SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 3
Download to read offline
1ST QUARTER 2010

………………………………                                             QUARTERLY COMMENTARY
1Q Review                                                Positive market returns of late have caused some investors to forget 2008; yet,
Last 3-Years Review                                      contrarian-minded investors have become even more cautious and skeptical.
                                                         We’ll take a moment to address the “Lost Decade,” which several clients have
Last Decade                                              referred to in the last few months; but first is a returns discussion centered
                                                         around volatility.
………………………………
                                                         First Quarter 2010
WHAT IS OCCAM’S RAZOR?

Occam’s Razor is a principle                             Volatility drives returns. 2008 gave us absurdly high volatility; and returns were
attributed to William Occam,                             driven deep into negative territory. We hoped that the high volatility of 2008
a 14th century philosopher. He                           would die down as mounting losses were becoming physically sickening. Yet,
stressed that explanations must                          we all also wished that before dying down, the high volatility would give us
not be multiplied beyond what                            some remarkable positive returns. We hoped this because volatility not only in-
is necessary. Thus, Occam’s Razor                        creases chances of negative returns, but it also provides opportunity for positive
is a term used to “shave off” or                         returns; thus, volatility drives returns. In the final three and a half quarters of
dismiss superfluous explanations                         2009 delivered substantial positive returns.
for a given event. This concept
is largely ignored within the
investment management landscape.
                                                          As of 3/31/2010
This newsletter will “shave off ”                         Asset Class                              Index                                                       1Q 2010         1 Year
popular investment misinformation                         US Large Cap                             S&P 500                                                      5.39%         49.77%
and present what is important for
achieving long-term investment                            US Large Cap Value                       Russell 1000 Value                                           6.79%         53.56%
success.                                                  US Large Cap Growth                      Russell 1000 Growth                                          4.65%         49.75%
                                                          US Small Cap                             Russell 2000                                                 8.85%         62.76%
DISCLOSURE The Company only transacts
business in states where it is properly registered, or    US Small Cap Value                       Russell 2000 Value                                           10.03%         65.06%
excluded or exempted from registration                    US Small Cap Growth                      Russell 2000 Growth                                          7.61%         60.31%
requirements. Please see our
disclosure pages for further detail.                      INTL Large Cap                           MSCI EAFE                                                    0.94%         55.20%
………………………………                                              INTL Large Cap Value                     MSCI EAFE Value                                              -0.17%        59.49%
                                                          INTL Small Cap                           MSCI EAFE Small Cap                                          4.82%          70.59%
This newsletter is published by:                          INTL Small Cap Value                     MSCI EAFE Small Value                                        4.49%          75.08%
McLean Asset Management Corp.                             Emerging Markets                         MSCI Emerging Markets                                        2.45%         81.55%
8200 Greensboro Road                                      REIT                                     Dow Jones US Select REIT                                     9.81%         113.47%
Suite 1150                                                US Short-term Bond                       Merrill Lynch One-Year US Treasury                           0.25%          1.06%
McLean, VA 22102                                          US Interm-term Bond                      Five-Year US Treasury Notes                                  1.76%          -0.07%
Phone: (703) 827-0636                                     Global Interm-term Bond                  Citi World Govt. Bond 1-5 Years                              0.76%          2.29%
www.mcleanam.com                                         All indices’ returns data are provided by the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP). Indices are not available for direct
www.investmentsignal.net                                 investment; their performance does not reflect the expenses associated with the management of an actual portfolio. Past per-
                                                         formance is not a guarantee of future results.

                                                         In the first quarter of 2010, the US equity markets continued its strong perform-
                                                         ance with the fourth consecutive quarter of above-average returns. The broad US
                                                         market gained about 6% in the quarter, with all asset classes delivering solid
                                                         gains. The substantial returns of the last year, shown below, were captured by
                                                                                                                                                                                         1

                To stay current with MAMC’s thoughts on investing, please visit www.investmentsignal.net
disciplined investors with diversified portfolios. It is capturing these types of re-
                          turns that help us to recover from a negative year like 2008. Over the last year,
                          churning the portfolio or concentrating positions into select asset classes or sectors
                          greatly minimized ones chances of recovering. While a lesson in probability and
                          statistics could help, all we really need to know is that if we have truly global ex-
                          posure in our portfolio, then our chances of catching return premiums over time
                          is much improved.

