SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 6
Download to read offline
Epidemiologic Reviews                                                                                                              Vol. 27, 2005
Copyright ª 2005 by the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health                                                         Printed in U.S.A.
All rights reserved                                                                                                   DOI: 10.1093/epirev/mxi007




Disasters: Introduction and State of the Art




Eric K. Noji

From the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Washington, DC.

Received for publication January 23, 2005; accepted for publication March 18, 2005.




   Fifteen years have passed since the last update on this                       Epidemiology, as the applied instrument of public health
topic was published in Epidemiologic Reviews (1) and 24                       interventions, can provide much needed information on
years since the first (2). In the intervening years, disaster                  which a rational, effective, and flexible policy for the
prevention, mitigation, and preparedness have evolved in                      management of disasters can be based. In particular,
important ways (3). Clearly, it was time to update the last                   epidemiology provides the tools for rapid and effective
review. Fifteen years ago, disaster management was simply                     problem solving during public health emergencies, such as
left to a few dedicated professionals. Roles were clear:                      natural and technologic disasters and emergencies from
Rescue workers rushed to help victims, and certain agencies                   terrorism.
stepped in to provide temporary shelter and food. Usually                        After sudden-impact disasters, time constraints and dis-
within weeks after the disaster’s impact, most people forgot                  ruption of an area’s infrastructure have frequently made it
about the disaster—until the next one came to wreak new                       necessary to conduct rapid assessment surveys using non-
destruction. Unfortunately, disasters throughout the world,                   probability sampling methods. These methods may produce
such as the series of four destructive hurricanes that struck                 biased results because they are often based on purposive,
the southeast coast of the United States from August to                       convenience, or haphazard selection of subjects for interview
September of 2004 (4) and the tsunami disaster in December                    (6). In the last 15 years, investigators demonstrated the use of
2004, have provided ample opportunities to test the policies                  a modified cluster-sampling method to perform a rapid needs
and recommendations set out in the late 1980s. At least 80                    assessment after hurricanes (7, 8). In the first survey con-
percent of the population growth in the 1990s has occurred                    ducted 3 days after Hurricane Andrew struck south Florida in
in towns and cities. According to the United Nations, in the                  August 1992, clusters were systematically selected from
year 2005, one half of the world’s population will live in                    a heavily damaged area by using a grid that had been overlaid
urban areas, crowded onto just 3 percent of the earth’s land.                 on aerial photographs. Survey teams interviewed seven
This is an alarming increase in population density. Problems                  occupied households in consecutive order in each selected
inherent in such rapid growth are especially unwieldy in                      cluster. Results were available within 24 hours of beginning
developing countries; 17 of the 20 largest cities are now in                  the survey. Surveys of the same heavily damaged area and of
developing countries compared with seven of 20 in 1950. By                    a less severely affected area were conducted 7 and 10 days
2025, 80 percent of the world’s population will reside in                     later, respectively.
developing countries. One of every two large cities in the                       Initial survey workers found few households with injured
developing world is vulnerable to natural disasters such as                   residents, but a large proportion of households were without
floods, severe storms, and earthquakes (3).                                    telephones or electricity. The workers’ findings convinced
   Fortunately, over the past decade, the public health                       disaster relief workers to focus on providing primary care
approach to disasters has changed significantly. Today, the                    and preventive services to residents rather than to divert
management of humanitarian assistance involves many                           resources in order to establish unnecessary mass-casualty
more and different players, and disaster management is                        trauma services. The cluster-survey method used in this
recognized as a significant priority of the public health                      rapid assessment was modified from methods developed by
system. Today, prevention, mitigation, and preparedness are                   the World Health Organization’s Expanded Programme on
part of the vocabulary of public health officials in national                  Immunization to assess vaccine coverage. Although cluster
and international organizations and, more importantly, they                   surveys have been used in refugee settings to assess nutri-
are used to advance the cause of reducing mortality and                       tional and health status, this activity represented the first
morbidity from disasters (5).                                                 use of the Expanded Programme on Immunization survey

 Correspondence to Dr. Eric K. Noji, CDC Washington Office, 200 Independence Avenue, SW, Room 719-B, Washington, DC 20201 (e-mail:
 exn1@cdc.gov).


                                                                          3                                    Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8
4 Noji


method to obtain population-based data after a sudden-            ambulances are not immediately available in sufficient
impact natural disaster.                                          numbers, the survivors will use whatever means of transport
   Although cluster-survey techniques hold promise for            that is expedient to accomplish that objective (e.g., private
providing information rapidly after a disaster, in certain        car, bus, taxi, or even on foot). During the September 11,
settings these techniques may be less applicable. For ex-         2001, World Trade Center attack, for example, only 6.7
ample, epidemiologists who used a cluster-survey technique        percent of the casualties were transported by ambulance.
after the January 1994 earthquake in Northridge, California,         As a result, in most disasters the closest hospitals receive
found that the technique needed modification. Unlike the           most of the casualties, while those slightly farther away wait
damage from hurricanes, which is generally uniform over           for casualties that never arrive. Furthermore, field triage,
a large geographic area and thus can support the use of cluster   first aid, and decontamination stations are often bypassed
sampling, earthquake-related damage varies considerably,          because those transporting victims are unaware of their
with some areas experiencing little destruction and others        existence or location, or because they believe that better care
experiencing heavy destruction. The extent of damage              is available at hospitals. This all happens very quickly, with
after earthquakes depends on local soil conditions, the           hospitals usually receiving no warning that a disaster has
distance and rate of ground-shaking attenuation from the          even occurred and, most importantly, that they will be
epicenter, and the quality of building construction. There-       inundated with casualties beginning to arrive within a few
fore, using a cluster-sampling approach to assess damages         minutes.
after an earthquake may cause health authorities to miss             Officials who are unaware of this evidence may in-
seriously affected areas and, thus, to underestimate overall      advertently create dysfunctional plans. For example, they
damages (9).                                                      may designate one hospital to receive casualties contami-
   Results of epidemiologic studies of disasters have not         nated by hazardous substances. They may assume that the
only led to the scientific measurement and description of          fire department will decontaminate casualties at the scene,
disaster-associated health effects but also been used to          or that hospital staff will have advanced notice so they can
identify groups in the population at particular risk for          don chemical protective suits and set up decontamination
adverse health events, to help emergency managers match           equipment before patients arrive.
resources to needs, to monitor the effectiveness of relief           Evidence collected by epidemiologists is also useful for
efforts, to improve contingency planning, and to formulate        planning. For example, the primary focus for disaster
recommendations for decreasing the adverse public health          medical planning has traditionally been on hospital treat-
consequences of future disasters (3). Unfortunately, it is        ment of the critically injured. However, evidence from
assumed by many that all disaster research has been and will      epidemiologic studies indicates that most disaster injuries
be based upon ‘‘scientific evidence.’’ Evidence consists of        are relatively minor and could easily be treated in urgent
data upon which a judgment or conclusion may be based.            care centers, private physicians’ offices, outpatient surgery
Evidence must be ‘‘valid.’’ Evidence-based disaster medi-         centers, and clinics—sparing hospitals for the more serious
cine, therefore, supposedly is based upon facts. For              cases. Additional evidence suggests that many postdisaster
example, disaster planning is only as good as the assump-         visits to hospital emergency departments are for medical
tions on which it is based. However, these assumptions are        conditions other than injuries (10). In some cases, these
often based on conventional wisdom and stereotypes rather         patients are elderly people who have lost access to their
than on systematically collected evidence. While these            routine sources of medical care (e.g., pharmacies, private
assumptions may be logical, what is logical is not always         doctors, home health care). Yet, there seems to be little
what is true (10). For example, it is often assumed that          planning to ensure that these sources of medical care can
disasters trigger widespread panic and leave stricken             survive, function, or expand capacity in disasters (4).
populations helpless and dependent on government author-             Evaluation of the medical and public health responses to
ities and rescue and relief organizations for strong leader-      disasters is one of the principal responsibilities of epidemi-
ship and assistance. Disaster planning often focuses on what      ologists with an eye toward progressive improvement in the
these agencies can do for the public with the view that the       ability of the health system to respond more effectively and
public can do little for itself.                                  efficiently to disasters (2). Such responses must be evaluated
   Planners may be unaware that there exists a large body of      from the perspective of their outcomes and to what extent
evidence on disaster responses that has been collected            these interventions benefited victims of the disaster, espe-
over several decades by rapid-response field teams from            cially relative to the goals that were expected by such planned
scientific institutions specializing in disaster research. This    responses. Epidemiologists have used a great variety of data
evidence shows that panic is extremely rare in disasters and      collection methods and strategies to study the postdisaster
that members of the public in the impact area will take the       health effects of major disasters involving acute events, such
initiative to help themselves and others.                         as earthquakes and tropical cyclones. Primarily using de-
   Most postearthquake or post-building collapse search and       scriptive epidemiology, they have collected large amounts of
rescue, for example, is carried out not by police, firefighters,    epidemiologic data through case studies of new and previous
and formally trained rescue teams but rather by the survivors     disasters.
themselves (family members, neighbors, coworkers,                    However, interventions also may be evaluated with regard
friends, and those who just happen to be in the area) (11).       to prevention or mitigation of the effect of an event. Such
To the lay public, the best emergency care is seen as             evaluations often are difficult, as their success is assessed by
transport as quickly as possible to the closest hospital. If      the fact that nothing happened that could have happened.

