SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 15
Geography Department  Land Evaluation Techniques Comparing Fuzzy AHP with Ideal Point methodsMukhtar Elaalem   Dr: Alexis ComberProf Dr: Pete Fisher  http://www.le.ac.uk/geography/staff/pg_elaalem.html
Overview Introduction Methodology Results Summary  Conclusion
1.Introduction Land resources are gradually becoming limited  Increases in population pressure on these natural resources Increased pressure is particularly problematic in countries with restricted water and soil resources such as developing countries Increased food production needed
1.Introduction Land evaluation systems in developing countries frequently makes little use of local knowledge .  There are many land evaluation techniques which are widely used in developing countries. The FAO framework  with the Boolean technique is the most popular one. ,[object Object],[object Object]
2. Methodology ,[object Object],Erosion Hazard;  Soil characteristics  Topographic Weighting parameters  A pairwise comparisons statistical analysis (table 1).
2.Methodology/ Model structure Land evaluation model using Fuzzy AHP  Convert the raw data (land characteristics) into standardized criterion scores scale using different fuzzy membership function models.  Generation standardized criterion map layers  Derivation weighted standardized fuzzy criterion map layers. Derivation fuzzy rating map layers Generation the final land suitability map
2.Methodology/ Model structure Land evaluation model using an Ideal Point Determine the maximum and the minimum values for each of the weighted standardized map layer for each land characteristic  Using the separation measure to compute “the distance” between the positive ideal point and each alternative An application the similar separation measure to determine “the distance” between the negative ideal point and each alternative Create maps from compute the relative closeness to the ideal point Ranking the alternatives and create the final land suitability map
3.Results         Fuzzy AHP  map                     an Ideal Point map
3.Results ,[object Object]
The result of the two models were cross-tabulated.
An overall accuracy and KHAT statistic analysis applied to assess the results (table 3). ,[object Object]
4. Summary Form this paper  it can summarize that : Few areas highly suitable classes have been found from the use the Fuzzy AHP and Ideal Point classifications. Few areas less suitable classes have been found from the use the Fuzzy AHP and Ideal Point classifications Most locations moderate suitableclasses have been found from the use the Fuzzy AHP and Ideal Point classifications There is little differences in the result: An Ideal Point classification has some biasness towards negative and positive ideal values. The high percentages of the KHAT accuracy and an overall accuracy shows that there is a good agreement between the maps.
5. Conclusion ,[object Object],Land characteristics affecting wheat production was very well organized and then assessed to fit into the framework of decision-making based on local knowledge The use of the Fuzzy AHP and Ideal Point methods to the model of land evaluation has facilitated the incorporation of expert knowledge from different local experts and literature reviews. Weighting land characteristics were made according to their relative importance with taken the crop requirement for wheat under local conditions into accounts.
Thank you

More Related Content

What's hot

Lab_6_Geo-referencing
Lab_6_Geo-referencingLab_6_Geo-referencing
Lab_6_Geo-referencingAtiqa khan
 
Presentation2 - GEOQUAL, ELCmapas & ECOGEO tools
Presentation2 - GEOQUAL, ELCmapas & ECOGEO toolsPresentation2 - GEOQUAL, ELCmapas & ECOGEO tools
Presentation2 - GEOQUAL, ELCmapas & ECOGEO toolsMauricio Parra Quijano
 
Water and Crop Response to Variable Rate Irrigation using Remote Sensing base...
Water and Crop Response to Variable Rate Irrigation using Remote Sensing base...Water and Crop Response to Variable Rate Irrigation using Remote Sensing base...
Water and Crop Response to Variable Rate Irrigation using Remote Sensing base...Daugherty Water for Food Global Institute
 
Spatial data analysis 1
Spatial data analysis 1Spatial data analysis 1
Spatial data analysis 1Johan Blomme
 
Remote sensing and mapping tool development of NFA Project in Vietnam
Remote sensing and mapping tool development of NFA Project in VietnamRemote sensing and mapping tool development of NFA Project in Vietnam
Remote sensing and mapping tool development of NFA Project in VietnamFAO
 
Using QGIS for ecological surveying
Using QGIS for ecological surveyingUsing QGIS for ecological surveying
Using QGIS for ecological surveyingRoss McDonald
 

What's hot (9)

Lab_6_Geo-referencing
Lab_6_Geo-referencingLab_6_Geo-referencing
Lab_6_Geo-referencing
 