                          Three Years as of March 31, 2010

                          The attractive positive returns of the first quarter and of the year ending 3/31/10
                          would usually be a great place to end a newsletter. If all of our portfolios were
                          incepted in Mid-March of 2009, we would be feeling pretty invincible, but that is
                          not the case. We must take the lesson of 2008 to heart. The matrix below shows
                          that only four of the displayed 15 asset classes produced positive total returns in
                          the last 3-years, and of the four, 3 of them were fixed income. The fourth being
                          Emerging Markets.
                          Total Return April 2007 - March 2010
                          Asset Class                                  Index                               Total Return
                          U Large Cap
                           S                                           S&P 500                               -11.98%
                          U Large Cap Value
                           S                                           Russell 1000 Value                    -20.41%
                          U Large Cap Growth
                           S                                           Russell 1000 Grow    th                -2.33%
                          U Sm Cap
                           S     all                                   Russell 2000                          -11.50%
                          U Sm Cap Value
                           S     all                                   Russell 2000 Value                    -16.16%
                          U Sm Cap Growth
                           S     all                                   Russell 2000 Grow    th                -7.09%
                          IN Large Cap
                            TL                                         M SCI EAFE                            -18.39%
                          IN Large Cap Value
                            TL                                         M SCI EAFE Value                      -21.71%
                          IN Sm Cap
                            TL      all                                M SCI EAFE Sm Cap
                                                                                       all                   -21.96%
                          IN Sm Cap Value
                            TL      all                                M SCI EAFE Sm Value
                                                                                       all                   -19.80%
                          Em erging M   arkets                         M SCI Em  erging M  arkets            17.28%
                          REIT                                         Dow Jones U Select REIT
                                                                                     S                       -31.84%
                          U Short-term Bond
                           S                                           M errill Lynch O ne-Year U Treasury
                                                                                                   S         10.71%
                          U Interm
                           S          -term Bond                       Five-Year U Treasury N
                                                                                    S             otes       21.50%
                          Global Interm   -term Bond                   Citi W orld Govt. Bond 1-5 Years      15.28%

                          All indices’ returns data are provided by the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP). Indices are not available for direct
                          investment; their performance does not reflect the expenses associated with the management of an actual portfolio. Past perform-
                          ance is not a guarantee of future results.

                          Over this three-year period, value stocks significantly underperformed growth.
                          This seems contrary to what we preach; however, in looking at the value versus
                          growth argument, one truly captures the value return premium by investing for
                          the long-term. The negative returns are primarily due to the performance from
                          late 2007 through early March of 2009. Despite the remarkable performance of
                          the last year, the losses are still apparent.

                          This matrix serves a purpose aside from bringing up painful memories. In retro-
                          spect, we look at this table and think, “I knew I should have moved into fixed in-
                          come or reduced my exposure to REITs.” Hindsight is great. But it still is not an
                          adequate predictor of the future. Would you know when to sell out of the fixed
                          income and move back into equity? Chances are that you would know after the
                          fact, just as we can now see what would have provided positive returns for this 3-
                          year period.



                                                                                                                                                          2

To stay current with MAMC’s thoughts on investing, please visit www.investmentsignal.net
In the last decade, what do the numbers look like? How does extending the time
                         horizon impact our strategy? Several clients have brought up that returns were
                         near or less than zero for portfolios invested in the stock market for the last 10-
                         years. In the following section we will address this comment.

                         The Last Decade

                         In the beginning of the year, many in the popular financial media claimed that
                         2000-2009 was a dismal period for US investors. Some commentators described
                         the period as the “Lost Decade” in stocks. From a narrow market perspective, they
                         are right. The US stock market has taken investors on a bumpy ride, and recent
                         volatility has tested investor discipline and prompted some to question their com-
                         mitment to equity markets. Investors who concentrated portfolios in US Large cap
                         stocks did not break even: one dollar invested in the S&P 500 in January 2000
                         turned into ninety-one cents over the next ten years. The results were even worse
                         for investors who made concentrated bets on individual companies that ultimately
                         failed. Names like AIG, Enron, MCI, Circuit City, GM, Lehman Brothers and Bear
                         Sterns comes to mind.

