SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 11
Baixar para ler offline
PARTHENOS-project.eu
PARTHENOS and the DMP
Firenze– 14/11/2016
Franco Niccolucci
Scientific Coordinator, PARTHENOS
PARTHENOS-project.eu 2
What is PARTHENOS
PARTHENOS is a “cluster” project (2015-2019) putting together Research Infrastructures in the
Humanities, Language and Cultural Heritage sectors, adopting a bottom-up approach to
develop joint strategies as regards:
•  Data policies: data management and quality; open data and access
•  Standards: produce recommendations to document primary sources, reference resources
and protocols and procedures
•  Interoperability and Semantics: develop a common semantic framework and a joint
Cataloguing Dataset Model
•  Services and Tools
PARTHENOS-project.eu
Current project progress
ü  Starting points set after wide consultation of the reference communities, also through needs reports
contributed by participating infrastructure projects
ü  Basic standardization kit defined
•  Work on recommendations in progress, delivery of drafts in 2017
ü  Dataset Model prototype created, currently under test
•  Work on data management in progress, delivery planned for May 2017
•  Parallel work on scientific data started within E-RIHS (European Research Infrastructure for Heritage
Science), an ESFRi project approved after PARTHENOS started, but collaborating with it – needs to be
recovered in the second iteration of PARTHENOS work
3
PARTHENOS-project.eu
What makes a Heritage Science DMP
more demanding than others?
4
PARTHENOS-project.eu
Guidelines for a HS DMP
•  Guidelines to create a DMP do not always consider the “special needs” of HS, and in the best case
they state: “take a note”. Here are some examples:
•  A survey of 47 DMP submitted to NEH (USA) in 2015 and 2016, only 2 concerning heritage and did not address the issue
•  U. Minnesota and Colorado School of Mines provide DMP examples with non digital data, but they do not address HS issues
•  The MIT DMP guide recommends to record “how the data was generated, including equipment or software used,
experimental protocol, other things you might include in a lab notebook”
•  The DCC (UK) 2011 guide states: “It is fundamental to capture contextual details about how and why the data were created.”
•  Plan de gestion de Datos, (PaGoDa) (ES) references UK good practice but does not mention this HS issue
•  The Humboldt University (DE) tool does not require specific information for the DMP, maybe because it aims at H2020 only
•  In Italy (and probably elsewhere) the DMP is linked to H2020, and the main reason stated for making it is that it is mandatory,
and failing to make it may cause the withdrawal of the funding (the path to brain passes through the wallet…)
5
PARTHENOS-project.eu
What are the requirements for a HS DMP: F & A
•  Findability & Accessibility: humanities and heritage sciences belong to the “long tail of
science” = many small datasets, little use of IT, limited (but increasing) deposit with
institutional/domain/national repositories è need for registries and search systems
•  The ARIADNE Registry and Portal for archaeological datasets
•  The (forthcoming) E-RIHS DIGILAB – Registry of HS-related datasets
•  Both will use the PARTHENOS CDM which is designed to support all dataset
documentation needs in the humanities and heritage science
6
PARTHENOS-project.eu
What are the requirements for a HS DMP: I
•  Interoperability: to define an overarching “umbrella” ontology with specializations for individual
domains. However, there are mainly two standards:
•  TEI for texts/humanities
•  CIDOC CRM for cultural heritage
•  They respond to different needs
•  Forking probable, with reconciliation at high level
•  The main difference is in the nature of the objects studied
•  Are they the focus of research (HS) or information carrier (HUM)?
•  According to which perspective prevails, there are different documentation requirements
7
PARTHENOS-project.eu
What are the requirements for a HS DMP: R
•  Re-use: to be able to re-use data, a large number of additional metadata must be provided: the
5W+H. This may be cumbersome for the data creator
•  Who: not only a question of researcher’s credibility (also!) but also of the scholarly perspective
the creator usually adopted, possibly not matching with the re-user’s one
•  Example: classifications of flint tools use different approaches, e.g. use vs. manufacturing
•  Why: what is the research question underlying the data creation? It may influence the way data
were generated
•  Example: 3D models created for communication may be unsuitable for research
•  What: which was/were the object(s) studied? Are they acceptable for data re-use?
•  Example: the object conditions may be corrupted and cause differences
8
PARTHENOS-project.eu
What are the requirements for a HS DMP: R (cont)
•  When/where: this is particularly relevant for legacy data, and all data become legacy after
some time... Technologies change and this may limit the reliability of results.
•  Example: the FLAME project (U. Oxford) studies the movement, exchange, and transformation of
metal in Eurasian societies during the Bronze and Early Iron Age. It collects metallurgic analyses
made on archaeological material since the XIX century; dating each one is paramount to qualify
their reliability
•  How: which protocol was used to generate the data? If data were created using equipment
(from a digital camera to a particle accelerator), the instrument features and settings may
significantly influence the response. Also different methods possibly lead to different results.
•  Example: 3D scan models may differ according to scanner type (laser, structured light, etc),
model (Minolta vs. Breuckmann), settings (resolution chosen) and post-processing (decimation)
9
PARTHENOS-project.eu
A (tentative) solution
•  The CIDOC CRM is developing a global system to address these issues and enable human
and machine re-use of heritage science data through proper documentation
•  CRMdig defines an ontology for documenting digital data acquisition (e.g. photo, 3D)
•  CRMsci (ext) defines an ontology for documenting the results of analytical experiments
in heritage science (e.g. XRF, XRD, FTIR, etc.)
•  CRMrel defines ways to express confidence in one’s results and communicate them to
future re-users
•  All need to be agreed upon, tested and assessed in real cases
10
PARTHENOS-project.eu
THANK YOU!
PARTHENOS is a project funded by the European
Commission under Horizon2020
Franco Niccolucci
PARTHENOS
franco.niccolucci@gmail.com www.parthenos-project.eu

