This document discusses debates around whether ice cores can reliably preserve atmospheric gases from ancient times. While ice core research is widely accepted, some scientists like Jaworowski argue that physical and chemical processes within ice sheets can alter the composition of trapped air bubbles over time. The document examines evidence on both sides, noting that while ice core researchers have developed methods to account for certain effects, processes like gas diffusion are not fully understood and could significantly impact interpretations of ice core records. Overall, it presents a nuanced perspective and does not take a definitive position, highlighting ongoing questions and debates within the field.

1. Its Polar Environment Central Carbon Records * Historic
Atmospheres Or Even Geophysical Items ?
Ice cores from Greenland as well as Antarctica are generally sacred support beams regarding
proof , establishing standards regarding co2 (co2 ) within Earth’s prehistoric atmospheres.
But could ice actually preserveatmospheric air(free from toxins as well as substance
amendment ) regarding 1000's , thousands , as well as hundreds of thousands regarding years
?
Fossil versus. Artifact
A fossil is a remnant as well as feeling regarding something that was around within previous
geological ages – an ancient kind stored in their initial look.
An artifact is often a item through an man-made personality as a result of extraneous company – an
object that's remaining from your series regarding imaginative activities.
The question for you is : carry out ice cores contain the fossils regarding Earth’s prehistoric
atmospheres, as well as carry out ice cores consist of artifacts regarding geophysical techniques that
continuously remix gas within glacial ice ?
Jaworowski’s arguments
In 92 , a small grouping of 3 or else respected researchers clarified this particular issue with a 57-
page article that gone resistant to the well-known see [1]. These kinds of 3 dissenters (directed
through Zbigniew Jaworowski) hereafter endured expert contempt [2], occupation endangerment [3],
as well as tough critique [4]. Involving 92 as well as '07 , Jaworowski developed 3 far more known
content condemning ice core research [5], [6], [7].
Mainstream researchers dispute well against Jaworowski, and they continue to refuse your ex today.
A significant exemption will be Emeritus teacher regarding natural and organic hormone balance ,
Joel m. Kauffman, which employs Jaworowski’s scenario to assist reexamine the highly questionable
matter regarding human-caused global warming [8].
Jaworowski with his fantastic readers persist that ice cores are generally unacceptable press
regarding figuring out co2 concentrations within Earth’s prehistoric atmospheres, since :
1. Ice sheets usually are not closed techniques that snare gas robotically as well as maintain these
people consistently. Alternatively , fluid saline water can can be found within ice from temperature
ranges down below –70° d , in a permeable ice published when a capillary fluid community acts as
a sieve to redistribute components , isotopes as well as micro-particles.
2. Air recovered from outdated ice will be polluted in the course of field as well as lab procedures.
3. The extensively acknowledged pre-industrial atmospheric co2 level of two hundred and ninety
parts per million rests upon not impartial rejections regarding high co2 blood pressure
measurements within ice cores. First scientific studies upon ice cores persistently confirmed a
selection of co2 blood pressure measurements which are more than after scientific studies – a
single scenario , research by the identical investigator for a passing fancy ice core confirmed
various numbers in numerous years.

2. Raynaud’s Response
D. Raynaud as well as coauthors [9] acknowledge that “several techniques may cause the gasoline
document measured within ice biological materials being distinctive from the original atmospheric
structure.” these people list the next techniques :
• absorption regarding gas on the outside regarding snow and ice deposits ,
• separation through the law of gravity as well as molecular diffusion with the gas inside the ice line ,
• alteration regarding gasoline structure through development regarding air flow hydrates from
excellent absolute depths inside the ice published as well as through presence regarding drilling-
induced cracks as well as cold weather breaks within ice biological materials ,
• alteration through substance interaction involving gas as well as ice upon number of years scales.
Raynaud guarantees us that experts can make sure estimate the end results of the interfering actual
physical techniques , quoting papers through Ethridge as well as Neftel – two with the writers who
Jaworowski competitions.
Critique regarding Raynaud
In essential phrases , Raynaud’s vocabulary will be unknown as well as lacking in effective detail –
this individual seems to elevate powerful statements regarding self-confidence previously mentioned
definitive points regarding processes that get rid of concerns within ice-core gasoline dimensions.
