Sample content Case Study: Out of Town Brown and the Besieged Probation Supervisor Case Study: Out of Town Brown It may be noted that the Collier County Probation Department received negative publicity in the past month and the case of “Out of Town Brown” and the Besieged Probation Supervisor discusses the department. As the chief probation officer is not present, Joan Casey, a career probation officer, is in charge. When the probation sentenced a stalker, the department got the negative publicity of being “soft on crime”. In the absence of the chief, Casey had to agree on a recommendation for probation of a young man who was convicted of the murder of his father. It may be added that the convict suffered many years of physical abuse, sexual abuse, and incest from the age of five. Casey’s point as that the recommendation for probation could be granted as the offender had no prior record of crime and is also otherwise a nonviolent person. When the official was almost at its end,

1. CJA 453 Case Study Out of Town Brown and the Besieged Probation Supervisor
Link : http://uopexam.com/product/cja-453-case-study-out-of-town-brown-and-the-besieged-
probation-supervisor/
Sample content
Case Study: Out of Town Brown and the Besieged Probation Supervisor
Case Study: Out of Town Brown

2. It may be noted that the Collier County Probation Department received negative
publicity in the past month and the case of “Out of Town Brown” and the Besieged
Probation Supervisor discusses the department. As the chief probation officer is
not present, Joan Casey, a career probation officer, is in charge. When the
probation sentenced a stalker, the department got the negative publicity of being
“soft on crime”. In the absence of the chief, Casey had to agree on a
recommendation for probation of a young man who was convicted of the murder of
his father. It may be added that the convict suffered many years of physical abuse,
sexual abuse, and incest from the age of five. Casey’s point as that the
recommendation for probation could be granted as the offender had no prior record
of crime and is also otherwise a nonviolent person.
When the official was almost at its end, Casey received a call from a well-known
local television anchor interested to know about the sentencing. In such a scenario,
Casey should not discuss the sentencing issues with the reporter as the public
would then rely on the reporter’s information in future. In fact, Casey should not
reveal information about the probation recommendation before the judge makes
the final decision as people may react against it before the final decision is made.
The best thing to do is to avoid the reporter in a pleasant way. In fact, the reporter’s
report may completely go against Casey.
Casey’s Response to the Reporter
The case is if Casey decides to talk with the reporter about officer’s
recommendation, she should relate things to researched data. One useful piece of
information is that about half of prison inmates are arrested and returned to prison
soon after release from an institution (Beck, 1989). In this case, though the crime
may sound horrific, the offender is low-risk; and moreover, he suffered emotional
as well as physical abuse, sexual abuse, and that forced him to psychological
disorder. As Prisons are meant for high-risk offenders, this offender may have so
intermediate sanctions that may include fines, community corrections, home
confinement, electronic monitoring, intensive probation supervision, and boot
camps. These sanctions have better supervision than used in prisons. We know
that first time offenders committing mid-level crimes and of low risk are eligible for
intermediate sanction. This saves money without posing public threat.
As intermediate sanctions are applicable for only specific offenders, probation
officers have to put offenders in appropriate programs suiting their needs and
treatment. Social skills and employments skills can be improved by placing
offenders in intermediate sanction. Standard probation, a community service
program, or fines can be sentenced if the offender is low-risk and have no affiliation
with drugs. Though this offender has a murderer, he is no threat to the society.

3. That is why we can argue that the judge should sentence the offender to a
community service program and give him access to treatment. We also see that
low-risk offenders can go for community service activities in their homes. They may
also go at a job site during the hours they are accepted to be away from their
home. The development of community service sentences has been found to be
good for the spirit (Maher & Dufour, 1987). Minor offenders also benefit from
community service and mixed sentencing. Experiencing prison and receiving
probation can take place throughout the week. In this case, intermediate sanction
should be applied. Moreover, if he is allowed to be involved in community service
programs, he will be able to remain in society with adequate supervision. This will
help his rehabilitation in turn. Moreover, his memory of abuse may also get erased
from his mind.
Probation Officer’s Recommendation of Intermediate Sanctions
Considering the facts that this 23 years old offender had no prior criminal history
and also a nonviolent person as well as a low recidivism risk, we can say that the
probation officer’s recommendation of intermediate sanctions would be the most
appropriate sentence. Of course, as the man suffered physical and emotional
problems since the age of five being an incest victim, the sentence is appropriate. It
is also of importance that the court put emphasis on the probation officer’s
recommendation as the officer examined the whole situation independently and
also kept in mind the systems goals in the use of intermediate sanctions. The US
Department of Health and Human Services (2009) describes the systems goals in
the use of intermediate sanctions in the following manner:
• Best of public money has to be ensured by using resources efficiently and
effectively.
• Crowding in jails, prison, and probation caseloads need to be reduced and so
there has to be
http://uopexam.com/product/cja-453-case-study-out-of-town-brown-and-the-besieged-
probation-supervisor/