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

The Digital Transformation of Research Support
The Digital Transformation of Research SupportThe Digital Transformation of Research Support
The Digital Transformation of Research SupportAndy Tattersall
 
Bl labs ucl-services
Bl labs ucl-servicesBl labs ucl-services
Bl labs ucl-servicesbenosteen
 
The Future is All Mine
The Future is All MineThe Future is All Mine
The Future is All Mineopenminted_eu
 
Library Science Talk: Tensions between copyright and knowledge discovery
Library Science Talk: Tensions between copyright and knowledge discoveryLibrary Science Talk: Tensions between copyright and knowledge discovery
Library Science Talk: Tensions between copyright and knowledge discoveryLIBER Europe
 
Geographic and linguistic normalization opensym2014 poster
Geographic and linguistic normalization opensym2014 posterGeographic and linguistic normalization opensym2014 poster
Geographic and linguistic normalization opensym2014 posterHanteng Liao
 
Lorna hughes 12 05-2013 NeDiMAH and ontology for DH
Lorna hughes 12 05-2013 NeDiMAH and ontology for DHLorna hughes 12 05-2013 NeDiMAH and ontology for DH
Lorna hughes 12 05-2013 NeDiMAH and ontology for DHlorna_hughes
 
The influence of social status on consensus building in collaboration networks
The influence of social status on consensus building in collaboration networksThe influence of social status on consensus building in collaboration networks
The influence of social status on consensus building in collaboration networksIlire Hasani-Mavriqi
 
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turn
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turnParthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turn
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turnParthenos
 
A theory of digital library metadata the emergence of enriching and filtering
A theory of digital library metadata the emergence of enriching and filteringA theory of digital library metadata the emergence of enriching and filtering
A theory of digital library metadata the emergence of enriching and filteringGetaneh Alemu
 
Linking Collections Through Linked Open Data
Linking Collections Through Linked Open DataLinking Collections Through Linked Open Data
Linking Collections Through Linked Open DataThe European Library
 
(Inter)disciplinary Infrastructures for Social Sciences and Humanities
(Inter)disciplinary Infrastructures for Social Sciences and Humanities(Inter)disciplinary Infrastructures for Social Sciences and Humanities
(Inter)disciplinary Infrastructures for Social Sciences and Humanitiesdri_ireland
 
WWW2014: Long Time No See: The Probability of Reusing Tags as a Function of F...
WWW2014: Long Time No See: The Probability of Reusing Tags as a Function of F...WWW2014: Long Time No See: The Probability of Reusing Tags as a Function of F...
WWW2014: Long Time No See: The Probability of Reusing Tags as a Function of F...Dominik Kowald
 
The Regulation of Text and Data Mining
The Regulation of Text and Data MiningThe Regulation of Text and Data Mining
The Regulation of Text and Data MiningLIBER Europe
 
HybridDocs - A Digital Learning Environment based on FlashCards
HybridDocs - A Digital Learning Environment based on FlashCardsHybridDocs - A Digital Learning Environment based on FlashCards
HybridDocs - A Digital Learning Environment based on FlashCardsChristian Heise
 
What can libraries do for researchers?
What can libraries do for researchers?What can libraries do for researchers?
What can libraries do for researchers?Michael Day
 
OpenMinted: It's Uses and Benefits for the Social Sciences
OpenMinted: It's Uses and Benefits for the Social SciencesOpenMinted: It's Uses and Benefits for the Social Sciences
OpenMinted: It's Uses and Benefits for the Social Sciencesopenminted_eu
 
Sshoc kick off meeting - Work Package 9 Pitch
Sshoc kick off meeting - Work Package 9 PitchSshoc kick off meeting - Work Package 9 Pitch
Sshoc kick off meeting - Work Package 9 PitchSSHOC
 
Le Flow Proposal Planning Rwth
Le Flow Proposal Planning RwthLe Flow Proposal Planning Rwth
Le Flow Proposal Planning RwthMart Laanpere
 
How can repositories support the text mining of their content and why?
How can repositories support the text mining of their content and why?How can repositories support the text mining of their content and why?
How can repositories support the text mining of their content and why?openminted_eu
 

Mais procurados (20)

The Digital Transformation of Research Support
The Digital Transformation of Research SupportThe Digital Transformation of Research Support
The Digital Transformation of Research Support
 
Bl labs ucl-services
Bl labs ucl-servicesBl labs ucl-services
Bl labs ucl-services
 
The Future is All Mine
The Future is All MineThe Future is All Mine
The Future is All Mine
 
Library Science Talk: Tensions between copyright and knowledge discovery
Library Science Talk: Tensions between copyright and knowledge discoveryLibrary Science Talk: Tensions between copyright and knowledge discovery
Library Science Talk: Tensions between copyright and knowledge discovery
 
Geographic and linguistic normalization opensym2014 poster
Geographic and linguistic normalization opensym2014 posterGeographic and linguistic normalization opensym2014 poster
Geographic and linguistic normalization opensym2014 poster
 
Lorna hughes 12 05-2013 NeDiMAH and ontology for DH
Lorna hughes 12 05-2013 NeDiMAH and ontology for DHLorna hughes 12 05-2013 NeDiMAH and ontology for DH
Lorna hughes 12 05-2013 NeDiMAH and ontology for DH
 
The influence of social status on consensus building in collaboration networks
The influence of social status on consensus building in collaboration networksThe influence of social status on consensus building in collaboration networks
The influence of social status on consensus building in collaboration networks
 
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turn
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turnParthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turn
Parthenos Training: Infrastructures - The infrastructural turn
 
