Ricky Erway and John MacColl's Research Information Management presentation from the RLG Partnership Annual Meeting June 2, 2009.

1. Research
Research Information Management
John MacColl and
Ricky Erway
Image by permission of Rick Luce RLG Partnership Meeting
June 2 2009
2,

2. 2008 RLG Partnership Meeting (part one)
• We reported on four areas:
• Collaboration among libraries, archives, and museums.
• A synthesis of the literature on disciplinary research behaviors.
• An investigation of expectations for scholarly use of the outputs
of book digitization.
g
• An exploration of institutional reputation based on research
outputs .
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 2 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

3. 2008 RLG Partnership Meeting (part two)
What attendees said was of interest on the way in:
y
Faculty partnerships
eScience
Work practices of faculty and students
Strategic planning
Institutional repository
p y
Data curation
Scholarly communication
eScholarship
p
Preservation
Other media
ePublishing
Reputation measures
Open content mandates
Library, archive, museum convergence
Collaborative space
Access to legacy collections
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 3 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

4. 2008 RLG Partnership Meeting (part three)
• What we heard as advice from the meeting:
• Extend the benefit and lessons from the LAM investigations
• Formulate guidance for those interested in managing personal
collections
• Write a scoping and opportunity p p on reputation and
p g pp y paper p
expertise profiling
• Profile a suite of services that could be built around faculty
workflow and research output p
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 4 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

5. The support that researchers need to meet their goals is
not currently provided by the typical research library, -
-- and the gap between what they need and what is
provided is growing wider
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 5 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

6. The Research Information Management Universe
Scholar; Scopus; WoK; WorldCat; Oaister; CiteSeer;
Google Books; datasets; databases; EEBO/ECCO;
VREs; repositories; etc
Large research-oriented
(tend toward STEM)
( d d
Smaller research-oriented
Data Environment (tend toward humanities)
Tenure issues
Funding issues
g
Institution
Domain
User JISC Names
ISNI
ResearcherID
People Australia
Assessment Regime DAI
Cooperative ID Hub?
Comfort zone, but with Self-assessment (Netherlands; Nordic)
competition issues Funding-based (UK, Australia)
Tenure based (US)
PR and institutional reputation (all)
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 6 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

7. RLG Research Information Management (RIM)
Program
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 7 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

8. RLG Research Information Management Activity
• Report on Scholarly Information Practices
• WRAP consultancy
• Joint investigation with RIN
• Projects with the RLG Partnership
j p
• Testing the desirability of research services
• A RIM manifesto
• Role of libraries in data curation
• Changing roles of library staff
• D f
Deferred projects
d j t
• Welcome your input
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 8 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

9. RIM Activity
• Report on Scholarly Information Practices
• WRAP consultancy
• Possible joint investigation with RIN
• Projects with the RLG Partnership
j p
• Testing the desirability of research services
• A RIM manifesto
• Role of libraries in data curation
• Changing roles of library staff
• D f
Deferred projects
d j t
• Welcome your input
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 9 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

10. Institution
Domain
User
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 10 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

11. Patterns of Convergence in Scholarly Practice
Interdisciplinary
probing
translating
accessing
assessing
Humanities chaining Sciences
browsing
b i disseminating direct searching
di hi
collecting networking scanning
re-reading co-authoring
assembling coordinating
consulting monitoring
note-taking data-sharing
Adapted from C. Palmer, L. Teffau, C. Pirmann (2009)
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 11 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

12. Workflows in Research Assessment Program (WRAP)
Consultancy
y
• Survey library roles in research assessment data-
g
gathering regimes within research universities in:
g g
• UK
• Netherlands
• Denmark
• Republic of Ireland
• Australia
• Describe the assessment regimes, placing them on a
spectrum from high- to low-intervention, noting
national characteristics.
Assessment Regime
Institution
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 12 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

13. Joint project with UK Research Information
Network
Investigate methods of managing places of
intersection around research support on campus
pp p
Data Environment
Institution
User
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 13 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

14. RIM Activity
• Report on Scholarly Information Practices
• WRAP consultancy
• Possible joint investigation with RIN
• Projects with the RLG Partnership
j p
• Testing the desirability of research services
• A RIM manifesto
• Role of libraries in data curation
• Changing roles of library staff
• D f
Deferred projects
d j t
• Welcome your input
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 14 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

