SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 8
Debate Camp Day 3
Solvency Press Step 1: Illustrate that their plan does not solve This can be done through reasoning or examples.  If there is too big of an inferential leap between the action of the plan and the results, you can exploit that vulnerability. Step 2: Revisit the harms (or whatever problems are being solved), and discuss how each one gets worse.  This is the impact to your solvency press and how you are able to garner offense for the Opp.
Practice 1) The USFG should implement a national single-payer healthcare system2) The EPA should mandate higher fuel efficiency standards for US motor vehicles3) The United Nations should deploy a peacekeeping force under unified command to decrease piracy off Somalia.4) The United Nations should sanction Israel5) The International Monetary Fund should stop collecting all arrears6) The USFG should substantially reduce the power of the Federal Reserve Bank7) The United Nations should remove veto power from the five permanent members of the security council.8) The United Nation should give one or more of the following nations permanent security council membership: Brazil, Japan, Argentina, Spain, and Israel.
Fiat Abuse Formatted Like topicality: Interpretations:  We believe that fiat should be… Violation:  They abused fiat by… Standards:  Ground, etc. Voter:  Fairness, etc.
Types of Fiat Abuse Multi-Step Multi-Actor Mindset What else?
Practice Topic:  This house should legalize it. PLAN:  The USFG will legalize all drugs and start rehab programs to help those who are addicted.
Practice Topic:  This house should change the current health care system. PLAN:  Iraq and North Korea will work together to make a joint health care bill for their people to share resources.
Practice Topic:  This house should significantly decrease recidivism.   PLAN:  The USFG will make it so that criminals no longer want to commit crimes, therefore lowering recidivism.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Semelhante a Solvency press and fiat abuse

Universal Periodic Review - training
Universal Periodic Review - trainingUniversal Periodic Review - training
Universal Periodic Review - trainingARC International
 
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4.pptx
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4.pptxCatch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4.pptx
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4.pptxrezamagdaraogckcigsa
 
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4 [Autosaved].pptx
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4 [Autosaved].pptxCatch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4 [Autosaved].pptx
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4 [Autosaved].pptxrezamagdaraogckcigsa
 
Write Research Proposal Research Proposal, Writin
Write Research Proposal Research Proposal, WritinWrite Research Proposal Research Proposal, Writin
Write Research Proposal Research Proposal, WritinJessica Rinehart
 
The Aquarius Doctrine A
The Aquarius Doctrine AThe Aquarius Doctrine A
The Aquarius Doctrine AblahIII
 
System Traps and Opportunities
System Traps and OpportunitiesSystem Traps and Opportunities
System Traps and OpportunitiesJason Yip
 
Ankit ie mim essay_1_version_2
Ankit ie mim essay_1_version_2Ankit ie mim essay_1_version_2
Ankit ie mim essay_1_version_2ankit loya
 
Uday Shankar "Indian response" - Second GPN Global Webinar "COVID-19. SUPERN...
 Uday Shankar "Indian response" - Second GPN Global Webinar "COVID-19. SUPERN... Uday Shankar "Indian response" - Second GPN Global Webinar "COVID-19. SUPERN...
Uday Shankar "Indian response" - Second GPN Global Webinar "COVID-19. SUPERN...GLOBAL PANDEMIC NETWORK
 
Education Please respond to the following· Based on the lectu.docx
Education Please respond to the following· Based on the lectu.docxEducation Please respond to the following· Based on the lectu.docx
Education Please respond to the following· Based on the lectu.docxSALU18
 
Students presentation
Students presentationStudents presentation
Students presentationivid1990
 
NDCC Memo Circular No. 05 s 2007 (2) Cluster Approach
NDCC Memo Circular No. 05 s 2007 (2) Cluster ApproachNDCC Memo Circular No. 05 s 2007 (2) Cluster Approach
NDCC Memo Circular No. 05 s 2007 (2) Cluster ApproachTudlo
 
The International NGO Council on Violence Against Children: "creating a non-v...
The International NGO Council on Violence Against Children: "creating a non-v...The International NGO Council on Violence Against Children: "creating a non-v...
The International NGO Council on Violence Against Children: "creating a non-v...Thomas Müller
 
2015 Prescription for America Rebrand and Rebuild
2015 Prescription for America  Rebrand and Rebuild2015 Prescription for America  Rebrand and Rebuild
2015 Prescription for America Rebrand and RebuildDarrell Prince
 
