Presentation held at the Virtual Knowledge Studio's research colloquium in Amsterdam, The Netherlands, on 7 May 2009 (www.virtualknowledgestudio.nl/). Thank you to Sara Kjellberg for initiating our exchange of ideas, Anne Beaulieu for inviting me and to everyone at VKS who attended!
Fostering Friendships - Enhancing Social Bonds in the Classroom
The Eroticism Of Paper
1. The Eroticism of Paper: (how) can we imagine Humanities scholarship beyond the printed text? Cornelius Puschmann University of Düsseldorf [email_address] 7 May 2009
5. universities spend between 05. percent and 1.00 percent of their budgets on journals subscriptions (Phillips, 2009)
6. academic journals have been the fastest growing media sub–sector of the past 15 years (Morgan Stanley, 2002)
7. the number of scholarly journals increased from 39,565 in 2003 to 61,620 in 2008
8. approximately 5.7 million people work in research and development worldwide, publishing on average one article per year, and reading 97 articles per year.
9. Challenges in the Humanities: economics Even as they face growing economic problems, university presses are receiving ever more submissions as a result of increased expectations for promotion and tenure in our disciplines and at our institutions of higher learning [..] Academics who think of a monograph as a particularly musty, narrowly focused tome [..] need to realize that for the scholarly press director today, monograph also describes virtually every book written by junior professors in the humanities seeking tenure [..] The term [..] applies to any book lacking in crossover sales potential . MLA Report: The Future of Scholarly Publishing, 2002
10. Challenges in the Humanities: access It is attractive to see these problems rooted in economics, and even more attractive to see the electronic world as an easy solution[..] However, the root problem is the centuries-old academic publishing model that insists upon restricted access to scholarship . This model requires scholarship to be a commodity within a market whose economics are based upon selling access [..] But in the electronic age [..] knowledge does not have to be sold . In fact, it shouldn't be. It's value increases with access and use , and the restricted-access paradigm is keeping Humanities scholarship quarantined. Burton, 2008
11. A (simplistic) comparison of different areas of scholarship Natural Sciences Humanities raison d'être “ discovery” “ reflection” signature method empiricism hermeneutics publishing: typical form journal article monograph publishing: critical aspect speed length & breadth publishing: prestige criterion ranking/IPF press/series name
12.
13.
14.
15. but : changes in the Natural Sciences are largely pragmatic, in Humanities more fundamental and philosophical
16.
17. support and interest from funding agencies and foundations (NEH, Mellon Foundation, DANS, DFG, ...)
18. but also skepticism: Heidelberg Appeal, conflation of legal issues (author rights), digitization, Open Access etc regarded as threats
19.
20. a change in the medium we write and publish in will naturally bring about change in Humanities scholarship in general