SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 15
Baixar para ler offline
Tiger Fund |Business Education Complex Baton Rouge, LA 70803
Performance Report For
TIGER FUND
4 Year Trading Analysis: 8/1/2011 – 6/30/2015
This report encapsulates the performance of the portfolio for the time
period mentioned above. It includes information pertaining to the
weights, returns, and risk of the portfolio as well as its respective
benchmark, the Russell Top 200 Index.
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 1
Table of Contents
1) Key Data......................................................................................................................................................................2
2) Trade Data Analysis....................................................................................................................................................3
3) Holdings Allocation: Top 10 .......................................................................................................................................3
4) Annual Returns...........................................................................................................................................................4
5) Cumulative Returns....................................................................................................................................................5
6) Average Annual Return (AAR) vs. St. Deviation of Returns (SDR)............................................................................6
7) Attribution..................................................................................................................................................................7
8) Holdings by Sector......................................................................................................................................................8
9) Max / Min Weights by Sector ....................................................................................................................................9
10) Annual Sector Weights.........................................................................................................................................10
11) Beta, Correlation, R2
& Other Ratios....................................................................................................................13
Student Managed Investment Fund................................................................................................................................14
Course Suggestions...........................................................................................................................................................14
Student Focused Recommendations ...............................................................................................................................14
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 2
Tiger Fund
July 2015
Period Analyzed - 8/1/2011 - 6/30/2015
Analysts:
Daniel Dowd
Jason Wyman
Steve Taylor
The Tiger Fund is a student managed investment fund which is part of the LSU Foundation. Within a top down
approach, undergraduate and graduate students managed the fund, which is benchmarked against the Russell 200 Top
200 index.
1) Key Data
The Tiger Fund has consistently underperformed its primary benchmark, the Russell Top 200. The Tiger Fund has
averaged an annualized return of 14.29%, while the Russell
Top 200 has averaged 15.36% over the period analyzed,
8/1/2011 - 6/30/2015. In addition, the Tiger Fund has
proven to be riskier than its benchmark. From a total risk
perspective, the standard deviation of returns for the Tiger
Fund has been 13.28%, while its benchmark standard
deviation was 12.75%. From a systemic risk perspective,
the Tiger Fund has been slightly more risky, having a Beta
of 1.01 relative to the Russell Top 200. While the Tiger
Fund has a higher risk profile, it has also under-performed
its benchmark on an absolute basis. Of course this causes
the risk adjusted performance to lag more dramatically
than the absolute performance, as evidenced by both the
Sharpe and Treynor ratios being less than the benchmark.
Both ratios indicate that the Tiger Fund is not getting as
much return per unit of risk as the benchmark. In addition,
risk appears to be asymmetric, as evidenced by the
upside/downside capture ratios. Upside capture for the
fund is 98.7%, while the fund is capturing 107.44% of the
downside of the index.
Figure 1 Key Data
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 3
2) Trade Data Analysis
In analyzing the Tiger Fund, we have determined one of the major drags to performance has been the decision making,
specifically the buy decisions, by each class. On average, the decisions made by classes, who serve as portfolio
managers, have reduced return, while adding volatility to the portfolio. We examined trade data over the period to
determine the average buy decisions made by the class, underperformed their sell decisions by 2.32% over the first six
months after the decision and 1.51% over the first twelve months. In addition, the buy decisions have underperformed
the benchmark by an average of 12.61% over the first six
months and 9.31% over the first twelve months. While
the buy decisions have been disappointing, the sell
decisions have been good. The sells actually
underperformed the benchmark over the six and twelve
month period. Unfortunately, the buy decisions
underperformed the sell decisions.
3) Holdings Allocation: Top 10
Certainly as a top down focused process, sector selection
also plays an important role as a driver of performance.
Over the period analyzed, sector selection has contributed
5.51% drag to total return of the portfolio. However, if it
were not for the exceptionally strong performance of three
holdings that have added to relative performance, the
results would be much worse. Gilead Sciences, Disney and
CVS have added 6.31%, 3.14% and 2.51% relative
performance to the fund, respectively, for a cumulative
