3. Foreword
Mark Foster
Group Chief Executive
Management Consulting &
Integrated Markets
Accenture
Globalization remains a durable and
constant presence in the headlines.
Recent turbulence shows only
too clearly that today’s markets
are extensively integrated and
interdependent, and that exploitation
of the global economy is characterized
equally by risk and opportunity.
More than ever before, business
executives from all regions on the
planet recognize that their responses
to the multi-polar world—where
economic power is increasingly
diffused across multiple countries
and regions—can be powerful drivers
of lasting company performance. Yet
there are few experienced navigators
of this new economic geography
and little consensus on the strategic
imperatives. Across the world, clients
tell me they are seeking a new
compass to help chart this latest stage
of multi-directional globalization and
insights into the options they have to
respond to short-term pressures while
investing for longer-term growth.
Accenture’s High Performance
Business research program, now
in its sixth year, focuses on the
attributes that a high-performance
business must not only attain but
also constantly balance and realign in
the face of changing circumstances.
The manifest changes in the external
business environment brought about
by the rise of the multi-polar world
drove us to integrate our high-
performance business thinking with
our ongoing research program into
this current phase of globalization.
We wanted to understand how
the economic trends shaping the
multi-polar world might also alter
the best practices and common
attributes behind high performance.
This report, the third in our Multi-Polar
World series, distills the findings of
primary and secondary research into
how high-performance businesses have
been evolving their business strategy
in response to the multi-polar world.
It offers persuasive evidence that high
performers from both the developed
and emerging markets do globalization
differently—in the way they create
focused geographic options, weave
themselves authentically into local
business ecosystems, and network
their organizations to allow the
rapid mobility of people and ideas.
There can be no set path for success
in a globalizing world. This report
therefore presents not a checklist
of actions but rather a playbook of
options to open up opportunity. It
sets out emerging best practices
and leading management ideas on
which companies from across the
globe can draw as they shape and
update their business strategy.
We hope the report will act as a
spur to the next stage of global
competitive endeavor as organizations
emerge from the current marketplace
turmoil and seek to become resilient
and agile leaders in a volatile
and interdependent world.
Mark Foster
Group Chief Executive
Management Consulting &
Integrated Markets
Accenture
3
4. Executive Summary
In 2008, the world acknowledged that
globalization had changed. Investors
and consumers beheld an increasingly
multi-polar global economy in which
risk and volatility went hand-in-
hand with emerging growth and
opportunity. Deeper integration of
markets meant that economic and
financial shocks were transmitted
across national boundaries more
rapidly than ever before. No longer
could businesses—however seemingly
local or insulated—assert immunity
from global interdependence.
Economic slowdown hastens the
search for cost efficiency, added
flexibility and new sources of
earnings growth in a more financially
constrained future. Paradoxically, it
is precisely by engaging purposefully
with the multi-polar world—which
has heightened and amplified
business risk as well as creating
opportunities—that companies can
find important elements of their
strategic response to the downturn,
while positioning themselves to
benefit from longer-term trends.
The multi-polar world is an arena of
dynamic shifts in economic power and
influence. Globalization has become
multidirectional, driven by advances
in information and communications
technologies, greater economic
openness, and the growing size and
geographic reach of multinational
companies. Emerging markets clearly
play an important role in this new
era, no longer passive recipients but
active shapers of globalization.
This new economic backdrop suggests
an urgent new layer of business
imperatives. What to do? Where to
begin? In the face of opportunities
matched by chronic volatility,
how can businesses achieve high
performance in a multi-polar world?
How should they use economic
geography to consistently outperform
their industry peers over multiple
economic and industry cycles?
To understand how companies can
harness the opportunities of the multi-
polar world, Accenture conducted
extensive research into the strategies
followed by high-performance
businesses across a range of countries
and industries in each of the five
defining dimensions of the multi-
polar world: new consumers, talent,
innovation, resource sustainability
and capital. We surveyed business
leaders from 375 companies,
representing all major industries and
53 developed and emerging markets.
We found that high-performance
businesses join battle in new and
distinctive ways in each of these
competitive and interdependent
dimensions of the multi-polar world.
In the way they create geographic
options, weave themselves into
multiple local markets, and sustain
a strong global operating model to
propel people and know-how across
a smart, enabling organization,
these companies are writing a new
playbook for globalization—one
that will help businesses withstand
short-term pressures while laying the
groundwork for growth in the upturn.
4
5. High Performance:
A globalization playbook
Evidence from our research
demonstrates that high-performance
businesses distinguish themselves
with a globalization strategy that
is conceived and executed in a new
and consistently different way. They
discover new fulcrums of growth,
cost efficiency and risk management
in the multi-polar world, develop
them and work them into the
fabric of their businesses. Across all
dimensions of the multi-polar world,
high-performance businesses are
guided by three central maxims:
Create geographic options
High-performance businesses
proactively and continually explore
new geographic sources of value.
They constantly look outward, sensing
their business environment (and that
of their value-chain partners) and
making focused choices about where
to compete and whom to engage. No
two markets are the same. Companies
often need to go to multiple
markets to find what they need, be
it talent, capital or raw materials.
Lessons from high performers:
• Reach out to potential customers
in overseas markets with new
business models, channels and
infrastructure investment that
unlock otherwise latent demand.
• Source talent wherever it may
exist geographically, as well as from
sectors of the population that may
have been overlooked previously, such
as women and rural workforces.
• Identify emerging centers
of excellence in different
technologies, products and
processes around the world.
• Build resource input security
via term contracts, upstream
acquisitions and investment in
diversified geographical sources
to minimize supply disruptions
and cost fluctuations.
• Improve access to capital
and diversify risk by updating
knowledge, relationships and
financing models to reflect the new
map of global investment flows.
Be authentically local
Although searching for value
in emerging markets is a cross-
border task, unlocking that value
is a local exercise. As tastes,
customs, regulations—and political
environments—differ widely, high
performers embed themselves with
full commitment in their chosen
local and regional markets as
they execute their strategies.
Lessons from high performers:
• Identify critical local differences
in consumer preferences and usage
and, in response, tailor products and
services to new consumer segments.
• Develop and mold local talent for
today and tomorrow by investing
across the skills spectrum.
• Embed innovation activities into
the local research and development
and consumer environment,
working in tandem with industry
peers and policymakers.
• Optimize resources strategy
under differing economic, cultural
and regulatory constraints across
markets and harness incentive
regimes, such as carbon trading,
for current and new business.
• Be willing to draw on a broad suite
of investment models tailored to the
characteristics of different markets.
Network the organization
Acting on knowledge from around the
world and executing company strategy
in multiple locations requires the
ability to transfer people, resources,
capital and know-how to the right
places at the right time. Creating
organizations that are permeable, both
internally and externally, enables flows
of people, ideas and best practices.
Lessons from high performers:
• Create structured channels to allow
rapid diffusion of ideas and know-
how across geographic regions.
• Build a global backbone of
standardized data, systems and
processes.
• Ensure multi-polar leadership
to cultivate a global mindset
from the top down.
Global choices for
global challenges
These lessons from high performers
are often grounded in a mastery of
business basics. Current realities
demand a focus on the basics—but
in an inescapably global arena. By
learning from the choices made
by high performers as part of their
multi-polar strategies, businesses
can find new ways to counter short-
term pressures while setting a path
for sustained high performance
in the recovery and beyond.
5
6. The last decade has illustrated vividly
both faces of the multi-polar world.
For much of the period, efficiency
gains, stable prices and sustained
economic growth owed much to
reduced economic distance and
tighter interdependence of markets.
Yet these very same forces have more
recently served to broaden and amplify
the current financial and economic
turbulence. The events of 2008
proved that no economy—however
seemingly local or insulated—is
truly immune from the forces of the
multi-polar world. Economies have
been rocked by a combination of
a credit crunch, slowing economic
growth and volatility in prices and
input costs. Banks failed despite being
thousands of miles and dozens of
decisions away from the underlying
bad investments. Record rises—and
then record falls—were seen in the
prices of oil and other commodities.
Emerging markets, along with
developed markets, are feeling the
effects of the current financial and
economic turbulence, particularly
as investors adjust global portfolios.
But with their growth anchored
in generally resilient economic
fundamentals—including income
and population growth, lower
costs and generally sound policy—
emerging markets are expected to
generate all of the expansion in
the global economy in 2009.1
Above all, for the company executive,
recent events show that company
strategy cannot be divorced from
the evolving multi-polar business
environment. Like it or not, global
economics affects companies’
performance, and companies can no
longer sit on the sidelines. Rather
than simply responding defensively—
protecting their position in increasingly
contested markets—businesses can
actively harness the multi-polar
world for their long-term benefit.
For multinational companies, as
for national economies, markets
beyond traditional borders can
cushion the impact of a slowdown
at home. A multi-polar approach
can give businesses the flexibility
to counter short-term pressures
while better managing future risks
and creating durable, competitive
cost structures, all of which produce
capacity for rapid expansion during a
recovery. Therefore, it is crucial that
businesses understand and evaluate
their options in exploiting economic
geography. By harnessing five dynamic
dimensions—new consumers, talent,
innovation, resource sustainability and
capital—multinational businesses can
achieve long-term growth as well as
shorter-term flexibility. (See page 7
for more detail on these dimensions.)
So how can businesses use the levers
of the multi-polar world to achieve
high performance? To begin to
answer these questions, Accenture
conducted extensive research into the
geographic strategies being followed
by high-performance businesses
across a range of countries and
industries. (See pages 9 and 33 for
an explanation of the criteria we
use to define high performance.) We
surveyed 375 companies, including
45 high-performance businesses. Our
survey sampled companies in all major
Multi-polar world:
Opportunity amidst volatility
6
7. The multi-polar
world
Accenture uses the term “multi-
polar world” to describe the diffusion
of economic power in the global
economy across a wider range of
regions and countries, underpinned by
the three key drivers of information
technology, greater economic
openness, and the growing size and
reach of multinational companies.
Many of these new poles of economic
activity and influence are to be found
in the emerging world—notably
the “Big 6” emerging economies
(Brazil, China, India, Mexico, Russia
and South Korea)—but also include
a wave of next-tier emergers.
