SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 14
Collective Scientific Expertise (ESCo) at the French National Institute for Agricultural Research (INRA)   a tool for decision making and public debate Dominique FOURNIER, Inra, Montpellier, France  &  Claire SABBAGH, Inra, Paris, France   Scientific and Technical Information and Rural Development IAALD XIIIth World Congress, Montpellier, France, 26-29 April 2010
Collective scientific expertise (ESCo) : definition  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Collective Scientific Expertise (ESCo) at INRA, France ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
ESCo at INRA : main actors ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
ESCo Process in 8 steps Focus on steps which deal with information
The case of Agriculture  & Biodiversity ESCo ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Step 0 : Societal question Step 1 : Question adressed to Inra Guideline
Step 2 : constitution of experts’ group  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Steps 3-4 : information searching  and collecting  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Steps 5 : experts’ analysis and writing based on ESCo database  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Steps 7-8 : outcomes of expertise  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Consequences of ESCo  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Agriculture & Biodiversity ESCo pointed out the emergence of multidisciplinary papers which associate ecologists, agronomes and economics    benefit synergies, new research field ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Conclusion  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Examples of INRA ESCo ,[object Object],Carbon stockage Pesticides, agriculture and environment drought and agriculture fruit and vegetable consumption agriculture and biodiversity farm animal  pain
Thanks for your attention Any questions ? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Semelhante a Collective scientific expertise at INRA : A tool for decision making and dialogue between science and society

Sharing or scattering information : a challenge for scientific information at...
Sharing or scattering information : a challenge for scientific information at...Sharing or scattering information : a challenge for scientific information at...
Sharing or scattering information : a challenge for scientific information at...IAALD Community
 
2nd e-ROSA Stakeholder workshop: Hologne, E-ROSA process
2nd e-ROSA Stakeholder workshop: Hologne, E-ROSA process2nd e-ROSA Stakeholder workshop: Hologne, E-ROSA process
2nd e-ROSA Stakeholder workshop: Hologne, E-ROSA processe-ROSA
 
Feeding knowlegde pre meeting
Feeding knowlegde pre meetingFeeding knowlegde pre meeting
Feeding knowlegde pre meetingadminmetid
 
"Lessons of excellence Learned from the ERC", por José Luís García, Rrepresen...
"Lessons of excellence Learned from the ERC", por José Luís García, Rrepresen..."Lessons of excellence Learned from the ERC", por José Luís García, Rrepresen...
"Lessons of excellence Learned from the ERC", por José Luís García, Rrepresen...Agencia Andaluza del Conocimiento
 
Fra scienza e impresa: l’innovazione nei processi produttivi –Esempi di innov...
Fra scienza e impresa: l’innovazione nei processi produttivi –Esempi di innov...Fra scienza e impresa: l’innovazione nei processi produttivi –Esempi di innov...
Fra scienza e impresa: l’innovazione nei processi produttivi –Esempi di innov...Italeaf S.p.A.
 
Vision for an Organic Food and Farming
Vision for an Organic Food and FarmingVision for an Organic Food and Farming
Vision for an Organic Food and Farmingx3G9
 
Vision for an Organic Food and Farming
Vision for an Organic Food and FarmingVision for an Organic Food and Farming
Vision for an Organic Food and Farmingx3G9
 
Communicating eu-research
Communicating eu-researchCommunicating eu-research
Communicating eu-researchGilles Grenot
 
International collaboration in a research institute: a bibliometric study
International collaboration in a research institute: a bibliometric studyInternational collaboration in a research institute: a bibliometric study
International collaboration in a research institute: a bibliometric studyIAALD Community
 
Winning ITNs with RRI - Relevant sources and further reading
Winning ITNs with RRI - Relevant sources and further readingWinning ITNs with RRI - Relevant sources and further reading
Winning ITNs with RRI - Relevant sources and further readingJobenco
 
Koch fp7 - info day - overview
Koch  fp7 - info day - overviewKoch  fp7 - info day - overview
Koch fp7 - info day - overviewEUintheUS
 
BiPday 2014 -- Pesole Graziano
BiPday 2014 -- Pesole GrazianoBiPday 2014 -- Pesole Graziano
BiPday 2014 -- Pesole Grazianoeventi-ITBbari
 
