Enviar pesquisa
Carregar
En riyad us_saliheen رياض الصالحين
•
0 gostou
•
300 visualizações
Loveofpeople
Seguir
Educação
Denunciar
Compartilhar
Denunciar
Compartilhar
1 de 552
Baixar agora
Baixar para ler offline
Recomendados
SHAYTAAN- HIS WAYS IN MISLEADING BY ABU IYAAD.
SHAYTAAN- HIS WAYS IN MISLEADING BY ABU IYAAD.
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
[ Hisn almuslim ] fortress of the muslim, invocations from the quran and sunnah
[ Hisn almuslim ] fortress of the muslim, invocations from the quran and sunnah
osama khan
Fortress Of The Muslim
Fortress Of The Muslim
Light Upon Light
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
The Chosen One
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Goswami Mahirpari
Presentation des pathologies les plus recurrentes au SENEGAL.pdf
Presentation des pathologies les plus recurrentes au SENEGAL.pdf
MahougnonRaymondeHOU
Arabindo belajar bahasa arab untuk orang indonesia
Arabindo belajar bahasa arab untuk orang indonesia
ROHADIPPOB
Ne301
Ne301
amandiodias
Recomendados
SHAYTAAN- HIS WAYS IN MISLEADING BY ABU IYAAD.
SHAYTAAN- HIS WAYS IN MISLEADING BY ABU IYAAD.
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
[ Hisn almuslim ] fortress of the muslim, invocations from the quran and sunnah
[ Hisn almuslim ] fortress of the muslim, invocations from the quran and sunnah
osama khan
Fortress Of The Muslim
Fortress Of The Muslim
Light Upon Light
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
The Chosen One
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Goswami Mahirpari
Presentation des pathologies les plus recurrentes au SENEGAL.pdf
Presentation des pathologies les plus recurrentes au SENEGAL.pdf
MahougnonRaymondeHOU
Arabindo belajar bahasa arab untuk orang indonesia
Arabindo belajar bahasa arab untuk orang indonesia
ROHADIPPOB
Ne301
Ne301
amandiodias
ESSENCE OF MY RESEARCH ENDEAVOUR BY AUTHOR DEVANSSH MEHTA
ESSENCE OF MY RESEARCH ENDEAVOUR BY AUTHOR DEVANSSH MEHTA
DevansshMehta
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
CLOVE Dental OMNI Hospitals Andhra Hospital
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
CLOVE Dental OMNI Hospitals Andhra Hospital
Void and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lecture
FAROUQ
Bulletin, ICOPMAS (from 1990-2018) published by PMO
Bulletin, ICOPMAS (from 1990-2018) published by PMO
Kabir Sadeghi
Law Questions compliments of Asif tufal law
Law Questions compliments of Asif tufal law
Jubilanté Cutting
Privity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & cases
FAROUQ
Terms of contract
Terms of contract
FAROUQ
Discharge lecture
Discharge lecture
FAROUQ
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
P6P
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2
FAROUQ
Remedies lecture 1
Remedies lecture 1
FAROUQ
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
zakir2012
En contemporary issues
En contemporary issues
Loveofpeople
Internet
Internet
Omar Alejo
Riesgoviolenciasuicidioadolescentes 1226531504060413-8
Riesgoviolenciasuicidioadolescentes 1226531504060413-8
Lili Rivoira
Campamentos con Actividades en Costa da Morte, Galicia
Campamentos con Actividades en Costa da Morte, Galicia
Enrique Pérez Sampedro
Greenberg, gary 101 mitos de la biblia
Greenberg, gary 101 mitos de la biblia
Fabio Gimenez
Tratamiento farmaceutico
Tratamiento farmaceutico
Ellay SuGato
Trabajo powert point sobre aula virtual
Trabajo powert point sobre aula virtual
munar88
El iphone 5
El iphone 5
pmondragon
Parcial 1 mayda castañeda paredes
Parcial 1 mayda castañeda paredes
Alejandra Castañeda
Mais conteúdo relacionado
Mais procurados
ESSENCE OF MY RESEARCH ENDEAVOUR BY AUTHOR DEVANSSH MEHTA
ESSENCE OF MY RESEARCH ENDEAVOUR BY AUTHOR DEVANSSH MEHTA
DevansshMehta
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
CLOVE Dental OMNI Hospitals Andhra Hospital
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
CLOVE Dental OMNI Hospitals Andhra Hospital
Void and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lecture
FAROUQ
Bulletin, ICOPMAS (from 1990-2018) published by PMO
Bulletin, ICOPMAS (from 1990-2018) published by PMO
Kabir Sadeghi
Law Questions compliments of Asif tufal law
Law Questions compliments of Asif tufal law
Jubilanté Cutting
Privity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & cases
FAROUQ
Terms of contract
Terms of contract
FAROUQ
Discharge lecture
Discharge lecture
FAROUQ
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
P6P
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2
FAROUQ
Remedies lecture 1
Remedies lecture 1
FAROUQ
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
zakir2012
En contemporary issues
En contemporary issues
Loveofpeople
Mais procurados
(14)
ESSENCE OF MY RESEARCH ENDEAVOUR BY AUTHOR DEVANSSH MEHTA
ESSENCE OF MY RESEARCH ENDEAVOUR BY AUTHOR DEVANSSH MEHTA
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
2nd book dr rahul & heena tiwari- how to write an article and publish it - c...
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognathic surgery
Void and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lecture
Bulletin, ICOPMAS (from 1990-2018) published by PMO
Bulletin, ICOPMAS (from 1990-2018) published by PMO
Law Questions compliments of Asif tufal law
Law Questions compliments of Asif tufal law
Privity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & cases
Terms of contract
Terms of contract
Discharge lecture
Discharge lecture
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 1
Remedies lecture 1
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
En contemporary issues
En contemporary issues
Destaque
Internet
Internet
Omar Alejo
Riesgoviolenciasuicidioadolescentes 1226531504060413-8
Riesgoviolenciasuicidioadolescentes 1226531504060413-8
Lili Rivoira
Campamentos con Actividades en Costa da Morte, Galicia
Campamentos con Actividades en Costa da Morte, Galicia
Enrique Pérez Sampedro
Greenberg, gary 101 mitos de la biblia
Greenberg, gary 101 mitos de la biblia
Fabio Gimenez
Tratamiento farmaceutico
Tratamiento farmaceutico
Ellay SuGato
Trabajo powert point sobre aula virtual
Trabajo powert point sobre aula virtual
munar88
El iphone 5
El iphone 5
pmondragon
Parcial 1 mayda castañeda paredes
Parcial 1 mayda castañeda paredes
Alejandra Castañeda
Diagramas de casos de uso
Diagramas de casos de uso
Lismirabal
El que no sirve no sirve, medellin que bueno que existas rodolfo gonzalez
El que no sirve no sirve, medellin que bueno que existas rodolfo gonzalez
Medellín Convention Bureau
Dreamweaver
Dreamweaver
Lismirabal
Duotono triptico
Duotono triptico
Fiorela Saldaña
Vive Puebla 2012 - Atletas
Vive Puebla 2012 - Atletas
jevb88
Network linkedin. Un nou cami per la recerca de feina (URV Taller)
Network linkedin. Un nou cami per la recerca de feina (URV Taller)
Susana Archondo Ormachea
Historia de flash andrea
Historia de flash andrea
Tu Muñekit Brava
Mastering architecture, design- and code-quality
Mastering architecture, design- and code-quality
Sebastian Dietrich
Eckwerte 2013
Eckwerte 2013
Arne Schneider
Sistemas operativos.
Sistemas operativos.
Roman-comedian
Real Academia
Real Academia
marisaesteban
TÜRKEI - Die Chance für Unternehmen aus Deutschland, Österrreich und der Schweiz
TÜRKEI - Die Chance für Unternehmen aus Deutschland, Österrreich und der Schweiz
Ahmet Dener
Destaque
(20)
Internet
Internet
Riesgoviolenciasuicidioadolescentes 1226531504060413-8
Riesgoviolenciasuicidioadolescentes 1226531504060413-8
Campamentos con Actividades en Costa da Morte, Galicia
Campamentos con Actividades en Costa da Morte, Galicia
Greenberg, gary 101 mitos de la biblia
Greenberg, gary 101 mitos de la biblia
Tratamiento farmaceutico
Tratamiento farmaceutico
Trabajo powert point sobre aula virtual
Trabajo powert point sobre aula virtual
El iphone 5
El iphone 5
Parcial 1 mayda castañeda paredes
Parcial 1 mayda castañeda paredes
Diagramas de casos de uso
Diagramas de casos de uso
El que no sirve no sirve, medellin que bueno que existas rodolfo gonzalez
El que no sirve no sirve, medellin que bueno que existas rodolfo gonzalez
Dreamweaver
Dreamweaver
Duotono triptico
Duotono triptico
Vive Puebla 2012 - Atletas
Vive Puebla 2012 - Atletas
Network linkedin. Un nou cami per la recerca de feina (URV Taller)
Network linkedin. Un nou cami per la recerca de feina (URV Taller)
Historia de flash andrea
Historia de flash andrea
Mastering architecture, design- and code-quality
Mastering architecture, design- and code-quality
Eckwerte 2013
Eckwerte 2013
Sistemas operativos.
Sistemas operativos.
Real Academia
Real Academia
TÜRKEI - Die Chance für Unternehmen aus Deutschland, Österrreich und der Schweiz
TÜRKEI - Die Chance für Unternehmen aus Deutschland, Österrreich und der Schweiz
Semelhante a En riyad us_saliheen رياض الصالحين
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Goswami Mahirpari
how to write an article and publish it - complete book
how to write an article and publish it - complete book
DrHeena tiwari
2nd Book- Dr Rahul & Heena Tiwari- How to Write an Article and Publish it - C...
2nd Book- Dr Rahul & Heena Tiwari- How to Write an Article and Publish it - C...
CLOVE Dental OMNI Hospitals Andhra Hospital
Fortress of the muslim
Fortress of the muslim
E verteta vjen nga Zoti
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim) - Arabic / Transliteration / English
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim) - Arabic / Transliteration / English
The Choice
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
The Choice
Fortress of a_muslim
Fortress of a_muslim
Mohammad Ali
Fortress of the_muslim
Fortress of the_muslim
Sonali Jannat
Fortress of the Muslim
Fortress of the Muslim
Zaffer Khan
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Abdulsalam Taha
9146art9
9146art9
PT Carbon Indonesia
La presentacion
La presentacion
disenoparticipativo
776b_01.pdf
776b_01.pdf
ssuser9e9723
Osho - Book of Wisdom (2009, Osho International) - libgen.li.pdf
Osho - Book of Wisdom (2009, Osho International) - libgen.li.pdf
AlexandarStojanovic
1st Book- Dr Rahul & Heena Tiwari- Periooral Soft Tissue & Orthognathic Surge...
1st Book- Dr Rahul & Heena Tiwari- Periooral Soft Tissue & Orthognathic Surge...
CLOVE Dental OMNI Hospitals Andhra Hospital
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognath...
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognath...
DrHeena tiwari
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
Islamic Homeschooling
Vfg client brochure1.0
Vfg client brochure1.0
Virtual Financial /Transamerica /Wealth Wave
Contemporary Issues
Contemporary Issues
Islamic Library
Semelhante a En riyad us_saliheen رياض الصالحين
(20)
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
Communal Harmony in Mahesh Dattani's Finally Solution
how to write an article and publish it - complete book
how to write an article and publish it - complete book
2nd Book- Dr Rahul & Heena Tiwari- How to Write an Article and Publish it - C...
2nd Book- Dr Rahul & Heena Tiwari- How to Write an Article and Publish it - C...
Fortress of the muslim
Fortress of the muslim
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim) - Arabic / Transliteration / English
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim) - Arabic / Transliteration / English
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of the Muslim (Hisnul-Muslim)
Fortress of a_muslim
Fortress of a_muslim
Fortress of the_muslim
Fortress of the_muslim
Fortress of the Muslim
Fortress of the Muslim
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
9146art9
9146art9
La presentacion
La presentacion
776b_01.pdf
776b_01.pdf
Osho - Book of Wisdom (2009, Osho International) - libgen.li.pdf
Osho - Book of Wisdom (2009, Osho International) - libgen.li.pdf
1st Book- Dr Rahul & Heena Tiwari- Periooral Soft Tissue & Orthognathic Surge...
1st Book- Dr Rahul & Heena Tiwari- Periooral Soft Tissue & Orthognathic Surge...
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognath...
1st book dr rahul & heena tiwari- periooral soft tissue & orthognath...
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
Vfg client brochure1.0
Vfg client brochure1.0
Contemporary Issues
Contemporary Issues
Mais de Loveofpeople
Ms virus syiah
Ms virus syiah
Loveofpeople
Ms prophets pray
Ms prophets pray
Loveofpeople
Ms pillars of islam
Ms pillars of islam
Loveofpeople
Ms pillars of eman
Ms pillars of eman
Loveofpeople
Ms im a muslim
Ms im a muslim
Loveofpeople
Ms hisn muslim
Ms hisn muslim
Loveofpeople
Ms dialogue between atheist prof and muslim student
Ms dialogue between atheist prof and muslim student
Loveofpeople
Ms brief illustrated guide to understanding islam
Ms brief illustrated guide to understanding islam
Loveofpeople
Ms islam religi all
Ms islam religi all
Loveofpeople
Ms azkar muslim
Ms azkar muslim
Loveofpeople
Sr jednoca boga
Sr jednoca boga
Loveofpeople
Zh this is islam briefly web
Zh this is islam briefly web
Loveofpeople
Zh this is islam
Zh this is islam
Loveofpeople
En why people accept islam
En why people accept islam
Loveofpeople
Zh khatem elnabeen
Zh khatem elnabeen
Loveofpeople
Ru znanie islamskoy aqydy
Ru znanie islamskoy aqydy
Loveofpeople
Ru talim assolyat bihtisar
Ru talim assolyat bihtisar
Loveofpeople
Ru subhan llah
Ru subhan llah
Loveofpeople
Ru prizyv k aqyde
Ru prizyv k aqyde
Loveofpeople
Ru ma yageb ma3reftoh 3an tahara
Ru ma yageb ma3reftoh 3an tahara
Loveofpeople
Mais de Loveofpeople
(20)
Ms virus syiah
Ms virus syiah
Ms prophets pray
Ms prophets pray
Ms pillars of islam
Ms pillars of islam
Ms pillars of eman
Ms pillars of eman
Ms im a muslim
Ms im a muslim
Ms hisn muslim
Ms hisn muslim
Ms dialogue between atheist prof and muslim student
Ms dialogue between atheist prof and muslim student
Ms brief illustrated guide to understanding islam
Ms brief illustrated guide to understanding islam
Ms islam religi all
Ms islam religi all
Ms azkar muslim
Ms azkar muslim
Sr jednoca boga
Sr jednoca boga
Zh this is islam briefly web
Zh this is islam briefly web
Zh this is islam
Zh this is islam
En why people accept islam
En why people accept islam
Zh khatem elnabeen
Zh khatem elnabeen
Ru znanie islamskoy aqydy
Ru znanie islamskoy aqydy
Ru talim assolyat bihtisar
Ru talim assolyat bihtisar
Ru subhan llah
Ru subhan llah
Ru prizyv k aqyde
Ru prizyv k aqyde
Ru ma yageb ma3reftoh 3an tahara
Ru ma yageb ma3reftoh 3an tahara
Último
未毕业在线购买日本熊本县立大学学位记🏆学习成绩单电子版定制🏆克隆爱尔兰大学文凭🏆CFA证书定制
未毕业在线购买日本熊本县立大学学位记🏆学习成绩单电子版定制🏆克隆爱尔兰大学文凭🏆CFA证书定制
gravestomas0
日本九州齿科大学毕业证制作🚩定制本科卒业证书🚩哪里可以购买假美国西南基督复临安息日会大学成绩单
日本九州齿科大学毕业证制作🚩定制本科卒业证书🚩哪里可以购买假美国西南基督复临安息日会大学成绩单
jakepaige317
003 DSKP KSSR SEMAKAN 2017 BAHASA CINA TAHUN 3.pdf
003 DSKP KSSR SEMAKAN 2017 BAHASA CINA TAHUN 3.pdf
shanshanhui1
加急代办一个日本鹿儿岛纯心女子大学学位记🌈学习成绩单电子版定制🌈仿制荷兰大学毕业证🌈日语JLPT证书定制
加急代办一个日本鹿儿岛纯心女子大学学位记🌈学习成绩单电子版定制🌈仿制荷兰大学毕业证🌈日语JLPT证书定制
bairnshajjes
布莱德福德大学毕业证制作/英国本科学历如何认证/购买一个假的香港中文大学专业进修学院硕士学位证书
布莱德福德大学毕业证制作/英国本科学历如何认证/购买一个假的香港中文大学专业进修学院硕士学位证书
kathrynalvarez364
澳洲圣母大学毕业证制作/加拿大硕士学历代办/购买一个假的中央警察大学硕士学位证书
澳洲圣母大学毕业证制作/加拿大硕士学历代办/购买一个假的中央警察大学硕士学位证书
kathrynalvarez364
哪里可以购买日本神奈川县立保健福祉大学学位记/录取通知书可以制作吗/补办马来西亚大学文凭/CIA证书定制
哪里可以购买日本神奈川县立保健福祉大学学位记/录取通知书可以制作吗/补办马来西亚大学文凭/CIA证书定制
kathrynalvarez364
Grade 6 Lesson 7 Environment Protection.pptx
Grade 6 Lesson 7 Environment Protection.pptx
PriscilleXu
JAWAPAN BUKU AKTIVITI BAHASA CINA TAHUN 3.pptx
JAWAPAN BUKU AKTIVITI BAHASA CINA TAHUN 3.pptx
CHANSUITNEEMoe
我了解到黑客在某些领域拥有卓越的技术能力,特别是在处理系统漏洞方面。在当前的情境下,如果我想要改变我的毕业成绩,他们的帮助或许是我唯一可行的选择。【微 t...