Raynaud quickly dismisses ice-core co2 testing strategies prior to the 1980’s, proclaiming why these
strategies had been unacceptable knowning that trustworthy outcomes emerged only after. This
particular discussion (in the event that true ) overcomes Jaworoski’s objection regarding suspiciously
larger co2 dimensions within ice cores prior to 1980’s. A similar discussion (employed by Harro a. M.
Meijer against Ernst-Georg Beck regulations away most of the 19th century air flow dimensions
regarding co2. nOt enough information , not enough expertise , as well as not enough correct
technique each is well-known justifications that refuse co2 dimensions more than two hundred and
ninety parts per million prior to the year 1958.
Regarding the soundness regarding ice core research , Raynaud as well as coauthors deduce :
“It is now strongly founded any time deciding on correct sampling web sites , the ice core document
regarding green house gas offers the the majority of one on one proof regarding previous
atmospheric alter.”
Expanding upon Raynaud’s self-confidence , captain christopher Readinger [10] creates :
“All with the contemporary logical techniques accustomed to remove these kinds of proxy records
happen to be developed as well as produced as time passes , and also the assistance regarding
better technology as well as brand-new tips , far more correct strategies to ice core studies are
increasingly being developed.”
Looking from Readinger’s finish set of limitations , on the other hand , a person could quickly take
hold of the hesitation that Jaworowski suggests.
Greenland ice Cores
Nagging Doubts
Digging through the books , i stumbled upon a cardstock from year 2000 through Bernhard Stauffer

3. as well as Jurg Tschumi [11] laying out problems that can vex ice core examination. These kinds of
writers admit the reality of artifacts , although they cannot condition overall why these artifacts turn off
trustworthy ice core examination. Their display will be terse as well as non-opinionated, nevertheless
their phrases communicate plainly.
For case in point , a single sentence in your essay , these people survey , “Despite the relatively good
understanding relating to the grip , the coloring 3 along with the camp one hundred year document for
the glacial portion , this grew to become obvious the outcomes do not symbolize a reliable document
with the atmospheric co2 concentrations.”
Later, these people describe :
“We done extremely thorough dimensions along quick sections of check your grip core as well as
witnessed significant variations over distances of a few centimeters within sections which in turn
present high co2 concentrations. … as mentioned above , such short-term variations cannot mirror
variations with the atmospheric co2 focus , it must always be an artifact. Delmas [1993] advised the
excessive co2 will be created by an acid carbonate response inside the ice. Yet another possible
ways to develop co2 will be the oxidation regarding natural and organic substance inside the ice.”
These writers do not convey a similar self-confidence as Raynaud as well as Readinger, nevertheless
through their relationship with all the colloquium upon ice core research in which their cardstock
appeared , i could only assume that they assistance ice core research. To provide a larger flavor with
their strengthen , i found Stauffer’s as well as Ischumi’s results , exactly as created :
• CO2 might be developed and in all probability additionally reduced through substance side effects
developing involving toxins within glacier ice. For the output of co2 oxidation side effects are
generally as important as acid carbonate side effects.
• Antarctic ice core records compared to those from Greenland are often a lesser amount of impacted
by such substance side effects , as a result of reduced impurity concentrations within Antarctic ice.
• The most reliable outcomes concerning reconstruction regarding old atmospheric co2
concentrations are generally acquired along with ice biological materials containing a low
concentration of carbonates as well as H20 2. Dimensions can be viewed trustworthy only when
expose high definition document along several twelve-monthly layers shows that the scattering with
the outcomes will be with the order because logical uncertainness.
• Measurements upon ice where air flow will be enclosed within clathrates present more difficulties as
a result of fractionation regarding air flow parts. This particular keeps particularly for the area in
which the two air flow pockets as well as clathrates coexist.
• It is vital to build up dried up extraction strategies , which permit for the extraction regarding gas
through an productivity all-around completely. The sublimation technique is currently the one which
will be the majority of encouraging.”
The true Picture
From this particular review up to now , a far more practical photograph regarding ice core research
begins to come out – images that could be far more understanding regarding Jaworowski, whose
work opportunities have inserted your ex inside the believe in regarding other people being a toxins

4. specialist.
