SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 13
Demystifying the COMREC Processes and
Procedures
Lucinda Manda-Taylor, PhD
COMREC Administrator
6th
Research Seminar, February 2015
Scope of Presentation
• Introduction – What is an IRB
• Functions of COMREC
• Processes of COMREC
• Submission of applications for COMREC
review
What is an IRB
Functions of COMREC
• Its main purpose is to protect the safety of human
and animal subjects participating in research –
scientifically valid and ethically sound.
• It aims to promote research in COM and publication
of results
• All research conducted by faculty must be approved
• Research approved by COMREC must be in the full
interest of research participants/communities
• Research approved by COMREC shall be monitored
Submission Procedures
• All new proposals must be submitted on or
before the 1st
of every month
• All new proposals must pay a processing fee
and proof of payment must be submitted
• All new proposals are screened for
administrative and regulatory purposes
• COMREC meets on the last Wednesday of
every month excluding December
Eligible applicants
• Full time member of staff, COM and their
collaborators/research affiliates
• Honorary members of staff of COM and their
collaborators/research affiliates
• Full time staff members of KCN and their
collaborators
• Students COM/KCN submitting a proposal
through their local supervisor
The Review Process
• Full review (proposals
reviewed by a fully convened
meeting)
• Expedited (limited to students
and proposals that have
previously been reviewed by a
fully convened meeting)
• Exemption from Review
(exempted from review by the
full committee)
• Amendments and
Modifications (expedited
review)
• Continuing review
Exemption from Review
Section 5.6 of the COMREC Guidelines state:
“Research involving the collection of existing
data, documents, records, program
evaluation, pathological specimens, or
diagnostic specimens, only if the sources are
publicly available or the information is
recorded by the investigator in such a manner
that subjects cannot be linked directly or
through identifiers linked to subjects”
COMREC’s Review Jurisdiction: Studies of
National Interest
Studies covering the following areas are
regarded as “National Interest Studies”
• All vaccine trials
• All drug and medical device trials where patent
issues are involved and where safety issues
remain fully unknown
• All stem cell research
• All cloning research
• All genetic studies
• All national health surveys
Elements of the Review
The primary focus of the review and approval focus is based on the science and ethics
of the proposed research. The following elements are considered:
• Project title
• Institutional affiliation
• Proposed sector
• Executive Summary
• Introduction/Literature review
• Justification
• Broad and Specific Objectives
• Methodology/Materials and Methods
• Ethical considerations
• An itemized budget and justification for the budget
• Source of funding
• Work plans
• Expected outcomes
• Strategies for dissemination
• References
COMREC Application Pack
• 4 hard copies of each proposal and the accompanying documents.
These include:
• COMREC Checklist
• Cover letter from the PI
• CVs of the PI and Co-investigator
• Letters of Support from Department[s] hosting the Research
• Material to be used {including advertisements} for recruitment
• ICFs (English and Chichewa)
• Investigator’s brochure or Product Insert
• If applying for waiver of 10% overhead fee, these letters should be
included
• Other IRB approval letters if COMREC is not the designated IRB
responsible for HSP oversight
Materials and Tools
• COMREC Guidelines on Health Research in Malawi
• NCST Regulatory Guidelines
• International ethical guidelines
• COMREC Proposal Format Guidelines
• COMREC Checklist
• Informed Consent Guidelines
• MTA Form
• Progress Report Forms
• FAQ document
For more information, please visit our website
www.medcol.mw/comrec/
Thank you

More Related Content

What's hot

NIH Public Access Policy: Overview
NIH Public Access Policy: OverviewNIH Public Access Policy: Overview
NIH Public Access Policy: Overviewlynnkysh
 
Architecture and Standards
Architecture and StandardsArchitecture and Standards
Architecture and StandardsARDC
 
Investigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspective
Investigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspectiveInvestigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspective
Investigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspectiveARDC
 
Trimble 12 12-11
Trimble 12 12-11Trimble 12 12-11
Trimble 12 12-11EUintheUS
 
Nicola Dowson: Ref2014 and beyond
Nicola Dowson: Ref2014 and beyondNicola Dowson: Ref2014 and beyond
Nicola Dowson: Ref2014 and beyondCILIP ARLG Eastern
 