Ciência Aberta na França: ponto da situação, legislação, iniciativas, ferrame...
Ciência Aberta na França: ponto da situação, legislação, iniciativas, ferrame...Ciência Aberta na França: ponto da situação, legislação, iniciativas, ferrame...
Ciência Aberta na França: ponto da situação, legislação, iniciativas, ferrame...Projeto RCAAP
 

Semelhante a Collective scientific expertise at INRA : A tool for decision making and dialogue between science and society (20)

Open Science at IRD
Open Science at IRD Open Science at IRD
Open Science at IRD
 
Sharing or scattering information : a challenge for scientific information at...
Sharing or scattering information : a challenge for scientific information at...Sharing or scattering information : a challenge for scientific information at...
Sharing or scattering information : a challenge for scientific information at...
 
2nd e-ROSA Stakeholder workshop: Hologne, E-ROSA process
2nd e-ROSA Stakeholder workshop: Hologne, E-ROSA process2nd e-ROSA Stakeholder workshop: Hologne, E-ROSA process
2nd e-ROSA Stakeholder workshop: Hologne, E-ROSA process
 
Feeding knowlegde pre meeting
Feeding knowlegde pre meetingFeeding knowlegde pre meeting
Feeding knowlegde pre meeting
 
HOMED Final Meeting
HOMED Final MeetingHOMED Final Meeting
HOMED Final Meeting
 
Application of a theory based approach for evaluating knowledge in fao
Application of a theory based approach for evaluating knowledge in faoApplication of a theory based approach for evaluating knowledge in fao
Application of a theory based approach for evaluating knowledge in fao
 
"Lessons of excellence Learned from the ERC", por José Luís García, Rrepresen...
"Lessons of excellence Learned from the ERC", por José Luís García, Rrepresen..."Lessons of excellence Learned from the ERC", por José Luís García, Rrepresen...
"Lessons of excellence Learned from the ERC", por José Luís García, Rrepresen...
 
Fra scienza e impresa: l’innovazione nei processi produttivi –Esempi di innov...
Fra scienza e impresa: l’innovazione nei processi produttivi –Esempi di innov...Fra scienza e impresa: l’innovazione nei processi produttivi –Esempi di innov...
Fra scienza e impresa: l’innovazione nei processi produttivi –Esempi di innov...
 
Vision for an Organic Food and Farming
Vision for an Organic Food and FarmingVision for an Organic Food and Farming
Vision for an Organic Food and Farming
 
Vision for an Organic Food and Farming
Vision for an Organic Food and FarmingVision for an Organic Food and Farming
Vision for an Organic Food and Farming
 
Vision for an Organic Food and Farming
Vision for an Organic Food and FarmingVision for an Organic Food and Farming
Vision for an Organic Food and Farming
 
D.T.1.4.1_PP3
D.T.1.4.1_PP3D.T.1.4.1_PP3
D.T.1.4.1_PP3
 
CV in English
CV in EnglishCV in English
CV in English
 
Communicating eu-research
Communicating eu-researchCommunicating eu-research
Communicating eu-research
 
International collaboration in a research institute: a bibliometric study
International collaboration in a research institute: a bibliometric studyInternational collaboration in a research institute: a bibliometric study
International collaboration in a research institute: a bibliometric study
 
Winning ITNs with RRI - Relevant sources and further reading
Winning ITNs with RRI - Relevant sources and further readingWinning ITNs with RRI - Relevant sources and further reading
Winning ITNs with RRI - Relevant sources and further reading
 
Barbara Kirsop
Barbara KirsopBarbara Kirsop
Barbara Kirsop
 
Koch fp7 - info day - overview
Koch  fp7 - info day - overviewKoch  fp7 - info day - overview
Koch fp7 - info day - overview
 
BiPday 2014 -- Pesole Graziano
BiPday 2014 -- Pesole GrazianoBiPday 2014 -- Pesole Graziano
BiPday 2014 -- Pesole Graziano
 
Ciência Aberta na França: ponto da situação, legislação, iniciativas, ferrame...
Ciência Aberta na França: ponto da situação, legislação, iniciativas, ferrame...Ciência Aberta na França: ponto da situação, legislação, iniciativas, ferrame...
Ciência Aberta na França: ponto da situação, legislação, iniciativas, ferrame...
 