我了解到黑客在某些领域拥有卓越的技术能力,特别是在处理系统漏洞方面。在当前的情境下,如果我想要改变我的毕业成绩,他们的帮助或许是我唯一可行的选择。【微 t...
黑客 接单【TG/微信qoqoqdqd】
Último
(10)
未毕业在线购买日本熊本县立大学学位记🏆学习成绩单电子版定制🏆克隆爱尔兰大学文凭🏆CFA证书定制
未毕业在线购买日本熊本县立大学学位记🏆学习成绩单电子版定制🏆克隆爱尔兰大学文凭🏆CFA证书定制
日本九州齿科大学毕业证制作🚩定制本科卒业证书🚩哪里可以购买假美国西南基督复临安息日会大学成绩单
日本九州齿科大学毕业证制作🚩定制本科卒业证书🚩哪里可以购买假美国西南基督复临安息日会大学成绩单
003 DSKP KSSR SEMAKAN 2017 BAHASA CINA TAHUN 3.pdf
003 DSKP KSSR SEMAKAN 2017 BAHASA CINA TAHUN 3.pdf
加急代办一个日本鹿儿岛纯心女子大学学位记🌈学习成绩单电子版定制🌈仿制荷兰大学毕业证🌈日语JLPT证书定制
加急代办一个日本鹿儿岛纯心女子大学学位记🌈学习成绩单电子版定制🌈仿制荷兰大学毕业证🌈日语JLPT证书定制
布莱德福德大学毕业证制作/英国本科学历如何认证/购买一个假的香港中文大学专业进修学院硕士学位证书
布莱德福德大学毕业证制作/英国本科学历如何认证/购买一个假的香港中文大学专业进修学院硕士学位证书
澳洲圣母大学毕业证制作/加拿大硕士学历代办/购买一个假的中央警察大学硕士学位证书
澳洲圣母大学毕业证制作/加拿大硕士学历代办/购买一个假的中央警察大学硕士学位证书
哪里可以购买日本神奈川县立保健福祉大学学位记/录取通知书可以制作吗/补办马来西亚大学文凭/CIA证书定制
哪里可以购买日本神奈川县立保健福祉大学学位记/录取通知书可以制作吗/补办马来西亚大学文凭/CIA证书定制
Grade 6 Lesson 7 Environment Protection.pptx
Grade 6 Lesson 7 Environment Protection.pptx
JAWAPAN BUKU AKTIVITI BAHASA CINA TAHUN 3.pptx
JAWAPAN BUKU AKTIVITI BAHASA CINA TAHUN 3.pptx
我了解到黑客在某些领域拥有卓越的技术能力,特别是在处理系统漏洞方面。在当前的情境下,如果我想要改变我的毕业成绩,他们的帮助或许是我唯一可行的选择。【微 t...
我了解到黑客在某些领域拥有卓越的技术能力,特别是在处理系统漏洞方面。在当前的情境下,如果我想要改变我的毕业成绩,他们的帮助或许是我唯一可行的选择。【微 t...
En riyad us_saliheen رياض الصالحين
1.
7+(%22.2)0,6(//$1
+$37(5 6,1(5,7$1'6,*1,),$1(2) ,17(17,216)25$//$7,216 $33$5(17$1'+,''(1 $OODKWKH([DOWHGVDV $QGWKHZHUHFRPPDQGHGQRWEXWWKDWWKHVKRXOGZRUVKLS$OODKDQG ZRUVKLSQRQHEXW+LP$ORQHDEVWDLQLQJIURPDVFULELQJSDUWQHUVWR+LP
2.
DQG SHUIRUP$V6DODW,TDPDWDV6DODW
3.
DQGJLYH=DNDWDQGWKDWLVWKHULJKW UHOLJLRQ
4.
,WLVQHLWKHUWKHLUPHDWQRUWKHLUEORRGWKDWUHDFKHV$OODKEXWLWLVSLHWIURP RXWKDWUHDFKHV+LP
5.
6D20XKDPPDG3%8+
6.
:KHWKHURXKLGHZKDWLVLQRXUEUHDVWVRU UHYHDOLW$OODKNQRZVLW
7.
1DUUDWHG 8PDUELQ$O.KDWWDE0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
8.
UHSRUWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK 3%8+
9.
VDLG7KHGHHGVDUHFRQVLGHUHGEWKHLQWHQWLRQVDQGDSHUVRQZLOOJHWWKHUHZDUGDFFRUGLQJ WRKLVLQWHQWLRQ6RZKRHYHUHPLJUDWHGIRU$OODKDQG+LV0HVVHQJHUKLVHPLJUDWLRQZLOOEHIRU$OODK DQG+LV0HVVHQJHUDQGZKRHYHUHPLJUDWHGIRUZRUOGOEHQHILWVRUIRUDZRPDQWRPDUUKLV HPLJUDWLRQZRXOGEHIRUZKDWKHHPLJUDWHGIRU $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU $FFRUGLQJWRVRPH$KDGLWKWKHUHDVRQIRUWKLV+DGLWK LVWKDWDSHUVRQVHQWDSURSRVDO RIPDUULDJHWRDZRPDQQDPHG8PP4DLVZKLFKVKHWXUQHGGRZQVDLQJWKDWKHVKRXOGKDYHWR HPLJUDWHWR$O0DGLQDKIRU
LW$FFRUGLQJOKHGLGLWIRUWKLVVSHFLILFSXUSRVHDQGWKHWZRZHUH PDUULHGWKHUH2QDFFRXQWRIWKLVHYHQWWKHPDQFDPHWREHNQRZQDPRQJWKHRPSDQLRQVDV0XKDMLU 8PP4DLV 2QWKHEDVLVRIWKLV+DGLWK 8ODPD DUHRIWKHXQDQLPRXVRSLQLRQWKDWWKHUHDOEDVLVRIRQH VDFWLRQVLV 1LDKLQWHQWLRQ
10.
DQGHYHURQHZLOOEHUHTXLWHGDFFRUGLQJWRKLV1LDK,WLVWUXHWKDW1LDKLV IRXQGHGLQRQH VKHDUWWKDWLVWRVDRQHKDVILUVWWRPDNHXSRQH VPLQGIRUZKDWKHLQWHQGVWRGRDQG KHVKRXOGQRWH[SUHVVLWYHUEDOO,QIDFWWKHODWWHULVD%LGCDKLQQRYDWLRQLQUHOLJLRQ
11.
EHFDXVHQRSURRI RILWLVIRXQGLQ6KDULDK 7KHSRLQWZKLFKEHFRPHVHYLGHQWIURPWKLV+DGLWKLVWKDW,NKODVVLQFHULW
12.
LVDPXVWIRUHYHUDFWLRQ ,QRWKHUZRUGVLQHYHUULJKWHRXV GHHGRQHVKRXOGVHHNRQOWKH3OHDVXUHRI$OODKRWKHUZLVHLWZLOO QRWEHDFFHSWHGE$OODK 1DUUDWHG $CLVKDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKHU
13.
UHSRUWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
14.
VDLG $Q DUPZLOOUDLGWKH.DCEDKDQGZKHQLWUHDFKHVDGHVHUWODQG DOORIWKHPZLOOEHVZDOORZHGXSEWKH HDUWK
6KHDVNHG 20HVVHQJHURI$OODK:KDOORIWKHP +HDQVZHUHG$OORIWKHPZLOOEH VZDOORZHGEWKHHDUWKEXWWKHZLOOEHUDLVHGIRU-XGJHPHQWDFFRUGLQJWRWKHLULQWHQWLRQV $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU (YHURQHZLOOEHUHZDUGHGRUSXQLVKHGDFFRUGLQJWRKLVDLPDQGLQWHQWLRQ7KLV+DGLWK DOVRSURYHVWKDWWKHFRPSDQRIGHSUDYHGSHUVRQVLVH[WUHPHOGDQJHURXV:KRVHDUPZRXOGLWEH ZKLFKKDVEHHQUHIHUUHGWRLQWKH+DGLWKDQGZKHQZLOOLWLQYDGH.DCEDKLVDPDWWHUNQRZQWR$OODK $ORQH6XFKSURSKHFLHVDUHDSDUWRIWKH8QVHHQZRUOG6LQFHWKHFRPHLQWKHFDWHJRURIWKHPLUDFOHV
15.
RIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
16.
LWLVQHFHVVDUWREHOLHYHLQWKHLUYHUDFLWDQGRFFXUUHQFH%HOLHYLQJLQVXFK SURSKHVLHVLVDOVRHVVHQWLDOEHFDXVHWKHZHUHUHYHDOHGE$OODK
17.
$CLVKDK 0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKHU
18.
QDUUDWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
19.
VDLG 7KHUHLVQR HPLJUDWLRQDIWHUWKHFRQTXHVWRI0DNNDK
20.
EXWRQO-LKDGVWULYLQJDQGILJKWLQJLQWKHFDXVHRI$OODK
21.
ZLOOFRQWLQXH@DQGJRRGLQWHQWLRQ 6RLIRXDUHVXPPRQHGWRILJKWJRIRUWK $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ ,QWHQWLRQDFFRUGLQJWR$Q1DZDZL,WPHDQVWKDWJRRGQHVVZKLFKFHDVHGWRFRQWLQXHEWKH FHVVDWLRQRIHPLJUDWLRQFDQVWLOOEHREWDLQHGE-LKDG DQGELQWHQGLQJDFFRPSOLVKLQJJRRGGHHGV RPPHQWDU:KHQDFRXQWURUDUHJLRQLVUHJDUGHGDV'DUXO,VODP ODQGRI,VODP
22.
LWLVQRW QHFHVVDUWRPLJUDWHIURPLWWRVRPHRWKHUSODFH,WLVKRZHYHUREOLJDWRUWRHPLJUDWHIURPVXFK UHJLRQVZKLFKDUH'DUXO.XIUODQGRILQILGHOV
23.
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
24.
DQGRQWKHRWKHUREVFHQLWDQGLQGHFHQFWKDWDUH FRPPRQLQVXFKFRXQWULHVDUHEHFRPLQJLQFUHDVLQJOFRPPRQDPRQJWKH0XVOLPVWRR $QRWKHUKLJKOLPSRUWDQWUHDVRQIRUWKHSURKLELWLRQRIPLJUDWLRQRI0XVOLPVWR'DUXO.XIULVWKDWLW JRHVDJDLQVWWKHVSLULWDVZHOODVWKHLUUHDGLQHVVIRU-LKDGILVDELOLOODKVWULYLQJDQGILJKWLQJLQWKHZD RI$OODK
25.
7KLVVSLULWDQGUHDGLQHVVPXVWEHNHSWDOZDVDOLYHVRWKDWWKH0XVOLPVPDUHVSRQGDWRQFH WRWKHFDOORI-LKDGZKHQHYHUWKHQHHGIRULWDULVHVDQZKHUH -DELUELQ$EGXOODK$O$QVDUL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
26.
UHSRUWHG:HDFFRPSDQLHGWKH 3URSKHW3%8+
27.
LQDQH[SHGLWLRQZKHQKHVDLG 7KHUHDUHVRPHPHQLQ$O0DGLQDKZKRDUHZLWKRX ZKHUHYHURXPDUFKDQGZKLFKHYHUYDOOHRXFURVV7KHKDYHQRWMRLQHGRXLQSHUVRQEHFDXVHRI WKHLULOOQHVV ,QDQRWKHUYHUVLRQKHVDLG
7KHVKDUHWKHUHZDUG ZLWKRX 0XVOLP@ ,WLVQDUUDWHGE%XNKDULIURP$QDVELQ0DOLN0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
28.
:HZHUHFRPLQJEDFN IURPWKHEDWWOHRI7DEXNZLWKWKH3URSKHW3%8+
29.
ZKHQKHUHPDUNHG 7KHUHDUHSHRSOHZKRPZHOHIW EHKLQGLQ$O0DGLQDKZKRDFFRPSDQLHGXVLQVSLULWLQHYHUSDVVDQGYDOOHZHFURVVHG7KH UHPDLQHGEHKLQGIRUDYDOLGH[FXVH RPPHQWDU :KDWZHOHDUQIURPWKLV+DGLWKLVWKDWLIWKHLQWHQWLRQDQGVSLULWRI-LKDGDUHSUHVHQWLQ WKHKHDUWRID0XVOLPEXWSKVLFDOOKHLVXQDEOHWRWDNHSDUWLQLWIRUYDOLGUHDVRQVKHZLOOJHWWKH UHZDUGRI-LKDGZLWKRXWHYHQKLVDFWXDOSDUWLFLSDWLRQLQLW
0DCQELQD]LGELQ$NKQDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
30.
KHKLVIDWKHUDQGKLVJUDQGIDWKHU DOOZHUHRPSDQLRQV
31.
UHSRUWHG0IDWKHUVHWDVLGHVRPHGLQDUVIRUFKDULWDQGJDYHWKHPWRDPDQLQ WKHPRVTXH,ZHQWWRWKDWPDQDQGWRRNEDFNWKRVHGLQDUV+HVDLG,KDGQRWLQWHQGHGRXWREH JLYHQ 6RZHZHQWWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
32.
DQGSXWIRUWKWKHPDWWHUEHIRUHKLP+HVDLGWRP IDWKHU D]LGRXKDYHEHHQUHZDUGHGIRUZKDWRXLQWHQGHG $QGKHVDLGWRPH
0DCQRXDUH HQWLWOHGWRZKDWRXKDYHWDNHQ $O%XNKDUL@ RPPHQWDU 7KLV+DGLWKOHDGVXVWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQWKDWLI6DGDTDKFKDULW
33.
JRHVWRDQHHGVRQRID0XVOLP WKHUHLVQRQHHGWRWDNHLWEDFNIURPKLPIRUWKHUHDVRQWKDWWKHIDWKHUKDGLQWHQGHGWRJLYHLWWRD GHVHUYLQJSHUVRQ7KHIRUPHUJHWVWKHUHZDUGIRULWRQDFFRXQWRIKLV1LDKLQWHQWLRQ
34.
7KLVKRZHYHU ZLOOEHUHFNRQHGDV1DIOL6DGDTDKYROXQWDUFKDULW
35.
EHFDXVHWKHREOLJDWRU=DNDW6DGDTDK
36.
FDQQRW EHJLYHQWRWKHGRQRU VRZQGHSHQGHQWV
37.
,WLVSHUPLVVLEOHLQ6KDULCDKWRPDNHVRPHRQHD:DNLO DWWRUQHRUDJHQW
38.
IRU6DGDTDK ,WGRHVQRWDPRXQWWRGLVREHGLHQFHRQWKHSDUWRIDVRQWRWDNHKLV IDWKHUWRDFRPSHWHQWDXWKRULWRU VFKRODUWRNQRZWKHOHJDOSRVLWLRQRQDQLVVXHLQWKHVDPHZDDVPXWXDOGLVFXVVLRQDQGGHEDWHRQ PDWWHUVRI6KDULCDKGRHVQRWDPRXQWWRLQVROHQFH)DWK$O%DULFKDSWHURQ=DNDW
39.
$EX,VKDT6DCGELQ$EX:DTTDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
40.
RQHRIWKHWHQZKRKDGEHHQ JLYHQWKHJODGWLGLQJVRIHQWULQWR-DQQDK
41.
QDUUDWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
42.
YLVLWHGPHLQP LOOQHVVZKLFKEHFDPHVHYHUHLQWKHHDURI+DMMDWXO:DGDC)DUHZHOO3LOJULPDJH
43.
,VDLG2 0HVVHQJHURI$OODKRXFDQVHHWKHSDLQZKLFK,DPVXIIHULQJDQG,DPDPDQRIPHDQVDQGWKHUHLV QRQHWRLQKHULWIURPPHH[FHSWRQHGDXJKWHU6KRXOG,JLYHWZRWKLUGVRIPSURSHUWLQFKDULW +H 3%8+
44.
VDLG 1R ,DVNHGKLP7KHQKDOI +HVDLG
1R 7KHQ,DVNHGDQ,JLYHDZDRQH WKLUG+HVDLG *LYHDZDRQHWKLUGDQGWKDWLVVWLOOWRRPXFK,WLVEHWWHUWROHDYHRXUKHLUVZHOORII WKDQWROHDYHWKHPSRRUEHJJLQJSHRSOHRXZLOOQRWH[SHQGDWKLQJLQFKDULWIRUWKHVDNHRI$OODK EXWRXZLOOEHUHZDUGHGIRULWHYHQWKHPRUVHORIIRRGZKLFKRXIHHGRXUZLIH ,VDLG2 0HVVHQJHURI$OODKZRXOG,VXUYLYHPFRPSDQLRQV +HVDLG ,IRXVXUYLYHRWKHUVDQGDFFRPSOLVK DWKLQJIRUWKHVDNHRI$OODKRXZRXOGJDLQKLJKHUUDQNLQJDQGVWDQGLQJRXZLOOVXUYLYHWKHP RXUVXUYLYDOZLOOEHEHQHILFLDOWRSHRSOHWKH0XVOLP
45.
DQGKDUPIXOWRRWKHUVWKHHQHPLHVRI,VODP
46.
RXZLOOVXUYLYHRWKHUVWLOOWKHSHRSOHZLOOGHULYHEHQHILWIURPRXDQGRWKHUVZRXOGEHKDUPHGE RX 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
47.
IXUWKHUVDLG 2$OODKFRPSOHWHIRUPRPSDQLRQVWKHLU HPLJUDWLRQDQGGRQRWFDXVHWKHPWRUHWUDFW 6DCGELQ.KDXODKZDVXQIRUWXQDWH
0HVVHQJHURI$OODK 3%8+
48.
ODPHQWHGKLVGHDWKDVKHGLHGLQ0DNNDK $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU ,QVSLWHRIDOOWKHLUORYHIRULWWKHRPSDQLRQVRIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
49.
GLGQRWOLNHWR GLHLQDFLWIURPZKLFKWKHHPLJUDWHGIRUWKHVDNHRI$OODK)RUWKLVUHDVRQ6DCG0D$OODKEH SOHDVHGZLWKKLP
50.
