SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 26
EXAMINING PAYMENTS/REWARDS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES  :  EXPERIENCES FROM PRO-POOR REWARDS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL  SERVICES IN AFRICA ( PRESA ) Sara Namirembe With Meine van Noordwijk Delia Catacutan Leimona Beria
PRESA Sites
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Redirecting development pathways towards environmental integrity Positive incentives are needed to reward rural poor for the envirponmental services they can/do provide
PRESA SO FAR: Can watersheds be managed sustainably through negotiated agreements between landowners and potential beneficiaries? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Key aspects of RES ,[object Object],[object Object],Context Mechanism +
REALISTIC ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Impacts of land use change - Kapingazi The impact of land use change on water yield is generally low.  Scenario Water yield (mm) Surface runoff % Base flow %  Base case 846 86 14 Convert tea farms to annual crops 936 84 16 Convert coffee farms to annual crops 864 88 12 Double built up areas 860 86 14
Effectiveness of landuse practices on hydrology Quantity:  Soil and water conservation practices have little effect on water yield Quality:  Significant effect on sediment yield Sasumua Landuse  practices Sediment yield reduction (%) Reduction in surface runoff  (%) Increase in base flow (%) Contour farming with trees 49 16 8 Grass filter strips 38 - - Grass waterway 41 - - Terraces 85 22 10
Towards a business case for PWS - Sasumua ,[object Object],Benefit to Nairobi City Water and Sewerage Cooperation  Reduction in cost of alum: Reduction in costs of desiltation of dam  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Net annual earning per household: 1,725,000  283,200 (Values in Kenya Shillings) 20% less sediment yield into Sasumua dam 566.4  400,000
Pay-back period based on constant cost of allum alone
Increasing value accruing to farmers ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Ulugurus Mts, Tanzania
Sediment sources in Sasumua ,[object Object],[object Object],Reducing costs:  targeting hotspots
VOLUNTARY ,[object Object]
Are sellers willing to accept payments for ES supply? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],BUT  may  underestimate opportunity costs  $93/ha/y  compared to model estimate of  $232/ha/y  ( Kapingazi) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Are buyers willing to pay for ES? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
CONDITIONALITY ,[object Object]
If performance will not happen without incentives  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],BENEFICIARIES Short run:  payments for effort based on trust – CSR Long run:  rigorous proof needed Western Usambaras, Tanzania
PES Paradigms Conditionality ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],van Noordwijk and Leimona (2010) Proxies, recurrent Plans investment 'Real' ES, recurrent
WHAT IS THE RIGHT MECHANISM? van Noordwijk and Leimona (2010) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],CO-INVESTMENT AND SHARED RESPONSIBILITY ENTAIL  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Free and prior informed consent Efficiency  Fairness Balancing act  is needed
 
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Buyers : Local & international companies Banks Governments Individuals Intermediaries : Regulators Brokers Project developers e.g., NGOs Researchers
 
Initial interest Effective increase in ES Signed contract External investors and regulators: learning curve Learning curve for local stakeholders (actors) of land use change Smooth  implemen- tation? Efficient + Fair reward systems require a two-way learning curve Negotiations
WHERE TO WITH PES? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Thank You Sara Namirembe ( [email_address] ) PRESA  World Agroforestry Centre http://www.worldagroforestrycentre.org/sea/Networks/RUPES http://presa.worldagroforestry.org

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Semelhante a EXAMINING PAYMENTS/REWARDS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES : EXPERIENCES FROM PRO-POOR REWARDS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES IN AFRICA ( PRESA )

Success factors and constraints of payment and reward schemes for environment...
Success factors and constraints of payment and reward schemes for environment...Success factors and constraints of payment and reward schemes for environment...
Success factors and constraints of payment and reward schemes for environment...World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Stakeholder engagement in the Dee Basin
Stakeholder engagement in the Dee BasinStakeholder engagement in the Dee Basin
Stakeholder engagement in the Dee BasinWorld Water Day
 
Session Governance - Principles for ppp april 2010
Session Governance - Principles for ppp april 2010Session Governance - Principles for ppp april 2010
Session Governance - Principles for ppp april 2010IRC
 
Ecosystem Services in plantations: from economic valuations to market-based i...
Ecosystem Services in plantations: from economic valuations to market-based i...Ecosystem Services in plantations: from economic valuations to market-based i...
Ecosystem Services in plantations: from economic valuations to market-based i...CIFOR-ICRAF
 