Together with the more established
centers of economic activity, these
economies are radically reshaping
the economic geography in which
businesses must operate. Accenture
first explored the characteristics
and drivers of this new phase of
globalization in its 2007 study titled
The Rise of the Multi-Polar World.
The canvas of the multi-polar world
also features a large and increasingly
diverse cast of public and private
players operating and competing
alongside traditional, developed-
market multinationals. Chief among
these are the emerging-market
multinationals, which have become
increasingly prominent as they
expand their international activities.
These companies were the subject
of Accenture’s 2008 study titled
The Rise of the Emerging-Market
Multinational. Sovereign wealth
funds—state-backed entities that
invest surplus foreign reserves
overseas—have also become important
players in the arena of global capital.
Accenture has identified five
increasingly competitive and
interdependent dimensions to the
multi-polar world—new consumers,
talent, innovation, resource
sustainability and capital—that
multinational businesses can harness
for short-term flexibility and long-
term growth. These dimensions
may be thought of as markets
spanning emerging and developed
economies in which companies
operate and need to compete.
New consumers
Many emerging markets continue to
enjoy impressive growth in consumer
spending, bolstered by long-term
fundamentals such as population
growth, an emerging middle class
of aspirational consumers, rising per
capita incomes and greater credit
availability. Retail sales in China
continue to grow at around 20 percent
per year.2
Goldman Sachs projects that
rising incomes could lift an additional
2 billion people into the global middle
class—defined as those with annual
incomes between US$6,000 and
US$30,000—by 2030.3
These new
sources of consumer spending can help
businesses counteract sagging demand
in Western economies and build a base
of new consumers for the upturn.
Talent
While many Western economies
are grappling with the effects of
contracting workforces and specialized
skills shortages, emerging-market
workforces are set to expand
dramatically. Between 2008 and
2015, the working-age population of
emerging economies is expected to
increase by more than 400 million,
compared with an increase of only
7 million in developed economies.4
While the vast labor reserves of
China and India have been amply
chronicled by many commentators,
less-well-known pockets of talent
have sprung up in many other parts
of the emerging world. For example,
more than half of Vietnam’s 84 million
population is under 25 years old, 83
percent of all graduates are science-
based, and the country’s labor pool
has around 80,000 IT graduates, a
figure increasing by 9,000 per year.5
Innovation
Innovation is no longer the exclusive
province of developed markets. A
combination of investment, education
and a strategic policy focus on
new technologies has spurred the
development of new clusters of
innovation in emerging economies.
Witness the rise of nanotechnologies
and biotech in Beijing, digital media
and genomics in Seoul, biofuels in
Brazil and automotive technologies
in Poland. As companies look to drive
new sources of revenue during the
recovery, a critical factor will be
their ability to distribute innovation
activities in a way that reflects this
fast-changing map of innovation.
Resource sustainability
After several years of soaring demand
and record price levels backed in part
by emerging-economy demand, global
commodity prices have dramatically
reversed direction as the economic
slowdown squeezes demand. While
rising commodity prices created
additional costs for business, falling
prices may undermine investment in
exploration and long-term supply, as
well as alternative sources, leading
to higher prices in the future. Either
way, and with continued geopolitical
uncertainty and global trading of
commodities, it is clear that a new
era of chronic volatility in resource
price levels has arrived. Thanks to
global commodity markets and
optimized supply chains, companies
feel the effects more quickly than
ever before. At the same time, the
prospect of a carbon-constrained
world means that businesses will be
faced with something closer to the
full economic cost of their resource-
intensive activities. The challenge for
companies sourcing critical inputs is
to find the right balance of supply
security, price stability, efficiency gains
and decarbonization. The challenge
for companies supplying resources
is to help them find this balance.
Capital
In the aftermath of the sub-prime
financial crisis, companies need
to survey the altered landscape of
investment capital sources. Pools
of capital are increasingly visible
in the emerging world—not only in
nascent capital markets but also
via a new cast of players such as
emerging-market multinationals
and sovereign wealth funds. With
approximately US$5 trillion in assets
under management,6
sovereign
wealth funds dwarf private equity
and could reach US$10 trillion by
2012,7
according to some estimates.
7
8. Reach out to
potential customers
in overseas markets
with new business
models, channels
and infrastructure
investment that
unlock otherwise
latent demand
Source talent
wherever it may exist
geographically, as
well as from sectors
of the population
that may have been
overlooked
previously, such as
women and rural
workforces
Identify emerging
centers of excellence
in different
technologies,
products and
processes around
the world
Build resource input
security via term
contracts, upstream
acquisitions and
investment in
diversified
geographical sources
Improve access to
capital and diversify
risk by updating
knowledge,
relationships and
financing models to
reflect the new map
of global investment
flows
Identify critical local
differences in
consumer
preferences and
usage and, in
response, tailor
products and
services to new
consumer segments
Be
authentically
local
Create
geographic
options
Resource
sustainability
CapitalInnovationNew consumers Talent
Develop and mold
local talent for today
and tomorrow by
investing across the
skills spectrum
Embed innovation
activities into the
local research and
development and
consumer
environment, working
in tandem with
industry peers and
policymakers
Optimize resources
strategy under
differing economic,
cultural and
regulatory
constraints across
markets and harness
incentive regimes,
such as carbon
trading, for current
and new business
Be willing to draw
on a broad suite of
investment models
tailored to the
characteristics of
different markets
Network the
organization
Create structured channels to allow rapid diffusion of ideas and know-how across geographic regions
Build a global backbone of standardized data, systems and processes
Ensure multi-polar leadership to cultivate a global mindset from the top down
industries, drawn from 53 developed
and emerging markets. We asked
questions about their current and
recent interventions in each of the
five battlegrounds of the multi-polar
world. In this report, we focused on
identifying differences between high
and low performers. (See page 9 for
more information about the survey.)
Strategies for achieving
high performance in a
multi-polar world
This report sets out our findings in the
form of a playbook—of emerging best
practices and leading management
ideas—for doing business in a multi-
polar world. Crucially, our survey
found strong evidence that high-
performance businesses, as distinct
from their low-performance peers,
do globalization differently. We
found that in each dimension of the
multi-polar world, whether scouting
for new ideas or tailoring existing
products to reach new consumers,
high performers recognize and
act on a number of imperatives
central to their success. Across all
battlegrounds, high-performance
businesses follow a balanced strategy
guided by three central maxims:
Create geographic options
High-performance businesses
proactively and continually explore
new geographic sources of value.
They constantly look outward, sensing
their business environment (and that
of their value chain partners) and
making focused choices about where
to compete and whom to engage.
Be authentically local
As tastes, customs, regulations and
political environments differ widely,
high performers embed themselves
with full commitment in their
chosen local and regional markets
as they execute their strategy.
Network the organization
High performers improve the flow of
ideas, people and capital across the
business by creating organizations
with permeable internal and
external boundaries. Technology
will play an increasingly important
role in creating and sustaining
the networked organization.
Generally, as companies learn
to embrace new information
technology—such as cloud computing,
collaborative media, smartphones
and comprehensive, cross-business
data analysis—they will find new,
quicker and cheaper ways of
competing in the five dimensions
of the multi-polar world and
networking their organization.
8
9. Survey and research
methodology
This report draws on two major
research components. First,
Accenture undertook extensive
secondary research into the global
strategies and operations of more
than 100 companies between
March and November 2008.
Second, Accenture conducted a
quantitative survey to discover
how companies are shaping their
strategies in response to the latest
trends in economic globalization.
The fieldwork was carried out via an
online worldwide survey, conducted
between August and October 2008.
The survey contained extensive
questions on a wide variety of topics,
including growth, investments,
innovation and talent management.
Survey participants included a
sample of companies analyzed
in Accenture’s High Performance
Business research, as well as a large
number of additional companies.
The survey was completed by 375
companies, including 45 high-
performance and 35 low-performance
businesses. (See below, and page 33,
for more information on underlying
definitions and methodology.)
All respondents held a position
of influence with regard to their
companies’ strategy and operations
in different parts of the world. Most
companies cited a home market
(or main market) in Asia-Pacific
(29 percent), Western Europe (28
percent) or North America (26
percent). The other companies came
from Eastern Europe, Latin America,
the Middle East and Africa. Over
80 percent of companies operated
in multiple countries. The survey
sample included companies with a
wide range of annual revenues, from
less than US$500 million to more
than US$10 billion. Responses were
distributed across a broad range
of industries including financial
services, communications and high-
tech, resources, consumer goods, and
professional and business services.
The survey results can be accessed
online at www.accenture.com/mpw
What is a
high-performance
business?
Accenture defines high-performance
businesses as those that:
• Effectively balance current
needs and future opportunities;
• Consistently outperform peers in
revenue growth, profitability and
total return to shareholders; and
• Sustain their superiority across
time, business cycles, industry
disruptions and changes in leadership.
For full details of Accenture’s High
Performance Business methodology,
which we apply to publicly listed
companies, see page 33. Future
developments of the methodology
will encompass enterprises from a
wider range of ownership models,
including the non-publicly-listed
enterprises that are commonly
found in emerging markets.
In October 2008, a snapshot of
our ongoing High Performance
Business research revealed 12
percent of the 963 companies
analyzed were high performers.
At the other end of the performance
scale sit “low-performance businesses.”
Eleven percent of the 963 companies
analyzed were low performers.
Most executives aspire to high
performance, yet relatively few
companies actually meet Accenture’s
definition. Accenture’s High
Performance Business research
program—now in its sixth year—has
been recognized by Harvard
Business Review as one of the 10
most notable initiatives in the field
during the past quarter century.8
Grounded in extensive analysis,
the initiative aims to identify the
characteristics and capabilities of
high-performance businesses so that
Accenture can help organizations
attain and maintain that status using
integrated and aligned offerings.
