Overview presentation on the challenges for telecom operators (telcos, carriers) in voice & messaging services. Examines general trends in evolution of Future of Voice, including fall-off of demand for basic services. Examines the impact & opportunities from a new technology WebRTC in accelerating this, and the ways that telcos can structure their thoughts & strategies. Disruptive Analysis is doing continual work & advising various companies in this area. [Note: this is not an intro to WebRTC technology itself & assumes existing knowledge]
Introduction to Telco-OTT - Disruptive Analysis Ltd and Martin Geddes consult...
Future of Voice & WebRTC - Implications & Opportunities for telcos (service providers)
1. WebRTC – Implications & Opportunities for Telcos
Dean Bubley, Disruptive Analysis
adapted from presentation at WebRTC Expo SF, Nov 2012
information@disruptive-analysis.com @disruptivedean
Contact information@disruptive-analysis.com for information on workshops & consulting
projects about WebRTC & Future of Voice. Watch for upcoming reports & subscribe to the
Disruptive Wireless blog http://disruptivewireless.blogspot.co.uk/p/subscribe-via-email.html
2. Introduction
This is adapted from a Nov 29th 2012 presentation by Dean
Bubley at the WebRTC Expo & Conference in San Francisco
It assumes a working knowledge of what WebRTC technology is,
and how it works.
If you are looking for a WebRTC introduction, check out:
www.webrtcworld.com/ http://bit.ly/xUfKud http://amzn.to/TS7Adp
This presentation focuses on issues for telecom operators
To understand WebRTC implications, it is necessary to first have
a good idea of what is happening to voice comms anyway
More WebRTC detail & analysis is available from Disruptive
Analysis’ consulting services, research reports, workshops & blog
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
3. About Disruptive Analysis
London-based analyst house & strategic consulting firm
Cross-silo, contrarian, visionary, independent
Advisor to MNOs, vendors, regulators & investors
Focus on 3G, 4G, operator strategies, VoIP, OTT, disruption
Published report on “Telco-OTT Strategies”, Feb 2012
Workshops on Future of Voice & #TelcoOTT
With Martin Geddes Consulting (credited for various slides here)
Next events in London & US in H1’13 (futureofvoice.com)
Twitter @disruptivedean .
Blog: disruptivewireless.blogspot.com
To understand the impact of WebRTC on telcos, it is first important to understand their
current marketplace & trends. WebRTC is then a catalyst & accelerant
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
4. It’s all looking pretty grim anyway
Voice & SMS saturation & cannibalisation
Regulation & competitive impacts
Weak content & VAS propositions
Economic pressures
Ecosystem competition
Connecting the last unconnected
Smartphones & data growth
Better segmentation, pricing & promotion
Innovative services & enablers
Embracing & exploiting fragmentation
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
5. Basic services’ demand & pricing is falling
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
6. “It’s all those nasty OTTs’ fault!!”
STOP looking for a scapegoat
& take responsibility
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
7. Voice ≠ Telephony
• Now: 2G & 3G • Future: Smartphones & LTE
Voice
Voice
Telephony
Telephony
Voicemail Gaming, CEBP,
Conferencing surveillance, social
PTT Video voice, TV voice etc
Video, context, sense
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
8. Service
e.g. Telephony
Product
e.g. Skype,
IP-PBX
Feature
e.g. Zynga IM
We have seen a years-long trend for billable
“services” to drift down to ownable products,
Function
and eventually appear as mere features of
functions of other apps or even device OSs
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
9. A telephony demand cliff?
It’s not just so-called OTT competitors, it’s apps removing the need for phone calls.
When was the last time you phoned a travel agent? Taxi apps are better than phoning
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
10. Telephony: Catastrophe imminent?
Supply Price & revenue Demand
Core question: Can data services offset the decline of voice & messaging?
Uncomfortable answer: probably not, based on recent evidence
Disruption and innovation are both inevitable
& essential, irrespective of WebRTC
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
11. Voice & messaging go in-context
Telephony and messaging is increasingly done “in-context” or
“in-app”. But in many cases, telco APIs don’t offer the right
“raw ingredients” or business model.
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
12. Peak telephony & SMS is here
Mobile core services revenue,
indicative W Europe Total c40% fall
BASELINE, ie excluding WebRTC from peak
Telephony c80%
fall from peak
SMS & today’s
mobile data services
Mobile telephony
Source: Disruptive Analysis, Telco 2.0 Analysis
2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020
Even without WebRTC, serious revenue falls are expected in basic telco services.
Given that telephony is >100 years old, it is now looking an old & creaky product
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
13. Personalisation is done by people
User-selected
Mobile calls portfolio:
SMS perfect fit for
MMS specific use
Email cases
99% of personal + Lowest common
comms for all Mobile calls
SMS denominator just
use cases
(RCS?) when needed
“Ubiquitous” & standardised interoperable telco services will increasingly be used only
as lowest-common denominators, when no better app/service is available for a given
instance of communication. Everyone will curate their own service portfolio.