ZDVDIUDLGRIGLQJLQ0DNNDK7KH3URSKHW3%8+
51.
SUDHGIRUWKHDFFRPSOLVKPHQW RI6DCG VHPLJUDWLRQDQGH[SUHVVHGUHJUHWRYHUWKHPLVIRUWXQHRI 6DCGELQ.KDXODK7KHODWWHUGLHGLQ 0DNNDK RQFOXVLRQ 7KH+DGLWKODVGRZQWKDWLQWKHFRXUVHRIDGLVHDVHZKLFKVHHPVWRSURYHIDWDORQHFDQQRWJLYH PRUH WKDQRQHWKLUGRIWKHSURSHUWLQFKDULW ,WLVDOVRHPSKDVL]HGWKDWRQHJHWVUHZDUGHYHQIRUZKDWKHVSHQGVRQKLVZLIHDQGFKLOGUHQ 2QHFDQUHSRUWWRRWKHUVKLVDLOPHQWRUWRVHHNWUHDWPHQWDQGDVNWKHPWRVXSSOLFDWHIURPKLP ,QWKHPDWWHURI6DGDTDKFKDULW
52.
ZKLFKRQHJLYHVWRVHHNWKH3OHDVXUHRI$OODKKLVFORVHVW UHODWLYHVVKRXOGDOZDVKDYHSULRULWDQGSUHIHUHQFHRYHURWKHUV $EX+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
53.
QDUUDWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
54.
VDLG $OODK GRHVQRW ORRNDWRXUILJXUHVQRUDWRXUDWWLUHEXW+HORRNVDWRXUKHDUWVDQGDFFRPSOLVKPHQWV 0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU
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
55.
UHSRUWHGWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK 3%8+
56.
ZDVDVNHGDERXWZKRILJKWVLQWKH EDWWOHILHOGRXWRIYDORXURURXWRI ]HDORURXWRI
KSRFULVZKLFK RIWKLVLVFRQVLGHUHGDVILJKWLQJLQWKHFDXVHRI$OODK+HVDLG +H ZKRILJKWVLQRUGHUWKDWWKH:RUG RI$OODKUHPDLQVWKHVXSUHPHLVFRQVLGHUHGDVILJKWLQJLQWKHFDXVHRI$OODK $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@
57.
RPPHQWDU 6LQFHRQH VDFWLRQZLOOEHHYDOXDWHGLQWHUPVRILQWHQWLRQVRKHDORQHZRXOGEHD 0XMDKLG ZDUULRULQWKHFDXVHRI'HHQ
58.
ZKRILJKWVWRJORULIWKH1DPHRI$OODK $EX%DNUDK$WK7KDTDIL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
59.
UHSRUWHG7KH3URSKHW3%8+
60.
VDLG :KHQWZR0XVOLPVDUHHQJDJHGLQDFRPEDWDJDLQVWHDFKRWKHUZLWKWKHLUVZRUG VDQGRQHLVNLOOHG ERWKDUHGRRPHGWR+HOO ,VDLG20HVVHQJHURI$OODK$VWRWKHRQHZKRNLOOVLWLVXQGHUVWDQGDEOH EXWZKWKHVODLQRQH+H3%8+
61.
UHSOLHG +HZDVHDJHUWRNLOOKLVRSSRQHQW $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU 7KLV+DGLWKOHDGVWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQWKDWRQHZRXOGEHSXQLVKHGIRUVXFKVLQIXO LQWHQWLRQIRUZKLFKKHKDVPDGHDILUPGHWHUPLQDWLRQDQGIRUWKHFRPPLWPHQWRIZKLFKKHKDVDGRSWHG QHFHVVDUPHDVXUHVHYHQLIKHGRHVQRWVXFFHHGLQFRPPLWWLQJLWEHFDXVHRIFHUWDLQREVWUXFWLRQ7KXV GHWHUPLQDWLRQLVGLIIHUHQWIURPDVXJJHVWLRQRIWKHGHYLO7KHODWWHULVH[FXVDEOHZKLOHRQHLV DFFRXQWDEOHIRUKLVGHWHUPLQDWLRQ+RZHYHUZKDWLVPHQWLRQHGLQWKH+DGLWKZLOOKDSSHQZKHQ 0XVOLPV
ILJKWDPRQJWKHPVHOYHVIRUZRUOGOKRQRXUDQGSUHMXGLFHVDQGQRUHOLJLRXVLVVXHZRXOGEH WKHFDXVHRIWKHLUFRQIOLFWEHFDXVHLQWKHODWWHUFDVHLWLVSRVVLEOHWKDWERWKPLJKWEHGHSHQGLQJRQWKHLU RZQ,MWLKDGH[HUFLVHRIRSLQLRQ
62.
IRUZKLFKWKHPDEHH[FXVHG $EX+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
63.
UHSRUWHGWKDW7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
64.
VDLG 7KHUHZDUGIRU6DODWSHUIRUPHGEDSHUVRQLQFRQJUHJDWLRQLVPRUHWKDQWLPHVJUHDWHUWKDQ WKDWRIWKH6DODWSHUIRUPHGLQRQH VKRXVHRUVKRS:KHQRQHSHUIRUPV:XGX SHUIHFWODQGWKHQ SURFHHGVWRWKHPRVTXHZLWKWKHVROHLQWHQWLRQRISHUIRUPLQJ6DODWWKHQIRUHYHUVWHSKHWDNHV WRZDUGVWKHPRVTXHKHLVXSJUDGHGRQHGHJUHHLQUHZDUGDQGRQHRIKLVVLQVLVHOLPLQDWHGXQWLOKH HQWHUVWKHPRVTXHDQGZKHQKHHQWHUVWKHPRVTXHKHLVFRQVLGHUHGDVSHUIRUPLQJ6DODWDVORQJDVLWLV WKH6DODWZKLFKSUHYHQWVKLPIURPOHDYLQJWKHPRVTXH
65.
DQGWKHDQJHOVNHHSRQVXSSOLFDWLQJ$OODKIRU KLPDVORQJDVKHUHPDLQVLQKLVSODFHRISUDHU7KHVD 2$OODKKDYHPHUFRQKLP2$OODK IRUJLYHKLVVLQV2$OODKDFFHSWKLVUHSHQWDQFH 7KLVZLOOFDUURQDVORQJDVKHGRHVQRWSDVVZLQG $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU 7KLV+DGLWKVKRZVWKDWDOWKRXJKLWLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRSHUIRUP6DODWLQGLYLGXDOOLQ PDUNHWSODFHVDQGKRXVHVEXWLWVFROOHFWLYHSHUIRUPDQFHLQWKHPRVTXHLVRUWLPHVPRUH PHULWRULRXVDVPHQWLRQHGLQRWKHU$KDGLWK C$EGXOODKELQC$EEDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
66.
UHSRUWHG 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
67.
VDLGWKDW$OODKWKH*ORULRXVVDLG 9HULO$OODK6:7
68.
KDVRUGHUHGWKDWWKHJRRGDQGWKHEDGGHHGV EHZULWWHQGRZQ7KHQ+HH[SODLQHGLWFOHDUOKRZWRZULWH
69.
+HZKRLQWHQGVWRGRDJRRGGHHGEXWKH GRHVQRWGRLWWKHQ$OODKUHFRUGVLWIRUKLPDVDIXOOJRRGGHHGEXWLI KHFDUULHVRXWKLVLQWHQWLRQWKHQ $OODKWKH([DOWHGZULWHVLWGRZQIRUKLPDVIURPWHQWRVHYHQKXQGUHGIROGVDQGHYHQPRUH%XWLIKH LQWHQGVWRGRDQHYLODFWDQGKDVQRWGRQHLWWKHQ$OODKZULWHVLWGRZQZLWK+LPDVDIXOOJRRGGHHG EXWLIKHLQWHQGVLWDQGKDVGRQHLW$OODKZULWHVLWGRZQDVRQHEDGGHHG $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU :KDWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
70.
UHODWHVWR$OODKLVFDOOHG+DGLWK4XGVL 6DFUHG7UDGLWLRQ
71.
6XFK+DGLWKLVUHYHDOHGWRWKH3URSKHW3%8+
72.
EPHDQVRI,OKDP LQVSLUDWLRQ
73.
7KLV+DGLWKPHQWLRQV WKHPDJQLWXGHRI'LYLQHEOHVVLQJVZKLFK+HEHVWRZVXSRQ+LVIDLWKIXOVODYHVRQWKH'DRI 5HVXUUHFWLRQ C$EGXOODKELQC8PDUELQ$O.KDWWDE0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
74.
QDUUDWHGWKDW+HKHDUG 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
75.
DVVDLQJ 7KUHHPHQDPRQJVWWKRVHZKRFDPHEHIRUHRXVHWRXWXQWLO QLJKWFDPHDQGWKHUHDFKHGDFDYHVRWKHHQWHUHGLW$URFNIHOOGRZQIURPWKHPRXQWDLQDQG EORFNHGWKHHQWUDQFHRIWKHFDYH7KHVDLGC1RWKLQJZLOOVDYHRXIURPWKLVXQOHVVRXVXSSOLFDWHWR $OODKEYLUWXHRIDULJKWHRXVGHHGRXKDYH GRQH 7KHUHXSRQRQHRIWKHPVDLGC2$OODK,KDG SDUHQWVZKRZHUHROGDQG,XVHGWRRIIHUWKHPPLONEHIRUHDQRIPFKLOGUHQRUVODYHV2QHGD, ZHQWIDUDZDLQVHDUFKRIJUD]LQJDQGFRXOGQRWFRPHEDFNXQWLOWKHKDGVOHSW:KHQ,PLONHGDV XVXDO
DQGEURXJKWWKHGULQN,IRXQGWKHPERWKDVOHHS,KDWHGWRGLVWXUEWKHPDQGDOVRGLVOLNHGWRJLYH PLONWRPFKLOGUHQEHIRUHWKHP0FKLOGUHQZHUHFULQJRXWRIKXQJHUDWPIHHWEXW,DZDLWHGZLWK WKHERZOLQPKDQGIRUWKHPWRZDNHXS:KHQWKHDZRNH DWGDZQWKHGUDQNPLON2$OODK,I , GLGVRWRVHHNRXU3OHDVXUHWKHQGHOLYHUXVIURPWKHGLVWUHVVFDXVHGEWKHURFN 7KHURFNPRYHG VOLJKWOEXWWKHZHUHXQDEOHWRHVFDSH7KHQH[WVDLGC2$OODK,KDGDFRXVLQZKRP,ORYHGPRUH
76.
WKDQDQRQHHOVHLQDQRWKHUYHUVLRQKHVDLGDVDPDQFDQORYHDZRPDQ
77.
,ZDQWHGWRKDYHVH[XDO LQWHUFRXUVHZLWKKHUEXWVKHUHIXVHG+DUGSUHVVHGLQDHDURIIDPLQHVKHDSSURDFKHGPH,JDYHKHU RQHKXQGUHGDQGWZHQWGLQDUVRQFRQGLWLRQWKDWVKHZRXOGLHOGKHUVHOIWRPH6KHDJUHHGDQGZKHQ ZHJRWWRJHWKHUIRUVH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVH
78.
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
79.
OLYHGDQGWKHWZRIROORZLQJ
80.
3UHIHUHQFHVKRXOGEHJLYHQWRWKHVHUYLFHRISDUHQWVHYHQRYHUWKHVHUYLFHRIRQH VRZQZLIHDQG FKLOGUHQ 7RDEVWDLQIURPVLQVRXWRIIHDURI$OODKLVDKLJKOPHULWRULRXVDFW /DERXUHUVVKRXOGDOZDVEHWUHDWHGIDLUO,IVRPHRQHKDVSDLGWRDODERXUHUOHVVWKDQKLVGXHLW VKRXOGEHSDLGWRKLPLQDGHFHQWPDQQHU $QVXSSOLFDWLRQZKLFKLVPDGHVLQFHUHODQGZLWKUHDOVHQVHRIKXPEOHQHVVLVJUDQWHGE$OODK $OODKVRPHWLPHVKHOSV+LVSLRXVPHQHYHQLQDQXQXVXDOPDQQHUZKLFKLVWHUPHGDV.DUDPDW ZRQGHURUPDUYHO
81.
7KXVOLNHWKHPLUDFOHVRIWKH3URSKHWVZRQGHUVRIWKHULJKWHRXVSHRSOHDUHDOVR WUXH%XWPLUDFOHVDQGZRQGHUVERWKDSSHDUZLWKWKH:LOORI$OODK
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
82.
2QHVKRXOGDOVRUHSHQWIURPDOOVLQV,IKHUHSHQWVIURPVRPHKLVUHSHQWDQFHZRXOGVWLOOEHVRXQG DFFRUGLQJWRWKHSHRSOHRIVRXQGNQRZOHGJH+HVKRXOGKRZHYHUUHSHQWIURPWKHUHVW 6FULSWXUDO SURRIVIURPWKH%RRNDQGWKH6XQQDKDQGWKHFRQVHQVXVRIWKHVFKRODUVVXSSRUWWKHLQFXPEHQFRI UHSHQWDQFH $OODKWKH([DOWHGVDV $QGDOORIRXEHJ$OODKWRIRUJLYHRX2EHOLHYHUVWKDWRXPDEHVXFFHVVIXO
83.
6HHNWKHIRUJLYHQHVVRIRXU5XEEDQGWXUQWR+LPLQUHSHQWDQFH
84.
2RXZKREHOLHYH7XUQWR$OODKZLWKVLQFHUHUHSHQWDQFH
85.
$EX+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
86.
UHSRUWHG,KHDUG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
87.
VDLQJ %$OODK,VHHN$OODK V IRUJLYHQHVVDQGUHSHQWWR+LPPRUHWKDQVHYHQWWLPHVDGD $O%XNKDUL@ RPPHQWDU ,WLVDQLQGXFHPHQWIRUVHHNLQJSDUGRQDQGIRUJLYHQHVV7KH3URSKHW3%8+
88.
ZKRVHSDVWDQGIXWXUH VLQVZHUHIRUJLYHQDVNHG$OODK VIRULJYHQHVV WKHQKRZDERXW XVZKRFRPPLWVLQVRQUHJXODUEDVLV QRWWRVHHNSDUGRQDQGIRUJLYHQHVVIURP$OODK 6LQFHUHDQGFHDVHOHVVSUDHUIRUSDUGRQLVHVVHQWLDOVRWKDWVLQVFRPPLWWHGEXVXQLQWHQWLRQDOODUH DOVRIRUJLYHQ7KHDERYH+DGLWKODVJUHDWHPSKDVLVRQVHHNLQJSDUGRQ
$O$JKDUUELQDVDU$O0X]DQL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
89.
QDUUDWHGWKDW7KH0HVVHQJHURI $OODK3%8+
90.
VDLG 7XUQRXSHRSOHLQUHSHQWDQFHWR$OODKDQGEHJSDUGRQRI +LP,WXUQWR+LPLQ UHSHQWDQFHDKXQGUHGWLPHVDGD 0XVOLP@
$QDVELQ0DOLN$O$QVDUL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
91.
WKHVHUYDQWRIWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK QDUUDWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
92.
VDLG 9HULO$OODKLVPRUHGHOLJKWHGZLWKWKHUHSHQWDQFHRI+LV VODYHWKDQDSHUVRQZKRORVWKLVFDPHOLQDGHVHUWODQGDQGWKHQILQGVLWXQH[SHFWHGO
93.
$O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ ,QDQRWKHUYHUVLRQRI0XVOLPKHVDLG 9HULO$OODKLVPRUHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHUHSHQWDQFHRI+LVVODYH WKDQDSHUVRQZKRKDVKLVFDPHOLQDZDWHUOHVVGHVHUWFDUULQJKLVSURYLVLRQRIIRRGDQGGULQNDQGLWLV ORVW+HKDYLQJORVWDOOKRSHVWRJHWWKDWEDFN
94.
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
95.
UHSRUWHG7KH3URSKHW3%8+
96.
VDLG $OODKWKH([DOWHGZLOOFRQWLQXHWRVWUHWFKRXW+LV+DQGLQWKHQLJKWVRWKDWWKHVLQQHUVRIWKHGDPD UHSHQWDQGFRQWLQXHWRVWUHWFK+LV+DQGLQWKHGDWLPHVRWKDWWKHVLQQHUVRIWKHQLJKWPDUHSHQWXQWLO WKHVXQULVHVIURPWKHZHVW 0XVOLP@
97.
RPPHQWDU 7KLV+DGLWKFRQILUPVDQHVVHQWLDO$WWULEXWHRI$OODKLHWKH+DQGZKLFK+HVWUHWFKHV RXWDQWLPH+HZLVKHVZLWKRXWGUDZLQJVLPLODULWWRLWQRULQWHUSUHWDWLRQ6XFKZDVWKHDWWLWXGHRIWKH SLRXVSUHGHFHVVRUVZLWKUHJDUGVWRDOORIWKHHVVHQWLDO$WWULEXWHVRI$OODK,WLVGHGXFHGIURPWKLV +DGLWKWKDWLIRQHFRPPLWVDVLQGXULQJDQKRXURIGDRUQLJKWKHVKRXOGLPPHGLDWHOVHHNWKH IRUJLYHQHVVRI$OODKDVDUHVXOW $EX+XUDLUDK
0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
98.
QDUUDWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
99.
VDLG +H ZKRUHSHQWVEHIRUHWKHVXQULVHVIURPWKHZHVW$OODKZLOOIRUJLYHKLP 0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU 7DXEDKPHDQVUHWXUQLQJWR$OODKIURPVLQV:KHQDSHUVRQFRPPLWVDVLQKHJRHV DZDIURP$OODK:KHQKHUHSHQWVKHUHWXUQVWR$OODKDQGGHVLUHVIRUEHLQJSDUGRQHGE+LPDQG JHWWLQJQHDU+LP7KLVUHWXUQLQJWRZDUGV+LPLV7DXEDK:KHQLWLVVDLGWKDWC$OODKWXUQVWRZDUGVKLP LWPHDQVWKDW$OODKDFFHSWVKLVUHSHQWDQFH
C$EGXOODKELQC8PDU ELQ$O.KDWWDE 0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
100.