Jaworowski is adament that well-known experts are generally daydreaming when they feel that they
might remove trustworthy info from the conundrum regarding feasible toxins problems within ice
cores. Well-known experts , conversely , claim that they do know about these problems and also
have these people in check. Brooks Hurd [12], an expert within wholesomeness regarding gas inside
the semiconductor along with other market sectors , echoes Jaworowski’s hesitation , any time this
individual creates , “concerns about decline as well as toxins regarding atmospheric aspects of
sampling handling ahead of examination ought to be a significant matter within serious ice core co2
studies.”
A small Science
Analyzing ice cores is often a relatively small research , in comparison to additional founded sciences
[13] [14], nevertheless even michael went bonkers , a investigator called Robert m. Delmas [15]
carefully talked about the presence of excessive co2 within Greenland ice biological materials. In a
very seemingly unwilling strengthen , this individual talked about relationships involving acid as well
as alkaline toxins that can lead to this particular excessive co2. This individual accepted the
excessive co2 might kind sometimes inside the ice published themselves as well as in the course of
ice-core safe-keeping. Even though this individual definitely avoided asking low published co2
valuations (one hundred eighty – 200ppm), this individual deducted :
“The results of this particular carbonate decomposition is that speedy co2 variances related to global
warming might 't be an atmospheric truth , no less than much less they are now reassembled from
Greenland ice core dimensions.”
He was cautious to emphasize , on the other hand , that his studies forged tiny hesitation upon
Antarctic ice cores as well as upon info about ice ages in Polar regions.
Gases within Ices
Ices with the Greenland as well as Antarctic ice sheets , therefore , continue to be the most
recognized records regarding Earth’s old atmospheres. Gas caught during these huge glaciers
continue to stay as believe in worthy fossils regarding prehistoric air flow.
Air fossils are generally certainly an interesting concept , but wait , how can air flow continue to be
secure regarding many years , in a very moderate that melts as well as refreezes quickly , runs as
well as reforms plastically, as well as seems as well as vanishes cyclically? to assist determine this
particular issue , let's seem lightly , from just how gas talk with glacial ices.
In ice sheets , ice converts via various stages , from snowfall on the outside to dense ice from
excellent absolute depths. Brand-new snowfall compresses progressively underneath the acquiring
weight regarding far more slipping snowfall. Outdated snowfall compresses into granular ice known
as “firn”. Grains that comprise firn squash collectively perhaps stronger to make successively more
dense layers regarding ice. This technique carries on right up until it produces the densest glacial ice.
During the entire change from snowfall to firn to glacial ice , atmospheric air flow intermingles with all
the ice published in a very further advancement of their individual [16]:
• Air combinations along with snowfall.

5. • Snow compresses under a unique weight into granular ice (firn), involving whose grains air flow
continues to stream.
• As firn compresses even more , air flow grows more at standstill plus much more closed off from the
ambiance.
• At deeper layers inside the ice published , air flow becomes caught as air flow pockets within dense
glacial ice.
• At the greatest absolute depths , air flow pockets find squeezed away altogether , as well as person
air flow compounds become caught within crates regarding hydrogen bonds , to create a type
regarding crystal-like shades known as “air hydrates” as well as “clathrates”.
According to ice core researchers , caught air flow offers a document with the initial ambiance that
grew to become covered inside the ice published. While difficulties within deciding on as well as
inspecting air flow biological materials most certainly can be found , ice core researchers yet again
assert self-confidence within strategies that untangle the dimensions regarding such biological
materials.
For case in point , erina Bender [17] says , “Measured concentrations regarding gas within ice cores
as well as firn air flow need to be corrected regarding outcomes of gravitational fractionizaton as well
as cold weather fractionization.” this individual additionally indicates , “there are generally significant
concerns related to get older [of ice as well as air] restricting our capacity to read a few records.” his
conversation makes apparent that scientific study has to deconvolute air flow dimensions as outlined
by ice flow models limited by standard unknowns as well as standard presumptions whose sanctity
few individuals issue.