11.96% of relative performance increase. While there has
been a slight increase in exposure to Gilead and a larger
increase in exposure to CVS, those positions existed prior to
the beginning of our analysis. Certainly those positions
serve to mask an even worse situation. Without the
positive selection attribution of those companies, sector
attribution would be about 280 basis points worse.
It appears as though part of the problem might be
inconsistency of thought process. What we noticed through the trade analysis is that classes tended to “undo” trades
that a prior class might have made. As demonstrated by the portfolio’s turnover of 39%, much of the portfolio is turned
over each year. While there are several long term holdings, many of the larger holdings have been bought and sold
relatively frequently, leading to the volatility and performance drag. Overall, the management of the fund has been
concerning on both an absolute and risk adjusted basis.
Figure 2 Trade Data Analysis
Figure 3 Holdings Allocation: Top 10
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 4
4) Annual Returns
Figure 4 Annual Returns Chart
Figure 5 Annual Returns Graph
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 5
5) Cumulative Returns
Further analysis of the 4 year term provide findings that the Relative Total Returns over the period from (8/1/2011 -
6/30/2015) would be 12% worse without GILD, DIS and CVS.
Figure 6 Cumulative Returns Graph
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 6
6) Average Annual Return (AAR) vs. St. Deviation of Returns (SDR)
Figure 7 Average Annual Returns vs. Standard Deviation Chart
Figure 8 Average Annual Returns vs. Standard Deviation Graph
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 7
7) Attribution
Based on the chart below, when looking at specific sector selection, ie. Underweight/overweight sectors, the fund has
negative allocation attribution for 7 out of 10 sectors examined. Fortunately strong relative performance of Gilead,
Disney and CVS helped balance out the total attribution of health care, consumer discretionary and staples.
Stock selection in technology and durables both exhibited poor selection that hurt the overall sector attribution.
Caterpillar was a major drag in durables, while numerous stocks contributed to the drag in technology.
Figure 9 Attribution
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 8
8) Holdings by Sector
Figure 10 Holdings by Sector
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 9
9) Max / Min Weights by Sector
Figure 11 Max/Min Weights by Sector (1-5)
Figure 12 Max/Min Weights by Sector (6-10)
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 10
10) Annual Sector Weights
Figure 13 Sector Weights Year 2011
Figure 14 Sector Weights Year 2012
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 11
Figure 15 Sector Weights Year 2013
Figure 16 Sector Weights Year 2014
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 12
Figure 17 Sector Weights Year 2015
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 13
11) Beta, Correlation, R2 & Other Ratios
Figure 18 Beta, Correlation, R2 & Other Ratios
Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 14
Student Managed Investment Fund
The large cap U.S equity market is extremely competitive and highly efficient. Even the most seasoned
investment professionals with robust research staff have a difficult time out performing the U.S large cap benchmarks.
Therefore it is not surprising that the Tiger Fund has performed mediocrely over the past years, never truly exceeding
the benchmark. We think this is simply due to the inexperience our students have when engaging the stock market. We
understand the class has the dual mandate to learn while gaining real life experience. To help students better maximize
investments in the future, we have come up with some suggestions. We certainly understand that the fund has a dual
mandate of educating students as well as superior relative performance. With that understanding, some of these
recommendations might hamper the mandate of educating students.
Course Suggestions
1) Constrain the decision making power of the class
a) Possibly narrowing the +/- 50% rule
2) Add another prerequisite to the course
a) With only Finance 3716 required to take this class, it could be beneficial for the students to have more/any
experience regarding the stock market before entering the Tiger Fund class. Classes currently available are FIN
3826 (basic Investments) and FIN 4830 (analysis of corporate financial statements).
3) Revamp the course
a) Many times we have noticed through our research that what one class will do, normally a semester or 2 later it
will be undone by other classes. We suggest a new structure to the Tiger Fund course in which:
i) PM’s are the advisory board
ii) Increase members of the advisory board from 3 to 5
(1) Possibly another asset management professional
(2) Alumni
ii) Students serve as research analyst for the board
4) Slim down the number of stocks students can choose from
a) 200 stocks is a lot for students to analyze each company, possibly through group consensus of the advisory
board slim down and give the students certain stocks to concentrate on each semester.
Student Focused Recommendations
In addition we compiled a few suggestions students in the future could benefit from understanding:
1) Valuations matter
a) Almost all valuations are helpful
b) Stock price can raise one or a combination of two ways
i. Higher P value
ii. Increase in company EPS
2) Understand how the market values particular companies
a) The market values companies differently. How is it valuing the company you are analyzing
i. Price to sales
ii. Price to earnings
iii. Price to book
iv. PEG ration
v. Dividend yield
3) Consensus opinion
a) Understand the markets consensus on a particular stock and think:
4) Is your consensus similar? If so the stock probably already reflects that view
i. Beware of bullish consensus
ii. “You pay a high price in the stock market for a rosy consensus” – Warren Buffett
5) Additional Fact Set/Bloomberg training

