Innovation Ecosystems refer to the inter-organizational, political, economic, environmental, and technological systems through which a milieu conducive to business growth is catalyzed, sustained, and supported. The orchestration of relationships through which talent, information and financial resources flow is a critical capability for regional transformation. Using data-driven visualizations of relationships for co-creation, examples from Norway, Europe and Austin are described in the context of technology-based wealth creation.
Paradip CALL GIRL❤7091819311❤CALL GIRLS IN ESCORT SERVICE WE ARE PROVIDING
Orchestrating Ecosystem Transformation with Data-Driven Network Visualizations
1. Orchestra)ng
Ecosystem
Transforma)ons
with
Data-‐driven
Network
Visualiza)ons
Martha
G
Russell
h-p://mediax.stanford.edu
Neil
Rubens,
Jukka
Huhtamäki,
Kaisa
SBll,
Camilla
Yu,
Rahul
Basole
13. InnovaBon
Ecosystems
Innova)on
Ecosystems
refer
to
the
inter-‐organizaBonal,
poliBcal,
economic,
environmental,
and
technological
systems
through
which
a
milieu
conducive
to
business
growth
is
catalyzed,
sustained,
and
supported.
Heterogeneous
and
conBnuously
evolving
set
of
firms
that
are
interconnected
through
a
complex,
global
network
of
relaBonships.
[Basole
et
al.,
2012
A
dynamic
innovaBon
ecosystem
is
characterized
by
a
conBnual
realignment
of
synergisBc
relaBonships
that
promote
growth
of
the
system.
In
agile
responsiveness
to
changing
internal
and
external
forces,
knowledge,
capital
and
other
vital
resources
flow
through
these
relaBonships.
Martha G. Russell, Kaisa Still, Jukka Huhtamaki, and Neil Rubens, “Transforming innovation ecosystems through shared vision
and network orchestration,” Triple Helix IX Conference, Stanford University, July 13, 2011.
14. InnovaBon
Ecosystems
Approach
• Networked
systems
perspecBve
to
examine
why,
when,
and
how
interfirm
networks
and
alliances
form
and
change
(Gula)
et
al.,
2000)
• Co-‐crea)on
creates
value
(Ramaswamy
&
Guillart,
2004)
• Value
creaBon
requires
orchestra)on
among
firms
across
segments
(Basole
&
Karla,
2012;
Dhanaraj
&
Parkhe,
2006)
• Responsiveness
to
changing
internal
and
external
forces
(Rubens
et
al.,
2011)
• Shared
Vision
guides
and
accelerates
transformaBon
(Russell
et
al.,
2011)
16. The Way We USED to Think About Organizations New
OrganizaBonal
Chart
Based
on
RelaBonships
Relationship-Focused Co-Creation Infrastructure
Stakeholder
Infrastructure
=
RelaBonships
(Companies
are
interlocked
through
key
people
–
informa8on
flow,
norms,
mental
models.(Davis,1996)
17. New Data & New Tools
Accessing Data Streams about Innovation
Building a Dataset on Innovation
Crystallisation Through Visualisation The
Card-‐Mackinlay-‐Shneiderman
visualisaBon
reference
model:(Card
et
al.,
1999;
Miksch,
2005)
!"#$%&'()*+%
,"-)*%
./0*1)2*3'1$%
4"-"/*3'1%
51*+6$)$%
,)1)10%
7)$8*+)2*3'1% 5(39"%
:1;"++)0"1("%
</)9*;"%
=*;*%
!"##$%&'()*+,'-%
Accuracy
of
Wikipedia
(Giles,
2005)
18. STEP
1
Boundary
SpecificaBon
STEP
2
Metrics
IdenBficaBon
STEP
3
ComputaBon,
Analysis
&
VisualizaBon
STEP
4
Sense
Making
&
Storytelling
DATA
determines
feeds
Deals
&
Alliances
Execu)ves
&
Funding
Public
Opinion
&
Discourse
IEN
NL
SDC
Iden8fy,
extract,
and
curate
InnovaBon
Ecosystem
Network
Data-‐driven
VisualizaBons
Basole,
Russell,
Huhtamäki,
SBll
and
Rubens,
“Understanding
Mobile
Ecosystem
Dynamics:
A
Data-‐Driven
Approach,”
Submi-ed
to
JIT
March
2013.