9
10. Creating geographic options
High-performance businesses
proactively and continually explore
new geographic sources of value. This
is particularly important in times of
economic turbulence, in which lower-
cost opportunities around the world
become increasingly attractive. High
performers constantly look outward,
sensing their business environment
(and that of their value chain partners)
and making focused choices about
where to compete and whom to
engage. They recognize that no two
markets are the same and that they
may need to go to multiple markets
to find what they need, be it talent,
capital or raw materials.
Accenture research shows that high-
performance businesses draw on a rich
arsenal of best practices to find and
give shape to new sources of value—
whether by unlocking growth, cutting
costs or controlling risks—in chosen
dimensions of the multi-polar world.
10
11. New consumers
Bridging to customers
across the globe
Eighty-six percent of companies
we surveyed reported that they are
looking to boost sales beyond their
home markets. Rapid growth and
development, particularly in emerging
markets, make an attractive proposition
for companies seeking revenue
growth in the future. A well-managed
portfolio of developed and emerging
markets also will help counteract
the shorter-term challenges posed
by slowdowns in some economies.
But companies struggle to access
these new customers in overseas
markets. Respondents told us that
among the challenges they face
in reaching new consumers are
inadequate distribution networks,
inadequate infrastructure and weak
marketing channels. In the face of these
obstacles, how do high-performance
businesses reach new customers?
First, they tap base-of-the-pyramid
demand. Nokia, working with the
Grameen Foundation and Siemens,
created the “Village Phone” program
to provide mobile access to remote
villages in Uganda and Rwanda.9
The program, which can reduce the
cost of owning a mobile phone to
US$3 per month, involves a local
entrepreneur who acquires subscribers,
an operator who offers services and a
microfinancier who procures a network
access point that supports 70 Nokia
handsets. (See case study on page 14.)
Second, they build infrastructure to
overcome the effects of geographic
distance—bringing markets closer.
One-third of the high-performance
businesses we surveyed do this to a
significant or great extent, compared
with 22 percent of low-performance
businesses. América Móvil deployed
wireless technology in Latin America
to reach out to clients who previously
lacked wireless coverage, investing
heavily in customers, coverage,
capacity and technology. As a result,
wireless penetration in Argentina has
reached 100 percent, from a base
of 19 percent when the company
entered the country in 2003.10
Third, they use apparently unorthodox
distribution and marketing channels
to reach previously under-served
customer groups. Norwegian media firm
Schibsted uses market developments
and its specialist expertise to capture
positions in its more peripheral markets
such as Italy, Austria, Singapore and
Russia.11
Despite the dominance of
television advertising in Russia—one of
the world’s fastest-growing advertising
markets—Schibsted’s efficiently
distributed free newspaper, Moi Rayon,
has created a new market, becoming
St. Petersburg’s most-read newspaper.12
And in a move away from its traditional
Web-based retail model, Dell now
also uses physical stores to sell and
distribute its products in countries with
comparatively low Internet usage.13
Business imperative
Reach under-served
customers
Reach out to potential customers
in overseas markets with new
business models, channels and
infrastructure investment that
unlock otherwise latent demand.
Talent
Finding the right people
around the world
Businesses seek strategies that
address long-term talent shortages
while providing flexibility to manage
the effects of the economic cycle
in the short term. Economic, social
and demographic trends, especially
in emerging markets, provide
opportunities to harness new pools of
talent now and for the future. High-
performance businesses realize this
and already are active in discovering
talent. Forty-four percent of high-
performance businesses in our survey
told us that accessing new talent pools
drives their investments in foreign
markets to a significant or great
extent, compared with just 20 percent
of low-performance businesses.
As a result, high performers
have workforces that are more
geographically widespread than
their low-performance counterparts.
More than three-quarters of high
performers have workforces located
in more than one country, compared
with less than half of low performers.
Fifty-one percent of high performers
(versus 34 percent of low performers)
are more likely to seek to expand their
workforce in foreign markets, both
by increasing the number of markets
where they recruit and by expanding
in markets where they already recruit.
How do high performers find the talent
they need in a multi-polar world?
Although both high-performance
and low-performance businesses use
international external recruiters as part
of their talent management strategy,
our survey found that high performers
draw on a wider range of recruitment
tools (Figure 1). High performers aim
to access the best people by tapping
into under-represented talent pools
and reaching diaspora populations.
Three out of four high performers
target under-represented talent pools,
such as women and rural populations,
compared with two out of four low
performers. Avon, one of the first
direct-selling firms to be granted a
license by the Chinese government,
successfully targeted women when
recruiting more than 560,000 active
representatives in China in 2007.14
This move caused its revenues in the
country to surge by 32 percent in just
one year.15
More than three-quarters
of high performers also recruit from
national diasporas, compared with less
than two-thirds of low performers.
All high-performance businesses we
surveyed also build links with local
universities and research institutes as
sources of interns and new recruits,
compared with 59 percent of low-
performance businesses. The high
performers are also more likely than
low performers to use innovative,
non-conventional recruiting
methods, such as competitions
and word-of-mouth strategies.
High performers are even alert to the
possibilities offered by talent pools
beyond their immediate operational
boundaries. Fifty-seven percent of high
performers reported that they actively
recruit from markets where they have
no operations or sales, compared
with 39 percent of low performers.
Business imperative
Discover emergent talent
Source talent wherever it may
exist—geographically as well as
from sectors of the population
that may have been overlooked
previously, such as women
and rural workforces.
11
12. 0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
%
High performers Low performers
Use international
external recruiters
Build links with local
universities and
research institutes
Target under-
represented talent
pools
Use non-conventional
recruiting
channels/networks
Recruit from
national diasporas
Recruit from where
business has no
operations or sales
Innovation
Scouting the world
for the best ideas
As hubs of innovation spring up in new
and unexpected locations, whether
organically or assisted by the policies of
specific cities or regions, companies can
find it difficult to keep up and address
the opportunities that this shifting
pattern presents. Innovation occurs
increasingly beyond the boundaries
of the enterprise, making it necessary
to look for new product, service and
business-model ideas in emerging
and developed markets alike. A good
external radar for innovation is critical.
High performers are more likely to
pursue geographically distributed
innovation. Our survey found that 58
percent of high performers source
innovation from more than one country,
compared with 34 percent of low
performers. Moreover, nearly three
times as many high performers look to
expand innovation in foreign markets
where they already source it than do
low performers. High-performance
businesses told us that the three main
advantages of expanding research and
development (R&D) in foreign markets
are the availability of leading-edge
expertise and specialized knowledge,
the presence of R&D clusters and
centers of excellence, and lower costs.
High-performance businesses look far
and wide for innovation in a variety
of ways. Nokia taps outside talent
via “Forum Nokia,” a portal available
in English, Chinese and Japanese, to
give developers from around the world
access to resources to help them
design, test, certify, market and sell
their own applications, content, services
or websites to mobile users via Nokia
devices.16
(See case study on page 14.)
Venture capital funds are another
increasingly popular way to discover
innovation. ArcelorMittal launched
two venture capital funds in July 2008
to find solutions for environmental
challenges.17
The first fund aims to
support the commercialization of
clean-energy technologies, while the
second fund manages €100 million
with the goal of engaging in the carbon
market and promoting climate-friendly
solutions for the steel industry.
High performers also listen to
local customers as a key source of
ideas for products, services and
business models. In fact, they are
more than twice as likely as low
performers (39 percent versus 16
percent) to seek input for innovation
processes from local customers
to a significant or great extent.
Recognizing the importance of
intellectual property rights to the
commercialization process, high
performers invest time in researching
and navigating intellectual property
laws in foreign markets. Half of the
high performers we surveyed reported
that they do this to a significant or
great extent, compared with only
about one-third of low performers.
Business imperative
Scout nascent innovation hubs
Identify emerging centers
of excellence in different
technologies, products and
processes around the world.
Figure 1. High-performance businesses reach out to new talent pools in a variety of ways
Which of the following steps is your company taking in foreign markets where it aims to expand its workforce?
12
13. Resource sustainability
Ensuring access to
essential inputs
Economic, geopolitical and regulatory
factors cause unpredictable swings
in the supply, demand and prices of
key commodities. Since 2002, the
prices of primary commodities had
been soaring, driven by the relatively
strong and stable performance of
the world economy. But the current
economic downturn is causing a
downswing in commodity prices.
Falling commodity prices reduce costs
for commodity users in the short
term but, paradoxically, may lead
to higher prices in the future due to
reduced investment in production
and exploration today. The prospect
of continued scarcity and volatility in
resources markets impels businesses
to secure their supplies even as prices
are falling. The high-performance
businesses we surveyed told us
their greatest resources challenges
over the next three years will be
higher input costs, greater cost
volatility and threat of supply
disruption, along with a changing
regulatory and policy environment.
High-performance businesses source
inputs globally to mitigate risks
and remain cost-efficient. Forty-
four percent diversify geographic
sources of inputs to a significant
or great extent, compared with
28 percent of low-performance
businesses (Figure 2). US-based
Danaher purchases raw materials—
including steel, copper, cast iron,
electronic components, aluminum,
plastics and other petroleum-based
products—from a large number
of independent sources around
the world.18
South Africa’s Anglo
Platinum searches for new sources
of raw material around existing
operations in the country’s Bushveld
Complex, where new exploration
permits were granted.19
However,
after encouraging exploration results,
the company also began drilling
in Danba in southern China and in
Murmansk Oblast in western Russia.20
Spanish utility Iberdrola imports
liquefied natural gas from seven
countries—Nigeria, Algeria, Egypt,
Qatar, Trinidad and Tobago, Libya
and Norway—to ensure a diversified
and flexible supply of natural gas.21
(See case study on page 15.)
In addition to diversifying sources
of inputs, high performers find
different varieties of inputs. Forty-
four percent search for new types
of raw materials and inputs to a
significant or great extent, compared
with just 22 percent of their low-
performance counterparts. One
example is Brazil’s Vale, the world’s
second-largest metals and mining
company, which has taken steps to
create its own energy supplies to
protect against instability of input
prices and to guarantee continuous
supply. Vale is a shareholder in eight
hydroelectric stations in Brazil and
also has hydroelectric facilities in
Canada and Indonesia.22
In seeking
low-carbon energy sources, Vale
has signed a memorandum of
understanding to explore for natural
gas in Mozambique in partnership
with Brazil’s national oil company,
Diversifying
geographic
sources of inputs
Searching for new
types of raw
materials/inputs
High performers Low performers
0
10
20
30
40
50
%
Figure 2. High performers are active in securing natural resource supplies
Is your company taking the following steps to a significant or great extent with
regard to natural resources?
