1. Solar Electricity
Arno Smets and Miro Zeman
Delft University of Technology
Delft
University of
Picture Source: www.nasa.gov
Technology
Challenge the future
2. About myself
Arno Smets
1974 born in Netherlands
1992-1997 Physics at TU Eindhoven
1998-2002 PhD TU Eindhoven
2002-2004 Post-doctoral Reseacher Helianthos Project
2005-2010 Researcher at AIST, Japan
2010-now Assistant professor at TU Delft
Photovoltaic Materials and Devices
3. Photovoltaic Materials and Devices
People
Scientific Staff
Secretary 4 Post docs 4 Technicians Guests
18 PhD students ~30 MSc students (15 final MSc project, 15 traineeship)
6. Humanity’s ten top problems
for next 50 years
1. ENERGY
2. WATER
3. FOOD
4. ENVIRONMENT
5. POVERTY
6. TERRORISM & WAR
7. DISEASE
8. EDUCATION
9. DEMOCRACY
10. POPULATION
Source: Lecture Prof. R.E. Smalley (Rice University) at 27th Illinois Junior Science & Humanities Symposium, 2005
7. Humanity’s ten top problems
for next 50 years
1. ENERGY
2. WATER
3. FOOD
4. ENVIRONMENT
5. POVERTY
6. TERRORISM & WAR
7. DISEASE
8. EDUCATION
9. DEMOCRACY
10. POPULATION
Source: Lecture Prof. R.E. Smalley (Rice University) at 27th Illinois Junior Science & Humanities Symposium, 2005
8. The Energy Problem Energy Shortage
Growing world
population
Results in pressure
on economy:
Ann. averg. oil price (in 2008 USD)
120
100
80
60
Increasing living standard: 40
20
0
1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000
Time
Energy consumption per capita
9. The Energy Problem Climate change
Jeopardizing our habitats:
Somalia Russia
Mexico Pakistan
“The weather makers”, Tim Flannery
10. Energy transition
50 years is a characteristic time scale for change in energy mix
Source: Lecture Prof. Moniz (MIT) at TUD 2010
11. Energy transition scenario
EJ/a
1400
geothermal
other renewables
solar thermal (heat only)
solar power 1000
(photovoltaics (PV) & PV & CSP
solar thermal
generation (CSP)
wind energy
600
biomass (advanced)
biomass (traditional)
hydroelectricity
nuclear power
gas 200
coal
oil
2000 2020 2040 2100
year
Source: German Advisory Council on Global Change, 2003, www.wbgu.de
12. Electricity
About 100 years of practical use
Symbol of modernity and progress
Secondary form of energy
2 billion people without electricity
Source: Google Images
13. Electricity generation
Gravitational
Nuclear Wind
Hydro-tidal
Heat Electric
engines generators
Thermal Mechanical Electrical
η<60% η=90%
η=90%
Fuel
Cells
Chemical
Coal, oil, gas,
biomass, hydrogen
Source: L. Freris, D. Infield, Renewable Energy in Power Systems, Wiley 2008
14. Electricity generation
Gravitational
Nuclear Wind
Hydro-tidal
Heat Electric
engines generators
Thermal Mechanical Electrical
η<60% η=90%
Photovoltaics
η=90%
Fuel Solar
Cells thermal
Chemical
Coal, oil, gas,
Solar
biomass, hydrogen
Source: L. Freris, D. Infield, Renewable Energy in Power Systems, Wiley 2008
15. Electricity generation 2007
ELECTRICITY
GENERATION
geothermal
other renewables conversion
hydro 19%
solar thermal (heat only)
losses
solar power
(photovoltaics (PV) & nuclear 16%
solar thermal
generation (CSP) 2/3
wind energy gas 15%
biomass (advanced) ELECTRICITY
biomass (traditional) CONSUMPTION
hydroelectricity
coal 40% 40% residential
nuclear power 1/3
gas 47% industry
coal
oil 10% 13% transmission
oil
losses
16. Electricity generation 2007
Electricity:
World Netherlands
20 202 TWh 103 TWh 20-25 kWh/d/p
wind 3%
geothermal nuclear 4%
hydro 19% biomass 6%
other renewables
solar thermal (heat only)
Total Energy:
solar power nuclear 16% (gas,oil,etc.)
