College Consortium OER Panel eLearning 2013
 

More from Marcel Harmon

Deeper Levels of Occupant Engagement to Ensure Energy Savings and Productivit...
Deeper Levels of Occupant Engagement to Ensure Energy Savings and Productivit...Deeper Levels of Occupant Engagement to Ensure Energy Savings and Productivit...
Deeper Levels of Occupant Engagement to Ensure Energy Savings and Productivit...Marcel Harmon
 
“Irrational” Vs “Rational" Behavior: Using Evolutionary Theory & Comprehensiv...
“Irrational” Vs “Rational" Behavior: Using Evolutionary Theory & Comprehensiv...“Irrational” Vs “Rational" Behavior: Using Evolutionary Theory & Comprehensiv...
“Irrational” Vs “Rational" Behavior: Using Evolutionary Theory & Comprehensiv...Marcel Harmon
 
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2014
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2014Sustainable building fundamentals class 2014
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2014Marcel Harmon
 
The Human Side of Achieving Sustainable Success
The Human Side of Achieving Sustainable SuccessThe Human Side of Achieving Sustainable Success
The Human Side of Achieving Sustainable SuccessMarcel Harmon
 
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2013
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2013Sustainable building fundamentals class 2013
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2013Marcel Harmon
 
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 2
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 2The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 2
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 2Marcel Harmon
 
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 1
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 1The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 1
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 1Marcel Harmon
 
Creating environments that promote efficiency and sustainability: anthropolog...
Creating environments that promote efficiency and sustainability: anthropolog...Creating environments that promote efficiency and sustainability: anthropolog...
Creating environments that promote efficiency and sustainability: anthropolog...Marcel Harmon
 
2012 Benefits of Green Schools Panel Selected Bibliography
2012 Benefits of Green Schools Panel Selected Bibliography2012 Benefits of Green Schools Panel Selected Bibliography
2012 Benefits of Green Schools Panel Selected BibliographyMarcel Harmon
 
The Decision to Go Green: Individual vs. Group Influences on Our Likelihood t...
The Decision to Go Green: Individual vs. Group Influences on Our Likelihood t...The Decision to Go Green: Individual vs. Group Influences on Our Likelihood t...
The Decision to Go Green: Individual vs. Group Influences on Our Likelihood t...Marcel Harmon
 
High Performance Refers to People Too
High Performance Refers to People TooHigh Performance Refers to People Too
High Performance Refers to People TooMarcel Harmon
 
Creating Environments That Promote Efficiency and Sustainability: Anthropolog...
Creating Environments That Promote Efficiency and Sustainability: Anthropolog...Creating Environments That Promote Efficiency and Sustainability: Anthropolog...
Creating Environments That Promote Efficiency and Sustainability: Anthropolog...Marcel Harmon
 
Energy Star Vs. Peer Group
Energy Star Vs. Peer GroupEnergy Star Vs. Peer Group
Energy Star Vs. Peer GroupMarcel Harmon
 

More from Marcel Harmon (13)

Deeper Levels of Occupant Engagement to Ensure Energy Savings and Productivit...
Deeper Levels of Occupant Engagement to Ensure Energy Savings and Productivit...Deeper Levels of Occupant Engagement to Ensure Energy Savings and Productivit...
Deeper Levels of Occupant Engagement to Ensure Energy Savings and Productivit...
 
“Irrational” Vs “Rational" Behavior: Using Evolutionary Theory & Comprehensiv...
“Irrational” Vs “Rational" Behavior: Using Evolutionary Theory & Comprehensiv...“Irrational” Vs “Rational" Behavior: Using Evolutionary Theory & Comprehensiv...
“Irrational” Vs “Rational" Behavior: Using Evolutionary Theory & Comprehensiv...
 
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2014
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2014Sustainable building fundamentals class 2014
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2014
 
The Human Side of Achieving Sustainable Success
The Human Side of Achieving Sustainable SuccessThe Human Side of Achieving Sustainable Success
The Human Side of Achieving Sustainable Success
 
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2013
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2013Sustainable building fundamentals class 2013
Sustainable building fundamentals class 2013
 
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 2
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 2The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 2
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 2
 
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 1
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 1The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 1
The commissioning agent as anthropologist: part 1
 
Creating environments that promote efficiency and sustainability: anthropolog...
Creating environments that promote efficiency and sustainability: anthropolog...Creating environments that promote efficiency and sustainability: anthropolog...
Creating environments that promote efficiency and sustainability: anthropolog...
 
