SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 11
Baixar para ler offline
Engineers Australia
                ATSE Joint Seminar

Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering
          for Extreme Natural Events

                    Thursday 15th September 2011




                                                        1

                                                   Western Australia Division
Engineers Australia WA Division                 Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011




     Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events


                                                 Abstract



This article describes the purpose, format, content, and recommendations arising from a half-day seminar
held to consider the nature, role and future challenges of Engineering for extreme natural events. In
particular the seminar concentrated on Engineering related to the four areas of earthquake (earth), high-
speed winds (wind), bushfires (fire) and large-amplitude water waves (water). Bringing experts in the
different areas together proved to be invaluable, no more so than in the concluding panel session. The
interaction with the audience also highlighted areas of concern that had not previously been discussed.
Several themes emerged that were general across the four different event areas, most especially the
notion of risk and its meaning for different groups from Engineers through to the general public. This leads
to the question of whether properties and infrastructure more subject to inundation, fire, seismicity or soil
liquefaction have a higher cost for insurance, not be insurable or in some cases be declared unable to be
sold. For such deliberations, it was agreed that an increased understanding and level of communication
across the many different stakeholders is highly desirable.



1. Introduction
2011 has brought into sharp focus the forms and effects of extreme natural events. Earthquakes
in Christchurch and Japan, tropical cyclones in Queensland Australia and the U.S Eastern
Seaboard along with a virulent tornado season in the U.S, bushfires both nationally and around
Perth, Western Australia, the Japanese tsunami in Sendai province and flooding in Brisbane,
Queensland have caused significant fatalities and wrought much damage. The occurrence of
extreme natural events seems to be increasing and climate change may be implicated. It is
therefore timely that the role of Engineering in safeguarding life and property against the effects
of extreme natural events should be considered and assessed.

Engineers Australia (EA) and the Australian Academy of Technological Sciences and
Engineering (ATSE) combined to host a half-day seminar Earth Wind Fire Water – Engineering
for Extreme Events held at Curtin University, Perth on the15 th September 2011. This seminar
linked to, and developed from, the seminar City to Cape – 2100 sea-level rise mounted by
ATSE, EA and Curtin University on the 22 nd July 2010 and its arising published report [1].

The theme of the seminar reported upon herein was the contributions of Engineering to
controlling the adverse effects arising from extreme natural events: earthquake, storm, bushfire
and inundation. In tandem, the seminar served to raise awareness of humanitarian engineering,
EA‟s 2011 focus, as an crucial arm of Engineering through the preservation of life and property
in the face of, and after, devastating natural events. The seminar also sought to communicate
the special challenges associated with designing and preparing for extreme natural events.

The seminar comprised four main presentations, each focusing on one of the extreme-event
sub-themes under the shorthand titles, earth, wind, fire and water. These are reported upon in
Section 2. Speakers were asked to establish the nature of the problem; highlight challenges for
engineers, scientists, disaster managers and planners; suggest what could be done better; and
to include reference to social or management challenges and the special plight of developing
communities in such circumstances. While it was not expected that each of the four speakers
could address all of these aspects, they were addressed in one form or another through the
seminar presentations taken in their totality.

The presentations were followed by a panel discussion that drew out common threads,
identifying challenges and matters of concern, that apply broadly to Engineering and its role,
responsibilities and contributions across all extreme natural events. This discussion and the
recommendations that emerged from it are summarised in Section 3. In addition to EA and
                                                                                                                                2
Engineers Australia WA Division             Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011



ATSE membership, the target audience of the seminar included people with a professional
interest in the impact of the topic and the capacity to act on the subjects of the presentations
including State government, local government, planners, academics, business and industry as
well as the members of the general public.

