SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 19
Rhetorical Analysis
By: Danielle Weiss
AUSTRALIA POST
• Australia's
  Government owned
  postal service
• Collects, processes
  and distributes
  letters throughout
  Australian and to
  other countries
  overseas.
“ If you really
want to touch
someone, send
them a letter. ”
GRANT DAVIE IDENTIFIES
FOUR CONSTITUENTS IN
RHETORICAL SITUATIONS:
EXIGENCE, RHETORS,
AUDIENCES, AND
CONSTRAINTS.
EXIGENCE
Grant-Davie defines exigence as:
“ problem or need that can be addressed by communication” and
“what the discourse is about, why it is needed, and what it should accomplish”
(Rhetorical Situations and Their Constituents)


Exengencies found in ad:
• Increasing reliance on technology for to communicate (texting,
  calling, email, social media, ect.)
• Neglect of writing letters to communicate.
• Post offices are becoming obsolete, workers losing jobs.
• Youth unaware of how to correctly write and send a letter.
RHETOR
“Those People, Real or Imagined, Responsible for the
Discourse and Its Authorial Voice” (Rhetorical Situations and Their Constituents)



• Ad originally found in a defense force magazine.
• Other ads like it were run in different magazines leading up to
  Valentine’s Day.
• One version came out around time of Mother’s Day.
• Created by M&C Saatchi Sydney, one of Australia's largest and
  most successful Marketing Agencies.
• Imagined rhetor: Australian Post
AUDIENCE
Defined by Laura Carroll “those who are the (intended or unintended) recipients of the
rhetorical message. The audience should be able to respond to the exigence” (Backpacks
vs. Briefcases)

Primary Audience:
•    Citizens of Australia
•    Males and females ages 15-35
(who may not often think to write a letter)
•    Specifically long distance relationship where such form of communication
     would be necessary.
•    Military girlfriends/ boyfriends

Secondary Audience:
•    Older citizens of Australia who may have neglected letter writing as a form
     of communication.
CONSTRAINTS
“All Factors In The Situation, Aside From The Rhetor And The Audience, That May Lead
The Audience To Be Either More Or Less Sympathetic To The Discourse, And That
May Therefore Influence The Rhetor's Response To The Situation” (Grant-davie)

Negative Constraints:
• Many young people may not know how to
  properly write and send out a letter.
• Mail is often slow and post offices may be closed
  on certain days, slowing down the communication
  process.
• May not have access to a mailbox.

Postive Constraints:
•   Sending a letter is often cheaper than
•   a text/ phone call.
•   Receiving a letter is always a great feeling.
PURPOSE
"rhetorical discourse comes into existence as a response to situation,
in the same sense that an answer comes into existence in response
to a question, or a solution in response to a problem”


• To encourage the use of the Australian Post as a service to out
  letters to loved ones.
• Express how much emotion can be locked inside a hand written
  letter.
• Show the difference of receiving a letter vs. an email, text
  message, ect.
RELATED ADS
EFFECTIVE ARGUMENTATION
Aristotle articulated three
“artistic appeals” that a
could draw on to make a
case: logos, pathos, and
ethos” (Carroll, Backpacks
vs. Briefcases)
LOGOS
Argument From Reason, Usually Appeals To An Audience’s Intellectual Side.
(Carroll, Backpacks Vs. Briefcases)



Results from a study done by: Catherine E. Mosher And Sharon Danoff–
burg “Health Effects Of Expressive Letter Writing”
(University at Albany, State University of New York)
• Undergrad college students told to write an expressive letter.
• Studies found enhanced physical and psychological well–being,
  reduced illness symptoms, relief of stress and anxiety.
PATHOS
Argument That Appeals To One’s Emotions


• Pathos is the main tool used in
  this ad.
• So many emotions can be
  expressed in a hand written
  letter, and so many emotions can
  be felt from reading one.
• “If you really want to touch
  someone, send them a letter”
(the best way to make someone feel
loved or to express your feelings is
in a hand written letter.)
ETHOS
The Credibility Of The Writer




