SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 7
Baixar para ler offline
Primary Source Analysis: AS Neill’s Letter to Dora Russell
  Laura McInerney – ELPA 9462 – Historical Study Project
Primary Source Analysis: AS Neill’s Letter to Dora Russell



The UK Progressive School movement began in the 1920s in reaction to

severe Victorian principles of schooling and to counteract them

using techniques based on Freud‟s writing. With the expressed

purpose of giving students a more relaxed developmental experience

many news articles labelled them the “Do-As-You-Please” Schools1.



The primary source included here is a letter from AS Neill - the

founder of Summerhill School - to Dora Russell, the co-founder of

Beacon Hill School. The letter was sent in the Spring of 1944

shortly after the closure of Beacon Hill and it was retrieved from

Dora Winifred Russell Archives(1906 – 1986) digitally held by the

International Institute of Social History.                                                       Russell‟s letters are

archived in alphabetical order of correspondent; only 3 letters with

AS Neill are in the archive. None of the letters in Russell‟s

archive are in AS Neill‟s published correspondence2.



The 1944 letter highlights several themes common across the three

schools I am studying in my project3. These themes are: the role of

romantic relationships, financial problems, staffing problems,

compromises of the progressive ethos and the role of journalism in

spreading the progressive message.                                             The relevant sections for each

theme have been highlighted on the source.



Interpretations & Themes in the Source

1 Unknown author, “A Do-As-You-Please School” The Daily News [Colombo, Ceylon] 21 April 1931, in the Dora Winifred Russell paper 1906 – 1986, #13-
9, Inventory 656, International Institute of Social History. Retrieved online 16 September 2012.
2 Croall, J. (1983) All the best, Neill: Letters from Summerhill, London: The Trinity Press
3 The three schools of the project are Beacon Hill (founded by Dora & Bertrand Russell), Summerhill (founded by AS Neill) and Malting House (founded by

Geoffrey Pyke & Susan Isaacs)
1. The Importance of relationships

Neill‟s wife was dying from a stroke when he wrote this letter. The

manner in which he describes her is somewhat shocking. Similar

bluntness about her death is apparent in his autobiography. In fact,

in all of Neill‟s writingthe school seems of far more importance

than his personal relationships. This contrasts with Beacon Hill

where the co-founders‟ divorce causedmany problems4 and at Malting

House where an affair between the founder and headmistress

potentially causedthe headmistresses resignation5. On a

psychoanalytic historical reading6 it appears that in all three

cases the adults were using the schools to meet their desire for

nurturing relationships they were unable to create within their

adult romantic lives.



      2. Financial Problems

Though relationships are important in the history of the schools,

the eventual reason for Beacon Hill and Malting Hill closures were

financial7. In the 1944 letter, Neill describes the financial

problems he is facing and notes that without capital he cannot

expand intake even though the school is popular. Neill continuously

wrote books about Summerhill to bring in extra capital for the

school, and he describes in another letter to Russell how he

downsized location when required to cushion financial losses8.

Without a similar publishing revenue streamBeacon Hill was badly hit

by WWII when the school premises were taken over as a military base

4Russell, Dora, and Countess Russell. The tamarisk tree: my quest for liberty and love. Vol. 1. Putnam, 1975.
5Graham,   Philip. Susan Isaacs: A Life Freeing the Minds of Children: A Life Freeing the Minds of Children. Karnac Books, 2008.
6Cocks, Geoffrey Ed, and Travis L. Crosby. Psycho/history: Readings in the method of psychology, psychoanalysis, and history. Yale University Press,

1987.
7Russell, Dora, and Countess Russell. The tamarisk tree: my quest for liberty and love. Vol. 1. Putnam, 1975.
8 Neill, AS. Letter to Dora Russell, 18 April 1932. Dora Winifred Russell Papers 1906 – 1986, #17-100, Inventory 71, International Institute of Social History.
Retrieved online September 25 2012.
and Russell could not claim compensation as she was only renting –

and did not own – the school property. Malting House closed when the

founder lost allhis money in the 1929 stock crash.