2012 Benefits of Green Schools Panel Selected Bibliography
2012 Benefits of Green Schools Panel Selected Bibliography2012 Benefits of Green Schools Panel Selected Bibliography
2012 Benefits of Green Schools Panel Selected Bibliography
 
The Decision to Go Green: Individual vs. Group Influences on Our Likelihood t...
The Decision to Go Green: Individual vs. Group Influences on Our Likelihood t...The Decision to Go Green: Individual vs. Group Influences on Our Likelihood t...
The Decision to Go Green: Individual vs. Group Influences on Our Likelihood t...
 
High Performance Refers to People Too
High Performance Refers to People TooHigh Performance Refers to People Too
High Performance Refers to People Too
 
Creating Environments That Promote Efficiency and Sustainability: Anthropolog...
Creating Environments That Promote Efficiency and Sustainability: Anthropolog...Creating Environments That Promote Efficiency and Sustainability: Anthropolog...
Creating Environments That Promote Efficiency and Sustainability: Anthropolog...
 
Energy Star Vs. Peer Group
Energy Star Vs. Peer GroupEnergy Star Vs. Peer Group
Energy Star Vs. Peer Group
 

Healthy Schools Lecture

  • 1. HEALTHY SCHOOLS ARCH 730; Fall 2012 The Environmental Psychology of Health & Well‐Being Wescoe 1007 Thurs 7:10 9:00pm 1007 Thurs 7:10‐9:00pm Instructor: Keith Diaz Moore, PhD, AIA Guest Lecturer: Marcel Harmon, PhD, PE, LEED‐AP O+M GENUINE  |  PROGRESSIVE  |  ADVOCATES
  • 2. Tonight’s Topics School / Community Reciprocal Relationships and their  impact on student / teacher health and well‐being. impact on student / teacher health and well‐being • School Impacts on Community • Community Impacts on School • Transportation / Walkability Transportation / Walkability Interior Environmental Impacts • Acoustics • Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) d i li ( ) • Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort • Lighting / Views • Food Environment Exterior Environmental Impacts • Playgrounds
  • 3. Some Background Why Environmental Health Matters in Schools • Children spend 30‐50 hours per week in and around school  facilities, on the bus, after school programs/events, etc. f ili i h b f h l / • The majority of that time is spent indoors • The average age of school facilities in the U S is 42 years The average age of school facilities in the U.S. is 42 years.
  • 4. Some Background Why Environmental Health Matters in Schools • Maintenance (infrastructure and  staffing), upgrades and  additions/renovations are often  deferred because of initial cost and  school district limited budgets.
  • 5. Some Background Why Environmental Health Matters in Schools • Our mental machinery and physiologies evolved for exterior  environmental input, while growing up, learning and living in small  l hl l dl ll communities. • Children's’ immature and developing physiologies and mental  Children s immature and developing physiologies and mental machinery are more susceptible to disruption from poor  environmental conditions.
  • 6. Some Background Why Evolutionary Theory Matters to Healthy Schools Wilson, D. S. (2011) The Neighborhood Project: Using Evolution to Improve My City,  One Block at a Time. Hachette Book Group, New York, NY. O Bl k Ti H h B kG N Y k NY Binghamton Neighborhood Project (BNP): Science Based Solutions to Real World  Problems in Our Community ‐ http://bnp.binghamton.edu/. EVOS – Evolutionary Studies Program at Binghamton University ‐ http://evolution.binghamton.edu/evos/.  Wilson’s epiphany: Darwin’s theory won’t fully  prove itself until it improves the quality of human  life in a practical sense.
  • 7. School Impacts on Community Lindsey‐Steiner Elementary, Portales, NM
  • 8. School Impacts on Community Lindsey‐Steiner Elementary, Portales, NM
  • 9. Community Impacts on School Surrounding Air Quality USA Today Special Report: The Smokestack Effect ‐ Toxicity and  America s Schools America’s Schools • http://content.usatoday.com/news/nation/environment/smok estack/index • Used EPA model to track path of industrial pollution and  mapped the locations of almost 128,000 schools to determine  the locations of toxic chemicals outside. the locations of toxic chemicals outside
  • 10. Community Impacts on School Hurley Elementary, Hurley, NM Train Tracks Impacts • Railroad Tracks – noise and fumes Railroad Tracks  noise and fumes • Poverty • Area Air Quality • National Rank of 67th percentile (85,947 of 127,809 schools have worse air.) • Sulfuric acid most responsible for toxicity outside this school. • Chino Mines Co., Hurley, New Mexico • Phelps Dodge Tyrone Inc., Tyrone, New Mexico
  • 11. Community Impacts on School Baca/Dlo'ay azhi Community School, Prewitt, NM Bar Baca Impacts • Proximity to bar • Area Air Quality • National Rank of 59th percentile (75,175 of 127,809 schools have worse air. • Manganese and manganese compounds (50%) and cobalt and cobalt  compounds (46%) most responsible for the toxicity outside this school • Tri‐State Generation & Transmission ‐ Escalante St, Prewitt, New Mexico