15. RIM Research Services Project
• A list of research support services will be tested with
researchers. The list exemplifies a user-centered
approach, with services that researchers should like
because they can make their work easier and help them in
maintaining their scholarly reputation.
Working Group
Susan Ashworth - University of Glasgow
Jeff Belliston - Brigham Young University
Niamh Brennan - Trinity College Dublin Data Environment
Sten Ch i t
St Christensen - U i University of S d
it f Sydney Institution
Zack Lane - Columbia University
User
Virginia Shih - University of California, Berkeley
Chair: Robin Green - University of Warwick
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 15 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

16. List of Research Support Services (slide 1 of 2)
We will…
• provide you dedicated space on a server.
• help you structure space to organize your notes datasets,
notes, datasets
others’ publications, presentations…
• help you load it if you like.
• back up your work
work.
• ensure you can access your data remotely, no matter where
you are.
• provide t l f group work and version control at th fil
id tools for k d i t l t the file
level.
• help you manage your research, tracking who is involved in
which grant, which research i f d d b which grant, and
hi h t hi h h is funded by hi h t d
purchasing grant-funded equipment.
• help you negotiate publication rights.
• h l you comply with NIH and other requirements. (
help l ih d h i (cont.)
)
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 16 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

17. List of Research Support Services (slide 2 of 2)
(Cont.) We will…
• see that your work is disseminated broadly, q
y y, quickly, and
y,
openly and that you get maximum impact for you and your
university.
• do the authority work to ensure you are credited for all y
y y your
work, despite the various forms of your name used in
indicating authorship.
• keep your personal bibliography up-to-date.
• provide you with a customizable personal web page.
• include you in the campus expertise database and facilitate
inclusion in disciplinary expert databases.
p y p
• preserve your outputs in the institutional repository and
facilitate inclusion in disciplinary repositories.
• see that you can take your work with you if you leave this
institution
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 17 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

18. RIM Roadmap Project
•This project involves issuing a provocative call to action, urging academic
action
libraries to take a more significant role in their institution's mission to support
research.
Working Group
Susan Ashworth - University of Glasgow
Niamh Brennan - Trinity College Dublin
Elizabeth Brown - Bi h
li b h B Binghamton University, S
i i SUNY
Sheila Cannell - University of Edinburgh
Ross Coleman - University of Sydney
Robin Green - University of Warwick
Data Environment
Geneva Henry - Rice University Assessment Regime
Allen Jones - The New School Institution
Rebecca Kennison - Columbia University
MJ Romaniuk - University of Alberta
Sally Rumsey - University of Oxford
Wendy Scheir - The New School
Anna Shadbolt - U i
A Sh db lt University of M lb
it f Melbourne
Chair: Chris Bourg - Stanford University
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 18 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

19. Data Curation Project
While big science often has its data curation needs met outside the library, the
library needs to be prepared to respond to the need for local dataset
management, to look beyond derivative data, to include the source data, and to
help researchers manage the entire data lifecycle.
Working Group
Jeff Belliston - Brigham Young University
Niamh Brennan - Trinity College Dublin
Elizabeth B
Eli b th Brown - Bi h t U i
Binghamton University, SUNY
it
Rowan Brownlee - University of Sydney
Faye Chadwell - Oregon State University
Robin Green - University of Warwick
y
Data Environment
Allen Jones - The New School
MJ Romaniuk - University of Alberta Institution
Domain
Sally Rumsey - University of Oxford User
Wendy Scheir - The New School
Anna Shadbolt - University of Melbourne
Chair: Patricia Cruse - California Digital Library
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 19 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

20. Data Curation
Assess library contributions related to data curation
• Big science vs. little science and humanities
• Derivative data and source data
• Data lifecycle management
• Data reuse
• Institutional vs disciplinary approaches
vs.
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 20 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

21. Changing Roles of Library Staff
This project entails an investigation of how traditional
library roles can be simplified, so that libraries can rise
to the increasing demands related to scholarly
communication and data curation.
Working Group
Susan Ashworth - University of Glasgow
Chris Bourg - Stanford University
Sheila Cannell - University of Edinburgh
Ross Coleman - University of Sydney Data Environment
Robin Green - University of Warwick Assessment Regime
Institution
Allen Jones - The New School Domain
Catherine Mitchell - California Digital Library
Barbara Rocchi - U i
B b R hi University of M lb
it f Melbourne
MJ Romaniuk - University of Alberta
Sally Rumsey - University of Oxford
Chair: Niamh Brennan - Trinity College Dublin
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 21 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