A theory of digital library metadata the emergence of enriching and filtering
A theory of digital library metadata the emergence of enriching and filteringA theory of digital library metadata the emergence of enriching and filtering
A theory of digital library metadata the emergence of enriching and filtering
 
Linking Collections Through Linked Open Data
Linking Collections Through Linked Open DataLinking Collections Through Linked Open Data
Linking Collections Through Linked Open Data
 
Connecting Museums with Linked Data
Connecting Museums with Linked DataConnecting Museums with Linked Data
Connecting Museums with Linked Data
 
(Inter)disciplinary Infrastructures for Social Sciences and Humanities
(Inter)disciplinary Infrastructures for Social Sciences and Humanities(Inter)disciplinary Infrastructures for Social Sciences and Humanities
(Inter)disciplinary Infrastructures for Social Sciences and Humanities
 
WWW2014: Long Time No See: The Probability of Reusing Tags as a Function of F...
WWW2014: Long Time No See: The Probability of Reusing Tags as a Function of F...WWW2014: Long Time No See: The Probability of Reusing Tags as a Function of F...
WWW2014: Long Time No See: The Probability of Reusing Tags as a Function of F...
 
The Regulation of Text and Data Mining
The Regulation of Text and Data MiningThe Regulation of Text and Data Mining
The Regulation of Text and Data Mining
 
HybridDocs - A Digital Learning Environment based on FlashCards
HybridDocs - A Digital Learning Environment based on FlashCardsHybridDocs - A Digital Learning Environment based on FlashCards
HybridDocs - A Digital Learning Environment based on FlashCards
 
What can libraries do for researchers?
What can libraries do for researchers?What can libraries do for researchers?
What can libraries do for researchers?
 
OpenMinted: It's Uses and Benefits for the Social Sciences
OpenMinted: It's Uses and Benefits for the Social SciencesOpenMinted: It's Uses and Benefits for the Social Sciences
OpenMinted: It's Uses and Benefits for the Social Sciences
 
Sshoc kick off meeting - Work Package 9 Pitch
Sshoc kick off meeting - Work Package 9 PitchSshoc kick off meeting - Work Package 9 Pitch
Sshoc kick off meeting - Work Package 9 Pitch
 
Le Flow Proposal Planning Rwth
Le Flow Proposal Planning RwthLe Flow Proposal Planning Rwth
Le Flow Proposal Planning Rwth
 
How can repositories support the text mining of their content and why?
How can repositories support the text mining of their content and why?How can repositories support the text mining of their content and why?
How can repositories support the text mining of their content and why?
 

Destaque

Stories of “Glocality"—Nations in a Global Infrastructure
Stories of “Glocality"—Nations in a Global InfrastructureStories of “Glocality"—Nations in a Global Infrastructure
Stories of “Glocality"—Nations in a Global InfrastructureResearch Data Alliance
 
Why Data Citation Currently Misses the Point
Why Data Citation Currently Misses the PointWhy Data Citation Currently Misses the Point
Why Data Citation Currently Misses the PointMark Parsons
 
Data Policy for Open Science
Data Policy for Open ScienceData Policy for Open Science
Data Policy for Open ScienceMark Parsons
 
Open Data is Not Enough: Making Data Sharing Work
Open Data is Not Enough: Making Data Sharing WorkOpen Data is Not Enough: Making Data Sharing Work
Open Data is Not Enough: Making Data Sharing WorkResearch Data Alliance
 
Parsons citation geodata2014
Parsons citation geodata2014Parsons citation geodata2014
Parsons citation geodata2014Mark Parsons
 
Parsons scidatacon2016
Parsons scidatacon2016Parsons scidatacon2016
Parsons scidatacon2016Mark Parsons
 
CoBRA guideline : a tool to facilitate sharing, reuse, and reproducibility of...
CoBRA guideline : a tool to facilitate sharing, reuse, and reproducibility of...CoBRA guideline : a tool to facilitate sharing, reuse, and reproducibility of...
CoBRA guideline : a tool to facilitate sharing, reuse, and reproducibility of...Research Data Alliance
 
Removing Barriers to Data Sharing: the Research Data Alliance
Removing Barriers to Data Sharing: the Research Data AllianceRemoving Barriers to Data Sharing: the Research Data Alliance
Removing Barriers to Data Sharing: the Research Data AllianceResearch Data Alliance
 
Efficient and effective: can we combine both to realize high-value, open, sca...
Efficient and effective: can we combine both to realize high-value, open, sca...Efficient and effective: can we combine both to realize high-value, open, sca...
Efficient and effective: can we combine both to realize high-value, open, sca...Research Data Alliance
 
SoBigData. European Research Infrastructure for Big Data and Social Mining
SoBigData. European Research Infrastructure for Big Data and Social MiningSoBigData. European Research Infrastructure for Big Data and Social Mining
SoBigData. European Research Infrastructure for Big Data and Social MiningResearch Data Alliance
 
OpenAIRE and Eudat services and tools to support FAIR DMP implementation
OpenAIRE and Eudat services and tools to support FAIR DMP implementation OpenAIRE and Eudat services and tools to support FAIR DMP implementation
OpenAIRE and Eudat services and tools to support FAIR DMP implementation Research Data Alliance
 
Rda in a_nutshell_february_2017_updated
Rda in a_nutshell_february_2017_updatedRda in a_nutshell_february_2017_updated
Rda in a_nutshell_february_2017_updatedResearch Data Alliance
 

Destaque (17)

Stories of “Glocality"—Nations in a Global Infrastructure
Stories of “Glocality"—Nations in a Global InfrastructureStories of “Glocality"—Nations in a Global Infrastructure
Stories of “Glocality"—Nations in a Global Infrastructure
 
