Enviar pesquisa
Carregar
Hulett david
•
2 gostaram
•
16,141 visualizações
N
NASAPMC
Seguir
Tecnologia
Negócios
Denunciar
Compartilhar
Denunciar
Compartilhar
1 de 47
Baixar agora
Baixar para ler offline
Recomendados
១២ រាជធានីភ្នំពេញ
១២ រាជធានីភ្នំពេញ
sam seyla hun
០៤ ខេត្តកំពង់ឆ្នាំង
០៤ ខេត្តកំពង់ឆ្នាំង
sam seyla hun
០២ ខេត្តបាត់ដំបង
០២ ខេត្តបាត់ដំបង
sam seyla hun
Brief survey on Three-Dimensional Displays
Brief survey on Three-Dimensional Displays
Taufiq Widjanarko
WCCI 2008 Tutorial on Computational Intelligence and Games, part 2 of 3
WCCI 2008 Tutorial on Computational Intelligence and Games, part 2 of 3
togelius
០១ ខេត្តបន្ទាយមានជ័យ
០១ ខេត្តបន្ទាយមានជ័យ
sam seyla hun
១០ ខេត្តក្រចេះ
១០ ខេត្តក្រចេះ
sam seyla hun
Iirs Artificial Naural network based Urban growth Modeling
Iirs Artificial Naural network based Urban growth Modeling
Tushar Dholakia
Recomendados
១២ រាជធានីភ្នំពេញ
១២ រាជធានីភ្នំពេញ
sam seyla hun
០៤ ខេត្តកំពង់ឆ្នាំង
០៤ ខេត្តកំពង់ឆ្នាំង
sam seyla hun
០២ ខេត្តបាត់ដំបង
០២ ខេត្តបាត់ដំបង
sam seyla hun
Brief survey on Three-Dimensional Displays
Brief survey on Three-Dimensional Displays
Taufiq Widjanarko
WCCI 2008 Tutorial on Computational Intelligence and Games, part 2 of 3
WCCI 2008 Tutorial on Computational Intelligence and Games, part 2 of 3
togelius
០១ ខេត្តបន្ទាយមានជ័យ
០១ ខេត្តបន្ទាយមានជ័យ
sam seyla hun
១០ ខេត្តក្រចេះ
១០ ខេត្តក្រចេះ
sam seyla hun
Iirs Artificial Naural network based Urban growth Modeling
Iirs Artificial Naural network based Urban growth Modeling
Tushar Dholakia
២១ ខេត្តតាកែវ
២១ ខេត្តតាកែវ
sam seyla hun
១៣ ខេត្តព្រះវិហារ
១៣ ខេត្តព្រះវិហារ
sam seyla hun
Open Garden for AndroidOpen
Open Garden for AndroidOpen
Micha Benoliel
Resource plan report stage 1 - final
Resource plan report stage 1 - final
Ajay Zitshi
LinkedIn's Q1 2012 Earnings
LinkedIn's Q1 2012 Earnings
LinkedIn
Capacidade Planejada
Capacidade Planejada
Rodrigo Campos
Julee mineral water
Julee mineral water
Yugashrasta Mohanty
Analytics Www.Informaticabiomedica.Com.Br 20080101 20091120 (Keywords Report)
Analytics Www.Informaticabiomedica.Com.Br 20080101 20091120 (Keywords Report)
Raony Guimarães
A Cheaper Hospital In Five Days
A Cheaper Hospital In Five Days
Jay Arthur
Coonce.tom
Coonce.tom
NASAPMC
Hazen michael
Hazen michael
NASAPMC
Terry.cooke davies
Terry.cooke davies
NASAPMC
Backup ronniegoodinchampionsinventors
Backup ronniegoodinchampionsinventors
NASAPMC
Canga.m.wood.j
Canga.m.wood.j
NASAPMC
Ann over
Ann over
NASAPMC
Baldwin.kristen
Baldwin.kristen
NASAPMC
Backup hesenperger kottmeyer
Backup hesenperger kottmeyer
NASAPMC
Ipao great houseetc-programmatic analysis ll
Ipao great houseetc-programmatic analysis ll
NASAPMC
Patterson.donna
Patterson.donna
NASAPMC
Taube
Taube
NASAPMC
Pollitt.julie
Pollitt.julie
NASAPMC
Gena.henderson
Gena.henderson
NASAPMC
Mais conteúdo relacionado
Mais procurados
២១ ខេត្តតាកែវ
២១ ខេត្តតាកែវ
sam seyla hun
១៣ ខេត្តព្រះវិហារ
១៣ ខេត្តព្រះវិហារ
sam seyla hun
Open Garden for AndroidOpen
Open Garden for AndroidOpen
Micha Benoliel
Resource plan report stage 1 - final
Resource plan report stage 1 - final
Ajay Zitshi
LinkedIn's Q1 2012 Earnings
LinkedIn's Q1 2012 Earnings
LinkedIn
Capacidade Planejada
Capacidade Planejada