Werner f. Kuhs [18] admits , “in a number of aspects , a deeper comprehension of the chemico-
physical behavior regarding air flow in touch with ice is not nevertheless acquired.” Kuhs makes a
number of essential things :
• Air hydrates (clathrates) almost certainly work as rigid models any time embedded in an ice
published subject to visco-plastic deformation techniques.
• Even therefore , there exists proof that diffusion regarding water compounds inside the minute
programs involving ice grains occurs quicker than the visco-plastic deformation method.
• At high challenges serious inside the ice published , the relationships involving air flow as well as ice
is a lot more complex , and just how this particular interaction occurs with a minute level continues
to be an empty issue.
In an incredibly techie cardstock , a. Watts. Rempel as well as m. Azines. Wetttlaufer [19] present
experience into the most up-to-date comprehension of glacial ice :
• Careful scientific studies disclose ice core sections where considerable changes in the original
debris have took place.
• Microscopic limits involving ice grains can join being a fluid community regarding problematic veins
where fluid carries as well as combinations toxins.
• Downward diffusion via this particular community regarding problematic veins sooner or later
outpaces the flow with the ice , therefore isolating elements from the ice along with which they had

6. been placed.
• Scientists have to have a style that includes such a capillary method to higher read ice records
regarding reconstructing prehistoric areas.
More upon Diffusion
In the diary regarding GLACIOLOGY (2008 ), Jinho Ahn [20] as well as coauthors, inside the article ,
CO2 Diffusion within Polar Ice, create , “The techniques regarding gasoline diffusion associated
with varied actual physical attributes regarding ice continue to be not necessarily recognized.” while
certainly not asking the fundamental assumption regarding making old atmospheres from ice core
co2 dimensions , these people however point out undeniable details :
• CO2 diffusion within ice following the air flow will be caught within pockets will be inadequately
understood , for the reason that very little price regarding co2 diffusion has not been precisely
determined.
• Other types of diffusion (for instance , through fluid within ice wheat limits as well as problematic
veins ) can also be essential , however influence has not been quantified.
• Substantial co2 diffusion may well exist in ice upon timescales regarding thousands of years.
Expanding about the 2nd reality previously mentioned , Ahn as well as coauthors create :
“Processes apart from amount diffusion could possibly be essential but you are difficult to assess. For
instance , there exists proof of arsenic intoxication melt from three-way junctions regarding wheat
limits within polar ice (Mulvaney among others , 1988). Therefore , co2 may well break up as well as
progress inside the fluid problematic vein , while noble-gas types , along with reduced solubility, may
well generally lodge at the original web sites. If it is the case , the diffusion via the fluid problematic
vein as well as ice wheat limits could possibly be ruled straight by the wheat growth rate , as advised
from an hormone balance study (Barnes among others , 2002 ).”
Additional essential things through these kinds of writers are generally :
• Diffusion regarding co2 may well significantly improve along with increased depth inside the ice as a
result of geothermal power warming.
• The relationship relating to the solubility regarding co2 within ice as well as temperature is
unidentified.
Ice published slip , Deformation, Recrystallization, as well as plastic
material Flow
Besides substance instabilities within ice sheets , in addition there are actual physical instabilities
within ice sheets.
The huge ice sheets regarding Greenland as well as Antarctica consist of ice that runs for the marine
underneath the force of their individual muscle size , sneaking like a viscous fluid along thousands of
years. Flow occurs mostly via deformation. Deformation occurs mostly on the foundation , as huge
weight brings about ice deposits to grind over one yet another as well as recrystallize. Such
deformation as well as recrystallization are generally what govern the slow movement as well as
alterations regarding ice sheets. [21] the large time-scales as well as relatively high temperature
ranges with the sneaking method continually alterations the minute composition regarding ice.

7. With this particular comprehension of ice sheets , Sergio h. Faria [22] produces a bold assert :
“In revenge to the fact that recrystallization phenomena have fundamentally a thermodynamic
personality , the majority of polycrystalline ice-sheet models offered up to now happen to be
according to ad hoc hypotheses , with no corroboration of the arduous thermodynamic examination.”
Paul n. Bons [23] as well as coauthors replicate Faria’s evaluation :
“The principal further complicating component is that a number of bundled fighting techniques
influence the micro constructing (elizabeth.g., diffusional slip , wheat boundary dropping as well as
recrystallization) … which means the characteristics regarding ice flow , such as the potential for
shear localization, are likely not necessarily completely captured by the common flow regulations
regarding ice.”