Female Genital Mutilation for Healthcare Professionals
Female Genital Mutilation for Healthcare ProfessionalsFemale Genital Mutilation for Healthcare Professionals
Female Genital Mutilation for Healthcare Professionalsmeducationdotnet
 
brown-finkelstein-2011-insuring-long-term-care-in-the-united-states.pdf
brown-finkelstein-2011-insuring-long-term-care-in-the-united-states.pdfbrown-finkelstein-2011-insuring-long-term-care-in-the-united-states.pdf
brown-finkelstein-2011-insuring-long-term-care-in-the-united-states.pdfAlkeshLund
 
Punishing success ?
Punishing success ?Punishing success ?
Punishing success ?clac.cab
 

Semelhante a Solvency press and fiat abuse (20)

Universal Periodic Review - training
Universal Periodic Review - trainingUniversal Periodic Review - training
Universal Periodic Review - training
 
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4.pptx
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4.pptxCatch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4.pptx
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4.pptx
 
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4 [Autosaved].pptx
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4 [Autosaved].pptxCatch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4 [Autosaved].pptx
Catch up Friday PE socialjustice-week 4 [Autosaved].pptx
 
Write Research Proposal Research Proposal, Writin
Write Research Proposal Research Proposal, WritinWrite Research Proposal Research Proposal, Writin
Write Research Proposal Research Proposal, Writin
 
The Aquarius Doctrine A
The Aquarius Doctrine AThe Aquarius Doctrine A
The Aquarius Doctrine A
 
System Traps and Opportunities
System Traps and OpportunitiesSystem Traps and Opportunities
System Traps and Opportunities
 
Ankit ie mim essay_1_version_2
Ankit ie mim essay_1_version_2Ankit ie mim essay_1_version_2
Ankit ie mim essay_1_version_2
 
Uday Shankar "Indian response" - Second GPN Global Webinar "COVID-19. SUPERN...
 Uday Shankar "Indian response" - Second GPN Global Webinar "COVID-19. SUPERN... Uday Shankar "Indian response" - Second GPN Global Webinar "COVID-19. SUPERN...
Uday Shankar "Indian response" - Second GPN Global Webinar "COVID-19. SUPERN...
 
World Vision
World VisionWorld Vision
World Vision
 
Education Please respond to the following· Based on the lectu.docx
Education Please respond to the following· Based on the lectu.docxEducation Please respond to the following· Based on the lectu.docx
Education Please respond to the following· Based on the lectu.docx
 
Students presentation
Students presentationStudents presentation
Students presentation
 
NDCC Memo Circular No. 05 s 2007 (2) Cluster Approach
NDCC Memo Circular No. 05 s 2007 (2) Cluster ApproachNDCC Memo Circular No. 05 s 2007 (2) Cluster Approach
NDCC Memo Circular No. 05 s 2007 (2) Cluster Approach
 
The International NGO Council on Violence Against Children: "creating a non-v...
The International NGO Council on Violence Against Children: "creating a non-v...The International NGO Council on Violence Against Children: "creating a non-v...
The International NGO Council on Violence Against Children: "creating a non-v...
 
2015 Prescription for America Rebrand and Rebuild
2015 Prescription for America  Rebrand and Rebuild2015 Prescription for America  Rebrand and Rebuild
2015 Prescription for America Rebrand and Rebuild
 
Female Genital Mutilation for Healthcare Professionals
Female Genital Mutilation for Healthcare ProfessionalsFemale Genital Mutilation for Healthcare Professionals
Female Genital Mutilation for Healthcare Professionals
 
brown-finkelstein-2011-insuring-long-term-care-in-the-united-states.pdf
brown-finkelstein-2011-insuring-long-term-care-in-the-united-states.pdfbrown-finkelstein-2011-insuring-long-term-care-in-the-united-states.pdf
brown-finkelstein-2011-insuring-long-term-care-in-the-united-states.pdf
 
Topic 1.ppt
Topic 1.pptTopic 1.ppt
Topic 1.ppt
 
Topic 1.ppt
Topic 1.pptTopic 1.ppt
Topic 1.ppt
 
Punishing success ?
Punishing success ?Punishing success ?
Punishing success ?
 
