Climate change is exacerbating rain-related disease risk. Models project significant increases in the frequency and intensity of intense rainfall events in Wisconsin by 2055 due to climate change. More frequent and intense storms increase the risk of waterborne diseases by overwhelming aging infrastructure and increasing pathogen runoff into water sources. Studies have shown increases in acute gastrointestinal illnesses, especially in children, following heavy rainfall events. Contaminated groundwater from failing septic systems also poses a disease risk. Climate change impacts like more frequent extreme rainfall events threaten greater waterborne disease outbreaks unless infrastructure is upgraded and policies are implemented to mitigate risks.
2013 HOW Conference: Climate Change Exacerbates Rain-Related Disease Risk
1. Climate
Change
Exacerbates
Rain-‐Related
Disease
Risk
Michael
Timm
Science
Communica<on
Specialist
Center
for
Water
Policy
School
of
Freshwater
Sciences
University
of
Wisconsin-‐Milwaukee
ma<mm@uwm.edu
c.
414.378.0945
2. Climate
Change
Exacerbates
Rain-‐Related
Disease
Risk
Michael
Campbell
COO
&
Senior
Vice
President
Ruekert/Mielke
Inc.,
Consul<ng
Engineers
mcampbell@ruekert-‐mielke.com
3. Audience:
Who
are
you?
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
NGOs?
Engineers?
Legislators?
Policymakers?
Scien<sts?
Students?
Public
Health
Officers?
Others?
13. More
storms
for
warmer
Wisconsin
Historical
Expected
by
2055
14. Historically,
Wisconsin
is
weger
in
some
areas
and
drier
in
others.
Drier
areas
may
face
added
stormwater
burden.
NOAA
15. Historically
we’ve
already
been
geing
warmer
and
weger
Data
from
1950
to
2006:
• Nighime
lows
temps
up
~1-‐4°F
• Average
annual
day<me
highs
up
~0.5-‐1°F
• Southern
precipita<on
Rainfall
over
S.
Wis.
increased
by
~2-‐4”
• Northern
precipita<on
decreased
by
~1-‐2”
10-‐15%
Kucharik
et
al.
2010
16. The
past
is
no
longer
an
adequate
guide
1950
≠
2006
Shioing
trends
mean
our
pipes
were
not
designed
or
constructed
to
convey
actual
or
expected
flows
17. • 90
million
gallons
of
sewage
overflows
at
61
communi<es
• 700
drinking
water
wells
contaminated
• $34
million
in
damage
claims
paid
Slide
courtesy
of
David
Liebl,
WICCI
18. Reedsburg
2008
Baraboo
River
Flooding
Credit:
WICCI;
UW-‐Extension
-‐
David
S.
Liebl
and
Bill
Bland
20. >?<
%
of
U.S.
waterborne
disease
outbreaks
(1948-‐1994)
preceded
by
top
20%
of
most
intense
storms
Breg
Favre’s
winning
percentage
(games
won
/
total
played)
22. Waterborne
Disease
in
U.S.
• More
than
half
of
U.S.
waterborne
disease
outbreaks
followed
heavy
storms
• Contaminated
water
is
responsible
for
between
6%
and
40%
of
diarrhea-‐related
illness
• Remember
Crypto?
– 403,000
sick
– 69
dead
– $96
million
costs
to
society
– $406
million
in
public
investment
as
cure
Curriero
et
al.
2001;
Gaffield
et
al.
2003;
Corso
et
al.
2003
23. Acute
Diarrhea
(AGI)
• 10%
of
U.S.
hospital
admissions
• 300
U.S.
kids’
deaths
per
year
• $1
billion
in
annual
costs
to
U.S.
society
• Biggest
concern
is
for
kids
age
5
and
under
– Less
immunity
– Smaller
body
size
– More
complica<ons
Elliot
2007
24. Rela<onship
between
rain
&
diarrhea
• 11%
increase
in
AGI
ER
visits
for
kids
four
days
aoer
rainfall
(2002-‐2007
Children’s
Hospital)
• Associated
with
rain,
not
overflows
• Probably
underes<mates
disease
incidence
• These
kids
were
primarily
served
by
surface
waters,
but
highlights
role
of
rain
in
transpor<ng
pathogens
• Pathway/s
not
iden<fied
in
this
study
Drayna
et
al.
2010
25. Kids
seem
to
be
geing
more
sick
from
well
water
than
surface
water
• Another
Children’s
Hospital
study
• Top
3
illness
risk
factors
in
order
of
odds
ra<os:
– Ill
contacts
in
the
home
(2.52)
– Well
water
(1.38)
– Primarily
bogled
water
(1.27)
Gorelick
et
al.
2011
26. Viruses
in
Wisconsin
groundwater
• Diarrhea
linked
with
sep<c
tank
proximity
in
central
Wisconsin
(Marshfield)
– Risk
for
viral
diarrhea
increased
8%
per
addi<onal
holding
tank
per
sec<on
• Viruses
in
pre-‐treated
drinking
water
from
groundwater,
with
sources
both
from
river
and
elsewhere
(La
Crosse)
• Tap
water
from
14
of
14
non-‐disinfec<ng
communi<es
tested
posi<ve
for
viruses
Borchardt
et
al.
2003;
Borchardt
et
al.
2004;
Borchardt
et
al.
2012
27. 2011
Wis.
Act
19
leaves
some
60
communi<es
vulnerable
by
not
requiring
municipal
well
disinfec<on.
~65,000
people
(1.1%
of
Wis.
pop)
and
about
4,000
kids
under
age
5
U.S.