Payments for peatland ecosystem services in the Natural Environment White Paper
Payments for peatland ecosystem services in the Natural Environment White PaperPayments for peatland ecosystem services in the Natural Environment White Paper
Payments for peatland ecosystem services in the Natural Environment White PaperAberdeen CES
 
Rainwater management for food security and environmental services in Ethiopia
Rainwater management for food security and environmental services in Ethiopia Rainwater management for food security and environmental services in Ethiopia
Rainwater management for food security and environmental services in Ethiopia ILRI
 
Presentation - 9th Roundtable on Financing water - Amgad Elmahdi
Presentation - 9th Roundtable on Financing water - Amgad ElmahdiPresentation - 9th Roundtable on Financing water - Amgad Elmahdi
Presentation - 9th Roundtable on Financing water - Amgad ElmahdiOECD Environment
 
Integrated Approaches to Nutrient Reduction: Protecting Soil and Water Resour...
Integrated Approaches to Nutrient Reduction: Protecting Soil and Water Resour...Integrated Approaches to Nutrient Reduction: Protecting Soil and Water Resour...
Integrated Approaches to Nutrient Reduction: Protecting Soil and Water Resour...Iwl Pcu
 
Raouf - water cost recovery options
Raouf - water cost recovery optionsRaouf - water cost recovery options
Raouf - water cost recovery optionsWANA forum
 
Raouf - Water Cost Recovery Options
Raouf - Water Cost Recovery OptionsRaouf - Water Cost Recovery Options
Raouf - Water Cost Recovery OptionsLaura Haddad
 

Semelhante a EXAMINING PAYMENTS/REWARDS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES : EXPERIENCES FROM PRO-POOR REWARDS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES IN AFRICA ( PRESA ) (20)

Icraf at ifad on res rupes presa part 1
Icraf at ifad on res rupes presa part 1Icraf at ifad on res rupes presa part 1
Icraf at ifad on res rupes presa part 1
 
UN sustainable goals
UN sustainable goalsUN sustainable goals
UN sustainable goals
 
Success factors and constraints of payment and reward schemes for environment...
Success factors and constraints of payment and reward schemes for environment...Success factors and constraints of payment and reward schemes for environment...
Success factors and constraints of payment and reward schemes for environment...
 
Rewarding upland farmers for reducing sedimentation: A river care scheme
Rewarding upland farmers for reducing sedimentation: A river care schemeRewarding upland farmers for reducing sedimentation: A river care scheme
Rewarding upland farmers for reducing sedimentation: A river care scheme
 
Stakeholder engagement in the Dee Basin
Stakeholder engagement in the Dee BasinStakeholder engagement in the Dee Basin
Stakeholder engagement in the Dee Basin
 
Mark Reed
Mark Reed Mark Reed
Mark Reed
 
Potential ‘value’ of ecosystem services vis-à-vis cost of project implementat...
Potential ‘value’ of ecosystem services vis-à-vis cost of project implementat...Potential ‘value’ of ecosystem services vis-à-vis cost of project implementat...
Potential ‘value’ of ecosystem services vis-à-vis cost of project implementat...
 
Introduction to PES and REDD+: Implications for participating land managers
Introduction to PES and REDD+: Implications for participating land managersIntroduction to PES and REDD+: Implications for participating land managers
Introduction to PES and REDD+: Implications for participating land managers
 
Addressing the rights and ownership challenge: gender, and land / water tenure
Addressing the rights and ownership challenge: gender, and land / water tenureAddressing the rights and ownership challenge: gender, and land / water tenure
Addressing the rights and ownership challenge: gender, and land / water tenure
 
Session Governance - Principles for ppp april 2010
Session Governance - Principles for ppp april 2010Session Governance - Principles for ppp april 2010
Session Governance - Principles for ppp april 2010
 
Ecosystem Services in plantations: from economic valuations to market-based i...
Ecosystem Services in plantations: from economic valuations to market-based i...Ecosystem Services in plantations: from economic valuations to market-based i...
Ecosystem Services in plantations: from economic valuations to market-based i...
 