(photovoltaics (PV) &
solar thermal gas 125 kWh/d/p
generation (CSP) gas 59%
wind energy 87%
biomass (advanced)
biomass (traditional)
65%
hydroelectricity coal
nuclear power
gas coal 26%
coal fossil oil
oil 2%
oil
25 Nuclear power plants
(0.5 GW)
Sorce: Eurostat 2009 edition , BP Statistical Review Full Report (http://www.bp.com/images)
23. Solar Resources
Global demand 2010: 16 TW Solar cell with 10% efficiency:
Global demand 2050: 32 TW 1250 1250 km2
Solar energy: 120 000 TW
http://visibleearth.nasa.gov
25. Photovoltaics (PV)
Solar module
Electricity
Sun Solar
radiation
Source: A. Poruba
26. Solar cell
sunlight
Solar cell
electricity
heat
Maximum electrical power out
Efficiency=
Light power in
27. Photovoltaic industry
Scaling production volume
40000
Global solar cell production 37185
MW
mono c-Si
30000 poly c-Si
27381
ribbon c-Si 36%
TF-Si Thin-
CdTe film
20000 CIS solar
rest cells
12464
118%
10000
7910
56%
4279
1815 2536 85%
750 1257 69%
560 34% 68% 45% 40%
0
2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Source: Photon International, March 2012
28. Photovoltaics
Historical development of cumulative PV power:
70 China
70
APEC
60 60
Cumulative Installed
29.6
PV Capacity (GW)
Rest of World
North America
50 Japan 50
39.53
European Union
40 40
22.90
30 30
20 .66 20 Nederland 2003:
15
9
9.4
8
46 MW (1.6 %)
6.9
0
10 10
5.4
6
4
3.9
6
2.8
9
6
2.2
1.7
Nederland 2010:
1.4
0 0
2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 97 MW (0.24 %)
Year
EPIA 2009: Global Market Outlook For Photovoltaics Until 2013
29. Trend in installed power technologies
The European Wind Energy Association: Wind in power: 2011 European Statistics, 2012
30. EU power capacity mix
Summary
in MW in MW
Total ~580 GW Total ~896 GW
The European Wind Energy Association: Wind in power: 2011 European Statistics, 2012
46. PV power
Latest news
Wednesday, May 30, 2012
May 30 – Guardian:
Solar power generation world record set in Germany
German solar power plants produced a world record 22 gigawatts of
electricity – equal to 20 nuclear power stations at full capacity – through the
midday hours of Friday and Saturday, the head of a renewable energy think
tank has said.
This met nearly 50% of the nation’s midday electricity needs.
The record-breaking amount of solar power shows one of the world’s
leading industrial nations was able to meet a third of its electricity needs on
a work day, Friday, and nearly half on Saturday when factories and offices
were closed.
The Guardian: May 30, 2012
50. PV system
Two main types:
Stand-alone system Grid-connected system
Grid
dc/ac
Charge Storage invertor
controller
=
~
DC dc/ac = AC
PV loads invertor PV loads
generator ~ generator
AC
loads
51. PV system
Power electronics
The highly varying environmental conditions and nonlinear
nature of the photovoltaic (PV) generator make the utilization of
PV energy a challenging task:
Power electronics converters:
Reliable operating interface between renewable energy
resources and the electrical power grid.
52. PV system
Markets/applications:
Rural stand-alone
and local grid
(10 Wp – 10 kWp)
Grid-connected
(building-)integrated
(1 kWp – 1 MWp)
Power plants
(1 MWp - 1 GWp)
Source: W Sinke, Solar Academy
53. PV systems
Terminology and definitions
Power (of cells, modules and systems) in Watt-peak (Wp)
(Average) ac system efficiency
Performance ratio =
(STC) dc module efficiency
Typically 0.75 – 0.85
Electricity yield in kWh/kWp (usually per year)
Typically 750 – 900 kWh/kWp for c-Si modules in NL
hours ac peak power per year
Capacity factor =
hours per year
Typically 0.09 – 0.11 in NL/DE
54. Grid-connected PV system
Overview biggest PV installations:
Power Location Description Commissioned Picture
100 MWp Ukraine, Perovo I-V PV power plant 2011
Perovo Constructed by: Activ Solar
97 MWp Canada, Sarnia PV power plant 2009-2010
Sarnia
84 MWp Italy, Montalto di Castro PV 2009-2010
Montalto di Castro power plant
Constructed by: SunPower, SunRay
Renewable
82 MWp Germany, Solarpark Senftenberg II,III 2011
http://www.pvresources.com/PVPowerPlants/Top50.aspx
Senftenberg Constructed by: Saferay
55. DESERTEC project
Solar Thermal Power
plants
Photovoltaics
Wind
Hydro
Biomass
Geothermal
Source: DESERTEC foundation
57. Solar irradiation on Earth
The Netherlands:
2.7 sun hours/day/year
2 3 4 5 6
Solar irradiation: solar irradiance integrated over a period of time
58. Grid-connected PV system
Grid-connected home PV system: 3×150 Wp modules
65
386.0 kWh Year 2010
60
55
Generated energy [kWh]
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
Month
M. Zeman, Delft
59. Costs grid-connected PV System
PV system is nowadays good investment!