      3. Staffing Problems

All three progressive schools struggled to find „good‟ staff, but as

Neill‟s letter shows it is difficult to know to what extent the

demanding ideals of the founders were the problem. Neill‟s school

demanded people with patience and an openness to non-traditional

atmospheres yet here he laments „hopeless idealists‟ and desires

someone with pragmatism – a difficult blend to find. Neill‟s

suggestion that “Newman had to leave to have her brat” also suggests

she was not able to stay at school while still teaching, however

Dora Russell was the mother of three children, and the third was

only an infant when Russell‟s husband left her to run the school

alone, suggesting that it was possible for women to teach when

tending to children and perhaps suggesting that Summerhill was not

amenable, rather than unable, to provide such an arrangement.



      4. Journalism and Publications

All three sets of school leaders published extensively about their

experiences, initially in magazines and later in books. AS Neill‟s

work became most widely spread in the 1960s, but all three wrote for

(and advertised) in The New Humanist, The New Statesman and Nature

magazine9. In doing so the schools became famous within left-wing

„middle-to-upper‟ class circles which significantly affected intake.



9Advertisements & articles from these magazines are in the ISSH archive for Dora Russell, are published in AS Neill’s correspondence (Croall, ibid) and
are republished in Graham’s autobiography of Susan Isaacs (Ibid).
5. Oceans of Compromise

When AS Neill says that progressive schools have become a

„compromise‟ it appears that he is talking about the fact that so

many of the schools from the 1920s have either closed or had changed

their philosophy to become more „mainstream‟. In order to keep

financially stable and ensure adequate staffing most „gave up‟ on

the Freudian idea.



Synthesis – What parallels can be drawn with US Education?

Although these schools are from a different period than that covered

by the class so far, and from a different country, there is an

important synthesis.

First: Finance is an important driver of change. Though

“progressivism” is considered correct it is foregone when its

founders could no longer fund it. In the US decisions regarding, for

example, gender integration often occur because the alternative was

unaffordable. Even if education leaders felt it more morally

appropriate to have separate sex schools, the lack of money

available meant such segregation did not occur. When considering the

history of schools it is therefore critical to carefully judge

whether money funds ideology, or if it works the other way around.

Secondly: If relationships are so important in the creation of

progressive schools, why are they missing from the histories of

education presented by Joel Spring, Tyack & Hansott, and James

Anderson? In fact, a quick glance at the leading educationalists in

their stories would suggest relationships are vastly important:

  -   Horace Mann’s second wife was Mary Taylor Peabody, a teacher

      who was greatly respected in Massachusetts, advised him on all
aspects of policy and was possibly more an inspiration for his

              working in education over law (as opposed to the riots!)10

      -       Thomas Jefferson had a long-term affair and children with

              Sally Hemmings, one of his slaves, as proven by DNA testing in

              199811. Was this important in his views regarding equality?

      -       Booker T. Washington’s wife, Olivia A. Davidson, was a co-

              founder of Tuskagee College. She trained at Hampton, then at a

              Normal School, was a teacher and an honors student12.

      -       W.E.B. Du Bois had continual affairs throughout his life all

              with highly „academic‟ and celebrate women some of whom were

              white. He had very little to do with his wife and daughter.13



Conclusion

The AS Neill letter is therefore a useful example of the problems

and strategies for success seen in the Progressive School movement

as the schools ambled towards closure or compromise. But more

importantly the letter shows us the importance of human interactions

and how the people in the history of educations had friendships,

romantic relationships and opinions about the people they worked

with. Often in history these relationships are missed out – as is

evidenced by the absence of the women discussed above in US

education history – but these relationships are important and can

help us understand people‟s motives in a new and illuminating way.

The “wives‟ tale” may yet be a missing piece in the history puzzle

that will help us understand how we got from no schooling at all to

where we are right now.