Payments for peatland ecosystem services in the Natural Environment White Paper
Payments for peatland ecosystem services in the Natural Environment White PaperPayments for peatland ecosystem services in the Natural Environment White Paper
Payments for peatland ecosystem services in the Natural Environment White Paper
 
Rainwater management for food security and environmental services in Ethiopia
Rainwater management for food security and environmental services in Ethiopia Rainwater management for food security and environmental services in Ethiopia
Rainwater management for food security and environmental services in Ethiopia
 
Presentation - 9th Roundtable on Financing water - Amgad Elmahdi
Presentation - 9th Roundtable on Financing water - Amgad ElmahdiPresentation - 9th Roundtable on Financing water - Amgad Elmahdi
Presentation - 9th Roundtable on Financing water - Amgad Elmahdi
 
Integrated Approaches to Nutrient Reduction: Protecting Soil and Water Resour...
Integrated Approaches to Nutrient Reduction: Protecting Soil and Water Resour...Integrated Approaches to Nutrient Reduction: Protecting Soil and Water Resour...
Integrated Approaches to Nutrient Reduction: Protecting Soil and Water Resour...
 
Brent swallow 6th october
Brent swallow 6th october Brent swallow 6th october
Brent swallow 6th october
 
Brent swallow, 6th october
Brent swallow, 6th october Brent swallow, 6th october
Brent swallow, 6th october
 
Raouf - water cost recovery options
Raouf - water cost recovery optionsRaouf - water cost recovery options
Raouf - water cost recovery options
 
Raouf - Water Cost Recovery Options
Raouf - Water Cost Recovery OptionsRaouf - Water Cost Recovery Options
Raouf - Water Cost Recovery Options
 
2.3 foogoa financing green loans in africa
2.3 foogoa financing green loans in africa2.3 foogoa financing green loans in africa
2.3 foogoa financing green loans in africa
 

Mais de World Agroforestry (ICRAF)

Resilience of rubber based agroforestry facing global change
Resilience of rubber based agroforestry facing global changeResilience of rubber based agroforestry facing global change
Resilience of rubber based agroforestry facing global changeWorld Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
How can we overcome obstacles and mobilize investments for successful, sustai...
How can we overcome obstacles and mobilize investments for successful, sustai...How can we overcome obstacles and mobilize investments for successful, sustai...
How can we overcome obstacles and mobilize investments for successful, sustai...World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Forest and agroforesty options for building resilience in refugee situations:...
Forest and agroforesty options for building resilience in refugee situations:...Forest and agroforesty options for building resilience in refugee situations:...
Forest and agroforesty options for building resilience in refugee situations:...World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
How local application of agroecological principles can transform food systems
How local application of agroecological principles can transform food systemsHow local application of agroecological principles can transform food systems
How local application of agroecological principles can transform food systemsWorld Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Agroforestry systems for restoration in Brazil: reconciling social and ecolo...
Agroforestry systems for restoration in Brazil:  reconciling social and ecolo...Agroforestry systems for restoration in Brazil:  reconciling social and ecolo...
Agroforestry systems for restoration in Brazil: reconciling social and ecolo...World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Vulnerabilities of forests and forest dependent people
Vulnerabilities of forests and forest dependent peopleVulnerabilities of forests and forest dependent people
Vulnerabilities of forests and forest dependent peopleWorld Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Pests and diseases of trees in Africa: review of a growing emergency
Pests and diseases of trees in Africa: review of a growing emergencyPests and diseases of trees in Africa: review of a growing emergency
Pests and diseases of trees in Africa: review of a growing emergencyWorld Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Wall posters on habitat distribution of nine tree species in Ethiopia
Wall posters on habitat distribution of nine tree species in EthiopiaWall posters on habitat distribution of nine tree species in Ethiopia
Wall posters on habitat distribution of nine tree species in EthiopiaWorld Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Not all roads lead to Rome: Inclusive business models and responsible finance...
Not all roads lead to Rome: Inclusive business models and responsible finance...Not all roads lead to Rome: Inclusive business models and responsible finance...
Not all roads lead to Rome: Inclusive business models and responsible finance...World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Decent work and economic growth: Potential impacts of SDG 8 on forests and fo...
Decent work and economic growth: Potential impacts of SDG 8 on forests and fo...Decent work and economic growth: Potential impacts of SDG 8 on forests and fo...
Decent work and economic growth: Potential impacts of SDG 8 on forests and fo...World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Forest conservation and socio-economic benefits through community forest conc...
Forest conservation and socio-economic benefits through community forest conc...Forest conservation and socio-economic benefits through community forest conc...
Forest conservation and socio-economic benefits through community forest conc...World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Sustainable land management for improved livelihoods and environmental sustai...
Sustainable land management for improved livelihoods and environmental sustai...Sustainable land management for improved livelihoods and environmental sustai...
Sustainable land management for improved livelihoods and environmental sustai...World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Rangeland Management in Africa Research and case studies
Rangeland Management in Africa Research and case studiesRangeland Management in Africa Research and case studies
Rangeland Management in Africa Research and case studiesWorld Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Sustainable transition of shifting cultivation systems for land degradation n...
Sustainable transition of shifting cultivation systems for land degradation n...Sustainable transition of shifting cultivation systems for land degradation n...
Sustainable transition of shifting cultivation systems for land degradation n...World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Understanding farmer behavior and options to improve outcomes
Understanding farmer behavior and options to improve outcomesUnderstanding farmer behavior and options to improve outcomes
Understanding farmer behavior and options to improve outcomesWorld Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
NRM Innovations for Risk Management and Agricultural Transformation in Semiar...
NRM Innovations for Risk Management and Agricultural Transformation in Semiar...NRM Innovations for Risk Management and Agricultural Transformation in Semiar...
NRM Innovations for Risk Management and Agricultural Transformation in Semiar...World Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 
Combining land restoration and livelihoods - examples from Niger
Combining land restoration and livelihoods - examples from NigerCombining land restoration and livelihoods - examples from Niger
Combining land restoration and livelihoods - examples from NigerWorld Agroforestry (ICRAF)
 