22. Changing Roles of Library Staff
Explore changing roles of library staff
• Increasing demands
• R l of "d t lib i "
Role f "data librarians"
• Faculty liaison role
• Specialization in rights and open access
• Ways to work with departments to increase data
management awareness and skills
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 22 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

23. RIM Activity
• Report on Scholarly Information Practices
• WRAP consultancy
• Possible joint investigation with RIN
• Projects with the RLG Partnership
j p
• Testing the desirability of research services
• A RIM manifesto
• Role of libraries in data curation
• Changing roles of library staff
• D f
Deferred projects
d j t
• Welcome your input
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 23 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

24. Other Possibilities
• Research Needs and Services Grid
• Personal Name Disambiguation
• Institutional Name Disambiguation
• Impact O ti i ti
I t Optimization
• Assessment Approaches
• Internal Research Assessment
• Expertise Profiling
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 24 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

25. Research Needs and Services Grid
• Map the research support landscape
• research activities
• examples of the services that exist to support them
• RLG Partnership Council support
• RLG RIM interest group, not so much
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 25 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

26. John MacColl and Ricky Erway
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
The high-level view of the Research Information
Institutional research output and assessment (services performed on behalf of the institution)
Peer revie
ew
ng
Dataminin
Assess
Exporting statistics
)
Individual reputation management (services performed on behalf of the scholar)
Research output
metrics
Publishing Output : grant ratio
Share
Teaching Optimize
discoverability
The researcher's workflow (services to support the scholar's work)
Data sharing Share Output to other
es
repositorie
Right
ts Publication
agement
Mana Open Acc
cess
Archiving phy
Bibliograp
Management Workflow
26
Writin
ng Long term
m
Create
preservation
Revieewing & Info asset
Retain
rating
g stewardshhip
Desc cribing Back-up
Analy
yzing Asses Inform tenure
m Persistent t
s
pro
ocess identifiers
Anno
otating ( Rights
Organizing Increased visibility Centers of
f
Gather
on Web excellence
e
g
Share
Acquiring Output se
ervices Placemen of grads
nt
Colle
ecting Public da
atabase Start-ups, spin-offs
Keep ping Identify e
expertise ontent
Acquire co
Collect
Discover curreent
Research
Analy
Strucctured Expert pr
rofiling Name authority
ze
findin
ng control
Collaaborative Authorita
ative ontrol
Quality co
findin
ng metadataa
Seren ndipitous Assembling data Input
Collect
findin
ng
Fun
Grant process Datamini
ing Faculty de
eposit
d

27. RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 27 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

28. RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 28 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

29. Personal Name Consistency
Investigate personal name consistency possibilities, by
doing one or more of the following:
• Refine use cases
• C
Compare related efforts at other i tit ti
l t d ff t t th institutions and d
organizations
• Conduct a p
C personal name disambiguation p j
g project
that would get us closer to a name server that could
be used by a variety of applications
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 29 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

30. Expertise Profiling
Assess various approaches to expertise profiling
• Ways of gathering data
• Intended uses
• Policy issues
• Outputs for other uses
• Compare institutional to discipline profiles
• Commercial approaches
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 30 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

31. Comments?
• Report on Scholarly Information Practices
• WRAP consultancy
• Possible joint investigation with RIN
• Projects with the RLG Partnership
j p
• Testing the desirability of research services
• A RIM manifesto
• Role of libraries in data curation
• Changing roles of library staff
• D f
Deferred projects
d j t
• Welcome your input
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 31 John MacColl and Ricky Erway

32. Resources
Research Information Management Program
www.oclc.org/programs/ourwork/researchinfo
gp g
OCLC Research White Papers
www.oclc.org/programs/publications/reports.htm
Ricky Erway erwayr@oclc.org
Ri k E l
John MacColl maccollj@oclc.org
RLG Partnership Meeting – June 2, 2009
Research 32 John MacColl and Ricky Erway