SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 9
Cambridge University Library




Summon – the other side of the coin


Isla Kuhn, Deputy & Reader Services Librarian
Cambridge University Medical Library
Dave’s Law




    users should not have to become
 mini-librarians in order to use the library

http://www.daveyp.com/blog/archives/1800
But in the words of Ben Goldacre…..



              "I think you’ll find it’s a bit more
                  complicated than that…"




 http://www.badscience.net/2008/12/i-think-youll-find-its-a-bit-more-
 complicated -than-that-and-other-excellent-christmas-gifts/
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-20014/Back-pain-Just-ignore-it.html
Advice to rest in bed versus advice to stay active
for acute low-back pain and sciatica.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD007612.pub2/abstract
1. clinical trial.pt.        24.   or/13-23                          46.   exp Bed Rest/
2. randomized.ab,ti.         25.   exp Spine/                        47.   bed rest.mp.
3. placebo.ab,ti.            26.   discitis.ab,ti.                   48.   or/39-47
4. dt.fs.                    27.   exp Spinal Diseases/              49.   24 or 38
5. randomly.ab,ti.           28.   (disc adj degeneration).ab,ti.    50.   12 and 49
6. trial.ab,ti.              29.   (disc adj prolapse).ab,ti.        51.   48 and 50
7. groups.ab,ti.             30.   (disc adj herniation).ab,ti.
8. or/1-7                    31.   spinal fusion.sh.
9. Animals/                  32.   spinal neoplasms.sh.
10. Humans/                  33.   (facet adj joints).ab,ti.
11. 9 not (9 and 10)         34.   intervertebral disk.sh.
12. 8 not 11                 35.   postlaminectomy.ab,ti.
13. dorsalgia.ab,ti.         36.   arachnoiditis.ab,ti.
14. exp Back Pain/           37.   (failed adj back).ab,ti.
15. exp Low Back Pain/ 38.         or/25-37
16. backache.ab,ti.          39.   exp activities of daily living/
17. (lumbar adj pain).ab,ti. 40.   activities of daily living.tw.
18. coccyx.ab,ti.            41.   day to day activ$.ti,ab.
19. coccydynia.ab,ti.        42.   daily activit$.ti,ab.
20. exp Sciatica/            43.   ordinary activit$.ti,ab.
21. sciatica.ab,ti.          44.   normal activit$.ti,ab.
22. spondylosis.ab,ti.       45.   stay$ active.ti,ab.
23. lumbago.ab,ti.
Horses for courses?

                                       Postgraduate
                                             vs

                                       Undergraduate
Known Knowns (eg reading lists)
             vs
Unknown Knowns (eg self-directed research)


                                       Just enough
                                           vs
                                       Everything


                                                       But……
PUBMED                      MATHSCINET

GEOref   JSTOR     CINAHL      FACTIVA

SCOPUS   ARTstor   ERIC      LEXIS NEXIS




             SUMMON
Thank you


Isla Kuhn

      Cambridge University Medical Library

      ilk1@cam.ac.uk / @ilk21

Emma Coonan (in absentia)
      Cambridge University Library

      Emma.Coonan@lib.cam.ac.uk / @LibGoddess

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Destaque

Pubmed & endnote michaelmas 2013
Pubmed & endnote   michaelmas 2013Pubmed & endnote   michaelmas 2013
Pubmed & endnote michaelmas 2013Isla Kuhn
 
CLAHRC january 2015
CLAHRC   january 2015CLAHRC   january 2015
CLAHRC january 2015Isla Kuhn
 
Fishing for pearls mphil2013
Fishing for pearls mphil2013Fishing for pearls mphil2013
Fishing for pearls mphil2013Isla Kuhn
 
Systematic reviewing may2012
Systematic reviewing may2012Systematic reviewing may2012
Systematic reviewing may2012Isla Kuhn
 