                                                                                                   Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8
Disasters: Introduction and State of the Art 5


Identification of risk factors for death or injury will require    significantly worsened, especially during the years since the
a more sophisticated, analytical approach. Such analytical        end of the Cold War. Third, on a more positive note, there
studies have usually been of a case-control design. For           has been a steady increase in technical publications in the
example, why did some people die while their neighbors,           form of journal articles, books, and manuals documenting
family members, or others survived? Isolated case studies of      public health outcomes and proposing more effective
the relation between death or injuries and the type of            responses to conflict-associated population emergencies.
traditional housing structures have provided clear indica-        The term complex humanitarian disaster reflects the multi-
tions regarding simple measures to be implemented in order        causal nature and complicated response mechanisms of
to reduce human losses. Such analyses following disasters         recent emergencies. In terms of their public health impact,
have yielded new information that has altered traditional         complex humanitarian disasters may be defined as ‘‘rela-
thinking about the prevention of disaster-related mortality.      tively acute situations affecting large populations, caused by
Results of epidemiologic research on disasters have formed        a combination of factors, generally including civil strife or
the scientific basis for increasingly effective prevention and     war, often exacerbated by food shortages and population
intervention strategies to decrease mortality in several          displacement, and resulting in significant excess mortality’’
disaster situations. For example, epidemiologic studies of        (16, p. 1012).
tornadoes have resulted in changes in local housing and              The public health impact of complex disasters in the
land-use regulations regarding the danger of mobile homes         1990s has been extensively documented. The Lancet and
and have formed the basis of National Weather Service             JAMA have both published reports on emergencies in
safety guidelines issued to citizens in tornado-prone parts of    northern Iraq, Somalia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Nepal,
the country (12). Results of epidemiologic investigations of      and Zaire. One useful article that appeared following the
a wide spectrum of adverse medical and health consequen-          Somali emergency documented the different approaches to
ces of disasters have allowed us to target specific inter-         the collection of public health information among various
ventions to prevent specific disaster-related health effects       agencies (17). Several years later, however, when 1 million
(e.g., improved warning and evacuation before flash floods          Rwandan refugees fled into the eastern Zaire province of
and tropical cyclones (13), the identification of effective        North Kivu, there was a remarkable degree of cooperation
safety actions that building occupants should take during         and standardization of information-gathering methods
earthquakes (14), and the development of measures to avoid        among the agencies present. This was reflected in a land-
clean-up injuries following hurricanes (15)), to measure the      mark article jointly authored by 24 epidemiologists from the
effectiveness of disaster prevention and preparedness             Zaire Ministry of Health, World Health Organization,
programs, and to help local communities develop better            United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, US
emergency preparedness and mitigation programs. More                                                               ´
                                                                  Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Medecins Sans
analytical studies such as these are needed to test conven-              `
                                                                  Frontieres (Doctors without Borders), the French Army, and
tional warnings and public safety advisories (5).                 the Red Cross (18).
   Despite the existence of useful, systematically collected         Major advances have been made during the past decade in
evidence from hundreds of disasters, this body of knowledge       the way the international community responds to the health
can quickly become out-of-date (1, 2). This is because of         and nutrition consequences of complex emergencies. The
changes in disaster threats (e.g., pandemic influenza, suicide     public health and clinical response to diseases of acute
terrorism, specific targeting of medical personnel in war          epidemic potential has improved, especially in camps. Case-
zones) and in the health-care system (advances in emer-           fatality rates for severely malnourished children have
gency medical service systems, emergency department               plummeted because of better protocols and products.
overcrowding, nursing shortages, closures of trauma cen-          Renewed focus is required on the major causes of death in
ters). In addition, there still exist critical data gaps in how   conflict-affected societies—particularly, acute respiratory
the health-care system deals with disasters. An example is        infections, diarrhea, malaria, measles, neonatal causes, and
the lack of systematically collected data on the medical and      malnutrition—outside camps and often across regions and
public health response to releases of hazardous chemicals.        even political boundaries. In emergencies in sub-Saharan
Furthermore, we lack an effective, nationally institutional-      Africa, particularly, southern Africa, human immunodefi-
ized process of knowledge transfer for gathering and              ciency virus/acquired immunodeficiency syndrome is also
disseminating lessons learned from health and medical             an important cause of morbidity and mortality. Stronger
responses to disasters from researchers to first responders.       coordination, increased accountability, and a more strategic
   Fifteen years ago, the term ‘‘complex humanitarian             positioning of nongovernmental organizations and United
disasters’’ was not commonly used. The focus of attention         Nations agencies are crucial to achieving lower maternal
was usually the plight of refugees fleeing conflicts related to     and child morbidity and mortality rates in complex emer-
the tensions between the two superpowers, the Soviet Union        gencies (19, 20).
and the United States. Much has changed in the intervening           While our understanding of the public health problems of
years. First, the geopolitical context has altered dramati-       refugees and displaced persons steadily improved, the
cally, with an initial increase in the intensity and scope of     causes of and response mechanisms to man-made emergen-
Cold War-related conflicts in the 1980s followed by the            cies became significantly more complicated. Whereas the
collapse of the Soviet Union and the subsequent ‘‘epi-            focus of assistance programs in the 1970s and early 1980s
demic’’ of ethnic and religious conflicts. Second, the public      was on refugees who had crossed borders to escape armed
health impact of armed conflicts on civilian populations has       conflicts, in the 1990s it was often necessary to provide

Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8
6 Noji


assistance to civilians still in the proximity of the conflict or   threatening environment of armed conflict in a global
displaced within their own countries. Civil wars in the            climate of political indecisiveness and moral inconsistency.
Darfur region of western Sudan, Somalia, Liberia, Sierra           While we await a concrete manifestation of the much-
Leone, Angola, Afghanistan, Chechnya, Sri Lanka, East              heralded new world order, relief agencies and the individ-
Timor, and the former Yugoslavia had profound and tragic           uals who make up their field teams will continue to work on
effects on the health of local civilian populations (21).          the front lines in an ethical limbo’’ (22, p. 134).
Today, complex emergencies are humanitarian crises that               On September 11, 2001, the United States experienced
involve, if not war, then high levels of violence. Increas-        the worst terrorist attack in its history. As the nation sought
ingly, civilians have become the intentional target of             to deal with this tragedy, it would face a second wave of
violence. Hundreds of thousands of civilians have been             terrorism—this time, in the form of a biologic attack. There
trapped in urban enclaves and siege-like situations where          should be no doubt by now that the challenge of terrorism
public utilities have been destroyed and basic medical             has left an indelible mark on the world as we know it,
services have collapsed. Children have been forcibly               spanning all inhabited continents, crossing all cultures, and
conscripted into opposing armed forces and have proved             penetrating the borders of all countries.
to be the most violent and pitiless of combatants. The                Unfortunately, a disaster caused by the intentional release
provision of humanitarian assistance in these settings has         of biologic weapons would be very different from other
proved extremely difficult and dangerous. The symbol of the         natural or technologic disasters, conventional military
Red Cross is no longer a guarantee of neutrality or even           strikes, or even attacks with other weapons of mass destruc-
safety, with dozens of staff from the International Commit-        tion (e.g., nuclear, chemical, or explosive). The initial
tee of the Red Cross murdered. Similar targeting and               responders to a biologic disaster will most likely include
assassination of United Nations and humanitarian relief            county and city health officers, hospital staff, members of
workers have now become an accepted hazard of doing such           the outpatient medical community, and a wide range of
work. We all mourn the death of Sergio Viera de Mello,             personnel in the public health system and not traditional first
United Nations Special Representative to Iraq, on August           responders such as police, fire, rescue, and ambulance
19, 2003.                                                          services. Expanded public health laboratory capacity, in-
   Since Somalia in 1992, military involvement has often           creased surveillance (disease monitoring), early alert,
become essential for the provision of security, intelligence,      warning and outbreak response capacity, and health com-
and logistic support to international relief organizations. In     munication and training are critical for an effective response
fact, without such assistance in Bosnia, Kosovo, Liberia,          to bioterrorism—with the focus of such public health
Sierra Leone, and the recent tsunami disaster in South Asia,       preparedness resources and expertise at the state and local
relief operations would have ground to a halt. As could be         levels.
predicted, the decade of the 1990s brought much confusion             It is likely that recognition of the nature of and
and uncertainty to the traditional humanitarian relief             appropriate response to future bioterrorist attacks and
community (both government and nongovernment) in the               natural epidemics, such as West Nile virus, pandemic
role of the military in complex emergencies. Usually, in           influenza, and the international outbreak of severe acute
these situations, organizations such as the United Nations         respiratory syndrome (SARS), also will unfold over time.
(e.g., World Health Organization, United Nations Children’s        This is a difficult lesson in an age of 24-hour media coverage
Fund, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees),              and expectations of instant answers. It is critical that public
nongovernmental organizations, the International Commit-           health authorities familiarize the communities they serve
tee of the Red Cross, and the International Federation of Red      and the media with the likelihood that reliable answers to
Cross have retained overall coordination, if not leadership        questions arising in future attacks will take time to assemble
and control. Until recently, this alone was felt to be essential   and validate (23). Furthermore, the public must understand
for maintaining the neutrality (and thus safety) of relief         that messages (including medical advice, recommendations
workers. However, since the Balkan wars, Western militar-          about who is at risk, and treatment) conveyed at one given
ies (particularly those of the United States) have sub-            point in time, although based on the best available in-
stantially increased their activities in humanitarian              formation, are subject to change when new facts become
projects, such as providing field clinical hospitals, water,        known.
sanitation, communicable disease control, food programs,              The myth that things go back to normal within a few
and community health. Despite the humanitarian motives             weeks is especially pernicious. The truth is that the effects
for such military operations, many relief organizations            of a disaster last a long time (24). Disaster-affected
believe that this engagement contributes to the danger to          countries deplete many of their financial and material
their field staff by blurring the lines between civilian and        resources in the immediate postimpact phase. The bulk of
military function and falsely associates them with the             the need for external assistance is in the restoration of
military forces. This became a major issue in the planning,        normal primary health-care services, water systems, hous-
execution, and recovery of the health infrastructure in Iraq       ing, and income-producing work. The longer-term recovery
following the end of major hostilities in Operation Iraqi          and rehabilitation needs in the affected areas are more
Freedom. One author of World in Crisis concluded his               poorly understood than the short-term needs, but they may
chapter on the role of medical relief agencies as follows:         be even more important. Many of the large relief agencies
‘‘many issues remain unresolved and hotly debated . . .            have substantial capacity for both relief and development,
foremost is the challenge of working in the hostile and            but effecting a transition from relief activities to sustainable