  • The rhetor displays ethos by the phrase at the
    bottom matching up to the emotion depicted on
    the lady’s emotion on her face when she is
    being “touched by the letter”
  • Her expression on her face shows a genuine
    sense of comfort and happiness.
  • Displays that writing a letter can “literally”
    touch someone.
A CLOSER LOOK AT THE AD :
               THE TEXT.
• Writing a letter, can bring emotion to someone that can’t be
  achieved through other forms of communication.
• The most effective way to depict your emotion.
A CLOSER LOOK AT THE
                AD :
              THE FONT
• Written in a simple common font.
• Not italicized, bolded or underlined.
• Can be compared to writing a letter- same way nothing fancy
  such as technology is needed to communicate effectively.
• Fancy font, or emphasis is not necessary to depict message.
A CLOSER LOOK AT THE
                    AD :
                FONT COLOR/
               BACKGROUND.
• White font pops against the red background.
• The red background stands out against the mostly white
  background of the ad.
• Also goes along with the theme of the simplicity of the message
  compared to the simplicity of a letter.
A CLOSER LOOK AT THE AD :
       THE IMAGE.

          • The image used in this ad evokes emotional
            appeal in the audience.
          • A young girl is feeling literally “touched” by
            the letter she received from her significant
            other.
          • The letter is literally reaching out an touching
            him as her boyfriend is actually there with
            her.
          • Handwritten letters have this ability as
            opposed to a text or email.

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Riders to-the-sea final
Riders to-the-sea final Riders to-the-sea final
Riders to-the-sea final mushtaq ahmed
 
Seamus heaney
Seamus heaneySeamus heaney
Seamus heaneyPato_Ch
 
Major themes oedipus rex
Major themes oedipus rexMajor themes oedipus rex
Major themes oedipus rexFRK NIAZI
 
Dryden's view on drama
Dryden's view on dramaDryden's view on drama
Dryden's view on dramanidhijasani
 
Oedipus rex by sophocles
Oedipus rex by sophoclesOedipus rex by sophocles
Oedipus rex by sophoclesamnaamna28
 
Northrop Frye's "Archetypal Criticism"
Northrop Frye's "Archetypal Criticism"Northrop Frye's "Archetypal Criticism"
Northrop Frye's "Archetypal Criticism"Riddhi Bhatt
 
Heart of Darkness Introduction
Heart of Darkness IntroductionHeart of Darkness Introduction
Heart of Darkness IntroductionPam Kiel
 
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And Tragedy
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And TragedyAristotle's Poetics - Epic And Tragedy
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And TragedyWater Birds (Ali)
 
Symbolism in 'a passage to India'.
Symbolism in 'a passage to India'.Symbolism in 'a passage to India'.
Symbolism in 'a passage to India'.Irshad Husein
 
Analysis of "Out of the cradle endlessly rocking" by Walt Whitman
Analysis of "Out of the cradle endlessly rocking"  by Walt Whitman Analysis of "Out of the cradle endlessly rocking"  by Walt Whitman
Analysis of "Out of the cradle endlessly rocking" by Walt Whitman Jenith Suganthy Clemenshia
 
modern tragedy by raymond williams
modern tragedy by raymond williamsmodern tragedy by raymond williams
modern tragedy by raymond williamsIqramushtaq1142
 
Aristotle's Tragedy
Aristotle's TragedyAristotle's Tragedy
Aristotle's Tragedyhctilley
 
Doctor faustus as a morality play
Doctor faustus as a morality playDoctor faustus as a morality play
Doctor faustus as a morality playSardarsinh Solanki
 
Presentation on The significance of the title of “She Stoops to Conquer”
Presentation on  The significance of the title of “She Stoops to Conquer”Presentation on  The significance of the title of “She Stoops to Conquer”
Presentation on The significance of the title of “She Stoops to Conquer”Fahad Rahman Ajhor
 
Edward said key_thinker
Edward said key_thinkerEdward said key_thinker
Edward said key_thinkerXillehumAMALIK
 

Mais procurados (20)

Riders to-the-sea final
Riders to-the-sea final Riders to-the-sea final
Riders to-the-sea final
 
