Ohio supreme court justices (campaign contributions)

Thomas J. Moyer Profile -- Money in Politics Page 1 of 2

Robert Cupp

Judith Lanzinger Thomas J. Moyer
Thomas Moyer
Supreme Court Justice
Maureen O'Connor
Republican
Terrence
O'Donnell Amount Raised 11/15/03-11/30/04:
$1,509,417
Paul Pfeifer

Evelyn Stratton

All Profiles
Average Individual Contribution: $262.26
Individual Contributions less than $200: 2,103
Individual Contributions $200 or more: 1,318

Top Organizational Contributors to Thomas Moyer
Rank Organization Economic Sector Amount

1 Cincinnati Financial Insurance $29,045

2 Vorys, Sater, Seymour & Pease Lawyers $23,070

3 Jones Day Lawyers $21,525

4 Nationwide Insurance $21,237

5 FirstEnergy Energy & Resources $20,550

6 Janik & Dorman Lawyers $19,000

7 American Financial Group Insurance $16,000

8 Baker & Hostetler Lawyers $15,800

9 Porter, Wright, Morris & Arthur Lawyers $14,530

10 Freund, Freeze & Arnold Lawyers $11,540

Organizational totals include PACs and employees.
Totals include monetary and in-kind contributions.

Top Economic Sectors to Thomas Moyer
Rank Economic Sector Amount

1 Lawyers $462,516

2 Insurance $221,241

3 Health $194,234

4 Ideological $109,320

5 Manufacturing $91,644

EXHIBIT
III

http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/moyer.html 12/13/2009

Thomas J. Moyer Profile -- Money in Politics Page 2 of 2

6 Energy & Natural Resources $63,370

7 Finance $59,098

8 Real Estate $42,167

9 Construction $30,375

10 Food & Beverage $26,075


Amount from Republican Party Committees: $92,912
Amount from Candidate Committees: $11,308
Amount from Leadership PACs: $5,000

Top Political Party & Candidate Committee Contributions to Thomas
Moyer
Rank Party or Candidate Committee Amount

1 Ohio Republican Party $60,037

2 Hamilton County Republican Party $15,000

3 Summit County GOP Judicial Committee $10,000

4 Cuyahoga County Republican Party Judicial Fund $7,500

5 Friends of Governor Taft $5,500

6 America’s Majority Trust/Rob Portman Leadership PAC $5,000

7 Oxley for Congress $1,000

Pryce for Congress $1,000

Hobson for Congress $1,000


http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/moyer.html 12/13/2009

Maureen O'Connor Profile -- Money in Politics Page 1 of 2

Robert Cupp

Judith Lanzinger Maureen O'Connor
Thomas Moyer
Maureen O'Connor
Republican
Terrence
$1,736,852
Paul Pfeifer

Evelyn Stratton

All Profiles

Top Organizational Contributors to Maureen O'Connor


2 American Financial Group Lawyers $20,900

3 Timken Manufacturing $13,350



6 Boich Companies Energy & Resources $11,000



9 Bricker & Eckler Lawyers $9,400

10 Fifth Third Bank Finance $8,750


Top Economic Sectors to Maureen O'Connor

1 Health $331,830



4 Lawyers $178,121


http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/oconnor.html 12/13/2009

Maureen O'Connor Profile -- Money in Politics Page 2 of 2

6 Finance $74,455



9 Transportation $53,040




Top Political Party & Candidate Committee Contributions to Maureen
O'Connor

1 Ohio Republican Party Judicial Account $142,000



4 Taft for Governor $5,500

Montgomery Campaign Committee $5,500

Citizens for Jim Petro $5,500

5 Ohio House Republican Campaign Committee $5,000

6 Ohio’s 17 Star PAC/Mike DeWine Leadership PAC $3,000

7 Hamilton County Republican Party Judicial Campaign Fund $2,500

Citizens for Householder $2,500

8 Buckeye PAC/George Voinovich Leadership PAC $2,000

Friends of Carney, Jr. $2,000

Committee to Elect Lynn R. Wachtmann $2,000


http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/oconnor.html 12/13/2009