10Marshall,Megan. The Peabody Sisters: Three women who ignited American romanticism. Mariner Books, 2006.
11Smith D. & Wade N. “DNA Test Finds Evidence of Jefferson Child By Slave” The New York Times November 01 1998. Retrieved 31 October 2012.
http://www.nytimes.com/1998/11/01/us/dna-test-finds-evidence-of-jefferson-child-by-slave.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm
12Darlene Clark Hine Black Women in America an Historical Encyclopedia Volumes 1 and 2 (Brooklyn, NY: Carlson Publishing, 1993).
13Lewis, David Levering. WEB Du Bois, 1868-1919: Biography of a Race. Vol. 1. Holt Paperbacks, 1994.
Biblography

Analysed primary source is:

Neill, A.S, Letter to Dora Russell. April 27, 1944. Dora Winifred Russell Papers 1906-1986, #17-102, Inventory
71, International Institute of Social History. Retrieved online September 25 2012.

Additional materials:
Cocks, Geoffrey Ed, and Travis L. Crosby. Psycho/history: Readings in the method of psychology,
psychoanalysis, and history. Yale University Press, 1987.
Croall, J. (1983) All the best, Neill: Letters from Summerhill, London: The Trinity Press
Graham, Philip. Susan Isaacs: A Life Freeing the Minds of Children: A Life Freeing the Minds of
Children. Karnac Books, 2008.
Hine, Darlene Clark Black Women in America an Historical Encyclopedia Volumes 1 and 2 (Brooklyn,
NY: Carlson Publishing, 1993).
Lewis, David Levering. WEB Du Bois, 1868-1919: Biography of a Race. Vol. 1. Holt Paperbacks, 1994.
Marshall, Megan. The Peabody Sisters: Three women who ignited American romanticism. Mariner
Books, 2006.
Neill, AS. Letter to Dora Russell, 18 April 1932. Dora Winifred Russell Papers 1906 – 1986, #17-100,
Inventory 71, International Institute of Social History. Retrieved online September 25 2012.
Russell, Dora, and Countess Russell. The tamarisk tree: my quest for liberty and love. Vol. 1. Putnam,
1975.
Smith D. & Wade N. “DNA Test Finds Evidence of Jefferson Child By Slave” The New York Times
November 01 1998. Retrieved 31 October 2012. http://www.nytimes.com/1998/11/01/us/dna-test-finds-
evidence-of-jefferson-child-by-slave.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm
Unknown author, “A Do-As-You-Please School” The Daily News [Colombo, Ceylon] 21 April 1931, in
the Dora Winifred Russell paper 1906 – 1986, #13-9, Inventory 656, International Institute of Social
History. Retrieved online 16 September 2012.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Diversity in Children's Literature
Diversity in Children's LiteratureDiversity in Children's Literature
Diversity in Children's Literaturehildebka
 
Lydia Child
Lydia ChildLydia Child
Lydia Childaa0232
 
Louisa May Alcott
Louisa May AlcottLouisa May Alcott
Louisa May Alcottmlmabry
 
Biographical Analysis: nalpay a namnama
Biographical Analysis: nalpay a namnamaBiographical Analysis: nalpay a namnama
Biographical Analysis: nalpay a namnamaflattsph
 
English project
English projectEnglish project
English projectjasvin2
 
What is YA Lit 2007 version
What is YA Lit 2007 versionWhat is YA Lit 2007 version
What is YA Lit 2007 versionJohan Koren
 
Muslim Representations in Children’s Literature
 Muslim Representations in Children’s Literature Muslim Representations in Children’s Literature
Muslim Representations in Children’s LiteratureTati D. Wardi Ph.D.
 
SIGMA TAU DELTA 1924 (PDF)
SIGMA TAU DELTA 1924 (PDF)SIGMA TAU DELTA 1924 (PDF)
SIGMA TAU DELTA 1924 (PDF)Betsy Blumenthal
 
Davidson on truth and meaning
Davidson on truth and meaning Davidson on truth and meaning
Davidson on truth and meaning Danica Talabong
 
History Of Childrens Literature
History Of Childrens LiteratureHistory Of Childrens Literature
History Of Childrens LiteratureTalia Mendez
 