The overall message that emerges is clear in that engineering education and practice needs to
accommodate the prospects of a greater frequency and greater severity of natural disasters.
Decision-makers, planners, engineers and architects need to work together to increase the rate
of structural survival following earthquakes, cyclones, bushfires, deluges and coastal inundation.
Regulators and the insurance industry need to consider limiting risk, recognising the
compounding of hazard and frequency, and all parties need to re-embrace the Precautionary
Principle, based upon sound data and well-established knowledge.



2. Findings Reported
What follows is a summary of key points that emerged from each of the four presentations. Note
that the titles and abstracts of the presentation and speaker biographies are presented as
Appendix 1, while the slides for each of the presentations and the iLecture (speaker audio
synchronised with slides) of the entire seminar are available at [2].



2.1 Earth – Presenter: Dr David Brunsdon

This presentation highlighted the risks of failure, the need for risk management and the role of
engineers. „Risk‟ is a function of both likelihood and potential damage. Its management can be
summarised by the 4Rs of risk: reduction, readiness, response, recovery. Accounting for risk in
design covers the spectrum: avoid, transfer, control, accept. The focus for Engineering is usually
upon „control‟ whereas effective risk-management includes all four parts of the spectrum.
Accordingly, Engineers need to increase their involvement more widely, especially in
communicating and sharing their expertise with other professionals such as planners and
architects.

Risk-reduction strategies for infrastructure development should be applied at each of three
stages, these being (i) „Site yet to be developed‟ (site selection and planning with regard to
potential hazards such as liquefaction and fall or collapse of geologic material), (ii) „[Site]
Developed, but not built (applying necessary design considerations and building regulations),
and (iii) „Built, existing infrastructure‟ (reviewing against standards). It was noted that the
appropriate implementation of these strategies is being affected by sea-level rise for coastal
developments.

The community tends to focus on the consequences of failure, whereas engineers tend to focus
on the likelihood (e.g. the 100 year earthquake). These two outlooks need to be combined. For
example, a rating of „low seismicity‟ indicates that the average time between events is large but it
does not mean that all events are small.

The presentation highlighted some of the dilemmas of design for earthquakes. Buildings may
need to have good escape systems, but the best way to survive an earthquake is by remaining
within a resilient building during the shaking event, as falling masonry often renders the
surroundings of the building unsafe. The escape system is needed to exit the damaged building
after the event.

Building design needs to take into account post-disaster use; design for damage tolerance or
design for damage resistance. For example, hospitals, assembly halls and emergency services
buildings need to remain in operation after the event.



                                                                                                                            3
Engineers Australia WA Division               Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011



Finally, the presentation addressed the role of Engineering in the aftermath of a severe
earthquake, in the first instance triaging buildings in the affected area to aid search and rescue
operations, assessing the safety of entry to „pancaked‟ buildings and, later, leading engineering
work to permit entry to collapsed buildings in the search for survivors.



2.2 Wind – Presenter: Mr Charles Boyle

This presentation focused on the need to blend traditional and modern western knowledge to
find building solutions for developing countries, using the Solomon Islands as an example. There
is a tendency in the Solomon Islands to view European housing as „better‟ as a result of
aspirations being set by former colonial administrations or present „Western‟ influences.
However, such housing is costly, complex in construction and maintenance, and can be
culturally intrusive. Instead, the appropriate use of local materials and techniques combined with
western structural-engineering knowledge can produce greatly improved and culturally
appropriate outcomes with buildings that are cyclone resistant.

Thus, for example, the lack of continuity between the floor, walls and roof of traditional buildings
leads to complete loss of the building in high winds. A blended design that utilises corrugated
steel roofing tied through the walls to the ground produces a far more resilient building, yet does
not alter the traditional floor plan and can make use of many of the local materials (e.g.
bamboo).