Presentation2 - GEOQUAL, ELCmapas & ECOGEO tools
Presentation2 - GEOQUAL, ELCmapas & ECOGEO toolsPresentation2 - GEOQUAL, ELCmapas & ECOGEO tools
Presentation2 - GEOQUAL, ELCmapas & ECOGEO tools
 
GIS
GISGIS
GIS
 
Sensor-Based Site-Specific Management of Irrigation and Fertilizer
Sensor-Based Site-Specific Management of Irrigation and FertilizerSensor-Based Site-Specific Management of Irrigation and Fertilizer
Sensor-Based Site-Specific Management of Irrigation and Fertilizer
 
Water and Crop Response to Variable Rate Irrigation using Remote Sensing base...
Water and Crop Response to Variable Rate Irrigation using Remote Sensing base...Water and Crop Response to Variable Rate Irrigation using Remote Sensing base...
Water and Crop Response to Variable Rate Irrigation using Remote Sensing base...
 
Spatial data analysis 1
Spatial data analysis 1Spatial data analysis 1
Spatial data analysis 1
 
Remote sensing and mapping tool development of NFA Project in Vietnam
Remote sensing and mapping tool development of NFA Project in VietnamRemote sensing and mapping tool development of NFA Project in Vietnam
Remote sensing and mapping tool development of NFA Project in Vietnam
 
Using QGIS for ecological surveying
Using QGIS for ecological surveyingUsing QGIS for ecological surveying
Using QGIS for ecological surveying
 
Aero
AeroAero
Aero
 

Similar to 5A_1_Land evaluation techniques comparing fuzzy ahp with ideal point methods

Beyond Dots on a Map: Spatially Modeled Surfaces of DHS data
Beyond Dots on a Map: Spatially Modeled Surfaces of DHS dataBeyond Dots on a Map: Spatially Modeled Surfaces of DHS data
Beyond Dots on a Map: Spatially Modeled Surfaces of DHS dataMEASURE Evaluation
 
Modeling the impact of global change on regional agricultural land use throug...
Modeling the impact of global change on regional agricultural land use throug...Modeling the impact of global change on regional agricultural land use throug...
Modeling the impact of global change on regional agricultural land use throug...Özcan Çavuşoğlu, Ph.D.(Cand.)
 
Alberta innovates pem_presentation_feb13_2012_ram_version1
Alberta innovates pem_presentation_feb13_2012_ram_version1Alberta innovates pem_presentation_feb13_2012_ram_version1
Alberta innovates pem_presentation_feb13_2012_ram_version1Bob MacMillan
 
Introduction to soil property mapping
Introduction to soil property mappingIntroduction to soil property mapping
Introduction to soil property mappingExternalEvents
 
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...IRJET Journal
 
Item 23. Development of transfer functions – progresses, needs and way forward
Item 23. Development of transfer functions – progresses, needs and way forward Item 23. Development of transfer functions – progresses, needs and way forward
Item 23. Development of transfer functions – progresses, needs and way forward Soils FAO-GSP
 
Item 7: Progress on implementation of GSOC17
Item 7: Progress on implementation of GSOC17Item 7: Progress on implementation of GSOC17
Item 7: Progress on implementation of GSOC17Stankovic G
 
CLEANED tool: Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a sustai...
CLEANED tool: Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a sustai...CLEANED tool: Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a sustai...
CLEANED tool: Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a sustai...ILRI
 
CLEANED tool : Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a susta...
CLEANED tool : Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a susta...CLEANED tool : Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a susta...
CLEANED tool : Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a susta...Catherine Pfeifer
 
Classification accuracy analyses using Shannon’s Entropy
Classification accuracy analyses using Shannon’s EntropyClassification accuracy analyses using Shannon’s Entropy
Classification accuracy analyses using Shannon’s EntropyIJERA Editor
 
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...FAO
 
Spatial data analysis
Spatial data analysisSpatial data analysis
Spatial data analysisJohan Blomme
 
Poster Pillar 5 - Asian Soil Partnership
Poster Pillar 5 - Asian Soil PartnershipPoster Pillar 5 - Asian Soil Partnership
Poster Pillar 5 - Asian Soil PartnershipExternalEvents
 
Pillar 5 : Harmonization of methods and measurements | Rainer Baritz, BGR
Pillar 5 : Harmonization of methods and measurements | Rainer Baritz, BGRPillar 5 : Harmonization of methods and measurements | Rainer Baritz, BGR
Pillar 5 : Harmonization of methods and measurements | Rainer Baritz, BGRFAO
 