Evelyn Stratton Profile -- Money in Politics Page 1 of 2

Robert Cupp

Judith Lanzinger Evelyn Stratton
Thomas Moyer
Maureen O'Connor
Republican
Terrence
$1,899,937
Paul Pfeifer

Evelyn Stratton

All Profiles

Top Organizational Contributors to Evelyn Stratton




4 State Farm Insurance Insurance $16,795




8 Norton Manufacturing Manufacturing $13,200

9 Cintas Manufacturing $12,100

10 Frost Brown Todd Lawyers $12,000


Top Economic Sectors to Evelyn Stratton

1 Health $392,229

2 Lawyers $313,430




http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/stratton.html 12/13/2009

Evelyn Stratton Profile -- Money in Politics Page 2 of 2


7 Finance $82,491






Top Political Party & Candidate Committee Contributions to Evelyn
Stratton

1 Ohio Republican Party Judicial Account $87,000



4 Ohio Republican State & Central Executive Committee $22,971

5 Montgomery Campaign Committee $5,500

Committee to Elect Lynn R. Wachtmann $5,500

Pryce for Congress $5,500

Taft for Governor $5,500

Citizens for Jim Petro $5,500

6 Columbiana County Republican Party $4,450

7 Buckeye PAC/George Voinovich Leadership PAC $2,200

8 Wayne County Republican Party $2,000

Citizens for Geoffrey C. Smith $2,000

America’s Majority Trust/Rob Portman Leadership PAC $2,000

Ohio’s 17 Star PAC/Mike DeWine Leadership PAC $2,000


http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/stratton.html 12/13/2009

Robert Cupp Profile -- Money in Politics Page 1 of 2

Robert Cupp

Judith Lanzinger
Robert Cupp
Thomas Moyer
Maureen O'Connor
Republican
Terrence
O'Donnell
Amount Raised 1/1/06-12/31/06: $999,150
Paul Pfeifer

Evelyn Stratton

All Profiles
Individual Contributions $200 or more: 854

Top Organizational Contributors to Robert Cupp
Economic
Rank Organization Amount
Sector

1 Cincinnati Financial Corporation Insurance $42,188




5 Calfee, Halter & Griswold Lawyers $12,000

6 Nationwide Insurance Insurance $11,155

Energy & Natural
7 FirstEnergy $10,367
Resources


9 Motorists Mutual Insurance Insurance $9,500

10 John J. & Thomas R. Schiff Co. Insurance $8,500


Top Economic Sectors to Robert Cupp


2 Lawyers $187,778

3 Health $137,418


http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/cupp.html 12/13/2009

Robert Cupp Profile -- Money in Politics Page 2 of 2



7 Finance $40,215






Top Political Party & Candidate Committee Contributions to Robert Cupp


2 Hobson for Congress $5,500


4 Citizens for Jim Petro $4,000

5 Columbiana County Republican Central Committee $1,150

6 Lake County Republican Party $1,084

7 Committee to Elect Bill Harris $1,000

Citizens for Austria $1,000

Citizens for Gillmor $1,000


http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/cupp.html 12/13/2009

Judith Lanzinger Profile -- Money in Politics Page 1 of 2

Robert Cupp

Judith Lanzinger Judith Lanzinger
Thomas Moyer
Maureen O'Connor
Republican
Terrence
$1,646,166
Paul Pfeifer

Evelyn Stratton

All Profiles

Top Organizational Contributors to Judith Lanzinger
Economic
Rank Organization Amount
Sector



Energy &
3 FirstEnergy $20,550
Resources


5 Fifth Third Bank Finance $17,400

6 Ohio National Financial Services Insurance $13,600


8 State Farm Insurance Insurance $11,427

9 RPM International Manufacturing $11,000

10 Procter & Gamble Manufacturing $10,850


Top Economic Sectors to Judith Lanzinger


2 Lawyers $271,126


4 Health $262,647

http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/lanzinger.html 12/14/2009