The presentation cautioned against „transitional‟ buildings that comprise an ad-hoc, or ill-
considered, combination of local and western materials and designs. Correct hybrid building
approaches need to be carefully engineered to yield techniques and material use that realise
complementary benefits of the traditional and the modern. Hybrid technology requires a
systematic approach that includes the documentation of traditional learning and skills,
established wisdoms and local materials that will be trialled or adapted to work effectively with
modern materials and techniques. In the subsequent design phase of hybrid buildings,
prototyping trials (at all scales, from fixing techniques through to entire building) are essential.
The roles of the administrating organisation, most effectively undertaken by NGOs, was
emphasised to ensure continuity of process, dissemination and adoption of new hybrid
techniques.



2.3 Fire – Presenter: Mr Ralph Smith

This presentation communicated the lessons learned from the Roleystone and Toodyay fires of
recent years in Western Australia. However, many of the causes of and means to reduce
damage are broadly applicable to other regions and situations. In particular, a range of data was
presented that demonstrated two main points:

         Reducing the fuel loads surrounding buildings, both the Building Protection Zone (BPZ)
         and Hazard Protection Zone (HPZ), by proper property management reduces the energy
         release rate to a point where the fire can be controlled using water. If this is not done,
         then the fire cannot be extinguished.

         Regardless of the main building cladding materials (e.g. brick, iron), buildings are not fire
         resistant if there are any entry points for embers. The vast majority of houses lost in the
         fires studied were the result of ember attack some distance away from the main fire.
         Typical ember entry arises from rooftop evaporative air-conditioners, lack of boxed eaves
         and, often, a lack of common sense in the identification of vulnerabilities.

The risk of fire damage can be significantly reduced by following existing well-developed
standards and easy-to-understand guidelines for property owners. A major challenge lies in

                                                                                                                              4
Engineers Australia WA Division              Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011



persuading planners to adopt, councils to enforce and the public take the actions that can
dramatically mitigate the effects of bush/forest fires.



2.4 Water – Presenter: Prof Chari Pattiaratchi

This presentation highlighted the destructive nature of a tsunami and the complicated nature of
the phenomenon. Earthquake-induced waves are refracted and reflected by subsea topography
and coastlines, leading to enormous variations in the strength of the waves as they strike
different parts of the coast. Reflected waves may in fact lead to larger tsunamis that reach a
coast many hours after the original incident waves. Understanding the topography of the
extended region is therefore a key to identifying potential tsunami events.

Meteorological tsunamis can also be induced by storms moving across the surface of the ocean
and these can be as important, through their frequency, as the more dramatic geologic
tsunamis. Thus, along the coast of Western Australia a meteorological tsunami that generates a
wave-height of one metre is very significant when it impacts the southern part of the state for
which the tidal range is approximately only 0.5 metres. Clearly, the frequency of such tsunamis
increases with the increased frequency of storm events associated with climate change.

The presentation described the advanced tsunami prediction models that are currently available
to assist in early warning and prediction of the level of likely inundation resulting from tsunamis
produced by both geological and storm events. Even with a predictive capability, implementing
coastal and beach responses remains complex with appropriate actions depending upon a
combination of factors that may be local to each particular region impacted by the tsunami.

Modelling and data-analysis also evidences the impact of sea-level rise on increasing the
strength and frequency of tsunamis, noting that the current 100 year flooding event may be
expected to occur on a monthly basis by 2050 if sea levels continue to rise at the rate they have
been doing so over the last 100 years. Accordingly more effective communication to and
understanding by planners and decision-makers for coastal regions is essential.



3. Discussion and recommendations
Several points were made during the discussions, with a focus on changes needed to the
education of scientists and engineers, and of governments and regulators and the general public
that utilise their services. Overall the key elements and recommendations are as follows.

         There is no escape from natural disaster. From city centres to rural communities, from
         the coast to the mountains, there is the potential for natural disasters in one or more
         forms, be they inundation, earthquake, fire or storm. The effects of global warming are
         increasing the likelihood of extreme events related to all but earthquake. The magnitude
         and frequency of global natural disasters appears to be increasing and whatever the
         cause we need to engineer to reduce the impact of compounded effects.