                         For disciplined and globally diversified investors, however, the last ten years was
                         not a lost decade. As suggested in the matrix below, investors who deployed their
                         capital across a broad mix of domestic, developed, and emerging markets were
                         generally rewarded with positive returns. Those seeking greater stability were also
                         able to reduce their portfolio volatility by incorporating high-quality fixed income
                         into the mix.
                         Total Return January 2000 - Decem 2009
                                                          ber
                         Asset Class                                    Index                               Total Return
                         US Large Cap                                   S&P 500                                -9.1%
                         US Large Cap Value                             Russell 1000 Value                     27.6%
                         US Large Cap Growth                            Russell 1000 Growth                   -33.4%
                         US Sm Cap
                                all                                     Russell 2000                           41.2%
                         US Sm Cap Value
                                all                                     Russell 2000 Value                    121.3%
                         US Sm Cap Growth
                                all                                     Russell 2000 Growth                   -12.9%
                         INTL Large Cap                                 M EAFE
                                                                          SCI                                  17.0%
                         INTL Large Cap Value                           M EAFE Value
                                                                          SCI                                  48.5%
                         INTL Sm Cap
                                   all                                  M EAFE Sm Cap
                                                                          SCI          all                     94.3%
                         INTL Sm Cap Value
                                   all                                  M EAFE Sm Value
                                                                          SCI          all                    146.3%
                         Em erging M   arkets                           M Em
                                                                          SCI     erging M arkets             162.0%
                         REIT                                           Dow Jones US Select REIT              175.6%
                         US Short-term Bond                             M errill Lynch One-Year US Treasury    45.5%
                         US Interm   -term Bond                         Five-Year US Treasury Notes            82.0%
                         Global Interm   -term Bond                     Citi W orld Govt. Bond 1-5 Years       57.7%

                         MSCI indices are total returns net of foreign withholding taxes on dividends. All indices’ returns data are provided by the Center
                         for Research in Security Prices (CRSP). Indices are not available for direct investment; their performance does not reflect the
                         expenses associated with the management of an actual portfolio. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results.

                         While it was a “Lost Decade” for some, those who walked a disciplined and
                         broadly diversified path were sheltered from the worst of the storm, reinforcing
                         the merits of this approach to investing. In an equally weighted portfolio of the
                         15 asset classes shown above, the average total return was 64.24% for the last 10-
                         year period.



                                                                                                                                                         3

To stay current with MAMC’s thoughts on investing, please visit www.investmentsignal.net

More Related Content

What's hot

Tactical Alpha Presentation April 2011
Tactical Alpha Presentation April 2011Tactical Alpha Presentation April 2011
Tactical Alpha Presentation April 2011treyhaydon
 
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 15 Oct. 2010
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 15 Oct. 2010BRICS PMS Performance Update - 15 Oct. 2010
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 15 Oct. 2010vivekmavani
 
Daily i-forex-report-1 by epic research 03.04.13
Daily i-forex-report-1 by epic research 03.04.13Daily i-forex-report-1 by epic research 03.04.13
Daily i-forex-report-1 by epic research 03.04.13Epic Daily Report
 
Market Outlook - September 22, 2010
Market Outlook - September 22, 2010Market Outlook - September 22, 2010
Market Outlook - September 22, 2010Angel Broking
 
Daily i-forex-report-by epic research 5 arril 2013
Daily i-forex-report-by epic research 5 arril 2013Daily i-forex-report-by epic research 5 arril 2013
Daily i-forex-report-by epic research 5 arril 2013Epic Daily Report
 
March 12 Quarterly
March 12 QuarterlyMarch 12 Quarterly
March 12 QuarterlyMark_Krygier
 
Improving Portfolio Returns Through Risk Reduction Oct 2010 Long Version
Improving Portfolio Returns Through Risk Reduction   Oct  2010   Long VersionImproving Portfolio Returns Through Risk Reduction   Oct  2010   Long Version
Improving Portfolio Returns Through Risk Reduction Oct 2010 Long Versionsorenk
 
Company overview, BT Global Growth Fund February 2016
Company overview, BT Global Growth Fund February 2016Company overview, BT Global Growth Fund February 2016
Company overview, BT Global Growth Fund February 2016BT Global
 