Both Faria as well as Bons point out just how ice flow continuously reworks the minute composition
regarding ice , nevertheless neither publisher questions regardless of whether ice-core co2 records
are generally trustworthy. One of the most Bons concedes are these claims :
“… the interpretation with the complex deformation background regarding polar ice will be tough as
well as is still reliant on intense investigation.”
Ice flow presumptions as well as ice core Drilling
According to g. Durand [24] as well as coauthors, researchers exercise ice cores exactly on the
covers regarding ice domes, where 3 principal presumptions implement :
• Ice runs symmetrically round the up and down axis.
• Ice thins due to up and down data compresion only , with no side to side absolute.
• Ice thins more and more along with raising depth , in a very clean , dull method.
These presumptions guide researchers within relationship ice and its particular contents. These kinds
of presumptions , on the other hand , overlook any kind of feasible community deformation, which in
turn Durand displays being completely wrong. What this individual displays is that flow disorder are
generally detectable from almost the most notable with the ice published on the absolute depths with
the ice published , raising within amount as well as intensity along with depth. Durand, therefore ,
suggests that ice core researchers reconsider the present normal relationship graphs.
The studies regarding Durand, Faria, as well as Bons assistance the concept that ice cores present
simply a static overview with the cumulative deformational background of the ice published. In the
event that such slow , continuous , fluid deformation occurs over many years , a person might wonder
regardless of whether a pokey , continuous , fluid remixing regarding contents additionally occurs.
Abruptly , Jaworowski’s arguments revisit bother the conversation yet again.
It is tough to get pregnant the physics regarding ice will be individual from the hormone balance
regarding ice – the contents of ice are generally individual from the a continual of their millennial flow.
How can something as vulnerable as air flow maintain any kind of bit of of their initial identification ,
and just how can experts discover any kind of place regarding enduring steadiness by which to
ascertain a genuine unique regarding any kind of old ambiance ? zero outstanding piece of books up
to now seems to answer this particular issue well.
Living breathing ice Sheets

8. In the temporary shape regarding individual expertise , the monolithic ice sheets regarding Greenland
as well as Antarctica show up static as well as spotless. In a very increased temporary shape , on the
other hand , and quite often upon smaller scales regarding measure , a far more dynamic photograph
unfolds. Extremely slow , small alterations occur continuously within ice sheets , regarding hundreds ,
1000's , thousands , as well as hundreds of thousands regarding years. Besides the dynamic
capabilities mentioned above previously mentioned , there are still other people :
Greenland SupraGlacial waters as well as Antarctica SubGlacial
Lakes
• NASA [25] reports the area regarding Antarctica from any one area , in different one moment ,
belies its true , complex personality , which includes several , productive swimming pools regarding
water beneath the huge ice published.
• Benjamin elizabeth. Smith [26] as well as coauthors create that , at the time of year 2008 , how
many subglacial waters within Antarctica will be 280, many which in turn sit underneath the skill
level with the eastern Antarctic ice published.
• Sarah b. Das [27] as well as coauthors report a competent subglacial waterflow and drainage
technique inside the Greenland ice published that disperses area body of water water. The writers
highlight a really speedy lake-draining event within 2006 whose flow price exceeded the average
flow price regarding Niagra drops.
Antarctic Volcanoes
Hugh Corr as well as brian Vaughan [28] survey a volcanic eruption underneath the west Antarctic ice
published as latest as 2000 in years past. Installments of water creation as well as relieve from the
volcano almost certainly afflicted ice flow. Continuing volcanic high temperature creation might
influence modern day ice characteristics of this glacial technique.
Microbial development , substance exercise as well as Cosmic light
within Glacial Ice
• The ice core working class [29], in the year 2002 , talked about brand-new breakthroughs regarding
microbial lifestyle within glacial ice as well as subglacial waters. One exciting issue these kinds of
researchers brought up was regardless of whether you can find metabolically productive bacterias
within fluid water problematic veins regarding strong glacial ice. They also explained :
“It is important that future ice-coring jobs include biological scientific studies inside the arranging
stages to ensure correct measures might be arrive at prevent microbial toxins. Most of days gone by
biological investigation upon ice cores has already established to fight toxins problems and it has
often yielded equivocal outcomes.”