UHSRUWHGWKDW7KH3URSKHW 3%8+
101.
VDLG $OODKDFFHSWVDVODYH VUHSHQWDQFHDVORQJDVWKHODWWHULVQRWRQKLVGHDWKEHGWKDWLV EHIRUHWKHVRXORIWKHGLQJSHUVRQUHDFKHVWKHWKURDW
102.
$W7LUPLGKLZKRFDWHJRULVHGLWDV+DGLWK+DVDQ@ RPPHQWDU 7KHZRUG*KDUJKDUDKPHDQVWKHVWDJHZKHQVRXOLVDERXWWROHDYHWKHERGDQG UHDFKHVWKHWKURDW,QRWKHUZRUGVWKHWLPHZKHQRQHVXIIHUVWKHDJRQRIGHDWK +DGLWK+DVDQPHDQVWKDW+DGLWKWKHDXWKHQWLFLWRIZKLFKLVFRQQHFWHGZLWKRXWDQWHFKQLFDOGHIHFW 7KHLUQDUUDWRUVKRZHYHUDUHQH[WWRWKRVHRI+DGLWK6DKLK,QWKHRSLQLRQRI0XKDGGLWKLQ
+DGLWK VFKRODUV
103.
+DGLWK+DVDQLVDOVRUHOLDEOHDV+DGLWK6DKLK =LUUELQ+XEDLVKUHSRUWHG,ZHQWWR6DIZDQELQC$VVDO 0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
104.
WRLQTXLUH DERXWZLSLQJZLWKZHWKDQGVRYHUOLJKWERRWVZKLOHSHUIRUPLQJ:XGX +HDVNHGPH:KDWEULQJVRX KHUH=LUU ,DQVZHUHG6HDUFKIRUNQRZOHGJH+HVDLG$QJHOVVSUHDGWKHLUZLQJVIRUWKHVHHNHURI NQRZOHGJHRXWRI MRIRUZKDWKHVHHNV,WROGKLP,KDYHVRPHGRXEWVLQPPLQGUHJDUGLQJZLSLQJ RIZHWKDQGVRYHUOLJKWERRWVLQWKHFRXUVHRISHUIRUPLQJ:XGX DIWHUGHIHFDWLRQRUXULQDWLQJ1RZ VLQFHRXDUHRQHRIWKHRPSDQLRQVRIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
105.
,KDYHFRPHWRDVNRXZKHWKHURX KHDUGDQVDLQJRIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
106.
FRQFHUQLQJLW+HUHSOLHGLQWKHDIILUPDWLYHDQGVDLG+H 3%8+
107.
LQVWUXFWHGXVWKDWGXULQJDMRXUQHZHQHHGQRWWDNHRIIRXUOLJKWERRWVIRUZDVKLQJWKHIHHWXS WRWKUHHGDVDQGQLJKWVH[FHSWLQFDVHRIPDMRULPSXULWDIWHUVH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVH
108.
,QRWKHUFDVHVVXFK DVVOHHSLQJUHOLHYLQJRQHVHOIRUXULQDWLQJWKHZLSLQJRIZHWKDQGVRYHUOLJKWERRWVZLOOVXIILFH , WKHQTXHVWLRQHGKLP'LGRXKHDUKLPVDDQWKLQJDERXWORYHDQGDIIHFWLRQ +HUHSOLHG:H DFFRPSDQLHGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
109.
LQDMRXUQHZKHQDEHGRXLQFDOOHGRXWLQDORXGYRLFH C20XKDPPDG 7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
110.
UHSOLHGKLPLQWKHVDPHWRQH C+HUH,DP ,VDLGWR KLPWKHEHGRXLQ
111.
C:RHWRRXORZHURXUYRLFHLQKLVSUHVHQFHEHFDXVHRXDUHQRWDOORZHGWRGR VR +HVDLGC%$OODK,ZLOOQRWORZHUPYRLFH DQGWKHQDGGUHVVLQJWKH3URSKHW3%8+
112.
KHVDLG C:KDWDERXWDSHUVRQZKRORYHVSHRSOHEXWKDVQRWIRXQGKLPVHOILQWKHLUFRPSDQ 0HVVHQJHURI $OODK3%8+
113.
UHSOLHG C2QWKH'DRI5HVXUUHFWLRQDSHUVRQZLOOEHLQWKHFRPSDQRIWKRVHZKRPKH ORYHV 7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKWKHQNHSWRQWDONLQJWRXVDQGLQWKHFRXUVHRIKLVWDONKHPHQWLRQHGD JDWHZDLQWKHKHDYHQWKH ZLGWKRIZKLFKFRXOGEHFURVVHGEDULGHULQIRUWRUVHYHQWHDUV
6XIDQRQHRIWKHQDUUDWRUVRIWKLVWUDGLWLRQVDLG7KLVJDWHZDLVLQWKHGLUHFWLRQRI6ULD$OODK FUHDWHGLWRQWKHGD+HFUHDWHGWKHKHDYHQVDQGWKHHDUWK,WLVRSHQIRUUHSHQWDQFHDQGZLOOQRWEHVKXW XQWLOWKHVXQULVHVIURPWKDWGLUHFWLRQLHWKH:HVW
114.
RQ'RRPVGD
115.
$W7LUPLGKLZKRFDWHJRULVHGLWDV+DGLWK+DVDQ6DKLK@ RPPHQWDU :HOHDUQIURPWKLV+DGLWKWKDWLQDEOXWLRQLWLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRZLSHRYHUOLJKWERRWVUDWKHUWKDQ ZDVKLQJWKHIHHW,WLVFDOOHG0DVK7KHSHULRGLQZKLFK0DVKLVLQWDFW LQFDVHRIWUDYHOOHUVLWLVWKUHH GDVDQGWKUHHQLJKWVZKLOHIRUWKHUHVLGHQWVLWLVRQHGDDQGRQHQLJKWRQO$SUHFRQGLWLRQIRULWLV WKDWOLJKWERRWVVKRXOGEHFOHDQDQGZRUQDIWHUIXOO:XGX $QNOHVVKRXOGDOVREHFRYHUHG,QFDVHRI EUHDFKRIDEOXWLRQWKHZLSLQJRYHUWKHVRFNVLVVXIILFLHQWDQGWKHUHLVQRQHHGIRUZDVKLQJWKHIHHW
116.
:XGX LVLQYDOLGDWHGEVOHHSLQJFDOORIQDWXUHDQGSDVVLQJRIZLQG7KLVLVFDOOHG+DGDWK$VJKDU,Q WKHFDVHRI+DGDWK$NEDUZKLFKRFFXUVEHFDXVHRIFRLWXVPHQVHVDQGZHWGUHDPZDVKLQJRIWKH ZKROHERGEHFRPHVREOLJDWRU,WPHDQVWKDWWKHSULYLOHJHRIZLSLQJRYHUWKHOLJKWERRWVLVDOVR ILQLVKHGLQWKLVFDVHLQWKHVDPHZDDVLWGRHVDIWHUWKHH[SLURISHULRGVSHFLILHGIRULW 2QHVKRXOGDVVRFLDWHKLPVHOIZLWKWKHSLRXVSHRSOHVRWKDWKHLVFRXQWHGDPRQJWKHP2QHDOVR FRPHVWRNQRZPDQRWKHUSRLQWVIURPWKLV+DGLWKZKLFKHYHULQWHOOLJHQWSHUVRQFDQXQGHUVWDQGZLWK DOLWWOHHIIRUW $EX6DCLG$O.KXGUL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
117.
UHSRUWHG3URSKHWRI$OODK3%8+
118.
VDLG 7KHUHZDVDPDQIURPDPRQJDQDWLRQEHIRUHRXZKRNLOOHGQLQHWQLQHSHRSOHDQGWKHQPDGHDQ LQTXLUDERXWWKHPRVWOHDUQHGSHUVRQRQWKHHDUWK+HZDVGLUHFWHGWRDPRQN+HFDPHWRKLPDQG WROGKLPWKDWKHKDGNLOOHGQLQHWQLQHSHRSOHDQGDVNHGKLPLIWKHUHZDVDQFKDQFHIRUKLVUHSHQWDQFH WREHDFFHSWHG+HUHSOLHGLQWKHQHJDWLYHDQGWKHPDQNLOOHGKLPDOVRFRPSOHWLQJRQHKXQGUHG+HWKHQ DVNHGDERXWWKHPRVWOHDUQHGPDQLQWKHHDUWK+HZDVGLUHFWHGWRDVFKRODU+HWROGKLPWKDWKHKDG NLOOHGRQHKXQGUHGSHRSOHDQGDVNHGKLPLIWKHUHZDVDQFKDQFHIRUKLVUHSHQWDQFHWREHDFFHSWHG+H UHSOLHGLQWKHDIILUPDWLYHDQGDVNHGC:KRVWDQGVEHWZHHQRXDQGUHSHQWDQFH*RWRVXFKDQGVXFK ODQGWKHUHRXZLOOILQG
119.
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
120.
ZKHUH KHLQWHQGHGWRJRDQGVRWKHDQJHOVRIPHUFFROOHFWHGKLVVRXO $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ ,QDQRWKHUYHUVLRQ +HZDVIRXQGWREHQHDUHUWRWKHORFDOLWRIWKH
SLRXVEDFXELWDQGZDVWKXV LQFOXGHGDPRQJWKHP $QRWKHUYHUVLRQVDV $OODKFRPPDQGHGWKHODQGZKLFKKHZDQWHGWROHDYH
121.
WRPRYHDZDDQGFRPPDQGHGWKHRWKHUODQGKLVGHVWLQDWLRQ
122.
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
123.
ZKHQKHEHFDPHEOLQGQDUUDWHG,KHDUG.DCEELQ0DOLN0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
124.
QDUUDWLQJWKH VWRURIKLVUHPDLQLQJEHKLQGLQVWHDGRI MRLQLQJ0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
125.
ZKHQKHOHIWIRUWKH EDWWOHRI7DEXN.DCEVDLG,DFFRPSDQLHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
126.
LQHYHUH[SHGLWLRQZKLFKKH XQGHUWRRNH[FHSWLQJWKHEDWWOHRI7DEXNDQGWKHEDWWOHRI%DGU$VIRUWKHEDWWOHRI%DGUQRERGZDV EODPHGIRUUHPDLQLQJEHKLQGDV0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
127.
DQGWKH0XVOLPVZKHQWKHVHWRXWKDG LQPLQGRQOWRLQWHUFHSWWKHFDUDYDQRIWKH4XUDLVK$OODKPDGHWKHPFRQIURQWWKHLUHQHPLHV XQH[SHFWHGO,KDGWKHKRQRXURIEHLQJZLWK0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
128.
RQWKHQLJKWRIC$TDEDK ZKHQZHSOHGJHGRXUDOOHJLDQFHWR,VODPDQGLWZDVGHDUHUWRPHWKDQSDUWLFLSDWLQJLQWKHEDWWOHRI %DGUDOWKRXJK%DGUZDVPRUHZHOONQRZQDPRQJWKHSHRSOHWKDQWKDW$QGWKLVLVWKHDFFRXQWRIP VWDLQJEHKLQGIURPWKHEDWWOHRI7DEXN,QHYHUKDGEHWWHUPHDQVDQGPRUHIDYRXUDEOHFLUFXPVWDQFHV WKDQDWWKHWLPHRIWKLVH[SHGLWLRQ$QGE$OODK,KDGQHYHUEHIRUHSRVVHVVHGWZRULGLQJFDPHOVDV, GLGGXULQJWKHWLPHRIWKLVH[SHGLWLRQ:KHQHYHU0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
129.
GHFLGHGWRJRRQD FDPSDLJQKHZRXOGQRWGLVFORVHKLVUHDOGHVWLQDWLRQWLOOWKHODVWPRPHQWRIGHSDUWXUH
130.
%XWRQWKLV
131.
H[SHGLWLRQKHVHWRXWLQH[WUHPHOKRWZHDWKHUWKHMRXUQHZDVORQJDQGWKHWHUUDLQZDVZDWHUOHVV GHVHUWDQGKHKDGWRIDFHDVWURQJDUPVRKHLQIRUPHGWKH0XVOLPVDERXWWKHDFWXDOSRVLWLRQVRWKDW WKHVKRXOGPDNHIXOOSUHSDUDWLRQIRUWKHFDPSDLJQ$QGWKH0XVOLPVZKRDFFRPSDQLHG0HVVHQJHURI $OODK3%8+
132.
DWWKDWWLPHZHUHLQODUJHQXPEHUEXWQRSURSHUUHFRUGRIWKHPZDVPDLQWDLQHG .DCE IXUWKHU
133.
VDLG)HZZHUHWKHSHUVRQVZKRFKRVHWRUHPDLQDEVHQWEHOLHYLQJWKDWWKHFRXOGHDVLOKLGH WKHPVHOYHVDQGWKXVUHPDLQXQGHWHFWHG
134.
XQOHVV5HYHODWLRQIURP$OODKWKH([DOWHGDQG*ORULRXV UHYHDOHGUHODWLQJWRWKHP
135.
$QG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
136.
VHWRXWRQWKLVH[SHGLWLRQZKHQWKHIUXLW ZHUHULSHDQGWKHLUVKDGHZDVVRXJKW,KDGDZHDNQHVVIRUWKHPDQGLWZDVGXULQJWKLVVHDVRQWKDW 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
137.
DQGWKH0XVOLPVPDGHSUHSDUDWLRQV,DOVRZRXOGVHWRXWLQWKHPRUQLQJWR PDNHSUHSDUDWLRQVDORQJZLWKWKHPEXWZRXOGFRPHEDFNKDYLQJGRQHQRWKLQJDQGVDLGWRPVHOI , KDYHPHDQVHQRXJKWRPDNHSUHSDUDWLRQV
138.
DVVRRQDV,OLNH $QG,ZHQWRQGRLQJWKLVSRVWSRQLQJP SUHSDUDWLRQV
139.
WLOOWKHWLPHRIGHSDUWXUHFDPHDQGLWZDVLQWKHPRUQLQJWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
140.
VHWRXWDORQJZLWKWKH0XVOLPVEXW,KDGPDGHQRSUHSDUDWLRQV,ZRXOGJRHDUOLQWKHPRUQLQJDQG FRPHEDFNEXWZLWKQRGHFLVLRQ,ZHQWRQGRLQJVRXQWLOWKHWKH0XVOLPV
141.
KDVWHQHGDQGFRYHUHGD JRRGGHDORIGLVWDQFH7KHQ,ZLVKHGWRPDUFKRQDQGMRLQWKHP:RXOGWKDW,KDGGRQHWKDW%XW SHUKDSVLWZDVQRWGHVWLQHGIRUPH$IWHUWKHGHSDUWXUHRI0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
142.
ZKHQHYHU, ZHQWRXW,ZDVJULHYHGWRILQGQRJRRGH[DPSOHWRIROORZEXWFRQILUPHGKSRFULWHVRUZHDNSHRSOH ZKRP$OODKKDGH[HPSWHGIURPPDUFKLQJIRUWKIRU-LKDG
143.
0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
144.
PDGHQR PHQWLRQRIPHXQWLOKHUHDFKHG7DEXN:KLOHKHZDVVLWWLQJZLWKWKHSHRSOHLQ7DEXNKHVDLG C:KDW KDSSHQHGWR.DCEELQ0DOLN $SHUVRQIURP%DQX6DOLPDKVDLG20HVVHQJHURI$OODKWKHEHDXW
145.
RIKLVFORDNDQGDQDSSUHFLDWLRQRI KLVILQHUKDYHGHWDLQHGKLP 8SRQWKLV0XCDGKELQ-DEDO 0DW$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
146.
DGPRQLVKHGKLPDQGVDLGWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
147.
%$OODK ZHNQRZQRWKLQJDERXWKLPEXWJRRG 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
148.
KRZHYHUNHSWTXLHW$WWKDWWLPH KHWKH3URSKHW3%8+
149.
150.
VDZDSHUVRQGUHVVHGLQZKLWHDQGVDLG C%H$EX.KDLWKDPDK $QGZDV$EX .KDLWKDPDK$O$QVDULZDVWKHSHUVRQZKRKDGFRQWULEXWHGD6DCRIGDWHVDQGZDVULGLFXOHGEWKH KSRFULWHV .DCEELQ0DOLNIXUWKHUVDLG:KHQWKHQHZVUHDFKHGPHWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
151.
ZDVRQKLVZDEDFNIURP7DEXN,ZDVJUHDWOGLVWUHVVHG,WKRXJKWRIIDEULFDWLQJDQH[FXVHDQGDVNHG PVHOIKRZ,ZRXOGVDYHPVHOIIURPKLVDQJHUWKHQH[WGD,QWKLVFRQQHFWLRQ,VRXJKWWKHFRXQVHOV RIHYHUSUXGHQWPHPEHURIPIDPLO:KHQ,ZDVWROGWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
152.
ZDVDERXWWR DUULYHDOOWKHZLFNHGLGHDVYDQLVKHGIURPPPLQG
153.
DQG,FDPHWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQWKDWQRWKLQJEXWWKH WUXWKFRXOGVDYHPH6R,GHFLGHGWRWHOOKLPWKHWUXWK,WZDVLQWKHPRUQLQJWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK 3%8+
154.
DUULYHGLQ$O0DGLQDK,WZDVKLVKDELWWKDWZKHQHYHUKHFDPHEDFNIURPDMRXUQHKHZRXOG ILUVWJRWRWKHPRVTXHDQGSHUIRUPWZR5DNCDKRIRSWLRQDO SUDHU
155.
DQGZRXOGWKHQVLWZLWKWKHSHRSOH :KHQKHVDWWKRVHZKRKDGUHPDLQHGEHKLQGKLPEHJDQWRSXWIRUZDUGWKHLUH[FXVHVDQGWDNHDQRDWK EHIRUHKLP7KHZHUHPRUHWKDQHLJKWLQQXPEHU0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
156.