Cost in 2012:
Costs €1030 Saves per year: €115 That’s €2875 in 25 years
(500 kWh*€0,23/kWh) A payback period of 9 years!
EY=877 kWh/kWp
M. Workum, PVMD, TU Delft
60. Costs grid-connected PV System
PV system is nowadays good investment!
Above € 6000 inverters
become relatively cheap
Average Dutch family
(3500 kWh @ €6800)
Cheapest system
(500 kWh @ €1030)
No installation or second inverter included. One year old data, prices are now even lower (see previous sheet)
M. Workum, PVMD, TU Delft
67. PV technology: 1st vs 2nd generation
First Generation Second Generation (thin film)
Melt processing Plasma processing
Sanyo, Silicon
Hetero-Junction cell NUON Helianthos
Pure material:
high efficiencies Lower quality material:
Expensive processing: lower efficiencies
cost-price energy higher Low costs processing:
cost-price energy lower
Silicon: record lab efficiency 20-27% Thin film: record lab efficiency 13-20%
68. PV technologies
CIGS
c-Si wafer based
CdTe
III-V semiconductor based
TF Si
69. PV technologies
1. Wafer based Si
2. Thin films
3. Cheap + efficient
MC manufacturing costs
SP average selling price
SIII installed cost for a utility scale system
SI installed cost for a residential system
Hillhouse and Beard, Curr. Opin. Colloid. In. 14, 245 (2009).
70. Thin-film silicon solar cells
Si-based solar cells
Al Al
SiO2 n+
electron
hole
p-type
p++ c-Si p++
Al
c-Si (180-250 μm)
71. Solar cell
Incident light
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
hole covalent bond
Semiconductor
Metal back electrode
72. Solar cell
Incident light
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
hole covalent bond
Semiconductor
Metal back electrode
73. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
hole covalent bond
Semiconductor
Metal back electrode
74. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
hole covalent bond
Semiconductor
Metal back electrode
75. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
hole covalent bond
hole
Semiconductor
Metal back electrode
76. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
hole covalent bond
hole
Semiconductor
Metal back electrode
77. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
hole covalent bond
P atom
Semiconductor
Metal back electrode
78. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
hole covalent bond
P atom
Semiconductor
B atom
Metal back electrode
79. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
hole covalent bond
P atom
Semiconductor
B atom
Metal back electrode
hole
80. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
hole covalent bond
P atom
Semiconductor
B atom
Metal back electrode
hole
81. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
covalent bond
P atom
Semiconductor
B atom
Metal back electrode
hole
82. Solar cell
Incident light
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
covalent bond
P atom
Semiconductor
B atom
Metal back electrode
hole
83. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
covalent bond
P atom
Semiconductor
B atom
Metal back electrode
hole
84. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
covalent bond
P atom
Semiconductor
B atom
Metal back electrode
hole
85. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
covalent bond
P atom
Semiconductor
B atom
Metal back electrode
hole
86. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
covalent bond
P atom
Semiconductor
B atom
Metal back electrode
hole
87. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Si atom
electron
covalent bond
P atom
Semiconductor
B atom
Metal back electrode
hole
88. Solar cell
Metal front
electrode
Semiconductor
Metal back electrode
89. Solar cell
Incident light
Metal front
electrode
ARC
electron
hole
Semiconductor
Metal back electrode
91. Solar cell
Additional losses
Incident light
Reflection
n1 ≠ n2
Metal front
electrode
ARC
electron
hole
Semiconductor
Metal back electrode
c-Si solar cell structure
Transmission (finite α)
92. Design principle of solar cells
Defect Engineering
Bulk defects
Interface defects
Meta-stable defects
Spectral Matching Light Trapping
Texture interfaces
Choice of Material
Reflectors
Multi-junctions
Plasmonic Approaches
93. Thin-film silicon solar cells
Si-based solar cells
Al Al
SiO2 n+ Thin-film Si (0.2 - 5 μm)
p-type
p++ c-Si p++
Al
c-Si (180-250 μm)
94. Thin-film silicon solar cells
Si-based solar cells
Al Al
Glass plate
SiO2 n+ Thin-film Si (0.2 - 5 μm)
TCO
p-type
Intrinsic
a-Si:H
p-type
p++ c-Si p++ n-type
Al Metal electrode
c-Si (180-250 μm) a-Si (0.2-0.3 μm)
95. The a-Si:H p-i-n junction
Problem 2: mismatch single junction with solar spectrum
96. The a-Si:H p-i-n junction
Problem 2: mismatch single junction with solar spectrum
Absorption
a-Si:H Does not cover entire spectrum!