Seamus heaney
Seamus heaneySeamus heaney
Seamus heaney
 
EcoCritism
EcoCritismEcoCritism
EcoCritism
 
Major themes oedipus rex
Major themes oedipus rexMajor themes oedipus rex
Major themes oedipus rex
 
Dryden's view on drama
Dryden's view on dramaDryden's view on drama
Dryden's view on drama
 
Aristotle's Poetics
Aristotle's Poetics Aristotle's Poetics
Aristotle's Poetics
 
Oedipus rex by sophocles
Oedipus rex by sophoclesOedipus rex by sophocles
Oedipus rex by sophocles
 
Northrop Frye's "Archetypal Criticism"
Northrop Frye's "Archetypal Criticism"Northrop Frye's "Archetypal Criticism"
Northrop Frye's "Archetypal Criticism"
 
Epic poetry
Epic poetryEpic poetry
Epic poetry
 
Heart of Darkness Introduction
Heart of Darkness IntroductionHeart of Darkness Introduction
Heart of Darkness Introduction
 
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And Tragedy
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And TragedyAristotle's Poetics - Epic And Tragedy
Aristotle's Poetics - Epic And Tragedy
 
The Return Of The Native
The Return Of The NativeThe Return Of The Native
The Return Of The Native
 
Symbolism in 'a passage to India'.
Symbolism in 'a passage to India'.Symbolism in 'a passage to India'.
Symbolism in 'a passage to India'.
 
Analysis of "Out of the cradle endlessly rocking" by Walt Whitman
Analysis of "Out of the cradle endlessly rocking"  by Walt Whitman Analysis of "Out of the cradle endlessly rocking"  by Walt Whitman
Analysis of "Out of the cradle endlessly rocking" by Walt Whitman
 
modern tragedy by raymond williams
modern tragedy by raymond williamsmodern tragedy by raymond williams
modern tragedy by raymond williams
 
Aristotle's Tragedy
Aristotle's TragedyAristotle's Tragedy
Aristotle's Tragedy
 
Doctor faustus as a morality play
Doctor faustus as a morality playDoctor faustus as a morality play
Doctor faustus as a morality play
 
Sophocles
SophoclesSophocles
Sophocles
 
Presentation on The significance of the title of “She Stoops to Conquer”
Presentation on  The significance of the title of “She Stoops to Conquer”Presentation on  The significance of the title of “She Stoops to Conquer”
Presentation on The significance of the title of “She Stoops to Conquer”
 
Edward said key_thinker
Edward said key_thinkerEdward said key_thinker
Edward said key_thinker
 

Destaque

Rhetorical Analysis
Rhetorical AnalysisRhetorical Analysis
Rhetorical Analysisstmiller555
 
Land Rover The First 60 Days 2010 Case Study
Land Rover The First 60 Days 2010 Case StudyLand Rover The First 60 Days 2010 Case Study
Land Rover The First 60 Days 2010 Case StudyBen Bloom
 
IMechE Birmingham and Coventry 2016
IMechE Birmingham and Coventry 2016IMechE Birmingham and Coventry 2016
IMechE Birmingham and Coventry 2016Lokesh Gupta
 
Print advertisement question 1
Print advertisement question 1Print advertisement question 1
Print advertisement question 1samuelnolan
 
Quiz @ 901 Episode 02
Quiz @ 901 Episode 02Quiz @ 901 Episode 02
Quiz @ 901 Episode 02Pritam Guha
 
Λαμπρινού ρατσισμός
Λαμπρινού   ρατσισμόςΛαμπρινού   ρατσισμός
Λαμπρινού ρατσισμόςthem1972
 
Administration and Employment Law
Administration and Employment LawAdministration and Employment Law
Administration and Employment LawJames Willis
 
Edu tech week 1 discussion 2
Edu tech week 1  discussion 2Edu tech week 1  discussion 2
Edu tech week 1 discussion 2Kim Paylor
 