• P. Buford value as well as Todd Sowers [30] assistance the see that , much down below the cold
place , fluid water on the inside ice as well as permafrost is available regarding metabolic process.
These people make clear at length :
“The thermodynamic steadiness regarding ion-rich fluid problematic veins from three-way grain-
boundaries within polycrystalline ice in addition to skinny videos regarding unfrozen water upon
microbial surfaces within permafrost makes it possible for transportation regarding vitamins and

9. minerals to as well as waste from their website. Certain toxins including nutrient chemicals as well as
salt can help to eliminate the cold place regarding water within narrow intergranular problematic veins
to as little as -90°C. Acidophilic psychrophiles in a very Greenland my own survive the frosty winters
from -30°C, almost certainly by subtracting benefit from such a home.”
• A. M. Colussi as well as m. 3rd theres r. Hoffman [31] concern the assumption that substance
exercise will be forever imprisoned within serious ice cores, praoclaiming that such exercise
presents a real overuse injury in evaluating Earth’s old atmospheres. These people point out
photochemical side effects driven through cosmic light penetrating serious into glacial ice. M. i.
Guzman [32] as well as coauthors provide a similar study upon chronic substance exercise within
glacial ice.
CONCLUSION
In this article , i've talked about many productive techniques that exist in the ice sheets regarding
Greenland as well as Antarctica:
• deformation as well as recrystallization
• air diffusion
• capillary fluid transport
• subglacial as well as supraglacial water flow
• subglacial volcanic exercise as well as geothermal power high temperature production
• microbial respiration
• chemical reactions
Not only might these kinds of techniques occur at present from any one moment in different one area
of the ice published , but additionally these kinds of techniques happened continuously , together ,
cumulatively, from various amounts as well as locations in a very expanding as well as going ice
published , over thousands regarding years or higher.
Whether or not current ice flow models adequately take into account the group impact of these kinds
of techniques continues to be an empty issue. Within my common sense , regardless of whether any
kind of style whatsoever can predict as well as restore the complex impact of the techniques with a
vulnerable air flow inclusion continues to be doubtful. As a result , my personal principal issue
continues to be unsettled – are generally ice core co2 air flow biological materials actually
atmospheric fossils as well as geophysical artifacts ?
SOURCES
1. Z. Jaworowski, t. /. Segalstad as well as n. Ono (92 )), Do glaciers notify a genuine
Atmospheric co2 history ?, the research with the full environment , vol 114, r 227-284
http://www.co2web.info/stoten92.pdf
.
2. Jim Easter (04 2005 ), Hans Oeschger’s page to ESPR, a few are generally BOOJUMS [web log]
http://www.someareboojums.org/blog/?p=12
.
3. (may well '07 ) The ice core Man [published online], nationwide post , CanWest MediaWorks

10. journals corporation.
http://www.geocraft.com/WVFossils/Reference_Docs/ice_core_man-canada_2007.pdf
.
4. Jim Easter (may well 2005 ), The fantastic Horseshoe award : Jaworowski along with the vast
co2 Conspiracy, a few are generally BOOJUMS [web log]
http://www.someareboojums.org/blog/?p=7
.
5. Zbigniew Jaworowski (spring the late nineties ), Ice core info present zero co2 Increase, twenty-
first one hundred year , r 42-52
http://www.21stcenturysciencetech.com/2006_articles/IceCoreSprg97.pdf
.
6. Zbigniew Jaworowski (03 2008 ), Climate alter : completely wrong home Pre-Industrial CO2,
[statement designed for congressional hearing]
http://www.john-daly.com/zjiceco2.htm
.
7. Zbigniew Jaworowski (03 '07 ), CO2: the greatest scientific Scandal in our Time, EIR research ,
r 38-53
http://www.warwickhughes.com/icecore/zjmar07.pdf
.
8. Fran m. Kauffman ('07 ), Climate alter Reexamined, diary regarding scientific search , vol twenty
one , zero several , r 723-749
http://www.scientificexploration.org/journal/jse_21_4_kauffman.pdf
.