Rodrigo Campos
Julee mineral water
Julee mineral water
Yugashrasta Mohanty
Analytics Www.Informaticabiomedica.Com.Br 20080101 20091120 (Keywords Report)
Analytics Www.Informaticabiomedica.Com.Br 20080101 20091120 (Keywords Report)
Raony Guimarães
A Cheaper Hospital In Five Days
A Cheaper Hospital In Five Days
Jay Arthur
Mais procurados
(9)
២១ ខេត្តតាកែវ
២១ ខេត្តតាកែវ
១៣ ខេត្តព្រះវិហារ
១៣ ខេត្តព្រះវិហារ
Open Garden for AndroidOpen
Open Garden for AndroidOpen
Resource plan report stage 1 - final
Resource plan report stage 1 - final
LinkedIn's Q1 2012 Earnings
LinkedIn's Q1 2012 Earnings
Capacidade Planejada
Capacidade Planejada
Julee mineral water
Julee mineral water
Analytics Www.Informaticabiomedica.Com.Br 20080101 20091120 (Keywords Report)
Analytics Www.Informaticabiomedica.Com.Br 20080101 20091120 (Keywords Report)
A Cheaper Hospital In Five Days
A Cheaper Hospital In Five Days
Destaque
Coonce.tom
Coonce.tom
NASAPMC
Hazen michael
Hazen michael
NASAPMC
Terry.cooke davies
Terry.cooke davies
NASAPMC
Backup ronniegoodinchampionsinventors
Backup ronniegoodinchampionsinventors
NASAPMC
Canga.m.wood.j
Canga.m.wood.j
NASAPMC
Ann over
Ann over
NASAPMC
Baldwin.kristen
Baldwin.kristen
NASAPMC
Backup hesenperger kottmeyer
Backup hesenperger kottmeyer
NASAPMC
Ipao great houseetc-programmatic analysis ll
Ipao great houseetc-programmatic analysis ll
NASAPMC
Patterson.donna
Patterson.donna
NASAPMC
Taube
Taube
NASAPMC
Pollitt.julie
Pollitt.julie
NASAPMC
Gena.henderson
Gena.henderson
NASAPMC
Al.worden
Al.worden
NASAPMC
Fayssal.safie
Fayssal.safie
NASAPMC
Newman.steve
Newman.steve
NASAPMC
Cathy.carr
Cathy.carr
NASAPMC
Hartford.wayne wh1
Hartford.wayne wh1
NASAPMC
James.hale
James.hale
NASAPMC
Louis.cioletti
Louis.cioletti
NASAPMC
Destaque
(20)
Coonce.tom
Coonce.tom
Hazen michael
Hazen michael
Terry.cooke davies
Terry.cooke davies
Backup ronniegoodinchampionsinventors
Backup ronniegoodinchampionsinventors
Canga.m.wood.j
Canga.m.wood.j
Ann over
Ann over
Baldwin.kristen
Baldwin.kristen
Backup hesenperger kottmeyer
Backup hesenperger kottmeyer
Ipao great houseetc-programmatic analysis ll
Ipao great houseetc-programmatic analysis ll
Patterson.donna
Patterson.donna
Taube
Taube
Pollitt.julie
Pollitt.julie
Gena.henderson
Gena.henderson
Al.worden
Al.worden
Fayssal.safie
Fayssal.safie
Newman.steve
Newman.steve
Cathy.carr
Cathy.carr
Hartford.wayne wh1
Hartford.wayne wh1
James.hale
James.hale
Louis.cioletti
Louis.cioletti
Semelhante a Hulett david
ST.Monteiro-EmbeddedFeatureSelection.pdf
ST.Monteiro-EmbeddedFeatureSelection.pdf
grssieee
MRV – SISA
MRV – SISA
John Davis
Why we don’t know how many colors there are
Why we don’t know how many colors there are
Jan Morovic
Miltenburg M Sc Presentation Tu Delft
Miltenburg M Sc Presentation Tu Delft
imiltenburg
Quantitative methods schedule
Quantitative methods schedule
John Goodpasture
Gregoire H&N
Gregoire H&N
fondas vakalis
DCT_TR802
DCT_TR802
Aniruddh Tyagi
DCT_TR802
DCT_TR802
aniruddh Tyagi
DCT_TR802
DCT_TR802
aniruddh Tyagi
Modeling & Simulation
Modeling & Simulation
Kurt D. Hamman
Shape contexts
Shape contexts
huebesao
Calvert, Do ‘normal’ traffic conditions really exist? Why modelling variation...