Anaemia and body mass index (BMI) of fisherwomen inhabiting in Karang island...
 Anaemia and body mass index (BMI) of fisherwomen inhabiting in Karang island... Anaemia and body mass index (BMI) of fisherwomen inhabiting in Karang island...
Anaemia and body mass index (BMI) of fisherwomen inhabiting in Karang island...Rustam Maishnam
 

Destaque (15)

Rhetorical Analysis
Rhetorical AnalysisRhetorical Analysis
Rhetorical Analysis
 
Land Rover The First 60 Days 2010 Case Study
Land Rover The First 60 Days 2010 Case StudyLand Rover The First 60 Days 2010 Case Study
Land Rover The First 60 Days 2010 Case Study
 
IMechE Birmingham and Coventry 2016
IMechE Birmingham and Coventry 2016IMechE Birmingham and Coventry 2016
IMechE Birmingham and Coventry 2016
 
Print advertisement question 1
Print advertisement question 1Print advertisement question 1
Print advertisement question 1
 
Quiz @ 901 Episode 02
Quiz @ 901 Episode 02Quiz @ 901 Episode 02
Quiz @ 901 Episode 02
 
Aslms talk 2010
Aslms talk 2010Aslms talk 2010
Aslms talk 2010
 
Hypass slideshow
Hypass slideshowHypass slideshow
Hypass slideshow
 
Kyoceraecosys
KyoceraecosysKyoceraecosys
Kyoceraecosys
 
Kyoceraecosys
KyoceraecosysKyoceraecosys
Kyoceraecosys
 
Λαμπρινού ρατσισμός
Λαμπρινού   ρατσισμόςΛαμπρινού   ρατσισμός
Λαμπρινού ρατσισμός
 
Administration and Employment Law
Administration and Employment LawAdministration and Employment Law
Administration and Employment Law
 
Project test
Project testProject test
Project test
 
CW Company Profile 2015
CW Company Profile 2015CW Company Profile 2015
CW Company Profile 2015
 
Edu tech week 1 discussion 2
Edu tech week 1  discussion 2Edu tech week 1  discussion 2
Edu tech week 1 discussion 2
 
Anaemia and body mass index (BMI) of fisherwomen inhabiting in Karang island...
 Anaemia and body mass index (BMI) of fisherwomen inhabiting in Karang island... Anaemia and body mass index (BMI) of fisherwomen inhabiting in Karang island...
Anaemia and body mass index (BMI) of fisherwomen inhabiting in Karang island...
 

Semelhante a Rhetorical analysis

The Speech Context
The Speech ContextThe Speech Context
The Speech ContextEstrebelloh
 
Types of speech context and styles
Types of speech context and stylesTypes of speech context and styles
Types of speech context and stylesJezreelLindero
 
what is communication
what is communicationwhat is communication
what is communicationNazakatAli36
 
Communication overview
Communication overviewCommunication overview
Communication overviewAsmaKhalil17
 
Communication overview
Communication overviewCommunication overview
Communication overviewAsmaKhalil17
 
Intercultural communication en
Intercultural communication enIntercultural communication en
Intercultural communication enjmalbos
 
Intercultural communication EN
Intercultural communication ENIntercultural communication EN
Intercultural communication ENjmalbos
 
· We are looking for a place (a wordphraseline) in the text· W.docx
· We are looking for a place (a wordphraseline) in the text· W.docx· We are looking for a place (a wordphraseline) in the text· W.docx
· We are looking for a place (a wordphraseline) in the text· W.docxoswald1horne84988
 
Communication,types And it's significance
Communication,types And it's significance Communication,types And it's significance
Communication,types And it's significance SyedaZahra84
 
Writing Open Letters
Writing Open LettersWriting Open Letters
Writing Open LettersJodie Nicotra
 
Barriers to communication (1).pptx
Barriers to communication (1).pptxBarriers to communication (1).pptx
Barriers to communication (1).pptxNehaAgrawal744616
 
week-3-Forms-of-Communication-28032022-115855am-20022024-012242am.pptx
week-3-Forms-of-Communication-28032022-115855am-20022024-012242am.pptxweek-3-Forms-of-Communication-28032022-115855am-20022024-012242am.pptx
week-3-Forms-of-Communication-28032022-115855am-20022024-012242am.pptxvisedes412
 
