#StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024
Capita selecta Les 4 paper reviews and feedback
1. capita selecta
Les 4
4 December 2013
Erik Duval
Dept. Computerwetenschappen
http://www.cs.kuleuven.ac.be/~erikd/
1
2. task in 2 weeks from
now…
!
two or three more papers
draft 2 short paper
2
3. Head Mounted Displays
Chuptys, De Coninck
Gaze-based Attentive
User Interfaces
Bartels, Beckers, De
Buyser
Gesture-Based Control
of In-Home Displays
De Haes, De Moor
Vanwijn
peer review feedback
ok
ok
ok
nieuwe papers
ok
ok
ok
nieuwe versie paper
ok
ok
ok
7. A Survey on Gesture-Based
Control of In-Home Displays
•
•
English very so-so
•
•
•
•
•
relation between four research issues unclear
second research issue seems less connected to gesture, more to inhome displays: separate these
recognition of gestures first focuses on cost (different issue)
contribution of papers not so clear
structure not clear - too much narrative, not enough analysis
no clear conclusion
8. Gaze-based Attentive
User Interfaces
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Good start to indicate why this is a relevant topic.
Uses structure of [15] to structure paper: good!
Eye-based interaction subsection on p.1 a bit lost?
Well-structured clear argumentation: good!
Still some TODO’s…
Rationale for paper selection rather weak.
No real conclusion.
[4], [7], [12], [14], [16], [17], [19]: incomplete
9. Head Mounted Displays
•
•
•
•
•
•
nog TODO’s
•
No conclusion or rationale for paper selection?
Google Glasses
Goed gebruik Engels.
Referenties nodig bij voorbeelden VR, Oculus Rift.
A table summarising main issues and comparing VR with AR would help.
Evaluation is more about evaluating in a domain rather than evaluation
the domain itself?
10. google plus en blog?
!
2de semester:
project over topic van paper
of allen zelfde project?
10