Calvert, Do ‘normal’ traffic conditions really exist? Why modelling variation...
flmkessels
Ukázkový report - SolidVision
Ukázkový report - SolidVision
3dskenovani
Forecast Modelling (Single Variable)
Forecast Modelling (Single Variable)
Mohd Paub
Jun 2009 Tatum Survey
Jun 2009 Tatum Survey
fnapoli
3D Combined Footing Design
3D Combined Footing Design
Mario Galvez
Feasible study of a light weight prediction system in China
Feasible study of a light weight prediction system in China
Osamu Masutani
Aug 2009 Tatum Survey
Aug 2009 Tatum Survey
fnapoli
Datasheet - Nuclear and Power
Datasheet - Nuclear and Power
Gagan Sood
GOwind_extendedversion_v3
GOwind_extendedversion_v3
jpdmaeye
Semelhante a Hulett david
(20)
ST.Monteiro-EmbeddedFeatureSelection.pdf
ST.Monteiro-EmbeddedFeatureSelection.pdf
MRV – SISA
MRV – SISA
Why we don’t know how many colors there are
Why we don’t know how many colors there are
Miltenburg M Sc Presentation Tu Delft
Miltenburg M Sc Presentation Tu Delft
Quantitative methods schedule
Quantitative methods schedule
Gregoire H&N
Gregoire H&N
DCT_TR802
DCT_TR802
DCT_TR802
DCT_TR802
DCT_TR802
DCT_TR802
Modeling & Simulation
Modeling & Simulation
Shape contexts
Shape contexts
Calvert, Do ‘normal’ traffic conditions really exist? Why modelling variation...
Calvert, Do ‘normal’ traffic conditions really exist? Why modelling variation...
Ukázkový report - SolidVision
Ukázkový report - SolidVision
Forecast Modelling (Single Variable)
Forecast Modelling (Single Variable)
Jun 2009 Tatum Survey
Jun 2009 Tatum Survey
3D Combined Footing Design
3D Combined Footing Design
Feasible study of a light weight prediction system in China
Feasible study of a light weight prediction system in China
Aug 2009 Tatum Survey
Aug 2009 Tatum Survey
Datasheet - Nuclear and Power
Datasheet - Nuclear and Power
GOwind_extendedversion_v3
GOwind_extendedversion_v3
Mais de NASAPMC
Bejmuk bo
Bejmuk bo
NASAPMC
Baniszewski john
Baniszewski john
NASAPMC
Yew manson
Yew manson
NASAPMC
Wood frank
Wood frank
NASAPMC
Wood frank
Wood frank
NASAPMC
Wessen randi (cd)
Wessen randi (cd)
NASAPMC
Vellinga joe
Vellinga joe
NASAPMC
Trahan stuart
Trahan stuart
NASAPMC
Stock gahm
Stock gahm
NASAPMC
Snow lee
Snow lee
NASAPMC
Smalley sandra
Smalley sandra
NASAPMC
Seftas krage
Seftas krage
NASAPMC
Sampietro marco
Sampietro marco
NASAPMC
Rudolphi mike
Rudolphi mike
NASAPMC
Roberts karlene
Roberts karlene
NASAPMC
Rackley mike
Rackley mike
NASAPMC
Paradis william
Paradis william
NASAPMC
Osterkamp jeff
Osterkamp jeff
NASAPMC
O'keefe william
O'keefe william
NASAPMC
Muller ralf
Muller ralf
NASAPMC
Mais de NASAPMC
(20)
Bejmuk bo
Bejmuk bo
Baniszewski john
Baniszewski john
Yew manson
Yew manson
Wood frank
Wood frank
Wood frank
Wood frank
Wessen randi (cd)
Wessen randi (cd)
Vellinga joe
Vellinga joe
Trahan stuart
Trahan stuart
Stock gahm
Stock gahm
Snow lee
Snow lee
Smalley sandra
Smalley sandra
Seftas krage
Seftas krage
Sampietro marco
Sampietro marco
Rudolphi mike
Rudolphi mike
Roberts karlene
Roberts karlene
Rackley mike
Rackley mike
Paradis william
Paradis william
Osterkamp jeff
Osterkamp jeff
O'keefe william
O'keefe william
Muller ralf
Muller ralf
Último
Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...
Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...
Jeffrey Haguewood
"I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ...
"I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ...
Zilliz
Strategies for Landing an Oracle DBA Job as a Fresher
Strategies for Landing an Oracle DBA Job as a Fresher
Remote DBA Services
Polkadot JAM Slides - Token2049 - By Dr. Gavin Wood
Polkadot JAM Slides - Token2049 - By Dr. Gavin Wood
Juan lago vázquez
Spring Boot vs Quarkus the ultimate battle - DevoxxUK
Spring Boot vs Quarkus the ultimate battle - DevoxxUK
Jago de Vreede
DBX First Quarter 2024 Investor Presentation
DBX First Quarter 2024 Investor Presentation
Dropbox
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
sudhanshuwaghmare1
Navigating the Deluge_ Dubai Floods and the Resilience of Dubai International...
Navigating the Deluge_ Dubai Floods and the Resilience of Dubai International...