13
14. Nokia
Who
The world’s number one manufacturer
of mobile devices, based in Finland.
Nokia had an estimated 38 percent
share of the global mobile device
market in 2007.23
Differentiator
Nokia instigated a major strategic
change in 1992 to generate a huge
sales increase outside Europe.24
By 2006, Nokia had sold more than
1 billion mobile phones around the
world.25
Today Nokia is a market
leader in emerging markets. Half
of its top 10 markets by sales are
emerging markets: China, India,
Russia, Indonesia and Brazil.26
Multi-polar focus
• Access new ideas through venture
capital and open innovation
• Hire locally to understand
emerging-market needs
• Tailor products to all price points
• Embed sustainability across
operations
Scout globally for new ideas
Nokia has a dedicated unit to identify
breakthrough ideas but also uses
a venture capital group to access
innovation.27
Nokia Growth Partners,
with offices in China, Finland, India
and the United States, manages
US$350 million for direct investments
and fund-of-fund investments in other
venture capital players, primarily in
the United States, Europe and Asia.28
One recent fund investment was in
Madhouse, which is China’s leading
mobile advertisement network.29
Tap into international research
and source new ideas and talent
through open innovation
Nokia’s open innovation model
taps two sources of expertise.
First, the company partners with
leading international universities.
Nokia’s Research Center in the
United Kingdom, for example, works
with the University of Cambridge,
developing nanotechnologies for
mobile communication and ambient
intelligence.30
Second, Nokia makes
abundant use of the Internet to
source new ideas and talent. Company
wikis post the progress of current
projects.31
A “beta labs” website plays
host to hundreds of thousands of
testers who provide feedback on new
and potential applications.32
“Forum
Nokia,” a portal available in English,
Chinese and Japanese, gives outside
developers access to resources to help
them design, test, certify, market and
sell their own applications, content,
services or websites to mobile users via
Nokia devices.33
Understand markets through
local hires
Nokia taps into local talent in selected
markets to help the company better
tailor its products and services. Nokia’s
research center in Beijing was set up
to take advantage of China’s fast-
growing economy, the world’s largest
mobile phone market, the country’s
dynamism and the region’s top-level
universities.34
Nokia also has a research
team in Bangalore that focuses on
emerging-market services, particularly
for urban and rural India.35
The group
studies mobile banking and the needs
of base-of-the-pyramid communities,
among other topics. Nokia mostly hires
local people in Bangalore and uses the
whole of India as a stage for research
while collaborating with MIT’s Media
Lab and Bangalore’s Srishti School of
Art, Design and Technology. Beyond
traditional R&D skill sets, Nokia uses
designers, economists, engineers and
social scientists on the ground to gain
insights into low-income consumers.
Create tailored products and
services
In China, Nokia has introduced low-
priced mobile phones to tap into
less-wealthy markets in small cities
and rural areas while introducing high-
end mobile phones to woo corporate
users.36
Nokia also creates tailored
services. The Mobiledu service in China
teaches English and offers more than
6,000 courses accessible anywhere to
people on the move who don’t need to
carry books or other materials—ideal
for a market where demand exists for
just-in-time learning.37
The service
had 300,000 users during its first six
months. Innovations like these have
helped the company become the
number one brand in Asia.38
Reach out to new customer
groups
Nokia Research Africa’s
multidisciplinary team works with
non-governmental organizations and
universities in Kenya, South Africa
and Uganda to better understand
the needs of African mobile phone
users.39
Nokia also works with the
Grameen Foundation and Siemens
to provide mobile access to remote
village communities. The “Village
Phone” program, operating in
Uganda and Rwanda, involves a local
entrepreneur who acquires subscribers,
an operator who offers services, and a
microfinancier who procures a network
access point that supports 70 Nokia
handsets.40
The program can reduce
the cost of owning a mobile phone to
approximately US$3 per month.
Influence value chain partners to
be sustainable
Nokia aims to influence a number of
stakeholders to conserve resources.
Its sustainability research program
works with research institutes such as
the Center for Corporate Citizenship
at Boston College and the Haas
Center for Responsible Business at
the University of Berkeley, as well as
industry bodies, including the World
Business Council for Sustainable
Development and StEP (Solving the
E-waste Problem).41
Since January
2008, Nokia has worked with the
WWF (formerly known as the World
Wildlife Fund) and with businesses to
show leadership in addressing climate
change through its membership
of the “Climate Savers” program.42
Nokia also has “greened” its supply
chain, insisting that all suppliers
meet international environmental
management standards.43
In addition,
Nokia provides environmental
content to encourage customers to
act responsibly green. One program,
featuring films on sustainability from
the Cannes Film Festival, attracted
240,000 young filmmakers in its first
three months to make films using
one of Nokia’s phones.44
Some phones
are even equipped to find the closest
recycling service point.
14
15. Iberdrola
Who
Spanish utility that aims to become
a global leader in renewable energy.
It is now the world’s fourth-
largest utility in terms of market
capitalization, up from its ranking as
19th in 2001.45
Recent acquisitions
central to the company’s growth
have included ScottishPower and
Energy East in the United States.46,47
Differentiator
Iberdrola has shifted its focus
from conventional generation to
renewables, a position the company
aims to strengthen while continuing to
invest in clean-generation technology.
Current investment plans emphasize
organic growth, with nearly 50 percent
in renewables and 65 percent of
the rest occurring outside Spain.48
Multi-polar focus
• Expand energy sources
• Consolidate position in
four core markets
• Access new sources of innovation
Diversify its generation base—
and thereby its customers’
power sources—with a specific
focus on renewables
By 2007, Iberdrola produced 31
percent of its power from combined-
cycle plants, 23 percent from
hydroelectric plants, 18 percent from
renewable energy, 18 percent from
thermal coal-fired and fuel oil/gas
plants, 8 percent from nuclear power
and 2 percent from combined heat
and power plants.49
Liquefied natural
gas imports from seven countries on
three continents ensure a diversified
and flexible supply of natural gas.50
Iberdrola’s main strategic focus is its
Renovables (renewables) subsidiary,
which is active in more than 20
countries and is on a path to more
than double its capacity by 2012.51
Renovables builds and operates
power plants and markets the power
they produce. This helps ensure that
42 percent of the company’s total
energy production is currently free
of carbon dioxide (CO2) and insulated
from the supply concerns and price
volatility of fossil fuel markets.52
Reinforce its position in
core strategic markets
The company’s strategic plan for
2008-2010 is multi-polar at its core,
aiming to consolidate Iberdrola’s
position in the company’s four main
regional markets: Iberia (Spain and
Portugal), the United Kingdom, the
United States and Latin America.53
Three main strategic guidelines
support achieving this objective: a
drive to improve operational efficiency
and to reduce the environmental
footprint of the different core
energy businesses; a continuous
effort to increase the quality of
supply and performance of network
activities to improve the reliability
of transmission and distribution
assets; and a more customer-centric
approach in retail activities to
improve service levels as liberalization
increases in the Iberian market and
the competitive environment in the
United Kingdom gets tougher.
Boost its access to innovation
inside and outside the company
Innovation initiatives at Iberdrola
are aligned with the key principles
of the company’s strategic plan,
aiming to improve the operating
and environmental efficiency of
energy operations. The company
is a leader is a number of areas,
including smart grids, as evidenced
by its work on the CRISALIDA project
(Convergence of Smart and Safe Grids
in Electric Applications Innovating in
Environmental Design); broadband
communications through electric
grids, an area where Iberdrola is
working to create the technology
standard; and protection and control
at electrical substations, for which
Iberdrola’s engineering subsidiary
in Mexico was awarded a 2007
technology and innovation prize
from the country’s Federal Electricity
Commission.54
Iberdrola looks to
share and promote its ideas with a
number of technological collaborators,
including manufacturers, universities
and technology centers. In 2007,
the company set up its own forum
explicitly for that purpose.55
In
addition, Renovables has established
an equity investment company,
Iberdrola Perseo, with an annual
budget of €6 million.56
It will support
renewable energy projects with a
high technology value, such as new
fuel sources and CO2 capture, helping
Iberdrola gain access to the latest
renewable energy technology.
15
16. Petrobras.57
In addition, Vale has
expanded its use of biodiesel, becoming
one of the world’s largest consumers
of the fuel, which is used to power
trains and trucks.58
These sources of
energy secure a valuable input for
the company and also diversify its
revenue structure, because surplus
power is sold to nearby customers.
To secure reliable supply, high-
performance businesses also undertake
upstream acquisitions and use term
contracts. Frontier, an American
airline, makes arrangements with
major fuel suppliers for substantial
portions of its fuel requirements.59
In light of rising coal prices, Anhui
Conch, a Chinese cement maker,
cooperates strategically with large coal
enterprises to widen its coal supply
channels and safeguard supply.60
French luxury retailer Hermès has
developed long-term relationships
with its partners and suppliers to
protect sources of supply as well as
critical know-how.61
In some cases
it will buy into carefully selected
companies to ensure the stability of
these relationships. Hermès acquired
stakes in watch-movement maker
Vaucher Manufacture Fleurier in
2006 and 2007 and in specialized raw
materials supplier Soficuir in 2007.62
Business imperative
Secure critical inputs
Build resource input security
via term contracts, upstream
acquisitions and investment in
diversified geographical sources
to minimize supply disruptions
and cost fluctuations.
Capital
Following the money
Few phenomena better exemplify the
rise of the multi-polar world than
the accumulation of new and deep
pools of investment capital in high-
saving economies in Asia and the
Middle East. Flush with petrodollars
and export earnings, these economies
play host to a new breed of sovereign
and private investors who will
increasingly shape the direction of
long-term capital movements.