Why Data Citation Currently Misses the Point
Why Data Citation Currently Misses the PointWhy Data Citation Currently Misses the Point
Why Data Citation Currently Misses the Point
 
Data Policy for Open Science
Data Policy for Open ScienceData Policy for Open Science
Data Policy for Open Science
 
Open Data is Not Enough: Making Data Sharing Work
Open Data is Not Enough: Making Data Sharing WorkOpen Data is Not Enough: Making Data Sharing Work
Open Data is Not Enough: Making Data Sharing Work
 
Parsons citation geodata2014
Parsons citation geodata2014Parsons citation geodata2014
Parsons citation geodata2014
 
Parsons scidatacon2016
Parsons scidatacon2016Parsons scidatacon2016
Parsons scidatacon2016
 
CoBRA guideline : a tool to facilitate sharing, reuse, and reproducibility of...
CoBRA guideline : a tool to facilitate sharing, reuse, and reproducibility of...CoBRA guideline : a tool to facilitate sharing, reuse, and reproducibility of...
CoBRA guideline : a tool to facilitate sharing, reuse, and reproducibility of...
 
Research Data Alliance Overview
Research Data Alliance OverviewResearch Data Alliance Overview
Research Data Alliance Overview
 
Removing Barriers to Data Sharing: the Research Data Alliance
Removing Barriers to Data Sharing: the Research Data AllianceRemoving Barriers to Data Sharing: the Research Data Alliance
Removing Barriers to Data Sharing: the Research Data Alliance
 
Efficient and effective: can we combine both to realize high-value, open, sca...
Efficient and effective: can we combine both to realize high-value, open, sca...Efficient and effective: can we combine both to realize high-value, open, sca...
Efficient and effective: can we combine both to realize high-value, open, sca...
 
Research Data Alliance Overview
Research Data Alliance OverviewResearch Data Alliance Overview
Research Data Alliance Overview
 
SoBigData. European Research Infrastructure for Big Data and Social Mining
SoBigData. European Research Infrastructure for Big Data and Social MiningSoBigData. European Research Infrastructure for Big Data and Social Mining
SoBigData. European Research Infrastructure for Big Data and Social Mining
 
"Cool" metadata for FAIR data
"Cool" metadata for FAIR data"Cool" metadata for FAIR data
"Cool" metadata for FAIR data
 
OpenAIRE and Eudat services and tools to support FAIR DMP implementation
OpenAIRE and Eudat services and tools to support FAIR DMP implementation OpenAIRE and Eudat services and tools to support FAIR DMP implementation
OpenAIRE and Eudat services and tools to support FAIR DMP implementation
 
Whole brain optical imaging
Whole brain optical imagingWhole brain optical imaging
Whole brain optical imaging
 
Rda in a_nutshell_february_2017_updated
Rda in a_nutshell_february_2017_updatedRda in a_nutshell_february_2017_updated
Rda in a_nutshell_february_2017_updated
 
Data curator: who is s/he?
Data curator: who is s/he?Data curator: who is s/he?
Data curator: who is s/he?
 

Semelhante a Cultural Heritage: when data are much worst than one can believe

Research data management at TU Eindhoven
Research data management at TU EindhovenResearch data management at TU Eindhoven
Research data management at TU EindhovenLeon Osinski
 
Open Data: Strategies for Research Data Management (and Planning)
Open Data: Strategies for Research Data  Management (and Planning)Open Data: Strategies for Research Data  Management (and Planning)
Open Data: Strategies for Research Data Management (and Planning)Martin Donnelly
 
Big Data Europe: SC6 Workshop 3: The European Research Data Landscape: Opport...
Big Data Europe: SC6 Workshop 3: The European Research Data Landscape: Opport...Big Data Europe: SC6 Workshop 3: The European Research Data Landscape: Opport...
Big Data Europe: SC6 Workshop 3: The European Research Data Landscape: Opport...BigData_Europe
 
Sensitive Data Workshop
Sensitive Data WorkshopSensitive Data Workshop
Sensitive Data WorkshopEUDAT
 
Open Data Strategies and Research Data Realities
Open Data Strategies and Research Data RealitiesOpen Data Strategies and Research Data Realities
Open Data Strategies and Research Data RealitiesMartin Donnelly
 
From Open Access to Open Data: Collaborative Work in the University Libraries...
From Open Access to Open Data: Collaborative Work in the University Libraries...From Open Access to Open Data: Collaborative Work in the University Libraries...
From Open Access to Open Data: Collaborative Work in the University Libraries...LIBER Europe
 
Introducing parthenos powerpoint presentation december 2015 updated
Introducing parthenos powerpoint presentation december 2015 updatedIntroducing parthenos powerpoint presentation december 2015 updated
Introducing parthenos powerpoint presentation december 2015 updatedParthenos
 
Developing a Data Management Plan
Developing a Data Management PlanDeveloping a Data Management Plan
Developing a Data Management PlanMartin Donnelly
 
The Italian Universities RDM WG: tools and best practices
The Italian Universities RDM WG:  tools and best practicesThe Italian Universities RDM WG:  tools and best practices
The Italian Universities RDM WG: tools and best practicesResearch Data Alliance
 
Birgit Plietzsch “RDM within research computing support” SALCTG June 2013
Birgit Plietzsch “RDM within research computing support” SALCTG June 2013Birgit Plietzsch “RDM within research computing support” SALCTG June 2013
Birgit Plietzsch “RDM within research computing support” SALCTG June 2013SALCTG
 
Managing 'Big Data' in the social sciences: the contribution of an analytico-...
Managing 'Big Data' in the social sciences: the contribution of an analytico-...Managing 'Big Data' in the social sciences: the contribution of an analytico-...
Managing 'Big Data' in the social sciences: the contribution of an analytico-...CILIP MDG
 