Judith Lanzinger Profile -- Money in Politics Page 2 of 2



7 Finance $65,758






Top Political Party & Candidate Committee Contributions to Judith
Lanzinger


2 Columbiana County GOP Judicial Account $17,723


4 Cuyahoga County Republican Party Judicial Fund $7,500


6 America’s Majority Trust/Rob Portman Leadership PAC $5,000

7 Oxley for Congress $3,000

8 Ohio’s 17 Star PAC/Mike DeWine Leadership PAC $2,500

Husted for Ohio $2,500

9 Care PAC/Ralph Regula Leadership PAC $2,000


http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/lanzinger.html 12/14/2009

Terrence O'Donnell Profile -- Money in Politics Page 1 of 2

Robert Cupp Terrence O'Donnell
Judith Lanzinger
Thomas Moyer
Republican
Maureen O'Connor
O’Donnell ran for Supreme Court Justice in
Terrence three elections: 2000, 2004, and 2006
O'Donnell

Paul Pfeifer
Amount raised:

Evelyn Stratton 11/16/99-11/11/00: $993,739
11/15/03-11/30/04: $1,595,986
All Profiles 1/06/06-12/31/06: $1,031,057

Total: $3,620,782


Top Organizational Contributors to Terrence O'Donnell







7 Calfee, Halter & Griswold Lawyers $33,600

8 Squire, Sanders & Dempsey Lawyers $30,600

9 Baker & Hostetler Lawyers $30,475

10 Procter & Gamble Manufacturing $29,000


Top Economic Sectors to Terrence O'Donnell

1 Lawyers $783,562


http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/odonnell.html 12/13/2009

Terrence O'Donnell Profile -- Money in Politics Page 2 of 2


4 Health $382,062


6 Finance $203,353







Top Political Party & Candidate Committee Contributions to Terrence
O'Donnell



3 Columbiana County GOP Judicial Account $17,723

4 Summit County GOP Judicial Committee $10,000

5 Citizens for Jim Petro $7,500

Cuyahoga County Republican Party Judicial Fund $7,500

6 Columbiana County Republican Party $7,300



Montgomery County Republican Party $5,000

America’s Majority Trust/Rob Portman Leadership PAC $5,000

WrightPAC/J. Craig Wright Leadership PAC $5,000

9 Butler County Republican Party $4,000

10 Ohio Self Insurers Association $2,000

Oxley for Congress $2,000


http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/odonnell.html 12/13/2009

Judicial Profiles -- Money in Politics Page 1 of 2

Follow the Money
Ohio Citizen Action today released overviews of campaign contributions to
members of the Ohio Supreme Court during the last four election cycles (2000-
2006). Chief Justice Thomas J. Moyer received $1.5 million (Election 2000),
Justice Robert Cupp nearly $1 million (Election 2006), Judith Lanzinger $1.6
million, Maureen O’Connor $1.7 million (Election 2002), Paul E. Pfeifer nearly
$80,000 (Election 2004), and Evelyn Lundberg Stratton $1.9 million (Election
2002). In this same time period, Justice Terrence O’Donnell ran for the Supreme
Court three times. In 2000, he raised nearly $1 million in an unsuccessful attempt
to defeat Alice Robie Resnick. O’Donnell was appointed by Governor Bob Taft to
Robert Cupp fill Deborah Cook’s seat in 2003, when she left the Ohio Supreme Court for the Terrence O'Donnell
federal bench. He raised $1.6 million to retain this seat in Election 2004.
O’Donnell’s seat was up for election again in 2006 and he raised an additional $1
million. In these three elections, O’Donnell raised a combined total of $3,620,782.
These campaign finance profiles include an overview of types of donors, large
contributors, and money from the political parties. The insurance industry played
a prominent role in Supreme Court elections, contributing a total of $1,781,568 to
six of the seven Justices. Insurance company Cincinnati Financial Corporation
($312,723) was the top donor to six members of the Ohio Supreme Court: Cupp,
Lanzinger, Moyer, O’Connor, O’Donnell, and Stratton. In sharp contrast, Pfeifer
did not receive any contributions from the insurance industry.