At the same time, companies see their
traditional debt and equity financing
models under strain in the wake of the
financial turbulence that has beset
global capital markets since 2007.
Looking to emerging markets is a
natural component of many companies’
response. Indeed, emerging-market
multinationals may find themselves
in better stead as a result of their
proximity to new pools of capital as
well as historical ties. While many are
listed on developed-market exchanges,
companies based in emerging markets
often look to other sources, such
as family members or local stock
markets, as well as to sovereign wealth
funds and other state-run bodies.
Mapping the new landscape
of investment capital, building
appropriate investor relations
capacity, understanding differences
in accounting standards and adapting
financing models are all first steps
being taken by companies assessing
the short- and long-term opportunities
that the globalization of capital can
offer (Figure 3). Above all, being alert
High performers Low performers
Achieving a lower
cost of capital
Diversifying risk by
raising capital in
multiple currencies
and economies
Accessing
financial products
and services
unavailable
domestically
Creating business
opportunities from
relationships established
with foreign investors/
stakeholders/
governments
Gaining ready access
to local capital in
target markets
Building credibility
and prestige in
foreign markets to
aid other business
goals
%
0
10
20
30
40
50
Figure 3. High performers diversify risk by raising capital from abroad
What do you think are the main advantages to your company of raising new/more finance from foreign markets?
16
17. and open to the possibilities presented
by more dispersed capital sources will
create options to alleviate short-term
pressures and drive long-term growth.
In 2006, Indian builder Larsen &
Toubro (L&T) secured the longest
tenured external commercial
borrowing in Indian history, despite a
dramatic slowdown in infrastructure
lending.63
L&T’s deal set Indian
records for both its length of lending
term and the degree of leverage,
indicating the company’s heightened
standing in the global debt market.
Half the funding was internationally
sourced from the Abu Dhabi
Commercial Bank. The transaction
was so notable that it won the
prestigious Euromoney Project Finance
“Transport Deal of the Year” award.
Foreign listings will continue to be an
important source of investment capital
for companies seeking to expand. LAN
Airlines was the first Chilean company
to be listed on the New York Stock
Exchange and certified by the US
Securities and Exchange Commission
under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act.64
(See
case study on page 19.) Wherever they
are listed, high-performance businesses
realize the importance of maintaining
good reputations and strong investor
relations around the world.
Business imperative
Broaden geographic
sources of capital
Improve access to capital and
diversify risk by updating
knowledge, relationships and
financing models to reflect the new
map of global investment flows.
Technology will facilitate a
number of these strategies
Information technology will be
a significant tool for companies
looking to expand into new markets.
As companies become even more
Internet-oriented, they will draw
on cloud computing, which enables
technical capabilities—hardware,
software and storage—to be sourced
through the Internet across company
firewalls and national boundaries. No
longer will they be limited by their
internal and usually fixed technical
and business capabilities, whether they
are hardware, software or business
processes. Additional computing
capacity can be added as needed;
business processes can be shared and
integrated with business partners;
entry into emerging markets—often
with unpredictable demands—can be
accomplished more quickly without
long lead times or large fixed costs;
local and regional partners can
be accommodated; and business
continuity can be enhanced as
companies’ IT environments become
insulated against local shocks.
17
18. ArcelorMittal
Who
Luxembourg-headquartered steel
company created in 2006 from the
merger of Luxembourg’s Arcelor and
India’s Mittal Steel.
Differentiator
The world’s largest steel company,
ranked 39th on the 2008 Fortune
Global 500 and 17th in terms of
revenue growth.65
Multi-polar focus
• Invest in emerging markets
• Secure resources
• Partner for innovation
Source capital from multiple
locations …
ArcelorMittal is listed on nine different
stock exchanges and issues bonds in
both US dollars and euros.66,67
… to make strategic investments
that strengthen its global
businesses
The company now has an industrial
presence in 20 countries.68
In 2007
alone, ArcelorMittal conducted
nearly three dozen acquisitions.
Those in emerging markets included
Mexico’s Sicartsa, China’s Rongcheng
Chengshan Steelcord and Estonia’s
Galvex OÜ.69
The company also
acquired minority stakes in China
Oriental Group and Argentina’s
Acindar. Greenfield projects focus
on India, but also extend to Africa,
Southeast Asia, Russia and the Middle
East.70
Secure supply and demand
Other strategic transactions are
conducted to reinforce the company’s
strength upstream and downstream.
ArcelorMittal has acquired businesses
upstream to secure access to raw
material inputs around the world.
The company bought coal mines in
Russia, a majority stake in German
gas distributor Saar Ferngas, and a
minority equity stake in General Moly,
a US mineral development and mining
company.71
ArcelorMittal acquired
downstream businesses to strengthen
distribution channels and access to
worldwide markets. To reinforce its
position in the automotive products
and energy sectors, the company
acquired two French businesses
as well as Venezuela’s Unicon.72
In the stainless steel market, the
company acquired Uruguay’s Cinter
and announced the purchase of
outstanding shares in ArcelorMittal
Inox Brasil.73
It also acquired steel
distributors in Europe, Turkey and
Argentina.74
Deploy venture capital to find
the best “green” innovation in its
sector
ArcelorMittal launched two venture
capital funds in July 2008 to
find solutions for environmental
challenges.75
The first fund aims to
support the commercialization of
clean-energy technologies. Its first
investment, of US$20 million, was in
Miasole, a US company that produces
solar products. The second fund
manages €100 million with the goal
of engaging in the carbon market and
promoting climate-friendly solutions
for the steel industry.
Embed itself in the innovation
needs of its international
customers
The company has 14 research centers
in Europe and the Americas.76
It also
has developed a large partnership
network, including universities, major
customers and other industrial players.
In its automotive and appliances
segments, ArcelorMittal deploys
R&D teams to customers’ plants
to co-engineer innovative product
solutions.77
Conserve resources to minimize
cost and embed sustainability
The company seeks to maximize
recycling and energy efficiency.
Its plant in Tubarão, Brazil, is self-
sufficient in energy; gas recovery
generates all its electric power.78
The plant also is registered within
the Clean Development Mechanism
introduced by the Kyoto Protocol and
earns Certified Emission Reduction
credits that ArcelorMittal can sell
in global carbon markets.79
The
company’s internal energy-efficiency
team assessed 22 plants in 2007,
identifying potential energy savings
representing 10 percent of prevailing
consumption.80
The company also
supports projects to identify emission-
reduction opportunities in the industry.
Across its business, ArcelorMittal
reduced CO2 emissions by more than
20 percent between 1990 and 2007.81
It also undertakes water recycling
initiatives, especially in plants in
emerging economies.82
18
19. LAN Airlines
Who
Chile-based airline serving 60
destinations around the world, with
an extensive network within Latin
America and flights to North America,
Europe and the South Pacific.83
Differentiator
The company’s new domestic business
model, along with a premium long-
haul service, helped revenue, passenger
traffic and net income grow by more
than 15 percent in 2007.84
In the
second quarter of 2008, revenue
soared by 38.8 percent, outpacing
the airline’s 8.5 percent growth in
capacity.85
Multi-polar focus
• Recruit local talent
• Expand customer base
• Source capital overseas
Create a future talent supply …
Recognizing the need to prime the
pump of local, emerging-market
talent, LAN launched “Visit the Base,”
a program to acquaint young people
from various South American countries
with the airline’s operations.86
Participants experience the pre-
flight process, tour workshops and
hangars and later board an aircraft.
More than 1,600 students from 30
Santiago schools, along with pupils
from 11 schools in three provinces in
Argentina, took part in the program in
2007.
… and deliver in-house training
to develop and retain skilled
employees
To deal with technical talent shortages
and build skills from within, LAN
recently established a corporate
academy to train company workers and
leaders. The academy ran more than
4,500 courses in 2007.87
The airline
also provides selected employees with
financial support to pursue post-
secondary technical, graduate and
diploma courses. To retain its best
people, LAN offers scholarships to
the family members of employees for
vocational training courses.
Bring air travel to new
customers in Latin America
LAN’s “New Way to Travel” program
aims to make short-haul air travel
more accessible and attractive to
the general public.88
Its goal is to
transform air travel into the most
commonly used transportation
method in Chile and to capture
market share by stimulating and
tapping new sources of demand. By
simplifying airport and on-board
processes, offering more non-stop
flights and schedule alternatives, and
discounting fares by up to 35 percent,
LAN created demand for air travel
among those who previously used land
transportation. The airline carried more
than 500,000 additional passengers in
2007.89
This demand-stimulus model
was piloted in Chile and later rolled
out in Peru; passenger traffic grew by
24 percent in Chile and 32 percent in
Peru.90
Use overseas capital markets to
finance operations and cross-
border purchases
LAN sought to broaden its access
to global capital via an American
Depositary Receipt listing on the
New York Stock Exchange—the first
Latin American airline to do this.91
After a decade of successful trading,
the company has demonstrated to
global investors that it is a serious
and prestigious player in the industry,
something that served the airline well
when it recently sought additional
funds to expand its fleet.92
More than
97 percent of the US$320 million
raised was sourced from the United
States—finance that might not have
been as readily available through a
domestic stock issuance.93
19
20. Although searching for value in
new markets is a cross-border task,
unlocking that value is a local
exercise. While the markets for
new consumers, talent, innovation,
resource sustainability and capital
are increasingly global, or globally
contestable, economic decisions in
all five dimensions of the multi-
polar world occur in local markets.
Decisions about investment, training,
work, consumption, and the use or
regulation of resources are crucially
conditioned by local circumstances
and priorities. Tastes, customs,
regulations and political environments
differ widely and often create
barriers to local success (Figure 4).
The rise of the multi-polar world is
as much a story about harnessing
and adapting to local diversity as
it is about global harmonization.
Being authentically local, then, can
help companies access and multiply
the value inherent in diverse markets
by putting themselves at the center of
local business ecosystems. But what
form might this take? This is both an
internal and external challenge for
companies: on one hand, adapting
strategy, operations and products
to meet local conditions and tastes,
and on the other, working to shape
the broader business environment
in which they operate. Accenture
research shows that high-performance
businesses are out in front in both
of these areas. Some seek to draw
on historical ties or affinities of
language and culture that often
provide a natural bridge between
home and overseas markets. All draw
on a rich playbook of best practices
and innovative tools to weave their
operations seamlessly into the local
business and societal fabric.
