How EDM and ECM can effectively reduce costs on many of today’s critical components, especially those made from metals with high machinability ratings.
Processes to be considered on difficult to machine materials
Block diagram reduction techniques in control systems.ppt
IMTS 2016 Presentation by John Stackhouse of Global Specialty Machines
1. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
How EDM and ECM can effectively reduce costs on many of today’s
critical components, especially those made from metals with high
machinability ratings
2. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Processes to be considered on difficult to machine materials
1.0. EDM – Electro Discharge Machining
1.1. Sinking EDM
1.2. Wire EDM
1.3. FHD (Fast Hole Drilling) EDM
1.4. Micro EDM
2.0. ECM – Electro Chemical Machining
2.1. Electro Chemical Machining … ECM
2.2. Precision (Pulsed) ECM ….... PECM
2.3. Electro Chemical Deburring ..... ECD
2.4. Electro Chemical Grinding …… ECG
2.5. Shaped Tube ECM ………..… STEM
2.6. ElectroStream Drilling
2.7. Capillary Drilling
3.0. LASER – Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation
3.1. Laser Drilling
3.2. Laser Ablation
3.3. Laser Cutting
3. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Processes to be discussed in this presentation
1.0. EDM – Electro Discharge Machining
1.1. Sinking EDM
1.2. Wire EDM
1.3. FHD (Fast Hole Drilling) EDM
1.4. Micro EDM
2.0. ECM – Electro Chemical Machining
2.1. Electro Chemical Machining … ECM
2.2. Precision (Pulsed) ECM …..... PECM
2.3. Electro Chemical Deburring ..... ECD
2.4. Electro Chemical Grinding …… ECG
2.5. Shaped Tube ECM ………...… STEM
2.6. ElectroStream Drilling
2.7. Capillary Drilling
3.0. LASER – Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation
3.1. Laser Drilling
3.2. Laser Ablation
3.3. Laser Cutting
4. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
FH40 FH50 FH60
X, Y Axis 40”x20” (1000x500mm) 50”x25” (1250x635mm) 60”x30” (1500x750mm)
Z Axis 26” (660mm) 24” (610mm) 24” (610mm)
W Axis 26” (660mm) 26“ (660mm) 26” (660mm)
FHD-EDM Machines
• Multi-axis positioning and machining system
• Tilting head EDM Slide carries 600mm Electrodes
• Robot Tool Changer for untended production
5. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
X, Y Axis Travel 31.5” x 23.6” 800mm x 600mm
Z Axis Travel 19.7” 500mm
W Axis Travel 19.7” 500mm
FHD-EDM Machines
6. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
7. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
Tilting EDM Head has +/- 100* travel
8. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
Shown with large Turbine Bucket being drilled
9. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
Process principles
• EDM, using Deionized water as a dielectric
• Tubular Electrodes - both hollow and Multi-core –
with dielectric flushed through – Copper or Brass
• High Depth to Diameter ratios possible because of the
Dielectric through-flushing
• A Thermal process, so Recast layer and Heat-affected
zone result
• Machines any conductive material, regardless of
hardness or machinability
10. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
Applications
Aircraft Engine Combustion Liners
• Material ……….... Hastalloy X
• Ca 2,500 holes
• Holes …............ 0.025” - 0.046” (0.64 - 1.20mm)
• Wall thickness … 0.060” - 0.080” (1.50 - 2.0mm)
• Total time ………. 8.00 hours
• Time per hole ….. < 12 seconds
• Finish …………… < 250 u” (6.3um) Ra
• Tolerance, diameter … 0.004”(0.13mm)
• Tolerance, TP ……….. 0.020”(0.5mm)
• Number of Toolchanges ………… 68
Note curved Electrode Guide for access
11. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
Applications
Industrial Gas Turbine Dome Ring
• Material ……….... Hastalloy X
• Ca 4,250 holes @ angles so 0.33” (7.62mm)dp
• Holes …....... 0.050” - 0.070” (1.30 – 1.80mm)
• Wall ……...... 0.120” – 0.200” (3.00 -5.00mm)
• Total time ………. 40.00 hours
• Time per hole ….. < 34 seconds
• Finish …………… < 250 u” (6.3um) Ra
• Tolerance, diameter … 0.006”(0.15mm)
• Tolerance, TP ……….. 0.020”(0.5mm)
• Number of Toolchanges ………… 569
12. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Creating a Shaped Hole by Interpolating the Brass Electrode during
the EDM process. The Fanuc Control will Track Voltage to Simulate
Servo and Gap functions.