Introduction to communications
Introduction to communicationsIntroduction to communications
Introduction to communicationsAhad Mehmood
 
How to write a letter to the editor
How to write a letter to the editorHow to write a letter to the editor
How to write a letter to the editorBochica
 
Communication skills.pptx
Communication skills.pptxCommunication skills.pptx
Communication skills.pptxMadhaviPatil26
 
Features of communication.pptx
Features of communication.pptxFeatures of communication.pptx
Features of communication.pptxCieloMariLucas1
 

Semelhante a Rhetorical analysis (20)

The Speech Context
The Speech ContextThe Speech Context
The Speech Context
 
Types of speech context and styles
Types of speech context and stylesTypes of speech context and styles
Types of speech context and styles
 
what is communication
what is communicationwhat is communication
what is communication
 
Communication overview
Communication overviewCommunication overview
Communication overview
 
Communication overview
Communication overviewCommunication overview
Communication overview
 
Intercultural communication en
Intercultural communication enIntercultural communication en
Intercultural communication en
 
Intercultural communication EN
Intercultural communication ENIntercultural communication EN
Intercultural communication EN
 
· We are looking for a place (a wordphraseline) in the text· W.docx
· We are looking for a place (a wordphraseline) in the text· W.docx· We are looking for a place (a wordphraseline) in the text· W.docx
· We are looking for a place (a wordphraseline) in the text· W.docx
 
Communication,types And it's significance
Communication,types And it's significance Communication,types And it's significance
Communication,types And it's significance
 
Writing Open Letters
Writing Open LettersWriting Open Letters
Writing Open Letters
 
Speech context
Speech contextSpeech context
Speech context
 
Barriers to communication (1).pptx
Barriers to communication (1).pptxBarriers to communication (1).pptx
Barriers to communication (1).pptx
 
Communication
CommunicationCommunication
Communication
 
Speech context
Speech contextSpeech context
Speech context
 
week-3-Forms-of-Communication-28032022-115855am-20022024-012242am.pptx
week-3-Forms-of-Communication-28032022-115855am-20022024-012242am.pptxweek-3-Forms-of-Communication-28032022-115855am-20022024-012242am.pptx
week-3-Forms-of-Communication-28032022-115855am-20022024-012242am.pptx
 
Introduction to communications
Introduction to communicationsIntroduction to communications
Introduction to communications
 
How to write a letter to the editor
How to write a letter to the editorHow to write a letter to the editor
How to write a letter to the editor
 
Impactful Communication Skills
Impactful Communication  SkillsImpactful Communication  Skills
Impactful Communication Skills
 
Communication skills.pptx
Communication skills.pptxCommunication skills.pptx
Communication skills.pptx
 
Features of communication.pptx
Features of communication.pptxFeatures of communication.pptx
Features of communication.pptx
 