         The problems of designing and preparing for natural disasters cannot be completely
         solved using existing knowledge. This is true for developed and particularly true in
         regard to developing nations, where cultural factors and resource limitations may render
         modern „developed‟ technologies and practices inappropriate. Innovative thinking is
         needed, and a willingness to understand local techniques and materials, in order to blend
         effectively traditional and western knowledge.         In developed countries, similar
         considerations may also apply. Throughout, however, the continuing policies of
         developers and regulators to encourage building of infrastructure close to the water table
         or a flood plain possibility must be reined in.


                                                                                                                             5
Engineers Australia WA Division                 Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011



         Service to the community is to be encouraged. Apart from the obvious community and
         humanitarian outcomes, this is an ideal way for engineers, technologists and managers
         to understand the competing demands and influences that must be addressed in any
         truly effective solution.

         Engineers and Scientists are not very well prepared for working with uncertainty. Clients
         are nearly always looking for the cheapest solution, but decreasing the risk of damage
         from natural disasters usually increases the costs. Such factors are often not taken into
         account as a result. Professionals should be more willing to lay out the risks and
         consequences, and to offer a range of solutions that mitigate risks at different levels.

         Engineers need to understand and manage the balance between risk and consequence
         in their design work and decisions, and to broaden their involvement to all stages in the
         development of infrastructure. Current obstacles that need to be overcome include:
         Engineers usually communicate through indirect channels that may be insufficiently
         forceful; it is difficult for Society to understand „risk‟ as a parameter worked with by
         Engineers; media reporting and language can be misleading - for example, it is
         preferable to use „intensity‟ instead of „magnitude‟ in earthquake descriptions.

         Government and insurance industry decisions can have a large impact on disaster
         mitigation, either by taking firm action to prevent development in areas prone to disaster
         (e.g. flood plains) or to make prohibitive the cost of insuring in risky situations.


4. Concluding Remarks
The design of the seminar proved to be very effective for the delivery of its expected outcomes.
Combining sometimes disparate disciplines that separately address Engineering for extreme
natural events, and bringing together experts in these areas, served to identify factors,
shortcomings and recommendations that cut across the different disciplines and which can
perhaps be better tackled at an all-of-Engineering level. Overall, the seminar concluded that
extreme natural events are becoming more frequent and that this warrants an increased focus
on the concomitant engineering challenges both within developed and developing communities
in order to find solutions that are technically effective while also being socially and commercially
appropriate.



                                          Acknowledgement
The authors and organisers of the seminar are grateful for the support of Curtin University for
providing the seminar venue and administrative support through Ms Sucy Leong.



                                               References
[1]      R.J. Purdy, A.D. Lucey and R.E. Smith 2010. City to Cape: 2100 Sea-level Rise, Seminar Report,
         Pub.: The Australian Academy of Technological Sciences and Engineering, ISBN 978 1 921388
         17 0. (Also available as a .pdf document at www.atse.org.au)

[2]      D. Brunsdon, C. Boyle, R. Smith and C. Pattiaratchi, 2011. Presentation slides and iLecture for
         Earth, Wind, Fire Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events seminar. At:
         www.engineersaustralia.wa.events and www.atse.org.au




                                                                                                                                6
Engineers Australia WA Division                   Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011



                                                Appendix 1:
          Titles and abstracts of speaker presentations and author biographies