Orbitshub
Cloud Frontiers: A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FME
Cloud Frontiers: A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FME
Safe Software
Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...
Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...
apidays
MS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectors
MS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectors
Nanddeep Nachan
Biography Of Angeliki Cooney | Senior Vice President Life Sciences | Albany, ...
Biography Of Angeliki Cooney | Senior Vice President Life Sciences | Albany, ...
Angeliki Cooney
Apidays New York 2024 - Scaling API-first by Ian Reasor and Radu Cotescu, Adobe
Apidays New York 2024 - Scaling API-first by Ian Reasor and Radu Cotescu, Adobe
apidays
AXA XL - Insurer Innovation Award Americas 2024
AXA XL - Insurer Innovation Award Americas 2024
The Digital Insurer
Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024
Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024
Victor Rentea
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
The Digital Insurer
Apidays New York 2024 - APIs in 2030: The Risk of Technological Sleepwalk by ...
Apidays New York 2024 - APIs in 2030: The Risk of Technological Sleepwalk by ...
apidays
Apidays New York 2024 - Passkeys: Developing APIs to enable passwordless auth...
Apidays New York 2024 - Passkeys: Developing APIs to enable passwordless auth...
apidays
Artificial Intelligence Chap.5 : Uncertainty
Artificial Intelligence Chap.5 : Uncertainty
Khushali Kathiriya
MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024
MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024
MIND CTI
Último
(20)
Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...
Web Form Automation for Bonterra Impact Management (fka Social Solutions Apri...
"I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ...
"I see eyes in my soup": How Delivery Hero implemented the safety system for ...
Strategies for Landing an Oracle DBA Job as a Fresher
Strategies for Landing an Oracle DBA Job as a Fresher
Polkadot JAM Slides - Token2049 - By Dr. Gavin Wood
Polkadot JAM Slides - Token2049 - By Dr. Gavin Wood
Spring Boot vs Quarkus the ultimate battle - DevoxxUK
Spring Boot vs Quarkus the ultimate battle - DevoxxUK
DBX First Quarter 2024 Investor Presentation
DBX First Quarter 2024 Investor Presentation
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Boost Fertility New Invention Ups Success Rates.pdf
Navigating the Deluge_ Dubai Floods and the Resilience of Dubai International...
Navigating the Deluge_ Dubai Floods and the Resilience of Dubai International...
Cloud Frontiers: A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FME
Cloud Frontiers: A Deep Dive into Serverless Spatial Data and FME
Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...
Apidays New York 2024 - The Good, the Bad and the Governed by David O'Neill, ...
MS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectors
MS Copilot expands with MS Graph connectors
Biography Of Angeliki Cooney | Senior Vice President Life Sciences | Albany, ...
Biography Of Angeliki Cooney | Senior Vice President Life Sciences | Albany, ...
Apidays New York 2024 - Scaling API-first by Ian Reasor and Radu Cotescu, Adobe
Apidays New York 2024 - Scaling API-first by Ian Reasor and Radu Cotescu, Adobe
AXA XL - Insurer Innovation Award Americas 2024
AXA XL - Insurer Innovation Award Americas 2024
Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024
Finding Java's Hidden Performance Traps @ DevoxxUK 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Axa Assurance Maroc - Insurer Innovation Award 2024
Apidays New York 2024 - APIs in 2030: The Risk of Technological Sleepwalk by ...
Apidays New York 2024 - APIs in 2030: The Risk of Technological Sleepwalk by ...
Apidays New York 2024 - Passkeys: Developing APIs to enable passwordless auth...
Apidays New York 2024 - Passkeys: Developing APIs to enable passwordless auth...
Artificial Intelligence Chap.5 : Uncertainty
Artificial Intelligence Chap.5 : Uncertainty
MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024
MINDCTI Revenue Release Quarter One 2024
Hulett david
1.
Integrated Cost /
Schedule Risk Analysis A presentation to the PM Challenge February 6-7, 2007 Moody Gardens, Galveston, TX David T. Hulett, Ph.D. Hulett & Associates, LLC Los Angeles, CA (310) 476-7699 / info@projectrisk.com www.projectrisk.com © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 1
2.
Agenda • Schedule Risk
Analysis – One-path schedule, two paths and the “merge bias” – Highest risk path – risk criticality – Probabilistic branching • Integrated Cost – Schedule Risk Analysis – Basics – risks in time-related and time-independent costs – Schedule in Project, Costs in Excel – Resources in the schedule – integrated simulations using Monte Carlo and Pertmaster on Primavera P3 schedules © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 2
3.
Risk of an
Individual Activity • Simple activity duration estimates are risky 30d Design Unit 1 © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 3
4.