97. The a-Si:H/μc-Si:H tandem
Problem 2: mismatch with solar spectrum
Absorption Absorption
a-Si:H c-Si:H
103. PV technologies
Wafer based crystalline silicon
½ century of manufacturing history, ~90% of 2007 market
progressing by innovation and volume
reduction of manufacturing costs is major challenge
module efficiencies:
- 12 ~ 20% (now)
- 18 ~ >22% (longer term)
Source: W Sinke
104. PV technologies
Thin-film silicon
low-cost potential and new application possibilities
positive impact of micro- and nanocrystalline silicon
efficiency enhancement is major challenge
stable module efficiencies:
– 6 ~ 11% (now)
– 11 ~ 16% (longer term)
Source: W Sinke
105. PV technologies
Cadmium Telluride
low-cost potential (partly already demonstrated)
positive impact of development of take-back and recycling
systems
efficiency enhancement is major challenge
module efficiencies:
– 7 ~ 11% (now)
– 10 ~ 15% (longer term)
Source: W Sinke
106. PV technologies
Copper-indium/gallium-selenide/sulphide (CIGS)
high performance & possibilities for multi-junction devices
reduction of manufacturing costs is major challenge; work on
low-cost varieties
module efficiencies:
– 9 ~ 12% (now)
–15 ~ 18% (longer term)
Source: W Sinke
108. Cost price elements vs abundancy
Averaged cost-price elements versus abundance in ore (2004-2009)
a-Si:H thin film
technology
M. Green, Progress in PV: Res. Appl. 17, 347 (2009)
111. Composition of the Earth’s crust
2nd generation CdTe: Cd,Te,S,Al,Zn,O
Ratio Te/Si: 10-9
1 m2 cell 2μm CdTe (50% =Te)
1 m2 hole having depth of
(110-6/ 110-9 )~ 103 m = 1 km
117. Thin-film Si PV technology
Glass plates:
Application
Industry hall, Thurnau, Germany
118. Helianthos project
Flexible substrate:
Dutch route: Temporary superstrate solar cell concept
Development of unique low-cost roll-to-roll technology for
fabrication of thin-film Si solar modules (started in 1996)
119. Thin-film Si PV technology
Flexible substrate:
Flexible, lightweight, monolithically series connected a-Si modules
123. PV technology
Summary
Direct conversion of light to electricity
(PV) is an elegant process suitable for
versatile, robust, low-cost technology; the
global potential is practically unlimited
A wide range of technology options is
commercially available, emerging or found in
the lab
The first major economic milestone on the road
to very large-scale use has been reached: grid
parity with retail electricity prices
124. PV status in 2012
Summary
Production:
- dominant c-Si PV technology, 90% market
- large production capacity in China
- difficult time for thin-film PV technologies (TF Si, CIGS, CdTe)
Installation:
- highest contribution to newly installed power capacity in EU
Price:
- <1 €/Wp; c-Si modules: 0.8-0.9 €/Wp expectation 0.5 €/Wp in 2015
- grid parity reached in Germany and Netherlands
Research trends
- increasing module efficiency (c-Si modules >20%)
125. PV technology
Challenges for TW scale implementation
turn-key system price < 1 €/Wp (generation costs < 3-10 c€/kWh)
- low-cost modules at very high efficiency (> 30%)
- add efficiency boosters (spectrum shapers), full spectrum utilization (advanced concepts)
- or: very low-cost modules (<< 0.5 €/Wp) at moderate efficiency (>10%)
- polymer solar cells, nanostructured (quantum dot) hybrid materials
- Low BOS costs
use of non-toxic, abundantly available materials
(preferably use Si, C, Al, O, N, …)
- indium replacement
- non-metallic conductors (Ag C?)
- all-silicon thin-film tandems
stability (20 to 40 years) and realibility
- intrinsic & extrinsic degradation of organics-based solar cells
126. Thank you for your attention!
Delft
University of
Picture Source: www.nasa.gov
Technology
Challenge the future
127. Thin-film Si PV technology
Present status:
+ Promising low-cost solar cell technology
+ Industrial production experience
(Flat panel display industry)
- Relatively low stabilized efficiencies (η ≈ 6-7%)
+ Double-junction micromorph solar cell (η>10%)
ideal combination of materials (a-Si:H/μc-Si:H) for
converting AM1.5 solar spectrum
+ 2008 production of modules 400 MW
production capacity ~ 1000 MW
Google images
128. Thin-film Si PV technology
Current developments:
increase in TF Si module production
complete production lines available
Future developments:
Oerlikon
short term: optimize micromorph tandem cell
long term: optimize triple cell, breakthrough
concepts for high efficiency (η>20%)
Applied Materials