Digital delivery models are impacting traditional businesses. Driven by consumer demand for convenience and new consumption models, including subscriptions, enterprises are moving to Digital Business offerings and finding huge upside from predictable revenue streams built around long-term customer relationships. But this shift is not easy. Companies at the beginning of the journey want to know - what are those challenges? And what are the strategies that lead to success?
Bajaj Allianz Life Insurance Company - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
4 Key Challenges in the Shift to Digital Recurring Revenue
1. Confidential and Proprietary Information. Do not distribute beyond intended audience.
Four Key Challenges in the Shift
to Digital Recurring Revenue
W e b i n a r w i t h Z u o r a a n d S a u g a t u c k T e c h n o l o g y
2. Brian Bell
Chief Marketing Officer
Mike West
Research Fellow
Joe Andrews
Sr. Director, Marketing
Moderator Featured Guests:
3. Agenda
1. Context – the enterprise business shift
2. Research – the four key challenges in making the shift
3. Relationship Business Management – a system of
innovation
4. Learning from companies who have made the shift
4. Slide 4 − Zuora Confidential, not for distribution beyond
intended recipient
4
Disruption of Everything.
CODE: VIP50
5. The Subscription Economy takes the changes wrought by the SaaS
model and applies them to companies in every industry.
We call this the Subscription Economy
Monetize RelationshipsShip Products
The Shift To Models Built on Relationships
6. CONSUMER BUSINESS
4 out of 5 businesses believe their customers are switching to
new consumption models.“
PearsonZendesk HPDellConnect America KaplanSPH
Reed
Elsevier
Intuit American ExpressNCRTripAdvisor GoodMouthTouring Car Suisse
ServCorpQualcomm InformaticaDocuSignCarfax MindBodyFinancial Times
Customer Preferences Have Changed
7. High Tech Cloud Infrastructure
Internet Of Things Education Healthcare
SaaS
Communications
Creating Business Model Innovation In Every Industry
51% of companies have changed or are in the process of
changing the way they deliver goods and services“ ”
Media
8. Copyright 2014 ǀ Saugatuck Technology, Inc. ǀ All Rights Reserved www.saugatucktechnology.com
Mike West
Research Fellow
Saugatuck Technology
9. Retooling for the Digital Economy
and Recurring Revenue
9
The Challenge:
How can you
make these
changes happen
cost-effectively
and with the least
disruption?
10. The digital imperative
Presents new technology challenges…
recurring revenue and monetization
new business partners
new systems
integration
10
11. recurring revenue and monetization
11
“Used to be 90 percent
broadcast, but today it’s over
50 percent digital products. It’s
everything from pure ad
revenue to content reach on
online platforms we
monetize, but the bigger piece
is in the shift to digital
downloads and other ways of
distributing video-on-demand
in a combination of a la carte
and subscription….”
12. Copyright 2013 ǀ Saugatuck Technology, Inc. ǀ All Rights Reserved www.saugatucktechnology.comPage: 12
new business partners
“We’ve been happy with ability to
deploy faster, increase the speed at
which we are moving, by partnering
and adopting an agile approach…
…especially with a complex solution
involving multiple partners. We are
dependent on our infrastructure
provider, our billing provider, on our
Cloud platform for scaling to meet
demand and need.”
13. new systems
13
“Need to make sure you’re
not just bringing the old stuff
and adding a few things…”
“New systems are
necessary, whether billing or
revenue recognition or go-to-
market, catalog, or social
channels in customer care.
New tools mostly but
sometimes just the same tool
implemented differently.”
14. integration
14
“We have a need to hook
ERP environments into
third party APIs, doing
handshakes for
exchanging sales keys -- If
it’s not automated, you
can’t scale -- for
monitoring customer
experience and for
monetization performance”
15. summary
Meeting the four key challenges:
one recurring revenue and monetization
two new business partners
three new systems
four integration
15
How can you make these changes happen cost-effectively
and with the least disruption?
16. closing
16
“We are always surprised where
innovation comes from. As we
deploy new capabilities in the Cloud
to make things easier for the
business, it lets the business focus
on innovation.”
17. summary
Meeting the four key challenges:
one recurring revenue and monetization
two new business partners
three new systems
four integration
17
How can you make these changes happen cost-effectively
and with the least disruption?