So you want to do a meta analysis
So you want to do a meta analysisSo you want to do a meta analysis
So you want to do a meta analysisPeggy Tyler
 
Study on Report Writing.pptx
Study on Report Writing.pptxStudy on Report Writing.pptx
Study on Report Writing.pptxMd Fahimuzzaman
 
Scoping Review Infographic
Scoping Review InfographicScoping Review Infographic
Scoping Review InfographicLaura Huey
 
PROSPERO: an international prospective register of systematic review protocols
PROSPERO: an international prospective register of systematic review protocolsPROSPERO: an international prospective register of systematic review protocols
PROSPERO: an international prospective register of systematic review protocolsHTAi Bilbao 2012
 

What's hot (14)

NIH Public Access Policy: Overview
NIH Public Access Policy: OverviewNIH Public Access Policy: Overview
NIH Public Access Policy: Overview
 
Architecture and Standards
Architecture and StandardsArchitecture and Standards
Architecture and Standards
 
Investigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspective
Investigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspectiveInvestigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspective
Investigator-initiated clinical trials: a community perspective
 
83341 ch23 jacobsen
83341 ch23 jacobsen83341 ch23 jacobsen
83341 ch23 jacobsen
 
Trimble 12 12-11
Trimble 12 12-11Trimble 12 12-11
Trimble 12 12-11
 
Nicola Dowson: Ref2014 and beyond
Nicola Dowson: Ref2014 and beyondNicola Dowson: Ref2014 and beyond
Nicola Dowson: Ref2014 and beyond
 
Research Design.pptx
Research Design.pptxResearch Design.pptx
Research Design.pptx
 
So you want to do a meta analysis
So you want to do a meta analysisSo you want to do a meta analysis
So you want to do a meta analysis
 
Study on Report Writing.pptx
Study on Report Writing.pptxStudy on Report Writing.pptx
Study on Report Writing.pptx
 
Chew schoeborn niso vc apr 29
Chew schoeborn niso vc apr 29Chew schoeborn niso vc apr 29
Chew schoeborn niso vc apr 29
 
Using PsycTESTS
Using PsycTESTSUsing PsycTESTS
Using PsycTESTS
 
Scoping Review Infographic
Scoping Review InfographicScoping Review Infographic
Scoping Review Infographic
 
PROSPERO: an international prospective register of systematic review protocols
PROSPERO: an international prospective register of systematic review protocolsPROSPERO: an international prospective register of systematic review protocols
PROSPERO: an international prospective register of systematic review protocols
 
Systematic review
Systematic reviewSystematic review
Systematic review
 

Similar to Demystifying the COMREC Processes and Procedures

Introduction to clinical research
Introduction to clinical researchIntroduction to clinical research
Introduction to clinical researchAnor Abidin
 
ROLES AND RESPONSIBLITIES OF CLINICAL TRIAL PERSONNEL-INVESTIGATOR.pptx
ROLES AND RESPONSIBLITIES OF CLINICAL TRIAL PERSONNEL-INVESTIGATOR.pptxROLES AND RESPONSIBLITIES OF CLINICAL TRIAL PERSONNEL-INVESTIGATOR.pptx
ROLES AND RESPONSIBLITIES OF CLINICAL TRIAL PERSONNEL-INVESTIGATOR.pptxE Poovarasan
 
Clinical research ppt,
Clinical research   ppt,Clinical research   ppt,
Clinical research ppt,Malay Singh
 
IRB Review and Aproval Process and ongoing mointoring of safety data.pptx
IRB Review and Aproval Process and ongoing mointoring of safety data.pptxIRB Review and Aproval Process and ongoing mointoring of safety data.pptx
IRB Review and Aproval Process and ongoing mointoring of safety data.pptxAartiVats5
 
Review process Ethics in Health Research workshop _eye 22 July 2023.pptx
Review process Ethics in Health Research workshop _eye 22 July 2023.pptxReview process Ethics in Health Research workshop _eye 22 July 2023.pptx
Review process Ethics in Health Research workshop _eye 22 July 2023.pptxNamitaGhimire1
 