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Quantitative methods in Hedge Fund of Fund ( HFOF ) construction ( Dec 2009 )
Quantitative methods in Hedge Fund of Fund ( HFOF ) construction ( Dec 2009 )Quantitative methods in Hedge Fund of Fund ( HFOF ) construction ( Dec 2009 )
Quantitative methods in Hedge Fund of Fund ( HFOF ) construction ( Dec 2009 )Peter Urbani
 
Asset Allocation and Factor Investing: An Integrated Solution
Asset Allocation and Factor Investing: An Integrated SolutionAsset Allocation and Factor Investing: An Integrated Solution
Asset Allocation and Factor Investing: An Integrated SolutionWindham Labs
 
Indian equities - 2021 review and 2022 Outlook
Indian equities - 2021 review and 2022 Outlook Indian equities - 2021 review and 2022 Outlook
Indian equities - 2021 review and 2022 Outlook AmitKumarGupta500230
 
DSP Quant Fund - Introduction
DSP Quant Fund - IntroductionDSP Quant Fund - Introduction
DSP Quant Fund - IntroductionDSP Mutual Fund
 
Master presentation june 2013
Master presentation june 2013Master presentation june 2013
Master presentation june 2013Michael Kennedy
 
Uop fin-571-week-4-connect-problems-new
Uop fin-571-week-4-connect-problems-newUop fin-571-week-4-connect-problems-new
Uop fin-571-week-4-connect-problems-newaagnaa
 
The relationship between activity based,
The relationship between activity based,The relationship between activity based,
The relationship between activity based,Arfan Afzal
 
Standard & poor's 16768282 fund-factors-2009 jan1
Standard & poor's 16768282 fund-factors-2009 jan1Standard & poor's 16768282 fund-factors-2009 jan1
Standard & poor's 16768282 fund-factors-2009 jan1bfmresearch
 
netwealth educational webinar - The evolution of asset allocation
netwealth educational webinar - The evolution of asset allocationnetwealth educational webinar - The evolution of asset allocation
netwealth educational webinar - The evolution of asset allocationnetwealthInvest
 
Impact ofmutualfundclosuresonfundmanagers
Impact ofmutualfundclosuresonfundmanagersImpact ofmutualfundclosuresonfundmanagers
Impact ofmutualfundclosuresonfundmanagersbfmresearch
 
WisdomTree Capabilities Brochure
WisdomTree Capabilities BrochureWisdomTree Capabilities Brochure
WisdomTree Capabilities BrochureScott Ferguson
 

Mais procurados (20)

Quantitative methods in Hedge Fund of Fund ( HFOF ) construction ( Dec 2009 )
Quantitative methods in Hedge Fund of Fund ( HFOF ) construction ( Dec 2009 )Quantitative methods in Hedge Fund of Fund ( HFOF ) construction ( Dec 2009 )
Quantitative methods in Hedge Fund of Fund ( HFOF ) construction ( Dec 2009 )
 
Asset Allocation and Factor Investing: An Integrated Solution
Asset Allocation and Factor Investing: An Integrated SolutionAsset Allocation and Factor Investing: An Integrated Solution
Asset Allocation and Factor Investing: An Integrated Solution
 
Ssrn id1685942
Ssrn id1685942Ssrn id1685942
Ssrn id1685942
 
DSP Healthcare Fund
DSP Healthcare FundDSP Healthcare Fund
DSP Healthcare Fund
 
Indian equities - 2021 review and 2022 Outlook
Indian equities - 2021 review and 2022 Outlook Indian equities - 2021 review and 2022 Outlook
Indian equities - 2021 review and 2022 Outlook
 
DSP Quant Fund - Introduction
DSP Quant Fund - IntroductionDSP Quant Fund - Introduction
DSP Quant Fund - Introduction
 
Master presentation june 2013
Master presentation june 2013Master presentation june 2013
Master presentation june 2013
 
Spiva mid2011
Spiva mid2011Spiva mid2011
Spiva mid2011
 
Uop fin-571-week-4-connect-problems-new
Uop fin-571-week-4-connect-problems-newUop fin-571-week-4-connect-problems-new
Uop fin-571-week-4-connect-problems-new
 
DSP Focus Fund
DSP Focus FundDSP Focus Fund
DSP Focus Fund
 
The relationship between activity based,
The relationship between activity based,The relationship between activity based,
The relationship between activity based,
 
Standard & poor's 16768282 fund-factors-2009 jan1
Standard & poor's 16768282 fund-factors-2009 jan1Standard & poor's 16768282 fund-factors-2009 jan1
Standard & poor's 16768282 fund-factors-2009 jan1
 
netwealth educational webinar - The evolution of asset allocation
netwealth educational webinar - The evolution of asset allocationnetwealth educational webinar - The evolution of asset allocation
netwealth educational webinar - The evolution of asset allocation
 
Select Directional 2016 08 31
Select Directional 2016 08 31Select Directional 2016 08 31
Select Directional 2016 08 31
 
Foord Presentation
Foord PresentationFoord Presentation
Foord Presentation
 
Comprehensive Ratio Analysis
Comprehensive  Ratio  AnalysisComprehensive  Ratio  Analysis
Comprehensive Ratio Analysis
 
Impact ofmutualfundclosuresonfundmanagers
Impact ofmutualfundclosuresonfundmanagersImpact ofmutualfundclosuresonfundmanagers
Impact ofmutualfundclosuresonfundmanagers
 