Mais de IAALD Community

11 04 lm alvare-mendeley
11 04 lm alvare-mendeley11 04 lm alvare-mendeley
11 04 lm alvare-mendeleyIAALD Community
 
Decentralizing Online Publishing in Your Organization; Creating websites on t...
Decentralizing Online Publishing in Your Organization; Creating websites on t...Decentralizing Online Publishing in Your Organization; Creating websites on t...
Decentralizing Online Publishing in Your Organization; Creating websites on t...IAALD Community
 
Almost Famous  Boost your research profile, collaborate and share using Mendeley
Almost Famous Boost your research profile, collaborate and share using MendeleyAlmost Famous Boost your research profile, collaborate and share using Mendeley
Almost Famous  Boost your research profile, collaborate and share using MendeleyIAALD Community
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: New tools and Repositories
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: New tools and RepositoriesIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: New tools and Repositories
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: New tools and RepositoriesIAALD Community
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: National experiences
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: National experiencesIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: National experiences
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: National experiencesIAALD Community
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Integrated information systems
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Integrated information systemsIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Integrated information systems
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Integrated information systemsIAALD Community
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovative learning processes
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovative learning processesIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovative learning processes
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovative learning processesIAALD Community
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Francophone workshop
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Francophone workshopIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Francophone workshop
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Francophone workshopIAALD Community
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovations in Biodiversity Information W...
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovations in Biodiversity Information W...IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovations in Biodiversity Information W...
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovations in Biodiversity Information W...IAALD Community
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Targeted Information Products and Services
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Targeted Information Products and ServicesIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Targeted Information Products and Services
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Targeted Information Products and ServicesIAALD Community
 
The Global Plant Health Centre: Building a Surveillance and Knowledge System
The Global Plant Health Centre: Building a Surveillance and Knowledge SystemThe Global Plant Health Centre: Building a Surveillance and Knowledge System
The Global Plant Health Centre: Building a Surveillance and Knowledge SystemIAALD Community
 
The CIARD RING, an infrastructure for interoperability of agricultural resear...
The CIARD RING, an infrastructure for interoperability of agricultural resear...The CIARD RING, an infrastructure for interoperability of agricultural resear...
The CIARD RING, an infrastructure for interoperability of agricultural resear...IAALD Community
 
The LIMS Community and its collaborative Livestock Information Management Sys...
The LIMS Community and its collaborative Livestock Information Management Sys...The LIMS Community and its collaborative Livestock Information Management Sys...
The LIMS Community and its collaborative Livestock Information Management Sys...IAALD Community
 
The Linnaeus Link Project
The Linnaeus Link ProjectThe Linnaeus Link Project
The Linnaeus Link ProjectIAALD Community
 
From databases to information flow: CIFOR and seamless integration of informa...
From databases to information flow: CIFOR and seamless integration of informa...From databases to information flow: CIFOR and seamless integration of informa...
From databases to information flow: CIFOR and seamless integration of informa...IAALD Community
 
A monitoring system for preventive control of Desert Locust in West Africa
A monitoring system for preventive control of Desert Locust in West AfricaA monitoring system for preventive control of Desert Locust in West Africa
A monitoring system for preventive control of Desert Locust in West AfricaIAALD Community
 
Capitalization of experiences and innovations
Capitalization of experiences and innovationsCapitalization of experiences and innovations
Capitalization of experiences and innovationsIAALD Community
 
Communicating Agricultural Science and Technology Indicators: Lessons learned
Communicating Agricultural Science and Technology Indicators: Lessons learnedCommunicating Agricultural Science and Technology Indicators: Lessons learned
Communicating Agricultural Science and Technology Indicators: Lessons learnedIAALD Community
 
The state and exchange of agricultural scientific and technical information i...
The state and exchange of agricultural scientific and technical information i...The state and exchange of agricultural scientific and technical information i...
The state and exchange of agricultural scientific and technical information i...IAALD Community
 
The AGROVOC Concept Server Workbench System: Empowering management of agricul...
The AGROVOC Concept Server Workbench System: Empowering management of agricul...The AGROVOC Concept Server Workbench System: Empowering management of agricul...
The AGROVOC Concept Server Workbench System: Empowering management of agricul...IAALD Community
 

Mais de IAALD Community (20)

11 04 lm alvare-mendeley
11 04 lm alvare-mendeley11 04 lm alvare-mendeley
11 04 lm alvare-mendeley
 
Decentralizing Online Publishing in Your Organization; Creating websites on t...
Decentralizing Online Publishing in Your Organization; Creating websites on t...Decentralizing Online Publishing in Your Organization; Creating websites on t...
Decentralizing Online Publishing in Your Organization; Creating websites on t...
 