ICRISAT Global Planning Meeting 2019: Research Involving Humans by Michael Ha...
ICRISAT Global Planning Meeting 2019: Research Involving Humans by Michael Ha...ICRISAT Global Planning Meeting 2019: Research Involving Humans by Michael Ha...
ICRISAT Global Planning Meeting 2019: Research Involving Humans by Michael Ha...ICRISAT
 
Suzanne Pozsonyi MedicReS World Congress 2013
Suzanne Pozsonyi MedicReS World Congress 2013Suzanne Pozsonyi MedicReS World Congress 2013
Suzanne Pozsonyi MedicReS World Congress 2013MedicReS
 
PhD_sensitization__slides[1].pptx
PhD_sensitization__slides[1].pptxPhD_sensitization__slides[1].pptx
PhD_sensitization__slides[1].pptxssuser75fd45
 
What is clinical research? Why to do it?
What is clinical research? Why to do it?What is clinical research? Why to do it?
What is clinical research? Why to do it?vsharma1087
 
Ethics committee’s role and functioning committee formation
Ethics committee’s role and functioning   committee formationEthics committee’s role and functioning   committee formation
Ethics committee’s role and functioning committee formationDrSatyabrataSahoo
 
Guidelines to the Preparation of document.pptx
Guidelines to the Preparation of document.pptxGuidelines to the Preparation of document.pptx
Guidelines to the Preparation of document.pptxShraddhaRaut43
 

Similar to Demystifying the COMREC Processes and Procedures (20)

Introduction to clinical research
Introduction to clinical researchIntroduction to clinical research
Introduction to clinical research
 
Ethics in Research.pptx
Ethics in Research.pptxEthics in Research.pptx
Ethics in Research.pptx
 
Hm 418 harris ch06 ppt
Hm 418 harris ch06 pptHm 418 harris ch06 ppt
Hm 418 harris ch06 ppt
 
ROLES AND RESPONSIBLITIES OF CLINICAL TRIAL PERSONNEL-INVESTIGATOR.pptx
ROLES AND RESPONSIBLITIES OF CLINICAL TRIAL PERSONNEL-INVESTIGATOR.pptxROLES AND RESPONSIBLITIES OF CLINICAL TRIAL PERSONNEL-INVESTIGATOR.pptx
ROLES AND RESPONSIBLITIES OF CLINICAL TRIAL PERSONNEL-INVESTIGATOR.pptx
 
Clinical research
Clinical researchClinical research
Clinical research
 
Clinical research ppt,
Clinical research   ppt,Clinical research   ppt,
Clinical research ppt,
 
IRB Review and Aproval Process and ongoing mointoring of safety data.pptx
IRB Review and Aproval Process and ongoing mointoring of safety data.pptxIRB Review and Aproval Process and ongoing mointoring of safety data.pptx
IRB Review and Aproval Process and ongoing mointoring of safety data.pptx
 
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials part 2
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials part 2A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials part 2
A researcher's guide to understanding clinical trials part 2
 
Review process Ethics in Health Research workshop _eye 22 July 2023.pptx
Review process Ethics in Health Research workshop _eye 22 July 2023.pptxReview process Ethics in Health Research workshop _eye 22 July 2023.pptx
Review process Ethics in Health Research workshop _eye 22 July 2023.pptx
 
ICRISAT Global Planning Meeting 2019: Research Involving Humans by Michael Ha...
ICRISAT Global Planning Meeting 2019: Research Involving Humans by Michael Ha...ICRISAT Global Planning Meeting 2019: Research Involving Humans by Michael Ha...
ICRISAT Global Planning Meeting 2019: Research Involving Humans by Michael Ha...
 
Medical ethics
Medical ethicsMedical ethics
Medical ethics
 
Suzanne Pozsonyi MedicReS World Congress 2013
Suzanne Pozsonyi MedicReS World Congress 2013Suzanne Pozsonyi MedicReS World Congress 2013
Suzanne Pozsonyi MedicReS World Congress 2013
 
Ethics in Medical Research
Ethics in Medical ResearchEthics in Medical Research
Ethics in Medical Research
 
PhD_sensitization__slides[1].pptx
PhD_sensitization__slides[1].pptxPhD_sensitization__slides[1].pptx
PhD_sensitization__slides[1].pptx
 
What is clinical research? Why to do it?
What is clinical research? Why to do it?What is clinical research? Why to do it?
What is clinical research? Why to do it?
 