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
Shaped Hole Technology
13. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
Shaped Hole Technology
14. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Shaped Hole Technology
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
15. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Fast Hole Drilling EDM
For Videos on Fast Hole Drilling go to:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wz2lXpfBpd8
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EunVelGAKQE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BB6mAlVexGg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2iaTlCIZijo
16. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
ECM
Process principles
• Think of it as “Accelerated Reverse Electro Plating”
• Material is removed “Molecule-by-molecule”
• Stress-free surfaces produced
• Not a thermal process, so no Recast
layer or Heat-affected zone
• Significant forces as Electrolyte flows up
to 300psi/300gpm (20bar @ 1,200l/m)
• Material Removal > 1.00 Cubic
Inch per minute per 10,000 amps
17. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
ECM
ECM is used in machining applications, including:
• Automotive - nozzles, drilling, deburring, production of cavities and curved channels
• Aerospace – airfoils, BLISKS, casings and ong cooling channels in vanes
• Industrial Gas Turbines – buckets, fuel nozzles
• Domestic Appliances – electric razor foils
• BPE/Semiconductor Fittings
• Micro parts - microscopes and other measuring equipment, molds, fuel cell tooling
• Medical - implants and medical devices
• Textile Industry
• Optical Industry - lenses and micro drillings
• Printing Industry - micro and macro textures on large upper surfaces
18. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
ECM
An ECM system consists of the following main components:
-Machining unit with CNC controlled axes –single or multi Ram
-Tooling
-Electrolyte tanks
-Power Supply
- Electrolyte Filtration Unit
-Electrolyte Cooling Unit
- Control System
19. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
ECM
______________________________________________________________
20. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
ECM
Tooling
- Cathodes made of copper or stainless steel >>>>>
- Workpiece holding fixture
- Flow box to control the electrolyte flow
21. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
ECM
<<<<< Cathode shown for Knee
Implant
Hip Implant
22. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
ECM
23. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
ECM
Applications
• These 6.000” (150mm) diameter Titanium discs are ECM’ed to a
stress-free condition with extremely thin wall thickness
• Result is a close-tolerance part with no distortion
24. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
ECM
Applications
• Tube Fittings has been ECM’ed after welding or
bending to remove the excess weld material and to
polish the internal surfaces.
• This can be done extremely rapidly with accurate
tolerance and high repeatability on BPE and
Semi Conductor Fittings
Applications
Applications
25. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
ECM
• Medium - conducting electrolyte, generally a Saline solution of Sodium Nitrate or Sodium Chloride
• Mechanics of material removal – electrolysis
• Tool material - Copper, brass, steel
• Tool life - infinite
• Machining gap 10 to 100 μm (0.0004” – 0.004”)
• Materials application - all conducting metals and alloys
• Critical parameters - voltage, current, feed rate, electrolyte conductivity
• Surface finishes down to 0.1 μm (4 MicroInch) Ra
• Shapes application - blind complex cavities, curved surfaces, through cutting, large through cavities
• Material Removal > 1.00 Cubic Inch per minute per 10,000 amps
Summary of ECM Characteristics
26. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
ECM
Various machine types
27. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
PECM
PECM :
• Pulsed (or “Precision” ECM)
• Oscillating Z Axis and Pulsed Power Supply
• Enables closer gaps
• Still uses Saline solution
• Gives much better Surface Finish than
traditional ECM
• Enables much finer detail to be produced
• Capable of ECM’ing Tungsten Carbide
28. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
PECM
New Trends and Capabilities – using PECM
29. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
Introduction
• An ECM process that enables holes
to be “drilled” to extreme L/D Ratios
• Specialized Applications such as Turbine
“Buckets” and Extrusion Dies for
Catalytic Converter material
30. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
Typical STEM Drilling Setup
Machine Features and Options:
• Daylight
• Stroke
• Number of Parts to be drilled
• Absolute encoders
• Positive air to Z axis
• Stainless Steel hardware
• Composite Granite base
31. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
Process principles
• ECM with Acid as an Electrolyte
• Nitric or sulphuric Acids used Ca 25% concentration
• Single axis process (Z) where Insulated Tubes descend into the part to be drilled
• Not a thermal process, so no Recast layer or Heat-affected zone
• Tubes advance at Ca 0.080” (2.00mm) per minute, regardless of quantity of holes
• Tubes are Titanium with special insulation (ParaXylene) on Outside Diameter
• Tubes have angled front-ends and need periodic Dressing
• All ECM action occurs on the exposed end of the Tube(s)
• STEM – “Shaped Tube Electrolytic Machining” – although mostly ROUND Holes!!
32. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
• Bi-Polar
• Forward Volts Machining - typically 15V for 5 seconds
• Reverse Volts to remove build-up of deposits on tip of tubes - typically 5V for 0.1s
• Sufficient Power to machine 3 blades simultaneously
• High Speed switch -off
• Water cooled
• Positive air pressure
Power Supplies
33. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
• Manufactured to ISO/CE Standards
• Timed Door interlocks – to allow fumes to be extracted
• Extraction of Hydrogen and acid fumes min 50m3/hour per 1000A
• Auto wash down of parts - valve directs water to separate tank
• Machine & Acid system connected to “Scrubber”
• PPE, including goggles, hats, aprons, gloves
• Stamp/handle drench shower
• Eye wash station
Safety features
34. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
• Acid must be a stable parameter
• Programmable emptying of dirty acid
• Programmable replenish of clean acid
• Remote control of wash down – with water
• Spreadsheet for Acid calculations
Acid management
35. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
Machine Radial Cooling Holes in Industrial
Gas Turbine Buckets, including the following:
• Siemens 94.2
• GE Frame 6 - Row 1
• GE Frame 6 - Row 2
• GE Frame 7 - Row 1
• GE Frame 9 - Row 1
36. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
Cooling Holes produced
up to 24” (600mm) deep
“Turbulated” holes for greater cooling efficiency
37. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
Typical Tooling includes
• STEM Tube Manifold
• STEM Tube Guide
• STEM Tube Target Plate
• Airfoil 6 point nest
• Clamping system
38. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
STEM Tube Manifold
• Provides through-flushing of Acid
• Variable flow
• Multiple tube sizes
39. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
STEM Tube Guide
• Titanium
• Produced by wire EDM
• Applies correct vector
40. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
STEM Tube Target Plate
• Ensures alignment prior to machining
• Separate for root & tip machining
• Alignment is crucial to maintaining True Position
• True Position necessary to maintain
“Minimum Wall” condition
• If “Minimum Wall” is not maintained then likelihood
of Bucket burning-up in service!!
41. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
STEM Drilling
Airfoil Fixture
• Airfoil (6) point “nest” - to establish
Stacking Axis of Bucket
• Clamping system
• Single or Multi Blade Fixtures
42. John Stackhouse - Executive Vice President
Global Specialty Machines, Mason, Ohio, USA
Processes discussed
1.0. EDM – Electro Discharge Machining
1.1. Sinking EDM
1.2. Wire EDM
1.3. FHD (Fast Hole Drilling) EDM
1.4. Micro EDM
2.0. ECM – Electro Chemical Machining
2.1. Electro Chemical Machining … ECM
2.2. Precision (Pulsed) ECM …..... PECM
2.3. Electro Chemical Deburring ..... ECD
2.4. Electro Chemical Grinding …… ECG
2.5. Shaped Tube ECM ………...… STEM
2.6. ElectroStream Drilling
2.7. Capillary Drilling
3.0. LASER – Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation
3.1. Laser Drilling
3.2. Laser Ablation
3.3. Laser Cutting