Stanlib
StanlibStanlib
Stanlib
 
DSP Healthcare Fund
DSP Healthcare FundDSP Healthcare Fund
DSP Healthcare Fund
 
WisdomTree Capabilities Brochure
WisdomTree Capabilities BrochureWisdomTree Capabilities Brochure
WisdomTree Capabilities Brochure
 

Destaque

I spy first name only
I spy first name onlyI spy first name only
I spy first name onlymitchellm1
 
6 word digital memoirs
6 word digital memoirs6 word digital memoirs
6 word digital memoirsmitchellm1
 
Technology_Presentation-(ATVI_IBM_INTC_QCOM)
Technology_Presentation-(ATVI_IBM_INTC_QCOM)Technology_Presentation-(ATVI_IBM_INTC_QCOM)
Technology_Presentation-(ATVI_IBM_INTC_QCOM)Jason Wyman
 
5 very important things to me
5 very important things to me5 very important things to me
5 very important things to memitchellm1
 
Module Madness 4
Module Madness 4Module Madness 4
Module Madness 4teacher581
 
4yrTradeAnalysis_Summary
4yrTradeAnalysis_Summary4yrTradeAnalysis_Summary
4yrTradeAnalysis_SummaryJason Wyman
 
Enterprise Ireland Presentation
Enterprise Ireland PresentationEnterprise Ireland Presentation
Enterprise Ireland PresentationIvan Stojanovic
 
WHO-IS- RISKIER FORD vs. GM_Dec2013
WHO-IS- RISKIER FORD vs. GM_Dec2013WHO-IS- RISKIER FORD vs. GM_Dec2013
WHO-IS- RISKIER FORD vs. GM_Dec2013Jason Wyman
 
National Employment Week 2015 Talent Summit - Digital Talent Attraction Mast...
National Employment Week 2015 Talent Summit -  Digital Talent Attraction Mast...National Employment Week 2015 Talent Summit -  Digital Talent Attraction Mast...
National Employment Week 2015 Talent Summit - Digital Talent Attraction Mast...Holly Fawcett
 
Real Estate Site Analysis & Feasibility_MixedUseProposal
Real Estate Site Analysis & Feasibility_MixedUseProposalReal Estate Site Analysis & Feasibility_MixedUseProposal
Real Estate Site Analysis & Feasibility_MixedUseProposalJason Wyman
 
Bab 2 Pendekatan Sistem dalam Kegiatan Pembelajaran
Bab 2 Pendekatan Sistem dalam Kegiatan PembelajaranBab 2 Pendekatan Sistem dalam Kegiatan Pembelajaran
Bab 2 Pendekatan Sistem dalam Kegiatan PembelajaranSyarifah Fadlilah Al-aydarus
 
Vietnam - Kitchen of the World
Vietnam - Kitchen of the WorldVietnam - Kitchen of the World
Vietnam - Kitchen of the WorldLinh Pham
 
Best in 2013_ielt_scommunity
Best in 2013_ielt_scommunityBest in 2013_ielt_scommunity
Best in 2013_ielt_scommunityLinh Pham
 
Portfolio-Mang_TECH_Fall-2016
Portfolio-Mang_TECH_Fall-2016Portfolio-Mang_TECH_Fall-2016
Portfolio-Mang_TECH_Fall-2016Jason Wyman
 
Taylor swift lyrics
Taylor swift lyricsTaylor swift lyrics
Taylor swift lyricsLinh Pham
 
Technology-Presentation_Qualcomm_Intel
Technology-Presentation_Qualcomm_IntelTechnology-Presentation_Qualcomm_Intel
Technology-Presentation_Qualcomm_IntelJason Wyman
 
TLCon Amsterdam: Diversity Tactics That Work (Holly Fawcett, Social Talent)
TLCon Amsterdam: Diversity Tactics That Work (Holly Fawcett, Social Talent)TLCon Amsterdam: Diversity Tactics That Work (Holly Fawcett, Social Talent)
TLCon Amsterdam: Diversity Tactics That Work (Holly Fawcett, Social Talent)Holly Fawcett
 
LINE BOT on the Perl (YAPC::Hokkaido ver.)
LINE BOT on the Perl (YAPC::Hokkaido ver.)LINE BOT on the Perl (YAPC::Hokkaido ver.)
LINE BOT on the Perl (YAPC::Hokkaido ver.)Kazuhiro Osawa
 

Destaque (18)

I spy first name only
I spy first name onlyI spy first name only
I spy first name only
 
6 word digital memoirs
6 word digital memoirs6 word digital memoirs
6 word digital memoirs
 
Technology_Presentation-(ATVI_IBM_INTC_QCOM)
Technology_Presentation-(ATVI_IBM_INTC_QCOM)Technology_Presentation-(ATVI_IBM_INTC_QCOM)
Technology_Presentation-(ATVI_IBM_INTC_QCOM)
 
5 very important things to me
5 very important things to me5 very important things to me
5 very important things to me
 