Probability Distributions Available
Date: 1/13/2003 5:21:27 PM Date: 1/13/2003 5:18:35 PM Samples: 3000 Samples: 3000 Unique ID: 3 Unique ID: 3 Name: Design Unit Name: Design Unit 0.09 1.0 0.16 1.0 0.08 0.9 0.9 0.14 Cumulative Probability Cumulative Probability 0.07 0.8 0.8 0.12 0.7 0.7 0.06 Frequency Frequency 0.6 0.10 0.6 0.05 0.5 0.08 0.5 0.04 0.4 0.06 0.4 0.03 0.3 0.3 0.02 0.04 0.2 0.2 0.01 0.1 0.02 0.1 6/21 7/3 7/15 6/21 7/2 7/15 Completion Date Completion Date Uniform Distribution Triangular Distribution Uniform Triangular © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 4
5.
Probability Distributions Available
(continued) Date: 7/10/2002 3:19:37 PM Date: 7/10/2002 3:20:30 PM Samples: 3000 Samples: 3000 Unique ID: 3 Unique ID: 3 Name: Design Unit Name: Design Unit 0.20 1.0 0.22 1.0 0.18 0.9 0.20 0.9 Cumulative Probability Cumulative Probability 0.16 0.8 0.17 0.8 0.14 0.7 0.7 Frequency Frequency 0.15 0.12 0.6 0.6 0.13 0.10 0.5 0.5 0.10 0.08 0.4 0.4 0.3 0.08 0.3 0.06 0.04 0.2 0.05 0.2 0.02 0.1 0.03 0.1 6/21 7/3 7/15 6/21 7/1 7/13 Completion Date Completion Date Normal Distribution Beta Distribution Normal BETA © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 5
6.
Comparison of Four
Distributions • The three distributions have different characteristics – The uniform expresses most risk (mean, Standard deviation) – Triangular is fairly conservative – The Beta is the least risky Comparison of Probability Distributions (20d, 30d, 45d) Mean Standard Deviation Uniform 33d 7.2d Triangular 32d 5.1d Normal 33d 4.1d Beta 31d 3.4d © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 6
7.
Risk Along a
Contiguous Schedule Path • Path risk is the combination of the risks of its activities Design Build Test Start Finish Unit Unit Unit © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 7
8.
Really Simple Schedule
• This schedule finishes on September 3 – 7-day weeks, like a model changeover, refinery turnaround ID Task Name Duration Start Finish May June July August Septembe 1 Project 95 d 6/1 9/3 2 Start 0d 6/1 6/1 6/1 3 Design Unit 30 d 6/1 6/30 6/1 6/30 4 Build Unit 40 d 7/1 8/9 7/1 8/9 5 Test Unit 25 d 8/10 9/3 8/10 9/3 6 Finish 0d 9/3 9/3 9/3 • If we can get into trouble with this simple schedule, we can get into trouble with real project schedules © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 8
9.
Add Duration Risk
to the Schedule using Triangular Distributions ID Task Name Rept ID Min Rdur ML Rdur Max Rdur Curve 1 Project 2 0d 0d 0d 0 2 Start 0 0d 0d 0d 0 3 Design Unit 0 20 d 30 d 45 d 2 4 Build Unit 0 35 d 40 d 50 d 2 5 Test Unit 0 20 d 25 d 50 d 2 6 Finish 0 0d 0d 0d 0 © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 9
10.
What is a
Simulation? • How do you find total project results? – Cannot add distributions – Must combine distributions • Combining distributions using simulation – Almost all possible combinations of durations – “Perform” the project many times © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 10
11.
Combine Distributions by
Simulation • Monte Carlo simulation – Very General – 50-year old method • Computer “performs” project many times – Exercise is a “simulation” – Each calculation is an “iteration” • Brute force solution – All combinations of possible costs or durations © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 11
12.
Monte Carlo Simulation
Results for Really Simple Schedule CPM date is not even the most likely – That’s about 9/10 Date: 2/18/2006 3:56:56 P M Com pletion S td Deviation: 8.75 d S am ples : 3000 95% Confidenc e Interval: 0.31 d Unique ID: 2 E ac h bar repres ents 3 d Nam e: P rojec t 0.14 1.0 Com pletion P robability Table 0.9 Cumulative Probability 0.12 P rob Date P rob Date 0.8 0.05 8/31 0.55 9/14 0.10 0.7 0.10 9/2 0.60 9/16 Frequency 0.6 0.15 9/4 0.65 9/17 0.08 0.5 0.20 9/6 0.70 9/18 0.06 0.4 0.25 9/7 0.75 9/19 0.3 0.30 9/8 0.80 9/21 0.04 0.35 9/10 0.85 9/23 0.2 0.02 0.40 9/11 0.90 9/25 0.1 0.45 9/12 0.95 9/29 8/21 9/13 10/10 0.50 9/13 1.00 10/10 C o mp le tio n D a te 80% Target is CPM date is&<15% Likely to be met © 2007 Hulett Associates, LLC. 9/21 12
13.
