SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 1
Baixar para ler offline
Tomari	
  Quinn,	
  editor	
  of	
  The	
  Topeka	
  Capital-­‐Journal	
  
616	
  S.E.	
  Jefferson,	
  Topeka,	
  Kan.	
  66607	
  
tomari.quinn@cjonline.com	
  
(785)	
  295-­‐1212	
  
	
  
Journalists	
  at	
  The	
  Topeka	
  Capital-­‐Journal	
  appreciate	
  the	
  Senate	
  State	
  and	
  Federal	
  Affairs	
  Committee’s	
  
consideration	
  of	
  this	
  bill	
  and	
  thank	
  Sen.	
  LaTurner	
  for	
  bringing	
  it	
  forward.	
  We	
  believe	
  a	
  transparent	
  and	
  
open	
  government	
  fosters	
  trust	
  in	
  its	
  citizens,	
  while	
  the	
  opposite	
  serves	
  only	
  to	
  breed	
  suspicion	
  and	
  
malcontent.	
  In	
  recent	
  years,	
  we	
  have	
  faced	
  greater	
  challenges	
  in	
  getting	
  information	
  that	
  should	
  be	
  
easily	
  available	
  to	
  the	
  public,	
  and	
  we	
  have	
  seen	
  government	
  agencies	
  asking	
  for	
  ever	
  increasing	
  fees	
  to	
  
comply	
  with	
  the	
  requests.	
  Following	
  are	
  a	
  few	
  examples	
  to	
  illustrate:	
  	
  
 After	
  receiving	
  a	
  tip	
  that	
  the	
  Kansas	
  Department	
  of	
  Agriculture	
  was	
  failing	
  in	
  its	
  duties	
  to	
  ensure	
  the	
  
accuracy	
  of	
  grain	
  and	
  livestock	
  scales,	
  backed	
  up	
  by	
  court	
  documents	
  from	
  a	
  recent	
  lawsuit,	
  reporter	
  
Andy	
  Marso	
  submitted	
  an	
  open	
  records	
  request	
  last	
  year	
  for	
  the	
  scale	
  test	
  reports	
  that	
  the	
  company	
  
named	
  in	
  the	
  suit	
  submitted	
  to	
  the	
  department.	
  The	
  request	
  was	
  denied	
  as	
  the	
  company	
  was	
  under	
  
"administrative	
  adjudication."	
  	
  Marso	
  resubmitted	
  the	
  request	
  in	
  January,	
  after	
  the	
  adjudication	
  
ended	
  in	
  a	
  $1,000	
  fine	
  he	
  was	
  told	
  was	
  uncommonly	
  low.	
  What	
  followed	
  was	
  a	
  week's	
  worth	
  of	
  
back-­‐and-­‐forth	
  emails	
  in	
  which	
  the	
  department	
  initially	
  quoted	
  him	
  an	
  estimated	
  price	
  of	
  $700	
  for	
  
copies	
  of	
  the	
  records.	
  He	
  made	
  several	
  attempts	
  to	
  mitigate	
  the	
  costs,	
  including	
  requesting	
  an	
  in-­‐
person	
  inspection	
  of	
  the	
  records	
  (which	
  is	
  specifically	
  allowed	
  by	
  law)	
  and	
  proposing	
  to	
  bring	
  his	
  
own	
  scanner/copier.	
  He	
  was	
  informed	
  he	
  could	
  inspect	
  the	
  records	
  in	
  person	
  only	
  if	
  a	
  Department	
  
of	
  Agriculture	
  attorney	
  was	
  present,	
  at	
  a	
  cost	
  of	
  $20	
  per	
  hour.	
  Marso	
  paid	
  for	
  three	
  hours	
  of	
  
inspection	
  time.	
  The	
  attorney	
  brought	
  him	
  the	
  records	
  one	
  scale	
  location	
  at	
  a	
  time,	
  therefore	
  
causing	
  dead	
  time	
  in	
  which	
  he	
  had	
  no	
  documents	
  to	
  scan	
  but	
  was	
  paying	
  for	
  her	
  services.	
  