FPVHub Northern Meet 2013 - Beginner Presentation
FPVHub Northern Meet 2013 - Beginner PresentationFPVHub Northern Meet 2013 - Beginner Presentation
FPVHub Northern Meet 2013 - Beginner PresentationLaniLogic
 
Systematic reviews - a "how to" guide
Systematic reviews - a "how to" guideSystematic reviews - a "how to" guide
Systematic reviews - a "how to" guideIsla Kuhn
 
Storymapping workshop for CHI Belgium
Storymapping workshop for CHI BelgiumStorymapping workshop for CHI Belgium
Storymapping workshop for CHI BelgiumHans De Mondt
 
Big 4 michaelmas 2013
Big 4  michaelmas 2013Big 4  michaelmas 2013
Big 4 michaelmas 2013Isla Kuhn
 
Big 4 michaelmas 2012
Big 4  michaelmas 2012Big 4  michaelmas 2012
Big 4 michaelmas 2012Isla Kuhn
 

Destaque (10)

Pubmed & endnote michaelmas 2013
Pubmed & endnote   michaelmas 2013Pubmed & endnote   michaelmas 2013
Pubmed & endnote michaelmas 2013
 
CLAHRC january 2015
CLAHRC   january 2015CLAHRC   january 2015
CLAHRC january 2015
 
Fishing for pearls mphil2013
Fishing for pearls mphil2013Fishing for pearls mphil2013
Fishing for pearls mphil2013
 
Mycarandme
MycarandmeMycarandme
Mycarandme
 
Systematic reviewing may2012
Systematic reviewing may2012Systematic reviewing may2012
Systematic reviewing may2012
 
FPVHub Northern Meet 2013 - Beginner Presentation
FPVHub Northern Meet 2013 - Beginner PresentationFPVHub Northern Meet 2013 - Beginner Presentation
FPVHub Northern Meet 2013 - Beginner Presentation
 
Systematic reviews - a "how to" guide
Systematic reviews - a "how to" guideSystematic reviews - a "how to" guide
Systematic reviews - a "how to" guide
 
Storymapping workshop for CHI Belgium
Storymapping workshop for CHI BelgiumStorymapping workshop for CHI Belgium
Storymapping workshop for CHI Belgium
 
Big 4 michaelmas 2013
Big 4  michaelmas 2013Big 4  michaelmas 2013
Big 4 michaelmas 2013
 
Big 4 michaelmas 2012
Big 4  michaelmas 2012Big 4  michaelmas 2012
Big 4 michaelmas 2012
 

Semelhante a Jibs 2013 summon

Isla Kuhn JIBS User Group Resource Discovery event February 2013
Isla Kuhn JIBS User Group Resource Discovery event February 2013Isla Kuhn JIBS User Group Resource Discovery event February 2013
Isla Kuhn JIBS User Group Resource Discovery event February 2013sherif user group
 
Fishing for pearls mphil2014
Fishing for pearls mphil2014Fishing for pearls mphil2014
Fishing for pearls mphil2014Isla Kuhn
 
Peter lisowski anatomical terms 1st ed. 2007
Peter lisowski anatomical terms 1st ed. 2007Peter lisowski anatomical terms 1st ed. 2007
Peter lisowski anatomical terms 1st ed. 2007Jeshua Devan
 
The Scientific Conquest of Death
The Scientific Conquest of DeathThe Scientific Conquest of Death
The Scientific Conquest of DeathVapula
 
Essay On Radiation.pdf
Essay On Radiation.pdfEssay On Radiation.pdf
Essay On Radiation.pdfLori Jones
 
Smith, Niall - Thesis - The everyday social geographies of living with epilepsy
Smith, Niall - Thesis - The everyday social geographies of living with epilepsySmith, Niall - Thesis - The everyday social geographies of living with epilepsy
Smith, Niall - Thesis - The everyday social geographies of living with epilepsyNiall Smith
 
Can a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosis
Can a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosisCan a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosis
Can a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosisSantosh Kathwate
 