"You Can't Unknow:" A Conversation with Ashley Farmer on Inequality and Intel...
"You Can't Unknow:" A Conversation with Ashley Farmer on Inequality and Intel..."You Can't Unknow:" A Conversation with Ashley Farmer on Inequality and Intel...
"You Can't Unknow:" A Conversation with Ashley Farmer on Inequality and Intel...YHRUploads
 

Mais procurados (18)

Context
ContextContext
Context
 
Context
ContextContext
Context
 
Diversity in Children's Literature
Diversity in Children's LiteratureDiversity in Children's Literature
Diversity in Children's Literature
 
Lydia Child
Lydia ChildLydia Child
Lydia Child
 
Gere Books Talk - J.R.R.Tolkien
Gere Books Talk - J.R.R.TolkienGere Books Talk - J.R.R.Tolkien
Gere Books Talk - J.R.R.Tolkien
 
Louisa May Alcott
Louisa May AlcottLouisa May Alcott
Louisa May Alcott
 
Biographical Analysis: nalpay a namnama
Biographical Analysis: nalpay a namnamaBiographical Analysis: nalpay a namnama
Biographical Analysis: nalpay a namnama
 
English project
English projectEnglish project
English project
 
What is YA Lit 2007 version
What is YA Lit 2007 versionWhat is YA Lit 2007 version
What is YA Lit 2007 version
 
Little women
Little womenLittle women
Little women
 
Muslim Representations in Children’s Literature
 Muslim Representations in Children’s Literature Muslim Representations in Children’s Literature
Muslim Representations in Children’s Literature
 
September 1 (71)
September 1 (71)September 1 (71)
September 1 (71)
 
SIGMA TAU DELTA 1924 (PDF)
SIGMA TAU DELTA 1924 (PDF)SIGMA TAU DELTA 1924 (PDF)
SIGMA TAU DELTA 1924 (PDF)
 
Davidson on truth and meaning
Davidson on truth and meaning Davidson on truth and meaning
Davidson on truth and meaning
 
Toni morrison
Toni  morrisonToni  morrison
Toni morrison
 
History Of Childrens Literature
History Of Childrens LiteratureHistory Of Childrens Literature
History Of Childrens Literature
 
Book Reviews
Book ReviewsBook Reviews
Book Reviews
 
"You Can't Unknow:" A Conversation with Ashley Farmer on Inequality and Intel...
"You Can't Unknow:" A Conversation with Ashley Farmer on Inequality and Intel..."You Can't Unknow:" A Conversation with Ashley Farmer on Inequality and Intel...
"You Can't Unknow:" A Conversation with Ashley Farmer on Inequality and Intel...
 

Semelhante a Primary source analysis laura mc inerney

(2014) Supplementary Notes for Dr. Bennett’s PowerPoint Presentation – 11/2014
(2014) Supplementary Notes for Dr. Bennett’s PowerPoint Presentation – 11/2014(2014) Supplementary Notes for Dr. Bennett’s PowerPoint Presentation – 11/2014
(2014) Supplementary Notes for Dr. Bennett’s PowerPoint Presentation – 11/2014K-12 STUDY CANADA
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioacallender1
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioacallender1
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioacallender1
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioacallender1
 
Systematic destruction of_american_education-fawcett-1981-1pg-edu
Systematic destruction of_american_education-fawcett-1981-1pg-eduSystematic destruction of_american_education-fawcett-1981-1pg-edu
Systematic destruction of_american_education-fawcett-1981-1pg-eduRareBooksnRecords
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioacallender1
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioacallender1
 
Elpa 9462 history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerney
Elpa 9462   history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerneyElpa 9462   history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerney
Elpa 9462 history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerneylauramcinerney
 
First Generation College Student Essay. Narrative Essay: First generation essay
First Generation College Student Essay. Narrative Essay: First generation essayFirst Generation College Student Essay. Narrative Essay: First generation essay
First Generation College Student Essay. Narrative Essay: First generation essayHeather Green
 
Freire and horton we make the road by walking
Freire and horton   we make the road by walkingFreire and horton   we make the road by walking
Freire and horton we make the road by walkingKatarina Dr Popovic
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioacallender1
 
A Essay About School.pdf
A Essay About School.pdfA Essay About School.pdf
A Essay About School.pdfJulie Johnson
 
