SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 24
The Tragedies of Mentor: A Reason to Fix Federal and the State of Ohio’s Anti-Bullying Legislation Michael T. Muha Regulatory Law  April 4, 2011
Agenda ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Why Should We Care?
Bullying Statistics Source: Data from Table 11.2 in Indicators of School Crime and Safety: 2009; National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education (http://nces.ed.gov/).
The Mentor Tragedies Eric Mohat, Sladjana Vidovics, Meredith Rezak, and Jennifer Eyring all committed suicide in little over than two years.  The family of Eric is suing Mentor on multiple counts including violations of their procedural and substantive Due Process rights of familial relationship and failing to properly train teachers and officers pursuant to  Monell v. Dept. of Social Services , 436 U.S. 658 (1978). Source:  Mohat v. Mentor Exempted Village School District , 2010 WL 359693 (2009).
Thesis ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Where Are We Right Now? Stage 1 Free Market Stage 2 Market Failure *Stage 3* Government Regulation Stage 4 Regulatory Failure Stage 5 Regulatory Reform Stage 6 Deregulation
Vectors of Influence
The Federal Government’s Role ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The Student Non-Discrimination Act (SNDA) ,[object Object]
The Safe Schools Improvement Act of 2011 (SSIA) ,[object Object],[object Object]
SSIA (continued) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Why Has It Taken So Long?  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Minnesota ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Sources:  http://minnesotaindependent.com/35560/advocates-call-anti-bullying-veto-a-lost-opportunity  &  http://minnesotaindependent.com/64047/anti-gay-group-organizes-in-anoka-schools-as-community-deals-with-gay-suicides
What Does A Normal State Anti-Bullying Law Look Like? ,[object Object]
What Are State Governments Doing? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Source: bullypolice.org
Ohio’s Anti-Bullying Legislation ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Mohat’s Claims ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Source:  Mohat v. Mentor Exempted Village School District
Mentor’s Response ,[object Object],[object Object],Source: Susan Donaldson James. Teen Commits Suicide Due to Bullying: Parents Sue School for Son’s Death. ABC News. April 2, 2009
What Does the Mentor Situation Mean? ,[object Object],[object Object]
What Does Mentor Mean? (cont.) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
How Mentor Could Have Been Prevented ,[object Object],[object Object]
How Do We Do It?  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Conclusion ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

America_Divided_Guide-4
America_Divided_Guide-4America_Divided_Guide-4
America_Divided_Guide-4Sara Wicht
 
MartinMA Research Paper
MartinMA Research PaperMartinMA Research Paper
MartinMA Research PaperMadison Martin
 
EVERFI and Peter Lake - The Future of Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
EVERFI and Peter Lake - The Future of Diversity, Equity & InclusionEVERFI and Peter Lake - The Future of Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
EVERFI and Peter Lake - The Future of Diversity, Equity & InclusionKatie Mitchell
 
Bicker, Jab And More Deadlock: Washington’s Bipartisan Solution For Income In...
Bicker, Jab And More Deadlock: Washington’s Bipartisan Solution For Income In...Bicker, Jab And More Deadlock: Washington’s Bipartisan Solution For Income In...
Bicker, Jab And More Deadlock: Washington’s Bipartisan Solution For Income In...peacefulstem061
 
Health Advocacy for LGBT community: Stakholders and Power Analysis
Health Advocacy for LGBT community: Stakholders and Power AnalysisHealth Advocacy for LGBT community: Stakholders and Power Analysis
Health Advocacy for LGBT community: Stakholders and Power AnalysisDr.Tanmay Singh
 
Kayla Barrett - Policy memorandum
Kayla Barrett - Policy memorandum Kayla Barrett - Policy memorandum
Kayla Barrett - Policy memorandum Kayla Barrett
 
Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)
Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)
Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)Swift Kick
 
Meagan Hubbard Federal Gov.
Meagan Hubbard Federal Gov.Meagan Hubbard Federal Gov.
Meagan Hubbard Federal Gov.MeaganHubbard2
 
Decreasing violence against sex workers through decriminalization, j nagorski
Decreasing violence against sex workers through decriminalization, j nagorskiDecreasing violence against sex workers through decriminalization, j nagorski
Decreasing violence against sex workers through decriminalization, j nagorskiJazmin Nagorski
 
VallasCriminalRecordsReport
VallasCriminalRecordsReportVallasCriminalRecordsReport
VallasCriminalRecordsReportTyler Cherry
 