Module Madness 4
Module Madness 4Module Madness 4
Module Madness 4
 
4yrTradeAnalysis_Summary
4yrTradeAnalysis_Summary4yrTradeAnalysis_Summary
4yrTradeAnalysis_Summary
 
Enterprise Ireland Presentation
Enterprise Ireland PresentationEnterprise Ireland Presentation
Enterprise Ireland Presentation
 
WHO-IS- RISKIER FORD vs. GM_Dec2013
WHO-IS- RISKIER FORD vs. GM_Dec2013WHO-IS- RISKIER FORD vs. GM_Dec2013
WHO-IS- RISKIER FORD vs. GM_Dec2013
 
National Employment Week 2015 Talent Summit - Digital Talent Attraction Mast...
National Employment Week 2015 Talent Summit -  Digital Talent Attraction Mast...National Employment Week 2015 Talent Summit -  Digital Talent Attraction Mast...
National Employment Week 2015 Talent Summit - Digital Talent Attraction Mast...
 
Real Estate Site Analysis & Feasibility_MixedUseProposal
Real Estate Site Analysis & Feasibility_MixedUseProposalReal Estate Site Analysis & Feasibility_MixedUseProposal
Real Estate Site Analysis & Feasibility_MixedUseProposal
 
Bab 2 Pendekatan Sistem dalam Kegiatan Pembelajaran
Bab 2 Pendekatan Sistem dalam Kegiatan PembelajaranBab 2 Pendekatan Sistem dalam Kegiatan Pembelajaran
Bab 2 Pendekatan Sistem dalam Kegiatan Pembelajaran
 
Vietnam - Kitchen of the World
Vietnam - Kitchen of the WorldVietnam - Kitchen of the World
Vietnam - Kitchen of the World
 
Best in 2013_ielt_scommunity
Best in 2013_ielt_scommunityBest in 2013_ielt_scommunity
Best in 2013_ielt_scommunity
 
Portfolio-Mang_TECH_Fall-2016
Portfolio-Mang_TECH_Fall-2016Portfolio-Mang_TECH_Fall-2016
Portfolio-Mang_TECH_Fall-2016
 
Taylor swift lyrics
Taylor swift lyricsTaylor swift lyrics
Taylor swift lyrics
 
Technology-Presentation_Qualcomm_Intel
Technology-Presentation_Qualcomm_IntelTechnology-Presentation_Qualcomm_Intel
Technology-Presentation_Qualcomm_Intel
 
TLCon Amsterdam: Diversity Tactics That Work (Holly Fawcett, Social Talent)
TLCon Amsterdam: Diversity Tactics That Work (Holly Fawcett, Social Talent)TLCon Amsterdam: Diversity Tactics That Work (Holly Fawcett, Social Talent)
TLCon Amsterdam: Diversity Tactics That Work (Holly Fawcett, Social Talent)
 
LINE BOT on the Perl (YAPC::Hokkaido ver.)
LINE BOT on the Perl (YAPC::Hokkaido ver.)LINE BOT on the Perl (YAPC::Hokkaido ver.)
LINE BOT on the Perl (YAPC::Hokkaido ver.)
 

Semelhante a 4yrTradeAnalysis_Full-Version

Abacus Weath Partners Investment slideshow
Abacus Weath Partners Investment slideshowAbacus Weath Partners Investment slideshow
Abacus Weath Partners Investment slideshowAbacus Wealth Partners
 
DSP Top 100 Equity Fund Presentation.pdf
DSP Top 100 Equity Fund Presentation.pdfDSP Top 100 Equity Fund Presentation.pdf
DSP Top 100 Equity Fund Presentation.pdfDSP Mutual Fund
 
Gilead Sciences Inc (GILD) Stock Analysis Report
 Gilead Sciences Inc (GILD) Stock Analysis Report Gilead Sciences Inc (GILD) Stock Analysis Report
Gilead Sciences Inc (GILD) Stock Analysis ReportStock Target Advisor
 
WMT: Walmart Inc. Stock Price, Quote and News
WMT: Walmart Inc. Stock Price, Quote and NewsWMT: Walmart Inc. Stock Price, Quote and News
WMT: Walmart Inc. Stock Price, Quote and NewsStocktargetadvisor.com
 
Big Lots Inc (BIG) Stock Analysis Report
Big Lots Inc (BIG) Stock Analysis ReportBig Lots Inc (BIG) Stock Analysis Report
Big Lots Inc (BIG) Stock Analysis ReportStock Target Advisor
 
Gmo absolute return
Gmo absolute returnGmo absolute return
Gmo absolute returnLance Conn
 
Long-term Corporate Finance Project on GlaxoSmithKline Inc.
Long-term Corporate Finance Project on GlaxoSmithKline Inc.Long-term Corporate Finance Project on GlaxoSmithKline Inc.
Long-term Corporate Finance Project on GlaxoSmithKline Inc.nroopraj24
 