 Several	
  times	
  since	
  joining	
  the	
  city	
  of	
  Topeka	
  in	
  August	
  2012,	
  the	
  city	
  manager	
  cited	
  his	
  efforts	
  
toward	
  transparency.	
  We	
  long	
  had	
  found	
  the	
  city	
  attorney’s	
  office	
  searches	
  far	
  and	
  wide	
  to	
  find	
  
ways	
  to	
  reject	
  KORA	
  requests	
  in	
  whole	
  and	
  part.	
  To	
  test	
  the	
  city’s	
  new	
  attitude,	
  reporter	
  Aly	
  Van	
  
Dyke	
  requested	
  14	
  weeks	
  of	
  the	
  city	
  manager’s	
  emails.	
  She	
  was	
  told	
  the	
  cost	
  would	
  be	
  $273	
  and	
  
paid	
  it.	
  Weeks	
  later,	
  she	
  was	
  given	
  one	
  week’s	
  emails,	
  79	
  percent	
  of	
  which	
  had	
  been	
  redacted.	
  Cost	
  
for	
  attorney	
  review	
  –	
  which	
  wasn’t	
  cited	
  in	
  the	
  original	
  cost	
  estimate	
  –	
  was	
  more	
  than	
  $180,	
  the	
  
amount	
  of	
  which	
  was	
  taken	
  from	
  our	
  original	
  payment.	
  One	
  city	
  department	
  often	
  cites	
  a	
  copying	
  
fee	
  of	
  more	
  than	
  25	
  cents	
  a	
  page,	
  claiming	
  city	
  ordinance	
  allows	
  it	
  and	
  outranks	
  state	
  statute.	
  
 Payroll	
  requests	
  were	
  sent	
  to	
  55	
  Shawnee	
  County	
  taxing	
  entities.	
  Costs	
  to	
  fulfill	
  our	
  requests	
  ranged	
  
from	
  $0	
  to	
  $280.	
  One	
  agency	
  with	
  fewer	
  than	
  20	
  employees	
  asked	
  for	
  $212.	
  We	
  have	
  paid	
  almost	
  
$1,300,	
  with	
  one	
  request	
  still	
  outstanding	
  (and	
  two	
  months	
  late	
  complying).	
  Payroll	
  information	
  is	
  
something	
  every	
  citizen	
  has	
  the	
  right	
  to,	
  but	
  not	
  everyone	
  can	
  afford	
  $1,300.	
  
	
  
We	
  thank	
  you	
  for	
  your	
  time	
  today	
  and	
  encourage	
  any	
  efforts	
  to	
  build	
  trust	
  within	
  our	
  community	
  by	
  
making	
  information	
  widely	
  and	
  easily	
  available	
  to	
  the	
  citizens	
  of	
  Kansas.	
  

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Semelhante a SB 10 Testimony - Tomari Quinn

Jack Schrold - The FTC Battle
Jack Schrold -  The FTC Battle Jack Schrold -  The FTC Battle
Jack Schrold - The FTC Battle Jack Schrold
 
June 2015 Newsletter_Issue2 revised.2
June 2015 Newsletter_Issue2  revised.2June 2015 Newsletter_Issue2  revised.2
June 2015 Newsletter_Issue2 revised.2Bernell Ward, EA
 
An Overview of Impact: Annual Report 2009
An Overview of Impact: Annual Report 2009An Overview of Impact: Annual Report 2009
An Overview of Impact: Annual Report 2009KKienast
 
As AgreedHello, I have a business law assignment (LPP225) due la.docx
As AgreedHello, I have a business law assignment (LPP225) due la.docxAs AgreedHello, I have a business law assignment (LPP225) due la.docx
As AgreedHello, I have a business law assignment (LPP225) due la.docxmammiesfa
 
Importance Of School Essay Essay On Importance Of
Importance Of School Essay  Essay On Importance OfImportance Of School Essay  Essay On Importance Of
Importance Of School Essay Essay On Importance OfLucy Castillo
 
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...Elliot Engstrom
 
Business Services Division Business Entity Report
Business Services Division Business Entity ReportBusiness Services Division Business Entity Report
Business Services Division Business Entity ReportHuntingtonChamber
 