Up from slavery
Up from slaveryUp from slavery
Up from slaveryjasiya4u
 
African american psychology
African american psychologyAfrican american psychology
African american psychologyPheismet
 
Charles Horten cooley, Jane Adam, Robert k Merton
Charles Horten cooley, Jane Adam, Robert k MertonCharles Horten cooley, Jane Adam, Robert k Merton
Charles Horten cooley, Jane Adam, Robert k MertonMoosa kaleem
 
Malcolm Knowles
Malcolm KnowlesMalcolm Knowles
Malcolm KnowlesJack Frost
 

Semelhante a Primary source analysis laura mc inerney (20)

(2014) Supplementary Notes for Dr. Bennett’s PowerPoint Presentation – 11/2014
(2014) Supplementary Notes for Dr. Bennett’s PowerPoint Presentation – 11/2014(2014) Supplementary Notes for Dr. Bennett’s PowerPoint Presentation – 11/2014
(2014) Supplementary Notes for Dr. Bennett’s PowerPoint Presentation – 11/2014
 
Kelley and Mickenberg
Kelley and MickenbergKelley and Mickenberg
Kelley and Mickenberg
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolio
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolio
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolio
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolio
 
Systematic destruction of_american_education-fawcett-1981-1pg-edu
Systematic destruction of_american_education-fawcett-1981-1pg-eduSystematic destruction of_american_education-fawcett-1981-1pg-edu
Systematic destruction of_american_education-fawcett-1981-1pg-edu
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolio
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolio
 
Elpa 9462 history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerney
Elpa 9462   history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerneyElpa 9462   history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerney
Elpa 9462 history of us education policy - project proposal - laura mc inerney
 
First Generation College Student Essay. Narrative Essay: First generation essay
First Generation College Student Essay. Narrative Essay: First generation essayFirst Generation College Student Essay. Narrative Essay: First generation essay
First Generation College Student Essay. Narrative Essay: First generation essay
 
Freire and horton we make the road by walking
Freire and horton   we make the road by walkingFreire and horton   we make the road by walking
Freire and horton we make the road by walking
 
Mass Media Essays
Mass Media EssaysMass Media Essays
Mass Media Essays
 
Multi cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolioMulti cultural literature portfolio
Multi cultural literature portfolio
 
The Vogue Of The Lady
The Vogue Of The LadyThe Vogue Of The Lady
The Vogue Of The Lady
 
A Essay About School.pdf
A Essay About School.pdfA Essay About School.pdf
A Essay About School.pdf
 
Up from slavery
Up from slaveryUp from slavery
Up from slavery
 
African american psychology
African american psychologyAfrican american psychology
African american psychology
 
Charles Horten cooley, Jane Adam, Robert k Merton
Charles Horten cooley, Jane Adam, Robert k MertonCharles Horten cooley, Jane Adam, Robert k Merton
Charles Horten cooley, Jane Adam, Robert k Merton
 
Malcolm Knowles
Malcolm KnowlesMalcolm Knowles
Malcolm Knowles
 

Mais de lauramcinerney

Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Page
Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One PageEducational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Page
Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Pagelauramcinerney
 
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...lauramcinerney
 
Middle tier structure (1)
Middle tier   structure (1)Middle tier   structure (1)
Middle tier structure (1)lauramcinerney
 
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letter
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letterE act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letter
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letterlauramcinerney
 
Ico decision notice lm
Ico decision notice   lmIco decision notice   lm
Ico decision notice lmlauramcinerney
 
Research ed presentation notes handout
Research ed presentation notes handoutResearch ed presentation notes handout
Research ed presentation notes handoutlauramcinerney
 
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013lauramcinerney
 
Poster presentation engineering culture
Poster presentation   engineering culturePoster presentation   engineering culture
Poster presentation engineering culturelauramcinerney
 
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012lauramcinerney
 
Young people in the media
Young people in the mediaYoung people in the media
Young people in the medialauramcinerney
 
Ashars citizenship work
Ashars citizenship workAshars citizenship work
Ashars citizenship worklauramcinerney
 

Mais de lauramcinerney (20)

Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Page
Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One PageEducational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Page
Educational Excellence Everywhere White Paper: On One Page
 
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...
Research Ed Talk - 2014 - Laura McInerney - 5 Big Mistakes When Writing & Tal...
 