Florida retirement system project
Florida retirement system projectFlorida retirement system project
Florida retirement system project
 

Mais de Eric Robertson

Club for Online Business Introduction
Club for Online Business IntroductionClub for Online Business Introduction
Club for Online Business IntroductionEric Robertson
 
Kritik english as debate language
Kritik english as debate languageKritik english as debate language
Kritik english as debate languageEric Robertson
 
Opp strategies overview
Opp strategies overviewOpp strategies overview
Opp strategies overviewEric Robertson
 
Govt case construction comparative advantages
Govt case construction  comparative advantagesGovt case construction  comparative advantages
Govt case construction comparative advantagesEric Robertson
 
Govt case const policy stock issues
Govt case const policy stock issuesGovt case const policy stock issues
Govt case const policy stock issuesEric Robertson
 
Govt case construction fact
Govt case construction factGovt case construction fact
Govt case construction factEric Robertson
 
Creating a govt case overview
Creating a govt case overviewCreating a govt case overview
Creating a govt case overviewEric Robertson
 
Criterion claims of fact
Criterion claims of factCriterion claims of fact
Criterion claims of factEric Robertson
 
Policy case formats comparative advantages version 2
Policy case formats  comparative advantages version 2Policy case formats  comparative advantages version 2
Policy case formats comparative advantages version 2Eric Robertson
 
Policy case format- comparative advantages
Policy case format-  comparative advantagesPolicy case format-  comparative advantages
Policy case format- comparative advantagesEric Robertson
 

Mais de Eric Robertson (20)

Club for Online Business Introduction
Club for Online Business IntroductionClub for Online Business Introduction
Club for Online Business Introduction
 
Kritik english as debate language
Kritik english as debate languageKritik english as debate language
Kritik english as debate language
 
Opportunity cost t
Opportunity cost tOpportunity cost t
Opportunity cost t
 
Trichotomy of debate
Trichotomy of debateTrichotomy of debate
Trichotomy of debate
 
Topicality drills
Topicality drillsTopicality drills
Topicality drills
 
Solvency gap
Solvency gapSolvency gap
Solvency gap
 
Random drills
Random drillsRandom drills
Random drills
 
Pre fiat impacts
Pre fiat impactsPre fiat impacts
Pre fiat impacts
 
Topicality overview
Topicality overviewTopicality overview
Topicality overview
 
Opp strategies overview
Opp strategies overviewOpp strategies overview
Opp strategies overview
 
Policy case overview
Policy case overview  Policy case overview
Policy case overview
 
Govt case construction comparative advantages
Govt case construction  comparative advantagesGovt case construction  comparative advantages
Govt case construction comparative advantages
 
Govt case const policy stock issues
Govt case const policy stock issuesGovt case const policy stock issues
Govt case const policy stock issues
 
Govt case construction fact
Govt case construction factGovt case construction fact
Govt case construction fact
 
Creating a govt case overview
Creating a govt case overviewCreating a govt case overview
Creating a govt case overview
 
Criterion policy
Criterion policyCriterion policy
Criterion policy
 
Criterion value case
Criterion value caseCriterion value case
Criterion value case
 
Criterion claims of fact
Criterion claims of factCriterion claims of fact
Criterion claims of fact
 
Policy case formats comparative advantages version 2
Policy case formats  comparative advantages version 2Policy case formats  comparative advantages version 2
Policy case formats comparative advantages version 2
 
Policy case format- comparative advantages
Policy case format-  comparative advantagesPolicy case format-  comparative advantages
Policy case format- comparative advantages
 

Solvency press and fiat abuse

  • 2. Solvency Press Step 1: Illustrate that their plan does not solve This can be done through reasoning or examples. If there is too big of an inferential leap between the action of the plan and the results, you can exploit that vulnerability. Step 2: Revisit the harms (or whatever problems are being solved), and discuss how each one gets worse. This is the impact to your solvency press and how you are able to garner offense for the Opp.
  • 3. Practice 1) The USFG should implement a national single-payer healthcare system2) The EPA should mandate higher fuel efficiency standards for US motor vehicles3) The United Nations should deploy a peacekeeping force under unified command to decrease piracy off Somalia.4) The United Nations should sanction Israel5) The International Monetary Fund should stop collecting all arrears6) The USFG should substantially reduce the power of the Federal Reserve Bank7) The United Nations should remove veto power from the five permanent members of the security council.8) The United Nation should give one or more of the following nations permanent security council membership: Brazil, Japan, Argentina, Spain, and Israel.
  • 4. Fiat Abuse Formatted Like topicality: Interpretations: We believe that fiat should be… Violation: They abused fiat by… Standards: Ground, etc. Voter: Fairness, etc.
  • 5. Types of Fiat Abuse Multi-Step Multi-Actor Mindset What else?
  • 6. Practice Topic: This house should legalize it. PLAN: The USFG will legalize all drugs and start rehab programs to help those who are addicted.
  • 7. Practice Topic: This house should change the current health care system. PLAN: Iraq and North Korea will work together to make a joint health care bill for their people to share resources.
  • 8. Practice Topic: This house should significantly decrease recidivism. PLAN: The USFG will make it so that criminals no longer want to commit crimes, therefore lowering recidivism.