18. Innovation Requires Agility, But…
As An Enterprise, You Have A Unique Challenge
A system that is not sufficiently flexible to meet changing business
demands is an anchor, not a sail, holding the business back, not driving it
forward.
“
You have invested heavily in your
ERP application
But your ERP system doesn’t help you
innovate in an agile fashion
19. BUY NOW SUBSCRIBE
Recurring Revenue
(Long-term, adoption, loyalty)
New approach
to growth
Sell One-Time
Units
Fixed, SKU Based
One-Time Transactions
Backwards Looking Metrics
Flexible, Plan Based
(Editions, Bundles, Usage)
Recurring
(upgrades, add-ons, renewals)
Forward Looking
(ARR, MRR, Churn, Renew
als)
You require a completely different approach
New approach
to pricing
New approach
to commerce
New approach
to finance
20. Innovation
in Pricing
& Packaging
Complexity in
Commerce
& Order
Management
Complexity in Billing
Complexity
in Payments
Complexity
in how you
Measure
Innovation in one area of your business causes
complexity in other areas
Without a system that can manage this complexity, business
model innovation is hard
1
2
3
4
5
21. Confidential and Proprietary Information. Do not distribute beyond intended audience.
You Need
Relationship Business Management
22. RBM Is Your
System of
Innovation
ERP Is Your
System Of
Record
Built For Monetizing
Products
Built For Monetizing
Relationships
24. It integrates with your existing enterprise
ecosystem
Systems For
Customer Engagement
Systems Of
Record
Relationship Business
Management
CRM
Website
ERP
Financial Applications
Systems Of
Innovation
25. “NCR rivals Paypal as Square’s scariest competitor.”
The Business Model Shift:
• NCR Silver represents NCR’s first foray into selling
POS solutions to individuals and small businesses
• NCR Silver is NCR’s first iPad base POS solution
The Challenge:
• Needed the ability to launch flexible pricing models
and iterate rapidly to compete in a crowded market
of over 300 providers like Square
• Needed to be launch in 2 months
The Solution:
NCR chooses Zuora as the commerce, billing and finance management platform for NCR Silver.
The project is delivered in 61 days, with web self service sign ups, integration to Salesforce, and summary
journal entry updates to Oracle. NCR uses Zuora to rapidly launch new pricing models, automate high volume
billing and collections, and manage subscription lifecycle events.
“NCR missed the transition to digital,” said CEO Bill Nuti, “and it hasn’t been engaged with small business owners
since 1971. But NCR wants a new relationship with small and medium businesses, and today it’s about to start. And
it’s going to do it via Apple’s iPad. Today marks the launch of NCR’s first new division aimed at small businesses in
50 years.”
26. “Touring Club Suisse replaces AS400 with Salesforce ,Zuora.”
Diginomica
The Business Model Shift:
• A business that counts half the population of
Switzerland as its customers needed to stay
relevant in an increasingly competitive market
• TCS needed a way to engage with a
younger, digitally engaged demographic
The Challenge:
• TCS had been running its operations on a AS/400
computer for over 20 years
• Making changes was an expensive and time
consuming process
• TCS was unable to offer anything other than annual
memberships on its current platform
The Solution:
TCS rebuilt it’s IT infrastructure with 6 cloud native apps. At the heart of this new infrastructure are Salesforce
and Zuora. Salesforce is the core CRM environment used by sales agents in the call center, and Zuora is used for
subscription management, billing for almost 3 million subscriptions. Zuora is also integrated with SAP for
consolidated financial management.
“Easy pricing, easy billing is absolutely key. We have built an environment now where the system adds a lot of
value …With Zuora we do get that kind of flexibility where we manage the whole payment cycle [separately] from
managing the subscription.” Ernest Gmunder, CIO, TCS
27. “Acxiom’s Audience Operating System could reinvent data driven
marketing.”
The Business Model Shift:
• AOS is Acxiom’s most important business initiative
in 30 years
• The launch of AOS represents a pivot from a low
volume of large 7 figure, high touch perpetual
license B2B sales to a high volume of B2Any
subscription sales in new markets.