Introduction of Lateral Decision Conveying Approach Based Multi Criteria Asse...
Introduction of Lateral Decision Conveying Approach Based Multi Criteria Asse...Introduction of Lateral Decision Conveying Approach Based Multi Criteria Asse...
Introduction of Lateral Decision Conveying Approach Based Multi Criteria Asse...ijsrd.com
 
IRJET-A Review on Implementation of High Dimension Colour Transform in Domain...
IRJET-A Review on Implementation of High Dimension Colour Transform in Domain...IRJET-A Review on Implementation of High Dimension Colour Transform in Domain...
IRJET-A Review on Implementation of High Dimension Colour Transform in Domain...IRJET Journal
 
Pillar 5 HARMONIZATION
Pillar 5 HARMONIZATIONPillar 5 HARMONIZATION
Pillar 5 HARMONIZATIONExternalEvents
 
Air quality challenges and business opportunities in China: Fusion of environ...
Air quality challenges and business opportunities in China: Fusion of environ...Air quality challenges and business opportunities in China: Fusion of environ...
Air quality challenges and business opportunities in China: Fusion of environ...CLIC Innovation Ltd
 

Similar to 5A_1_Land evaluation techniques comparing fuzzy ahp with ideal point methods (20)

Beyond Dots on a Map: Spatially Modeled Surfaces of DHS data
Beyond Dots on a Map: Spatially Modeled Surfaces of DHS dataBeyond Dots on a Map: Spatially Modeled Surfaces of DHS data
Beyond Dots on a Map: Spatially Modeled Surfaces of DHS data
 
Modeling the impact of global change on regional agricultural land use throug...
Modeling the impact of global change on regional agricultural land use throug...Modeling the impact of global change on regional agricultural land use throug...
Modeling the impact of global change on regional agricultural land use throug...
 
Alberta innovates pem_presentation_feb13_2012_ram_version1
Alberta innovates pem_presentation_feb13_2012_ram_version1Alberta innovates pem_presentation_feb13_2012_ram_version1
Alberta innovates pem_presentation_feb13_2012_ram_version1
 
Introduction to soil property mapping
Introduction to soil property mappingIntroduction to soil property mapping
Introduction to soil property mapping
 
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...
A Combined Entropy-FR Weightage Formulation Model for Delineation of Groundwa...
 
Mv2522052211
Mv2522052211Mv2522052211
Mv2522052211
 
Item 23. Development of transfer functions – progresses, needs and way forward
Item 23. Development of transfer functions – progresses, needs and way forward Item 23. Development of transfer functions – progresses, needs and way forward
Item 23. Development of transfer functions – progresses, needs and way forward
 
Item 7: Progress on implementation of GSOC17
Item 7: Progress on implementation of GSOC17Item 7: Progress on implementation of GSOC17
Item 7: Progress on implementation of GSOC17
 
SIEMPRE: A GIS aided multi-criteria decision analysis application for settin...
SIEMPRE:  A GIS aided multi-criteria decision analysis application for settin...SIEMPRE:  A GIS aided multi-criteria decision analysis application for settin...
SIEMPRE: A GIS aided multi-criteria decision analysis application for settin...
 
CLEANED tool: Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a sustai...
CLEANED tool: Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a sustai...CLEANED tool: Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a sustai...
CLEANED tool: Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a sustai...
 
CLEANED tool : Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a susta...
CLEANED tool : Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a susta...CLEANED tool : Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a susta...
CLEANED tool : Live spatial simulation to develop a shared vision for a susta...
 
Classification accuracy analyses using Shannon’s Entropy
Classification accuracy analyses using Shannon’s EntropyClassification accuracy analyses using Shannon’s Entropy
Classification accuracy analyses using Shannon’s Entropy
 
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...
Improved Agricultural Monitoring Systems through satellite imagery for IRAN: ...
 
Spatial data analysis
Spatial data analysisSpatial data analysis
Spatial data analysis
 
Poster Pillar 5 - Asian Soil Partnership
Poster Pillar 5 - Asian Soil PartnershipPoster Pillar 5 - Asian Soil Partnership
Poster Pillar 5 - Asian Soil Partnership
 
Pillar 5 : Harmonization of methods and measurements | Rainer Baritz, BGR
Pillar 5 : Harmonization of methods and measurements | Rainer Baritz, BGRPillar 5 : Harmonization of methods and measurements | Rainer Baritz, BGR
Pillar 5 : Harmonization of methods and measurements | Rainer Baritz, BGR
 
Introduction of Lateral Decision Conveying Approach Based Multi Criteria Asse...
Introduction of Lateral Decision Conveying Approach Based Multi Criteria Asse...Introduction of Lateral Decision Conveying Approach Based Multi Criteria Asse...
Introduction of Lateral Decision Conveying Approach Based Multi Criteria Asse...
 