9. N. Raynaud, m. Jouzel, m.m. Barnola, m. Chappellaz, 3rd theres r.m. Delmas, d. Lorius (feb.
Michael went bonkers ), The ice document regarding green house Gases, research brand-new
collection , Vol 259, zero 5097, r 926-934
http://www.csun.edu/~hmc60533/CSUN_311/article_references/Sc_Feb93_IceRecordGHgases.pdf
.
10. Captain christopher Readinger (feb. 2006 ), Ice core Proxy means of checking weather
Change, PROQUEST [website]
http://www.csa.com/discoveryguides/icecore/review.php
.
11. Bernhard Stauffer as well as Jiirg Tschumi (2000 ), Reconstruction regarding previous
Atmospheric co2 concentrations through ice core Analyses, within PHYSICS regarding ice core
records , modified through t. Hondoh, Hokkaido college push , Sapporo, r 217-241
http://eprints.lib.hokudai.hvac.jp/dspace/bitstream/2115/32470/1/P217-241.pdf
.
12. Brooks Hurd (the fall of 2006 ), Analyses regarding co2 along with other Atmospheric Gases
, within AIG information , r 10-11
http://www.biomind.de/nogreenhouse/daten/AIGnewsNov06.pdf#page=10

11. .
13. College regarding Copenhagen, center regarding ice as well as weather , Neils Bohr institute ,
The background regarding Danish ice core Science [webpage]
http://www.iceandclimate.nBi.ku.dk/about_centre/history/
.
14. Chester d. Langway, junior. (2008 ) the regarding first POLAR ice CORES, u. Azines. Military
Corps regarding designers [ebooklet]
http://www.crrel.usace.military.mil/library/technicalreports/ERDC-CRREL-TR-08-1.pdf
.
15. Robert m. Delmas (may well michael went bonkers ), A organic Artefact within Greenland Ice-
Core co2 Measurements, TELLUS b , Vol fortyfive matter several , r 391-396
http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/cgi-bin/fulltext/119302738/PDFSTART
.
16. Werner f. Kuhs, Gas Hydrates (Clathrate Hydrates) [webpage]
http://peggy.uni-mki.gwdg.de/docs/kuhs/clathrate_hydrates.html
.
17. Erina Bender, Todd Sowers as well as ed stream (september the late nineties ), Gases within ice
Cores, proceedings nationwide academy regarding SCIENCES, vol ninety four , r 8343–8349,
Colloquium cardstock [This cardstock was offered with a colloquium eligible co2 as well as global
warming , arranged through Charles n. Keeling, used the fall of 13–15, 1997 on the nationwide
academy regarding Sciences, Irvine, ca )
http://www.pnas.org/content/94/16/8343.complete.pdf
.
18. Werner f.Kuhs, Alice Klapproth as well as Bertrand Chazallon (2000 ), Chemical Physics
regarding air flow Clathrate Hydrates, within PHYSICS regarding ice core records , modified
through t. Hondoh, Hokkaido college push , Sapporo, r 373-392
http://eprints.lib.hokudai.hvac.jp/dspace/bitstream/2115/32476/1/P373-392.pdf
.
19. A.watts. Rempel as well as m.azines. Wettlaufer (2002 ), Segregation, transportation , as well
as interaction regarding weather proxy servers within Polycrystalline Ice, CANADIAN diary
regarding PHYSICS, vol eighty one matter 1/2, r 89-97
http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=aph&AN=9988916&site=ehost-live
.
20. Jinho Ahn, Melissa Headly, Martin Wahlen, ed m. Stream , paul a. Mayewske, Kendrick d. Taylor
(2008 ), CO2 Diffusion within Polar ice : observations from effortlessly shaped co2 surges
inside the Siple Dome (Antarctica) ice Core, diary regarding GLACIOLOGY, Vol. 54 , zero. 187, r
685-695
http://www.igsoc.org/journal/54/187/j07j102.pdf
.

12. 21. Maurine Montagnat as well as paul Duval (2008 ), The Viscoplastic behaviour regarding ice
within Polar ice sheets : experimental outcomes as well as Modelling, COMPTES RENDUS
entire body , your five , r 699-708
http://www-lgge.obs.ujf-grenoble.fr/~maurine/publis/CRAS2004Paru.pdf
.