Risk at Merge
Points: The “Merge Bias” • Many parallel paths merge in a real schedule • Finish driven by the latest converging path • Merge Bias has been understood for 40 years Design Unit 1 Build Unit 1 Test Unit 1 Start Finish Design Unit 2 Build Unit 2 Test Unit 2 © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 13
14.
This Schedule has
Three Parallel Paths ID Task Name Rept ID Min Rdur ML Rdur Max Rdur Curve May June July August Septemb 1 Project 2 0d 0d 0d 0 2 Start 0 0d 0d 0d 0 6/1 3 Unit 1 1 0d 0d 0d 0 4 Design Unit 0 20 d 30 d 45 d 2 6/1 6/30 5 Build Unit 1 0 35 d 40 d 50 d 2 7/1 8/9 6 Test Unit 1 0 20 d 25 d 50 d 2 8/10 9/3 7 Unit 2 1 0d 0d 0d 0 11 Unit 3 1 0d 0d 0d 0 15 Finish 0 0d 0d 0d 0 9/3 Two paths are collapsed Each path has exactly the same structure © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 14
15.
Evidence of the
Merge Bias Date: 2/18/2006 4:04:12 PM Date: 2/18/2006 3:56:56 PM Samples: 3000 Samples: 3000 Unique ID: 2 Unique ID: 2 Name: Project Name: Project 0.16 1.0 0.14 1.0 0.9 0.9 0.14 Cumulative Probability Cumulative Probability 0.12 0.8 0.8 0.12 0.7 0.10 0.7 Frequency Frequency 0.10 0.6 0.6 0.08 0.08 0.5 0.5 0.4 0.06 0.4 0.06 0.3 0.04 0.3 0.04 0.2 0.2 0.02 0.02 0.1 0.1 8/31 9/21 10/14 8/21 9/13 10/10 Completion Date Completion Date Three Path Project One Path Project © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 15
16.
Evidence of Merge
Bias (continued) C o m p le t io n S t d D e via t io n : 6 . 9 5 d C o m p le t io n S t d D e via t io n : 8 . 9 3 d 9 5 % C o n fid e n c e In t e rva l: 0 . 2 5 d 9 5 % C o n fid e n c e In t e rva l: 0 . 3 2 d E a c h b a r re p re s e n t s 3 d E a c h b a r re p re s e n t s 3 d C o m p le t io n P ro b a b ilit y Ta b le C o m p le t io n P ro b a b ilit y Ta b le P ro b D ate P ro b Date P ro b D ate P ro b D ate 0.05 9/10 0.55 9/22 0.05 8/31 0.55 9/14 0.10 9/13 0.60 9/23 0.10 9/3 0.60 9/15 0.15 9/14 0.65 9/24 0.15 9/4 0.65 9/17 0.20 9/15 0.70 9/25 0.20 9/6 0.70 9/18 0.25 9/16 0.75 9/26 0.25 9/7 0.75 9/20 0.30 9/17 0.80 9/27 0.30 9/8 0.80 9/21 0.35 9/18 0.85 9/29 0.35 9/9 0.85 9/23 0.40 9/19 0.90 10/1 0.40 9/11 0.90 9/25 0.45 9/20 0.95 10/3 0.45 9/12 0.95 9/29 0.50 9/21 1.00 10/14 0.50 9/13 1.00 10/15 Three Path Schedule One Path Schedule © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 16
17.
Graphical Evidence of
the Merge Bias The "Merge Bias" 100% 90% 80% 70% One 60% Path b. Cum.Pro Three 50% Path 40% Merge Bias 30% 20% 10% 0% 8/11 8/21 8/31 9/10 9/20 9/30 10/10 10/20 Date © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 17
18.
Cost and Schedule
Risk Integration Risk Project Schedule Cost Risk Risk “Burn Rate” Time Independent Time Costs Time Dependent Project Costs Cost Risk © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 18
19.
Cost Estimating Basics •
Cost estimates can be constructed by multiplying: – Workers assigned – Daily rate – Duration of task • Uncertainty in any of these variables leads to uncertainty in project cost estimates • Cost risk estimating can be more accurate and the reasons for risk better illuminated when time and cost factors are addressed individually rather than as one cost uncertainty distribution © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 19
20.
Cost / Schedule
Risk Using a Schedule • Simple schedule • Starts June 1, finishes without risk on September 6 ID Task Name Duration Start Finish May June July August SeptembO 0 Integrated Cost-Sched 98 d 6/1 9/6 1 Start 0d 6/1 6/1 6/1 2 Design 28 d 6/1 6/28 6/1 6/28 3 Build 45 d 6/29 8/12 6/29 8/12 4 Test 25 d 8/13 9/6 8/13 9/6 5 Finish 0d 9/6 9/6 9/6 © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 20
21.