IRJET-A Review on Implementation of High Dimension Colour Transform in Domain...
IRJET-A Review on Implementation of High Dimension Colour Transform in Domain...IRJET-A Review on Implementation of High Dimension Colour Transform in Domain...
IRJET-A Review on Implementation of High Dimension Colour Transform in Domain...
 
Pillar 5 HARMONIZATION
Pillar 5 HARMONIZATIONPillar 5 HARMONIZATION
Pillar 5 HARMONIZATION
 
Air quality challenges and business opportunities in China: Fusion of environ...
Air quality challenges and business opportunities in China: Fusion of environ...Air quality challenges and business opportunities in China: Fusion of environ...
Air quality challenges and business opportunities in China: Fusion of environ...
 

More from GISRUK conference

7B_3_Matterhorn on the horizon
7B_3_Matterhorn on the horizon7B_3_Matterhorn on the horizon
7B_3_Matterhorn on the horizonGISRUK conference
 
7B_2_Topological consistent generalization of openstreetmap
7B_2_Topological consistent generalization of openstreetmap7B_2_Topological consistent generalization of openstreetmap
7B_2_Topological consistent generalization of openstreetmapGISRUK conference
 
7A_4_Gps data collection setting for pedestrian activity modelling
7A_4_Gps data collection setting for pedestrian activity modelling7A_4_Gps data collection setting for pedestrian activity modelling
7A_4_Gps data collection setting for pedestrian activity modellingGISRUK conference
 
5A_3_GIS based spatial modelling for improving the sustainability of aggregat...
5A_3_GIS based spatial modelling for improving the sustainability of aggregat...5A_3_GIS based spatial modelling for improving the sustainability of aggregat...
5A_3_GIS based spatial modelling for improving the sustainability of aggregat...GISRUK conference
 
4B_3_Automatically generating keywods for georeferenced imaged
4B_3_Automatically generating keywods for georeferenced imaged4B_3_Automatically generating keywods for georeferenced imaged
4B_3_Automatically generating keywods for georeferenced imagedGISRUK conference
 
4B_1_How many volunteers does it take to map an area well
4B_1_How many volunteers does it take to map an area well4B_1_How many volunteers does it take to map an area well
4B_1_How many volunteers does it take to map an area wellGISRUK conference
 
4A_1_Uncertainty in the 2001 output area classification for the census of eng...
4A_1_Uncertainty in the 2001 output area classification for the census of eng...4A_1_Uncertainty in the 2001 output area classification for the census of eng...
4A_1_Uncertainty in the 2001 output area classification for the census of eng...GISRUK conference
 
3A_4_Applying network analysis to quantify accessibility to urban greenspace ...
3A_4_Applying network analysis to quantify accessibility to urban greenspace ...3A_4_Applying network analysis to quantify accessibility to urban greenspace ...
3A_4_Applying network analysis to quantify accessibility to urban greenspace ...GISRUK conference
 
3A_2_Modelling health-harming behaviours in a socially ranked geographic space
3A_2_Modelling health-harming behaviours in a socially ranked geographic space3A_2_Modelling health-harming behaviours in a socially ranked geographic space
3A_2_Modelling health-harming behaviours in a socially ranked geographic spaceGISRUK conference
 
1A_3_A geodemographic classification of london primary schools
1A_3_A geodemographic classification of london primary schools1A_3_A geodemographic classification of london primary schools
1A_3_A geodemographic classification of london primary schoolsGISRUK conference
 
UK Map Challenge Aidan Slingsby
UK Map Challenge   Aidan SlingsbyUK Map Challenge   Aidan Slingsby
UK Map Challenge Aidan SlingsbyGISRUK conference
 
SP_4 Supporting spatial negotiations in land use planning
SP_4 Supporting spatial negotiations in land use planningSP_4 Supporting spatial negotiations in land use planning
SP_4 Supporting spatial negotiations in land use planningGISRUK conference
 