The Challenge:
• Needed flexible subscription based pricing and
packaging for the success of AOS
• Needed seamless integration to Salesforce for front
office and PeopleSoft for back office
• Needed to be live in less than 6 months
The Solution:
Acxiom chooses Zuora as the commerce, billing and subscription management platform for AOS.
The project is delivered in 159 days, with integration to Salesforce, PeopleSoft. Acxiom uses Zuora to
experiment with new pricing models, and sign on new AOS clients that represent new markets and the next
phase of growth for the company.
“We are at an inflection point and starting the next chapter in our journey,” said Acxiom CEO Scott Howe. “We are a
new company. Over the past two years we have worked to build a better business and to drive innovation. While it’s
early, we are pleased with our launch of the Acxiom Audience Operating System and the resulting customer
reaction and support.”
I’d like to begin by giving you a little insight into the trends we are seeing the market that influence how Zuora thinks about the challenges faced by businesses similar to yours, and how we have designed a solution to solve for those challenges.
This shift is creating a new kind of economic force that we call the Subscription Economy, because when your customers consume your services over an extended period of time and on a recurring basis, they are in effect subscribing to your products services. As a subscription business, you establish a long term recurring relationship with your customers, and the ability to monetize this relationship forms the foundation of your business model.
A study conducted by the economic intelligence unit reveals that 4 out of 5 businesses believe their customers are switching to new consumption models. We see these new models of consumption every day, across both B2C and B2C businesses that we work with
This shift to new models of consumption may have started with SaaS ,media and telco companies, but today, this shift has gained momentum across all industries. SaaS, high Tech Cloud, education, healthcare, media, telco and even devices. In fact businesses are increasingly changing their business models to cater to a demand from consumers to consume services via a subscription service. A recent study by the EIU found that 51% of all businesses are in the process of changing the way they deliver goods and services.
Digital Business CFO observed that the impact of digital offerings has completely transformed how the media company views its decision-making on content production projects“The way we make decisions has changed. We rely on data, and you’d better convince me there is a monetization model behind it – and reach – across any channel and devices, including wearable, YouTube, games. The challenge with media in general is still the same – how do we produce as cheaply as possible? But now we can’t take out any more cost, so show us how to grow revenue by driving the reach.” “Used to be 90 percent broadcast, but today it’s over 50 percent digital products. It’s everything from pure ad revenue to content reach on online platforms we monetize, but the bigger piece is in the shift to digital downloads and other ways of distributing video-on-demand in a combination of a la carte and subscription. On channels like Hulu, Netflix, Amazon, Apple iTunes; and we are now developing content especially for digital distributors, different formats and offshoots of our core content.”
Vice President of Product Management at the major vendor in Digital Transformation recalls: “We’ve been happy with ability to deploy faster, increase the speed at which we are moving, by partnering and adopting an agile approach, keeping projects smaller not gigantic. Partnering with people who really know what they are doing.“Clearly there are new service delivery challenges, especially being a provider and having to meet SLAs, and especially with a complex solution involving multiple partners. We are dependent on our infrastructure provider, our billing provider, on our Cloud platform for scaling to meet demand and need.”
“One challenge is making sure you don’t bring non-digital baggage with you. We have a lot of policies based on a different model, how you do refunds, for example, and its just different in a digital world. Need to make sure you’re not just bringing the old stuff and adding a few things, because that introduces a lot of complexity, not beneficial to customer or to you…”VP of Product Management at a well-known vendor, talking about managing both on-premises and Cloud solutions in a business in the midst of transformation, “New systems are necessary, whether billing or revenue recognition or go-to-market, catalog, or social channels in customer care. New tools mostly but sometimes just the same tool implemented differently.”
Director of Technology Planning and Strategy at the very large enterprise in transformation noted, “We have a need to hook ERP environments into third party APIs, doing handshakes for exchanging sales keys. If it’s not automated, you can’t scale. We are leveraging new technologies for monitoring customer experience and for monetization performance. And it’s in real-time production mode today, as opposed to wrap it and mail it, the way it used to be.”
Director of Technology Planning and Strategy at an established large enterprise said about the transformation to Digital Business, “We are always surprised where innovation comes from. As we deploy new capabilities in the Cloud to make things easier for the business, it lets the business focus on innovation.”