Module cell structure and function
Module cell structure and functionModule cell structure and function
Module cell structure and functionJohn Daniel Gumban
 
The Universe: Hasn't Physics disproved God?
The Universe: Hasn't Physics disproved God?The Universe: Hasn't Physics disproved God?
The Universe: Hasn't Physics disproved God?Costa Belfrey
 
A Biological Definition Of Self
A Biological Definition Of SelfA Biological Definition Of Self
A Biological Definition Of SelfApril Knyff
 
Eval 5epnsc massavia_s 17 questions
Eval  5epnsc massavia_s 17 questionsEval  5epnsc massavia_s 17 questions
Eval 5epnsc massavia_s 17 questionsmatea muñoz
 
Geis Science Seminar 3
Geis Science Seminar 3Geis Science Seminar 3
Geis Science Seminar 3johnwest
 
Discussion Conjoined Twins and Split Brain Patients.docx
Discussion Conjoined Twins and Split Brain Patients.docxDiscussion Conjoined Twins and Split Brain Patients.docx
Discussion Conjoined Twins and Split Brain Patients.docxstirlingvwriters
 
Infinite bounce 1_final
Infinite bounce 1_finalInfinite bounce 1_final
Infinite bounce 1_finalAnupam Sinha
 
Theise Upaya 1 2008
Theise Upaya 1 2008Theise Upaya 1 2008
Theise Upaya 1 2008Neil Theise
 
مذكرة لغة انجليزية للصف الاول الثانوى ترم اول 2017 - موقع ملزمتي
مذكرة لغة انجليزية للصف الاول الثانوى ترم اول 2017 - موقع ملزمتيمذكرة لغة انجليزية للصف الاول الثانوى ترم اول 2017 - موقع ملزمتي
مذكرة لغة انجليزية للصف الاول الثانوى ترم اول 2017 - موقع ملزمتيملزمتي
 
Diaphragic Pressure Essay
Diaphragic Pressure EssayDiaphragic Pressure Essay
Diaphragic Pressure EssayFelicia Barker
 
Essay On Latest Topics. Hundreds of Argumentative Essay Topics for Any Assign...
Essay On Latest Topics. Hundreds of Argumentative Essay Topics for Any Assign...Essay On Latest Topics. Hundreds of Argumentative Essay Topics for Any Assign...
Essay On Latest Topics. Hundreds of Argumentative Essay Topics for Any Assign...Cynthia Washington
 
How to Write a Scientific Paper Worth Reading
How to Write a Scientific Paper Worth ReadingHow to Write a Scientific Paper Worth Reading
How to Write a Scientific Paper Worth ReadingMichaelEdits.com
 

Semelhante a Jibs 2013 summon (20)

Isla Kuhn JIBS User Group Resource Discovery event February 2013
Isla Kuhn JIBS User Group Resource Discovery event February 2013Isla Kuhn JIBS User Group Resource Discovery event February 2013
Isla Kuhn JIBS User Group Resource Discovery event February 2013
 
Fishing for pearls mphil2014
Fishing for pearls mphil2014Fishing for pearls mphil2014
Fishing for pearls mphil2014
 
Peter lisowski anatomical terms 1st ed. 2007
Peter lisowski anatomical terms 1st ed. 2007Peter lisowski anatomical terms 1st ed. 2007
Peter lisowski anatomical terms 1st ed. 2007
 
The Scientific Conquest of Death
The Scientific Conquest of DeathThe Scientific Conquest of Death
The Scientific Conquest of Death
 
Essay On Radiation.pdf
Essay On Radiation.pdfEssay On Radiation.pdf
Essay On Radiation.pdf
 
Smith, Niall - Thesis - The everyday social geographies of living with epilepsy
Smith, Niall - Thesis - The everyday social geographies of living with epilepsySmith, Niall - Thesis - The everyday social geographies of living with epilepsy
Smith, Niall - Thesis - The everyday social geographies of living with epilepsy
 
Can a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosis
Can a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosisCan a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosis
Can a biologist fix a radio or what i learned while studying apoptosis
 
Module cell structure and function
Module cell structure and functionModule cell structure and function
Module cell structure and function
 
The Universe: Hasn't Physics disproved God?
The Universe: Hasn't Physics disproved God?The Universe: Hasn't Physics disproved God?
The Universe: Hasn't Physics disproved God?
 