                                                                                                    Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8
Disasters: Introduction and State of the Art 7


and meaningful reconstruction activities is neither a simple        opportunities in the public health consequences of disasters
nor a straightforward task. Relief organizations still have         (up from just 10 percent 8 years ago).
much to learn about shifting from short-term medical-aid               This issue of Epidemiologic Reviews consists of several
efforts to productive, sustainable interventions that promote       updates and reviews that will provide readers with sub-
the development of a local health-care system (25).                 stantial technical descriptions of recent disasters and
   In particular, social and mental health problems will            humanitarian crises (3–5, 10, 11, 21, 23, 24, 26). The
appear when the acute crisis has subsided and the victims           articles published in this issue of Epidemiologic Reviews
feel (and often are) abandoned to their own means (10).             were selected on the basis of their demonstration of
Unfortunately, mental health and the psychological conse-           advances in the conduct of disaster relief and humanitarian
quences of disasters have not yet received the attention they       assistance and the methodology of disaster research since
deserve in the epidemiologic literature (especially compared        the last major review of this topic.
with the extensive research and body of knowledge in the               A common theme that runs through every single one of
social and behavioral sciences). Research of populations            these articles is that, although all disasters are unique, some
affected by disasters (whether due to civil conflict or volcanic     similarities exist among the health effects of different
eruptions) has revealed that these populations may have             disasters, which, if recognized, can ensure that health and
to cope with widespread depression, anxiety, and post-              emergency medical relief and limited resources are well
traumatic stress for years after the disaster (24). Successful      managed.
relief programs incorporate long-term mental health-care
services in their overall planning for disaster relief, recovery,
and reconstruction.
   The physical health of survivors may also be adversely           REFERENCES
affected for years, particularly in technologic disasters, such
as those involving chemicals and radiation. For example, the         1. Lechat MF. Updates: the epidemiology of health effects of
most pressing health concerns associated with nuclear-                  disasters. Epidemiol Rev 1990;12:192–7.
reactor incidents are the delayed effects from long-term             2. Logue JN, Melick ME, Hansen H. Research issues and di-
                                                                        rections in the epidemiology of health effects of disasters.
exposure to low levels of radiation (26). Cancer or genetic
                                                                        Epidemiol Rev 1981;3:140–62.
defects induced by radiation exposure may not appear until
                                                                     3. Ahern M, Kovats RS, Wilkinson P, et al. Global health impacts
many years after exposure and may be induced by low levels
                                                                        of floods: epidemiologic evidence. Epidemiol Rev 2005;
of exposure (26).                                                       27:36–46.
   Epidemiologic study of disasters has clearly increased            4. Shultz JM, Russell J, Espinel Z. Epidemiology of tropical
during the past 15 years, especially in university and aca-             cyclones: the dynamics of disaster, disease, and development.
demic communities, and it has undergone an explosive                    Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:21–35.
acceleration since September 11, 2001. Dozens of new                 5. Ebi KL, Schmier JK. A stitch in time: improving public health
professional societies and scientific forums for the presenta-           early warning systems for extreme weather events. Epidemiol
tion of original work in the epidemiology of disasters                  Rev 2005;27:115–21.
appeared. Dozens of university research centers now con-             6. World Health Organization. Rapid health assessment protocols
centrate on the health and medical effects of disasters,                for emergencies. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organi-
including collaborating centers under the sponsorship of the            zation, 1999.
World Health Organization. Some of these institutions have           7. Hlady WG, Quenemoen LE, Armenia-Cope RR, et al. Use of
also developed curricula that include basic disaster epide-             a modified cluster sampling method to perform rapid needs
miology, information systems for disasters and communi-                 assessment after Hurricane Andrew. Ann Emerg Med 1994;
cable diseases, immunization, emergency food programs,                  23:719–25.
and reproductive health.                                             8. Malilay J, Flanders WD, Brogan D. A modified cluster-
   A refugee crisis in western Sudan (Darfur) (21), a cata-             sampling method for post-disaster rapid assessment of needs.
strophic tsunami in the Indian Ocean (4), investigations of             Bull World Health Organ 1995;74:399–405.
deliberate biologic and chemical weapons releases, and               9. Noji EK. Progress in disaster management. Lancet 1994;343:
earthquakes in California (11) may not have much in                     1239–40.
                                                                    10. van den Berg B, Grievink L, Yzermans J, et al. Medically
common, but in the investigation of all four, the epidemio-
                                                                        unexplained physical symptoms in the aftermath of disasters.
logic approach has proved powerful. As relief agencies
                                                                        Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:92–106.
have come to accept the role of epidemiology in disaster            11. Ramirez M, Peek-Asa C. Epidemiology of traumatic injuries
responses, their reliance on the ad hoc crisis management               from earthquakes. Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:47–55.
approach has lessened. An organized approach to data col-           12. Liu S, Quenemoen LE, Malilay J, et al. Assessment of a severe
lection in disaster situations also helps disaster managers             weather warning system and disaster preparedness, Calhoun
make crucial decisions and predict the variety of options that          County, Alabama, 1994. Am J Public Health 1996;86:87–9.
they will face during the different phases of a disaster (3).       13. Staes C, Orengo JC, Malilay J, et al. Deaths due to flash floods
   In summary, with both disasters and the number of people             in Puerto Rico, January 1992: implications for prevention. Int J
affected by such events on the increase, the importance of              Epidemiol 1994;23:968–75.
disasters as a public health problem is now widely recog-           14. Armenian HK, Noji EK, Oganessian AP. Case control study of
nized. This is now reflected by the fact that every school of            injuries due to the earthquake in Soviet Armenia. Bull World
public health in the United States now offers some training             Health Organ 1992;70:251–7.

Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8
8 Noji


15. Noji EK. Analysis of medical needs during disasters caused by    21. Guha-Sapir D, van Panhuis WG, Degomme O, et al. Civil
    tropical cyclones: anticipated injury patterns. J Trop Med Hyg       conflicts in four African countries: a five-year review of
    1993;96:370–6.                                                       trends in nutrition and mortality. Epidemiol Rev 2005;
16. Burkholder BT, Toole MJ. Evolution of complex disasters.             27:67–77.
    Lancet 1995;346:1012–15.                                                ´                   `
                                                                     22. Medecins Sans Frontieres. World in crisis: the politics of
17. Boss L, Toole MJ, Yip R. Assessments of mortality, morbidity,        survival at the end of the 20th century. New York, NY:
    and nutritional status in Somalia during the 1991–1992               Routledge, 1997.
    famine: recommendations for standardization of methods.          23. Vasterman P, Yzermans CJ, Dirkzwager AJE. The role of
    JAMA 1994;272:371–6.                                                 the media and media hypes in the aftermath of disasters.
18. Public health impact of Rwandan refugee crisis: what hap-            Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:107–14.
    pened in Goma, Zaire, in July 1994? Goma Epidemiology            24. Galea S, Nandi A, Vlahov D. The epidemiology of post-
    Group. Lancet 1995;345:339–44.                                       traumatic stress disorder after disasters. Epidemiol Rev 2005;
19. Noji EK, Toole MJ. The historical development of                     27:78–91.
    public health responses to disaster. Disasters 1997;21:          25. VanRooyen M, Leaning J. After the Tsunami—facing the
    366–76.                                                              public health challenges. N Engl J Med 2005;352:435–8.
20. Salama P, Spiegel P, Talley L, et al. Lessons learned from       26. Hatch M, Ron E, Bouville A, et al. The Chernobyl disaster:
    complex emergencies over past decade. Lancet 2004;364:               cancer following the accident at the Chornobyl nuclear power
    1801–13.                                                             plant. Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:56–66.