Mais de World Agroforestry (ICRAF) (20)

Resilience of rubber based agroforestry facing global change
Resilience of rubber based agroforestry facing global changeResilience of rubber based agroforestry facing global change
Resilience of rubber based agroforestry facing global change
 
DryDev Closeout Webinar 30th June 2020
DryDev Closeout Webinar 30th June 2020DryDev Closeout Webinar 30th June 2020
DryDev Closeout Webinar 30th June 2020
 
Farmland Biodiversity
Farmland BiodiversityFarmland Biodiversity
Farmland Biodiversity
 
How can we overcome obstacles and mobilize investments for successful, sustai...
How can we overcome obstacles and mobilize investments for successful, sustai...How can we overcome obstacles and mobilize investments for successful, sustai...
How can we overcome obstacles and mobilize investments for successful, sustai...
 
Forest and agroforesty options for building resilience in refugee situations:...
Forest and agroforesty options for building resilience in refugee situations:...Forest and agroforesty options for building resilience in refugee situations:...
Forest and agroforesty options for building resilience in refugee situations:...
 
How local application of agroecological principles can transform food systems
How local application of agroecological principles can transform food systemsHow local application of agroecological principles can transform food systems
How local application of agroecological principles can transform food systems
 
Agroforestry systems for restoration in Brazil: reconciling social and ecolo...
Agroforestry systems for restoration in Brazil:  reconciling social and ecolo...Agroforestry systems for restoration in Brazil:  reconciling social and ecolo...
Agroforestry systems for restoration in Brazil: reconciling social and ecolo...
 
Vulnerabilities of forests and forest dependent people
Vulnerabilities of forests and forest dependent peopleVulnerabilities of forests and forest dependent people
Vulnerabilities of forests and forest dependent people
 
Pests and diseases of trees in Africa: review of a growing emergency
Pests and diseases of trees in Africa: review of a growing emergencyPests and diseases of trees in Africa: review of a growing emergency
Pests and diseases of trees in Africa: review of a growing emergency
 
Wall posters on habitat distribution of nine tree species in Ethiopia
Wall posters on habitat distribution of nine tree species in EthiopiaWall posters on habitat distribution of nine tree species in Ethiopia
Wall posters on habitat distribution of nine tree species in Ethiopia
 
Not all roads lead to Rome: Inclusive business models and responsible finance...
Not all roads lead to Rome: Inclusive business models and responsible finance...Not all roads lead to Rome: Inclusive business models and responsible finance...
Not all roads lead to Rome: Inclusive business models and responsible finance...
 
Decent work and economic growth: Potential impacts of SDG 8 on forests and fo...
Decent work and economic growth: Potential impacts of SDG 8 on forests and fo...Decent work and economic growth: Potential impacts of SDG 8 on forests and fo...
Decent work and economic growth: Potential impacts of SDG 8 on forests and fo...
 
Forest conservation and socio-economic benefits through community forest conc...
Forest conservation and socio-economic benefits through community forest conc...Forest conservation and socio-economic benefits through community forest conc...
Forest conservation and socio-economic benefits through community forest conc...
 
Sustainable land management for improved livelihoods and environmental sustai...
Sustainable land management for improved livelihoods and environmental sustai...Sustainable land management for improved livelihoods and environmental sustai...
Sustainable land management for improved livelihoods and environmental sustai...
 