Add Resources to
the Simple Schedule • Designers, builders and testers are assigned and cost data are specified ID Task Name Duration Start Finish Resource Names 0 Integrated Cost-Schedule 98 d 6/1 9/6 1 Start 0d 6/1 6/1 2 Design 28 d 6/1 6/28 Designers[5] 3 Build 45 d 6/29 8/12 Builders[10] 4 Test 25 d 8/13 9/6 Testers[8] 5 Finish 0d 9/6 9/6 Resource Name Type of Resource Rate Designers Work $90/hr Builders Work $80/hr Testers Work $105/hr © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 21
22.
Computing Schedule Risk
when Time and Resources are in MS Project • Using Risk+, simulate the MS Project schedule, collecting cost results for the project • Inputs – 3-point estimates for duration of tasks • Outputs – Pairs of cost and date for each iteration • Note: the cost of each resource per time period is fixed in this method © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 22
23.
Inputs to Schedule
Risk Analysis ID Task Name Rept Min Rd ML Rdu Max Rd Curve 0 Integrated Cost- 2 0d 0d 0d 0 1 Start 0 0d 0d 0d 0 2 Design 0 20 d 28 d 40 d 2 3 Build 0 35 d 45 d 60 d 2 4 Test 0 15 d 25 d 40 d 2 5 Finish 0 0d 0d 0d 0 © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 23
24.
Schedule Risk Analysis:
Dates Date: 2/18/2006 9:49:40 AM Completion Std Deviation: 8.25 d Samples: 3000 95% Confidence Interval: 0.29 d Unique ID: 0 Each bar represents 3 d Name: Integrated Cost-Schedule 0.14 1.0 Completion Probability Table 0.9 Cumulative Probability 0.12 Prob Date Prob Date 0.8 0.05 8/29 0.55 9/12 0.10 0.7 0.10 8/31 0.60 9/13 Frequency 0.6 0.15 9/2 0.65 9/14 0.08 0.5 0.20 9/4 0.70 9/16 0.06 0.4 0.25 9/5 0.75 9/17 0.3 0.30 9/7 0.80 9/18 0.04 0.35 9/8 0.85 9/20 Source: 0.2 0.40 9/9 0.90 9/22 0.02 Risk+® 0.1 0.45 9/10 0.95 9/25 8/17 9/11 10/7 0.50 9/11 1.00 10/7 Completion Date Sept. 6 is 25 – 30% likely. 80th percentile is Sept. 20 for a 2-week contingency © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 24
25.
All Resource Types
are “Work” • Each resource is assumed to work on a daily basis – Baseline cost is $556,800 – Each extra day of work is extra cost, dollar for dollar • Cost risk is determined by uncertain durations only ID Task Name Duration Total Cost 0 Integrated Cost-Schedule 98 d $556,800 1 Start 0d $0 2 Design 28 d $100,800 3 Build 45 d $288,000 4 Test 25 d $168,000 5 Finish 0d $0 © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 25
26.
All Resource Types
are “Work” (2) Date: 2/18/2006 9:49:40 AM Cost Standard Deviation: $49,645 Samples: 3000 95% Confidence Interval: $1,777 Unique ID: 0 Each bar represents $25,000 Name: Integrated Cost-Schedule 0.20 1.0 Cost Probability Table 0.18 0.9 Cumulative Probability Prob Cost Prob Cost 0.16 0.8 0.05 $503,329 0.55 $589,111 0.14 0.7 0.10 $519,541 0.60 $595,793 Frequency 0.12 0.6 0.15 $530,895 0.65 $602,967 0.10 0.5 0.20 $539,706 0.70 $610,397 0.08 0.4 0.25 $547,195 0.75 $617,877 0.06 0.3 0.30 $555,041 0.80 $626,705 0.35 $562,138 0.85 $636,646 0.04 0.2 0.40 $569,210 0.90 $649,900 0.02 0.1 0.45 $575,955 0.95 $667,044 $432,397 $583,479 $736,369 0.50 $583,082 1.00 $736,369 Cost Cost risk results differ because activity duration risks differ © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 26
27.
With Work-Type Resources,
Cost and Time are Highly Correlated Scatter Plot of Time and Cost for Work-Type Resources 800,000 700,000 600,000 500,000 Cost 400,000 300,000 200,000 100,000 0 8/11 8/21 8/31 9/10 9/20 9/30 10/10 Date © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 27
28.
Uncertainty in the
“Burn Rate” • Usually resources are found in a spreadsheet • This enables us to deal with uncertain burn rates • Cost estimates are often at a less detailed level than the schedule • We also will often need schedule risk analysis for a summary task © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 28
29.
Cost Estimates are
in a Spreadsheet / Schedules are in Scheduling Package • Process when schedule is in MS Project and costs are in MS Excel • Use schedule risk results from Risk+ for Project and Crystal Ball for Excel – Simulate MS Project with Risk+ for duration, not dates – Read the detailed iteration results into a spreadsheet – Estimate the Crystal Ball function that fits the best – Use that function in the cost estimate to represent uncertain duration in Crystal Ball simulation of cost risk © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 29
30.