                                                                                                       Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8

More Related Content

What's hot

Managing Health Related Problems in Disasters Effectively: Use of ICT from Pr...
Managing Health Related Problems in Disasters Effectively: Use of ICT from Pr...Managing Health Related Problems in Disasters Effectively: Use of ICT from Pr...
Managing Health Related Problems in Disasters Effectively: Use of ICT from Pr...Apollo Hospitals Group and ATNF
 
Disasters and Their Awareness in J&K
Disasters and Their Awareness in J&KDisasters and Their Awareness in J&K
Disasters and Their Awareness in J&KIRJAES Editor
 
Disaster Health Information Sources for Canadians
Disaster Health Information Sources for CanadiansDisaster Health Information Sources for Canadians
Disaster Health Information Sources for CanadiansRobin Featherstone
 
Nepal's readiness and response to pandemic covid 19
Nepal's readiness and response to pandemic covid 19Nepal's readiness and response to pandemic covid 19
Nepal's readiness and response to pandemic covid 19Ndrc Nepal
 
15 fa transportation-system_ws2015
15 fa transportation-system_ws201515 fa transportation-system_ws2015
15 fa transportation-system_ws2015Luca Marescotti
 
Venttriage2011
Venttriage2011Venttriage2011
Venttriage2011John Wible
 
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C England
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C EnglandMapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C England
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C EnglandKurtis Garbutt
 
Environmental Epidemiology
Environmental EpidemiologyEnvironmental Epidemiology
Environmental EpidemiologyNibretiemekonnen
 
Environmental Epidemiology in Small areas
Environmental Epidemiology in Small areasEnvironmental Epidemiology in Small areas
Environmental Epidemiology in Small areasNik Ronaidi
 
International health organizations lecture ppt
International health organizations lecture pptInternational health organizations lecture ppt
International health organizations lecture pptDr.Farhana Yasmin
 

What's hot (20)

Managing Health Related Problems in Disasters Effectively: Use of ICT from Pr...
Managing Health Related Problems in Disasters Effectively: Use of ICT from Pr...Managing Health Related Problems in Disasters Effectively: Use of ICT from Pr...
Managing Health Related Problems in Disasters Effectively: Use of ICT from Pr...
 
Disasters and Their Awareness in J&K
Disasters and Their Awareness in J&KDisasters and Their Awareness in J&K
Disasters and Their Awareness in J&K
 
Disaster Health Information Sources for Canadians
Disaster Health Information Sources for CanadiansDisaster Health Information Sources for Canadians
Disaster Health Information Sources for Canadians
 
Research as a Part of Public Health Emergency Response
Research as a Part of Public Health Emergency ResponseResearch as a Part of Public Health Emergency Response
Research as a Part of Public Health Emergency Response
 
Nepal's readiness and response to pandemic covid 19
Nepal's readiness and response to pandemic covid 19Nepal's readiness and response to pandemic covid 19
Nepal's readiness and response to pandemic covid 19
 
MIMMS
MIMMSMIMMS
MIMMS
 
15 fa transportation-system_ws2015
15 fa transportation-system_ws201515 fa transportation-system_ws2015
15 fa transportation-system_ws2015
 
Venttriage2011
Venttriage2011Venttriage2011
Venttriage2011
 
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C England
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C EnglandMapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C England
Mapping social vulnerability to flood hazard in Norfolk%2C England
 
Risk assessment
Risk assessmentRisk assessment
Risk assessment
 
Bucci_LIU_Thesis
Bucci_LIU_ThesisBucci_LIU_Thesis
Bucci_LIU_Thesis
 
Era cd
Era cdEra cd
Era cd
 
Environmental Epidemiology
Environmental EpidemiologyEnvironmental Epidemiology
Environmental Epidemiology
 
Considerations in the epidemiology of earthquake injuries
Considerations in the epidemiology of earthquake injuriesConsiderations in the epidemiology of earthquake injuries
Considerations in the epidemiology of earthquake injuries
 
Environmental Epidemiology in Small areas
Environmental Epidemiology in Small areasEnvironmental Epidemiology in Small areas
Environmental Epidemiology in Small areas
 
All in one version 1.5
All in one version 1.5All in one version 1.5
All in one version 1.5
 
International health organizations lecture ppt
International health organizations lecture pptInternational health organizations lecture ppt
International health organizations lecture ppt
 
15 Role of epidemiology in public health
15 Role of epidemiology in public health15 Role of epidemiology in public health
15 Role of epidemiology in public health
 
Epidemiologist
EpidemiologistEpidemiologist
Epidemiologist
 
FINAL PAPER drm
FINAL PAPER  drmFINAL PAPER  drm
FINAL PAPER drm
 

Viewers also liked

video de amor
video de amorvideo de amor
video de amorlucesitha
 
M E A N I N G A N D P H A S E S O F B U S I N E S S C Y C L E S
M E A N I N G  A N D  P H A S E S  O F  B U S I N E S S  C Y C L E SM E A N I N G  A N D  P H A S E S  O F  B U S I N E S S  C Y C L E S
M E A N I N G A N D P H A S E S O F B U S I N E S S C Y C L E SSyed Sibtain Shah
 
90 kWp Solar PV Project with Punjab Energy Development Agency
90 kWp Solar PV Project with Punjab Energy Development Agency 90 kWp Solar PV Project with Punjab Energy Development Agency
90 kWp Solar PV Project with Punjab Energy Development Agency Adesh Saxena
 
video de reggae
video de reggaevideo de reggae
video de reggaelucesitha
 
Vision Of The Drowning Man
Vision Of The Drowning ManVision Of The Drowning Man
Vision Of The Drowning Mandeesunshine
 
Tv Sorozatok, Avagy A Média legaddiktívabb ága
Tv Sorozatok, Avagy A Média legaddiktívabb ágaTv Sorozatok, Avagy A Média legaddiktívabb ága
Tv Sorozatok, Avagy A Média legaddiktívabb ágaguest71f58340
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Coordinated Assessments in emergencies - What we know now: Key lessons from f...
Coordinated Assessments in emergencies - What we know now: Key lessons from f...Coordinated Assessments in emergencies - What we know now: Key lessons from f...
Coordinated Assessments in emergencies - What we know now: Key lessons from f...
 
Live&Learn In Globe3.0 Apr2007
Live&Learn In Globe3.0 Apr2007Live&Learn In Globe3.0 Apr2007
Live&Learn In Globe3.0 Apr2007
 
Aristobulo
AristobuloAristobulo
Aristobulo
 
Chef 11概要-osct
Chef 11概要-osctChef 11概要-osct
Chef 11概要-osct
 
wiliams
wiliamswiliams
wiliams
 
video de amor
video de amorvideo de amor
video de amor
 
M E A N I N G A N D P H A S E S O F B U S I N E S S C Y C L E S
M E A N I N G  A N D  P H A S E S  O F  B U S I N E S S  C Y C L E SM E A N I N G  A N D  P H A S E S  O F  B U S I N E S S  C Y C L E S
M E A N I N G A N D P H A S E S O F B U S I N E S S C Y C L E S
 
90 kWp Solar PV Project with Punjab Energy Development Agency
90 kWp Solar PV Project with Punjab Energy Development Agency 90 kWp Solar PV Project with Punjab Energy Development Agency
90 kWp Solar PV Project with Punjab Energy Development Agency
 
THE 2013 HURRICANE SEASON IS ONLY 5 MONTHS AWAY
THE 2013 HURRICANE SEASON IS ONLY 5 MONTHS AWAYTHE 2013 HURRICANE SEASON IS ONLY 5 MONTHS AWAY
THE 2013 HURRICANE SEASON IS ONLY 5 MONTHS AWAY
 
Credit Cards
Credit CardsCredit Cards
Credit Cards
 
Mudslide Disaster In Washington State USA 22 March 22 2014
 Mudslide Disaster In Washington State USA 22 March 22 2014 Mudslide Disaster In Washington State USA 22 March 22 2014
Mudslide Disaster In Washington State USA 22 March 22 2014
 
video de reggae
video de reggaevideo de reggae
video de reggae
 
Lessons From Past Notable Earthquakespart - Sichuan China
Lessons From Past Notable Earthquakespart - Sichuan ChinaLessons From Past Notable Earthquakespart - Sichuan China
Lessons From Past Notable Earthquakespart - Sichuan China
 
Strengthening Research and Action on Gender-based Violence in Africa
Strengthening Research and Action on Gender-based Violence in AfricaStrengthening Research and Action on Gender-based Violence in Africa
Strengthening Research and Action on Gender-based Violence in Africa
 
Adv Or 13902 Chap3 Integer Programming
Adv Or 13902 Chap3 Integer ProgrammingAdv Or 13902 Chap3 Integer Programming
Adv Or 13902 Chap3 Integer Programming
 
Notable severe windstorm events and disasters of 2014
Notable severe windstorm events and disasters of 2014Notable severe windstorm events and disasters of 2014
Notable severe windstorm events and disasters of 2014
 
Vision Of The Drowning Man
Vision Of The Drowning ManVision Of The Drowning Man
Vision Of The Drowning Man
 
Tv Sorozatok, Avagy A Média legaddiktívabb ága
Tv Sorozatok, Avagy A Média legaddiktívabb ágaTv Sorozatok, Avagy A Média legaddiktívabb ága
Tv Sorozatok, Avagy A Média legaddiktívabb ága
 
Silent Volcanic Hazard in Hawaii October 2014
Silent Volcanic Hazard in Hawaii October 2014Silent Volcanic Hazard in Hawaii October 2014
Silent Volcanic Hazard in Hawaii October 2014
 
Presentacion; felicitat
Presentacion; felicitatPresentacion; felicitat
Presentacion; felicitat
 