Elag workshop sessie 1 en 2 v10
Elag workshop sessie 1 en 2 v10Elag workshop sessie 1 en 2 v10
Elag workshop sessie 1 en 2 v10Jeroen Rombouts
 
PARTHENOS Community Involvement and Requirements
PARTHENOS Community Involvement and RequirementsPARTHENOS Community Involvement and Requirements
PARTHENOS Community Involvement and RequirementsParthenos
 
Data Management Planning at the DCC
Data Management Planning at the DCCData Management Planning at the DCC
Data Management Planning at the DCCMartin Donnelly
 
Libraries and Research Data Management – What Works? Lessons Learned from the...
Libraries and Research Data Management – What Works? Lessons Learned from the...Libraries and Research Data Management – What Works? Lessons Learned from the...
Libraries and Research Data Management – What Works? Lessons Learned from the...LIBER Europe
 
DMP lessons from Europe
DMP lessons from EuropeDMP lessons from Europe
DMP lessons from EuropeSarah Jones
 

Semelhante a Cultural Heritage: when data are much worst than one can believe (20)

Research data management at TU Eindhoven
Research data management at TU EindhovenResearch data management at TU Eindhoven
Research data management at TU Eindhoven
 
Open Data: Strategies for Research Data Management (and Planning)
Open Data: Strategies for Research Data  Management (and Planning)Open Data: Strategies for Research Data  Management (and Planning)
Open Data: Strategies for Research Data Management (and Planning)
 
Big Data Europe: SC6 Workshop 3: The European Research Data Landscape: Opport...
Big Data Europe: SC6 Workshop 3: The European Research Data Landscape: Opport...Big Data Europe: SC6 Workshop 3: The European Research Data Landscape: Opport...
Big Data Europe: SC6 Workshop 3: The European Research Data Landscape: Opport...
 
Sensitive Data Workshop
Sensitive Data WorkshopSensitive Data Workshop
Sensitive Data Workshop
 
Open Data Strategies and Research Data Realities
Open Data Strategies and Research Data RealitiesOpen Data Strategies and Research Data Realities
Open Data Strategies and Research Data Realities
 
From Open Access to Open Data: collaborative work in the university libraries...
From Open Access to Open Data: collaborative work in the university libraries...From Open Access to Open Data: collaborative work in the university libraries...
From Open Access to Open Data: collaborative work in the university libraries...
 
From Open Access to Open Data: Collaborative Work in the University Libraries...
From Open Access to Open Data: Collaborative Work in the University Libraries...From Open Access to Open Data: Collaborative Work in the University Libraries...
From Open Access to Open Data: Collaborative Work in the University Libraries...
 
Introducing parthenos powerpoint presentation december 2015 updated
Introducing parthenos powerpoint presentation december 2015 updatedIntroducing parthenos powerpoint presentation december 2015 updated
Introducing parthenos powerpoint presentation december 2015 updated
 
Developing a Data Management Plan
Developing a Data Management PlanDeveloping a Data Management Plan
Developing a Data Management Plan
 
Research Data Management: CSUC activities & services
Research Data Management: CSUC activities & services Research Data Management: CSUC activities & services
Research Data Management: CSUC activities & services
 
The Italian Universities RDM WG: tools and best practices
The Italian Universities RDM WG:  tools and best practicesThe Italian Universities RDM WG:  tools and best practices
The Italian Universities RDM WG: tools and best practices
 
Birgit Plietzsch “RDM within research computing support” SALCTG June 2013
Birgit Plietzsch “RDM within research computing support” SALCTG June 2013Birgit Plietzsch “RDM within research computing support” SALCTG June 2013
Birgit Plietzsch “RDM within research computing support” SALCTG June 2013
 
Research data management: DMP & repository
Research data management: DMP & repositoryResearch data management: DMP & repository
Research data management: DMP & repository
 
Managing 'Big Data' in the social sciences: the contribution of an analytico-...
Managing 'Big Data' in the social sciences: the contribution of an analytico-...Managing 'Big Data' in the social sciences: the contribution of an analytico-...
Managing 'Big Data' in the social sciences: the contribution of an analytico-...
 
Elag workshop sessie 1 en 2 v10
Elag workshop sessie 1 en 2 v10Elag workshop sessie 1 en 2 v10
Elag workshop sessie 1 en 2 v10
 
RDM Priorities, Stakeholders, Practice
RDM Priorities, Stakeholders, PracticeRDM Priorities, Stakeholders, Practice
RDM Priorities, Stakeholders, Practice
 
PARTHENOS Community Involvement and Requirements
PARTHENOS Community Involvement and RequirementsPARTHENOS Community Involvement and Requirements
PARTHENOS Community Involvement and Requirements
 
Data Management Planning at the DCC
Data Management Planning at the DCCData Management Planning at the DCC
Data Management Planning at the DCC
 
Libraries and Research Data Management – What Works? Lessons Learned from the...
Libraries and Research Data Management – What Works? Lessons Learned from the...Libraries and Research Data Management – What Works? Lessons Learned from the...
Libraries and Research Data Management – What Works? Lessons Learned from the...
 