The Cost Estimate
may be at a Higher Level than the Schedule Summary Cost Estimate Cost Element Value Average Workers 8 Hourly Rate 88 Hours/Day 8 Days 98 Total Cost 556,800 © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 30
31.
Determine the Best
Crystal Ball Distribution for the Uncertain Schedule Risk Duration: Beta Source: Crystal Ball® © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 31
32.
Distribution Parameters
© 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 32
33.
Insert Uncertain Burn
Rate into Cost Model Summary Cost Estimate Cost Element Value Minimum Most Likely Maximum Average Workers 8 6 8 12 Hourly Rate 88 84 88 100 Hours/Day 8 Days 98 Fitted Beta Distribution Total Cost 556,800 © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 33
34.
Adding Uncertainty in
Burn Rate Uncertain Duration, Workers and Rate per Hour 1,200,000 1,000,000 800,000 Cost 600,000 400,000 200,000 More Scatter, Less Tightly Correlated due 0 8/11 8/21 8/31 9/10 9/20 9/30 10/10 to Uncertain Burn Rate Date © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 34
35.
Consider More Realism:
Time-Independent Resources • Some resources’ costs are not determined by time – E.g., test equipment, materials • These are “use-type” or “material-type” resources • Their costs may not be known with certainty but they are not determined by activity durations © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 35
36.
Add Test Equipment
@ $200,000 Time and Material Resources Resource Type Hourly Rate Rate per Use Designers Work $90/hr N/A Builders Work $80/hr N/A Testers Work $105/hr N/A Test Equipment Material N/A $200,000 ID Task Name Duration Start Finish Cost Resource Names 0 Integrated Cost-Schedule 98 d 6/1 9/6 $756,800 1 Start 0d 6/1 6/1 $0 2 Design 28 d 6/1 6/28 $100,800 Designers[5] 3 Build 45 d 6/29 8/12 $288,000 Builders[10] 4 Test 25 d 8/13 9/6 $368,000 Testers[8],Test Equipme 5 Finish 0d 9/6 9/6 $0 © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 36
37.
Add Risky Materials
Cost Independent of Time Summary Cost Estimate Cost Element Value Minimum Most Likely Maximum Average Workers 8 6 8 12 Hourly Rate 88 84 88 100 Hours/Day 8 Days 98 Beta Distribution Time-Related Cost 556,800 Test Equipment 200,000 160,000 200,000 280,000 Total Cost 756,800 © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 37
38.
Adding Materials with
Time-Independent Risk Adding Time-Independent Equipment Cost Risk 1,400,000 1,200,000 1,000,000 800,000 Cost Series1 600,000 400,000 More Scatter, 200,000 tightly Less Correlated due to0 Uncertain Burn Rate and 8/21 8/11 8/31 9/10 9/20 9/30 10/10 Date Risky Time-Independent Material Cost © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 38
39.
Computing Schedule Risk
when Cost and Schedule are in the Scheduling Program • Resources are identified and their hourly or daily cost are input into the scheduling software • Resources are assigned to tasks and costs of those tasks and the total project are computed • Uncertainty can be added by: – Probability distribution of the duration – Probability distribution of the burn rate – Use or material resources can also be risky and their costs varied • Jointly simulate the cost and schedule in the program © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 39
40.
Hardware / Software
Build and Integrate Build the Schedule in Primavera Project Planner (P3) © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 40
41.
Modern Approach to
Integrated C/S Risk: Import P3 Schedule to Pertmaster © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 41
42.
Pertmaster Risk from
P3 Schedules Duration Risk Range © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 42
43.
Pertmaster Risk from
P3 Schedules (2) Time-Independent Risk Range Burn Rate Risk Range © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 43
44.
Integrated Cost and
Schedule Risk Results Overrun both Cost and Schedule Date and Cost Scatter plot from Pertmaster® schedule risk software © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 44
45.
Summary of Main
Principles • Schedule Risk depends on the schedule logic and uncertainty in the activity durations • Monte Carlo simulation is the accepted method of estimating the uncertainty from all risks simultaneously • Simulation software allows Monte Carlo for schedules in several packages (e.g. Project, P3) © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 45
46.
Summary of Main
Principles (2) • Cost risk depends in large part on elements of schedule uncertainty – The cost estimate is not secure if the schedule is slipping • Uncertain burn rates for time-dependent costs • Uncertain costs for time-independent costs © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 46
47.
Integrated Cost /
Schedule Risk Analysis A presentation to the PM Challenge February 6-7, 2007 Moody Gardens, Galveston, TX David T. Hulett, Ph.D. Hulett & Associates, LLC Los Angeles, CA (310) 476-7699 / info@projectrisk.com www.projectrisk.com © 2007 Hulett & Associates, LLC. 47
Baixar agora