Saratoga April 2018 newsletter
Saratoga April 2018 newsletterSaratoga April 2018 newsletter
Saratoga April 2018 newsletterRishi Kumar
 
Chapter 6 recording transactions in a general journal
Chapter 6 recording transactions in a general journalChapter 6 recording transactions in a general journal
Chapter 6 recording transactions in a general journalIva Walton
 
Classification Essay Instruction With Prewri
Classification Essay Instruction With PrewriClassification Essay Instruction With Prewri
Classification Essay Instruction With PrewriBrittany Allen
 

Semelhante a SB 10 Testimony - Tomari Quinn (20)

April 19 2016 Press Kit
April 19 2016 Press KitApril 19 2016 Press Kit
April 19 2016 Press Kit
 
James Gilbert press kit
James Gilbert press kitJames Gilbert press kit
James Gilbert press kit
 
‘Staggering’ Legal Fees in Boy Scouts Bankruptcy Case
‘Staggering’ Legal Fees in Boy Scouts Bankruptcy Case‘Staggering’ Legal Fees in Boy Scouts Bankruptcy Case
‘Staggering’ Legal Fees in Boy Scouts Bankruptcy Case
 
MnCitiesJanFeb2014
MnCitiesJanFeb2014MnCitiesJanFeb2014
MnCitiesJanFeb2014
 
Jack Schrold - The FTC Battle
Jack Schrold -  The FTC Battle Jack Schrold -  The FTC Battle
Jack Schrold - The FTC Battle
 
Blowing the Whistle on E-RATE Fraud
Blowing the Whistle on E-RATE FraudBlowing the Whistle on E-RATE Fraud
Blowing the Whistle on E-RATE Fraud
 
SWCLC Legislative agenda September 2019
SWCLC Legislative agenda September 2019SWCLC Legislative agenda September 2019
SWCLC Legislative agenda September 2019
 
The Business of Government by John Cheves
The Business of Government by John ChevesThe Business of Government by John Cheves
The Business of Government by John Cheves
 
June 2015 Newsletter_Issue2 revised.2
June 2015 Newsletter_Issue2  revised.2June 2015 Newsletter_Issue2  revised.2
June 2015 Newsletter_Issue2 revised.2
 
An Overview of Impact: Annual Report 2009
An Overview of Impact: Annual Report 2009An Overview of Impact: Annual Report 2009
An Overview of Impact: Annual Report 2009
 
The Real Estate Investment News - September 2013
The Real Estate Investment News - September 2013The Real Estate Investment News - September 2013
The Real Estate Investment News - September 2013
 
As AgreedHello, I have a business law assignment (LPP225) due la.docx
As AgreedHello, I have a business law assignment (LPP225) due la.docxAs AgreedHello, I have a business law assignment (LPP225) due la.docx
As AgreedHello, I have a business law assignment (LPP225) due la.docx
 
Importance Of School Essay Essay On Importance Of
Importance Of School Essay  Essay On Importance OfImportance Of School Essay  Essay On Importance Of
Importance Of School Essay Essay On Importance Of
 
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...
5-6-2016-Pls.-Mem.-Supp.-Summ.-J.-Deitz-v.-Belmont-15-CVS-3203-Gaston-Cty.-Su...
 
State of the Judiciary 1.26.11
State of the Judiciary 1.26.11State of the Judiciary 1.26.11
State of the Judiciary 1.26.11
 
Business Services Division Business Entity Report
Business Services Division Business Entity ReportBusiness Services Division Business Entity Report
Business Services Division Business Entity Report
 
Saratoga April 2018 newsletter
Saratoga April 2018 newsletterSaratoga April 2018 newsletter
Saratoga April 2018 newsletter
 
Chapter 6 recording transactions in a general journal
Chapter 6 recording transactions in a general journalChapter 6 recording transactions in a general journal
Chapter 6 recording transactions in a general journal
 
Finding Information about Private Companies by Chris Roush
Finding Information about Private Companies by Chris RoushFinding Information about Private Companies by Chris Roush
Finding Information about Private Companies by Chris Roush
 