The equi max approach sept 2012
The equi max approach sept 2012The equi max approach sept 2012
The equi max approach sept 2012Atul Khanna
 
Way Forward For Juniors R Schodde AusImm 7 July 2009
Way Forward For Juniors   R Schodde AusImm 7 July 2009Way Forward For Juniors   R Schodde AusImm 7 July 2009
Way Forward For Juniors R Schodde AusImm 7 July 2009RichardSchodde
 
Portfolio Diversification
Portfolio DiversificationPortfolio Diversification
Portfolio DiversificationTom DeVol
 
Northstar Commodity Investment Co., LLC managed futures program
Northstar Commodity Investment Co., LLC managed futures programNorthstar Commodity Investment Co., LLC managed futures program
Northstar Commodity Investment Co., LLC managed futures programnorthstarcommodity
 
Using Proprietary Algorithms to Identify an Option's Relative Price
Using Proprietary Algorithms to Identify an Option's Relative PriceUsing Proprietary Algorithms to Identify an Option's Relative Price
Using Proprietary Algorithms to Identify an Option's Relative PriceRYAN RENICKER
 
In House Calls Review September 09
In House Calls Review   September 09In House Calls Review   September 09
In House Calls Review September 09anikshah
 

What's hot (20)

Tactical Alpha Presentation April 2011
Tactical Alpha Presentation April 2011Tactical Alpha Presentation April 2011
Tactical Alpha Presentation April 2011
 
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 15 Oct. 2010
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 15 Oct. 2010BRICS PMS Performance Update - 15 Oct. 2010
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 15 Oct. 2010
 
Daily i-forex-report-1 by epic research 03.04.13
Daily i-forex-report-1 by epic research 03.04.13Daily i-forex-report-1 by epic research 03.04.13
Daily i-forex-report-1 by epic research 03.04.13
 
Market Outlook - September 22, 2010
Market Outlook - September 22, 2010Market Outlook - September 22, 2010
Market Outlook - September 22, 2010
 
Daily i-forex-report-by epic research 5 arril 2013
Daily i-forex-report-by epic research 5 arril 2013Daily i-forex-report-by epic research 5 arril 2013
Daily i-forex-report-by epic research 5 arril 2013
 
March 12 Quarterly
March 12 QuarterlyMarch 12 Quarterly
March 12 Quarterly
 
Improving Portfolio Returns Through Risk Reduction Oct 2010 Long Version
Improving Portfolio Returns Through Risk Reduction   Oct  2010   Long VersionImproving Portfolio Returns Through Risk Reduction   Oct  2010   Long Version
Improving Portfolio Returns Through Risk Reduction Oct 2010 Long Version
 
Nap investor presentation august 2012
Nap investor presentation august 2012Nap investor presentation august 2012
Nap investor presentation august 2012
 
NAP Investor Presentation October 2011
NAP Investor Presentation October 2011NAP Investor Presentation October 2011
NAP Investor Presentation October 2011
 
Company overview, BT Global Growth Fund February 2016
Company overview, BT Global Growth Fund February 2016Company overview, BT Global Growth Fund February 2016
Company overview, BT Global Growth Fund February 2016
 
The equi max approach sept 2012
The equi max approach sept 2012The equi max approach sept 2012
The equi max approach sept 2012
 
Way Forward For Juniors R Schodde AusImm 7 July 2009
Way Forward For Juniors   R Schodde AusImm 7 July 2009Way Forward For Juniors   R Schodde AusImm 7 July 2009
Way Forward For Juniors R Schodde AusImm 7 July 2009
 
Portfolio Diversification
Portfolio DiversificationPortfolio Diversification
Portfolio Diversification
 
Website presentation 16.01.2013
Website presentation 16.01.2013Website presentation 16.01.2013
Website presentation 16.01.2013
 
Northstar Commodity Investment Co., LLC managed futures program
Northstar Commodity Investment Co., LLC managed futures programNorthstar Commodity Investment Co., LLC managed futures program
Northstar Commodity Investment Co., LLC managed futures program
 
Using Proprietary Algorithms to Identify an Option's Relative Price
Using Proprietary Algorithms to Identify an Option's Relative PriceUsing Proprietary Algorithms to Identify an Option's Relative Price
Using Proprietary Algorithms to Identify an Option's Relative Price
 