  • 12. Community Impacts on School Woodlawn Elementary, Lawrence, KS Train Tracks ICL Plant ICL Plant Impacts • Train Tracks – not the  same issue as at Hurley  same issue as at Hurley for sound/fumes, but a  walkability issue. • Area Air Quality • National Rank of 47th percentile (59,823 of 127,809 schools have worse air) h • Manganese compounds (38%), Sulfuric acid (35%) and Lead/lead compounds (16%) • Lawrence Energy Center, Lawrence, Kansas • Schlumberger Technology Corp Lawrence Product Center, Lawrence, Kansas Schlumberger Technology Corp Lawrence Product Center, Lawrence, Kansas • Griffin Wheel Co Kansas City Plant, Kansas City, Kansas • Nearman Creek Power Station, Kansas City, Kansas
  • 13. Transportation / Walkability Baca/Dlo'ay azhi Community School, Prewitt, NM • Long Bus Rides – Pros/Cons • Long Teacher / Staff Commutes
  • 18. School / Community Compare / Contrast New York Langston Hughes • Current Enrollment: 174 students Current Enrollment: 174 students • Current Enrollment: 475 students Current Enrollment: 475 students • 77.05% low SES • 12.10% low SES • 1.64% ELL • 5.40% ELL • 12.57% Disabilities • 6.05% Disabilities • 0.23 miles from downtown • 1.15 miles to nearest retail/grocery • Embedded in an established neighborhood • Edge of newer neighborhood • Approx. Weighted Avg. Facility Age: 50 yrs • Approx. Weighted Avg. Facility Age: 13 yrs  National Rank of 49th percentile (62,218 of  • N ti l R k f 49 til (62 218 f National Rank OF 73rd percentile (93,621 of  • N ti l R k OF 73 til (93 621 f 127,809 schools have worse air); polluters: 127,809 schools have worse air) • Lawrence Energy Center, Lawrence,  • Lawrence Energy Center, Lawrence,  Kansas Kansas • Schlumberger Technology Corp  • Schlumberger Technology Corp  Lawrence Product Center, Lawrence,  Lawrence Product Center, Lawrence,  Kansas Kansas • Griffin Wheel Co Kansas City Plant,  Kansas City, Kansas • Nearman Creek Power Station, Kansas  City, Kansas
  • 19. Facility / Site Impacts General Impacts • A study of Chicago and Washington, DC schools found that better school  facilities can add 3 to 4 percentage points to a school s standardized test scores,  facilities can add 3 to 4 percentage points to a school’s standardized test scores, even after controlling for demographic factors. Schneider, Mark. “Public School Facilities and Teaching: Washington, DC and  Chicago,” November 2002. A Report Prepared for the Neighborhood Capital  Budget Group (NCBG). Available at: http://www.ncbg.org/press/press111302.htm.  B d tG (NCBG) A il bl t htt // b / / 111302 ht • Based on actual improvements in design in green schools and based on a very  substantial data set on productivity and test performance of healthier, more  p y p , comfortable study and learning environments, a 3‐5% improvement in learning  ability and test scores in green schools appears reasonable and conservative. Kats, G. 2006 Greening America’s Schools: Costs and Benefits. Capital E. www.cap‐ e.com.  e com
  • 21. Interior Environment Acoustics American National Standards Institute (ANSI) S12.60‐2002, Acoustical Performance Criteria,  Design Requirements and Guidelines for Schools standard • The American Speech‐Language‐Hearing Association (ASHA) endorses the endorses the  ANSI standard and recommends the following criteria for classroom acoustics: • Unoccupied classroom levels must not exceed 35 dBA • The signal‐to‐noise ratio (the difference between the teacher's voice and the The signal to noise ratio (the difference between the teacher s voice and the  background noise) should be at least +15 dB at the child's ears. • Unoccupied classroom reverberation must not surpass 0.6 seconds in smaller  classrooms or 0.7 seconds in larger rooms. You can access the standard at the following (2) websites: • http://www.asha.org/public/hearing/American‐National‐Standard‐on‐Classroom‐Acoustics/ • http://acousticalsociety.org/about_acoustics/acoustics_of_classrooms Impacts • Intelligibility, understanding and learning • Focus and concentration • S Stress  • Voice strain • Privacy
  • 22. Interior Environment Acoustics V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM g 2010 CEFPI James D. MacConnell Award Finalist BUILDING DATA 418,000 s.f. 2,350 Students $ $120 M Construction $11.5M FF&E + Tech 7 Academies
  • 23. Interior Environment Acoustics V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM ANSI/ASA S12.60‐ / 2010  Sound  Measurements Analysis:  ANSI/ASA S12.60‐2010 PERMITS GREATEST WEIGHTED SOUND LEVEL OF 35 DB FOR CORE LEARNING SPACES LESS THAN 10,000 GSF AND 40 DB FOR CORE LEARNING SPACES GREATER THAN 10,000 GSF .  THE LARGE CORE LEARNING AREAS ARE SUBSTANTIALLY OVER THE PERMITTED TOLERANCES, AND THE HVAC IS SPECIFICALLY SCHEDULED “OFF” WHEN THESE CLASSROOMS ARE OCCUPIED.