DMP lessons from Europe
DMP lessons from EuropeDMP lessons from Europe
DMP lessons from Europe
 

Mais de Research Data Alliance

The Value of the Research Data Alliance to Individuals
The Value of the Research Data Alliance to IndividualsThe Value of the Research Data Alliance to Individuals
The Value of the Research Data Alliance to IndividualsResearch Data Alliance
 
The Value of the Research Data Alliance to Individuals
The Value of the Research Data Alliance to IndividualsThe Value of the Research Data Alliance to Individuals
The Value of the Research Data Alliance to IndividualsResearch Data Alliance
 
RDA Value for Infrastructure Providers
RDA Value for Infrastructure ProvidersRDA Value for Infrastructure Providers
RDA Value for Infrastructure ProvidersResearch Data Alliance
 
The Value of the Rda Value for Organisations Performing Research
The Value of the Rda Value for Organisations Performing ResearchThe Value of the Rda Value for Organisations Performing Research
The Value of the Rda Value for Organisations Performing ResearchResearch Data Alliance
 

Mais de Research Data Alliance (20)

RDA in a Nutshell - September 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - September 2020RDA in a Nutshell - September 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - September 2020
 
RDA in a Nutshell - August 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - August 2020RDA in a Nutshell - August 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - August 2020
 
RDA in a Nutshell - July 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - July 2020RDA in a Nutshell - July 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - July 2020
 
RDA in a Nutshell - June 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - June 2020RDA in a Nutshell - June 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - June 2020
 
RDA in a Nutshell - May 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - May 2020RDA in a Nutshell - May 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - May 2020
 
RDA in a Nutshell - April 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - April 2020RDA in a Nutshell - April 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - April 2020
 
RDA in a Nutshell - March 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - March 2020RDA in a Nutshell - March 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - March 2020
 
RDA in a Nutshell - February 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - February 2020RDA in a Nutshell - February 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - February 2020
 
RDA in a Nutshell - January 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - January 2020RDA in a Nutshell - January 2020
RDA in a Nutshell - January 2020
 
Rda in a Nutshell - December 2019
Rda in a Nutshell - December 2019Rda in a Nutshell - December 2019
Rda in a Nutshell - December 2019
 
Rda in a Nutshell - November 2019
Rda in a Nutshell - November 2019Rda in a Nutshell - November 2019
Rda in a Nutshell - November 2019
 
RDA in a Nutshell - October 2019
RDA in a Nutshell - October 2019RDA in a Nutshell - October 2019
RDA in a Nutshell - October 2019
 
The Value of the Research Data Alliance to Individuals
The Value of the Research Data Alliance to IndividualsThe Value of the Research Data Alliance to Individuals
The Value of the Research Data Alliance to Individuals
 
The Value of the Research Data Alliance to Individuals
The Value of the Research Data Alliance to IndividualsThe Value of the Research Data Alliance to Individuals
The Value of the Research Data Alliance to Individuals
 
RDA Value for Infrastructure Providers
RDA Value for Infrastructure ProvidersRDA Value for Infrastructure Providers
RDA Value for Infrastructure Providers
 
Rda in a nutshell september 2019
Rda in a nutshell september 2019Rda in a nutshell september 2019
Rda in a nutshell september 2019
 
The Value of the Rda Value for Organisations Performing Research
The Value of the Rda Value for Organisations Performing ResearchThe Value of the Rda Value for Organisations Performing Research
The Value of the Rda Value for Organisations Performing Research
 
RDA Value for Libraries
RDA Value for LibrariesRDA Value for Libraries
RDA Value for Libraries
 
The Value of the RDA for Funders
The Value of the RDA for FundersThe Value of the RDA for Funders
The Value of the RDA for Funders
 
Rda in a nutshell august 2019
Rda in a nutshell august 2019Rda in a nutshell august 2019
Rda in a nutshell august 2019
 

Último

Cash Is Still King: ATM market research '2023
Cash Is Still King: ATM market research '2023Cash Is Still King: ATM market research '2023
Cash Is Still King: ATM market research '2023Vladislav Solodkiy
 
Mapping the pubmed data under different suptopics using NLP.pptx
Mapping the pubmed data under different suptopics using NLP.pptxMapping the pubmed data under different suptopics using NLP.pptx
Mapping the pubmed data under different suptopics using NLP.pptxVenkatasubramani13
 
5 Ds to Define Data Archiving Best Practices
5 Ds to Define Data Archiving Best Practices5 Ds to Define Data Archiving Best Practices
5 Ds to Define Data Archiving Best PracticesDataArchiva
 
Virtuosoft SmartSync Product Introduction
Virtuosoft SmartSync Product IntroductionVirtuosoft SmartSync Product Introduction
Virtuosoft SmartSync Product Introductionsanjaymuralee1
 
Strategic CX: A Deep Dive into Voice of the Customer Insights for Clarity
Strategic CX: A Deep Dive into Voice of the Customer Insights for ClarityStrategic CX: A Deep Dive into Voice of the Customer Insights for Clarity
Strategic CX: A Deep Dive into Voice of the Customer Insights for ClarityAggregage
 
Master's Thesis - Data Science - Presentation
Master's Thesis - Data Science - PresentationMaster's Thesis - Data Science - Presentation
Master's Thesis - Data Science - PresentationGiorgio Carbone
 
MEASURES OF DISPERSION I BSc Botany .ppt
MEASURES OF DISPERSION I BSc Botany .pptMEASURES OF DISPERSION I BSc Botany .ppt
MEASURES OF DISPERSION I BSc Botany .pptaigil2
 
CI, CD -Tools to integrate without manual intervention
CI, CD -Tools to integrate without manual interventionCI, CD -Tools to integrate without manual intervention
CI, CD -Tools to integrate without manual interventionajayrajaganeshkayala
 
Elements of language learning - an analysis of how different elements of lang...
Elements of language learning - an analysis of how different elements of lang...Elements of language learning - an analysis of how different elements of lang...
Elements of language learning - an analysis of how different elements of lang...PrithaVashisht1
 
How is Real-Time Analytics Different from Traditional OLAP?
How is Real-Time Analytics Different from Traditional OLAP?How is Real-Time Analytics Different from Traditional OLAP?
How is Real-Time Analytics Different from Traditional OLAP?sonikadigital1
 