Similar to Disasters: Introduction and State of the Art

original.ppteefefedfeddfeddedfwqdfqdqdqdqddfqafwq
original.ppteefefedfeddfeddedfwqdfqdqdqdqddfqafwqoriginal.ppteefefedfeddfeddedfwqdfqdqdqdqddfqafwq
original.ppteefefedfeddfeddedfwqdfqdqdqdqddfqafwqSamKuruvilla5
 
Evolving a strategy for emergency response to natural disaster
Evolving a strategy for emergency response to natural disasterEvolving a strategy for emergency response to natural disaster
Evolving a strategy for emergency response to natural disasterNicholas Kman, MD, FACEP
 
Computational Epidemiology tutorial featured at ACM Knowledge Discovery and D...
Computational Epidemiology tutorial featured at ACM Knowledge Discovery and D...Computational Epidemiology tutorial featured at ACM Knowledge Discovery and D...
Computational Epidemiology tutorial featured at ACM Knowledge Discovery and D...Biocomplexity Institute of Virginia Tech
 
disasterriskawarendpreparedness-240216081534-fa96d94b.pdf
disasterriskawarendpreparedness-240216081534-fa96d94b.pdfdisasterriskawarendpreparedness-240216081534-fa96d94b.pdf
disasterriskawarendpreparedness-240216081534-fa96d94b.pdfLataJimma
 
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdf
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdfDisaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdf
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdfLataJimma
 
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdf
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdfDisaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdf
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdfLataJimma
 
Article - Medical Response Capabilities to a Catastrophic Disaster - Journal ...
Article - Medical Response Capabilities to a Catastrophic Disaster - Journal ...Article - Medical Response Capabilities to a Catastrophic Disaster - Journal ...
Article - Medical Response Capabilities to a Catastrophic Disaster - Journal ...Evelyn A. Donahue, MS, BSN, RN
 
Waste Management, Disease Control, ROLES & RESPONSIBILITIES OF GOVERNMENT
Waste Management, Disease Control, ROLES & RESPONSIBILITIES OF GOVERNMENTWaste Management, Disease Control, ROLES & RESPONSIBILITIES OF GOVERNMENT
Waste Management, Disease Control, ROLES & RESPONSIBILITIES OF GOVERNMENTAlpana Ingale
 
1. Basic Epidemiology.ppt
1. Basic Epidemiology.ppt1. Basic Epidemiology.ppt
1. Basic Epidemiology.pptNajmulHassan27
 
Global%20disease
Global%20diseaseGlobal%20disease
Global%20diseasePaul Vidal
 
Public health emergencies DR. MADHUR VERMA PGIMS ROHTAK
Public health emergencies DR. MADHUR VERMA PGIMS ROHTAKPublic health emergencies DR. MADHUR VERMA PGIMS ROHTAK
Public health emergencies DR. MADHUR VERMA PGIMS ROHTAKMADHUR VERMA
 
Disaster management
Disaster managementDisaster management
Disaster managementutpal sharma
 
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShuttSantosConleyha
 
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShuttBenitoSumpter862
 

Similar to Disasters: Introduction and State of the Art (20)

original.ppteefefedfeddfeddedfwqdfqdqdqdqddfqafwq
original.ppteefefedfeddfeddedfwqdfqdqdqdqddfqafwqoriginal.ppteefefedfeddfeddedfwqdfqdqdqdqddfqafwq
original.ppteefefedfeddfeddedfwqdfqdqdqdqddfqafwq
 
Epidemiologic surveillance following disasters
Epidemiologic surveillance following disastersEpidemiologic surveillance following disasters
Epidemiologic surveillance following disasters
 
Disaster Epidemiology - breif overview
Disaster Epidemiology - breif overview Disaster Epidemiology - breif overview
Disaster Epidemiology - breif overview
 
Evolving a strategy for emergency response to natural disaster
Evolving a strategy for emergency response to natural disasterEvolving a strategy for emergency response to natural disaster
Evolving a strategy for emergency response to natural disaster
 
Computational Epidemiology tutorial featured at ACM Knowledge Discovery and D...
Computational Epidemiology tutorial featured at ACM Knowledge Discovery and D...Computational Epidemiology tutorial featured at ACM Knowledge Discovery and D...
Computational Epidemiology tutorial featured at ACM Knowledge Discovery and D...
 
disasterriskawarendpreparedness-240216081534-fa96d94b.pdf
disasterriskawarendpreparedness-240216081534-fa96d94b.pdfdisasterriskawarendpreparedness-240216081534-fa96d94b.pdf
disasterriskawarendpreparedness-240216081534-fa96d94b.pdf
 
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdf
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdfDisaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdf
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdf
 
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdf
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdfDisaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdf
Disaster_Risk_Awareness_and_Preparedness.pdf
 
Article - Medical Response Capabilities to a Catastrophic Disaster - Journal ...
Article - Medical Response Capabilities to a Catastrophic Disaster - Journal ...Article - Medical Response Capabilities to a Catastrophic Disaster - Journal ...
Article - Medical Response Capabilities to a Catastrophic Disaster - Journal ...
 
A case-control study of injuries arising from the earthquake in Armenia, 1988
A case-control study of injuries arising from the earthquake in Armenia, 1988A case-control study of injuries arising from the earthquake in Armenia, 1988
A case-control study of injuries arising from the earthquake in Armenia, 1988
 
Public health in disaster
Public health in disasterPublic health in disaster
Public health in disaster
 
Waste Management, Disease Control, ROLES & RESPONSIBILITIES OF GOVERNMENT
Waste Management, Disease Control, ROLES & RESPONSIBILITIES OF GOVERNMENTWaste Management, Disease Control, ROLES & RESPONSIBILITIES OF GOVERNMENT
Waste Management, Disease Control, ROLES & RESPONSIBILITIES OF GOVERNMENT
 
1. Basic Epidemiology.ppt
1. Basic Epidemiology.ppt1. Basic Epidemiology.ppt
1. Basic Epidemiology.ppt
 
Global%20disease
Global%20diseaseGlobal%20disease
Global%20disease
 
Disaster Nursing
Disaster NursingDisaster Nursing
Disaster Nursing
 
Public health emergencies DR. MADHUR VERMA PGIMS ROHTAK
Public health emergencies DR. MADHUR VERMA PGIMS ROHTAKPublic health emergencies DR. MADHUR VERMA PGIMS ROHTAK
Public health emergencies DR. MADHUR VERMA PGIMS ROHTAK
 
Disaster management
Disaster managementDisaster management
Disaster management
 
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt
 
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt
1114237 - Jones & Bartlett Learning ©T© ALMAGAMIShutt
 
Disaster Management.pdf
Disaster Management.pdfDisaster Management.pdf
Disaster Management.pdf
 

More from Professor Eric K. Noji, M.D., MPH, DTMH(Lon), FRCP(UK)hon

More from Professor Eric K. Noji, M.D., MPH, DTMH(Lon), FRCP(UK)hon (20)

Indoor Air Pollution
Indoor Air PollutionIndoor Air Pollution
Indoor Air Pollution
 
Past present future disaster risk of natural hazards: Key drivers of future d...
Past present future disaster risk of natural hazards: Key drivers of future d...Past present future disaster risk of natural hazards: Key drivers of future d...
Past present future disaster risk of natural hazards: Key drivers of future d...
 
Historical Review of Notable Earthquakes in the Mediterranean Region
Historical Review of Notable Earthquakes in the Mediterranean RegionHistorical Review of Notable Earthquakes in the Mediterranean Region
Historical Review of Notable Earthquakes in the Mediterranean Region
 
October 2015 Earthquake in Afghanistan: Need for improved tools for rapid dam...
October 2015 Earthquake in Afghanistan: Need for improved tools for rapid dam...October 2015 Earthquake in Afghanistan: Need for improved tools for rapid dam...
October 2015 Earthquake in Afghanistan: Need for improved tools for rapid dam...
 
2016 historic floods in louisiana and mississippi
2016 historic floods in louisiana and mississippi2016 historic floods in louisiana and mississippi
2016 historic floods in louisiana and mississippi
 
16 April 2016 magnitude 7.8 earthquake strikes Ecuador
16 April 2016 magnitude 7.8 earthquake strikes Ecuador16 April 2016 magnitude 7.8 earthquake strikes Ecuador
16 April 2016 magnitude 7.8 earthquake strikes Ecuador
 
Japan eq
Japan eqJapan eq
Japan eq
 
Today's Earthquake in Nepal
Today's Earthquake in NepalToday's Earthquake in Nepal
Today's Earthquake in Nepal
 
2015 2030 sendai framework for action on global disaster risk reduction actions
2015 2030 sendai framework for action on global disaster risk reduction actions2015 2030 sendai framework for action on global disaster risk reduction actions
2015 2030 sendai framework for action on global disaster risk reduction actions
 
A time for re energized global disaster risk reduction actions
A time for re energized global disaster risk reduction actionsA time for re energized global disaster risk reduction actions
A time for re energized global disaster risk reduction actions
 
Two Of Mexico's Dangerous Volcanoes Are Threatening To Erupt
Two Of Mexico's Dangerous Volcanoes Are Threatening To EruptTwo Of Mexico's Dangerous Volcanoes Are Threatening To Erupt
Two Of Mexico's Dangerous Volcanoes Are Threatening To Erupt
 
India Case Study. A paradigm shift towards earthquake disaster resilience.
 India Case Study.  A paradigm shift towards earthquake disaster resilience. India Case Study.  A paradigm shift towards earthquake disaster resilience.
India Case Study. A paradigm shift towards earthquake disaster resilience.
 