But if you are a large established enterprise, you are faced with a unique challengeYour ERP system forms the backbone of your IT infrastructure. Gartner reports that 80% of IT budget is spent on ERP maintenance. At any time, on average, 70% of all ERP projects are at risk. But none of the of ERP systems in the market were designed to manage recurring revenue processes out of the box. They don’t support agile business model innovation.
A business built on recurring relationships requires a complete new approach. A new approach to revenue growth.Instead of growing by shipping more units, your growth model is based maximizing recurring revenueA new approach to pricing. Instead of fixed, SKU based pricing models, your pricing needs to be flexible, plan based pricing.A new approach to commerce. Instead of acommerce that consists of a discrete one time transactions, your commerce model is now a series of recurring interlinked transactionsA new approach to finance. Instead of financial metrics that are backwards looking and focused on past performance, your financial model is heavily reliant on forward looking metrics that give insight into future recurring revenue.It requires your to innovate in a number of areas of your business
Innovation in one area of your business causes complexity in other areasBusiness model innovation typically begins with pricing and packaging. When you change your pricing and packaging, it leads to complexity in commerce and order management. Different order types such as renewals, upgrades, downgrades lead to complexity in billing and payments. And this in turn leads to complexity in how your measure the health of your business. And often, based on how your business is performing, you might make adjustments to how you price your services and the cycle continues. Without a system to manage this complexity in a holistic way, business model innovation is hard.
You need Relationship Business Management
Your ERP system that was built to monetize products is great as a system of record. Relationship Business Management or RBM is a system that supports all the necessary elements of business model innovation that are required for monetizing relationships. let me take a few minutes to explain:
- Relationship business management delivers a plan based pricing catalog designed to monetize recurring relationships so that your customers can buy in their own way. - RBM delivers a billing engine capable of automating billing and payment transactions at scale. - RBM systems also includes a finance engine capable of understanding the financial impacts of recurring revenue - A relationship business management system is built on a subscription data model that is capable of delivering the metrics you need to measure long term recurring relationships.When you choose a relationship business management solution to run a business that is based on long term recurring customer relationships, you get the benefits of a system that understands the complexity of relationship commerce, recurring billing and payments, and recurring revenue management. Other systems focus narrowly on a few of these areas, but as you can see from this table, Zuora is the only company that is taking a holistic approach to helping business that want to monetize long term relationships with customers.
And finally,A relationship business management system MUST integrate with your existing enterprise ecosystemYou already have systems for customer engagement like your CRM systems and your websiteAnd you already have systems for back office operations like your ERP system and your financial applications.A relationship business management system MUST integrate with these core pieces of your enterprise IT infrastructure.
NCR is a $6Bn business that was losing market share in the small business sector to Square. NCR needed to launch an innovative new service, in a short span of time, with flexible pricing models and an easy, intuitive customer experience to complete with Square. This was NCRs most strategic project in 2012. NCR chose Zuora’s relationship business management system to manage commerce, billing and finance for NCR Silver. The service was launched in 2 months with self service sign up, integration to salesforce for customer care and assisted sales, and journal entry updates to Oracle.
TCS is the AAA of Switzerland and counts half the population of Switzerland amongst its customer base. TCS had been running its operations on a AS/400 mainframe computer for over 20 years. And this system was preventing TCS from remaining relevant in a market where new competitors were cropping up, offering services that in the past were only offered by TCS. In addition, TCS was losing the younger, more digitally engaged demographic. TCS rebuilt it’s IT infrastructure with 6 cloud native apps, and at the heart of this infrastructure are Salesforce and Zuora. Zuora is used for subscription management, billing, payments for almost 3 million subscriptions. Zuora is also integrated with SAP for consolidated financial management.Challenge they had was competition coming into market offering things they used to exclusively offer e.g roadside assistance - they were also losing market share among younger demographic who had preference for digital world - you had to go in person to post office and pay
Partnered with Zuora when they launched AOS"Audience Operating System" - rolled out a year ago ad Adweek in New York - revenue will ramp up in 3-5 years - ”true subscription product”Axciom profile / Core offerings - marketing services and data targeting F100 clients (60%) - "MS&D" - IT outsourcing group (20%) - Email marketing (10%) - ad hoc services