TINJUAN PEMROSESAN TRANSAKSI DAN ERP.pptx
TINJUAN PEMROSESAN TRANSAKSI DAN ERP.pptxTINJUAN PEMROSESAN TRANSAKSI DAN ERP.pptx
TINJUAN PEMROSESAN TRANSAKSI DAN ERP.pptxDwiAyuSitiHartinah
 
The Universal GTM - how we design GTM and dataLayer
The Universal GTM - how we design GTM and dataLayerThe Universal GTM - how we design GTM and dataLayer
The Universal GTM - how we design GTM and dataLayerPavel Šabatka
 
AI for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
AI for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)AI for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
AI for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)Data & Analytics Magazin
 
Persuasive E-commerce, Our Biased Brain @ Bikkeldag 2024
Persuasive E-commerce, Our Biased Brain @ Bikkeldag 2024Persuasive E-commerce, Our Biased Brain @ Bikkeldag 2024
Persuasive E-commerce, Our Biased Brain @ Bikkeldag 2024Guido X Jansen
 
SFBA Splunk Usergroup meeting March 13, 2024
SFBA Splunk Usergroup meeting March 13, 2024SFBA Splunk Usergroup meeting March 13, 2024
SFBA Splunk Usergroup meeting March 13, 2024Becky Burwell
 
YourView Panel Book.pptx YourView Panel Book.
YourView Panel Book.pptx YourView Panel Book.YourView Panel Book.pptx YourView Panel Book.
YourView Panel Book.pptx YourView Panel Book.JasonViviers2
 
ChistaDATA Real-Time DATA Analytics Infrastructure
ChistaDATA Real-Time DATA Analytics InfrastructureChistaDATA Real-Time DATA Analytics Infrastructure
ChistaDATA Real-Time DATA Analytics Infrastructuresonikadigital1
 

Último (17)

Cash Is Still King: ATM market research '2023
Cash Is Still King: ATM market research '2023Cash Is Still King: ATM market research '2023
Cash Is Still King: ATM market research '2023
 
Mapping the pubmed data under different suptopics using NLP.pptx
Mapping the pubmed data under different suptopics using NLP.pptxMapping the pubmed data under different suptopics using NLP.pptx
Mapping the pubmed data under different suptopics using NLP.pptx
 
5 Ds to Define Data Archiving Best Practices
5 Ds to Define Data Archiving Best Practices5 Ds to Define Data Archiving Best Practices
5 Ds to Define Data Archiving Best Practices
 
Virtuosoft SmartSync Product Introduction
Virtuosoft SmartSync Product IntroductionVirtuosoft SmartSync Product Introduction
Virtuosoft SmartSync Product Introduction
 
Strategic CX: A Deep Dive into Voice of the Customer Insights for Clarity
Strategic CX: A Deep Dive into Voice of the Customer Insights for ClarityStrategic CX: A Deep Dive into Voice of the Customer Insights for Clarity
Strategic CX: A Deep Dive into Voice of the Customer Insights for Clarity
 
Master's Thesis - Data Science - Presentation
Master's Thesis - Data Science - PresentationMaster's Thesis - Data Science - Presentation
Master's Thesis - Data Science - Presentation
 
MEASURES OF DISPERSION I BSc Botany .ppt
MEASURES OF DISPERSION I BSc Botany .pptMEASURES OF DISPERSION I BSc Botany .ppt
MEASURES OF DISPERSION I BSc Botany .ppt
 
CI, CD -Tools to integrate without manual intervention
CI, CD -Tools to integrate without manual interventionCI, CD -Tools to integrate without manual intervention
CI, CD -Tools to integrate without manual intervention
 
Elements of language learning - an analysis of how different elements of lang...
Elements of language learning - an analysis of how different elements of lang...Elements of language learning - an analysis of how different elements of lang...
Elements of language learning - an analysis of how different elements of lang...
 
How is Real-Time Analytics Different from Traditional OLAP?
How is Real-Time Analytics Different from Traditional OLAP?How is Real-Time Analytics Different from Traditional OLAP?
How is Real-Time Analytics Different from Traditional OLAP?
 
TINJUAN PEMROSESAN TRANSAKSI DAN ERP.pptx
TINJUAN PEMROSESAN TRANSAKSI DAN ERP.pptxTINJUAN PEMROSESAN TRANSAKSI DAN ERP.pptx
TINJUAN PEMROSESAN TRANSAKSI DAN ERP.pptx
 
The Universal GTM - how we design GTM and dataLayer
The Universal GTM - how we design GTM and dataLayerThe Universal GTM - how we design GTM and dataLayer
The Universal GTM - how we design GTM and dataLayer
 
AI for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
AI for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)AI for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
AI for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
 
Persuasive E-commerce, Our Biased Brain @ Bikkeldag 2024
Persuasive E-commerce, Our Biased Brain @ Bikkeldag 2024Persuasive E-commerce, Our Biased Brain @ Bikkeldag 2024
Persuasive E-commerce, Our Biased Brain @ Bikkeldag 2024
 
SFBA Splunk Usergroup meeting March 13, 2024
SFBA Splunk Usergroup meeting March 13, 2024SFBA Splunk Usergroup meeting March 13, 2024
SFBA Splunk Usergroup meeting March 13, 2024
 
YourView Panel Book.pptx YourView Panel Book.
YourView Panel Book.pptx YourView Panel Book.YourView Panel Book.pptx YourView Panel Book.
YourView Panel Book.pptx YourView Panel Book.
 