Towards disaster resilience in Pakistan. A paradigm shift that will improve t...
Towards disaster resilience in Pakistan. A paradigm shift that will improve t...Towards disaster resilience in Pakistan. A paradigm shift that will improve t...
Towards disaster resilience in Pakistan. A paradigm shift that will improve t...
 
Making Our World Disaster Resilient Is Our Legacy
Making Our World Disaster Resilient Is Our LegacyMaking Our World Disaster Resilient Is Our Legacy
Making Our World Disaster Resilient Is Our Legacy
 
Snow Tsunami Temporarily Spares Northeastern USA 25 January 2015
Snow Tsunami Temporarily Spares Northeastern USA 25 January 2015Snow Tsunami Temporarily Spares Northeastern USA 25 January 2015
Snow Tsunami Temporarily Spares Northeastern USA 25 January 2015
 
Towards Pre-Earthquake Planning for Post-Earthquake Recovery 2015-2020
Towards Pre-Earthquake Planning for Post-Earthquake Recovery 2015-2020Towards Pre-Earthquake Planning for Post-Earthquake Recovery 2015-2020
Towards Pre-Earthquake Planning for Post-Earthquake Recovery 2015-2020
 
Towards faster disaster recovery. case study the 2008 midwest usa floods
Towards faster disaster recovery.  case study the 2008 midwest usa floodsTowards faster disaster recovery.  case study the 2008 midwest usa floods
Towards faster disaster recovery. case study the 2008 midwest usa floods
 
5th Anniversary of the Haiti Earthquake: 12 January 2010
5th Anniversary of the Haiti Earthquake: 12 January 20105th Anniversary of the Haiti Earthquake: 12 January 2010
5th Anniversary of the Haiti Earthquake: 12 January 2010
 
20th Anniversary of the Great Kobe Japan Earthquake
20th Anniversary of the Great Kobe Japan Earthquake20th Anniversary of the Great Kobe Japan Earthquake
20th Anniversary of the Great Kobe Japan Earthquake
 
Northridge California Earthquake January 17, 2014
Northridge California Earthquake January 17, 2014Northridge California Earthquake January 17, 2014
Northridge California Earthquake January 17, 2014
 