Judith Lanzinger Paul Pfeifer
Methodology

The Money in Politics Project of the Ohio Citizen Action Education Fund analyzed
contributions to the Chief Justice and the Justices of the Ohio Supreme Court from
Elections 2000, 2002, 2004, and 2006. Totals include contributions from political
action committees (PACs), labor unions, and individuals.

The database is based on the filings of candidates for the Ohio Supreme Court,
available in computerized form from the Ohio Secretary of State. These filings
were submitted electronically by the candidate committees to the Secretary of
State and are available on-line at www.sos.state.oh.us. Candidates for the Ohio
Supreme Court are permitted to raise money only during the time period that they
Thomas Moyer Evelyn Stratton
are on the ballot. The Justices were given an opportunity to review their campaign
finance profiles. Overviews:

To identify the employers of contributors, the Ohio Citizen Action  Attorney donors
Education Fund used the following:  Insurance donors
 Manufacturing
1. Databases of architects, doctors, dentists, funeral directors, and certified donors
public accountants registered to do business in Ohio from the Ohio Division  Union donors
of Administrative Services,
2. A database from the Ohio Supreme Court of attorneys in Ohio
3. A list of lobbyists in Ohio from the Joint Legislative Ethics Committee,
4. A list of contributors to political action committees in Ohio,
Maureen O'Connor
5. Database of physicians provided by the American Medical Association,
6. Database of attorneys provided by Martindale-Hubble.
7. Search engines like Google.

For each candidate the total amount in this campaign finance
database includes the following:

 Contributions received

http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/profiles.html 12/13/2009

Judicial Profiles -- Money in Politics Page 2 of 2

 Contributions received at a social or fundraising event
 In-kind contributions received
 Contributions the candidate gave to his own campaign

The campaign finance profiles do not include Statement of Other Income, which
includes interest, refunds, returns, and other non-contribution income.

http://www.ohiocitizen.org/money/judicial/profiles/profiles.html 12/13/2009

LexisNexis® Martindale-Hubbell® Page 1 of 3

Print Close Window
Frost Brown Todd LLC

Frost Brown Todd LLC
(Frost & Jacobs LLP) (Brown, Todd & Heyburn PLLC)
Cincinnati, Ohio Office
View all offices

2200 PNC Center, 201 East Fifth Street
Cincinnati, Ohio 45202-4182
(Hamilton Co.)

Telephone: 513-651-6800
Telecopier: 513-651-6981
http://www.frostbrowntodd.com

Send Email View Website

Bar Register Practice Areas

About this office:
With offices throughout 4 mid-western states, Frost Brown Todd is one of the largest law firms in the
country and represents many of America's best-known companies. With over 370 lawyers spanning 60+
integrated practice areas and industry groups, the firm leverages technical and legal knowledge with
industry expertise to serve a diverse client base, ranging from global multinationals to small,
entrepreneurial companies.

79 Frost Brown Todd lawyers are named to Woodward-White's The Best Lawyers in America (2007).

Frost Brown Todd is listed as a "Go-to" law firm in Corporate Counsel's Directory of In-House Law
Departments at the Top 500 Companies (2005, 2006).

The BTI Consulting Group has named Frost Brown Todd one of only 40 law firms "consistently
introducing innovative changes into the legal services marketplace" in the Market Front Runners report
(2006).

Frost Brown Todd has strategic alliances with Wahlert Rechtsanwälte located in Stuttgart, Germany and
is a member of Multilaw and the US Law Firm Group.