ChistaDATA Real-Time DATA Analytics Infrastructure
ChistaDATA Real-Time DATA Analytics InfrastructureChistaDATA Real-Time DATA Analytics Infrastructure
ChistaDATA Real-Time DATA Analytics Infrastructure
 

Cultural Heritage: when data are much worst than one can believe

  • 1. PARTHENOS-project.eu PARTHENOS and the DMP Firenze– 14/11/2016 Franco Niccolucci Scientific Coordinator, PARTHENOS
  • 2. PARTHENOS-project.eu 2 What is PARTHENOS PARTHENOS is a “cluster” project (2015-2019) putting together Research Infrastructures in the Humanities, Language and Cultural Heritage sectors, adopting a bottom-up approach to develop joint strategies as regards: •  Data policies: data management and quality; open data and access •  Standards: produce recommendations to document primary sources, reference resources and protocols and procedures •  Interoperability and Semantics: develop a common semantic framework and a joint Cataloguing Dataset Model •  Services and Tools
  • 3. PARTHENOS-project.eu Current project progress ü  Starting points set after wide consultation of the reference communities, also through needs reports contributed by participating infrastructure projects ü  Basic standardization kit defined •  Work on recommendations in progress, delivery of drafts in 2017 ü  Dataset Model prototype created, currently under test •  Work on data management in progress, delivery planned for May 2017 •  Parallel work on scientific data started within E-RIHS (European Research Infrastructure for Heritage Science), an ESFRi project approved after PARTHENOS started, but collaborating with it – needs to be recovered in the second iteration of PARTHENOS work 3
  • 4. PARTHENOS-project.eu What makes a Heritage Science DMP more demanding than others? 4
  • 5. PARTHENOS-project.eu Guidelines for a HS DMP •  Guidelines to create a DMP do not always consider the “special needs” of HS, and in the best case they state: “take a note”. Here are some examples: •  A survey of 47 DMP submitted to NEH (USA) in 2015 and 2016, only 2 concerning heritage and did not address the issue •  U. Minnesota and Colorado School of Mines provide DMP examples with non digital data, but they do not address HS issues •  The MIT DMP guide recommends to record “how the data was generated, including equipment or software used, experimental protocol, other things you might include in a lab notebook” •  The DCC (UK) 2011 guide states: “It is fundamental to capture contextual details about how and why the data were created.” •  Plan de gestion de Datos, (PaGoDa) (ES) references UK good practice but does not mention this HS issue •  The Humboldt University (DE) tool does not require specific information for the DMP, maybe because it aims at H2020 only •  In Italy (and probably elsewhere) the DMP is linked to H2020, and the main reason stated for making it is that it is mandatory, and failing to make it may cause the withdrawal of the funding (the path to brain passes through the wallet…) 5
  • 6. PARTHENOS-project.eu What are the requirements for a HS DMP: F & A •  Findability & Accessibility: humanities and heritage sciences belong to the “long tail of science” = many small datasets, little use of IT, limited (but increasing) deposit with institutional/domain/national repositories è need for registries and search systems •  The ARIADNE Registry and Portal for archaeological datasets •  The (forthcoming) E-RIHS DIGILAB – Registry of HS-related datasets •  Both will use the PARTHENOS CDM which is designed to support all dataset documentation needs in the humanities and heritage science 6
  • 7. PARTHENOS-project.eu What are the requirements for a HS DMP: I •  Interoperability: to define an overarching “umbrella” ontology with specializations for individual domains. However, there are mainly two standards: •  TEI for texts/humanities •  CIDOC CRM for cultural heritage •  They respond to different needs •  Forking probable, with reconciliation at high level •  The main difference is in the nature of the objects studied •  Are they the focus of research (HS) or information carrier (HUM)? •  According to which perspective prevails, there are different documentation requirements 7
  • 8. PARTHENOS-project.eu What are the requirements for a HS DMP: R •  Re-use: to be able to re-use data, a large number of additional metadata must be provided: the 5W+H. This may be cumbersome for the data creator •  Who: not only a question of researcher’s credibility (also!) but also of the scholarly perspective the creator usually adopted, possibly not matching with the re-user’s one •  Example: classifications of flint tools use different approaches, e.g. use vs. manufacturing •  Why: what is the research question underlying the data creation? It may influence the way data were generated •  Example: 3D models created for communication may be unsuitable for research •  What: which was/were the object(s) studied? Are they acceptable for data re-use? •  Example: the object conditions may be corrupted and cause differences 8
  • 9. PARTHENOS-project.eu What are the requirements for a HS DMP: R (cont) •  When/where: this is particularly relevant for legacy data, and all data become legacy after some time... Technologies change and this may limit the reliability of results. •  Example: the FLAME project (U. Oxford) studies the movement, exchange, and transformation of metal in Eurasian societies during the Bronze and Early Iron Age. It collects metallurgic analyses made on archaeological material since the XIX century; dating each one is paramount to qualify their reliability •  How: which protocol was used to generate the data? If data were created using equipment (from a digital camera to a particle accelerator), the instrument features and settings may significantly influence the response. Also different methods possibly lead to different results. •  Example: 3D scan models may differ according to scanner type (laser, structured light, etc), model (Minolta vs. Breuckmann), settings (resolution chosen) and post-processing (decimation) 9
  • 10. PARTHENOS-project.eu A (tentative) solution •  The CIDOC CRM is developing a global system to address these issues and enable human and machine re-use of heritage science data through proper documentation •  CRMdig defines an ontology for documenting digital data acquisition (e.g. photo, 3D) •  CRMsci (ext) defines an ontology for documenting the results of analytical experiments in heritage science (e.g. XRF, XRD, FTIR, etc.) •  CRMrel defines ways to express confidence in one’s results and communicate them to future re-users •  All need to be agreed upon, tested and assessed in real cases 10
  • 11. PARTHENOS-project.eu THANK YOU! PARTHENOS is a project funded by the European Commission under Horizon2020 Franco Niccolucci PARTHENOS franco.niccolucci@gmail.com www.parthenos-project.eu