Being authentically local
20
21. %
0
10
20
30
40
50
Inadequate
distribution
networks
Inadequate
infrastructure
Weak marketing
channels
Cultural and
language barriers
Government
regulations
Translating brand
across different
markets
Tailoring
products/services
to cultural
differences
High performers Low performers
New consumers
Adapting to cultural
differences
After deciding to enter a market and
finding a route to their customers,
companies can still discover that
their products fail to find a niche,
either because of local competition or
because they do not understand the
market’s distinctive characteristics.
High-performance businesses avoid
this fate by identifying and isolating
important regional differences and
tailoring products and services to
chosen consumer segments. They
often use deep customer analytics
to increase their understanding
of new customer segments. (See
page 32 for more information
on the future of analytics.)
India’s Tata Motors’ customer
relationship management program
makes real-time customer and
vehicle data available across more
than 1,000 locations.94
In addition
to its research and marketing
intelligence staff, Avon, a US
cosmetics company, employs internal
and external statisticians to develop
proprietary regression analyses
using Avon’s vast product and sales
history.95
US automotive-component
supplier Johnson Controls uses
market research to tailor products
to different markets. One of its
studies across the United States,
Germany and the Czech Republic
investigated women’s preferences
in vehicle interior design.96
Lack of available customer data,
especially in emerging markets,
can make it difficult to identify
consumer preferences and trends.
High-performance businesses get
around these difficulties by hiring
and partnering locally to get closer
to customers. US-headquartered
consumer electronics retailer Best
Buy partnered with The Carphone
Warehouse, Europe’s leading
mobile phone retailer, in 2006 to
serve European consumers with its
Geek Squad services (agents who
make help-desk house calls).97
The
companies agreed to a joint venture
granting Best Buy a 50 percent share
of European retail stores and other
businesses.98
This mode of market
entry fits with Best Buy’s careful
expansion strategy as it enables
the company to benefit from The
Carphone Warehouse’s understanding
of European consumers before
launching its own branded stores.
High performers also use their market
insight to tailor products and services
to meet local tastes and requirements.
Local consumption patterns, for
example, are rarely the same. There
are culturally specific tastes and
preferences, varying income levels,
disparate modes of shopping for
goods and services, and uneven retail
infrastructures. Because Chinese
consumers traditionally buy groceries
on a daily basis at “wet” markets and
prefer fresh produce, many of Tesco’s
stores in China have large, water-
filled tanks of live turtles and toads.99
This approach of tailoring offerings to
accommodate local shopping habits
has proved so successful that Tesco
now operates 60 stores in China.100
(See case study on page 26.)
Figure 4. Businesses face a variety of challenges when targeting foreign customers
Which of the following challenges is your company facing in foreign markets where it aims to expand its sales?
21
22. In addition, companies need to
improvise around the constraints
imposed by physical isolation and
inadequate infrastructure in many
markets, often by using new business
models. Nearly three-quarters of
high performers experiment with
new business models to appeal
to new customers to a moderate
or greater extent, compared with
59 percent of low performers.
In terms of reaching customers,
mobile devices will be both a business
opportunity and a business necessity.
In the developed world, mobile phones
will augment personal computers as
e-commerce and customer support
channels. In the emerging world,
where there are more than 1 billion
new consumers, mobile devices are
likely to be the sole electronic channel
for most people. Nearly 4 billion
people—or 60 percent of the world’s
population—are mobile customers.
Over 500 million new customers were
added in 2008 alone. Seventy-five
percent of subscribers are located in
emerging markets, where the mobile
phone is their sole means of electronic
communication. Nearly all the devices
have SMS texting capability and
an increasing number have some
rudimentary Internet connectivity.
Norwegian telecommunications
company Telenor has brought mobile
banking to migrant workers who
might otherwise have insufficient
access to regular banking services. In
a partnership with Citibank, Telenor’s
DiGiREMIT service allows customers
in Malaysia to transfer money
securely to Bangladesh, Indonesia
and the Philippines.101
Subscribers
to Telenor’s TeleDoctor service in
Pakistan receive easy access to
experienced physicians who provide
medical advice and symptom diagnosis
in eight languages, eliminating the
need to travel to an appointment.102
(See case study on page 27.)
Business imperative
Relate and tailor offerings
to new consumers
Identify critical local differences
in consumer preferences and
usage and, in response, tailor
products and services to
new consumer segments.
Talent
Creating business-ready
local workforces for
today and tomorrow
Deep immersion in local talent pools
is critical but far from easy to achieve.
Talent pools can be shallower than
they first appear, with business-
ready skills often in short supply.
Knowledge-based work increasingly
demands not only technical proficiency
but also a range of complementary
softer skills, such as management
experience, organizational ability
and creativity—attributes that can be
harder to find in emerging markets.
Often this situation is compounded
by the lack of a senior management
cadre with experience suitable for an
international business. Expatriates
can fill the gap in the short term
but seldom represent a sustainable
model in terms of cultural insight,
business stewardship and cost.
High-performance businesses are
distinguished by their ability to ensure
that their workforces are equipped
with the full complement of technical
and managerial skills. Nearly nine
out of 10 high performers—compared
with fewer than six out of 10 low
performers—establish their own
academies. These programs can
help to augment technical skills,
build management proficiencies and
emphasize less tangible aspects of
performance, such as teamwork and
creativity. Cisco has ramped up its
Global Talent Acceleration program,
which now has hubs in India, Jordan
and South Africa.103
The program aims
to narrow the gap between the supply
and demand of regional networking
talent by creating next-generation
consulting, engineering and sales
expertise in emerging countries.104
The 37-week program offers two
tracks: professional, for students with
three to five years’ experience, and
associate, for recent graduates. All
program graduates are expected to
join Cisco as full-time employees.105
Wherever possible, high performers
favor the acquisition and retention of
local talent. In its overseas markets,
UK-headquartered Tesco becomes
part of the environment in the host
country in part by keeping down the
number of expatriate employees.
Despite talent bottlenecks in China,
the grocer has managed to fill 80
percent of managerial posts with local
hires.106
(See case study on page 26.)
Local leadership in particular helps
businesses plant deep roots in local
talent markets. Nearly two-thirds
of high-performance businesses
have local people in charge of local
operations to a significant or great
extent, compared with fewer than half
of their low-performance counterparts.
Best Buy prefers to seek out local
leaders to fuel its international
growth—rather than transplanting
Americans—because local talent
simply understands the markets and
customers better. Best Buy even chose
to moderate its rate of expansion in
2006 because it wanted to take the
time to “develop local talent wherever
the customer meets the brand.”107
However, attracting and retaining
skilled local talent is often difficult,
especially as employees in different
markets have different rewards
preferences. In response to this
challenge, all the high-performance
businesses we surveyed tailor
reward packages to local markets,
compared with 65 percent of
low-performance businesses.
We found that high-performance
businesses take a long-term view,
looking beyond immediate talent needs
and acting to build a pipeline of skills.
In particular, they work with external
stakeholders, such as governments
and local communities, to boost skills
development. Ninety-two percent
collaborate with external stakeholders,
such as academic or governmental
organizations on education and health
initiatives, compared with 73 percent
of low-performance businesses.
Telenor has worked with the Technical
Education and Vocational Training
Authority in Pakistan and two industry
peers to launch the Telecoms Futures
program, which develops technical
skills in individuals from deprived
backgrounds.108
(See case study on
page 27.)
In a joint initiative with UNESCO and
the World Economic Forum, Cisco
has pioneered an e-learning program
to help energize local economies;
22
23. the program now operates in
approximately 165 countries.109
Cisco’s
academy in India seeks to improve
social and economic conditions by
developing IT skills in a predominantly
agrarian region, targeting girls, rural
and urban underprivileged children
and people with special needs.110
Business imperative
Develop local talent
Develop and mold local talent for
today and tomorrow by investing
across the skills spectrum.
Innovation
Embed in local networks
Even companies that have successfully
identified appropriate new hubs of
innovation often find it difficult to
tap into the ideas, innovation and
expertise present there, including
open innovation systems. More
generally, companies targeting
sales growth in new markets can
struggle to keep their innovation
engines fueled with local-market
insight, preferences and feedback.
Understanding this, high performers
focus on establishing innovation
activity in locations close to emerging
and future customers. Our survey
showed that high performers are more
likely than low performers—86 percent
versus 63 percent—to locate research
and development facilities near their
customer bases in new markets (Figure
5). With a view to consolidating
growing biotech research activities
and facilitate operational excellence,
Monsanto invested in a facility in
Bangalore in March 1998 to research
biotech crops with resistance to
viruses and tolerance to drought,
heat and salinity.111
The center tested
and gained approval for Bollgard,
the only biotech crop sanctioned in
India. Yields for Bollgard acreage
are 64 percent higher than for
conventional cotton, according to a
survey of more than 4,000 farmers
by the Indian Market Research
Bureau.112
The net profit increase for
farmers using Bollgard is Rs 6,727
per acre, or more than 118 percent.
High-performance businesses benefit
from innovation clusters in local
markets by placing themselves at the
heart of a wider web of relationships
among companies, universities,
research institutes and governments.
India’s Bharat Heavy Electricals
formed a number of joint ventures,
including one with GE to repair and
service GE-designed gas turbines and
another with Siemens to improve
the performance of old fossil-fuel
power plants.113
Our survey found
that high-performance businesses
are far more likely than their low-
performance counterparts to partner
with local universities or research
institutions (85 percent versus 58
percent). For example, Canada’s
Imperial Oil has an external technology
network maintained through links
with universities, industry and
government research alliances.114
Sometimes growth by acquisition
is needed to permit effective
participation in local innovation
clusters, particularly when access
to specific know-how or technology
is critical. Our survey found that
high-performance businesses are
significantly more likely than low-
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
%
Working with
governments in
shaping intellectual
property laws
Partnering with local
or national
government
Acquiring foreign
companies with specific
R&D expertise/
complementary
technology
Partnering with local
universities or
research institutes
Locating R&D centers
close to new
customer markets
High performers Low performers
Figure 5. High-performance businesses use a number of methods to embed themselves deeper into local innovation hubs
Is your company taking the following steps in foreign markets where it aims to expand R&D/innovation activities?