  • 24. Interior Environment Acoustics High ceiling spaces without lay‐in ceilings • Described as noisy, with decreased audibility • Supported by instantaneous sound level measurements • Some of these spaces set to “unoccupied” in BAS  system during class periods to minimize distracting  noise i • But data loggers demonstrated that this could result in  a less thermally comfortable space • These spaces may require: These spaces may require: • Addition of sound absorbing surfaces • T&B • Duct acoustic liners or other HVAC sound control Duct acoustic liners or other HVAC sound control  methods V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM
  • 25. Interior Environment Acoustics Q19: Average Intelligibility Rating 7.00 6.00 5.36 5.36 5.36 5.17 5.17 5.17 5.00 4.75 4.00 3.86 Mean 3.00 2.00 1.00 Cordley Hillcrest Kennedy New York Pinckney Sunset Hill Group 1 Langston  Hughes Lawrence, KS School District
  • 26. Interior Environment Acoustics & Spatial Restrictions Survey Quotes: • Kennedy (Early Childhood Special Ed): “There are four of us sharing ‘office’ space which  we make phone calls and also connected to a therapy space ‐‐ it can be very  overwhelming at times and difficult to concentrate on all of the paperwork that we are  required to do. required to do.” • New York (Resource Room): “I share a resource room and at times we have four  different groups being taught in this space. It gets distracting for all students and staff at  times like this.” Lawrence, KS School District
  • 27. Interior Environment Acoustics & Spatial Restrictions 2 2 2 2 2 2 1 2 2 3 2 Approximate location of small  # group activities plus the # of  students engaged in those  t d t d i th activities. Sunset Hill 5th Grade Classroom Sunset Hill 5 Grade Classroom • This 5th grade classroom has 28 desks; at the time of the observations there were 25 students present. This  classroom provides an example of the crowding that occurs in the district’s elementary schools, particularly  the upper grades.  • The desks end up taking up the vast majority of the floor area and t makes it difficult to find enough space to  work in small groups (and still maintain some level of separation between the small groups). • Exacerbates noise and thermal comfort issues, negatively impacting focus/concentration. Lawrence, KS School District
  • 28. Interior Environment Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) • Schools with high IAQ total scores and a high Healthy Greenness School Index  (GSI) were more likely to have high student attendance rates (36% and 22%  respectively).  • Schools with well maintained air filters were also 42% more likely to have good  4th grade academic performance.  Lin, S., C. Kielb, A. Orsini & N. Muscatiello The Evaluation of Green School Building  Attributes and Their Effect on the Health and Performance of Students and  Teachers in New York State. Final Project Report ‐ Proposal Number: #147 funded  by the US Green Building Council.  http://www.usgbc.org/ShowFile.aspx?DocumentID 8627.  http://www.usgbc.org/ShowFile.aspx?DocumentID=8627. • An analysis of two school districts in Illinois found that student attendance rose  by 5% after incorporating cost effective indoor air quality improvements. Illinois Healthy Schools Campaign, “Apparently Size Doesn’t Matter: Two Illinois School  Illi i H lth S h l C i “A tl Si D ’t M tt T Illi i S h l Districts Show Successful IAQ Management.” School Health Watch, Summer 2003.  http://healthyschoolscampaign.org/news/newsletter/2003‐summer_HSC‐ newsletter.pdf. Also see: US Environmental Protection Agency. “IAQ Tools for Schools,”  December 2000 (Second Edition). Available at: http://www.epa.gov/iaq/schools/. 
  • 29. Interior Environment Indoor Air Quality (IAQ) Landscaping Impacts IAQ Increased Cleaning & Poorer IAQ VE/Defer Landscaping V. Sue Cleveland High School,  Rio Rancho, NM
  • 30. Interior Environment Indoor Air Quality Q 17: Average Air Quality Rating 7.00 7 00 6.00 5.25 5.00 4.67 4.43 4.43 3.97 4.00 3.75 3.72 3.76 Mean 3.00 2.00 1.00 Cordley Hillcrest Kennedy New York Pinckney Sunset Hill Group 1 Langston  Hughes Lawrence, KS School District
  • 31. Interior Environment Indoor Air Quality ASHRAE Design Standard for Schools g • CO2 maximum of 1,000 ppm, and not exceeding the outdoor concentration by  more than about 650 ppm when the exterior outdoor CO2 concentration is 380  ppm. • Based on studies linking CO2 levels above these limits to drowsiness, lethargy, poor  concentration, respiratory ailments, headaches, and other negative health impacts.  • These negative impacts are not necessarily a direct result of the CO2 levels found  indoors (typically less than 5000 ppm), but the higher pollution rates in general that  occur as a result of not having enough outside air, or adequate ventilation. • ASHRAE ventilation requirements are intended to provide enough fresh air to dilute  interior pollutants, and the CO2 levels end up being a good way to measure if you  interior pollutants and the CO2 levels end up being a good way to measure if you have adequate ventilation inside your buildings. Lawrence, KS School District