Middle tier structure (1)
Middle tier   structure (1)Middle tier   structure (1)
Middle tier structure (1)
 
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letter
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letterE act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letter
E act multi-academy trust inspection outcome letter
 
Rotherham tbnp
Rotherham tbnpRotherham tbnp
Rotherham tbnp
 
Ico decision notice lm
Ico decision notice   lmIco decision notice   lm
Ico decision notice lm
 
Research ed presentation notes handout
Research ed presentation notes handoutResearch ed presentation notes handout
Research ed presentation notes handout
 
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013
How the TouchPaper Problems could save us all - Researched 2013
 
Poster presentation engineering culture
Poster presentation   engineering culturePoster presentation   engineering culture
Poster presentation engineering culture
 
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012
FOI GCSE English Controlled Assessment Marks 2012
 
Young people in the media
Young people in the mediaYoung people in the media
Young people in the media
 
Parth proof
Parth proofParth proof
Parth proof
 
Citizen cw
Citizen cwCitizen cw
Citizen cw
 
#1 citizen animation
#1 citizen animation#1 citizen animation
#1 citizen animation
 
Ashars citizenship work
Ashars citizenship workAshars citizenship work
Ashars citizenship work
 
EMA Campaign Update
EMA Campaign UpdateEMA Campaign Update
EMA Campaign Update
 
Jazz riot sentencing
Jazz   riot sentencingJazz   riot sentencing
Jazz riot sentencing
 