19. The
new
maps
may
be
based
on
the
connecBons
through
relaBonships
-‐
rather
than
on
distance.
§ Ecosystem
PerspecBve
§ RelaBonship
based
§ Links
form
networks
§ Resource
flows
=
knowledge,
capital,
talent
§ Network
orchestraBon
21. Norwegian
Tech-‐based
Companies
Their
Branch
Offices
and
Their
Financial
Orgs
Links
show
relaBonships
Example
view
to
IEN
dataset
in
Gephi.
Companies
are
selected
with
keyword
search
“Norway
+
Norwegian;”
the
funding
organizaBons
associated
with
those
companies
are
added
Nodes
represent
companies
and
their
investors;
edges
indicate
resource
flows.
The
network
layout
is
created
with
Yifan
Hu
MulBlevel
algorithm
and
nodes
are
inflated
according
to
their
indegree,
i.e.
the
number
of
the
connected
investors.
22. Advisors & Angels Expand Access
Investors
leverage
co-‐creaBon
opportuniBes
with
investments
in
mulBple
companies.
Intl
companies
not
shown.
Companies
leverage
value
co-‐creaBon
opportuniBes
through
relaBonships
with
mulBple
investors.
Some
investors
are
internaBonal.
Timeline
analysis
of
investment
events
reveals
pa-erns
of
co-‐investment
–
an
indicaBon
of
intenBon
to
co-‐create
value
and,
perhaps,
sBmulus
programs.
IEN
Dataset,
July
2010
23. Sørlandet is world leading in offshore oil drilling
technology
Torger Rev, Innovation Ecosystems Summit, Stanford University, July 11, 2011
24. Shipping
brokers
Effective
ports and
terminals
Advanced
ship equip-
ment
Maritime
R&D
Specialized
ship yards
Maritime
education
Ship
design
Maritime
IT
Ship
management
Marine
insurance
Shipping
finance
Advanced
fisheries
Environmental
standards
MariBme
policies
Offshore
oil
and
gas
industry
LogisBcs
systems
MariBme
lawyers
Ship
classificaBon
services
SHIPPING
Mari)me:
From
ship
tonnage
to
mari)me
technology
and
finance
Torger Rev, Innovation Ecosystems Summit, Stanford University, July 11, 2011
25. SHIPPING
Torger Rev, Innovation Ecosystems Summit, Stanford University, July 11, 2011
Mari)me:
From
ship
tonnage
to
mari)me
technology
and
finance
26. Insights
About
Norway
• Dual
offices:
regional
and
Oslo
• In
sectors
we
studied
– Business
locaBons
parallel
technical
university
programs
– Investor
relaBonships
have
strong
local
links
• Some
invesBng
organizaBons
are
governmental
programs
• Expands
to
Oslo
when
offices
are
in
Oslo
• InternaBonal
relaBonships
linked
to
small
set
of
personal
relaBonships
at
execuBve
level
– InternaBonal
investors
drawn
through
execuBve
relaBonships
• RelaBonships
through
execs
at
Google
and
AOL
provide
channels
for
global
network
expansion
27.
28. CapDigital
-‐
Regional
Sector
Catalyst
Vision
To
catalyze
the
new
digital
infrastructure
in
France
with
global
connecBons
To
create
an
ecosystem
to
facilitate
the
relaBonship
between
France
and
global
market
Enable
Paris
to
become
global
region
of
the
market
for
digital
services
How
do
you
spend
money
locally
to
enhance
global
parBcipaBon
in
a
way
that
returns
the
benefit
back
home?
• CapDigital
members:
– Small
startups
– Large
companies
– Support
programs
28
31. CapDigital
Program
OpportuniBes
Pale Red: French company
Dark Red: CapDigital member
Light Green: Foreign Venture/ firm
Dark Green: French venture firm
Blue: Foreign company
Zone
2:
VC
Community
Zone
3:
New
CapDigital
Members
Zone
4
of
Parisian
Two-‐Level
InnovaBon
Ecosystem
From
IEN
Dataset
2010
Selected
Paris
companies
Linked
people
&
venture/financing
enBBes
Linked
companies,
people
&
v/f
enBBes
1
degree
2
degree
32.