Nap investor presentation_june_2012
Nap investor presentation_june_2012Nap investor presentation_june_2012
Nap investor presentation_june_2012
 
Daily Newsletter - Sep 5, 2011
Daily Newsletter - Sep 5, 2011Daily Newsletter - Sep 5, 2011
Daily Newsletter - Sep 5, 2011
 
Nap investor presentation_may_2012
Nap investor presentation_may_2012Nap investor presentation_may_2012
Nap investor presentation_may_2012
 
In House Calls Review September 09
In House Calls Review   September 09In House Calls Review   September 09
In House Calls Review September 09
 

Similar to 1Q 2010 Quarterly Commentary Review

John hancock-lesson
John hancock-lessonJohn hancock-lesson
John hancock-lessonlsorrentino1
 
Investing for a lifetime
Investing for a lifetimeInvesting for a lifetime
Investing for a lifetimetubesock
 
Investments For Life
Investments For LifeInvestments For Life
Investments For LifeMBritos
 
Advice For The Wise : September'2011
Advice For The Wise : September'2011Advice For The Wise : September'2011
Advice For The Wise : September'2011Karvy Private Wealth
 
"Opportunities and Pitfalls in Momentum Investing" by Gary Antonacci, Author ...
"Opportunities and Pitfalls in Momentum Investing" by Gary Antonacci, Author ..."Opportunities and Pitfalls in Momentum Investing" by Gary Antonacci, Author ...
"Opportunities and Pitfalls in Momentum Investing" by Gary Antonacci, Author ...Quantopian
 
DSP Multi Asset Allocation Fund PPT.pdf
DSP Multi Asset Allocation Fund  PPT.pdfDSP Multi Asset Allocation Fund  PPT.pdf
DSP Multi Asset Allocation Fund PPT.pdfDSP Mutual Fund
 
2011 - Q1 - Commentary
2011 - Q1 - Commentary2011 - Q1 - Commentary
2011 - Q1 - CommentaryDrew Beja
 
March 11 Quarterly
March 11 QuarterlyMarch 11 Quarterly
March 11 QuarterlyMark_Krygier
 
2012 Midyear Economic And Market Outlook
2012 Midyear Economic And Market Outlook2012 Midyear Economic And Market Outlook
2012 Midyear Economic And Market Outlooksumguyatvt
 
Advice for the Wise - February 2012
Advice for the Wise - February 2012Advice for the Wise - February 2012
Advice for the Wise - February 2012Karvy Private Wealth
 
Fall 12 Market Commentary
Fall 12 Market CommentaryFall 12 Market Commentary
Fall 12 Market CommentaryMark_Krygier
 
The Little Book of TCF
The Little Book of TCFThe Little Book of TCF
The Little Book of TCFTCFInvestment
 
2Q09 Asset Allocation
2Q09 Asset Allocation2Q09 Asset Allocation
2Q09 Asset Allocationcoterieternal
 
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 28 February 2011
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 28 February 2011BRICS PMS Performance Update - 28 February 2011
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 28 February 2011vivekmavani
 
Parul kumar hedge funds ppt
Parul kumar hedge funds pptParul kumar hedge funds ppt
Parul kumar hedge funds pptvaibhav Kukreja
 
Portfolio Diversification
Portfolio DiversificationPortfolio Diversification
Portfolio DiversificationGreg Ferguson
 
Managed Futures Presentation
Managed Futures PresentationManaged Futures Presentation
Managed Futures PresentationEveryDayFX
 

Similar to 1Q 2010 Quarterly Commentary Review (20)

John hancock-lesson
John hancock-lessonJohn hancock-lesson
John hancock-lesson
 
Investing for a lifetime
Investing for a lifetimeInvesting for a lifetime
Investing for a lifetime
 
Investments For Life
Investments For LifeInvestments For Life
Investments For Life
 
Advice For The Wise : September'2011
Advice For The Wise : September'2011Advice For The Wise : September'2011
Advice For The Wise : September'2011
 
"Opportunities and Pitfalls in Momentum Investing" by Gary Antonacci, Author ...
"Opportunities and Pitfalls in Momentum Investing" by Gary Antonacci, Author ..."Opportunities and Pitfalls in Momentum Investing" by Gary Antonacci, Author ...
"Opportunities and Pitfalls in Momentum Investing" by Gary Antonacci, Author ...
 