DFFHSWHGWKHLU H[FXVHVRQWKHYHUIDFHRIWKHPDQGDFFHSWHGWKHLUDOOHJLDQFHDQGVRXJKWIRUJLYHQHVVIRUWKHPDQGOHIW WKHLULQVLJKWVWR$OODKXQWLO,DSSHDUHGEHIRUHKLP,JUHHWHGKLPDQGKHVPLOHGDQGWKHUHZDVDWLQJHRI DQJHULQWKDW+HWKHQVDLGWRPH RPHIRUZDUG ,ZHQWIRUZDUGDQG,VDWLQIURQWRIKLP+HVDLGWR PH
C:KDWNHSWRXEDFNRXOGRXQRWDIIRUGWRJRLQIRUDULGH ,VDLG 20HVVHQJHURI$OODKE $OODKLI,ZHUHWRVLWEHIRUHDQERGHOVHDPDQRIWKHZRUOG,ZRXOGKDYHGHILQLWHOVDYHGPVHOI IURPKLVDQJHU RQRQHSUHWH[WRUWKHRWKHUDQG,KDYHDJLIWHGVNLOOLQDUJXPHQWDWLRQEXWE$OODK,DP IXOODZDUHWKDWLI,ZHUHWRSXWIRUZDUGEHIRUHRXDODPHH[FXVHWRSOHDVHRX$OODKZRXOGGHILQLWHO SURYRNHRXUZUDWKXSRQPH,QFDVH,VSHDNWKHWUXWKRXPDEHDQJUZLWKPHEXW,KRSHWKDW $OODKZRXOGEHSOHDVHGZLWKPHDQGDFFHSWPUHSHQWDQFH
157.
%$OODKWKHUHLVQRYDOLGH[FXVHIRUPH %$OODK,QHYHUSRVVHVVHGVRJRRGPHDQVDQG,QHYHUKDGVXFKIDYRXUDEOHFRQGLWLRQVIRUPHDV,KDG ZKHQ,VWDHGEHKLQG 7KHUHXSRQ0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
158.
VDLG 7KLVPDQVSRNHWKHWUXWKVRJHW XSDQGZDLW
159.
XQWLO$OODKJLYHVDGHFLVLRQDERXWRX ,OHIWDQGVRPHSHRSOHRI %DQX6DOLPDKIROORZHG PH7KHVDLGWRPHC%$OODKZHGRQRWNQRZWKDWRXFRPPLWWHGDVLQEHIRUHRXKRZHYHU VKRZHGLQDELOLWWRSXWIRUZDUGDQH[FXVHEHIRUH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
160.
OLNHWKRVHZKRVWDHG EHKLQGKLP,WZRXOGKDYHEHHQHQRXJKIRUWKHIRUJLYHQHVVRIRXUVLQWKDW0HVVHQJHURI$OODK 3%8+
161.
ZRXOGKDYHVRXJKWIRUJLYHQHVVIRURX %$OODKWKHNHSWRQUHSURDFKLQJPHXQWLO,WKRXJKW RIJRLQJEDFNWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
162.
DQGUHWUDFWPFRQIHVVLRQ7KHQ,VDLGWRWKHP +DV DQRQHHOVHPHWWKHVDPHIDWH 7KHVDLG HVWZRSHUVRQVKDYHPHWWKHVDPHIDWH7KHPDGH WKH VDPHVWDWHPHQWDVRXGLGDQGWKHVDPHYHUGLFWZDVGHOLYHUHGLQWKHLUFDVH ,DVNHGC:KRDUHWKH 7KHVDLG 0XUDUDKELQ$U5DELC$OC$PULDQG+LODOELQ8PDLDK$O:DTLIL 7KHPHQWLRQHGWKHVH WZRSLRXVPHQZKRKDGWDNHQSDUWLQWKHEDWWOHRI%DGUDQGWKHUHZDVDQH[DPSOHIRUPHLQWKHP,ZDV FRQILUPHGLQPRULJLQDOUHVROYH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
163.
SURKLELWHGWKH0XVOLPVWRWDONWRWKH WKUHHRIXVIURPDPRQJVWWKRVHZKRKDGVWDHGEHKLQG7KHSHRSOHEHJDQWRDYRLGXVDQGWKHLUDWWLWXGH WRZDUGVXVFKDQJHGDQGLWVHHPHGDVLIWKHZKROHDWPRVSKHUHKDGWXUQHGDJDLQVWXVDQGLWZDVLQIDFW WKHVDPHDWPRVSKHUHRIZKLFK,ZDVIXOODZDUHDQGLQZKLFK,KDGOLYHGIRUDIDLUOORQJWLPH
164.
:H
165.
VSHQWILIWQLJKWVLQWKLVYHUVWDWHDQGPWZRIULHQGVFRQILQHGWKHPVHOYHVZLWKLQWKHLUKRXVHVDQG VSHQWPRVWRIWKHLU
166.
WLPHZHHSLQJ$V,ZDVWKHRXQJHVWDQGWKHVWURQJHVW,ZRXOGOHDYHPKRXVH DWWHQGWKHFRQJUHJDWLRQDO6DODWPRYHDERXWLQWKHED]DDUVEXWQRQHZRXOGVSHDNWRPH,ZRXOGFRPH WR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
167.
DVKHVDWDPRQJVWSHRSOH
168.
DIWHUWKH6DODWJUHHWKLPDQGZRXOGDVN PVHOIZKHWKHURUQRWKLVOLSVPRYHGLQUHVSRQVHWRPJUHHWLQJV7KHQ,ZRXOGSHUIRUP6DODWQHDUKLP DQGORRNDWKLPVWHDOWKLO:KHQ,ILQLVKP6DODWKHZRXOGORRNDW PHDQGZKHQ,ZRXOGFDVWDJODQFH DWKLPKHZRXOGWXUQDZDKLVHHVIURPPH:KHQWKHKDUVKWUHDWPHQWRIWKH0XVOLPVWRPH FRQWLQXHGIRUDFRQVLGHUDEOH
169.
OHQJWKRIWLPH,ZDONHGDQG,FOLPEHGXSRQWKHZDOORIWKHJDUGHQRI $EX4DWDGDKZKRZDVPFRXVLQDQG,KDGDJUHDWORYHIRUKLP,JUHHWHGKLPEXWE$OODKKHGLG QRWDQVZHUWRPJUHHWLQJ,VDLGWRKLPC2$EX4DWDGDK,DGMXUHRXLQWKH1DPHRI$OODKDUHRX QRWDZDUHWKDW,ORYH$OODKDQG+LV0HVVHQJHU3%8+
170.
,DVNHGKLPWKHVDPHTXHVWLRQDJDLQEXWKH UHPDLQHGVLOHQW,DJDLQDGMXUHGKLPZKHUHXSRQKHVDLGC$OODKDQG+LV0HVVHQJHU3%8+
171.
NQRZ EHWWHU 0HHVZHUHILOOHGZLWKWHDUVDQG,FDPHEDFNFOLPELQJGRZQWKHZDOO $V,ZDVZDONLQJLQWKHED]DDUVRI$O0DGLQDKDPDQIURPWKH6ULDQSHDVDQWVZKRKDGFRPHWRVHOO IRRGJUDLQVLQ$O0DGLQDKDVNHGSHRSOHWRGLUHFWKLPWR.DCEELQ0DOLN3HRSOHSRLQWHGWRZDUGVPH +HFDPHWRPHDQGGHOLYHUHGDOHWWHUIURPWKH.LQJRI*KDVVDQDQGDV,ZDVDVFULEH,UHDGWKDWOHWWHU ZKRVHSXUSRUWZDV C,WKDVEHHQFRQYHHGWRXVWKDWRXUIULHQGWKH3URSKHW3%8+
172.
173.
ZDVWUHDWLQJRX KDUVKO$OODKKDVQRWFUHDWHGRXIRUDSODFHZKHUHRXDUHWREHGHJUDGHGDQGZKHUHRXFDQQRWILQG RXUULJKWSODFHVRFRPHWRXVDQGZHVKDOOUHFHLYHRXJUDFLRXVO $V,UHDGWKDWOHWWHU,VDLG 7KLVLV WRRDWULDO VR,SXWLWWRILUHLQDQRYHQ:KHQIRUWGDVKDGHODSVHGDQG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
174.
UHFHLYHGQR5HYHODWLRQWKHUHFDPHWRPHDPHVVHQJHURIWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKDQGVDLGC9HULO 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
175.
KDVFRPPDQGHGRXWRNHHSDZDIURPRXUZLIH ,VDLGC6KRXOG, GLYRUFHKHURUZKDWHOVHVKRXOG,GR +HVDLGC1REXWRQONHHSDZDIURPKHUDQGGRQ WKDYHVH[XDO FRQWDFWZLWKKHU 7KHVDPHPHVVDJHZDVVHQWWRPFRPSDQLRQV6R,VDLGWR PZLIH RXEHWWHUJR WRRXUSDUHQWVDQGVWDWKHUHZLWKWKHPXQWLO$OODKJLYHVWKHGHFLVLRQLQPFDVH 7KHZLIHRI+LODO ELQ8PDLDKFDPHWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
176.
DQGVDLG 20HVVHQJHURI$OODK+LODOELQ 8PDLDKLVDVHQLOHSHUVRQDQGKDVQR VHUYDQW'RRXGLVDSSURYHLI,VHUYHKLP +HVDLG C1REXW GRQ WOHWKLPKDYHDQVH[XDOFRQWDFWZLWKRX 6KHVDLG %$OODKKHKDVQRVXFKGHVLUHOHIWLQKLP %$OODKKHKDVEHHQLQWHDUVVLQFHWKLVFDODPLW
177.
VWUXFNKLP 0HPEHUVRIPIDPLOVDLGWRPH CRXVKRXOGKDYHVRXJKWSHUPLVVLRQIURP0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
178.
LQUHJDUGWRRXUZLIH+HKDV DOORZHGWKHZLIHRI+LODOELQ8PDLDKWRVHUYHKLP ,VDLG ,ZRXOGQRWVHHNSHUPLVVLRQIURP 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
179.
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
180.
UHOLHIIRUPH 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
181.
KDGLQIRUPHGWKHSHRSOHDERXWWKHDFFHSWDQFHRIRXUUHSHQWDQFHE$OODK DIWHUKH KDGRIIHUHGWKH)DMUSUDHU6RWKHSHRSOHZHQWRQWRJLYHXVJODGWLGLQJVDQGVRPHRIWKHP ZHQWWRPFRPSDQLRQVLQRUGHUWRJLYHWKHPWKHJODGWLGLQJV$PDQVSXUUHGKLVKRUVHWRZDUGVPHWR JLYHWKHJRRGQHZV
182.
DQGDQRWKHURQHIURPWKHWULEHRI$VODPFDPHUXQQLQJIRUWKHVDPHSXUSRVHDQG DVKHDSSURDFKHGWKHPRXQW,UHFHLYHGWKHJRRGQHZVZKLFKUHDFKHGPHEHIRUHWKHULGHUGLG:KHQWKH RQHZKRVHYRLFH,KDGKHDUGFDPHWRPHWRFRQJUDWXODWHPH,WRRNRIIPJDUPHQWVDQGJDYHWKHPWR KLPIRUWKHJRRGQHZVKHEURXJKWWRPH%$OODK,SRVVHVVHGQRWKLQJHOVHLQWKHIRUPRIFORWKHV
183.
H[FHSWWKHVHJDUPHQWVDWWKDWWLPH7KHQ,ERUURZHGWZRJDUPHQWVGUHVVHGPVHOIDQGFDPHWR 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
184.
2QPZD,PHWJURXSVRISHRSOHZKRJUHHWHGPHIRUWKHDFFHSWDQFH RI
185.
UHSHQWDQFHDQGWKHVDLG RQJUDWXODWLRQVIRUDFFHSWDQFHRIRXUUHSHQWDQFH ,UHDFKHGWKHPRVTXH ZKHUH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
186.
ZDVVLWWLQJDPLGVWSHRSOH7DOKDKELQC8EDLGXOODKJRWXSDQG UXVKHGWRZDUGVPHVKRRNKDQGVZLWKPHDQGJUHHWHGPH%$OODKQRSHUVRQVWRRGXSWRJUHHWPH
187.
IURPDPRQJVWWKH0XKDMLUXQEHVLGHVKLP .DCEVDLGWKDWKHQHYHUIRUJRWWKLVJRRGJHVWXUHRI
188.
7DOKDK .DCEIXUWKHUVDLG,JUHHWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
189.
ZLWKC$VVDODPXCDODLNXP DQGKLVIDFHZDV EHDPLQJZLWKSOHDVXUH+H3%8+
190.
VDLG C5HMRLFHZLWKWKHEHVWGDRXKDYHHYHUVHHQVLQFHRXU PRWKHUJDYHRXELUWK ,VDLGC20HVVHQJHURI$OODK,VWKLVJRRGQHZV
191.
IURPRXRUIURP$OODK +H VDLG C1RLWLVIURP$OODK $QGLWZDVFRPPRQZLWK0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
192.
WKDWZKHQHYHUKH ZDVKDSSKLVIDFHZRXOGJORZDVLILWZHUHDSDUWRIWKHPRRQDQGLWZDVIURPWKLVWKDWZHUHFRJQL]HG LWKLVGHOLJKW
193.
$V,VDWEHIRUHKLP,VDLG,KDYHSODFHGDFRQGLWLRQXSRQPVHOIWKDWLI$OODKDFFHSWV P7DXEDK,ZRXOGJLYHXSDOORIPSURSHUWLQFKDULWIRUWKHVDNHRI$OODKDQG+LV0HVVHQJHU 3%8+
194.
7KHUHXSRQ0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
195.
VDLG C.HHSVRPHSURSHUWZLWKRXDVLWLVEHWWHU
196.
IRURX ,VDLG ,VKDOONHHSZLWKPHWKDWSRUWLRQZKLFKLVLQ.KDLEDU ,DGGHG 20HVVHQJHURI$OODK 9HULO$OODKKDVJUDQWHGPHVDOYDWLRQEHFDXVHRIPWUXWKIXOQHVVDQGWKHUHIRUHUHSHQWDQFHREOLJHV PHWRVSHDNQRWKLQJEXWWKHWUXWKDVORQJDV,DPDOLYH .DCEDGGHG%$OODK,GRQRWNQRZDQRQH DPRQJWKH0XVOLPVZKRKDVEHHQJUDQWHGWUXWKIXOQHVVEHWWHUWKDQPHVLQFH,VDLGWKLVWRWKH3URSKHW 3%8+
197.
%$OODK6LQFHWKHWLPH,PDGHDSOHGJHRIWKLVWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
198.
,KDYHQHYHU LQWHQGHGWRWHOODOLHDQG,KRSHWKDW$OODKZRXOGSURWHFWPHDJDLQVWWHOOLQJOLHV
199.
IRUWKHUHVWRIPOLIH $OODKWKH([DOWHGWKH*ORULRXVUHYHDOHGWKHVH9HUVHV $OODKKDVIRUJLYHQWKH3URSKHW3%8+
200.
WKH0XKDMLUXQ0XVOLP(PLJUDQWVZKROHIWWKHLUKRPHVDQG FDPHWR$O0DGLQDK
201.
DQGWKH$QVDU0XVOLPVRI$O0DGLQDK
202.
ZKRIROORZHGKLP0XKDPPDG 3%8+
203.
204.
LQWKHWLPHRIGLVWUHVV7DEXNH[SHGLWLRQ
205.
DIWHUWKHKHDUWVRIDSDUWRIWKHPKDGQHDUO GHYLDWHGIURPWKH5LJKW3DWK
206.
EXW+HDFFHSWHGWKHLUUHSHQWDQFHHUWDLQO+HLVXQWRWKHPIXOORI NLQGQHVV0RVW0HUFLIXO$QG +HGLGIRUJLYHDOVR
207.
WKHWKUHHZKRGLGQRWMRLQWKH7DEXNH[SHGLWLRQ DQGZKRVHFDVHZDVGHIHUUHGEWKH3URSKHW3%8+
208.
209.
IRU$OODK V'HFLVLRQ@WLOOIRUWKHPWKHHDUWKYDVW DVLWLVZDVVWUDLWHQHGDQGWKHLURZQVHOYHVZHUHVWUDLWHQHGWRWKHPDQGWKHSHUFHLYHGWKDWWKHUHLVQR IOHHLQJIURP$OODKDQGQRUHIXJHEXWZLWK+LP7KHQ+HIRUJDYHWKHPDFFHSWHGWKHLUUHSHQWDQFH
210.
WKDWWKHPLJKWEHJIRU+LV3DUGRQUHSHQWXQWR+LP
211.
@9HULO$OODKLVWKH2QH:KRIRUJLYHVDQG DFFHSWVUHSHQWDQFH0RVW0HUFLIXO2RXZKREHOLHYH%HDIUDLGRI$OODKDQGEHZLWKWKRVHZKRDUH WUXHLQZRUGDQGGHHGV
212.
.DCEVDLG%$OODKVLQFH$OODKJXLGHGPHWR,VODPWKHUHKDVEHHQQREOHVVLQJPRUHVLJQLILFDQWIRU PHWKDQWKLVWUXWKRIPLQHZKLFK,VSRNHWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
213.
DQGLI,ZHUHWRWHOODOLH, ZRXOGKDYHEHHQUXLQHGDVZHUHUXLQHGWKRVHZKRKDGWROGOLHVIRU$OODKGHVFULEHGWKRVHZKRWROGOLHV ZLWKWKHZRUVWGHVFULSWLRQ+HHYHUDWWULEXWHGWRDQERGHOVHDV+HVHQWGRZQWKH5HYHODWLRQ 7KHZLOOVZHDUE$OODKWRRX0XVOLPV
214.
ZKHQRXUHWXUQWRWKHPWKDWRXPDWXUQDZDIURP WKHP6RWXUQDZDIURPWKHP6XUHOWKHDUH5LMVXQLH1DMDVXQLPSXUH
215.