                                                   EARTH

Planning and Design for Earthquakes: Consequences and Opportunities

Mr Dave Brunsdon
New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering

Engineers have a key role in reducing the risk to the community from extreme natural hazard events.
While it is implicit in much of what professional engineers do on a day to day basis as they apply design
codes, the wider context of this risk mitigation work is not always fully appreciated, particularly for complex
hazards such as earthquake.
The effective mitigation of urban earthquake risk involves consideration of the following elements:
         Understanding of the components of seismic hazard, and in particular the threat of permanent
         ground deformation;
         Conveying seismic risk to urban planners (what the consequences are of developing on at-risk
         land);
         Ensuring that building codes provide for an appropriate level of seismic resistance, and function
         within an effective regulatory framework;
         Having appropriate arrangements (both technical and regulatory) in place for assessing and
         strengthening potential at-risk older building stock;
         Ensuring that both the construction and renewal of infrastructure assets includes seismic
         resilience considerations
A key enabler that sits across these elements is establishing and conveying the consequences of seismic
hazards on the built environment. Professional engineers are uniquely placed to undertake this role, and
indeed have the responsibility to do so. In the current climate of strong awareness of natural hazard
threats, this represents a significant opportunity to make a difference.
This presentation will cover each of these earthquake risk mitigation aspects, drawing upon the
September 2009 Padang earthquake and the Canterbury earthquake series of 2010/11 as case study
examples.

Biography

Dave is a Fellow and Past-President of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, and is a
member of the Australian Earthquake Engineering Society and the Institution of Engineers Australia. He
is a director of Kestrel Group Ltd, a New Zealand-based consulting practice specialising in strategic
emergency management planning for local and central government agencies and infrastructure providers.

In 2009, Dave led a team of NZ engineers to assist government agencies following the devastating
Padang earthquake in Indonesia. In September last year he co-ordinated the building safety evaluation
process immediately following the Darfield, Canterbury earthquake, and in February he led the NZ USAR
Engineering team during the response to the Christchurch aftershock. He continues to be closely involved
in activities relating to the building recovery process there.



                                                    WIND

Advancing Cyclone Resistant Construction Practices with Local Communities in the
Solomon Islands

Mr Charles Boyle
Architect/Project Manager, Curtin University

While engineered timber frame construction can be formally designed quantified and quality controlled,
traditional building practices are too varied in both the level of skill and quality of materials to be similarly
                                                                                                                                  7
Engineers Australia WA Division                  Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011



assessed. Being as much an issue of social dynamics, anthropology and material culture, the latter falls
as much within the domain of the architect as that of the structural engineer.

While a high population growth, urban growth, land ownership and general development aspirations have
seen Solomon Islanders aspire to better housing, the economic conditions of a country still recovering
from what was in effect a civil war constrain affordability and educational opportunity.

In the informal housing sector this typically sees traditional materials used to emulate modern timber
framed building construction, or the use of modern building materials to traditional construction methods,
an approach favoured for re-construction by the government following 1985 cyclone Namu and which
stimulated Charles‟ interest in disaster mitigation through better building practice and his work with the
Australian Overseas Disaster Response Organisation, Ausaid and UNIDO.

The presentation will explore some of the dynamics of housing aspirations in Solomon Islands, and how
traditional building methods and modern technology morph into hybrid forms of construction, and the
significance this may have on the risks during cyclone events.

Starting with a basic inquiry into traditional construction practices in Solomon Islands, Charles will discuss
the work of Hybrid Technology, a not-for-profit NGO established in parallel with his own commercial
architectural practice and how it developed small disaster-resistant buildings and explored discrete
improvements to traditional buildings to successfully enhance cyclone resistance in Solomon Islands.

Biography

UK trained and registered, Charles took up a position in a small architectural practice in Solomon Islands
in the early 1980‟s. Following a major cyclone that killed over 100 people and destroyed several thousand
homes, he assisted in the establishment of a local building materials council, and established a not for
profit NGO “Hybrid Technology” to research and better understand traditional building practices and
develop methods of building using local materials and available skills.



                                                   FIRE

Lessons Learnt from the Recent Bushfires

Mr Ralph Smith
Branch Manager, Bush Fire & Environmental Protection,
Fire & Emergency Services Authority of WA

Since 2008 FESA has initiated a process following a bushfire event, were specialist staff analyse why
houses were damaged and destroyed while other houses in the vicinity did not suffer any damage.