  • 32. Interior Environment Indoor Air Quality 4,000 4,000 3,000 3,000 CO PPM CO PPM 2,000 2,000 O2 O2 1,000 1,000 0 0 Kennedy Langston Hughes
  • 33. Interior Environments Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort • Activity Levels Activity Levels • Clothing Insulative Properties • Air Temperature • Air Movement /  • Mean Radiant  Velocity Velocit Temperature • Relative Humidity
  • 34. Interior Environments Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort Limitations • ASHRAE Standard 55 2004 and the ISO 7730 Standard for Moderate ASHRAE Standard 55‐2004 and the ISO 7730 Standard for Moderate  Thermal Environments are based on experimental studies of adults,  not children.  • New ‘adaptive’ models of thermal comfort have not been incorporated  New  adaptive models of thermal comfort have not been incorporated into school HVAC systems standards. Student metabolic rates vary as  they move between rooms or activities. • HVAC system design focuses almost exclusively on the thermal and HVAC system design focuses almost exclusively on the thermal and  humidity specifications as directed by building codes. Internal mixing,  air velocities, and vertical temperature gradients are rarely addressed. Committee to Review and Assess the Health and  Committee to Review and Assess the Health and Productivity Benefits of Green Schools (National  Research Council, 2006:65‐66)
  • 35. Interior Environments Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort Personal Control Increased tenant environmental control have been found to  I dt t i t l t lh b f dt provide average measured workforce productivity gains of: • 7.1% with lighting control 7.1% with lighting control  • 1.8% with ventilation control • 1.2% with thermal control Kats, G., L. Alevantis, A. Berman, E. Mills, and J. Perlman, 2003.  The Costs and Financial Benefits of Green Building: A Report to  California’s Sustainable Building Task Force. 
  • 36. Interior Environments Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort V. Sue Cleveland High School Survey Responses • Teachers, Staff and Administrators: Spaces are only thermally Teachers, Staff and Administrators: Spaces are only thermally  acceptable (ASHRAE definition) during the fall (ranges from 66% ‐ 75%  for other three seasons) • Students: Not thermally acceptable during any season (ranges from Students: Not thermally acceptable during any season (ranges from   32% ‐ 51% for all four seasons).
  • 37. Interior Environments Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort V. Sue Cleveland Benefits of Personal Control • Surveys focus groups and interviews: Expressed strong Surveys, focus groups and interviews: Expressed strong  appreciation of and desire for local temperature control . • Productivity increases with increasing personal control over  temperature and ventilation. temperat re and entilation • Having control mitigates some of the negative perceptions  associated with non‐optimal HVAC system performance • “being able to monitor my own classroom temperature  … is GREAT!!!”
  • 38. Interior Environments Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort V. Sue Cleveland Correlation Between Temperature Control and  Thermal Comfort Ratings Thermal Comfort Ratings • Spearman’s Rho test: found a positive correlation between adult  temperature control effectiveness ratings and their thermal  comfort ratings. comfort ratings • Contributing factor for the more positive adult thermal comfort  ratings.
  • 40. Interior Environments Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort Clothing Variability Signage Computers T‐Shirt Logos Messages using images,  graphics, text, student  Flat  generated videos displaying /  / Screens promoting desired behavior Spread using existing school Spread using existing school  means or others – be  creative and relevant to your  Smart Phones audience
  • 41. Interior Environments Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort Q 13: Average Thermal Comfort Rating 7.00 6.00 5.00 4.80 4.57 3.93 3.95 4.07 3.92 4.00 3.75 Mean M 3.17 3.00 2.00 1.00 Cordley Hillcrest Kennedy New York Pinckney Sunset Hill Group 1 Langston  Hughes
  • 42. Interior Environments Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort New York Classroom Sunset Hill Classroom Pinckney Classroom New York Classroom New York Classroom Closure of Blinds: Frequently observed that blinds were closed in the down position, allowing heat  gain to still occur in the occupied zone as well as creating a source of horizontal band glare (direct and  reflected). Closing blinds in the up position minimizes this as well as throws additional light up and  into the space (if blinds not completely closed). District should consider an education initiative to  change how people close their blinds.