EHFDXVHRIWKHLUHYLO GHHGV@DQG+HOOLVWKHLUGZHOOLQJSODFH DUHFRPSHQVHIRUWKDWZKLFKWKHXVHGWRHDUQ7KHWKH KSRFULWHV
216.
VZHDUWRRX0XVOLPV
217.
WKDWRXPDEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHPEXWLIRXDUHSOHDVHGZLWK WKHPFHUWDLQO$OODKLVQRWSOHDVHGZLWKWKHSHRSOHZKRDUH$O)D VLTXQUHEHOOLRXVGLVREHGLHQWWR $OODK
218.
.DCEIXUWKHUDGGHG7KHPDWWHURIWKHWKUHHRIXVUHPDLQHGSHQGLQJIRUGHFLVLRQDSDUWIURPWKHFDVH RIWKRVHZKRKDGPDGHH[FXVHVRQRDWKEHIRUH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
219.
DQGKHDFFHSWHGWKRVH WRRNIUHVKRDWKVRIDOOHJLDQFHIURPWKHPDQGVXSSOLFDWHGIRUWKHLUIRUJLYHQHVV7KH3URSKHW3%8+
220.
NHSWRXUPDWWHUSHQGLQJWLOO$OODKGHFLGHGLW 7KHWKUHHZKRVHPDWWHUZDVGHIHUUHGKDYHEHHQVKRZQ PHUF 7KHUHIHUHQFHKHUHLVQRWWRRXUVWDLQJEDFNIURPWKHH[SHGLWLRQEXWWRKLVGHODLQJRXUPDWWHU DQGNHHSLQJLWSHQGLQJEHRQGWKHPDWWHURIWKRVHZKRPDGHWKHLUH[FXVHVRQRDWKZKLFKKHDFFHSWHG $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@
$QRWKHUYHUVLRQDGGV0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
221.
VHWRXWIRU7DEXNRQ7KXUVGD+HXVHGWRSUHIHU WRVHWRXWRQMRXUQHRQ7KXUVGD $QRWKHUYHUVLRQVDV0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
222.
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
223.
2QHPXVWIDFHZLWKIRUEHDUDQFHWKHGLIILFXOWLHVZKLFKFRPHLQWKHZDRI'HHQ ,WLVQRWSUDLVHZRUWKWKDWRQHJLYHVLQFKDULWDOOWKHSURSHUWKHKDV2QHPXVWNHHSZKDWLVQHHGHG IRUWKHODZIXOQHHGV ,WLVODZIXOWRJLYHVRPHWKLQJEZDRIJLIWDQGUHZDUGWRDSHUVRQZKRFRQJUDWXODWHVLQWKHHYHQWV RIKDSSLQHVV 7KHDELOLWWRVHHNSDUGRQLVDJLIWIURP$OODKIRUZKLFKRQHPXVWH[SUHVVJUDWLWXGHWR+LP $QSURPLVHWKDWRQHPDNHVPXVWEHNHSWHWFHWF ,PUDQELQ$O+XVDLQ$O.KX]DCL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
224.
UHSRUWHG$ZRPDQIURPWKH WULEH-XKDLQDKFDPHWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
225.
ZKLOHVKHZDVSUHJQDQWIURP=LQD
226.
DGXOWHUDQG VDLGWRKLP20HVVHQJHURI$OODK,KDYHFRPPLWWHGDQRIIHQVHOLDEOHWR+DGGSUHVFULEHG SXQLVKPHQW
227.
VRH[DFWWKHH[HFXWLRQRIWKHVHQWHQFH 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
228.
FDOOHGKHUJXDUGLDQ DQGVDLGWRKLP 7UHDWKHUNLQGO%ULQJKHUWRPHDIWHUWKHGHOLYHURIWKHFKLOG 7KDWPDQFRPSOLHG ZLWKWKHRUGHUV$WODVWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
229.
FRPPDQGHGWRFDUURXWWKHVHQWHQFH+HUFORWKHVZHUH VHFXUHGDURXQGKHUDQGVKHZDVVWRQHGWRGHDWK7KH3URSKHW3%8+
230.
OHGKHUIXQHUDOSUDHUVC8PDU VXEPLWWHG20HVVHQJHURI$OODK6KHFRPPLWWHG=LQDDQGRXKDYHSHUIRUPHGIXQHUDOSUDHUIRU KHU +HUHSOLHG 9HULOVKHPDGHUHSHQWDQFHZKLFKZRXOGVXIILFHIRUVHYHQWRIWKHSHRSOHRI$O 0DGLQDKLILWLVGLYLGHGDPRQJWKHPDQWKHUHEHDQKLJKHUGHJUHHRI UHSHQWDQFHWKDQWKDWVKH VDFULILFHGKHUOLIHYROXQWDULOWRZLQWKH3OHDVXUHRI$OODKWKH([DOWHG 0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU
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
231.
UHSRUWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK 3%8+
232.
VDLG ,IDVRQRI$GDPZHUHWRRZQDYDOOHIXOORIJROGKHZRXOGGHVLUHWRKDYHWZR 1RWKLQJFDQILOOKLVPRXWKH[FHSWWKHHDUWKRIWKHJUDYH
233.
$OODKWXUQVZLWKPHUFWRKLPZKRWXUQVWR +LPLQUHSHQWDQFH $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU 7KLV+DGLWKGHDOVZLWKPDQ VJUHHGDQGKLVOXVWIRUPDWHULDOZHDOWK2QOWKHSHUVRQ ZKRKDVDSHUIHFW)DLWKFDQVDYHKLPVHOIIURPLW $EX
+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
234.
UHSRUWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
235.
VDLG $OODK WKH([DOWHGVPLOHVDWWZRPHQRQHRIWKHPNLOOHGWKHRWKHUDQGERWKZLOOHQWHU-DQQDK7KHILUVWLV NLOOHGEWKHRWKHUZKLOHKHLVILJKWLQJLQWKHDXVHRI$OODKDQGWKHUHDIWHU$OODKZLOOWXUQLQPHUFWR WKHVHFRQGDQGJXLGHKLPWRDFFHSW,VODPDQGWKHQKHGLHVDVD6KDKHHGPDUWU
236.
ILJKWLQJLQWKHDXVH RI$OODK $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@
237.
RPPHQWDU (YHQWKHJUHDWHVWVLQVLQFOXGLQJWKRVHZKLFKRQHKDVFRPPLWWHGEHIRUHHPEUDFLQJ ,VODPDUHIRUJLYHQEUHSHQWDQFH 6PLOLQJLVDOVRRQHRIWKH$WWULEXWHVRI$OODKDOWKRXJKZHDUHXQDZDUHRIWKHQDWXUHRILW
+$37(5 3$7,(1($1'3(56(9(5$1( $OODKWKH([DOWHGVDV 2RXZKREHOLHYH(QGXUHDQGEHPRUHS DWLHQW
238.
$QGFHUWDLQO:HVKDOOWHVWRXZLWKVRPHWKLQJRIIHDUKXQJHUORVVRIZHDOWKOLYHVDQGIUXLWV EXWJLYHJODGWLGLQJVWR$V6DELUXQWKHSDWLHQW
239.
2QOWKRVHZKRDUHSDWLHQWVKDOOUHFHLYHWKHLUUHZDUGLQIXOOZLWKRXWUH
FNRQLQJ
240.
$QGYHULOZKRVRHYHUVKRZVSDWLHQFHDQGIRUJLYHVWKDWZRXOGWUXOEHIURPWKHWKLQJV UHFRPPHQGHGE$OODK
241.
6HHNKHOSLQSDWLHQFHDQG$V
6DODWWKHSUDHU
242.
7UXO$OODKLVZLWK$V
6DELUXQWKHSDWLHQW
243.
$QGVXUHO:HVKDOOWURXWLOO:HWHVWWKRVHZKRVWULYHKDUGIRUWKHDXVHRI$OODK
244.
DQG$V
6DELUXQWKHSDWLHQW
245.
7KHUHDUHQXPHURXV9HUVHVRIWKH1REOH4XU DQLQFXOFDWLQJSDWLHQFHDQGH[WROOLQJLW $EX0DOLN$O+DULWKELQ$VLP$O$VKCDU0D $OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
246.
UHSRUWHGWKDW7KH 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
247.
VDLG :XGX LVKDOIRI6DODKWKHXWWHUDQFHRI $OKDPGXOLOODK
DOO SUDLVHEHORQJVWR$OODK
248.
ILOOVWKH6FDOHVRIJRRGDFWLRQVWKHXWWHUDQFHRI6XEKDQ$OODKZD$OKDPGX OLOODK
249.
$OODKLVIDUUHPRYHGIURPHYHULPSHUIHFWLRQDQGDOOSUDLVHEHORQJVWR$OODK
250.
ILOOVWKHVSDFH EHWZHHQWKHKHDYHQVDQGWKHHDUWKDQG6DODWSUDHU
251.
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
252.
2QHVKRXOGQRWOHDYHRQHVHOILGOHEXWNHHSLWEXV EXVLQVRPHQREOHZRUNRWKHUZLVHLWZRXOG WHQGWRHYLOZKLFKZLOOHYHQWXDOOUXLQKLP 2QHVKRXOGVSHQGWKLVWUDQVLWRUHDUWKOOLIHLQWKHREHGLHQFHRI$OODK $EX6D LG$O.KXGUL0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
253.
UHSRUWHGWKDWHUWDLQSHRSOHRIWKH$QVDU DVNHGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
254.
DQGKHJDYHWKHPWKHQWKHDJDLQDVNHGKLPDQGKHJDYHWKHP XQWLODOOZKDWKHSRVVHVVHGZDVH[KDXVWHG7KHQWKH3URSKHW3%8+
255.
VDLG :KDWHYHUZHDOWK,KDYH, ZLOOQRWZLWKKROGIURPRX:KRVRHYHUZRXOGEHFKDVWHDQGPRGHVW$OODKZLOONHHSKLPFKDVWHDQG PRGHVWDQGZKRVRHYHUZRXOGVHHNVHOIVXIILFLHQF$OODKZLOOPDNHKLPVHOIVXIILFLHQWDQGZKRVRHYHU ZRXOGEHSDWLHQW$OODKZLOOJLYHKLPSDWLHQFHDQGQRRQHLVJUDQWHGDJLIWEHWWHUDQGPRUH FRPSUHKHQVLYHWKDQSDWLHQFH $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU %HVLGHVGHVFULELQJJHQHURVLWNLQGQHVVPXQLILFHQFHDQGQRELOLWRIWKH3URSKHW 3%8+
256.
KHKDVEHHQRUGDLQHGE$OODKWRDGRSWSDWLHQFHFRQWHQWPHQWDQGVHOIUHVSHFWDQGWRDYRLG DQRQH VIDYRXU $EXDKD6XKDLEELQ6LQDQ0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
257.
UHSRUWHGWKDW7KH0HVVHQJHURI $OODK3%8+
258.
VDLG +RZZRQGHUIXOLVWKHFDVHRIDEHOLHYHUWKHUHLVJRRGIRUKLPLQHYHUWKLQJDQG WKLVDSSOLHVRQOWRDEHOLHYHU,ISURVSHULWDWWHQGVKLPKHH[SUHVVHVJUDWLWXGHWR$OODKDQGWKDWLV JRRGIRUKLPDQGLIDGYHUVLWEHIDOOVKLPKHHQGXUHVLWSDWLHQWODQGWKDWLVEHWWHUIRUKLP 0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU $0XVOLPLVUHTXLUHGWREHKDYHLQSRYHUWDQGSURVSHULWDIIOXHQFHDQGKDUGVKLSLQ WKHPDQQHUVWDWHGLQWKLV+DGLWK,WPHDQVWKDWWRIRUJHW$OODKLQSURVSHULW
UDWKHUWKDQEHLQJWKDQNIXO WR+LPIRU+LV)DYRXULVGHILDQFHRI+LV2UGHUV6LPLODUOLWLVXQEHFRPLQJRID0XVOLPWKDWLQ WURXEOHVDQGWXUPRLOUDWKHUEHLQJSDWLHQWKHWHQGVWRZHHSLQJDQGFULQJJURXVLQJDQGJULHYLQJ DJDLQVWWKH:LOORI$OODK $QDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
259.
UHSRUWHG:KHQWKHODVWLOOQHVVRI0HVVHQJHURI$OODK 3%8+
260.
PDGHKLPXQFRQVFLRXV)DWLPDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKHU
261.
H[FODLPHG$KWKHGLVWUHVV RIPGHDUIDWKHU +H3%8+
262.
VDLG 7KHUHZLOOEHQRGLVWUHVVIRURXUIDWKHUDIWHUWRGD:KHQKH GLHGVKHVDLG0IDWKHU$OODKKDVFDOOHGRXEDFNDQGRXKDYHUHVSRQGHGWR+LVDOO2IDWKHU *DUGHQRI)LUGDXVLVRXUDERGH2IDWKHU:HDQQRXQFHWR-LEULORXUGHDWK :KHQKHZDVEXULHGVKH VDLG$UHRXVDWLVILHGQRZWKDWRXSXWHDUWKRYHUWKHJUDYHRI
263.
0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
264.
$O%XNKDUL@ RPPHQWDU 7KLV+DGLWKVKRZVWKDWLWLVSHUPLVVLEOHWRH[SUHVVWKHWURXEOHDQGUHVWOHVVQHVVZKLFK RQHIHHOVDWWKHWLPHRIGHDWK6LPLODUOH[SUHVVLRQRISDLQDQG JULHILQDQDWXUDOZDLQWKHHYHQWRI VRPHRQH VGHDWKLVDOVRSHUPLVVLEOH7RUHPHPEHUWKHYLUWXHVRIWKHGHFHDVHGLVDOVRSHUPLWWHGEXWLWLV WREHIUHHIURPZDLOLQJDQGPRDQLQJODPHQWDWLRQDQGFULQJDQGWHDULQJRIIFORWKHVHWF7KHODVW ZRUGVRI)DWLPDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKHU
265.
DUHDOVRDZDRIH[SUHVVLQJJULHI DQGVDGQHVVDQG QRWDFULWLFLVPRQWKHEXULDORIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
266.
EHFDXVHVXFKFULWLFLVPLVSURKLELWHGE6KDULCDK DQGQRRQHLVH[HPSWHGIURPLW 8VDPDKELQ=DLG0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
267.
QDUUDWHG7KHGDXJKWHURIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
268.
VHQWIRUKLPDVKHUFKLOGZDVGLQJEXWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
269.
UHWXUQHGWKHPHVVHQJHUDQGVHQWKHUJRRG ZLVKHVVDLQJ :KDWHYHU$OODKWDNHVDZDRUJLYHVEHORQJVWR+LPDQGHYHUWKLQJZLWK+LPKDVD OLPLWHGIL[HGWHUPLQWKLVZRUOG
270.
DQGVRVKHVKRXOGEHSDWLHQWDQGDQWLFLSDWH$OODK VUHZDUG 6KH DJDLQVHQWIRUKLPDGMXULQJKLPIRUWKHVDNHRI$OODKWRFRPH7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKDFFRPSDQLHG ZLWK6DCGELQC8EDGDK0XCDGKELQ-DEDO8ED ELQ.DCE=DLGELQ7KDELWDQGVRPHRWKHUPHQZHQW WRVHHKHU7KHFKLOGZDVOLIWHGXSWRWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODKZKLOHKLVEUHDWKZDVGLVWXUEHGLQKLV FKHVW2QVHHLQJWKDWWKHHHVRIWKH3URSKHW3%8+
271.
VWUHDPHGZLWKWHDUV6DCGVDLG20HVVHQJHURI $OODK:KDWLVWKLV +HUHSOLHG ,WLVFRPSDVVLRQZKLFK$OODKKDVSODFHGLQWKHKHDUWVRI+LVVODYHV $OODKLVRPSDVVLRQDWHRQOWRWKRVHDPRQJ+LVVODYHVZKRDUHFRPSDVVLRQDWH WRRWKHUV
272.
$QRWKHUYHUVLRQVDV0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
273.
VDLG $OODKVKRZVFRPSDVVLRQRQOWRWKRVH DPRQJ+LVVODYHVZKRDUHFRPSDVVLRQDWH $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU *DWKHULQJRIDOOWKHUHODWLYHVLVQRWQHFHVVDUDWWKHWLPHRIVRPHRQH VGHDWK+RZHYHUWKHLU SDUWLFLSDWLRQLQWKHIXQHUDOSUDHULV0XVWDKDE)DUG.LIDDKDGHVLUDEOHFROOHFWLYHGXWXSRQDOO 0XVOLPVEXWZKLFKLVVXIILFLHQWRUHTXLYDOHQWWRDOOKDYLQJSHUIRUPHGLWLILWLVSHUIRUPHGERQO VRPHRIWKHP
274.
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
275.
UHSRUWHGWKDWWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
276.
VDLG 7KHUH OLYHGDNLQJEHIRUHRXDQGKHKDGDFRXUWPDJLFLDQ$VKHWKHPDJLFLDQ
277.
JUHZROGKHVDLGWRWKHNLQJ C,KDYHJURZQROGVRVHQGPHD RXQJERLQRUGHUWRWHDFKKLPPDJLF 7KHNLQJVHQWKLPDRXQJ ERWRVHUYHWKHSXUSRVH$QGRQKLVZDWRWKHPDJLFLDQ
278.
WKHRXQJERPHWDPRQNWRZKRPKH OLVWHQHGWRDQGOLNHGLW,WEHFDPHKLVKDELWWKDWRQKLVZDWRWKHPDJLFLDQKHZRXOGPHHWWKHPRQN DQGVLWWKHUHDQGZRXOGFRPHWRWKHPDJLFLDQODWH
279.