Classification Essay Instruction With Prewri
Classification Essay Instruction With PrewriClassification Essay Instruction With Prewri
Classification Essay Instruction With Prewri
 

Mais de Keri Strahler

2012 Kansas Domestic Violence Report
2012 Kansas Domestic Violence Report2012 Kansas Domestic Violence Report
2012 Kansas Domestic Violence ReportKeri Strahler
 
7.12.12 TANF work requirement letter
7.12.12 TANF work requirement letter 7.12.12 TANF work requirement letter
7.12.12 TANF work requirement letter Keri Strahler
 
2013 DRC Newsletter
2013 DRC Newsletter 2013 DRC Newsletter
2013 DRC Newsletter Keri Strahler
 
The strengthening the child welfare response to trafficking act
The strengthening the child welfare response to trafficking actThe strengthening the child welfare response to trafficking act
The strengthening the child welfare response to trafficking actKeri Strahler
 
Pornography and Crime
Pornography and CrimePornography and Crime
Pornography and CrimeKeri Strahler
 
Hutchinson News - Editorial Copy Fees
Hutchinson News - Editorial Copy FeesHutchinson News - Editorial Copy Fees
Hutchinson News - Editorial Copy FeesKeri Strahler
 
SB 10 Testimony - Jan Jarman
SB 10 Testimony - Jan JarmanSB 10 Testimony - Jan Jarman
SB 10 Testimony - Jan JarmanKeri Strahler
 
Property and Belongingness: Rethinking Gender-Biased Disinheritance
Property and Belongingness: Rethinking Gender-Biased DisinheritanceProperty and Belongingness: Rethinking Gender-Biased Disinheritance
Property and Belongingness: Rethinking Gender-Biased DisinheritanceKeri Strahler
 
CPJ - Roots Of Impunity ..
CPJ - Roots Of Impunity ..CPJ - Roots Of Impunity ..
CPJ - Roots Of Impunity ..Keri Strahler
 
H.R. 1229 To promote economic security ..
H.R. 1229 To promote economic security .. H.R. 1229 To promote economic security ..
H.R. 1229 To promote economic security .. Keri Strahler
 

Mais de Keri Strahler (14)

2012 Kansas Domestic Violence Report
2012 Kansas Domestic Violence Report2012 Kansas Domestic Violence Report
2012 Kansas Domestic Violence Report
 
7.12.12 TANF work requirement letter
7.12.12 TANF work requirement letter 7.12.12 TANF work requirement letter
7.12.12 TANF work requirement letter
 
Oei 07-98-00260
Oei 07-98-00260Oei 07-98-00260
Oei 07-98-00260
 
Ss06 03-038
Ss06 03-038Ss06 03-038
Ss06 03-038
 
2013 DRC Newsletter
2013 DRC Newsletter 2013 DRC Newsletter
2013 DRC Newsletter
 
The strengthening the child welfare response to trafficking act
The strengthening the child welfare response to trafficking actThe strengthening the child welfare response to trafficking act
The strengthening the child welfare response to trafficking act
 
Pornography and Crime
Pornography and CrimePornography and Crime
Pornography and Crime
 
99818
9981899818
99818
 
Hutchinson News - Editorial Copy Fees
Hutchinson News - Editorial Copy FeesHutchinson News - Editorial Copy Fees
Hutchinson News - Editorial Copy Fees
 
SB10
SB10SB10
SB10
 
SB 10 Testimony - Jan Jarman
SB 10 Testimony - Jan JarmanSB 10 Testimony - Jan Jarman
SB 10 Testimony - Jan Jarman
 
Property and Belongingness: Rethinking Gender-Biased Disinheritance
Property and Belongingness: Rethinking Gender-Biased DisinheritanceProperty and Belongingness: Rethinking Gender-Biased Disinheritance
Property and Belongingness: Rethinking Gender-Biased Disinheritance
 
CPJ - Roots Of Impunity ..
CPJ - Roots Of Impunity ..CPJ - Roots Of Impunity ..
CPJ - Roots Of Impunity ..
 