Lettre des économistes contre Trump
Lettre des économistes contre TrumpLettre des économistes contre Trump
Lettre des économistes contre TrumpGrégoire Normand
 
Juvenile Delinquency
Juvenile DelinquencyJuvenile Delinquency
Juvenile Delinquencymacabremine
 
Summerlin discussion guide final
Summerlin discussion guide finalSummerlin discussion guide final
Summerlin discussion guide finalJazmin Nagorski
 

Mais procurados (19)

America_Divided_Guide-4
America_Divided_Guide-4America_Divided_Guide-4
America_Divided_Guide-4
 
MartinMA Research Paper
MartinMA Research PaperMartinMA Research Paper
MartinMA Research Paper
 
EVERFI and Peter Lake - The Future of Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
EVERFI and Peter Lake - The Future of Diversity, Equity & InclusionEVERFI and Peter Lake - The Future of Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
EVERFI and Peter Lake - The Future of Diversity, Equity & Inclusion
 
Bicker, Jab And More Deadlock: Washington’s Bipartisan Solution For Income In...
Bicker, Jab And More Deadlock: Washington’s Bipartisan Solution For Income In...Bicker, Jab And More Deadlock: Washington’s Bipartisan Solution For Income In...
Bicker, Jab And More Deadlock: Washington’s Bipartisan Solution For Income In...
 
Health Advocacy for LGBT community: Stakholders and Power Analysis
Health Advocacy for LGBT community: Stakholders and Power AnalysisHealth Advocacy for LGBT community: Stakholders and Power Analysis
Health Advocacy for LGBT community: Stakholders and Power Analysis
 
Kayla Barrett - Policy memorandum
Kayla Barrett - Policy memorandum Kayla Barrett - Policy memorandum
Kayla Barrett - Policy memorandum
 
Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)
Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)
Violence Against Women Act (VAWA)
 
Meagan Hubbard Federal Gov.
Meagan Hubbard Federal Gov.Meagan Hubbard Federal Gov.
Meagan Hubbard Federal Gov.
 
6.8 Adrienne Fernandes Alcantara
6.8 Adrienne Fernandes Alcantara6.8 Adrienne Fernandes Alcantara
6.8 Adrienne Fernandes Alcantara
 
LGBT
LGBTLGBT
LGBT
 
Decreasing violence against sex workers through decriminalization, j nagorski
Decreasing violence against sex workers through decriminalization, j nagorskiDecreasing violence against sex workers through decriminalization, j nagorski
Decreasing violence against sex workers through decriminalization, j nagorski
 
VallasCriminalRecordsReport
VallasCriminalRecordsReportVallasCriminalRecordsReport
VallasCriminalRecordsReport
 
White Privilege
White Privilege White Privilege
White Privilege
 
Lettre des économistes contre Trump
Lettre des économistes contre TrumpLettre des économistes contre Trump
Lettre des économistes contre Trump
 
PY622 Final Paper (correct)
PY622 Final Paper (correct)PY622 Final Paper (correct)
PY622 Final Paper (correct)
 
Juvenile Delinquency
Juvenile DelinquencyJuvenile Delinquency
Juvenile Delinquency
 
Summerlin discussion guide final
Summerlin discussion guide finalSummerlin discussion guide final
Summerlin discussion guide final
 
LGBT GROUP
LGBT GROUPLGBT GROUP
LGBT GROUP
 
Distracted driving civics
Distracted driving civicsDistracted driving civics
Distracted driving civics
 

Destaque

Pasos para constituir una empresa de telecomunicaciones en venezuela
Pasos para constituir una empresa de telecomunicaciones en venezuelaPasos para constituir una empresa de telecomunicaciones en venezuela
Pasos para constituir una empresa de telecomunicaciones en venezuelagass23
 
Herlenzagadki
HerlenzagadkiHerlenzagadki
Herlenzagadkimsonon
 
Herlentso
HerlentsoHerlentso
Herlentsomsonon
 
III тульский парад мам и детей 2011
III тульский парад мам и детей 2011III тульский парад мам и детей 2011
III тульский парад мам и детей 2011MamCompany
 
ποδοσφαιρο
 ποδοσφαιρο ποδοσφαιρο
ποδοσφαιροxristos00
 
Phase change materials in renewable energy
Phase change materials in renewable energyPhase change materials in renewable energy
Phase change materials in renewable energyTejwant Navalkar
 
Social media and learning elle wang
Social media and learning   elle wangSocial media and learning   elle wang
Social media and learning elle wangellewy
 