  • 43. Interior Environments Temperature / RH / Thermal Comfort Clothing Layering • Layering of clothing is a district‐wide approach.  • Students from low SES families own less clothing limiting their ability to layer New York has clothing Students from low SES families own less clothing, limiting their ability to layer. New York has clothing  available for these students to use.  • Source of inequity between those schools with high percentages of low SES families and those without: • Kennedy Survey Comment: “When students have to wear jackets/sweaters etc., many students only  have one coat. That is it. They can t or don t bring layers. It is hard to teach in a cold classroom with  have one coat That is it They can't or don't bring layers It is hard to teach in a cold classroom with students in coats.”  • Langston Hughes Survey Comment: Related comment that they have to call parents to bring additional  layers – something that many parents at the east schools can’t do. Cordley Clothing Observed: 9/14/2012 Pinckney Clothing Observed: 8/27/2012
  • 44. Interior Environments Lighting / Views Compared to little or no daylighting,  classrooms with appropriate  daylighting may increase the rate of  student learning by: student learning by: • 20% in math • 26% in reading Heschong Mahone Group. 1999. Daylighting in Schools:  An Investigation into the Relationship Between Daylight  and Human Performance. Report submitted to Pacific Gas  and Electric. http://www.h‐m‐g.com. 
  • 45. Interior Environments Lighting / Views Communication, Education & Buy‐In Edward Gonzales Elementary School  Edward Gonzales Elementary  Classroom School, Albuquerque, NM
  • 47. Interior Environments Lighting / Views V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM • Lack of Adequate Daylighting Control Lack of Adequate Daylighting • South Facing Windows and Some East/West  Windows: Shades with relatively high openness  value. value • Remaining Windows: No shades, curtains or blinds • No Other Means of Daylight Control
  • 48. Interior Environments Lighting / Views V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM Percentage  Survey Question of Teacher Responses Reflected images of the windows/skylights appear on my work  surface, PC monitor, and/or on the smart board/white board/chalk  f d/ h b d/ h b d/ h lk board. 49% Windows/skylights create glare in my field of vision as I work. 37% Direct sunlight falls on my work surface, PC monitor, and/or on the  smart board/white board/chalk board, washing it out and making  b d/ hi b d/ h lk b d hi i d ki it difficult to see what I’m working on. 47% Percentage Top three reasons for closing blinds/shades (or covering windows  o of  with paper for those without blinds/shades) ih f h ih bli d / h d ) Responses Direct sunlight falling on my work surface, PC monitor, and/or on  the smart board/white board/chalk board  42% y , , / Reflection of the windows on my work surface, PC monitor, and/or  on the smart board/white board/chalk board  24% Distracting Views 22%
  • 49. Interior Environments Lighting / Views V. Sue Cleveland High School, Rio Rancho, NM • E i Estimated quantitative impacts from lack of adequate  d i i i f l k f d daylighting control Estimated Teacher/Staff Annual Productivity  Delta Due to Lack of Adequate Daylighting Control ‐$169,457 ‐$169 457 Estimated Impact of Glare on Student Math  Scores ‐1.50% Estimated Impact of Glare on Student Reading  Scores ‐‐0.91%
  • 50. Interior Environments Lighting / Views Lawrence, KS School District – Available Daylight Deerfield, Broken Arrow Cordley, Hillcrest, Kennedy,  Langston Hughes,  New York, Hillcrest, Sunset Hill,  Prairie Park, Quail Run,  P i i P k Q il R Schwegler, Woodlawn S h l W dl Sunflower Potential 20% delta in math scores Potential 26% delta in reading scores
  • 51. Interior Environments Food Environment Some Important Factors Associated w/ Lunch (and Breakfast to a Lesser Extent) • School provided meals (and weekend assistance programs) often provide a School provided meals (and weekend assistance programs) often provide a  significant portion of low SES student nutritional needs. • Breakfast and lunch are important for keeping kids fueled (mentally and  physically) for the school day. physically) for the school day. • Provide time to eat calmly instead of inhaling food.  Avoid diverting additional  blood from the brain and potentially making students drowsier after lunch  (though many variables are at play here – see Kanarek 1997 and Smith & Maben  1992). • The social/cultural importance of, or “ritual” associated with, meals (part of our  social “glue”) vs. the limited time, highly structured/scheduled nature of most  school lunches. h ll h Kanarek, R. (1997) Psychological Effects of Snacks and Altered Meal Frequency. British Journal of  Nutrition 77, Suppl. 1:S105‐S120. Smith, A. and A. Maben (1992) Effects of Sleep Deprivation, Lunch, and Personality on  Performance, Mood, and Cardiovascular Function. Physiology & Behavior 54:967‐972.