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
SODFHGLWLQWKHPLGGOHRIKLVKHDG DQGFXWKLPLQWRWZRSDUWVWKDWIHOOGRZQ7KHQWKHFRXUWLHURIWKHNLQJZDVEURXJKWIRUZDUGDQGLWZDV VDLGWRKLPC7XUQEDFNIURPRXUUHOLJLRQ +HWRRUHIXVHGDQGWKHVDZZDVSODFHGLQWKHPLGVWRIKLV KHDGDQGKHZDVWRUQLQWRWZRSDUWV7KHQWKHERZDVVHQWIRUDQGLWZDVVDLGWRKLPC7XUQEDFNIURP RXUUHOLJLRQ +HUHIXVHG7KHNLQJWKHQKDQGHGKLPRYHUWRDJURXSRIKLVFRXUWLHUVDQGVDLGWRWKHP C7DNHKLPWRVXFKDQGVXFKPRXQWDLQPDNHKLPFOLPEXSWKDWPRXQWDLQDQGZKHQRXUHDFKLWVSHDN DVNKLPWRUHQRXQFHKLV)DLWK,IKHUHIXVHVWRGRVRSXVKKLPWRKLVGHDWK 6RWKHWRRNKLPDQGPDGH KLPFOLPEXSWKHPRXQWDLQDQGKHVDLGC2$OODKVDYHPHIURPWKHPLQDQZDRXOLNH DQGWKH PRXQWDLQEHJDQ WRVKDNHDQGWKHDOOIHOOGRZQGHDG
280.
DQGWKDWRXQJERFDPHZDONLQJWRWKHNLQJ 7KHNLQJVDLGWRKLPC:KDWKDSSHQHGWRRXUFRPSDQLRQV +HVDLGC$OODKKDVVDYHGPHIURPWKHP
281.
+HDJDLQKDQGHGKLPWRVRPHRIKLVFRXUWLHUVDQGVDLGC7DNHKLPDQGFDUUKLPLQDERDWDQGZKHQ RXUHDFKWKHPLGGOHRIWKHVHDDVNKLPWRUHQRXQFHKLVUHOLJLRQ,IKHGRHVQRWUHQRXQFHKLVUHOLJLRQ WKURZKLPLQWRWKHZDWHU
282.
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
283.
UHOLJLRQ WKURZKLP LQWKHILUH RUCKHZRXOGEHRUGHUHGWRMXPSLQWRLW 7KHGLGVRWLOODZRPDQFDPHZLWKKHUFKLOG6KH IHOWKHVLWDQWLQMXPSLQJLQWRWKHILUH7KHFKLOGVDLGWRKHUC2PRWKHU(QGXUHWKLVRUGHDO
284.
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
285.
UHSRUWHG7KH3URSKHW3%8+
286.
SDVVHGEDZRPDQZKRZDV FULQJRYHUDJUDYHDQGVDLG )HDU$OODKDQGEHSDWLHQW 6KHVDLG$ZDIURPPH0FDODPLWKDV QRWEHIDOOHQRXDQGRXDUH
QRWDZDUHRILW 7KHZRPDQZDVODWHUWROGWKDWLWZDVWKH3URSKHW3%8+
287.
ZKRKDGDGYLVHGKHU
288.
6KHFDPHWRKLVGRRUZKHUHVKHIRXQGQRGRRUNHHSHU6KHVDLG,DPVRUU
289.
, GLGQRWNQRZRX 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
290.
VDLG 3DWLHQFHLVEHFRPLQJ
291.
RQODWWKHILUVWVWURNH
292.
RIJULHI $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ $QRWKHUQDUUDWLRQLQ0XVOLPVDV7KHZRPDQZDVFULQJRYHUKHUVRQ RPPHQWDU 7KLV+DGLWKLQGLFDWHVWKHH[FHOOHQFHRIWKH3URSKHW VFKDUDFWHU7KHZRPDQZKRPKH DGYLVHGWRKDYHSDWLHQFHGLGQRWEHKDYHSURSHUOEXWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
293.
ZDVQHLWKHUDQQRHGQRUGLG KHUHSURDFKKHU:KHQVKHDSSHDUHGEHIRUHKLPIRUWKHVHFRQGWLPHKHDJDLQUHSHDWHGKLVDGYLFHIRU SDWLHQFH7KLV+DGLWKKDVDJUHDWOHVVRQIRUWKRVHZKRFDOOSHRSOHWRWKH5LJKW3DWK2XUVFKRODUVDQG SUHDFKHUVVKRXOGIROORZWKLVH[FHOOHQWH[DPSOH $EX+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
294.
UHSRUWHG7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
295.
VDLG $OODKWKH([DOWHGVDV ,KDYHQRUHZDUGRWKHUWKDQ-DQQDKIRUDEHOLHYLQJVODYHRI0LQHZKR UHPDLQVSDWLHQWIRU0VDNHZKHQ,WDNHDZDKLVEHORYHGRQHIURPDPRQJWKHLQKDELWDQWVRIWKH ZRUOG $O%XNKDUL@
296.
RPPHQWDU KLOGZLIHDQGSDUHQWVHWFDUHWKHGHDUHVWSHRSOHWRHYHURQH,WLVDJUHDWVLJQRI )DLWKWRDFFHSWWKHLUGHDWKDVWKH:LOORI$OODKWREHDUWKHLUORVVZLWKSDWLHQFH:DLOLQJDQGVDLQJ QRQVHQVHWKLQJVVKRZZHDNQHVVRI )DLWK7KHUHZDUGRISDWLHQFHRQVXFKWUDJHGLHVLV-DQQDKZKLOHWKH UHVXOWRILPSDWLHQFHLVGLVSOHDVXUHRI$OODK
C$LVKDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKHU
297.
UHSRUWHG,DVNHGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
298.
DERXW SHVWLOHQFHDQGKHVDLG ,WLVDSXQLVKPHQWZKLFK$OODKVHQGVXSRQZKRPVRHYHU+HZLOOVEXW$OODKKDV PDGHLWDVDPHUFWRWKHEHOLHYHUV$QRQHZKRUHPDLQVLQDWRZQZKLFKLVSODJXHGZLWKSHVWLOHQFH PDLQWDLQLQJSDWLHQFHH[SHFWLQJWKHUHZDUGIURP$OODKDQGNQRZLQJWKDWQRWKLQJZLOOEHIDOOKLPRWKHU WKDQZKDW$OODKKDVIRUHRUGDLQHGIRUKLPKHZRXOGUHFHLYHDUHZDUGRI6KDKHHG $O%XNKDUL@ RPPHQWDU 7RHQGXUHSDWLHQWOLQDFLWZKHUHRQH
UHVLGHVZKHQLWLVDIIHFWHGESODJXHRUVXFK RWKHUHSLGHPLFVDQGQRWWRIOHHIURPLWHOHYDWHVD0XVOLPWRWKHOHYHORI6KDKDGDKLQWKHZDRI$OODK DVLVWKHFDVHLQFHUWDLQRWKHUFLUFXPVWDQFHVOLNHGHDWKEGURZQLQJRULQPDWHUQLWHWF7KLVRUGHULV EDVHGRQWKHFRQVLGHUDWLRQWKDWWKHHSLGHPLFVKRXOGQRWVSUHDGWRRWKHUFLWLHV2QWKHRWKHUKDQG UHVLGHQWVRIRWKHUFLWLHVDUHRUGHUHGWRUHIUDLQIURPYLVLWLQJWKHDIIHFWHGFLW7KH+DGLWKFOHDUOVKRZV WKDWLWGRHVQRWJRDJDLQVWIDLWKLQ$OODKWRWDNHVWHSVQHFHVVDUIRUSUHYHQWLRQDQGFXUH6LPLODUO SDWLHQFHLQWKHHYHQWRIVLFNQHVVLVDSURRIRIRQH VSHUIHFWIDLWKLQWKH:LOORI$OODK $QDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
299.
VDLG,KHDUGWKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
300.
VDLQJ $OODKWKH*ORULRXVDQG([DOWHGVDLGC:KHQ,DIIOLFWPVODYHLQKLVWZRGHDUWKLQJVLHKLVHHV
301.
DQGKHHQGXUHVSDWLHQWO,VKDOOFRPSHQVDWHKLPIRUWKHPZLWK-DQQDK $O%XNKDUL@ RPPHQWDU %OLQGQHVVLVWKHJUHDWHVWGHSULYDWLRQLQWKHZRUOGDQG$OODKJUDQWVLWVUHZDUGDFFRUGLQJ WR+LV3OHDVXUH)RUWKLVUHDVRQSDWLHQFHLQWKLVFDVHLVKLJKOPHULWRULRXV,WVUHZDUGLV-DQQDK SURYLGHGWKHEOLQGLVHQRUPRXVOULFKLQ)DLWK C$WD ELQ$EX5DEDKUHSRUWHG,EQC$EEDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
302.
DVNHGKLPZKHWKHUKH ZRXOGOLNHWKDWKHVKRXOGVKRZKLPDZRPDQZKRLVIURPWKHSHRSOH-DQQDK:KHQKHUHSOLHGWKDWKH FHUWDLQOZRXOGKHVDLG7KLVEODFNZRPDQZKRFDPHWRWKH3URSKHW3%8+
303.
DQGVDLGC,VXIIHUIURP HSLOHSVDQGGXULQJILWVPERGLVH[SRVHGVRPDNHVXSSOLFDWLRQWR$OODKIRUPH +H3%8+
304.
UHSOLHG ,IRXZLVKRXHQGXUHLWSDWLHQWODQGRXEHUHZDUGHGZLWK-DQQDKRULIRXZLVK,VKDOO PDNHVXSSOLFDWLRQWR$OODKWRFXUHRX 6KHVDLG ,VKDOOHQGXUHLW 7KHQVKHDGGHGC%XWPERGLV H[SRVHGVRSUDWR$OODKWKDWLWPDQRWKDSSHQ +H3URSKHW3%8+
305.
306.
WKHQVXSSOLFDWHGIRUKHU $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU :KLOHFRQWLQXLQJPHGLFDOWUHDWPHQWRQHVKRXOGQRWLJQRUHKLVSUDHUWR$OODKEHFDXVH ERWKKDYHLPSRUWDQFHDQGXWLOLWRIWKHLURZQ C$EGXOODKELQ0DVCXG0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
307.
UHSRUWHG,FDQVWLOOUHFDOODVLI,DPVHHLQJ WKH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
308.
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
309.
UHSRUWHGWKDWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
310.
VDLG 1HYHUDEHOLHYHULVVWULFNHQZLWKDGLVFRPIRUWDQLOOQHVVDQDQ[LHWDJULHIRUPHQWDOZRUURU HYHQWKHSULFNLQJRIDWKRUQEXW$OODKZLOOH[SLDWHKLVVLQVRQDFFRXQWRIKLVSDWLHQFH $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@
311.
RPPHQWDU 7KLV+DGLWKPHQWLRQVWKHVSHFLDO*UDFHDQG0HUFRI$OODKIRUWKH0XVOLPV,WUHODWHV KRZ$OODKWXUQVWKHKDUGVKLSVDQGWURXEOHVVXIIHUHGED0XVOLPLQWRDPHDQVRIH[SLDWLRQIRUKLVVLQV %XWWKLVLVRQOSRVVLEOHLIWKHEHOLHYHUH[HUFLVHVSDWLHQFH+RZHYHULIKHVWDUWVZDLOLQJLQVWHDGRI VKRZLQJSDWLHQFHWKHQEHVLGHVXIIHULQJKDUGVKLSVKHZRXOGEHGHSULYHGRIWKHUHZDUGZKLFKOLHVLQ EHDULQJWKHPSDWLHQWO7KXVKHVKDOOKDYHWRWDNHWKHEXUGHQRIDGGLWLRQDOVLQVDOVR ,EQ0DVCXG0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
312.
UHSRUWHG,YLVLWHGWKH3URSKHW3%8+
313.
ZKHQKHZDV VXIIHULQJIHYHU,VDLGRXVHHPWREHVXIIHULQJJUHDWO20HVVHQJHURI$OODK 7KH3URSKHW3%8+
314.
UHSOLHG HV,VXIIHUDVPXFKDVWZRSHUVRQV ,VDLG,VWKDWEHFDXVHRXKDYHDGRXEOHUHZDUG +H UHSOLHG
WKDWWKDWZDVVRDQGWKHQVDLG1R0XVOLPLVDIIOLFWHGEDKDUPEHLWWKHSULFNLQJRIDWKRUQRU VRPHWKLQJPRUHSDLQIXOWKDQWKDW
315.
EXW$OODKWKHUHEFDXVHVKLVVLQVWRIDOODZDMXVWDVDWUHHVKHGVLWV OHDYHV $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU 3URSKHWVKDYHWRIDFHPRUHWKDQRUGLQDUWURXEOHVDQGIRUWKDWUHDVRQWKHLUUHZDUGWR EHDUWKHPLVDOVRLQFUHDVHG7KXVWKHH[FHVVRIKDUGVKLSVDQGJULHILVDVLJQRISHUIHFW)DLWKDQGQRWD VLJQRI$OODK VGLVSOHDVXUH $EX+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
316.
UHSRUWHGWKDW7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
317.
VDLG +HZKRP$OODKLQWHQGVJRRG+HPDNHVKLPWRVXIIHUIURPVRPHDIIOLFWLRQ $O%XNKDUL@ RPPHQWDU 7URXEOHVRIWKLVZRUOGOLNHJULHIFDODPLWGLVHDVHSRYHUWORVVRIOLIHDQGSURSHUW HWFKDYHDEHQLJQDVSHFWIRUD0XVOLPLQWKHVHQVHWKDWRQDFFRXQWRIWKHPKHWXUQVWRZDUGV$OODKDQG EHJVPHUFDQGFRPSDVVLRQIURP+LPEHFDXVHRIZKLFKKLVVLQVDUHIRUJLYHQ7KXVLQWKHVHWURXEOHV WKHUHLVDEOHVVLQJIRUKLPLQWKH+HUHDIWHU
$QDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
318.
UHSRUWHGWKDW7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
319.
VDLG /HW QRWRQHRIRXZLVKIRUGHDWKEHFDXVHRIDPLVIRUWXQHZKLFKEHIDOOVKLP,I KHFDQQRWKHOSGRLQJVR KHVKRXOGVD 2$OODKNHHSPHDOLYHDVORQJDVRXNQRZWKDWOLIHLVEHWWHUIRUPHDQGPDNHPHGLH ZKHQGHDWKLVEHWWHUIRUPH $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU
6LQFHPDQKDVQRNQRZOHGJHRIKLVIXWXUHZKHWKHULWLVJRRGRUEDGVRRQHVKRXOG QHYHUGHVLUHIRURQH VRZQGHDWKLQFRQVHTXHQFHRIIUXVWUDWLRQFUHDWHGEWURXEOHVDQGWXUPRLOIRUWZR UHDVRQV)LUVWOGHVLUHIRUGHDWKLVVKHHULPSDWLHQFH6HFRQGOLWLVTXLWHSRVVLEOHWKDWUHPDLQLQJSDUW RIKLVOLIHPDEHJRRGIRUKLVUHOLJLRXVDQGZRUOGOOLIH6RLWLVSURKLELWHGWRGHVLUHGHDWK,WLV KRZHYHUSHUPLVVLEOHWRGHVLUHIRU6KDKDGDKRUGHDWKLQ0DNNDKRU$O0DGLQDKEXWLWLVDVXEMHFWTXLWH GLIIHUHQWIURPWKHRQHXQGHUGLVFXVVLRQ+RZHYHULIRQHKDVWRH[SUHVVZLVKIRUKLVRZQGHDWKKH VKRXOGGRVRLQWKHZRUGVTXRWHGLQWKH+DGLWKFRQFHUQHG .KDEEDEELQ$O$UDWW0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
320.
UHSRUWHG:HFRPSODLQHGWRWKH0HVVHQJHU RI$OODK3%8+
321.
UHJDUGLQJWKHSHUVHFXWLRQLQIOLFWHGXSRQXVEWKHGLVEHOLHYHUVZKLOHKHZDVOLQJLQ WKHVKDGHRIWKH.DCEDKKDYLQJPDGHDSLOORZRIKLVFORDN:HVXEPLWWHG:KGRRXQRWVXSSOLFDWH IRURXUSUHYDOHQFHRYHUWKHRSSRQHQWV
322.
+H3%8+
323.
UHSOLHG $PRQJWKRVHSHRSOHEHIRUHRXD PDQZRXOGEHVHL]HGDQGKHOGLQDSLWGXJIRUKLPLQWKHJURXQGDQGKHZRXOGEHVDZHGLQWRWZR KDOYHVIURPKLVKHDGDQGKLVIOHVKWRUQDZDIURPKLVERQHVZLWKDQLURQFRPEEXWLQVSLWHRIWKLVKH ZRXOGQRWZHDQDZDIURPKLV)DLWK%$OODK$OODKZLOOEULQJWKLVPDWWHUWRLWVFRQVXPPDWLRQXQWLOD ULGHUZLOOWUDYHOIURP6DQCD WR+DGUDPRXWIHDULQJQRQHH[FHSW$OODKDQGH[FHSWWKHZROIIRUKLVVKHHS EXWRXDUHLQWRRPXFKRIDKXUU $O%XNKDUL@ $QRWKHUQDUUDWLRQLV+H3%8+
324.
KDGSODFHGKLVFORDNXQGHUKLVKHDGDQGZHKDGEHHQWRUWXUHGEWKH SROWKHLVWV RPPHQWDU 'LIILFXOWLHVLQWKHSDWKRI )DLWKGRQRWFRPHLQDQSDUWLFXODUSHULRG3HRSOHGHYRWHGWRWKHLU'HHQ KDYHSDVVHGWKURXJKWULDOVDQGWULEXODWLRQVHYHUZKHUHDQGLQHYHUDJHDQG KDYHHPHUJHGSXULILHGDV
325.
GRHVWKHJROGDIWHUSDVVLQJWKURXJKWKHIXUQDFH6RLWLVXQEHFRPLQJIRUD0XVOLPWREHGLVWXUEHGE KDUGVKLSV 7KHJODGWLGLQJVDERXWGRPLQDWLRQRIUHOLJLRQDQGSHDFHDQGVHFXULWZHUHJLYHQLQWKHHDUOSHULRG RI,VODPZKLFKZHUHVXEVHTXHQWOZLWQHVVHGEWKHSHRSOH(YHQQRZZKHUHYHU,VODPLVSUDFWLVHGLQ WUXHVHQVHSHDFHDQGVHFXULWDUHGLVWLQFWLYHIHDWXUHVRIWKHVVWHPRIWKDWFRXQWU ,EQ0DVCXG0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
326.