DSP Multi Asset Allocation Fund PPT.pdf
DSP Multi Asset Allocation Fund  PPT.pdfDSP Multi Asset Allocation Fund  PPT.pdf
DSP Multi Asset Allocation Fund PPT.pdf
 
2011 - Q1 - Commentary
2011 - Q1 - Commentary2011 - Q1 - Commentary
2011 - Q1 - Commentary
 
March 11 Quarterly
March 11 QuarterlyMarch 11 Quarterly
March 11 Quarterly
 
2012 Midyear Economic And Market Outlook
2012 Midyear Economic And Market Outlook2012 Midyear Economic And Market Outlook
2012 Midyear Economic And Market Outlook
 
Advice for the Wise - February 2012
Advice for the Wise - February 2012Advice for the Wise - February 2012
Advice for the Wise - February 2012
 
Advice for the wise february 2012
Advice for the wise february 2012Advice for the wise february 2012
Advice for the wise february 2012
 
Newsletter Q3 2016
Newsletter Q3 2016Newsletter Q3 2016
Newsletter Q3 2016
 
Fall 12 Market Commentary
Fall 12 Market CommentaryFall 12 Market Commentary
Fall 12 Market Commentary
 
Little book
Little bookLittle book
Little book
 
The Little Book of TCF
The Little Book of TCFThe Little Book of TCF
The Little Book of TCF
 
2Q09 Asset Allocation
2Q09 Asset Allocation2Q09 Asset Allocation
2Q09 Asset Allocation
 
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 28 February 2011
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 28 February 2011BRICS PMS Performance Update - 28 February 2011
BRICS PMS Performance Update - 28 February 2011
 
Parul kumar hedge funds ppt
Parul kumar hedge funds pptParul kumar hedge funds ppt
Parul kumar hedge funds ppt
 
Portfolio Diversification
Portfolio DiversificationPortfolio Diversification
Portfolio Diversification
 
Managed Futures Presentation
Managed Futures PresentationManaged Futures Presentation
Managed Futures Presentation
 

More from MAMC84

Rebalancing Intelligently
Rebalancing IntelligentlyRebalancing Intelligently
Rebalancing IntelligentlyMAMC84
 
Occam\'s Razor on Inflation
Occam\'s Razor on InflationOccam\'s Razor on Inflation
Occam\'s Razor on InflationMAMC84
 
Occam\'s Razor - Inflation (Sept. 2009)
Occam\'s Razor - Inflation (Sept. 2009)Occam\'s Razor - Inflation (Sept. 2009)
Occam\'s Razor - Inflation (Sept. 2009)MAMC84
 
Rebalancing
RebalancingRebalancing
RebalancingMAMC84
 
Rebalancing Intelligently
Rebalancing IntelligentlyRebalancing Intelligently
Rebalancing IntelligentlyMAMC84
 

More from MAMC84 (7)

TIPS
TIPSTIPS
TIPS
 
Rebalancing Intelligently
Rebalancing IntelligentlyRebalancing Intelligently
Rebalancing Intelligently
 
Occam\'s Razor on Inflation
Occam\'s Razor on InflationOccam\'s Razor on Inflation
Occam\'s Razor on Inflation
 
Occam\'s Razor - Inflation (Sept. 2009)
Occam\'s Razor - Inflation (Sept. 2009)Occam\'s Razor - Inflation (Sept. 2009)
Occam\'s Razor - Inflation (Sept. 2009)
 
TIPS
TIPSTIPS
TIPS
 
Rebalancing
RebalancingRebalancing
Rebalancing
 
Rebalancing Intelligently
Rebalancing IntelligentlyRebalancing Intelligently
Rebalancing Intelligently
 