23
24. performance businesses to buy
foreign companies to acquire specific
R&D expertise or complementary
technologies (96 percent versus 63
percent). For example, Kingspan
Group, Ireland-headquartered
building-products company,
acquired Thermomax, a leading-edge
European solar thermal business,
to bolster its suite of sustainable
building solutions.115
(See also
ArcelorMittal case study on page 18
and Telenor case study on page 27.)
Each market has a distinct innovation
ecosystem in which regulation and
public policy are crucial forces.
Accordingly, high performers
participate in dialogues about
innovation policy at a local level to
better anticipate trends and shape
them where possible. In fact, nearly
eight out of 10 high performers team
up with local or national governments,
compared with fewer than six out of
10 low performers. And more than
three-quarters of high performers
work with governments to shape
intellectual property laws, compared
with only one-third of low performers.
Business imperative
Embed in the local
innovation fabric
Embed innovation activities into
the local research and development
and consumer environment,
working in tandem with industry
peers and policymakers.
Resource sustainability
Harnessing local markets
and incentives
Although the upstream supply of
energy and natural resources is
swayed by global markets, final
consumption of resources—by
companies or individuals—occurs in
differing local markets, each with
its own economic, cultural and
regulatory backdrop. Similarly, in
a world increasingly conscious of
global climate change, countries
and regions differ in the way they
regulate, or intend to regulate,
greenhouse gas-emitting activities.
Companies are beginning to
respond by making a business
out of low-carbon activities.
High performers know that this
requires a deep understanding
of regulatory, tax and incentive
regimes enabling them to identify
the most attractive opportunities
in multiple markets—whether to
enhance the cost benefits of energy
efficiency or decarbonization,
to support investment in new
and adjacent markets for future
revenue growth, to diversify
regulatory risk or to maximize
exposure to emerging technology.
Iberdrola’s focus on renewables has
allowed the company to explore
new sources of revenue from the
government. The company benefits
from feed-in tariffs in Spain,
“green” certificates in the United
Kingdom, and tax incentives, “green”
certificates and investment subsidies
in the United States.116
It also has
registered its Mexican wind farm
and Guatemalan hydropower plant
with the United Nations Clean
Development Mechanism, earning
Certified Emission Reduction credits
that can be sold on the global
market.117
(See case study on page 15.)
US chemicals-solution provider
Praxair works with the US Department
of Energy and other companies to
develop high-efficiency oxygen supply
systems for next-generation IGCC
(integrated gasification combined
cycle) power plants.118
Praxair also
participates in projects in Germany,
Spain and the United States that
demonstrate Praxair’s oxy-coal
technology and carbon dioxide
capture and processing systems.119
High performers in general have
been quicker than low performers
to embrace carbon trading. The
Copenhagen Consensus, a periodic
review of global challenges by leading
economists, identified R&D in low-
carbon energy technologies as one
of the major solutions to the world’s
challenges in 2008.120
Over one-third
of high performers seek to increase
revenues through new markets, such
as carbon trading, to a significant
or great extent, compared with 22
percent of low performers. US utility
PPL generates electricity but also has
moved into trading. The company
now actively buys and sells energy in
selected competitive wholesale and
deregulated retail markets.121
Overall,
generation and energy marketing and
trading account for more than half of
the corporation’s annual earnings.122
Business imperative
Localize resource
sustainability
Optimize resources strategy under
differing economic, cultural and
regulatory constraints across
markets and harness incentive
regimes, such as carbon trading,
for current and new business.
Capital
Acquiring expertise
and market access
Allocating scarce investment capital
to projects in foreign markets is
challenging. Some markets are
volatile and uncertain. Some have
regulations that hinder certain modes
of investment. In others, the most
appropriate mode of investment
may appear to be incompatible
with a company’s current operating
model. It is no wonder that high
performers recognize that in
this context a proactive, creative
and—above all—open-minded
approach is indispensable.
Acquisitions are a preferred investment
mode in foreign markets for both high
and low performers (Figure 6). Yet in
some emerging markets, acquisitions
and greenfield entry in certain
sectors may be restricted, whether
by local laws and regulations or by
the strength of market incumbents.
High-performance businesses respond
flexibly, often using joint ventures to
enter such markets. Tesco created a
joint venture to establish a presence
alongside the restricted Indian retail
market. Government legislation
protects the millions of family-run
“kirana” shops, and domestic retail
chains prohibit foreign multiple-
brand retailers from selling directly
to customers.123
Tesco plans to
enter India in 2009 by establishing
wholesale cash-and-carry stores to
sell directly to domestic retailers,
restaurants and caterers.124
Stores
will be set up through a partnership
agreement with Trent, the retail
arm of Tata, one of India’s largest
conglomerates.125
Tesco is laying the
24
25. groundwork for a strong presence in
the Indian market on which it can
capitalize should foreign investment
rules be relaxed in the retail sector.126
(See case study on page 26.)
In addition to helping with access
to foreign markets, joint ventures
also can help companies enter new
sectors and gain expertise. Larsen &
Toubro recently partnered with GE
Energy in India to focus on the power
generation market.127
GE Energy will
provide products from its power plant
main control system, and L&T will
leverage its strengths in engineering
and project execution as well as its
experience in the Indian market.
When companies wish to tap into
new ideas and markets quickly—but
investment outcomes are less
certain—a venture-capital approach
might be appropriate. Nokia’s
venture capital group, launched in
2004, manages US$350 million for
direct investments and fund-of-fund
investments in other venture capital
players. Nokia Growth Partners
aims to support portfolio companies
with their global perspective on
the mobile phone industry and the
necessary strategic guidance, network
and platform to accelerate growth
domestically and internationally.128
(See case study on page 14.) Similarly,
Iberdrola’s Renovables subsidiary
has set up an equity investment
company, Iberdrola Perseo, with an
annual budget of €6 million.129
It will
support renewable energy projects
with a high technology value, such
as new fuel sources and CO2 capture,
helping Iberdrola gain access to the
latest renewable energy technology.
(See case study on page 15.)
Business imperative
Be open to a variety of
investment models
Be willing to draw on a broad suite
of investment models tailored to the
characteristics of different markets.
Figure 6. Acquisitions are the preferred investment strategy in foreign markets
Which of the following investment modes does your company use in foreign markets?
High performers Low performers
%
0
10
20
30
40
50
Greenfield
investment
Acquisitions Franchising Joint ventures Licensing
agreements
Our company
does not invest
abroad
25
26. Tesco
Who
Based in the United Kingdom, Tesco
is the world’s third-largest grocer,
operating more than 3,900 stores in 14
countries.130
Differentiators
More than 60 percent of Tesco’s sales
space is now located outside the
United Kingdom.131
The company made
its first move abroad in 1994, when it
set up in Hungary, followed by Poland,
Slovakia and the Czech Republic.132
In
addition to becoming a clear winner
in Eastern Europe, the company is now
the market leader in Malaysia.133
Tesco
also planned to double the number
of Tesco Express stores in Turkey in
2008 and more than doubled its online
grocery sales in South Korea—its
second-most profitable market—since
2007.134
Across Tesco’s new markets,
sales grew by 25 percent in 2007, and
growth remained strong in 2008. In
the first half of the year, same-store
sales in China rose by 14 percent.135
In the third quarter, international
sales were up 28.1 percent at actual
exchange rates (and by 14.6 percent at
constant rates).136
In the United Kingdom, Tesco’s
multiple product ranges—spanning
numerous price points—have allowed
the company to position itself as a
major discounter during challenging
economic times.
Multi-polar focus
• Partner with local players in
emerging markets
• Cater to local shopping preferences
• Source talent globally, staff locally
• Deploy a global operating model for
standardization efficiencies
• Pioneer sustainability initiatives
Use joint ventures to enter new
markets
Tesco entered the US$270 billion-
a-year grocery market in China in
2004 through a joint venture with
Taiwan’s Hymall, of which it now
owns 90 percent.137
Today, Tesco
operates 60 stores in China, with 95
percent of products sourced within
the country.138
Global reach is key to
local effectiveness: Tesco believes
that in China it can use the experience
it has gained from operating around
the world to localize its food offerings
better than its two major rivals.139
In India, Tesco partners with Trent
(the retail arm of Tata) to establish
wholesale cash-and-carry stores for
retailers, restaurants and caterers
and to expand Trent’s Star Bazaar
hypermarkets by sharing know-how
and technology.140
If current rules that
restrict foreign ownership of retail
outlets are relaxed in the future, Tesco
expects to be well positioned.
Tailor the store experience to
local preferences
Tesco is highly flexible in its retailing
format to respond to different
consumer norms and tastes. Noting
that grocery shoppers in Japan like
to buy small amounts of fresh food
each day, Tesco entered the market
not by opening hypermarkets but by
acquiring a discount supermarket
operator.141
The company’s stores in
Thailand seek to replicate the product
selection experience of traditional
street markets, with less emphasis on
the neatly packaged portions found in
many Western markets.142
Tesco sells
live toads and turtles from tanks in
Chinese stores, catering to consumers’
preference for shopping in “wet”
markets.143
Look locally—and globally—to
overcome talent bottlenecks …
Recruiting employees of the right
caliber remains a challenge. Tesco
views overseas growth as “not about
putting flags down in countries,
[but] about the quality of people.”144
The company has filled 80 percent
of managerial posts in China with
people hired locally, consistent with
its strategy of acclimatizing to each
country and keeping down the number
of expatriate employees.145
At the same
time, the company has recruited MBA-
degree holders from Indian consulting
firms to staff the global function
charged with deploying Tesco’s new
global operating model, called TOM,
around the world.146
… and standardize systems and
processes across the company
One of TOM’s benefits is swifter and
easier expansion into new markets
because TOM standardizes operations.