SP_3 Automatic identification of high streets and classification of urban lan...
SP_3 Automatic identification of high streets and classification of urban lan...SP_3 Automatic identification of high streets and classification of urban lan...
SP_3 Automatic identification of high streets and classification of urban lan...GISRUK conference
 
9B_1_Trust in web gis a preliminary investigation of the environment agencys ...
9B_1_Trust in web gis a preliminary investigation of the environment agencys ...9B_1_Trust in web gis a preliminary investigation of the environment agencys ...
9B_1_Trust in web gis a preliminary investigation of the environment agencys ...GISRUK conference
 
9A_2_Automatic classification of retail spaces from a large scale topographc ...
9A_2_Automatic classification of retail spaces from a large scale topographc ...9A_2_Automatic classification of retail spaces from a large scale topographc ...
9A_2_Automatic classification of retail spaces from a large scale topographc ...GISRUK conference
 
9A_1_On automatic mapping of environmental data using adaptive general regres...
9A_1_On automatic mapping of environmental data using adaptive general regres...9A_1_On automatic mapping of environmental data using adaptive general regres...
9A_1_On automatic mapping of environmental data using adaptive general regres...GISRUK conference
 
8B_4_Exploring the usability of geographic information
8B_4_Exploring the usability of geographic information8B_4_Exploring the usability of geographic information
8B_4_Exploring the usability of geographic informationGISRUK conference
 
8B_2_Using sound to represent uncertainty in address locations
8B_2_Using sound to represent uncertainty in address locations8B_2_Using sound to represent uncertainty in address locations
8B_2_Using sound to represent uncertainty in address locationsGISRUK conference
 
8B_1_A map to hear - use of sound in enhancing the map use experience
8B_1_A map to hear - use of sound in enhancing the map use experience8B_1_A map to hear - use of sound in enhancing the map use experience
8B_1_A map to hear - use of sound in enhancing the map use experienceGISRUK conference
 

More from GISRUK conference (20)

8A_1_To vote or not to vote
8A_1_To vote or not to vote8A_1_To vote or not to vote
8A_1_To vote or not to vote
 
7B_3_Matterhorn on the horizon
7B_3_Matterhorn on the horizon7B_3_Matterhorn on the horizon
7B_3_Matterhorn on the horizon
 
7B_2_Topological consistent generalization of openstreetmap
7B_2_Topological consistent generalization of openstreetmap7B_2_Topological consistent generalization of openstreetmap
7B_2_Topological consistent generalization of openstreetmap
 
7A_4_Gps data collection setting for pedestrian activity modelling
7A_4_Gps data collection setting for pedestrian activity modelling7A_4_Gps data collection setting for pedestrian activity modelling
7A_4_Gps data collection setting for pedestrian activity modelling
 
5A_3_GIS based spatial modelling for improving the sustainability of aggregat...
5A_3_GIS based spatial modelling for improving the sustainability of aggregat...5A_3_GIS based spatial modelling for improving the sustainability of aggregat...
5A_3_GIS based spatial modelling for improving the sustainability of aggregat...
 
4B_3_Automatically generating keywods for georeferenced imaged
4B_3_Automatically generating keywods for georeferenced imaged4B_3_Automatically generating keywods for georeferenced imaged
4B_3_Automatically generating keywods for georeferenced imaged
 
4B_1_How many volunteers does it take to map an area well
4B_1_How many volunteers does it take to map an area well4B_1_How many volunteers does it take to map an area well
4B_1_How many volunteers does it take to map an area well
 
4A_1_Uncertainty in the 2001 output area classification for the census of eng...
4A_1_Uncertainty in the 2001 output area classification for the census of eng...4A_1_Uncertainty in the 2001 output area classification for the census of eng...
4A_1_Uncertainty in the 2001 output area classification for the census of eng...
 
3A_4_Applying network analysis to quantify accessibility to urban greenspace ...
3A_4_Applying network analysis to quantify accessibility to urban greenspace ...3A_4_Applying network analysis to quantify accessibility to urban greenspace ...
3A_4_Applying network analysis to quantify accessibility to urban greenspace ...
 