Statement of Practice Summary:
Alternative Dispute Resolution, Bankruptcy and Reorganization, Business Acquisitions, Business and
Corporate, Commercial Finance, Commercial Litigation, Commercial/Real Estate, Construction,
Copyright, Corporate Responsibility and Defense, Employee Benefits, Energy and Natural Resources,

http://www.martindale.com/print.aspx 12/13/2009

LexisNexis® Martindale-Hubbell® Page 2 of 3

Entrepreneurial, Environmental, Equine, Estate Planning and Administration, Financial Institutions, Fire
and Explosion, Health Care, Immigration, International, Intellectual Property, International Business,
Internet and Electronic Commerce, Labor and Employment Law, Litigation, Media, Mold and Water
Intrusion, Multi-District Litigation, Patent Litigation, Personal Planning and Family Business, Privacy and
Information Security, Product Liability, Public Finance, Securities, Tax, Tort & Insurance Law,
Trademark, Venture Capital, General Trial Practice in all State and Federal Courts.

For additional business information about this firm, click here to view this firm's ranking
in key ALM lists and surveys.

Documents by Lawyers at this office

A CAN-SPAM Refresher
Jill P. Meyer, Kevin T. Shook, November 3, 2009
After six years of litigation, the impetus behind the federal CAN-SPAM Act is now more relevant than
ever. The next big splash in spamming appears to have arrived in the form of social media. Twitter
recently announced a "report as spam" button on user profiles geared toward combating...

Endorse This! New FTC Guidelines on Endorsements and Testimonials
Patricia Foster, November 3, 2009
In an effort to stem false or misleading endorsements, the Federal Trade Commission ("FTC") revised its
Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising ("Guides") on October 5,
2009. When the Guides were last updated in 1980, the internet was in its...

Better Pleading of Voidable Transfer Claims is Coming
Kimberly K. Mauer, September 23, 2009
The United States Supreme Court raised the standard for pleading complaints in Bell Atl. Corp. v.
Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (2007). Previously, the rule was that a complaint would not be dismissed for
failure to state a claim unless "it appears without a doubt that the plaintiff can prove no set...

View more

Year Established: 1919

Representative Clients:
AAF-McQuay Inc.; AEGON USA Realty Advisors, Inc.; AIG Insurance Group; AK Steel Corporation;
Anthem Health Plans; Broadwing Inc.; Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corporation; Catholic Healthcare
Partners; Central Bank & Trust Company; Chapelthorp plc; Chiquita Brands International; ClubLink
Corporation; Convergys Corporation; Coolmore Castlehyde and Associated Stud Farms; Federated
Department Stores, Inc.; Firstar/U.S. Bank; Taco Bell Franchise Management Advisory Council
(FRANMAC); General Electric Company; ICI Paints World Group; Jewish Hospital HealthCare Services,
Inc.; LensCrafters, Inc.; Lexis-Nexis; LG&E Energy Corp.; Liberty Mutual Insurance Group; Lightyear
Communications, Inc.; MidAmerica Bancorp; New Horizon Resources, Inc.; NTS Development Company;
OneBeacon Insurance Group; Progressive Insurance Company; PNC Bank Corp. and PNC Bank; Res-
Care, Inc.; The Rouse Companies, LLC; Services Net Incorporated; Smithkline Beecham Clinical Lab;
Terex Corporation; Turner Construction Company; Unified Foodservice Purchasing Co-op, LLC; United
Parcel Service; Vincor International Inc.; Waste Management of North America; Western Southern Life
Insurance Company.

Languages: Afrikaans, Chinese, Cyrillic Script, Dutch, English, Flemish, French, German, Japanese.

Law Firm Affiliations: UNITED STATES LAW FIRM GROUP

The Firm has attorneys licensed to practice in numerous states, including but not limited to Washington,
D.C.