Rangeland Management in Africa Research and case studies
Rangeland Management in Africa Research and case studiesRangeland Management in Africa Research and case studies
Rangeland Management in Africa Research and case studies
 
Sustainable transition of shifting cultivation systems for land degradation n...
Sustainable transition of shifting cultivation systems for land degradation n...Sustainable transition of shifting cultivation systems for land degradation n...
Sustainable transition of shifting cultivation systems for land degradation n...
 
Understanding farmer behavior and options to improve outcomes
Understanding farmer behavior and options to improve outcomesUnderstanding farmer behavior and options to improve outcomes
Understanding farmer behavior and options to improve outcomes
 
Scaling watershed development in India
Scaling watershed development in IndiaScaling watershed development in India
Scaling watershed development in India
 
NRM Innovations for Risk Management and Agricultural Transformation in Semiar...
NRM Innovations for Risk Management and Agricultural Transformation in Semiar...NRM Innovations for Risk Management and Agricultural Transformation in Semiar...
NRM Innovations for Risk Management and Agricultural Transformation in Semiar...
 
Combining land restoration and livelihoods - examples from Niger
Combining land restoration and livelihoods - examples from NigerCombining land restoration and livelihoods - examples from Niger
Combining land restoration and livelihoods - examples from Niger
 

EXAMINING PAYMENTS/REWARDS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES : EXPERIENCES FROM PRO-POOR REWARDS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES IN AFRICA ( PRESA )

  • 1. EXAMINING PAYMENTS/REWARDS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES : EXPERIENCES FROM PRO-POOR REWARDS FOR ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES IN AFRICA ( PRESA ) Sara Namirembe With Meine van Noordwijk Delia Catacutan Leimona Beria
  • 3.
  • 4. Redirecting development pathways towards environmental integrity Positive incentives are needed to reward rural poor for the envirponmental services they can/do provide
  • 5.
  • 6.
  • 7. Impacts of land use change - Kapingazi The impact of land use change on water yield is generally low. Scenario Water yield (mm) Surface runoff % Base flow % Base case 846 86 14 Convert tea farms to annual crops 936 84 16 Convert coffee farms to annual crops 864 88 12 Double built up areas 860 86 14
  • 8. Effectiveness of landuse practices on hydrology Quantity: Soil and water conservation practices have little effect on water yield Quality: Significant effect on sediment yield Sasumua Landuse practices Sediment yield reduction (%) Reduction in surface runoff (%) Increase in base flow (%) Contour farming with trees 49 16 8 Grass filter strips 38 - - Grass waterway 41 - - Terraces 85 22 10
  • 9.
  • 10. Pay-back period based on constant cost of allum alone
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20. Free and prior informed consent Efficiency Fairness Balancing act is needed
  • 21.  
  • 22.
  • 23.  
  • 24. Initial interest Effective increase in ES Signed contract External investors and regulators: learning curve Learning curve for local stakeholders (actors) of land use change Smooth implemen- tation? Efficient + Fair reward systems require a two-way learning curve Negotiations
  • 25.
  • 26. Thank You Sara Namirembe ( [email_address] ) PRESA World Agroforestry Centre http://www.worldagroforestrycentre.org/sea/Networks/RUPES http://presa.worldagroforestry.org

Notas do Editor

  1. In a landscape, the community deals with three other main groups in five major ways (see arrows in Fig. 2): Private sector entities who buy marketable commodities for further processing and trade and/or use the landscape resources for added value (e.g. through hydropower or the sale of drinking water), Governments imposing rules on the private sector and their interaction with ES Government agencies, sometimes acting to represent international conventions, regulating what the community is allowed to do, how it has to organize its administration and how it can be part of development processes prioritized at higher levels, Consumers who buy local goods and may be interested in supporting ES as well, Consumers elsewhere in the world who opt for competitively priced goods, but also have concerns about the status of poverty indicators, natural resources and human rights in the area
  2. In a landscape, the community deals with three other main groups in five major ways (see arrows in Fig. 2): Private sector entities who buy marketable commodities for further processing and trade and/or use the landscape resources for added value (e.g. through hydropower or the sale of drinking water), Governments imposing rules on the private sector and their interaction with ES Government agencies, sometimes acting to represent international conventions, regulating what the community is allowed to do, how it has to organize its administration and how it can be part of development processes prioritized at higher levels, Consumers who buy local goods and may be interested in supporting ES as well, Consumers elsewhere in the world who opt for competitively priced goods, but also have concerns about the status of poverty indicators, natural resources and human rights in the area