Almost Famous  Boost your research profile, collaborate and share using Mendeley
Almost Famous Boost your research profile, collaborate and share using MendeleyAlmost Famous Boost your research profile, collaborate and share using Mendeley
Almost Famous  Boost your research profile, collaborate and share using Mendeley
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: New tools and Repositories
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: New tools and RepositoriesIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: New tools and Repositories
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: New tools and Repositories
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: National experiences
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: National experiencesIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: National experiences
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: National experiences
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Integrated information systems
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Integrated information systemsIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Integrated information systems
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Integrated information systems
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovative learning processes
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovative learning processesIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovative learning processes
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovative learning processes
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Francophone workshop
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Francophone workshopIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Francophone workshop
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Francophone workshop
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovations in Biodiversity Information W...
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovations in Biodiversity Information W...IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovations in Biodiversity Information W...
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Innovations in Biodiversity Information W...
 
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Targeted Information Products and Services
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Targeted Information Products and ServicesIAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Targeted Information Products and Services
IAALD 2010 Closing Session Report: Targeted Information Products and Services
 
The Global Plant Health Centre: Building a Surveillance and Knowledge System
The Global Plant Health Centre: Building a Surveillance and Knowledge SystemThe Global Plant Health Centre: Building a Surveillance and Knowledge System
The Global Plant Health Centre: Building a Surveillance and Knowledge System
 
The CIARD RING, an infrastructure for interoperability of agricultural resear...
The CIARD RING, an infrastructure for interoperability of agricultural resear...The CIARD RING, an infrastructure for interoperability of agricultural resear...
The CIARD RING, an infrastructure for interoperability of agricultural resear...
 
The LIMS Community and its collaborative Livestock Information Management Sys...
The LIMS Community and its collaborative Livestock Information Management Sys...The LIMS Community and its collaborative Livestock Information Management Sys...
The LIMS Community and its collaborative Livestock Information Management Sys...
 
The Linnaeus Link Project
The Linnaeus Link ProjectThe Linnaeus Link Project
The Linnaeus Link Project
 
From databases to information flow: CIFOR and seamless integration of informa...
From databases to information flow: CIFOR and seamless integration of informa...From databases to information flow: CIFOR and seamless integration of informa...
From databases to information flow: CIFOR and seamless integration of informa...
 
A monitoring system for preventive control of Desert Locust in West Africa
A monitoring system for preventive control of Desert Locust in West AfricaA monitoring system for preventive control of Desert Locust in West Africa
A monitoring system for preventive control of Desert Locust in West Africa
 
Capitalization of experiences and innovations
Capitalization of experiences and innovationsCapitalization of experiences and innovations
Capitalization of experiences and innovations
 
Communicating Agricultural Science and Technology Indicators: Lessons learned
Communicating Agricultural Science and Technology Indicators: Lessons learnedCommunicating Agricultural Science and Technology Indicators: Lessons learned
Communicating Agricultural Science and Technology Indicators: Lessons learned
 
The state and exchange of agricultural scientific and technical information i...
The state and exchange of agricultural scientific and technical information i...The state and exchange of agricultural scientific and technical information i...
The state and exchange of agricultural scientific and technical information i...
 
The AGROVOC Concept Server Workbench System: Empowering management of agricul...
The AGROVOC Concept Server Workbench System: Empowering management of agricul...The AGROVOC Concept Server Workbench System: Empowering management of agricul...
The AGROVOC Concept Server Workbench System: Empowering management of agricul...
 

Collective scientific expertise at INRA : A tool for decision making and dialogue between science and society

  • 1. Collective Scientific Expertise (ESCo) at the French National Institute for Agricultural Research (INRA) a tool for decision making and public debate Dominique FOURNIER, Inra, Montpellier, France & Claire SABBAGH, Inra, Paris, France Scientific and Technical Information and Rural Development IAALD XIIIth World Congress, Montpellier, France, 26-29 April 2010
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 5. ESCo Process in 8 steps Focus on steps which deal with information
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.