1. Our book mentions, An analyst could easily get lost in examini.docx
1. Our book mentions, An analyst could easily get lost in examini.docx1. Our book mentions, An analyst could easily get lost in examini.docx
1. Our book mentions, An analyst could easily get lost in examini.docxjackiewalcutt
 
Entergy Corporation (ETR) Stock Analysis
Entergy Corporation (ETR) Stock AnalysisEntergy Corporation (ETR) Stock Analysis
Entergy Corporation (ETR) Stock AnalysisStock Target Advisor
 
Analysis Based on the above factual data collected and complied
 Analysis Based on the above factual data collected and complied Analysis Based on the above factual data collected and complied
Analysis Based on the above factual data collected and compliedMargaritoWhitt221
 
SSIF Performance Update for Investment Committee - FY2015
SSIF Performance Update for Investment Committee - FY2015SSIF Performance Update for Investment Committee - FY2015
SSIF Performance Update for Investment Committee - FY2015Greg Poapst
 
DSP Equity Oppotunities Fund
DSP Equity Oppotunities FundDSP Equity Oppotunities Fund
DSP Equity Oppotunities FundDSP Mutual Fund
 
2016Q1 SCFG Commentary with Snapshot
2016Q1 SCFG Commentary with Snapshot2016Q1 SCFG Commentary with Snapshot
2016Q1 SCFG Commentary with SnapshotDrew Beja
 
Running Head FINANCIAL ANALYSIS1FINANCIAL ANALYSIS7.docx
Running Head FINANCIAL ANALYSIS1FINANCIAL ANALYSIS7.docxRunning Head FINANCIAL ANALYSIS1FINANCIAL ANALYSIS7.docx
Running Head FINANCIAL ANALYSIS1FINANCIAL ANALYSIS7.docxcharisellington63520
 

Semelhante a 4yrTradeAnalysis_Full-Version (20)

Abacus Weath Partners Investment slideshow
Abacus Weath Partners Investment slideshowAbacus Weath Partners Investment slideshow
Abacus Weath Partners Investment slideshow
 
DSP Top 100 Equity Fund Presentation.pdf
DSP Top 100 Equity Fund Presentation.pdfDSP Top 100 Equity Fund Presentation.pdf
DSP Top 100 Equity Fund Presentation.pdf
 
DSP Top 100 Equity Fund
DSP Top 100 Equity FundDSP Top 100 Equity Fund
DSP Top 100 Equity Fund
 
Gilead Sciences Inc (GILD) Stock Analysis Report
 Gilead Sciences Inc (GILD) Stock Analysis Report Gilead Sciences Inc (GILD) Stock Analysis Report
Gilead Sciences Inc (GILD) Stock Analysis Report
 
Halliburton Company
Halliburton CompanyHalliburton Company
Halliburton Company
 
Wharton Final Report
Wharton Final ReportWharton Final Report
Wharton Final Report
 
DSP Quant Fund
DSP Quant FundDSP Quant Fund
DSP Quant Fund
 
WMT: Walmart Inc. Stock Price, Quote and News
WMT: Walmart Inc. Stock Price, Quote and NewsWMT: Walmart Inc. Stock Price, Quote and News
WMT: Walmart Inc. Stock Price, Quote and News
 
Big Lots Inc (BIG) Stock Analysis Report
Big Lots Inc (BIG) Stock Analysis ReportBig Lots Inc (BIG) Stock Analysis Report
Big Lots Inc (BIG) Stock Analysis Report
 
Gmo absolute return
Gmo absolute returnGmo absolute return
Gmo absolute return
 
Long-term Corporate Finance Project on GlaxoSmithKline Inc.
Long-term Corporate Finance Project on GlaxoSmithKline Inc.Long-term Corporate Finance Project on GlaxoSmithKline Inc.
Long-term Corporate Finance Project on GlaxoSmithKline Inc.
 
1. Our book mentions, An analyst could easily get lost in examini.docx
1. Our book mentions, An analyst could easily get lost in examini.docx1. Our book mentions, An analyst could easily get lost in examini.docx
1. Our book mentions, An analyst could easily get lost in examini.docx
 
Entergy Corporation (ETR) Stock Analysis
Entergy Corporation (ETR) Stock AnalysisEntergy Corporation (ETR) Stock Analysis
Entergy Corporation (ETR) Stock Analysis
 
Analysis Based on the above factual data collected and complied
 Analysis Based on the above factual data collected and complied Analysis Based on the above factual data collected and complied
Analysis Based on the above factual data collected and complied
 
Dfa basic slides 2013
Dfa basic slides 2013Dfa basic slides 2013
Dfa basic slides 2013
 
SSIF Performance Update for Investment Committee - FY2015
SSIF Performance Update for Investment Committee - FY2015SSIF Performance Update for Investment Committee - FY2015
SSIF Performance Update for Investment Committee - FY2015
 