Ahmed's work
Ahmed's workAhmed's work
Ahmed's work
 
Ahmed's petition
Ahmed's petitionAhmed's petition
Ahmed's petition
 
Bhavik citz
Bhavik citzBhavik citz
Bhavik citz
 

Primary source analysis laura mc inerney

  • 1. Primary Source Analysis: AS Neill’s Letter to Dora Russell Laura McInerney – ELPA 9462 – Historical Study Project
  • 2. Primary Source Analysis: AS Neill’s Letter to Dora Russell The UK Progressive School movement began in the 1920s in reaction to severe Victorian principles of schooling and to counteract them using techniques based on Freud‟s writing. With the expressed purpose of giving students a more relaxed developmental experience many news articles labelled them the “Do-As-You-Please” Schools1. The primary source included here is a letter from AS Neill - the founder of Summerhill School - to Dora Russell, the co-founder of Beacon Hill School. The letter was sent in the Spring of 1944 shortly after the closure of Beacon Hill and it was retrieved from Dora Winifred Russell Archives(1906 – 1986) digitally held by the International Institute of Social History. Russell‟s letters are archived in alphabetical order of correspondent; only 3 letters with AS Neill are in the archive. None of the letters in Russell‟s archive are in AS Neill‟s published correspondence2. The 1944 letter highlights several themes common across the three schools I am studying in my project3. These themes are: the role of romantic relationships, financial problems, staffing problems, compromises of the progressive ethos and the role of journalism in spreading the progressive message. The relevant sections for each theme have been highlighted on the source. Interpretations & Themes in the Source 1 Unknown author, “A Do-As-You-Please School” The Daily News [Colombo, Ceylon] 21 April 1931, in the Dora Winifred Russell paper 1906 – 1986, #13- 9, Inventory 656, International Institute of Social History. Retrieved online 16 September 2012. 2 Croall, J. (1983) All the best, Neill: Letters from Summerhill, London: The Trinity Press 3 The three schools of the project are Beacon Hill (founded by Dora & Bertrand Russell), Summerhill (founded by AS Neill) and Malting House (founded by Geoffrey Pyke & Susan Isaacs)
  • 3. 1. The Importance of relationships Neill‟s wife was dying from a stroke when he wrote this letter. The manner in which he describes her is somewhat shocking. Similar bluntness about her death is apparent in his autobiography. In fact, in all of Neill‟s writingthe school seems of far more importance than his personal relationships. This contrasts with Beacon Hill where the co-founders‟ divorce causedmany problems4 and at Malting House where an affair between the founder and headmistress potentially causedthe headmistresses resignation5. On a psychoanalytic historical reading6 it appears that in all three cases the adults were using the schools to meet their desire for nurturing relationships they were unable to create within their adult romantic lives. 2. Financial Problems Though relationships are important in the history of the schools, the eventual reason for Beacon Hill and Malting Hill closures were financial7. In the 1944 letter, Neill describes the financial problems he is facing and notes that without capital he cannot expand intake even though the school is popular. Neill continuously wrote books about Summerhill to bring in extra capital for the school, and he describes in another letter to Russell how he downsized location when required to cushion financial losses8. Without a similar publishing revenue streamBeacon Hill was badly hit by WWII when the school premises were taken over as a military base 4Russell, Dora, and Countess Russell. The tamarisk tree: my quest for liberty and love. Vol. 1. Putnam, 1975. 5Graham, Philip. Susan Isaacs: A Life Freeing the Minds of Children: A Life Freeing the Minds of Children. Karnac Books, 2008. 6Cocks, Geoffrey Ed, and Travis L. Crosby. Psycho/history: Readings in the method of psychology, psychoanalysis, and history. Yale University Press, 1987. 7Russell, Dora, and Countess Russell. The tamarisk tree: my quest for liberty and love. Vol. 1. Putnam, 1975. 8 Neill, AS. Letter to Dora Russell, 18 April 1932. Dora Winifred Russell Papers 1906 – 1986, #17-100, Inventory 71, International Institute of Social History. Retrieved online September 25 2012.
  • 4. and Russell could not claim compensation as she was only renting – and did not own – the school property. Malting House closed when the founder lost allhis money in the 1929 stock crash. 3. Staffing Problems All three progressive schools struggled to find „good‟ staff, but as Neill‟s letter shows it is difficult to know to what extent the demanding ideals of the founders were the problem. Neill‟s school demanded people with patience and an openness to non-traditional atmospheres yet here he laments „hopeless idealists‟ and desires someone with pragmatism – a difficult blend to find. Neill‟s suggestion that “Newman had to leave to have her brat” also suggests she was not able to stay at school while still teaching, however Dora Russell was the mother of three children, and the third was only an infant when Russell‟s husband left her to run the school alone, suggesting that it was possible for women to teach when tending to children and perhaps suggesting that Summerhill was not amenable, rather than unable, to provide such an arrangement. 4. Journalism and Publications All three sets of school leaders published extensively about their experiences, initially in magazines and later in books. AS Neill‟s work became most widely spread in the 1960s, but all three wrote for (and advertised) in The New Humanist, The New Statesman and Nature magazine9. In doing so the schools became famous within left-wing „middle-to-upper‟ class circles which significantly affected intake. 9Advertisements & articles from these magazines are in the ISSH archive for Dora Russell, are published in AS Neill’s correspondence (Croall, ibid) and are republished in Graham’s autobiography of Susan Isaacs (Ibid).