Rhetorical analysis

  • 2. AUSTRALIA POST • Australia's Government owned postal service • Collects, processes and distributes letters throughout Australian and to other countries overseas.
  • 3. “ If you really want to touch someone, send them a letter. ”
  • 4.
  • 5. GRANT DAVIE IDENTIFIES FOUR CONSTITUENTS IN RHETORICAL SITUATIONS: EXIGENCE, RHETORS, AUDIENCES, AND CONSTRAINTS.
  • 6. EXIGENCE Grant-Davie defines exigence as: “ problem or need that can be addressed by communication” and “what the discourse is about, why it is needed, and what it should accomplish” (Rhetorical Situations and Their Constituents) Exengencies found in ad: • Increasing reliance on technology for to communicate (texting, calling, email, social media, ect.) • Neglect of writing letters to communicate. • Post offices are becoming obsolete, workers losing jobs. • Youth unaware of how to correctly write and send a letter.
  • 7. RHETOR “Those People, Real or Imagined, Responsible for the Discourse and Its Authorial Voice” (Rhetorical Situations and Their Constituents) • Ad originally found in a defense force magazine. • Other ads like it were run in different magazines leading up to Valentine’s Day. • One version came out around time of Mother’s Day. • Created by M&C Saatchi Sydney, one of Australia's largest and most successful Marketing Agencies. • Imagined rhetor: Australian Post
  • 8. AUDIENCE Defined by Laura Carroll “those who are the (intended or unintended) recipients of the rhetorical message. The audience should be able to respond to the exigence” (Backpacks vs. Briefcases) Primary Audience: • Citizens of Australia • Males and females ages 15-35 (who may not often think to write a letter) • Specifically long distance relationship where such form of communication would be necessary. • Military girlfriends/ boyfriends Secondary Audience: • Older citizens of Australia who may have neglected letter writing as a form of communication.
  • 9. CONSTRAINTS “All Factors In The Situation, Aside From The Rhetor And The Audience, That May Lead The Audience To Be Either More Or Less Sympathetic To The Discourse, And That May Therefore Influence The Rhetor's Response To The Situation” (Grant-davie) Negative Constraints: • Many young people may not know how to properly write and send out a letter. • Mail is often slow and post offices may be closed on certain days, slowing down the communication process. • May not have access to a mailbox. Postive Constraints: • Sending a letter is often cheaper than • a text/ phone call. • Receiving a letter is always a great feeling.
  • 10. PURPOSE "rhetorical discourse comes into existence as a response to situation, in the same sense that an answer comes into existence in response to a question, or a solution in response to a problem” • To encourage the use of the Australian Post as a service to out letters to loved ones. • Express how much emotion can be locked inside a hand written letter. • Show the difference of receiving a letter vs. an email, text message, ect.
  • 12. EFFECTIVE ARGUMENTATION Aristotle articulated three “artistic appeals” that a could draw on to make a case: logos, pathos, and ethos” (Carroll, Backpacks vs. Briefcases)
  • 13. LOGOS Argument From Reason, Usually Appeals To An Audience’s Intellectual Side. (Carroll, Backpacks Vs. Briefcases) Results from a study done by: Catherine E. Mosher And Sharon Danoff– burg “Health Effects Of Expressive Letter Writing” (University at Albany, State University of New York) • Undergrad college students told to write an expressive letter. • Studies found enhanced physical and psychological well–being, reduced illness symptoms, relief of stress and anxiety.
  • 14. PATHOS Argument That Appeals To One’s Emotions • Pathos is the main tool used in this ad. • So many emotions can be expressed in a hand written letter, and so many emotions can be felt from reading one. • “If you really want to touch someone, send them a letter” (the best way to make someone feel loved or to express your feelings is in a hand written letter.)
  • 15. ETHOS The Credibility Of The Writer • The rhetor displays ethos by the phrase at the bottom matching up to the emotion depicted on the lady’s emotion on her face when she is being “touched by the letter” • Her expression on her face shows a genuine sense of comfort and happiness. • Displays that writing a letter can “literally” touch someone.
  • 16. A CLOSER LOOK AT THE AD : THE TEXT. • Writing a letter, can bring emotion to someone that can’t be achieved through other forms of communication. • The most effective way to depict your emotion.
  • 17. A CLOSER LOOK AT THE AD : THE FONT • Written in a simple common font. • Not italicized, bolded or underlined. • Can be compared to writing a letter- same way nothing fancy such as technology is needed to communicate effectively. • Fancy font, or emphasis is not necessary to depict message.
  • 18. A CLOSER LOOK AT THE AD : FONT COLOR/ BACKGROUND. • White font pops against the red background. • The red background stands out against the mostly white background of the ad. • Also goes along with the theme of the simplicity of the message compared to the simplicity of a letter.
  • 19. A CLOSER LOOK AT THE AD : THE IMAGE. • The image used in this ad evokes emotional appeal in the audience. • A young girl is feeling literally “touched” by the letter she received from her significant other. • The letter is literally reaching out an touching him as her boyfriend is actually there with her. • Handwritten letters have this ability as opposed to a text or email.

Notas do Editor

  1. http://www.southernct.edu/~brownm/HealthBenefitsLetterWriting.pdf