DSP Equity Oppotunities Fund
DSP Equity Oppotunities FundDSP Equity Oppotunities Fund
DSP Equity Oppotunities Fund
 
Ratio analysis
Ratio analysisRatio analysis
Ratio analysis
 
2016Q1 SCFG Commentary with Snapshot
2016Q1 SCFG Commentary with Snapshot2016Q1 SCFG Commentary with Snapshot
2016Q1 SCFG Commentary with Snapshot
 
Running Head FINANCIAL ANALYSIS1FINANCIAL ANALYSIS7.docx
Running Head FINANCIAL ANALYSIS1FINANCIAL ANALYSIS7.docxRunning Head FINANCIAL ANALYSIS1FINANCIAL ANALYSIS7.docx
Running Head FINANCIAL ANALYSIS1FINANCIAL ANALYSIS7.docx
 

4yrTradeAnalysis_Full-Version

  • 1. Tiger Fund |Business Education Complex Baton Rouge, LA 70803 Performance Report For TIGER FUND 4 Year Trading Analysis: 8/1/2011 – 6/30/2015 This report encapsulates the performance of the portfolio for the time period mentioned above. It includes information pertaining to the weights, returns, and risk of the portfolio as well as its respective benchmark, the Russell Top 200 Index.
  • 2. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 1 Table of Contents 1) Key Data......................................................................................................................................................................2 2) Trade Data Analysis....................................................................................................................................................3 3) Holdings Allocation: Top 10 .......................................................................................................................................3 4) Annual Returns...........................................................................................................................................................4 5) Cumulative Returns....................................................................................................................................................5 6) Average Annual Return (AAR) vs. St. Deviation of Returns (SDR)............................................................................6 7) Attribution..................................................................................................................................................................7 8) Holdings by Sector......................................................................................................................................................8 9) Max / Min Weights by Sector ....................................................................................................................................9 10) Annual Sector Weights.........................................................................................................................................10 11) Beta, Correlation, R2 & Other Ratios....................................................................................................................13 Student Managed Investment Fund................................................................................................................................14 Course Suggestions...........................................................................................................................................................14 Student Focused Recommendations ...............................................................................................................................14
  • 3. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 2 Tiger Fund July 2015 Period Analyzed - 8/1/2011 - 6/30/2015 Analysts: Daniel Dowd Jason Wyman Steve Taylor The Tiger Fund is a student managed investment fund which is part of the LSU Foundation. Within a top down approach, undergraduate and graduate students managed the fund, which is benchmarked against the Russell 200 Top 200 index. 1) Key Data The Tiger Fund has consistently underperformed its primary benchmark, the Russell Top 200. The Tiger Fund has averaged an annualized return of 14.29%, while the Russell Top 200 has averaged 15.36% over the period analyzed, 8/1/2011 - 6/30/2015. In addition, the Tiger Fund has proven to be riskier than its benchmark. From a total risk perspective, the standard deviation of returns for the Tiger Fund has been 13.28%, while its benchmark standard deviation was 12.75%. From a systemic risk perspective, the Tiger Fund has been slightly more risky, having a Beta of 1.01 relative to the Russell Top 200. While the Tiger Fund has a higher risk profile, it has also under-performed its benchmark on an absolute basis. Of course this causes the risk adjusted performance to lag more dramatically than the absolute performance, as evidenced by both the Sharpe and Treynor ratios being less than the benchmark. Both ratios indicate that the Tiger Fund is not getting as much return per unit of risk as the benchmark. In addition, risk appears to be asymmetric, as evidenced by the upside/downside capture ratios. Upside capture for the fund is 98.7%, while the fund is capturing 107.44% of the downside of the index. Figure 1 Key Data
  • 4. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 3 2) Trade Data Analysis In analyzing the Tiger Fund, we have determined one of the major drags to performance has been the decision making, specifically the buy decisions, by each class. On average, the decisions made by classes, who serve as portfolio managers, have reduced return, while adding volatility to the portfolio. We examined trade data over the period to determine the average buy decisions made by the class, underperformed their sell decisions by 2.32% over the first six months after the decision and 1.51% over the first twelve months. In addition, the buy decisions have underperformed the benchmark by an average of 12.61% over the first six months and 9.31% over the first twelve months. While the buy decisions have been disappointing, the sell decisions have been good. The sells actually underperformed the benchmark over the six and twelve month period. Unfortunately, the buy decisions underperformed the sell decisions. 