  • 52. Interior Environments Food Environment ‐ Gymacafetorium Issues Sunset Hill Gym as Cafeteria • Smallest “cafeteria” out of the (6) Group 1 schools; completely filled with tables and serving line during  ( ) p ; p y g g lunch; tables must be stored in closet space outside the gym. • Cramped quarters in general typically result in greater sound levels, though the staging of students is such  that (1) row of tables  during each wave is mostly empty; this combined with the music generally keeps  the sound levels as low, if not lower than the other (6) Group 1 schools. • Some of the adults wear earplugs during lunch, and I was offered some to wear. Though Sunset Hill wasn’t  the loudest of the (6) schools, at least on the days I visited. Kennedy was probably the loudest. This raises  the question – if the adults think they need earplugs, then are the students at risk to hearing damage or  additional psychological stress from the noise?
  • 53. Interior Environments Food Environment ‐ Gymacafetorium Issues Kennedy Cafeteria as Cafeteria •H i Having a separate cafeteria from the gym relieves  f i f h li general stress relative to scheduling compared to  schools with gymacafeterias and gymacafetoriums. • (15) round tables + (2) rectangular tables – round  tables are used first and was told that they are more  tables are used first and was told that they are more popular with the students. Round Tables Vs. Rectangular Tables • R Round Table Pros: Easier to interact with all of those at the table and you feel you’re  d T bl P E i t i t t ith ll f th t th t bl d f l ’ eating with a smaller group. • Round Table Cons: Takes up more space, therefore more difficult to use in the smaller  cafeterias and gymacafetoriums; because they potentially encourage interaction more  than rectangular tables, may add to the noise level and make it more difficult for  students to focus on eating their lunch; this is exacerbated by short time available to  eat.
  • 54. Interior Environments Food Environment ‐ Gymacafetorium Issues Total Lunch Period / No. of Sections Total Lunch Period / No. of Students 8.00 0.40 7.00 Cordley Cordley 0.35 6.00 Hillcrest Hillcrest 0.30 5.00 Kennedy 0.25 Kennedy 4.00 New York 0.20 New York 3.00 Pinckney 0.15 Pinckney 2.00 Sunset Hill 0.10 Sunset Hill 1.00 Broken Arrow 0.05 Broken Arrow 0.00 0.00 Deerfield Deerfield Quail Run Quail Run Schwegler Schwegler Total Lunch Period / School Sq. Ft. 3.50E‐03 Cordley 3.00E‐03 Hillcrest 2.50E 03 2 50E‐03 Kennedy 2.00E‐03 New York 1.50E‐03 Pinckney Sunset Hill 1.00E‐03 Broken Arrow 5.00E‐04 5 00E 04 Deerfield 0.00E+00 Quail Run Schwegler Sunflower
  • 55. Interior Environments Food Environment ‐ Gymacafetorium Issues Some of the gyms can get loud during lunch, though most schools take measures to deal with  that with varying success levels. Use of music seemed to have the greatest impact, particularly  that with varying success levels Use of music seemed to have the greatest impact particularly the way it was done at Sunset Hill. • Pinckney: Hand bell to ring to get everyone to quiet down (as well as mark points along  lunch timeline). • Hill Hillcrest: ? t ? • Kennedy: Turned one bank of lights off/on and raised hands to signal students to quiet  down, though volume quickly ratcheted back up; principal eventually did a quick ring of  the alarm to quiet students. • Sunset Hill: Played music (light jazz), but not constantly. Played at least once during each  “wave” of students to help provide them a few minutes of “down time” to focus on eating  (no talking); seemed pretty effective at keeping the students quiet during that time – probably the most effective method among the (6) schools observed. However even here  a large amount of food is wasted. • New York: ? • Cordley: Played music (piano “elevator” music) constantly.; seemed less effective than  Sunset Hill, but more effective than other schools. Sunset Hill, but more effective than other schools.
  • 56. Exterior Environment Playgrounds – Lindsey Steiner Elementary, Portales, NM Playground Considerations • Proper landscaping  • Minimum #/types of equipment • Larger open areas for running playing Larger open areas for running, playing  ball/sports and generally blowing off steam • Shaded areas • Exterior drinking fountains • Separate younger/older playgrounds NA Separate younger/older playgrounds NA