22. Sergio h. Faria (september 8-10 , 2006 ), Creep as well as Recrystallization of enormous
Polycrystalline masses. Iii. Continuum concept regarding ice Sheets, proceedings with the regal
society a , vol 462, zero 2073, r 2797-2816
http://rspa.rOyalsocietypublishing.org/content/462/2073/2797.full
.
23. Paul n. Bons, Sérgio h. Faria, as well as Sepp Kipfstuhl (2008 ), Modelling regarding
Deformation as well as Recrystallisation Microstructures within Polar ice : mathematical
Studies [joint project], institute regarding Geosciences, Tubingen University
http://homepages.uni-tuebingen.de/paul.bons/paul/position/NUMOPOLI_short.pdf
.
24. G. Durand, f. Graner as well as m. Weiss (come early july 2008 ), Deformation regarding wheat
limits within Polar Ice, EUROPHYSICS correspondence , vol 67 , zero some , r 1038-1044
http://graner.nEt/francois/publis/durand_ice.pdf
.
25. NASA (04 '07 ), Sub-glacial waters – Antarctica, globe OBSERVATORY [website]
http://earthobservatory.nAsa.gov/IOTD/view.php?id=7624
.
26. Benjamin elizabeth. Smith , sally a. Fricker, Ian 3rd theres r. Joughin, Slawek Tulaczyk (2009 ),
An supply regarding productive Subglacial waters within Antarctica found through ICESat
(2003–2008), diary regarding GLACIOLOGY, Vol. 55 , zero. 192, r 573-595
http://www.igsoc.org/journal/55/192/j09J034.pdf
.
27. Darlene b. Das, Ian Joughin, tag n. Behn, Ian m. Howat, matt a. Full , dan Lizarralde, Maya r.
Bhatia (feb. 2008 ), Fracture distribution on the lower Greenland ice published in the course of
Supraglacial body of water Drainage, revised model uploaded to SCIENCE
https://darchive.mblwhoilibrary.org/bitstream/handle/1912/2506/DasetalScience2008_revised.pdf file
;jsessionid=75814908980D1B0B48AFB037ED2C17EA?sequence=1
.
28. Hugh f. M. Corr as well as brian g. Vaughan (jan 2008 ), A latest Volcanic Eruption beneath the
west Antarctic ice Sheet, dynamics GEOSCIENCE, vol one , r 122-125
http://ruby.fgcu.edu/courses/twimberley/EnviroPhilo/Corr.pdf
.
29. Ice core working class (06 2002 ), u. Azines. Ice core SCINECE: ideas for the long run [a survey
good course , the long run regarding u.azines. Ice Coring research , 03 20-21, Arlington, Virginia], r
25-28

13. http://74.one hundred twenty five.47.132/search?q=cache:zckcyID1reIJ:nicl-
smo.unh.edu/icwg/ICWG2003.pdf+is+ice+core+science+valid&cd=11&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us
.
30. R. Buford value as well as Todd Sowers (03 2008 ), Temperature reliance regarding Metabolic
charges regarding Microbial development , maintenance , as well as Survival, proceedings with
the nationwide academy regarding SCIENCES, vol information and facts , zero 13 , r 4631-4636
http://www.pnas.org/content/101/13/4631.full
.
31. A. m. Colussi as well as m. 3rd theres r. Hoffmann (2002 ), In Situ Photolysis regarding
serious ice core contaminants through Cerenkov light regarding Cosmic Origin,
GEOPHYSICAL investigation correspondence , vol 25 , zero several , r 1195-1198
http://www.physics.ohio-
state.edu/~kagan/phy596/Articles/CerenkovRadiation/GeophysicalResLet2003-Colussi.pdf
.
32. M. i. Guzman, m. 3rd theres r. Hoffmann and a. M. Colussi (may well '07 ), Photolysis regarding
Pyruvic acid within ice : feasible significance to co as well as co2 ice core document
Anomalies, diary regarding GEOPHYSICAL investigation , vol 112
http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.one.one.114.7463&rep=rep1&type=pdf
.
dao tao wordpress