In recent years, FESA has surveyed the bushland and houses in the Parkerville, Toodyay, Lake Clifton
and Roleystone / Kelmscott fire affected areas. These surveys have been conducted on houses that were
destroyed, houses that were damaged and houses that suffered no damage. The surveys have
considered the building construction standards, as prescribed in Australian Standard 3959 Construction of
buildings in bushfire-prone areas, the building protection zone (20 metre circle of safety), the hazard
separation zone (up to 100 metres from the house) and the landscape zone vegetation, including the fuel
load and the fire behaviour.

Land use planning and the subsequent developments that occur have a significant effect on the
emergency services that are required to try and protect those communities during a period of adversity.
Frequently these developments occur in the bushland interface areas where there are continuous bushfire
fuels within the landscapes.

To assist developers, local government and State government agencies, FESA in partnership with the
Department of Planning and the WA Planning Commission have developed and published Planning for
Bush Fire Protection Guidelines. The 2010 guidelines have been developed in accordance with clause 6
of State Planning Policy 3.4 Natural Hazards and Disasters (SPP 3.4). The guidelines replace DC 3.7 Fire
Planning and the first edition of Planning for Bush Fire Protection (2001), which were released by the
WAPC and FESA in December 2001. A current and second edition of the Planning for Bush Fire
                                                                                                                                 8
Engineers Australia WA Division                  Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011



Protection Guidelines, was released in 2010. The guidelines have been linked to Australian Standard
3959 – Construction of buildings in bushfire-prone areas which were published in 1999 and revised in
2009, 2010 and 2011.

FESA provides advice on planning developments, separation distances between the house and the
vegetation, construction standards, fuel loads and vegetation management. These are all factors in the
survivability of houses attacked by a bushfire. The analysis by FESA seeks to identify why the houses are
damaged or destroyed, if there are any weaknesses in the advice provided by FESA and how the damage
or destruction can be avoided in the future.

Biography

Ralph commenced working in the mid-1970s as a field officer with the Forests Department. Ralph worked
for 26 years with the Forests Department and the Department of Conservation and Land Management. In
2001 Ralph moved to the Fire and Emergency Services Authority as the Manager of Wildfire Prevention.
In 2004 Ralph was promoted to the position of Branch Manager of Bush Fire and Environmental
Protection within the Fire and Emergency Services Authority.

Ralph has extensive knowledge and understanding of bush fire behaviour and the impact that the fire
behaviour can have on buildings and the environment. Ralph has served as an Australian Fire and
Emergency Services Authorities Council (AFAC) representative on the technical working group for the
“Australian Standard 3959 Construction of buildings in bushfire-prone areas”. Ralph has also been a co-
author of the planning guidelines document “Planning for Bush Fire Protection” for both the 2001 and
2010 editions.

Ralph and his team have undertaken analysis of the complex bush fire behaviour and house loss
assessments for all of the recent significant Western Australian bush fire events. Ralph was also invited
to work with the Victorian‟s undertaking bush fire investigations during the Black Saturday fires.

Ralph‟s work has been recognised with a number of State and National awards for bush fire arson
prevention, and the research and publications associated with the “Bush Fire Management Guidelines for
Western Australia”.



                                                 WATER

Coastal Hazards and the Design of Coastal Structures

Winthrop Professor Charitha Pattiaratchi
University of Western Australia

The importance and impacts of coastal hazards, particularly extreme events such as tsunamis and storm
surges, has been illustrated very graphically through recent events such as the Japanese earthquake in
March and Cyclone Yasi. During both of these events, extreme inundation of coastal areas occurred
resulting in significant damage to infrastructure. In this presentation, different processes which contribute
to coastal sea level variability leading to extreme events will be reviewed with an emphasis on Western
Australia. It is shown that these processes occur over a range timescales ranging from seconds to
centuries and are subject to long-term variability some of which, such as those due to astronomical tides,
may be predicted.