  • 57. Exterior Environment Playgrounds – Hurley Elementary, Hurley, NM Playground Considerations • Proper landscaping  • Minimum #/types of equipment • Larger open areas for running, playing Larger open areas for running, playing  ball/sports and generally blowing off steam • Shaded areas • Exterior drinking fountains • Separate younger/older playgrounds Separate younger/older playgrounds According to the secretary, students are in daily  with bumps, bruises, cuts, stickers, etc.
  • 58. Exterior Environment Playgrounds – Edward Gonzales Elementary, Albuquerque, NM Playground Considerations • Proper landscaping  • Minimum #/types of equipment • LLarger open areas for running, playing  f i l i ball/sports and generally blowing off steam • Shaded areas • Exterior drinking fountains • SSeparate younger/older playgrounds / ld l d More than 200 injuries significant enough to report to the Nurse’s office are logged  every month, and School Nurses estimate 90% of injuries are playground‐related. 
  • 59. Exterior Environment Playgrounds – Hillcrest Elementary, Lawrence, KS Playground Considerations • Proper landscaping  • Minimum #/types of equipment • Larger open areas for running playing Larger open areas for running, playing  ball/sports and generally blowing off steam • Shaded areas • Exterior drinking fountains • Separate younger/older playgrounds Separate younger/older playgrounds Maintenance costs associated with elaborate playgrounds
  • 60. References American National Standards Institute (ANSI) S12.60‐2002, Acoustical Performance Criteria,  Design Requirements and Guidelines for Schools standard  http://www.asha.org/public/hearing/American‐National‐Standard‐on‐Classroom‐Acoustics/ http://acousticalsociety.org/about_acoustics/acoustics_of_classrooms   http://acousticalsociety org/about acoustics/acoustics of classrooms Committee to Review and Assess the Health and Productivity Benefits of Green Schools  (National Research Council, 2006:65‐66). Heschong Mahone Group. 1999. Daylighting in Schools: An Investigation into the Relationship  Between Daylight and Human Performance. Report submitted to Pacific Gas and Electric.  http://www.h‐m‐g.com.  Illinois Healthy Schools Campaign, “Apparently Size Doesn’t Matter: Two Illinois School Districts  Show Successful IAQ Management. School Health Watch Summer 2003 Show Successful IAQ Management ” School Health Watch, Summer 2003.  http://healthyschoolscampaign.org/news/newsletter/2003‐summer_HSC‐newsletter.pdf.  Also see: US Environmental Protection Agency. “IAQ Tools for Schools,” December 2000  (Second Edition). Available at: http://www.epa.gov/iaq/schools/.  Kanarek, R. (1997) Psychological Effects of Snacks and Altered Meal Frequency. British Journal  K k R (1997) P h l i l Eff t f S k d Alt d M l F B iti h J l of Nutrition 77, Suppl. 1:S105‐S120. Kats, G. 2006 Greening America’s Schools: Costs and Benefits. Capital E. www.cap‐e.com.  Kats, G., L. Alevantis, A. Berman, E. Mills, and J. Perlman, 2003. The Costs and Financial  Kats, G., L. Alevantis, A. Berman, E. Mills, and J. Perlman, 2003. The Costs and Financial Benefits of Green Building: A Report to California’s Sustainable Building Task Force. 
  • 61. References Lin, S., C. Kielb, A. Orsini & N. Muscatiello The Evaluation of Green School Building Attributes  and Their Effect on the Health and Performance of Students and Teachers in New York State.  Final Project Report ‐ Proposal Number: #147 funded by the US Green Building Council.  http://www.usgbc.org/ShowFile.aspx?DocumentID=8627.  http://www usgbc org/ShowFile aspx?DocumentID=8627 Schneider, Mark. “Public School Facilities and Teaching: Washington, DC and Chicago,”  November 2002. A Report Prepared for the Neighborhood Capital Budget Group (NCBG).  Available at: http://www.ncbg.org/press/press111302.htm.   Smith, A. and A. Maben (1992) Effects of Sleep Deprivation, Lunch, and Personality on  Performance, Mood, and Cardiovascular Function. Physiology & Behavior 54:967‐972 Treasure, J. Why architects need to use their ears. TED Talk  http://www.ted.com/talks/julian_treasure_why_architects_need_to_use_their_ears.html http://www ted com/talks/julian treasure why architects need to use their ears html USA Today Special Report: The Smokestack Effect ‐ Toxicity and America’s Schools  http://content.usatoday.com/news/nation/environment/smokestack/index Why Environmental Health Matters in Schools ‐ EPA Webinar: 10/17/2012 ‐ https://esbuildings.webex.com/mw0307l/mywebex/default.do?siteurl=esbuildings. Wilson, D. S. (2011) The Neighborhood Project: Using Evolution to Improve My City, One Block  at a Time. Hachette Book Group, New York, NY. Wilson, D. S., D. Tumminelli O Briena and A. Sesmac (2009) Human Prosociality From an  Wilson D S D Tumminelli O'Briena and A Sesmac (2009) Human Prosociality From an Evolutionary Perspective: Variation and Correlations at a City‐Wide Scale. Evolution and  Human Behavior 30:190–200.