Disasters: Introduction and State of the Art

  • 1. Epidemiologic Reviews Vol. 27, 2005 Copyright ª 2005 by the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health Printed in U.S.A. All rights reserved DOI: 10.1093/epirev/mxi007 Disasters: Introduction and State of the Art Eric K. Noji From the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Washington, DC. Received for publication January 23, 2005; accepted for publication March 18, 2005. Fifteen years have passed since the last update on this Epidemiology, as the applied instrument of public health topic was published in Epidemiologic Reviews (1) and 24 interventions, can provide much needed information on years since the first (2). In the intervening years, disaster which a rational, effective, and flexible policy for the prevention, mitigation, and preparedness have evolved in management of disasters can be based. In particular, important ways (3). Clearly, it was time to update the last epidemiology provides the tools for rapid and effective review. Fifteen years ago, disaster management was simply problem solving during public health emergencies, such as left to a few dedicated professionals. Roles were clear: natural and technologic disasters and emergencies from Rescue workers rushed to help victims, and certain agencies terrorism. stepped in to provide temporary shelter and food. Usually After sudden-impact disasters, time constraints and dis- within weeks after the disaster’s impact, most people forgot ruption of an area’s infrastructure have frequently made it about the disaster—until the next one came to wreak new necessary to conduct rapid assessment surveys using non- destruction. Unfortunately, disasters throughout the world, probability sampling methods. These methods may produce such as the series of four destructive hurricanes that struck biased results because they are often based on purposive, the southeast coast of the United States from August to convenience, or haphazard selection of subjects for interview September of 2004 (4) and the tsunami disaster in December (6). In the last 15 years, investigators demonstrated the use of 2004, have provided ample opportunities to test the policies a modified cluster-sampling method to perform a rapid needs and recommendations set out in the late 1980s. At least 80 assessment after hurricanes (7, 8). In the first survey con- percent of the population growth in the 1990s has occurred ducted 3 days after Hurricane Andrew struck south Florida in in towns and cities. According to the United Nations, in the August 1992, clusters were systematically selected from year 2005, one half of the world’s population will live in a heavily damaged area by using a grid that had been overlaid urban areas, crowded onto just 3 percent of the earth’s land. on aerial photographs. Survey teams interviewed seven This is an alarming increase in population density. Problems occupied households in consecutive order in each selected inherent in such rapid growth are especially unwieldy in cluster. Results were available within 24 hours of beginning developing countries; 17 of the 20 largest cities are now in the survey. Surveys of the same heavily damaged area and of developing countries compared with seven of 20 in 1950. By a less severely affected area were conducted 7 and 10 days 2025, 80 percent of the world’s population will reside in later, respectively. developing countries. One of every two large cities in the Initial survey workers found few households with injured developing world is vulnerable to natural disasters such as residents, but a large proportion of households were without floods, severe storms, and earthquakes (3). telephones or electricity. The workers’ findings convinced Fortunately, over the past decade, the public health disaster relief workers to focus on providing primary care approach to disasters has changed significantly. Today, the and preventive services to residents rather than to divert management of humanitarian assistance involves many resources in order to establish unnecessary mass-casualty more and different players, and disaster management is trauma services. The cluster-survey method used in this recognized as a significant priority of the public health rapid assessment was modified from methods developed by system. Today, prevention, mitigation, and preparedness are the World Health Organization’s Expanded Programme on part of the vocabulary of public health officials in national Immunization to assess vaccine coverage. Although cluster and international organizations and, more importantly, they surveys have been used in refugee settings to assess nutri- are used to advance the cause of reducing mortality and tional and health status, this activity represented the first morbidity from disasters (5). use of the Expanded Programme on Immunization survey Correspondence to Dr. Eric K. Noji, CDC Washington Office, 200 Independence Avenue, SW, Room 719-B, Washington, DC 20201 (e-mail: exn1@cdc.gov). 3 Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8
  • 2. 4 Noji method to obtain population-based data after a sudden- ambulances are not immediately available in sufficient impact natural disaster. numbers, the survivors will use whatever means of transport Although cluster-survey techniques hold promise for that is expedient to accomplish that objective (e.g., private providing information rapidly after a disaster, in certain car, bus, taxi, or even on foot). During the September 11, settings these techniques may be less applicable. For ex- 2001, World Trade Center attack, for example, only 6.7 ample, epidemiologists who used a cluster-survey technique percent of the casualties were transported by ambulance. after the January 1994 earthquake in Northridge, California, As a result, in most disasters the closest hospitals receive found that the technique needed modification. Unlike the most of the casualties, while those slightly farther away wait damage from hurricanes, which is generally uniform over for casualties that never arrive. Furthermore, field triage, a large geographic area and thus can support the use of cluster first aid, and decontamination stations are often bypassed sampling, earthquake-related damage varies considerably, because those transporting victims are unaware of their with some areas experiencing little destruction and others existence or location, or because they believe that better care experiencing heavy destruction. The extent of damage is available at hospitals. This all happens very quickly, with after earthquakes depends on local soil conditions, the hospitals usually receiving no warning that a disaster has distance and rate of ground-shaking attenuation from the even occurred and, most importantly, that they will be epicenter, and the quality of building construction. There- inundated with casualties beginning to arrive within a few fore, using a cluster-sampling approach to assess damages minutes. after an earthquake may cause health authorities to miss Officials who are unaware of this evidence may in- seriously affected areas and, thus, to underestimate overall advertently create dysfunctional plans. For example, they damages (9). may designate one hospital to receive casualties contami- Results of epidemiologic studies of disasters have not nated by hazardous substances. They may assume that the only led to the scientific measurement and description of fire department will decontaminate casualties at the scene, disaster-associated health effects but also been used to or that hospital staff will have advanced notice so they can identify groups in the population at particular risk for don chemical protective suits and set up decontamination adverse health events, to help emergency managers match equipment before patients arrive. resources to needs, to monitor the effectiveness of relief Evidence collected by epidemiologists is also useful for efforts, to improve contingency planning, and to formulate planning. For example, the primary focus for disaster recommendations for decreasing the adverse public health medical planning has traditionally been on hospital treat- consequences of future disasters (3). Unfortunately, it is ment of the critically injured. However, evidence from assumed by many that all disaster research has been and will epidemiologic studies indicates that most disaster injuries be based upon ‘‘scientific evidence.’’ Evidence consists of are relatively minor and could easily be treated in urgent data upon which a judgment or conclusion may be based. care centers, private physicians’ offices, outpatient surgery Evidence must be ‘‘valid.’’ Evidence-based disaster medi- centers, and clinics—sparing hospitals for the more serious cine, therefore, supposedly is based upon facts. For cases. Additional evidence suggests that many postdisaster example, disaster planning is only as good as the assump- visits to hospital emergency departments are for medical tions on which it is based. However, these assumptions are conditions other than injuries (10). In some cases, these often based on conventional wisdom and stereotypes rather patients are elderly people who have lost access to their than on systematically collected evidence. While these routine sources of medical care (e.g., pharmacies, private assumptions may be logical, what is logical is not always doctors, home health care). Yet, there seems to be little what is true (10). For example, it is often assumed that planning to ensure that these sources of medical care can disasters trigger widespread panic and leave stricken survive, function, or expand capacity in disasters (4). populations helpless and dependent on government author- Evaluation of the medical and public health responses to ities and rescue and relief organizations for strong leader- disasters is one of the principal responsibilities of epidemi- ship and assistance. Disaster planning often focuses on what ologists with an eye toward progressive improvement in the these agencies can do for the public with the view that the ability of the health system to respond more effectively and public can do little for itself. efficiently to disasters (2). Such responses must be evaluated Planners may be unaware that there exists a large body of from the perspective of their outcomes and to what extent evidence on disaster responses that has been collected these interventions benefited victims of the disaster, espe- over several decades by rapid-response field teams from cially relative to the goals that were expected by such planned scientific institutions specializing in disaster research. This responses. Epidemiologists have used a great variety of data evidence shows that panic is extremely rare in disasters and collection methods and strategies to study the postdisaster that members of the public in the impact area will take the health effects of major disasters involving acute events, such initiative to help themselves and others. as earthquakes and tropical cyclones. Primarily using de- Most postearthquake or post-building collapse search and scriptive epidemiology, they have collected large amounts of rescue, for example, is carried out not by police, firefighters, epidemiologic data through case studies of new and previous and formally trained rescue teams but rather by the survivors disasters. themselves (family members, neighbors, coworkers, However, interventions also may be evaluated with regard friends, and those who just happen to be in the area) (11). to prevention or mitigation of the effect of an event. Such To the lay public, the best emergency care is seen as evaluations often are difficult, as their success is assessed by transport as quickly as possible to the closest hospital. If the fact that nothing happened that could have happened. Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8
  • 3. Disasters: Introduction and State of the Art 5 Identification of risk factors for death or injury will require significantly worsened, especially during the years since the a more sophisticated, analytical approach. Such analytical end of the Cold War. Third, on a more positive note, there studies have usually been of a case-control design. For has been a steady increase in technical publications in the example, why did some people die while their neighbors, form of journal articles, books, and manuals documenting family members, or others survived? Isolated case studies of public health outcomes and proposing more effective the relation between death or injuries and the type of responses to conflict-associated population emergencies. traditional housing structures have provided clear indica- The term complex humanitarian disaster reflects the multi- tions regarding simple measures to be implemented in order causal nature and complicated response mechanisms of to reduce human losses. Such analyses following disasters recent emergencies. In terms of their public health impact, have yielded new information that has altered traditional complex humanitarian disasters may be defined as ‘‘rela- thinking about the prevention of disaster-related mortality. tively acute situations affecting large populations, caused by Results of epidemiologic research on disasters have formed a combination of factors, generally including civil strife or the scientific basis for increasingly effective prevention and war, often exacerbated by food shortages and population intervention strategies to decrease mortality in several displacement, and resulting in significant excess mortality’’ disaster situations. For example, epidemiologic studies of (16, p. 1012). tornadoes have resulted in changes in local housing and The public health impact of complex disasters in the land-use regulations regarding the danger of mobile homes 1990s has been extensively documented. The Lancet and and have formed the basis of National Weather Service JAMA have both published reports on emergencies in safety guidelines issued to citizens in tornado-prone parts of northern Iraq, Somalia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Nepal, the country (12). Results of epidemiologic investigations of and Zaire. One useful article that appeared following the a wide spectrum of adverse medical and health consequen- Somali emergency documented the different approaches to ces of disasters have allowed us to target specific inter- the collection of public health information among various ventions to prevent specific disaster-related health effects agencies (17). Several years later, however, when 1 million (e.g., improved warning and evacuation before flash floods Rwandan refugees fled into the eastern Zaire province of and tropical cyclones (13), the identification of effective North Kivu, there was a remarkable degree of cooperation safety actions that building occupants should take during and standardization of information-gathering methods earthquakes (14), and the development of measures to avoid among the agencies present. This was reflected in a land- clean-up injuries following hurricanes (15)), to measure the mark article jointly authored by 24 epidemiologists from the effectiveness of disaster prevention and preparedness Zaire Ministry of Health, World Health Organization, programs, and to help local communities develop better United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, US emergency preparedness and mitigation programs. More ´ Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Medecins Sans analytical studies such as these are needed to test conven- ` Frontieres (Doctors without Borders), the French Army, and tional warnings and public safety advisories (5). the Red Cross (18). Despite the existence of useful, systematically collected Major advances have been made during the past decade in evidence from hundreds of disasters, this body of knowledge the way the international community responds to the health can quickly become out-of-date (1, 2). This is because of and nutrition consequences of complex emergencies. The changes in disaster threats (e.g., pandemic influenza, suicide public health and clinical response to diseases of acute terrorism, specific targeting of medical personnel in war epidemic potential has improved, especially in camps. Case- zones) and in the health-care system (advances in emer- fatality rates for severely malnourished children have gency medical service systems, emergency department plummeted because of better protocols and products. overcrowding, nursing shortages, closures of trauma cen- Renewed focus is required on the major causes of death in ters). In addition, there still exist critical data gaps in how conflict-affected societies—particularly, acute respiratory the health-care system deals with disasters. An example is infections, diarrhea, malaria, measles, neonatal causes, and the lack of systematically collected data on the medical and malnutrition—outside camps and often across regions and public health response to releases of hazardous chemicals. even political boundaries. In emergencies in sub-Saharan Furthermore, we lack an effective, nationally institutional- Africa, particularly, southern Africa, human immunodefi- ized process of knowledge transfer for gathering and ciency virus/acquired immunodeficiency syndrome is also disseminating lessons learned from health and medical an important cause of morbidity and mortality. Stronger responses to disasters from researchers to first responders. coordination, increased accountability, and a more strategic Fifteen years ago, the term ‘‘complex humanitarian positioning of nongovernmental organizations and United disasters’’ was not commonly used. The focus of attention Nations agencies are crucial to achieving lower maternal was usually the plight of refugees fleeing conflicts related to and child morbidity and mortality rates in complex emer- the tensions between the two superpowers, the Soviet Union gencies (19, 20). and the United States. Much has changed in the intervening While our understanding of the public health problems of years. First, the geopolitical context has altered dramati- refugees and displaced persons steadily improved, the cally, with an initial increase in the intensity and scope of causes of and response mechanisms to man-made emergen- Cold War-related conflicts in the 1980s followed by the cies became significantly more complicated. Whereas the collapse of the Soviet Union and the subsequent ‘‘epi- focus of assistance programs in the 1970s and early 1980s demic’’ of ethnic and religious conflicts. Second, the public was on refugees who had crossed borders to escape armed health impact of armed conflicts on civilian populations has conflicts, in the 1990s it was often necessary to provide Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8