UHSRUWHG$IWHUWKHEDWWOHRI+XQDLQ0HVVHQJHURI $OODK3%8+
327.
IDYRXUHGVRPHSHRSOHLQWKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIVSRLOV IRUFRQVRODWLRQ
328.
+HJDYH$O$TUDC ELQ+DELVDQGC8DLQDKELQ+LVQDKXQGUHGFDPHOVHDFKDQGVKRZHGIDYRXUDOVRWRVRPHPRUH KRQRXUDEOHSHUVRQVDPRQJWKH$UDEV6RPHRQHVDLG7KLVGLYLVLRQLVQRWEDVHGRQMXVWLFHDQGLWZDV QRWLQWHQGHGWRZLQWKH3OHDVXUHRI$OODK ,VDLGWRPVHOI%$OODK,ZLOOLQIRUP0HVVHQJHURI $OODK3%8+
329.
RIWKLV ,ZHQWWRKLPDQGLQIRUPHGKLP+LVIDFHEHFDPHUHGDQGKHVDLG:KRZLOOGR MXVWLFHLI$OODKDQG+LV0HVVHQJHUGRQRW 7KHQKHVDLG 0D$OODKKDYHPHUFRQ3URSKHW
330.
0XVD 0RVHV
331.
KHZDVFDXVHGPRUHGLVWUHVVWKDQWKLVEXWKHUHPDLQHGSDWLHQW +DYLQJKHDUGWKLV,VDLGWR PVHOI,VKDOOQHYHUFRQYHDQWKLQJRIWKLVNLQGWRKLPLQIXWXUH $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU 7KLV+DGLWKOHDGVWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQWKDWWKHOHDGHURIWKHSHRSOHRUWKHFDOLSKDKDVD ULJKWLIVLWXDWLRQGHPDQGVWRJLYHWRWKHQHZ0XVOLPVDQGRWKHULQIOXHQWLDODQGUHVSHFWDEOHSHRSOHRI WKHVRFLHWPRUHWKDQRWKHUVIRUWKHLUVDWLVIDFWLRQDQGHQFRXUDJHPHQW7KHPDQZKRUDLVHGREMHFWLRQRQ WKHGLVWULEXWLRQRIERRWEWKH3URSKHW3%8+
332.
ZDVDKSRFULWH'HYRXW0XVOLPVFRXOGQHYHUWKLQN WKDWWKH3URSKHW3%8+
333.
FRXOGEHXQMXVWWRDQRQH7KLVLQFLGHQWDOVR JRHVWRSURYHWKDWWKH3URSKHW 3%8+
334.
DOVRIHOWDVPXFKDVRWKHUVGLGWKHWKLQJVZKLFKLQIXULDWHGRUSOHDVHGRWKHUVEHFDXVHKHZDVD PDQDQGQRWDVXSHUKXPDQEHLQJ $QDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
335.
UHSRUWHGWKDW7KH0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
336.
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
$QDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
337.
UHSRUWHG2QHRIWKHVRQVRI$EX7DOKDK0D$OODKEH SOHDVHGZLWKKLP
338.
ZDVDLOLQJ$EX7DOKDKZHQWRXWDQGWKHERGLHGLQKLVDEVHQFH:KHQKHFDPH EDFNKHLQTXLUHG+RZLVWKHER 8PP6XODLPWKHPRWKHURIWKHERUHSOLHG%HWWHUWKDQ EHIRUH7KHQVKHSODFHGKLVHYHQLQJPHDOEHIRUHKLPDQGKHDWHLWDQGWKHUHDIWHUVOHSWZLWKKHU$W ODVWVKHVDLGWRKLP$UUDQJHIRUWKHEXULDORIWKHER,QWKHPRUQLQJ$EX7DOKDKZHQWWR 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
339.
DQGLQIRUPHGKLPRIWKHHYHQW+HHQTXLUHG 'LGRXVOHHSWRJHWKHUODVW QLJKW $EX7DOKDKUHSOLHGLQWKHDIILUPDWLYHRQZKLFKWKH3URSKHW3%8+
340.
VXSSOLFDWHG 2$OODK EOHVVWKHP 7KHUHDIWHUVKHJDYHELUWKWRDER$EX7DOKDKVDLGWRPH7DNHXSWKHERDQGFDUU KLPWRWKH3URSKHW3%8+
341.
DQGKHVHQWVRPHGDWHVZLWKKLP7KH3URSKHW3%8+
342.
HQTXLUHG ,V WKHUHDQWKLQJZLWKKLP +HVDLGHVVRPHGDWHV7KH3URSKHW3%8+
343.
WRRNDGDWHFKHZHGLWDQG SXWLWLQWKHPRXWKRIWKHEDEDQGUXEEHGWKHFKHZHGGDWHDURXQGWKHEDE VJXPDQGQDPHGKLP C$EGXOODK $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ 7KHQDUUDWLRQLQ%XNKDULDGGV,EQC8DLQDKUHODWHVWKDWDPDQIURPWKH$QVDUWROGKLPWKDWKHKDG VHHQQLQHVRQVRIWKLVC$EGXOODKHYHURQHRIZKRPKDGFRPPLWWHGWKH1REOH4XU DQWRPHPRU 7KHQDUUDWLRQRI0XVOLPVDV7KHVRQRI$EX7DOKDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
344.
ZKRZDVERUQ RI8PP6XODLPGLHG6KH8PP6XODLP
345.
VDLGWRWKHPHPEHUVRIWKHIDPLO'RQRWWHOO$EX7DOKDK DERXWKLVVRQXQWLO,PHQWLRQLWWRKLPPVHOI $EX7DOKDKFDPHKRPH
346.
DQGVKHJDYHKLPVXSSHU+H DWHDQGGUDQN6KHWKHQEHDXWLILHGKHUVHOIWKHEHVWZDVKHHYHUGLGDQGKHVOHSWZLWKKHU:KHQVKH
347.
VDZWKDWKHZDVVDWLVILHGDIWHUVH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVHZLWKKHUVKHVDLG2$EX7DOKDK,IVRPHSHRSOH ERUURZVRPHWKLQJIURPDQRWKHUIDPLODQGWKHQWKHPHPEHUVRIWKHIDPLO
348.
DVNIRULWVUHWXUQZRXOG WKHUHIXVHWRJLYHLWEDFNWRWKHP +HVDLG1R6KHVDLG7KHQKRSHUHZDUGIRURXUVRQ$EX 7DOKDKJRWDQJUDQGVDLGRXOHIWPHXQLQIRUPHGXQWLO,VWDLQHGPVHOIZLWKVH[XDOLQWHUFRXUVH
349.
DQGWKHQRXWROGPHDERXWPVRQ+HZHQWWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
350.
DQGLQIRUPHGKLPDERXW WKHPDWWHU7KHUHXSRQ0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
351.
VDLG 0D$OODKEOHVVWKHQLJKWRXVSHQW WRJHWKHU +HWKHQDUUDWRU
352.
VDLG6KHFRQFHLYHG2QHGD
353.
0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
354.
ZDVLQWKH FRXUVHRIDMRXUQHDQGVKHZDVDORQJZLWKKLP:KHQ0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
355.
XVHGWRFRPHEDFN WR$O0DGLQDKIURPDMRXUQHKHZRXOGQRWHQWHULWGXULQJWKHQLJKW
356.
:KHQWKHSHRSOHFDPHQHDU$O 0DGLQDKVKHIHOWODERXUSDLQV+H$EX7DOKDK
357.
UHPDLQHGZLWKKHUDQG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
358.
SURFHHGHGRQ$EX7DOKDKVDLG25XEERXNQRZWKDW,ORYHWRJRDORQJZLWK0HVVHQJHURI$OODK 3%8+
359.
ZKHQKHJRHVRXWDQGHQWHUDORQJZLWKKLPZKHQKHHQWHUVDQG,KDYHEHHQGHWDLQHGDVRX VHH 8PP6XODLPWKHQVDLG2$EX7DOKDK,GRQRWIHHOVRPXFKSDLQ
360.
DV,ZDVIHHOLQJHDUOLHUVR ZHEHWWHUSURFHHGRQ6RZHSURFHHGHGRQDQGVKHIHOWWKHODERXURIGHOLYHUDVWKHUHDFKHG$O 0DGLQDK
361.
6KHJDYHELUWKWRDPDOHFKLOG0PRWKHUVDLGWRPH2$QDVQRQHVKRXOGVXFNOHKLP XQWLORXJRWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
362.
WRPRUURZ PRUQLQJ 7KHQH[WPRUQLQJ,FDUULHGWKHEDE ZLWKPHWR0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
363.
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
364.
WKHVHUYLFHVVXFKDVGUHVVLQJRIWKHZRXQGHGZHOIDUHRIWKHSDWLHQWV VXSSORIIRRGHWF $EX+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
365.
UHSRUWHG 0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
366.
VDLG 7KH VWURQJPDQLVQRWRQHZKRLVJRRGDWZUHVWOLQJEXWWKHVWURQJPDQLVRQHZKRFRQWUROVKLPVHOILQDILW RIUDJH $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU 7KLV+DGLWKLQVWUXFWVRQHVHOIWRNHHSLQFRQWUROLQRUGHUWRRYHUFRPHKLVUDJH
6XODLPDQELQ6XUDG0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
367.
UHSRUWHG,ZDVVLWWLQJZLWKWKH3URSKHW 3%8+
368.
ZKHQWZRPHQEHJDQWRTXDUUHODQGFXUVHHDFKRWKHUDQGWKHIDFHRIRQHRIWKHPWXUQHGUHG DQGWKHYHLQVRIKLVQHFNZHUHVZROOHQIURPUDJH
369.
0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
370.
VDLG ,NQRZRID ZRUGLIKHZHUHWRXWWHUWKDWKLVUDJHZRXOGYDQLVKDQGWKDWLV$CXGKXELOODKLPLQDVK6KDLWDQQLU UDMLP,VHHNUHIXJHZLWK$OODKIURP6DWDQWKHDFFXUVHG
371.
6RWKHRPSDQLRQV
372.
VDLGWRKLP7KH 3URSKHW3%8+
373.
WHOOVRXWRXWWHU ,VHHNUHIXJHZLWK$OODKIURP6DWDQWKHDFFXUVHG $O%XNKDULDQG0XVOLP@ RPPHQWDU ,QWKHHYHQWRIUDJHLIDSHUVRQEHFRPHVFRQVFLRXVWKDWZKDWKHLVIHHOLQJLVD VXJJHVWLRQIURP6DWDQKHVKRXOGSUHYHQWKLPVHOIIURPLWWKLVFRQVFLRXVQHVVLVWKHEHVWUHPHGWR RYHUFRPHWKHUDJH7KRVHZKRDUHHDVLOLQIXULDWHGFRXOGPDNHXVHRIWKLVSUHVFULSWLRQ 0XCDGKELQ$QDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
374.
UHSRUWHG7KH3URSKHW3%8+
375.
VDLG 7KHRQH ZKRVXSSUHVVHVDQJHUDQGKDVWKHSRZHUWRJLYHHIIHFWWRLWZLOOEHFDOOHGRXWE$OODKWKH([DOWHGWR WKHIRUHIURQWRIWKHFUHDWXUHVRQWKH'DRI 5HVXUUHFWLRQDQGKHZLOOEHDVNHGWRFKRRVHDQRIWKH
376.
YLUJLQV+XU
377.
RIKLVOLNLQJ $EX'DZXGDQG$W7LUPLGKL@ RPPHQWDU 7KHZRUGC+XU LVWKHSOXUDORIC+DXUD DQH[WUHPHOEHDXWLIXOZRPDQRIIDLU FRPSOH[LRQ7KHZRUG (LQ
LVWKHSOXUDORI $LQDZRPDQZLWKODUJHHHV%RWKWKHZRUGVVWDQGIRU WKHPRVWEHDXWLIXOZRPHQZKRZLOOEHDZDUGHGWR0XVOLPVLQ-DQQDK7KLV+DGLWKPHQWLRQVWKH GLVWLQFWLRQDQGUHZDUGRIVHOIFRQWURORIDPDQZKRLQVSLWHRIEHLQJSRZHUIXODQGKDYLQJWKHPHDQVWR DYHQJHVXSSUHVVHVKLVUDJHDQGGRHVQRWH[HUFLVHKLVSRZHU $EX+XUDLUDK0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
378.
UHSRUWHG$PDQDVNHGWKH3URSKHW3%8+
379.
IRUDQ DGYLFHDQGKH3%8+
380.
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
381.
UHSRUWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
382.
VDLG $ 0XVOLPPDOHRUIHPDOHFRQWLQXHVWRUHPDLQXQGHUWULDOLQUHVSHFWRIKLVOLIHSURSHUWDQGRIIVSULQJ XQWLOKHIDFHV$OODKWKH([DOWHGZLWKQRVLQUHFRUG $W7LUPLGKL@ RPPHQWDU :HFRPHWRNQRZIURPWKLV+DGLWKWKDW0XVOLPVDUHVSHFLDOWDUJHWVRIWULDOVEXWD UHGHHPLQJIHDWXUHRIWKHVHWULDOVLVWKDW0XVOLPV VLQVDUHSDUGRQHGWKURXJKWKHPSURYLGHGWKHUHPDLQ ILUPLQWKHLU)DLWKDQGSDWLHQFH
,EQC$EEDV0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKWKHP
383.
UHSRUWHG 8DLQDKELQ+LVQFDPHWR$O0DGLQDKDQG VWDHGZLWKKLVQHSKHZ+XUUELQ4DLVZKRZDVDPRQJWKRVHZKRP8PDU0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWK KLP
384.
VKRZHGIDYRXUWR7KHNQRZOHGJHDEOHSHRSOH4XUUD
385.
ZKHWKHUWKHZHUHROGRURXQJKDGWKH SULYLOHJHRIMRLQLQJ8PDU VFRXQFLODQGKHXVHGWRFRQVXOWWKHP 8DLQDKVDLGWR+XUU0QHSKHZ WKH/HDGHURIWKH%HOLHYHUVVKRZVIDYRXUWRRX:LOORXREWDLQSHUPLVVLRQIRUPHWRVLWZLWKKLP +XUUDVNHGC8PDUDQGKHDFFRUGHGSHUPLVVLRQ:KHQC8DLQDKFDPHLQWRWKHSUHVHQFHRIC8PDUKH DGGUHVVHGKLPWKXV2VRQRI.KDWWDERXQHLWKHUEHVWRZPXFKRQXVQRUGHDOZLWKXVMXVWO C8PDU 0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
386.
JRWDQJUDQGZDVDERXWWREHDWKLPXSZKHQ+XUUVDLGCC2/HDGHU RIWKH%HOLHYHUV$OODKVDLGWR +LV3URSKHW3%8+
387.
6KRZIRUJLYHQHVVHQMRLQZKDWLVJRRGDQGWXUQ DZDIURPWKHIRROLVKLHGRQ WSXQLVKWKHP
388.
7KLVRQHLVIURPWKHLJQRUDQWV:KHQ+XUU UHFLWHGWKLVC8PDUEHFDPHTXLWHPRWLRQOHVVLQKLVVHDW+HDOZDVDGKHUHGVWULFWOWRWKH%RRNRI $OODK $O%XNKDUL@ RPPHQWDU ,QWKLV+DGLWKWKHZRUGC4XUUD GRHVQRWVWDQGIRUWKHNLQGRIWKHC4XUUD UHFLWHUV
389.
RIWKHSUHVHQWDJH ZKRDUHRQOSURIHVVLRQDOLQWKHDUWRIUHFLWLQJWKH4XU DQDQGKDYHDPHORGLRXVYRLFHEXWZKDWLW UHDOOPHDQWZDVWKHFODVVRIVFKRODUVZKRZHUHZHOOYHUVHGLQLWVPHDQLQJVDQGLPSOLFDWLRQVDQGZKR FRXOGWKRURXJKOGLVWLQJXLVKEHWZHHQWKHODZIXODQGWKHXQODZIXOIDLUDQGIRXO6XFKPHQXVHGWREH WKHFRPSDQLRQVRIWKHHDUOQREOHFDOLSKV,WOHDGVWRWKHFRQFOXVLRQWKDWUXOHUVVKRXOGFKRRVHWKHLU DGYLVRUVIURPUHOLJLRXVVFKRODUVDQGQRWIURPWKRVHZKRDUHJLYHQWRWKHZRUOGDQGZKRVHVROHDLPLQ OLIHLVWRDPDVVZHDOWKUDWKHUWKDQFDUHDERXWWKHZHOIDUHRIWKHSHRSOHDQGZKRVHDGYLFHLVEDVHGRQ VHOILVKPRWLYHVDQGYHVWHGLQWHUHVWV
390.
6LQFHVFKRODUVKLSDQGSLRXVQHVVDUHWKHIRUHPRVWTXDOLILFDWLRQVIRUFRXQVHOORUVDQGDGYLVRUVWKHUHLV QRUHVWULFWLRQRIDJHIRUWKHP 7KHUXOHUVKRXOGDOZDVEHYHUFRQVLGHUDWHDQGWROHUDQW 7KHUXOHUVKRXOGQHYHUKHVLWDWHIURPDFFHSWLQJWUXWKDQGULJKWHRXVQHVV ,EQ0DVCXG0D$OODKEHSOHDVHGZLWKKLP
391.
UHSRUWHG0HVVHQJHURI$OODK3%8+
392.
VDLG RXZLOO VHHDIWHUPHIDYRXULWLVPDQGWKLQJVZKLFKRXZLOOGLVDSSURYHRI 7KHVXEPLWWHG:KDWGRRX RUGHUXVWRGRXQGHUVXFKFLUFXPVWDQFHV
Baixar agora