SHARED GEOMETRY TANGIBLE DIGITAL ENVIRONMENT
SHARED GEOMETRY TANGIBLE DIGITAL ENVIRONMENTSHARED GEOMETRY TANGIBLE DIGITAL ENVIRONMENT
SHARED GEOMETRY TANGIBLE DIGITAL ENVIRONMENTJoan Terres
 
Herlenzagadki
HerlenzagadkiHerlenzagadki
Herlenzagadkimsonon
 
Herlen
HerlenHerlen
Herlenmsonon
 
Новомосковский родильный дом
Новомосковский родильный домНовомосковский родильный дом
Новомосковский родильный домMamCompany
 
судалгаа1
судалгаа1судалгаа1
судалгаа1msonon
 
V Парад Мам и Детей в Туле, 1 июня 2013 года
V Парад Мам и Детей в Туле, 1 июня 2013 годаV Парад Мам и Детей в Туле, 1 июня 2013 года
V Парад Мам и Детей в Туле, 1 июня 2013 годаMamCompany
 
Challenges implementing Green Initiatives in Tall Buildings
Challenges implementing Green Initiatives in Tall BuildingsChallenges implementing Green Initiatives in Tall Buildings
Challenges implementing Green Initiatives in Tall BuildingsTejwant Navalkar
 

Destaque (17)

Pasos para constituir una empresa de telecomunicaciones en venezuela
Pasos para constituir una empresa de telecomunicaciones en venezuelaPasos para constituir una empresa de telecomunicaciones en venezuela
Pasos para constituir una empresa de telecomunicaciones en venezuela
 
Herlenzagadki
HerlenzagadkiHerlenzagadki
Herlenzagadki
 
Herlentso
HerlentsoHerlentso
Herlentso
 
III тульский парад мам и детей 2011
III тульский парад мам и детей 2011III тульский парад мам и детей 2011
III тульский парад мам и детей 2011
 
ποδοσφαιρο
 ποδοσφαιρο ποδοσφαιρο
ποδοσφαιρο
 
Phase change materials in renewable energy
Phase change materials in renewable energyPhase change materials in renewable energy
Phase change materials in renewable energy
 
Social media and learning elle wang
Social media and learning   elle wangSocial media and learning   elle wang
Social media and learning elle wang
 
SHARED GEOMETRY TANGIBLE DIGITAL ENVIRONMENT
SHARED GEOMETRY TANGIBLE DIGITAL ENVIRONMENTSHARED GEOMETRY TANGIBLE DIGITAL ENVIRONMENT
SHARED GEOMETRY TANGIBLE DIGITAL ENVIRONMENT
 
Herlenzagadki
HerlenzagadkiHerlenzagadki
Herlenzagadki
 
Herlen
HerlenHerlen
Herlen
 
Grammar
GrammarGrammar
Grammar
 
Новомосковский родильный дом
Новомосковский родильный домНовомосковский родильный дом
Новомосковский родильный дом
 
судалгаа1
судалгаа1судалгаа1
судалгаа1
 
V Парад Мам и Детей в Туле, 1 июня 2013 года
V Парад Мам и Детей в Туле, 1 июня 2013 годаV Парад Мам и Детей в Туле, 1 июня 2013 года
V Парад Мам и Детей в Туле, 1 июня 2013 года
 
4058075 kamus-akuntansi
4058075 kamus-akuntansi4058075 kamus-akuntansi
4058075 kamus-akuntansi
 
Barrios
BarriosBarrios
Barrios
 
Challenges implementing Green Initiatives in Tall Buildings
Challenges implementing Green Initiatives in Tall BuildingsChallenges implementing Green Initiatives in Tall Buildings
Challenges implementing Green Initiatives in Tall Buildings
 

Semelhante a The Tragedies Of Mentor: A Reason To Fix Federal and the State of Ohio\'s Anti-Bullying Legislation

Jeffrey powell dcl 25 apr-2012
Jeffrey powell dcl 25 apr-2012Jeffrey powell dcl 25 apr-2012
Jeffrey powell dcl 25 apr-2012Jeffrey Powell
 
Stepping up our sexual education game pt 2
Stepping up our sexual education game pt 2Stepping up our sexual education game pt 2
Stepping up our sexual education game pt 2Sidney Andrews
 
Essex, nathan l. sexual violence and public schools nfeasj v33 n4 2015
Essex, nathan l. sexual violence and public schools nfeasj v33 n4 2015Essex, nathan l. sexual violence and public schools nfeasj v33 n4 2015
Essex, nathan l. sexual violence and public schools nfeasj v33 n4 2015William Kritsonis
 