A Biological Definition Of Self
A Biological Definition Of SelfA Biological Definition Of Self
A Biological Definition Of Self
 
Eval 5epnsc massavia_s 17 questions
Eval  5epnsc massavia_s 17 questionsEval  5epnsc massavia_s 17 questions
Eval 5epnsc massavia_s 17 questions
 
Geis Science Seminar 3
Geis Science Seminar 3Geis Science Seminar 3
Geis Science Seminar 3
 
Discussion Conjoined Twins and Split Brain Patients.docx
Discussion Conjoined Twins and Split Brain Patients.docxDiscussion Conjoined Twins and Split Brain Patients.docx
Discussion Conjoined Twins and Split Brain Patients.docx
 
Infinite bounce 1_final
Infinite bounce 1_finalInfinite bounce 1_final
Infinite bounce 1_final
 
Theise Upaya 1 2008
Theise Upaya 1 2008Theise Upaya 1 2008
Theise Upaya 1 2008
 
Promises of Synthetic Biology by Drew Endy
Promises of Synthetic Biology by Drew EndyPromises of Synthetic Biology by Drew Endy
Promises of Synthetic Biology by Drew Endy
 
مذكرة لغة انجليزية للصف الاول الثانوى ترم اول 2017 - موقع ملزمتي
مذكرة لغة انجليزية للصف الاول الثانوى ترم اول 2017 - موقع ملزمتيمذكرة لغة انجليزية للصف الاول الثانوى ترم اول 2017 - موقع ملزمتي
مذكرة لغة انجليزية للصف الاول الثانوى ترم اول 2017 - موقع ملزمتي
 
Diaphragic Pressure Essay
Diaphragic Pressure EssayDiaphragic Pressure Essay
Diaphragic Pressure Essay
 
Essay On Latest Topics. Hundreds of Argumentative Essay Topics for Any Assign...
Essay On Latest Topics. Hundreds of Argumentative Essay Topics for Any Assign...Essay On Latest Topics. Hundreds of Argumentative Essay Topics for Any Assign...
Essay On Latest Topics. Hundreds of Argumentative Essay Topics for Any Assign...
 
How to Write a Scientific Paper Worth Reading
How to Write a Scientific Paper Worth ReadingHow to Write a Scientific Paper Worth Reading
How to Write a Scientific Paper Worth Reading
 

Mais de Isla Kuhn

systematic reviews and what the library can do to help
systematic reviews and what the library can do to helpsystematic reviews and what the library can do to help
systematic reviews and what the library can do to helpIsla Kuhn
 
Fishing for pearls 2015 - part 2s
Fishing for pearls 2015 - part 2sFishing for pearls 2015 - part 2s
Fishing for pearls 2015 - part 2sIsla Kuhn
 
Quantitative critical appraisal october 2015
Quantitative critical appraisal october 2015Quantitative critical appraisal october 2015
Quantitative critical appraisal october 2015Isla Kuhn
 
EoE HLN summer conference 2015 IK - open access & research data management
EoE HLN summer conference 2015 IK - open access & research data managementEoE HLN summer conference 2015 IK - open access & research data management
EoE HLN summer conference 2015 IK - open access & research data managementIsla Kuhn
 
Cnir feb 2015
Cnir feb 2015Cnir feb 2015
Cnir feb 2015Isla Kuhn
 
Fishing for pearls 2014 - part 2s
Fishing for pearls 2014 - part 2sFishing for pearls 2014 - part 2s
Fishing for pearls 2014 - part 2sIsla Kuhn
 