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
14. Fragmentation is valuable
Convergence & Fragmentation &
standards innovation
It will fragment “because it
can”. Consumer need for
ubiquity is over-rated
… new standardised services are neither necessary, nor sufficient.
They are irrelevant at best, and actively damaging at worst.
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
15. Device diversity = OTT inevitable
Probability of all of a user’s Internet / messaging devices being
on a single telco’s network
100%
90% Free 3rd party WiFi
80%
Shared data plans only a
70%
partial response
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10% # connected devices owned
0%
1 2 3 4 5 6
Users will want same apps & service ID on every device – but will inevitably have
multiple telcos. This means that OTT-style services will be mandatory
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
16. Telcos already exploiting Internet
Owned & operated by mobile operators
Usable by anyone, not just subscribers
Via apps & public Internet
Telco-OTT Services
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
17. Harsh truth: Telco-OTT mandatory
• Telephony & SMS prices have peaked
• Telephony & SMS demand has peaked
• APIs, HD, Video, Bundles only delay the inevitable
• Need for new voice-based services beyond “calls”
• Too fast-evolving for new “federated” services
• Too uncertain / innovation-driven for standards
OTT-style services offer the only hope for continued
telco services growth & increased relevance
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
18. Telco-OTT: more than just VoIP/RTC
Comms
Connec- Over 100 identified
Telco-OTT products in the
tivity
market.
Content
Cloud
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
19. Biz models may not be obvious
…. Carriers need to move away
from the obsession with
“subscriptions” with
WebRTC/OTT
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
20. WebRTC: game-changer & threat
The future?
In the crossfire
Microsoft CU-RTC-WEB ????
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
21. WebRTC is a magnifier & catalyst
Now
With WebRTC
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
22. My enemy’s enemy is my friend…. ???
“WebRTC will hurt OTTs more than Telcos!”
… & create new, better, more disruptive OTT players.
Great.
Actually, my enemy’s enemy is probably even nastier & uglier than the
current bunch. Anything that damages Skype is bad news for telcos too
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
23. Telco involvement with WebRTC
AT&T most visible
Participant in standards, eg proposing push for notifications
Developer-centric approach
Telefonica likely a major player
TokBox acquisition
Firefox OS advocacy
TUMe & other TefDig products
DT & FT at recent events
FT on W3C WG
Vodafone, Telecom Italia, SKT, Smart, China Unicom also on WG
Increasing anecdotal evidence from client interest
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
24. Multiple constituencies involved
Enterprise VoIP
Ground-up
/ UC /
interest in
conferencing
WebRTC (in
moving to
labs etc)
WebRTC
VoLTE & Telco- Apps, developer
OTT teams & HTML5
curious/worried initiatives adding
by WebRTC Telco WebRTC
WebRTC
interest
+ Policy / broadband teams: Can we detect / block / bill for it?
Regulatory: What does this mean, how do we do 911 etc?
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
25. Overlapping universes
Softphones etc
“Gateway into IMS” Telco
services
Pure
WebRTC OTT
apps
Network & platform APIs
Browser-based Telco-OTT
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
26. “Easy options” for Telcos+WebRTC
Charging platform
Legal requirements
Notifications
Numbers / directories
WiFi access (in theory…)
Network QoS (in theory…)
But does any of this really move the needle?
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
27. Some myths to avoid for WebRTC
A quick diversion to some pet topics of mine:
Quality & QoS WiFi
Impending quali-pocalypse “Seamless connection”
Users appear to care less HetNets
than expected
Mobile carriers are very
Some high-Q use cases (eg
sales call) important or in control
Internet vs. non-Internet The user & operator are the
Quality driven by much only stakeholders
more than network
Eg Coverage (esp for LTE)
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
28. Main WebRTC strategies for SPs
Perpetuate legacy models
“Put lipstick on a pig” – eg RCS
Extend on-
net services
Enhance Turbocharge
Improves developer Telco-OTT
platform apps
relevance… but Lower
revenue? costs/complexity &
improve reach &
Sell “virality”
packaged
Sell genuine “new WebRTC
services to
stuff” to existing subscriber Also: invest / incubate
audience
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012
29. Conclusions: WebRTC & SPs
No definitive answers yet
Makes the threats worse & the opportunities better
Battle new OTTs or old ones: result is the same
Extending “reach” for poor services doesn’t help
SPs need to exploit WebRTC to create or resell
Avoid the “federation trap”
Manage diverse internal stakeholders & teams
WebRTC will be pervasive across telco “domains”
Be nimble
Contact information@disruptive-analysis.com for information on workshops & consulting
projects about WebRTC & Future of Voice. Watch for upcoming reports & subscribe to the
Disruptive Wireless blog http://disruptivewireless.blogspot.co.uk/p/subscribe-via-email.html
December 2012 Copyright Disruptive Analysis Ltd 2012