3) Holdings Allocation: Top 10 Certainly as a top down focused process, sector selection also plays an important role as a driver of performance. Over the period analyzed, sector selection has contributed 5.51% drag to total return of the portfolio. However, if it were not for the exceptionally strong performance of three holdings that have added to relative performance, the results would be much worse. Gilead Sciences, Disney and CVS have added 6.31%, 3.14% and 2.51% relative performance to the fund, respectively, for a cumulative 11.96% of relative performance increase. While there has been a slight increase in exposure to Gilead and a larger increase in exposure to CVS, those positions existed prior to the beginning of our analysis. Certainly those positions serve to mask an even worse situation. Without the positive selection attribution of those companies, sector attribution would be about 280 basis points worse. It appears as though part of the problem might be inconsistency of thought process. What we noticed through the trade analysis is that classes tended to “undo” trades that a prior class might have made. As demonstrated by the portfolio’s turnover of 39%, much of the portfolio is turned over each year. While there are several long term holdings, many of the larger holdings have been bought and sold relatively frequently, leading to the volatility and performance drag. Overall, the management of the fund has been concerning on both an absolute and risk adjusted basis. Figure 2 Trade Data Analysis Figure 3 Holdings Allocation: Top 10
  • 5. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 4 4) Annual Returns Figure 4 Annual Returns Chart Figure 5 Annual Returns Graph
  • 6. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 5 5) Cumulative Returns Further analysis of the 4 year term provide findings that the Relative Total Returns over the period from (8/1/2011 - 6/30/2015) would be 12% worse without GILD, DIS and CVS. Figure 6 Cumulative Returns Graph
  • 7. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 6 6) Average Annual Return (AAR) vs. St. Deviation of Returns (SDR) Figure 7 Average Annual Returns vs. Standard Deviation Chart Figure 8 Average Annual Returns vs. Standard Deviation Graph
  • 8. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 7 7) Attribution Based on the chart below, when looking at specific sector selection, ie. Underweight/overweight sectors, the fund has negative allocation attribution for 7 out of 10 sectors examined. Fortunately strong relative performance of Gilead, Disney and CVS helped balance out the total attribution of health care, consumer discretionary and staples. Stock selection in technology and durables both exhibited poor selection that hurt the overall sector attribution. Caterpillar was a major drag in durables, while numerous stocks contributed to the drag in technology. Figure 9 Attribution
  • 9. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 8 8) Holdings by Sector Figure 10 Holdings by Sector
  • 10. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 9 9) Max / Min Weights by Sector Figure 11 Max/Min Weights by Sector (1-5) Figure 12 Max/Min Weights by Sector (6-10)
  • 11. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 10 10) Annual Sector Weights Figure 13 Sector Weights Year 2011 Figure 14 Sector Weights Year 2012
  • 12. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 11 Figure 15 Sector Weights Year 2013 Figure 16 Sector Weights Year 2014
  • 13. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 12 Figure 17 Sector Weights Year 2015
  • 14. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 13 11) Beta, Correlation, R2 & Other Ratios Figure 18 Beta, Correlation, R2 & Other Ratios
  • 15. Tiger Fund Performance Report Page 14 Student Managed Investment Fund The large cap U.S equity market is extremely competitive and highly efficient. Even the most seasoned investment professionals with robust research staff have a difficult time out performing the U.S large cap benchmarks. Therefore it is not surprising that the Tiger Fund has performed mediocrely over the past years, never truly exceeding the benchmark. We think this is simply due to the inexperience our students have when engaging the stock market. We understand the class has the dual mandate to learn while gaining real life experience. To help students better maximize investments in the future, we have come up with some suggestions. We certainly understand that the fund has a dual mandate of educating students as well as superior relative performance. With that understanding, some of these recommendations might hamper the mandate of educating students. Course Suggestions 1) Constrain the decision making power of the class a) Possibly narrowing the +/- 50% rule 2) Add another prerequisite to the course a) With only Finance 3716 required to take this class, it could be beneficial for the students to have more/any experience regarding the stock market before entering the Tiger Fund class. Classes currently available are FIN 3826 (basic Investments) and FIN 4830 (analysis of corporate financial statements). 3) Revamp the course a) Many times we have noticed through our research that what one class will do, normally a semester or 2 later it will be undone by other classes. We suggest a new structure to the Tiger Fund course in which: i) PM’s are the advisory board ii) Increase members of the advisory board from 3 to 5 (1) Possibly another asset management professional (2) Alumni ii) Students serve as research analyst for the board 4) Slim down the number of stocks students can choose from a) 200 stocks is a lot for students to analyze each company, possibly through group consensus of the advisory board slim down and give the students certain stocks to concentrate on each semester. Student Focused Recommendations In addition we compiled a few suggestions students in the future could benefit from understanding: 1) Valuations matter a) Almost all valuations are helpful b) Stock price can raise one or a combination of two ways i. Higher P value ii. Increase in company EPS 2) Understand how the market values particular companies a) The market values companies differently. How is it valuing the company you are analyzing i. Price to sales ii. Price to earnings iii. Price to book iv. PEG ration v. Dividend yield 3) Consensus opinion a) Understand the markets consensus on a particular stock and think: 4) Is your consensus similar? If so the stock probably already reflects that view i. Beware of bullish consensus ii. “You pay a high price in the stock market for a rosy consensus” – Warren Buffett 5) Additional Fact Set/Bloomberg training