1Q 2010 Quarterly Commentary Review

  • 1. 1ST QUARTER 2010 ……………………………… QUARTERLY COMMENTARY 1Q Review Positive market returns of late have caused some investors to forget 2008; yet, Last 3-Years Review contrarian-minded investors have become even more cautious and skeptical. We’ll take a moment to address the “Lost Decade,” which several clients have Last Decade referred to in the last few months; but first is a returns discussion centered around volatility. ……………………………… First Quarter 2010 WHAT IS OCCAM’S RAZOR? Occam’s Razor is a principle Volatility drives returns. 2008 gave us absurdly high volatility; and returns were attributed to William Occam, driven deep into negative territory. We hoped that the high volatility of 2008 a 14th century philosopher. He would die down as mounting losses were becoming physically sickening. Yet, stressed that explanations must we all also wished that before dying down, the high volatility would give us not be multiplied beyond what some remarkable positive returns. We hoped this because volatility not only in- is necessary. Thus, Occam’s Razor creases chances of negative returns, but it also provides opportunity for positive is a term used to “shave off” or returns; thus, volatility drives returns. In the final three and a half quarters of dismiss superfluous explanations 2009 delivered substantial positive returns. for a given event. This concept is largely ignored within the investment management landscape. As of 3/31/2010 This newsletter will “shave off ” Asset Class Index 1Q 2010 1 Year popular investment misinformation US Large Cap S&P 500 5.39% 49.77% and present what is important for achieving long-term investment US Large Cap Value Russell 1000 Value 6.79% 53.56% success. US Large Cap Growth Russell 1000 Growth 4.65% 49.75% US Small Cap Russell 2000 8.85% 62.76% DISCLOSURE The Company only transacts business in states where it is properly registered, or US Small Cap Value Russell 2000 Value 10.03% 65.06% excluded or exempted from registration US Small Cap Growth Russell 2000 Growth 7.61% 60.31% requirements. Please see our disclosure pages for further detail. INTL Large Cap MSCI EAFE 0.94% 55.20% ……………………………… INTL Large Cap Value MSCI EAFE Value -0.17% 59.49% INTL Small Cap MSCI EAFE Small Cap 4.82% 70.59% This newsletter is published by: INTL Small Cap Value MSCI EAFE Small Value 4.49% 75.08% McLean Asset Management Corp. Emerging Markets MSCI Emerging Markets 2.45% 81.55% 8200 Greensboro Road REIT Dow Jones US Select REIT 9.81% 113.47% Suite 1150 US Short-term Bond Merrill Lynch One-Year US Treasury 0.25% 1.06% McLean, VA 22102 US Interm-term Bond Five-Year US Treasury Notes 1.76% -0.07% Phone: (703) 827-0636 Global Interm-term Bond Citi World Govt. Bond 1-5 Years 0.76% 2.29% www.mcleanam.com All indices’ returns data are provided by the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP). Indices are not available for direct www.investmentsignal.net investment; their performance does not reflect the expenses associated with the management of an actual portfolio. Past per- formance is not a guarantee of future results. In the first quarter of 2010, the US equity markets continued its strong perform- ance with the fourth consecutive quarter of above-average returns. The broad US market gained about 6% in the quarter, with all asset classes delivering solid gains. The substantial returns of the last year, shown below, were captured by 1 To stay current with MAMC’s thoughts on investing, please visit www.investmentsignal.net
  • 2. disciplined investors with diversified portfolios. It is capturing these types of re- turns that help us to recover from a negative year like 2008. Over the last year, churning the portfolio or concentrating positions into select asset classes or sectors greatly minimized ones chances of recovering. While a lesson in probability and statistics could help, all we really need to know is that if we have truly global ex- posure in our portfolio, then our chances of catching return premiums over time is much improved. Three Years as of March 31, 2010 The attractive positive returns of the first quarter and of the year ending 3/31/10 would usually be a great place to end a newsletter. If all of our portfolios were incepted in Mid-March of 2009, we would be feeling pretty invincible, but that is not the case. We must take the lesson of 2008 to heart. The matrix below shows that only four of the displayed 15 asset classes produced positive total returns in the last 3-years, and of the four, 3 of them were fixed income. The fourth being Emerging Markets. Total Return April 2007 - March 2010 Asset Class Index Total Return U Large Cap S S&P 500 -11.98% U Large Cap Value S Russell 1000 Value -20.41% U Large Cap Growth S Russell 1000 Grow th -2.33% U Sm Cap S all Russell 2000 -11.50% U Sm Cap Value S all Russell 2000 Value -16.16% U Sm Cap Growth S all Russell 2000 Grow th -7.09% IN