Return to the Frost Brown Todd LLC Firm Overview

Source: Martindale-Hubbell Print Close Window

http://www.martindale.com/print.aspx 12/13/2009

Morrison Knudsen - Note Cancellation And Restructuring Agreement Page 1 of 8

Sign in | Shopping Cart
Looking for an agreement? Search from over 500,000 agreements now: Search
advanced search
Home About Us FAQ Contact Us

Your Account
 sign in
 shopping cart

Search by Company
Go

enter company

Search by Law Firm
select a law firm Jones Day

enter a search term

Go

Search by Governing Law
select a US state/country Alabama

enter a search term

Go

Search by Industry
Go

enter industry

Recent Deals

http://www.techagreements.com/agreement-preview.aspx?search=lawfirm&lawFirmID=... 12/13/2009

Morrison Knudsen - Note Cancellation And Restructuring Agreement Page 2 of 8

 Nautilus, Inc. Announces Entry Into Agreements For Sale of A Portion of Commercial Assets

 U.s. Bankruptcy Court Confirms Pilgrim's Pride Plan of Reorganization; Company Expects To
Emerge BY End of December

 Medicinova And Avigen Announce Stockholder Election Deadline And Update To Estimated
Merger Consideration

 BPW Acquisition Corp. And The Talbots, Inc. Sign Definitive Merger Agreement

 Diedrich Coffee Enters Into Agreement With Green Mountain Coffee Roasters To Acquire
Diedrich Coffee For $35.00 Cash Per Share

More news here

See Directories For:
 Employment Agreements
 Real Estate Agreements

Ask our Consultants
Send us a request via email for a specific type of Agreement and our experts will do the search for you
Browse by Company > Liberty Mutual Insurance Company > Agreement Preview
Agreement#: AG-505319
Pages: 24 pages
Format: MS Word Compatible
Price: $35.00
Click the "Add To Cart" button to download the full agreeement.
Add To Cart

See other similar agreements:

 All Restructuring Agreement by Industry Agreements

Note Cancellation And Restructuring Agreement
Effective Date: June 20, 1996
Parties: Morrison Knudsen
Sectors: Materials and Construction
Law Firms: Jones Day
Governing Law: Delaware


Acorn Products - Employment Agreement Page 1 of 6

advanced search

Your Account
 sign in
 shopping cart

Search by Company
Go

enter company

Search by Law Firm
select a law firm Porter Wright Morris & A

enter a search term

Go


enter a search term

Go

Search by Industry
Go

enter industry

Recent Deals


Acorn Products - Employment Agreement Page 2 of 6






More news here


Ask our Consultants
Pages: 16 pages
Price: $35.00
Add To Cart


 All Employment Agreements by Industry

Employment Agreement
Effective Date: June 11, 2002
Parties: Acorn Products
Sectors: Manufacturing
Law Firms: Porter Wright Morris & Arthur
Governing Law: New York


Borden Chemicals & Plastics - Third Amended Joint Plan of Liquidation Page 1 of 46

advanced search

Your Account
 sign in
 shopping cart

Search by Company
Go

enter company

Search by Law Firm
select a law firm Vorys, Sater, Seymour

enter a search term

Go


enter a search term

Go

Search by Industry
Go

enter industry

Recent Deals


Borden Chemicals & Plastics - Third Amended Joint Plan of Liquidation Page 2 of 46






More news here


Ask our Consultants
Pages: 115 pages
Price: $35.00
Add To Cart


 Liquidation Agreements

Third Amended Joint Plan of Liquidation
Effective Date: December 05, 2002
Parties: Borden Chemicals & Plastics
Sectors: Materials and Construction
Law Firms: Baker & Hostetler, Blank Rome, Reed Smith, Duane Morris, Jones Day, Kramer
Levin Naftalis & Frankel, Saul Ewing, Vorys, Sater, Seymour and Pease


Ohio supreme court justices (campaign contributions)

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (20)

Similar to Ohio supreme court justices (campaign contributions)

Similar to Ohio supreme court justices (campaign contributions) (20)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (12)

Ohio supreme court justices (campaign contributions)