33. Analysis
of
EIT
ICT
Labs:
Trento
included
as
the
sixth
node,
more
ciBes
connected
to
colocaBon
centers,
updated
data
and
transformaBon
in
place
SBll,
Huhtamäki,
Russell,
Rubens
(2012).
Transforming
Innova8on
Ecosystems
Through
Network
Orchestra8on:
Case
EIT
ICT
Labs
34. Adding
San
Francisco
Bay
Area
as
“the
seventh
EIT
ICT
Labs
node”
for
contrast,
interconnecBons,
comparison
and
benchmark
SBll,
Huhtamäki,
Russell,
Rubens
(2012).
Transforming
Innova8on
Ecosystems
Through
Network
Orchestra8on:
Case
EIT
ICT
Labs
39. Zone 1: Multiple Connections & Investors
Datical
ATI company. Datical received seed fund of $660K in July last year. It has
diversified investors, including Austin Ventures.
Funding
TOTAL
$660K
Seed,
7/12
AusBn
Ventures
Mohr
Davidow
Ventures
Mercury
Fund
John
Hime
Robert
Reeves
Daniel
Nelson
Leadership
Daniel
Nelson
CEO,
Cofounder
Pete
Pickerill
VP
Products,
Cofounder
Robert
Reeves
CTO,
Cofounder
40. John Hime is on the board of both Affinegy (ATI alumus company) and Datical
(current ATI company). Datical has had several venture investments; Affinegy
has had none yet. Relationship may create bridge to investment.
ZONE 1: Emerging Network
41. Ordoro - ATI Alumus
A current ATI company is
connected with an ATI alumus
company through Central Texas
Angel Network.
Contribution of ATI, such as
introducing the companies
XERIS develops patient-
friendly injectables based
on its XeriJect™ and
XeriSol™ formulation and
delivery platforms.
Ordoro provides a web app
for small and medium-sized
e-commerce retailers to
manage their orders,
inventory and suppliers.
XERIS - Current ATIZONE 2: Potential Network
45. AusBn
Start-‐ups,
Founders
and
Angels
IEN
Dataset,
March,
2013
692
companies
3500+
investors
$79K
average
investment
46. Colleges/Universi)es
=
200+
University
of
Texas,
AusBn
Stanford
University
Massachuse-s
InsBtute
of
Technology
University
of
California,
Berkeley
Georgia
InsBtute
of
Technology
University
of
Michigan
Harvard
University
Purdue
University
University
of
Colorado,
Boulder
University
of
Chicago
Loca)ons
=
200+
San
Francisco
New
York,
NY
Los
Angeles
Houston
Palo
Alto
Dallas
London
Boston
Chicago
Silicon
Valley
Sectors/Markets
=
374
Social
media
Mobile
SaaS
e-‐commerce
Digital
media
Social
commerce
Consumer
internet
Marketplaces
Small
and
medium
businesses
EducaBon
Companies
=
2000+
Latakoo
Bazaarvoice
Infochimps
SalesVu
OwnLocal
Predictable
Data
Mass
Relevance
ForcasBx
SQMOS
Vivogig
Network
of
AusBn
Start-‐ups,
Founders
&
Angels
IEN
Dataset,
March,
2013
47. Actors &
Events
Impact
over time
Coalitions
Shared
Vision
TransformaBon
Measure & Track
Interact &
Feedback
Co-Create
Value
Measuring Impact of Transformative Coalitions
in Innovation Ecosystems
Martha G. Russell, Kaisa Still, Jukka Huhtamaki, and Neil Rubens, “Transforming innovation ecosystems through shared vision
and network orchestration,” Triple Helix IX Conference, Stanford University, July 13, 2011.
50. THE
GOAL
OF
CREATIVE
COLLABORATIONS
IS
TO
DO
SOMETHING
TOGETHER
THAT
NEITHER
COULD
DO
INDEPENDENTLY
PATE
IN
IC2
IITIATIVE
JOIN
THE
EFFORT
AND
HELP
US
MAP
IT
IC2-‐IEN
WORKING
SESSION
–
JUNE
3-‐4,
2013
FUTUR
EST
EN
SEINE,
PARIS,
JUNE
12-‐13,
2013
INTERNATIONAL
SOCIETY
OF
PROFESSIONAL
INNOVATION
MANAGERS
–
JUNE
16-‐19,
HELSINKI