Large Cap TL M SCI EAFE -18.39% IN Large Cap Value TL M SCI EAFE Value -21.71% IN Sm Cap TL all M SCI EAFE Sm Cap all -21.96% IN Sm Cap Value TL all M SCI EAFE Sm Value all -19.80% Em erging M arkets M SCI Em erging M arkets 17.28% REIT Dow Jones U Select REIT S -31.84% U Short-term Bond S M errill Lynch O ne-Year U Treasury S 10.71% U Interm S -term Bond Five-Year U Treasury N S otes 21.50% Global Interm -term Bond Citi W orld Govt. Bond 1-5 Years 15.28% All indices’ returns data are provided by the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP). Indices are not available for direct investment; their performance does not reflect the expenses associated with the management of an actual portfolio. Past perform- ance is not a guarantee of future results. Over this three-year period, value stocks significantly underperformed growth. This seems contrary to what we preach; however, in looking at the value versus growth argument, one truly captures the value return premium by investing for the long-term. The negative returns are primarily due to the performance from late 2007 through early March of 2009. Despite the remarkable performance of the last year, the losses are still apparent. This matrix serves a purpose aside from bringing up painful memories. In retro- spect, we look at this table and think, “I knew I should have moved into fixed in- come or reduced my exposure to REITs.” Hindsight is great. But it still is not an adequate predictor of the future. Would you know when to sell out of the fixed income and move back into equity? Chances are that you would know after the fact, just as we can now see what would have provided positive returns for this 3- year period. 2 To stay current with MAMC’s thoughts on investing, please visit www.investmentsignal.net
  • 3. In the last decade, what do the numbers look like? How does extending the time horizon impact our strategy? Several clients have brought up that returns were near or less than zero for portfolios invested in the stock market for the last 10- years. In the following section we will address this comment. The Last Decade In the beginning of the year, many in the popular financial media claimed that 2000-2009 was a dismal period for US investors. Some commentators described the period as the “Lost Decade” in stocks. From a narrow market perspective, they are right. The US stock market has taken investors on a bumpy ride, and recent volatility has tested investor discipline and prompted some to question their com- mitment to equity markets. Investors who concentrated portfolios in US Large cap stocks did not break even: one dollar invested in the S&P 500 in January 2000 turned into ninety-one cents over the next ten years. The results were even worse for investors who made concentrated bets on individual companies that ultimately failed. Names like AIG, Enron, MCI, Circuit City, GM, Lehman Brothers and Bear Sterns comes to mind. For disciplined and globally diversified investors, however, the last ten years was not a lost decade. As suggested in the matrix below, investors who deployed their capital across a broad mix of domestic, developed, and emerging markets were generally rewarded with positive returns. Those seeking greater stability were also able to reduce their portfolio volatility by incorporating high-quality fixed income into the mix. Total Return January 2000 - Decem 2009 ber Asset Class Index Total Return US Large Cap S&P 500 -9.1% US Large Cap Value Russell 1000 Value 27.6% US Large Cap Growth Russell 1000 Growth -33.4% US Sm Cap all Russell 2000 41.2% US Sm Cap Value all Russell 2000 Value 121.3% US Sm Cap Growth all Russell 2000 Growth -12.9% INTL Large Cap M EAFE SCI 17.0% INTL Large Cap Value M EAFE Value SCI 48.5% INTL Sm Cap all M EAFE Sm Cap SCI all 94.3% INTL Sm Cap Value all M EAFE Sm Value SCI all 146.3% Em erging M arkets M Em SCI erging M arkets 162.0% REIT Dow Jones US Select REIT 175.6% US Short-term Bond M errill Lynch One-Year US Treasury 45.5% US Interm -term Bond Five-Year US Treasury Notes 82.0% Global Interm -term Bond Citi W orld Govt. Bond 1-5 Years 57.7% MSCI indices are total returns net of foreign withholding taxes on dividends. All indices’ returns data are provided by the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP). Indices are not available for direct investment; their performance does not reflect the expenses associated with the management of an actual portfolio. Past performance is not a guarantee of future results. While it was a “Lost Decade” for some, those who walked a disciplined and broadly diversified path were sheltered from the worst of the storm, reinforcing the merits of this approach to investing. In an equally weighted portfolio of the 15 asset classes shown above, the average total return was 64.24% for the last 10- year period. 3 To stay current with MAMC’s thoughts on investing, please visit www.investmentsignal.net