Census
Bureau
Seeley
in
Wisconsin
State
Journal,
2012
28. That’s
just
municipal
systems
• Popula<on
served
by
non-‐community
public
water
systems*
and
private
wells
is
~1.65
million
(28%
of
state
popula<on)
*Public
non-‐municipal
systems
include
sites
like
mobile
home
parks,
hotels,
churches,
schools,
etc.
Source:
Jeff
Helmuth
29. Viruses
in
deep
Madison
groundwater
Data
from
six
wells
from
2007
to
2009
Bradbury
et
al.
2013
How
are
they
geing
there?
30. • Leaky
sanitary
sewer
pipes
implicated,
transported
by
recharge
from
heavy
rains
Bradbury
et
al.
2013
32. Length
of
pipe
under
America
>?<
Dwight
Burdege
Distance
from
Earth
to
Moon
NASA
33. 13
billion
feet
>
1.3
billion
feet
Dwight
Burdege
42
feet
of
pipe
per
capita
NASA
34. Leaky
pipes
Laid
Lifespan
Replacement
1880s
1920s
1950s+
90-‐150
yrs
100
yrs
75
yrs
1970s-‐2030s
2020s
2025+
• Old
sewer
pipes
leak,
pathogens
get
out,
especially
when
hydrology
is
conducive,
e.g.
when
stormwater
changes
the
game
• Old
water
mains
break
(1
per
10
miles
per
year
or
~800/day),
allowing
viruses
to
seep
into
municipal
distribu<on
systems
American
Water
Works
Associa<on
2012;
Folkman
2012
35. Systemic
Vulnerability
• Even
with
best
treatment,
if
the
distribu<on
system
is
vulnerable,
then
we
remain
at
risk
• Proximity
of
water
and
sanitary
pipes:
WI:
8o;
other
states,
10o;
in
reality
there
is
likely
communica<on
when
groundwater
tables
rise
under
heavy
recharge
&
stormwater
flows
• Remember
those
14
non-‐disinfected
communi<es?
The
distribuGon
system
was
implicated
as
the
entry
point
for
viruses
from
sewage.
Lamber<ni
et
al.
2012
36. Wisconsin’s
es<mated
20-‐yr
needs
• $2.5
billion
for
treatment
upgrades
• $3.5
billion
for
distribu<on
upgrades
U.S.
EPA
2007
Wisconsin
budget
priori<es
• $94
million
in
low-‐interest
loans
for
drinking
water
infrastructure
(short
of
projected
20-‐yr
need
by
a
lot)
• State
highways
get
$3.6
billion
over
2
years
Wis
2013
Act
20
37. Then
there
are
leaky
laterals…
Milwaukee
Metropolitan
Sewerage
District
41. Policy
Priori<es
Inventory
state’s
sewer
and
water
• infrastructure
vulnerabili<es.
• Disinfect
all
public
municipal
wells.
Codify
comprehensive
statewide
stormwater
• design
standards.
42. For
example:
ATCP
48.26
• DRAINAGE
CAPACITY.
Every
district
drain
constructed
aoer
July
1,
1995
shall
be
designed
and
constructed
so
that
it
is
capable
of
removing
the
volume
of
water
from
a
10-‐
year
24-‐hour
rainfall
event
within
48
hours
aoer
that
rainfall
event.
For
each
county,
a
10-‐
year
24-‐hour
rainfall
event
is
the
amount
of
rain
shown
in
table
1
falling
in
24
hours.
43. Funding
Priori<es
Invest
$3.5
billion
through
2027
to
bring
•
Wisconsin’s
aging
underground
infrastructure
up
to
date.
The
state
should
assist
municipali<es
in
• incen<vizing
the
replacement
of
privately-‐
owned
sewer
laterals.
44. For
example:
Lateral
Replacement
Incen<ves
• When
the
city
rips
up
the
street
• Madison
offers
75%
of
lateral
replacement
costs
from
main
up
to
property
line
• Marshfield
forgives
replacement
costs
of
lateral
under
public
right-‐of-‐way
if
private
replaced
• 90%
par<cipa<on
w/
opt-‐out
default
45. Research
Priori<es
Research
human
health
risks
of
stormwater
• vs.
sewage
overflows.
Access
broader
health
ata
sets
to
clarify
• rela<onships
between
dainfall
and
disease.
r
46. Out-‐of-‐box
Solu<ons?
• Green
infrastructure
to
promote
infiltra<on
• Waterless
toilet
infrastructure
a
la
Gates
Founda<on
Challenge
in
2012
• Remapping
ci<es
and
towns
to
account
for
hydrology
instead
of
history
47. Where’s
Our
Water?
Out
of
sight,
but
not
out
of
mind
Where’s
My
Water’s
lovable
alligator,
Swampy,
knows
a
thing
or
two
about
failing
pipes
48. Where’s
My
Water?
app
•
•
•
•
•
•
Instant
gra<fica<on
Addic<ve
memes
Widely
disseminated
Youth
oriented
Makes
hidden
visible
Puts
face
to
issue
Use
as
communicaGon
tool
to
reach
your
consGtuencies
hgp://www.flashgamesplayer.com/Free/Where-‐is-‐my-‐Water/Play.html
49. Thank
you!
Michael
Campbell
Jenny
Kehl
Megan
Christenson
Sandra
McLellan
Larry
Timm
Michael
Carvan
David
Liebl
Jeff
Helmuth
Henry
“Andy”
Anderson
Kristen
Malecki
Jonathan
Patz
Deb
Dila
Randy
Metzger
Greg
Barske
Tomorra
Smith
Madeline
Gotkowitz
Marc
Borchardt
Jen
Yauck
Cheryl
Nenn
MMSD
CDC
WDPH
UWM
SFS
CWP
WICCI
Healing
Our
Waters
–
Milwaukee,
Wisconsin
–
2013