3A_2_Modelling health-harming behaviours in a socially ranked geographic space
3A_2_Modelling health-harming behaviours in a socially ranked geographic space3A_2_Modelling health-harming behaviours in a socially ranked geographic space
3A_2_Modelling health-harming behaviours in a socially ranked geographic space
 
1A_3_A geodemographic classification of london primary schools
1A_3_A geodemographic classification of london primary schools1A_3_A geodemographic classification of london primary schools
1A_3_A geodemographic classification of london primary schools
 
UK Map Challenge Aidan Slingsby
UK Map Challenge   Aidan SlingsbyUK Map Challenge   Aidan Slingsby
UK Map Challenge Aidan Slingsby
 
SP_4 Supporting spatial negotiations in land use planning
SP_4 Supporting spatial negotiations in land use planningSP_4 Supporting spatial negotiations in land use planning
SP_4 Supporting spatial negotiations in land use planning
 
SP_3 Automatic identification of high streets and classification of urban lan...
SP_3 Automatic identification of high streets and classification of urban lan...SP_3 Automatic identification of high streets and classification of urban lan...
SP_3 Automatic identification of high streets and classification of urban lan...
 
9B_1_Trust in web gis a preliminary investigation of the environment agencys ...
9B_1_Trust in web gis a preliminary investigation of the environment agencys ...9B_1_Trust in web gis a preliminary investigation of the environment agencys ...
9B_1_Trust in web gis a preliminary investigation of the environment agencys ...
 
9A_2_Automatic classification of retail spaces from a large scale topographc ...
9A_2_Automatic classification of retail spaces from a large scale topographc ...9A_2_Automatic classification of retail spaces from a large scale topographc ...
9A_2_Automatic classification of retail spaces from a large scale topographc ...
 
9A_1_On automatic mapping of environmental data using adaptive general regres...
9A_1_On automatic mapping of environmental data using adaptive general regres...9A_1_On automatic mapping of environmental data using adaptive general regres...
9A_1_On automatic mapping of environmental data using adaptive general regres...
 
8B_4_Exploring the usability of geographic information
8B_4_Exploring the usability of geographic information8B_4_Exploring the usability of geographic information
8B_4_Exploring the usability of geographic information
 
8B_2_Using sound to represent uncertainty in address locations
8B_2_Using sound to represent uncertainty in address locations8B_2_Using sound to represent uncertainty in address locations
8B_2_Using sound to represent uncertainty in address locations
 
8B_1_A map to hear - use of sound in enhancing the map use experience
8B_1_A map to hear - use of sound in enhancing the map use experience8B_1_A map to hear - use of sound in enhancing the map use experience
8B_1_A map to hear - use of sound in enhancing the map use experience
 

5A_1_Land evaluation techniques comparing fuzzy ahp with ideal point methods

  • 1. Geography Department Land Evaluation Techniques Comparing Fuzzy AHP with Ideal Point methodsMukhtar Elaalem Dr: Alexis ComberProf Dr: Pete Fisher http://www.le.ac.uk/geography/staff/pg_elaalem.html
  • 2. Overview Introduction Methodology Results Summary Conclusion
  • 3. 1.Introduction Land resources are gradually becoming limited Increases in population pressure on these natural resources Increased pressure is particularly problematic in countries with restricted water and soil resources such as developing countries Increased food production needed
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7. 2.Methodology/ Model structure Land evaluation model using Fuzzy AHP Convert the raw data (land characteristics) into standardized criterion scores scale using different fuzzy membership function models. Generation standardized criterion map layers Derivation weighted standardized fuzzy criterion map layers. Derivation fuzzy rating map layers Generation the final land suitability map
  • 8. 2.Methodology/ Model structure Land evaluation model using an Ideal Point Determine the maximum and the minimum values for each of the weighted standardized map layer for each land characteristic Using the separation measure to compute “the distance” between the positive ideal point and each alternative An application the similar separation measure to determine “the distance” between the negative ideal point and each alternative Create maps from compute the relative closeness to the ideal point Ranking the alternatives and create the final land suitability map
  • 9. 3.Results Fuzzy AHP map an Ideal Point map
  • 10.
  • 11. The result of the two models were cross-tabulated.
  • 12.
  • 13. 4. Summary Form this paper it can summarize that : Few areas highly suitable classes have been found from the use the Fuzzy AHP and Ideal Point classifications. Few areas less suitable classes have been found from the use the Fuzzy AHP and Ideal Point classifications Most locations moderate suitableclasses have been found from the use the Fuzzy AHP and Ideal Point classifications There is little differences in the result: An Ideal Point classification has some biasness towards negative and positive ideal values. The high percentages of the KHAT accuracy and an overall accuracy shows that there is a good agreement between the maps.
  • 14.