H.R. 1229 To promote economic security ..
H.R. 1229 To promote economic security .. H.R. 1229 To promote economic security ..
H.R. 1229 To promote economic security ..
 

SB 10 Testimony - Tomari Quinn

  • 1. Tomari  Quinn,  editor  of  The  Topeka  Capital-­‐Journal   616  S.E.  Jefferson,  Topeka,  Kan.  66607   tomari.quinn@cjonline.com   (785)  295-­‐1212     Journalists  at  The  Topeka  Capital-­‐Journal  appreciate  the  Senate  State  and  Federal  Affairs  Committee’s   consideration  of  this  bill  and  thank  Sen.  LaTurner  for  bringing  it  forward.  We  believe  a  transparent  and   open  government  fosters  trust  in  its  citizens,  while  the  opposite  serves  only  to  breed  suspicion  and   malcontent.  In  recent  years,  we  have  faced  greater  challenges  in  getting  information  that  should  be   easily  available  to  the  public,  and  we  have  seen  government  agencies  asking  for  ever  increasing  fees  to   comply  with  the  requests.  Following  are  a  few  examples  to  illustrate:      After  receiving  a  tip  that  the  Kansas  Department  of  Agriculture  was  failing  in  its  duties  to  ensure  the   accuracy  of  grain  and  livestock  scales,  backed  up  by  court  documents  from  a  recent  lawsuit,  reporter   Andy  Marso  submitted  an  open  records  request  last  year  for  the  scale  test  reports  that  the  company   named  in  the  suit  submitted  to  the  department.  The  request  was  denied  as  the  company  was  under   "administrative  adjudication."    Marso  resubmitted  the  request  in  January,  after  the  adjudication   ended  in  a  $1,000  fine  he  was  told  was  uncommonly  low.  What  followed  was  a  week's  worth  of   back-­‐and-­‐forth  emails  in  which  the  department  initially  quoted  him  an  estimated  price  of  $700  for   copies  of  the  records.  He  made  several  attempts  to  mitigate  the  costs,  including  requesting  an  in-­‐ person  inspection  of  the  records  (which  is  specifically  allowed  by  law)  and  proposing  to  bring  his   own  scanner/copier.  He  was  informed  he  could  inspect  the  records  in  person  only  if  a  Department   of  Agriculture  attorney  was  present,  at  a  cost  of  $20  per  hour.  Marso  paid  for  three  hours  of   inspection  time.  The  attorney  brought  him  the  records  one  scale  location  at  a  time,  therefore   causing  dead  time  in  which  he  had  no  documents  to  scan  but  was  paying  for  her  services.    Several  times  since  joining  the  city  of  Topeka  in  August  2012,  the  city  manager  cited  his  efforts   toward  transparency.  We  long  had  found  the  city  attorney’s  office  searches  far  and  wide  to  find   ways  to  reject  KORA  requests  in  whole  and  part.  To  test  the  city’s  new  attitude,  reporter  Aly  Van   Dyke  requested  14  weeks  of  the  city  manager’s  emails.  She  was  told  the  cost  would  be  $273  and   paid  it.  Weeks  later,  she  was  given  one  week’s  emails,  79  percent  of  which  had  been  redacted.  Cost   for  attorney  review  –  which  wasn’t  cited  in  the  original  cost  estimate  –  was  more  than  $180,  the   amount  of  which  was  taken  from  our  original  payment.  One  city  department  often  cites  a  copying   fee  of  more  than  25  cents  a  page,  claiming  city  ordinance  allows  it  and  outranks  state  statute.    Payroll  requests  were  sent  to  55  Shawnee  County  taxing  entities.  Costs  to  fulfill  our  requests  ranged   from  $0  to  $280.  One  agency  with  fewer  than  20  employees  asked  for  $212.  We  have  paid  almost   $1,300,  with  one  request  still  outstanding  (and  two  months  late  complying).  Payroll  information  is   something  every  citizen  has  the  right  to,  but  not  everyone  can  afford  $1,300.     We  thank  you  for  your  time  today  and  encourage  any  efforts  to  build  trust  within  our  community  by   making  information  widely  and  easily  available  to  the  citizens  of  Kansas.