Clinical protocol
Clinical protocolClinical protocol
Clinical protocol
 
Ethics committee’s role and functioning committee formation
Ethics committee’s role and functioning   committee formationEthics committee’s role and functioning   committee formation
Ethics committee’s role and functioning committee formation
 
Preparation of protocol
Preparation of protocolPreparation of protocol
Preparation of protocol
 
Guidelines to the Preparation of document.pptx
Guidelines to the Preparation of document.pptxGuidelines to the Preparation of document.pptx
Guidelines to the Preparation of document.pptx
 
ICH GCP.ppt
ICH GCP.pptICH GCP.ppt
ICH GCP.ppt
 

Demystifying the COMREC Processes and Procedures

  • 1. Demystifying the COMREC Processes and Procedures Lucinda Manda-Taylor, PhD COMREC Administrator 6th Research Seminar, February 2015
  • 2. Scope of Presentation • Introduction – What is an IRB • Functions of COMREC • Processes of COMREC • Submission of applications for COMREC review
  • 4. Functions of COMREC • Its main purpose is to protect the safety of human and animal subjects participating in research – scientifically valid and ethically sound. • It aims to promote research in COM and publication of results • All research conducted by faculty must be approved • Research approved by COMREC must be in the full interest of research participants/communities • Research approved by COMREC shall be monitored
  • 5. Submission Procedures • All new proposals must be submitted on or before the 1st of every month • All new proposals must pay a processing fee and proof of payment must be submitted • All new proposals are screened for administrative and regulatory purposes • COMREC meets on the last Wednesday of every month excluding December
  • 6. Eligible applicants • Full time member of staff, COM and their collaborators/research affiliates • Honorary members of staff of COM and their collaborators/research affiliates • Full time staff members of KCN and their collaborators • Students COM/KCN submitting a proposal through their local supervisor
  • 7. The Review Process • Full review (proposals reviewed by a fully convened meeting) • Expedited (limited to students and proposals that have previously been reviewed by a fully convened meeting) • Exemption from Review (exempted from review by the full committee) • Amendments and Modifications (expedited review) • Continuing review
  • 8. Exemption from Review Section 5.6 of the COMREC Guidelines state: “Research involving the collection of existing data, documents, records, program evaluation, pathological specimens, or diagnostic specimens, only if the sources are publicly available or the information is recorded by the investigator in such a manner that subjects cannot be linked directly or through identifiers linked to subjects”
  • 9. COMREC’s Review Jurisdiction: Studies of National Interest Studies covering the following areas are regarded as “National Interest Studies” • All vaccine trials • All drug and medical device trials where patent issues are involved and where safety issues remain fully unknown • All stem cell research • All cloning research • All genetic studies • All national health surveys
  • 10. Elements of the Review The primary focus of the review and approval focus is based on the science and ethics of the proposed research. The following elements are considered: • Project title • Institutional affiliation • Proposed sector • Executive Summary • Introduction/Literature review • Justification • Broad and Specific Objectives • Methodology/Materials and Methods • Ethical considerations • An itemized budget and justification for the budget • Source of funding • Work plans • Expected outcomes • Strategies for dissemination • References
  • 11. COMREC Application Pack • 4 hard copies of each proposal and the accompanying documents. These include: • COMREC Checklist • Cover letter from the PI • CVs of the PI and Co-investigator • Letters of Support from Department[s] hosting the Research • Material to be used {including advertisements} for recruitment • ICFs (English and Chichewa) • Investigator’s brochure or Product Insert • If applying for waiver of 10% overhead fee, these letters should be included • Other IRB approval letters if COMREC is not the designated IRB responsible for HSP oversight
  • 12. Materials and Tools • COMREC Guidelines on Health Research in Malawi • NCST Regulatory Guidelines • International ethical guidelines • COMREC Proposal Format Guidelines • COMREC Checklist • Informed Consent Guidelines • MTA Form • Progress Report Forms • FAQ document For more information, please visit our website www.medcol.mw/comrec/