The Campus Sexual Violence Elimination Act: What You Need to Know
The Campus Sexual Violence Elimination Act: What You Need to KnowThe Campus Sexual Violence Elimination Act: What You Need to Know
The Campus Sexual Violence Elimination Act: What You Need to KnowJennifer Hill
 
Jeffrey powell print DCL 25-April-2012
Jeffrey powell print DCL 25-April-2012Jeffrey powell print DCL 25-April-2012
Jeffrey powell print DCL 25-April-2012Jeffrey Powell
 
Bullying in the digital age4
Bullying in the digital age4Bullying in the digital age4
Bullying in the digital age4lheikkila
 
ChangeHappensFourthEditionMaster
ChangeHappensFourthEditionMasterChangeHappensFourthEditionMaster
ChangeHappensFourthEditionMasterErin Burrows
 
Safer change happensguide_2007
Safer change happensguide_2007Safer change happensguide_2007
Safer change happensguide_2007Bulbul Gupta
 

Semelhante a The Tragedies Of Mentor: A Reason To Fix Federal and the State of Ohio\'s Anti-Bullying Legislation (13)

Jeffrey powell dcl 25 apr-2012
Jeffrey powell dcl 25 apr-2012Jeffrey powell dcl 25 apr-2012
Jeffrey powell dcl 25 apr-2012
 
Stepping up our sexual education game pt 2
Stepping up our sexual education game pt 2Stepping up our sexual education game pt 2
Stepping up our sexual education game pt 2
 
Essex, nathan l. sexual violence and public schools nfeasj v33 n4 2015
Essex, nathan l. sexual violence and public schools nfeasj v33 n4 2015Essex, nathan l. sexual violence and public schools nfeasj v33 n4 2015
Essex, nathan l. sexual violence and public schools nfeasj v33 n4 2015
 
"Dear Colleague" Letter
"Dear Colleague" Letter"Dear Colleague" Letter
"Dear Colleague" Letter
 
312 Proposal
312 Proposal312 Proposal
312 Proposal
 
The Campus Sexual Violence Elimination Act: What You Need to Know
The Campus Sexual Violence Elimination Act: What You Need to KnowThe Campus Sexual Violence Elimination Act: What You Need to Know
The Campus Sexual Violence Elimination Act: What You Need to Know
 
Bullying
BullyingBullying
Bullying
 
Jeffrey powell print DCL 25-April-2012
Jeffrey powell print DCL 25-April-2012Jeffrey powell print DCL 25-April-2012
Jeffrey powell print DCL 25-April-2012
 
Sexual Haressment
Sexual HaressmentSexual Haressment
Sexual Haressment
 
Sexual Haressment
Sexual HaressmentSexual Haressment
Sexual Haressment
 
Bullying in the digital age4
Bullying in the digital age4Bullying in the digital age4
Bullying in the digital age4
 
ChangeHappensFourthEditionMaster
ChangeHappensFourthEditionMasterChangeHappensFourthEditionMaster
ChangeHappensFourthEditionMaster
 
Safer change happensguide_2007
Safer change happensguide_2007Safer change happensguide_2007
Safer change happensguide_2007
 

The Tragedies Of Mentor: A Reason To Fix Federal and the State of Ohio\'s Anti-Bullying Legislation

  • 1. The Tragedies of Mentor: A Reason to Fix Federal and the State of Ohio’s Anti-Bullying Legislation Michael T. Muha Regulatory Law April 4, 2011
  • 2.
  • 4. Bullying Statistics Source: Data from Table 11.2 in Indicators of School Crime and Safety: 2009; National Center for Education Statistics, U.S. Department of Education (http://nces.ed.gov/).
  • 5. The Mentor Tragedies Eric Mohat, Sladjana Vidovics, Meredith Rezak, and Jennifer Eyring all committed suicide in little over than two years. The family of Eric is suing Mentor on multiple counts including violations of their procedural and substantive Due Process rights of familial relationship and failing to properly train teachers and officers pursuant to Monell v. Dept. of Social Services , 436 U.S. 658 (1978). Source: Mohat v. Mentor Exempted Village School District , 2010 WL 359693 (2009).
  • 6.
  • 7. Where Are We Right Now? Stage 1 Free Market Stage 2 Market Failure *Stage 3* Government Regulation Stage 4 Regulatory Failure Stage 5 Regulatory Reform Stage 6 Deregulation
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13.
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.