Fishing for pearls Babraham PhD
Fishing for pearls Babraham PhDFishing for pearls Babraham PhD
Fishing for pearls Babraham PhDIsla Kuhn
 
Systematic review how to- easter 2014
Systematic review   how to- easter 2014Systematic review   how to- easter 2014
Systematic review how to- easter 2014Isla Kuhn
 
International Public Health SSC April 2014
International Public Health SSC April 2014International Public Health SSC April 2014
International Public Health SSC April 2014Isla Kuhn
 
Bibliographies michaelmas 2013
Bibliographies   michaelmas 2013Bibliographies   michaelmas 2013
Bibliographies michaelmas 2013Isla Kuhn
 
Systematic review how to- michaelmas 2013
Systematic review   how to- michaelmas 2013Systematic review   how to- michaelmas 2013
Systematic review how to- michaelmas 2013Isla Kuhn
 
Fishing for pearls 2012
Fishing for pearls 2012Fishing for pearls 2012
Fishing for pearls 2012Isla Kuhn
 
Systematic review how to - lent 2013
Systematic review   how to - lent 2013Systematic review   how to - lent 2013
Systematic review how to - lent 2013Isla Kuhn
 
Systematic review how to - michaelmas 2012
Systematic review   how to - michaelmas 2012Systematic review   how to - michaelmas 2012
Systematic review how to - michaelmas 2012Isla Kuhn
 
Big 4 march 2012
Big 4   march 2012Big 4   march 2012
Big 4 march 2012Isla Kuhn
 
Pubmed & endnote march2012
Pubmed & endnote march2012Pubmed & endnote march2012
Pubmed & endnote march2012Isla Kuhn
 
Bibliographies
BibliographiesBibliographies
BibliographiesIsla Kuhn
 
Systematic reviewing oct2011
Systematic reviewing oct2011Systematic reviewing oct2011
Systematic reviewing oct2011Isla Kuhn
 

Mais de Isla Kuhn (18)

systematic reviews and what the library can do to help
systematic reviews and what the library can do to helpsystematic reviews and what the library can do to help
systematic reviews and what the library can do to help
 
Fishing for pearls 2015 - part 2s
Fishing for pearls 2015 - part 2sFishing for pearls 2015 - part 2s
Fishing for pearls 2015 - part 2s
 
Quantitative critical appraisal october 2015
Quantitative critical appraisal october 2015Quantitative critical appraisal october 2015
Quantitative critical appraisal october 2015
 
EoE HLN summer conference 2015 IK - open access & research data management
EoE HLN summer conference 2015 IK - open access & research data managementEoE HLN summer conference 2015 IK - open access & research data management
EoE HLN summer conference 2015 IK - open access & research data management
 
Cnir feb 2015
Cnir feb 2015Cnir feb 2015
Cnir feb 2015
 
Fishing for pearls 2014 - part 2s
Fishing for pearls 2014 - part 2sFishing for pearls 2014 - part 2s
Fishing for pearls 2014 - part 2s
 
Fishing for pearls Babraham PhD
Fishing for pearls Babraham PhDFishing for pearls Babraham PhD
Fishing for pearls Babraham PhD
 
Systematic review how to- easter 2014
Systematic review   how to- easter 2014Systematic review   how to- easter 2014
Systematic review how to- easter 2014
 
International Public Health SSC April 2014
International Public Health SSC April 2014International Public Health SSC April 2014
International Public Health SSC April 2014
 
Bibliographies michaelmas 2013
Bibliographies   michaelmas 2013Bibliographies   michaelmas 2013
Bibliographies michaelmas 2013
 
Systematic review how to- michaelmas 2013
Systematic review   how to- michaelmas 2013Systematic review   how to- michaelmas 2013
Systematic review how to- michaelmas 2013
 