  • 5. 5. Oceans of Compromise When AS Neill says that progressive schools have become a „compromise‟ it appears that he is talking about the fact that so many of the schools from the 1920s have either closed or had changed their philosophy to become more „mainstream‟. In order to keep financially stable and ensure adequate staffing most „gave up‟ on the Freudian idea. Synthesis – What parallels can be drawn with US Education? Although these schools are from a different period than that covered by the class so far, and from a different country, there is an important synthesis. First: Finance is an important driver of change. Though “progressivism” is considered correct it is foregone when its founders could no longer fund it. In the US decisions regarding, for example, gender integration often occur because the alternative was unaffordable. Even if education leaders felt it more morally appropriate to have separate sex schools, the lack of money available meant such segregation did not occur. When considering the history of schools it is therefore critical to carefully judge whether money funds ideology, or if it works the other way around. Secondly: If relationships are so important in the creation of progressive schools, why are they missing from the histories of education presented by Joel Spring, Tyack & Hansott, and James Anderson? In fact, a quick glance at the leading educationalists in their stories would suggest relationships are vastly important: - Horace Mann’s second wife was Mary Taylor Peabody, a teacher who was greatly respected in Massachusetts, advised him on all
  • 6. aspects of policy and was possibly more an inspiration for his working in education over law (as opposed to the riots!)10 - Thomas Jefferson had a long-term affair and children with Sally Hemmings, one of his slaves, as proven by DNA testing in 199811. Was this important in his views regarding equality? - Booker T. Washington’s wife, Olivia A. Davidson, was a co- founder of Tuskagee College. She trained at Hampton, then at a Normal School, was a teacher and an honors student12. - W.E.B. Du Bois had continual affairs throughout his life all with highly „academic‟ and celebrate women some of whom were white. He had very little to do with his wife and daughter.13 Conclusion The AS Neill letter is therefore a useful example of the problems and strategies for success seen in the Progressive School movement as the schools ambled towards closure or compromise. But more importantly the letter shows us the importance of human interactions and how the people in the history of educations had friendships, romantic relationships and opinions about the people they worked with. Often in history these relationships are missed out – as is evidenced by the absence of the women discussed above in US education history – but these relationships are important and can help us understand people‟s motives in a new and illuminating way. The “wives‟ tale” may yet be a missing piece in the history puzzle that will help us understand how we got from no schooling at all to where we are right now. 10Marshall,Megan. The Peabody Sisters: Three women who ignited American romanticism. Mariner Books, 2006. 11Smith D. & Wade N. “DNA Test Finds Evidence of Jefferson Child By Slave” The New York Times November 01 1998. Retrieved 31 October 2012. http://www.nytimes.com/1998/11/01/us/dna-test-finds-evidence-of-jefferson-child-by-slave.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm 12Darlene Clark Hine Black Women in America an Historical Encyclopedia Volumes 1 and 2 (Brooklyn, NY: Carlson Publishing, 1993). 13Lewis, David Levering. WEB Du Bois, 1868-1919: Biography of a Race. Vol. 1. Holt Paperbacks, 1994.
  • 7. Biblography Analysed primary source is: Neill, A.S, Letter to Dora Russell. April 27, 1944. Dora Winifred Russell Papers 1906-1986, #17-102, Inventory 71, International Institute of Social History. Retrieved online September 25 2012. Additional materials: Cocks, Geoffrey Ed, and Travis L. Crosby. Psycho/history: Readings in the method of psychology, psychoanalysis, and history. Yale University Press, 1987. Croall, J. (1983) All the best, Neill: Letters from Summerhill, London: The Trinity Press Graham, Philip. Susan Isaacs: A Life Freeing the Minds of Children: A Life Freeing the Minds of Children. Karnac Books, 2008. Hine, Darlene Clark Black Women in America an Historical Encyclopedia Volumes 1 and 2 (Brooklyn, NY: Carlson Publishing, 1993). Lewis, David Levering. WEB Du Bois, 1868-1919: Biography of a Race. Vol. 1. Holt Paperbacks, 1994. Marshall, Megan. The Peabody Sisters: Three women who ignited American romanticism. Mariner Books, 2006. Neill, AS. Letter to Dora Russell, 18 April 1932. Dora Winifred Russell Papers 1906 – 1986, #17-100, Inventory 71, International Institute of Social History. Retrieved online September 25 2012. Russell, Dora, and Countess Russell. The tamarisk tree: my quest for liberty and love. Vol. 1. Putnam, 1975. Smith D. & Wade N. “DNA Test Finds Evidence of Jefferson Child By Slave” The New York Times November 01 1998. Retrieved 31 October 2012. http://www.nytimes.com/1998/11/01/us/dna-test-finds- evidence-of-jefferson-child-by-slave.html?pagewanted=all&src=pm Unknown author, “A Do-As-You-Please School” The Daily News [Colombo, Ceylon] 21 April 1931, in the Dora Winifred Russell paper 1906 – 1986, #13-9, Inventory 656, International Institute of Social History. Retrieved online 16 September 2012.