  • 4. 6 Noji assistance to civilians still in the proximity of the conflict or threatening environment of armed conflict in a global displaced within their own countries. Civil wars in the climate of political indecisiveness and moral inconsistency. Darfur region of western Sudan, Somalia, Liberia, Sierra While we await a concrete manifestation of the much- Leone, Angola, Afghanistan, Chechnya, Sri Lanka, East heralded new world order, relief agencies and the individ- Timor, and the former Yugoslavia had profound and tragic uals who make up their field teams will continue to work on effects on the health of local civilian populations (21). the front lines in an ethical limbo’’ (22, p. 134). Today, complex emergencies are humanitarian crises that On September 11, 2001, the United States experienced involve, if not war, then high levels of violence. Increas- the worst terrorist attack in its history. As the nation sought ingly, civilians have become the intentional target of to deal with this tragedy, it would face a second wave of violence. Hundreds of thousands of civilians have been terrorism—this time, in the form of a biologic attack. There trapped in urban enclaves and siege-like situations where should be no doubt by now that the challenge of terrorism public utilities have been destroyed and basic medical has left an indelible mark on the world as we know it, services have collapsed. Children have been forcibly spanning all inhabited continents, crossing all cultures, and conscripted into opposing armed forces and have proved penetrating the borders of all countries. to be the most violent and pitiless of combatants. The Unfortunately, a disaster caused by the intentional release provision of humanitarian assistance in these settings has of biologic weapons would be very different from other proved extremely difficult and dangerous. The symbol of the natural or technologic disasters, conventional military Red Cross is no longer a guarantee of neutrality or even strikes, or even attacks with other weapons of mass destruc- safety, with dozens of staff from the International Commit- tion (e.g., nuclear, chemical, or explosive). The initial tee of the Red Cross murdered. Similar targeting and responders to a biologic disaster will most likely include assassination of United Nations and humanitarian relief county and city health officers, hospital staff, members of workers have now become an accepted hazard of doing such the outpatient medical community, and a wide range of work. We all mourn the death of Sergio Viera de Mello, personnel in the public health system and not traditional first United Nations Special Representative to Iraq, on August responders such as police, fire, rescue, and ambulance 19, 2003. services. Expanded public health laboratory capacity, in- Since Somalia in 1992, military involvement has often creased surveillance (disease monitoring), early alert, become essential for the provision of security, intelligence, warning and outbreak response capacity, and health com- and logistic support to international relief organizations. In munication and training are critical for an effective response fact, without such assistance in Bosnia, Kosovo, Liberia, to bioterrorism—with the focus of such public health Sierra Leone, and the recent tsunami disaster in South Asia, preparedness resources and expertise at the state and local relief operations would have ground to a halt. As could be levels. predicted, the decade of the 1990s brought much confusion It is likely that recognition of the nature of and and uncertainty to the traditional humanitarian relief appropriate response to future bioterrorist attacks and community (both government and nongovernment) in the natural epidemics, such as West Nile virus, pandemic role of the military in complex emergencies. Usually, in influenza, and the international outbreak of severe acute these situations, organizations such as the United Nations respiratory syndrome (SARS), also will unfold over time. (e.g., World Health Organization, United Nations Children’s This is a difficult lesson in an age of 24-hour media coverage Fund, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees), and expectations of instant answers. It is critical that public nongovernmental organizations, the International Commit- health authorities familiarize the communities they serve tee of the Red Cross, and the International Federation of Red and the media with the likelihood that reliable answers to Cross have retained overall coordination, if not leadership questions arising in future attacks will take time to assemble and control. Until recently, this alone was felt to be essential and validate (23). Furthermore, the public must understand for maintaining the neutrality (and thus safety) of relief that messages (including medical advice, recommendations workers. However, since the Balkan wars, Western militar- about who is at risk, and treatment) conveyed at one given ies (particularly those of the United States) have sub- point in time, although based on the best available in- stantially increased their activities in humanitarian formation, are subject to change when new facts become projects, such as providing field clinical hospitals, water, known. sanitation, communicable disease control, food programs, The myth that things go back to normal within a few and community health. Despite the humanitarian motives weeks is especially pernicious. The truth is that the effects for such military operations, many relief organizations of a disaster last a long time (24). Disaster-affected believe that this engagement contributes to the danger to countries deplete many of their financial and material their field staff by blurring the lines between civilian and resources in the immediate postimpact phase. The bulk of military function and falsely associates them with the the need for external assistance is in the restoration of military forces. This became a major issue in the planning, normal primary health-care services, water systems, hous- execution, and recovery of the health infrastructure in Iraq ing, and income-producing work. The longer-term recovery following the end of major hostilities in Operation Iraqi and rehabilitation needs in the affected areas are more Freedom. One author of World in Crisis concluded his poorly understood than the short-term needs, but they may chapter on the role of medical relief agencies as follows: be even more important. Many of the large relief agencies ‘‘many issues remain unresolved and hotly debated . . . have substantial capacity for both relief and development, foremost is the challenge of working in the hostile and but effecting a transition from relief activities to sustainable Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8
  • 5. Disasters: Introduction and State of the Art 7 and meaningful reconstruction activities is neither a simple opportunities in the public health consequences of disasters nor a straightforward task. Relief organizations still have (up from just 10 percent 8 years ago). much to learn about shifting from short-term medical-aid This issue of Epidemiologic Reviews consists of several efforts to productive, sustainable interventions that promote updates and reviews that will provide readers with sub- the development of a local health-care system (25). stantial technical descriptions of recent disasters and In particular, social and mental health problems will humanitarian crises (3–5, 10, 11, 21, 23, 24, 26). The appear when the acute crisis has subsided and the victims articles published in this issue of Epidemiologic Reviews feel (and often are) abandoned to their own means (10). were selected on the basis of their demonstration of Unfortunately, mental health and the psychological conse- advances in the conduct of disaster relief and humanitarian quences of disasters have not yet received the attention they assistance and the methodology of disaster research since deserve in the epidemiologic literature (especially compared the last major review of this topic. with the extensive research and body of knowledge in the A common theme that runs through every single one of social and behavioral sciences). Research of populations these articles is that, although all disasters are unique, some affected by disasters (whether due to civil conflict or volcanic similarities exist among the health effects of different eruptions) has revealed that these populations may have disasters, which, if recognized, can ensure that health and to cope with widespread depression, anxiety, and post- emergency medical relief and limited resources are well traumatic stress for years after the disaster (24). Successful managed. relief programs incorporate long-term mental health-care services in their overall planning for disaster relief, recovery, and reconstruction. The physical health of survivors may also be adversely REFERENCES affected for years, particularly in technologic disasters, such as those involving chemicals and radiation. For example, the 1. Lechat MF. Updates: the epidemiology of health effects of most pressing health concerns associated with nuclear- disasters. Epidemiol Rev 1990;12:192–7. reactor incidents are the delayed effects from long-term 2. Logue JN, Melick ME, Hansen H. Research issues and di- rections in the epidemiology of health effects of disasters. exposure to low levels of radiation (26). Cancer or genetic Epidemiol Rev 1981;3:140–62. defects induced by radiation exposure may not appear until 3. Ahern M, Kovats RS, Wilkinson P, et al. Global health impacts many years after exposure and may be induced by low levels of floods: epidemiologic evidence. Epidemiol Rev 2005; of exposure (26). 27:36–46. Epidemiologic study of disasters has clearly increased 4. Shultz JM, Russell J, Espinel Z. Epidemiology of tropical during the past 15 years, especially in university and aca- cyclones: the dynamics of disaster, disease, and development. demic communities, and it has undergone an explosive Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:21–35. acceleration since September 11, 2001. Dozens of new 5. Ebi KL, Schmier JK. A stitch in time: improving public health professional societies and scientific forums for the presenta- early warning systems for extreme weather events. Epidemiol tion of original work in the epidemiology of disasters Rev 2005;27:115–21. appeared. Dozens of university research centers now con- 6. World Health Organization. Rapid health assessment protocols centrate on the health and medical effects of disasters, for emergencies. Geneva, Switzerland: World Health Organi- including collaborating centers under the sponsorship of the zation, 1999. World Health Organization. Some of these institutions have 7. Hlady WG, Quenemoen LE, Armenia-Cope RR, et al. Use of also developed curricula that include basic disaster epide- a modified cluster sampling method to perform rapid needs miology, information systems for disasters and communi- assessment after Hurricane Andrew. Ann Emerg Med 1994; cable diseases, immunization, emergency food programs, 23:719–25. and reproductive health. 8. Malilay J, Flanders WD, Brogan D. A modified cluster- A refugee crisis in western Sudan (Darfur) (21), a cata- sampling method for post-disaster rapid assessment of needs. strophic tsunami in the Indian Ocean (4), investigations of Bull World Health Organ 1995;74:399–405. deliberate biologic and chemical weapons releases, and 9. Noji EK. Progress in disaster management. Lancet 1994;343: earthquakes in California (11) may not have much in 1239–40. 10. van den Berg B, Grievink L, Yzermans J, et al. Medically common, but in the investigation of all four, the epidemio- unexplained physical symptoms in the aftermath of disasters. logic approach has proved powerful. As relief agencies Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:92–106. have come to accept the role of epidemiology in disaster 11. Ramirez M, Peek-Asa C. Epidemiology of traumatic injuries responses, their reliance on the ad hoc crisis management from earthquakes. Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:47–55. approach has lessened. An organized approach to data col- 12. Liu S, Quenemoen LE, Malilay J, et al. Assessment of a severe lection in disaster situations also helps disaster managers weather warning system and disaster preparedness, Calhoun make crucial decisions and predict the variety of options that County, Alabama, 1994. Am J Public Health 1996;86:87–9. they will face during the different phases of a disaster (3). 13. Staes C, Orengo JC, Malilay J, et al. Deaths due to flash floods In summary, with both disasters and the number of people in Puerto Rico, January 1992: implications for prevention. Int J affected by such events on the increase, the importance of Epidemiol 1994;23:968–75. disasters as a public health problem is now widely recog- 14. Armenian HK, Noji EK, Oganessian AP. Case control study of nized. This is now reflected by the fact that every school of injuries due to the earthquake in Soviet Armenia. Bull World public health in the United States now offers some training Health Organ 1992;70:251–7. Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8
  • 6. 8 Noji 15. Noji EK. Analysis of medical needs during disasters caused by 21. Guha-Sapir D, van Panhuis WG, Degomme O, et al. Civil tropical cyclones: anticipated injury patterns. J Trop Med Hyg conflicts in four African countries: a five-year review of 1993;96:370–6. trends in nutrition and mortality. Epidemiol Rev 2005; 16. Burkholder BT, Toole MJ. Evolution of complex disasters. 27:67–77. Lancet 1995;346:1012–15. ´ ` 22. Medecins Sans Frontieres. World in crisis: the politics of 17. Boss L, Toole MJ, Yip R. Assessments of mortality, morbidity, survival at the end of the 20th century. New York, NY: and nutritional status in Somalia during the 1991–1992 Routledge, 1997. famine: recommendations for standardization of methods. 23. Vasterman P, Yzermans CJ, Dirkzwager AJE. The role of JAMA 1994;272:371–6. the media and media hypes in the aftermath of disasters. 18. Public health impact of Rwandan refugee crisis: what hap- Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:107–14. pened in Goma, Zaire, in July 1994? Goma Epidemiology 24. Galea S, Nandi A, Vlahov D. The epidemiology of post- Group. Lancet 1995;345:339–44. traumatic stress disorder after disasters. Epidemiol Rev 2005; 19. Noji EK, Toole MJ. The historical development of 27:78–91. public health responses to disaster. Disasters 1997;21: 25. VanRooyen M, Leaning J. After the Tsunami—facing the 366–76. public health challenges. N Engl J Med 2005;352:435–8. 20. Salama P, Spiegel P, Talley L, et al. Lessons learned from 26. Hatch M, Ron E, Bouville A, et al. The Chernobyl disaster: complex emergencies over past decade. Lancet 2004;364: cancer following the accident at the Chornobyl nuclear power 1801–13. plant. Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:56–66. Epidemiol Rev 2005;27:3–8