Fishing for pearls 2012
Fishing for pearls 2012Fishing for pearls 2012
Fishing for pearls 2012
 
Systematic review how to - lent 2013
Systematic review   how to - lent 2013Systematic review   how to - lent 2013
Systematic review how to - lent 2013
 
Systematic review how to - michaelmas 2012
Systematic review   how to - michaelmas 2012Systematic review   how to - michaelmas 2012
Systematic review how to - michaelmas 2012
 
Big 4 march 2012
Big 4   march 2012Big 4   march 2012
Big 4 march 2012
 
Pubmed & endnote march2012
Pubmed & endnote march2012Pubmed & endnote march2012
Pubmed & endnote march2012
 
Bibliographies
BibliographiesBibliographies
Bibliographies
 
Systematic reviewing oct2011
Systematic reviewing oct2011Systematic reviewing oct2011
Systematic reviewing oct2011
 

Jibs 2013 summon

  • 1. Cambridge University Library Summon – the other side of the coin Isla Kuhn, Deputy & Reader Services Librarian Cambridge University Medical Library
  • 2. Dave’s Law users should not have to become mini-librarians in order to use the library http://www.daveyp.com/blog/archives/1800
  • 3. But in the words of Ben Goldacre….. "I think you’ll find it’s a bit more complicated than that…" http://www.badscience.net/2008/12/i-think-youll-find-its-a-bit-more- complicated -than-that-and-other-excellent-christmas-gifts/
  • 5. Advice to rest in bed versus advice to stay active for acute low-back pain and sciatica. http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD007612.pub2/abstract
  • 6. 1. clinical trial.pt. 24. or/13-23 46. exp Bed Rest/ 2. randomized.ab,ti. 25. exp Spine/ 47. bed rest.mp. 3. placebo.ab,ti. 26. discitis.ab,ti. 48. or/39-47 4. dt.fs. 27. exp Spinal Diseases/ 49. 24 or 38 5. randomly.ab,ti. 28. (disc adj degeneration).ab,ti. 50. 12 and 49 6. trial.ab,ti. 29. (disc adj prolapse).ab,ti. 51. 48 and 50 7. groups.ab,ti. 30. (disc adj herniation).ab,ti. 8. or/1-7 31. spinal fusion.sh. 9. Animals/ 32. spinal neoplasms.sh. 10. Humans/ 33. (facet adj joints).ab,ti. 11. 9 not (9 and 10) 34. intervertebral disk.sh. 12. 8 not 11 35. postlaminectomy.ab,ti. 13. dorsalgia.ab,ti. 36. arachnoiditis.ab,ti. 14. exp Back Pain/ 37. (failed adj back).ab,ti. 15. exp Low Back Pain/ 38. or/25-37 16. backache.ab,ti. 39. exp activities of daily living/ 17. (lumbar adj pain).ab,ti. 40. activities of daily living.tw. 18. coccyx.ab,ti. 41. day to day activ$.ti,ab. 19. coccydynia.ab,ti. 42. daily activit$.ti,ab. 20. exp Sciatica/ 43. ordinary activit$.ti,ab. 21. sciatica.ab,ti. 44. normal activit$.ti,ab. 22. spondylosis.ab,ti. 45. stay$ active.ti,ab. 23. lumbago.ab,ti.
  • 7. Horses for courses? Postgraduate vs Undergraduate Known Knowns (eg reading lists) vs Unknown Knowns (eg self-directed research) Just enough vs Everything But……
  • 8. PUBMED MATHSCINET GEOref JSTOR CINAHL FACTIVA SCOPUS ARTstor ERIC LEXIS NEXIS SUMMON
  • 9. Thank you Isla Kuhn Cambridge University Medical Library ilk1@cam.ac.uk / @ilk21 Emma Coonan (in absentia) Cambridge University Library Emma.Coonan@lib.cam.ac.uk / @LibGoddess