All stores use the same technology
and processes for billing customers,
purchasing goods and managing the
stores. Tesco plans to centralize IT
applications under a single network
and voice contract and to standardize
its main finance, human resources
and sales applications.147
Standard
reporting functions will allow
executives to manage a store in
Malaysia or Japan just as they would a
store in the United Kingdom.148
Embed resource sustainability in
its operations
Tesco has pledged to halve emissions
from existing stores and distribution
centers worldwide by 2020 and to
reduce the amount of packaging
on branded and Tesco’s own-label
products by 25 percent by 2010.149
The
retailer is also a pioneer in the use of
sustainable and cost-saving materials,
experimenting recently with a store
of wooden construction in Slovakia.150
Its service center in India—where
it replaced all 2,500 of its compact
fluorescent lamps (energy-saving light
bulbs) with LED lighting—has set local
standards for energy conservation in
interior lighting.151
26
27. Telenor
Who
Norwegian telecommunications giant
providing mobile services to more than
150 million subscribers in 12 markets
across Europe and Asia, as well as
fixed-line and broadcast services in the
Nordic region.152
Differentiator
Telenor joined forces in 1997
with Grameenphone—now the
largest mobile service provider in
Bangladesh—for its first venture
in Asia.153
In 2007 alone, Telenor’s
subscriber base in the country grew
by more than 50 percent. Telenor
Pakistan launched its service in 2005
and is now the country’s second-
largest provider, with 33 percent of the
market.154
Multi-polar focus
• Deploy capital to acquire emerging-
market players
• Attract local talent with technical
education programs
• Tailor innovation and services to
critical lifestyle needs in emerging
markets
Mobilize capital to expand
internationally
Telenor’s strategy in emerging markets
is to capture a large subscriber base
early on so it can enter the industry’s
consolidation phase in a dominant
position.155
As a result, it has chosen
to expand by deploying capital to
acquire top-tier players in low-income
but high-growth markets. Telenor
now owns Telenor Pakistan, Telenor
Serbia, ProMonte (Montenegro) and
Pannon (Hungary) and holds partial
equity stakes in other companies
including DiGi (Malaysia, 51 percent),
Grameenphone (Bangladesh, 62
percent) and DTAC (Thailand, 65
percent).156
Expansion continues in the
current economic climate. Telenor is
entering India—the world’s second-
largest mobile phone market—via the
purchase of a controlling stake in
Unitech Wireless, a local greenfield
mobile operator with pan-Indian
telecommunications licenses.157
Telenor
plans to launch its Indian services in
2009.
Having identified high-growth
markets, Telenor invests for the long
term. In Ukraine and Hungary, the
company was looking for subscriber
growth in 1998. By 2004, both markets
generated revenues for the company
and, by 2008, they generated profits.158
Invest in basic education to
expand future talent pools
Telenor invests locally to offset local
shortages of technical skills and
experience. In Pakistan it worked
with the Technical Education and
Vocational Training Authority and
with Nokia and Siemens to create
the industry’s first industry-academia
collaboration.159
Telenor’s employment
qualification—a two-year higher
national diploma—is aimed expressly
at making the company accessible to
people from deprived backgrounds.
Innovate for the local market
Telenor uses its Malaysia-based
Research & Innovation Centre Asia
Pacific (TRICAP) to improve its
understanding of Asian consumers’
behaviors and preferences and to
develop new technology and services.160
TRICAP considers that the insights
from its many consumer interviews
are especially valuable for Telenor as
a whole because Asian consumers are
often early adopters of new technology.
Reach new consumer groups
Telenor’s offer to consumers is
highly tailored and markedly local.
Its TeleDoctor service in Pakistan
offers subscribers easy access to
experienced physicians for remote
medical advice and symptom diagnosis
in eight languages.161
Customers also
can indicate whether they would
prefer to connect to a male or female
doctor. The company’s BillPay system
in Bangladesh allows natural-gas
consumers to settle their bills using
their phones.162
Telenor provides
free life insurance in Thailand to
subscribers of a year’s standing.163
And
in an evolution of communications
and banking business models, Telenor
teamed with Citibank to allow
customers in Malaysia to transfer
money securely to Bangladesh,
Indonesia and the Philippines via SMS
text-message technology, bringing
remittance-dependent migrant
workers into the customer base of
both companies.164
27
28. The ability to scan the evolving
economic geography of the multi-
polar world and embed business
activities in local markets are
essential hallmarks of the businesses
we studied. But high-performance
businesses go beyond this: they
actively find ways to scale the benefits
of local success to the organization at
large. By creating organizations that
are permeable—both internally and
externally—companies enable flows
of people, ideas and best practices.
Many companies are still on the
journey to find the right global
operating model. High performers
are taking steps toward a model that
mirrors their multi-polar business
environment and enables them to
reap the benefits of being both
super-global and super-local.
Networking the organization
28
29. Facilitating mobility
Being successful in local markets is
not enough for a company to thrive
in a competitive global economy.
Scaling success across a company
is challenging, but mobilizing the
best people and ideas from all
global operations ensures that
companies multiply their resources.
The high performers we surveyed
undertake a number of activities that
help facilitate mobility across their
organizations. In the realm of talent,
high performers equip employees
with the skills and opportunities to
work across different markets. Fifty-
one percent of high performers do
this to a significant or great extent,
for instance by offering language
courses or job rotations, compared
with 35 percent of low performers.
Furthermore, more than half of
the high-performance businesses
we surveyed give employees early
opportunities in their career to work
abroad to a significant or great extent,
compared with 31 percent of low-
performance businesses. British luxury
fashion house Burberry promotes
cross-border employee transfers,
including international secondments
with exchanges among France,
Italy, Spain, South Korea, the United
Kingdom and the United States.165
To prepare employees for success
in the global business community,
Burberry provides language courses
in French, English, Spanish and
Italian and offers one-on-one
lessons for senior management.166
Connecting an organization is partly
about moving people but also about
sharing ideas, innovation and best
practices. Nearly two-thirds of
high performers have processes to
swiftly transfer new technology and
innovations across the organization
to a significant or great extent,
compared with less than one-third
of low performers. Businesses can
also encourage employees to connect
and share knowledge globally so that
best practices can be transferred
across the firm. Best Buy’s CEO,
Bob Willett, describes the benefits
of global interconnectedness this
way: “What we learn in China can
improve our business in Canada
and the United States and vice
versa. By connecting human beings
around the globe we believe we
can learn faster. More access to
new ideas in different markets, we
think, fuels faster growth.”167
To ensure that ideas flow across the
entire company, Norwegian media
firm Schibsted established an editor
forum in 2007.168
Membership includes
30 editors-in-chief, deputy editors-
in-chief and news editors from
Estonia, France, Lithuania, Norway,
Russia, Spain and Sweden.169
The
forum’s agenda addresses common
challenges, the exchange of ideas
and fundamental problems in each
country, allowing editors to learn
from each other’s experiences.
Collaboration technologies, which
companies have traditionally seen
simply as the electronic extension of
meeting rooms, will play a big part
in creating a networked organization
into the future. Companies and
individuals today have a wide range
of options for communication
and collaboration: e-mail, instant
messaging, voice-over-IP, process-
oriented collaboration, very high-end
telepresence, social networks, blogs,
wikis, RSS, free content distribution
mechanisms, twitters and murmurs.
But in spite of the proliferation of
these technologies, work practices
have largely remained the same
in most companies: a fixed group
of employees assigned to specific
projects, coming into a building every
morning, sitting at desks or in meeting
rooms. Add to this the newer pressures
imposed by large e-mail volume and
late-night conference calls with
colleagues in far-away time zones, and
it becomes easy to see how current
work practices could be improved.
Given the aging Western workforce
and the competition for global talent,
companies now have many different
technological options to consider for
their workforces and work practices.
For example: How to effectively deploy
an expert across multiple projects?
How to reduce the time wasted in
daily commutes? How to reduce the
amount of office space? Indeed, how
to create and manage what we may
come to call an “elastic” organization?
Business imperative
Create structured channels
to allow rapid diffusion
of ideas and know-how
across geographic regions
Invest in mobility and technology
solutions that facilitate the
movement of talent and ideas
within the company and between
value chain partners.
29
30. Maintaining a strong core
Operating successfully at global
scale involves making the right
components of a global operating
model—organizational architecture,
information systems, business
processes and data—consistent and
standardized across the enterprise.
Global enterprise resource planning
systems will continue to have an
important role in coordinating and
harmonizing these activities across the
organization. Maintaining a backbone
of best practices enables the mobility
that allows a company to scale
successfully. At the same time, it can
create competitive cost structures that
enable the business to multiply in size
without multiplying underlying costs.
Common processes and the proactive
sharing of best practices help high
performers scale product and service
innovations across multiple markets.
In fact, as Figure 7 shows, high
performers are more than three times
as likely as low performers to replicate
successful innovations across different
markets to a significant or great
extent (57 percent versus 16 percent).
One example is Japanese auto
manufacturer Suzuki, which plans to
use the lessons learned from its R&D
for the Indian market to strengthen
its approach to other emerging
markets in South Asia, the Middle
East and Africa.170
As asset manager
Masayuki Kubota explains, “Suzuki
is capturing the very best spots—
emerging markets and small cars… It
entered the markets far before other
carmakers and is benefiting now.”171
An organizational structure with
channels that guide people and
ideas to where they will create
the most value will be critically
important. This can involve creating
dedicated leadership positions for
different geographical markets.
Our survey found that 47 percent
of businesses have already created
specific executive leadership positions
for new geographic markets, and
77 percent of companies said they
plan to do so within three years.
Business imperative
Build a global backbone
of standardized data,
systems and processes
Develop a global operating
model with consistent core
components of organization
design, data, businesses
processes and information
systems to foster the circulation
of ideas and best practices.
Figure 7. High performers multiply local innovation across geographies
To what extent is your company replicating successful innovations across
different markets where it aims to expand R&D/innovation activities?
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
%
High performers Low performers
To a great or
significant extent
To a moderate extent To a limited extent
30