The action of the wind on the sea surface generates surface gravity waves with periods of the order of
10s. Although the swell waves are generated in the deeper ocean they have a major influence in coastal
regions. Globally, the astronomical forces of the Sun and the Moon result in tidal variability with periods of
12 and 24 hours as well as tidal modulations with periods up to 18.6 years. In many regions, the effects of
the tides dominate the water level variability – however, in regions where the tidal effects are small other
processes also become important in determining the local water level. In this presentation, sea level data
from Fremantle (tidal range ~0.5m), which has one of the longest time series records in the southern
hemisphere, and other sea level recoding stations from Western Australia are presented to highlight the
different processes ranging from seiches, tsunamis (generated through earthquakes and thunderstorms),
tides, storm surges, continental shelf waves, annual and inter-annual variability. As the contribution from
each of these processes is of the same order of magnitude they all contribute to the extreme sea levels.
                                                                                                                                 9
Engineers Australia WA Division                       Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011




The majority of existing coastal infrastructure in Australia was designed to tolerate or at least survive
occasional effects from extreme sea levels (e.g., 1 in 100 or l in 1,000 year prospects of inundation). As a
result of coastal hazards, including mean sea level rise due to global warming, these designed tolerances
will be exceeded with increasing frequency. The implications for changes in return periods on coastal
infrastructure in Western Australia will be discussed.

Biography

Charitha Pattiaratchi is a Winthrop professor of coastal oceanography at the School of Environmental
Systems Engineering, the University of Western Australia. His research interests are in coastal physical
oceanography and coastal sediment transport, using field and numerical modelling techniques. He
obtained a BSc (joint honours in oceanography and applied mathematics), MSc and PhD (both in
oceanography) from the University of Wales, Swansea, UK. He has been at UWA since 1988.

Currently his affiliations includes Leader, Australian National Facility for Ocean Gliders, Node leader, West
Australian Integrated Marine Observation System (WAIMOS), Chair, Numerical modelling, forecasting and
scenario development working group of the Indian Ocean Tsunami Warning System, Chair, Physics of
Estuaries and Coastal Seas International conference.

He has supervised over 100 honours students and 30 postgraduate students and published over 100
refereed journal articles.




                       Note: Photograph of the speakers (during the panel session) below
                 (L to R): Prof Charitha Pattiaratchi; Mr Ralph Smith; Mr David Brunsdon; Mr Charles Boyle




                                                                                                                                      10
Engineers Australia WA Division
                             712 Murray Street
                             West Perth WA 6005
                             Phone: (08) 9321 3340
                             Fax: (08) 9481 4332
                             Email: wa@engineersaustralia.org.au
                             Web: www.engineersaustralia.org.au/wa
Western Australia Division

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Disaster Resilience: A National Imperative - Susan Cutter
Disaster Resilience: A National Imperative - Susan CutterDisaster Resilience: A National Imperative - Susan Cutter
Disaster Resilience: A National Imperative - Susan CutterEERI
 
DEIR Resiliency Plan San Tim Canyon
DEIR Resiliency Plan San Tim CanyonDEIR Resiliency Plan San Tim Canyon
DEIR Resiliency Plan San Tim CanyonBrian Robey
 
Enhance Community Resilience to Landslide Hazards
Enhance Community Resilience to Landslide HazardsEnhance Community Resilience to Landslide Hazards
Enhance Community Resilience to Landslide HazardsGlobal Risk Forum GRFDavos
 
Facing a Disaster & Safety Measures Tips
Facing  a Disaster & Safety Measures TipsFacing  a Disaster & Safety Measures Tips
Facing a Disaster & Safety Measures TipsPeter Prasanta Debbarma
 
Towards an Efficient and Robust Wireless Disaster Management Architecture for...
Towards an Efficient and Robust Wireless Disaster Management Architecture for...Towards an Efficient and Robust Wireless Disaster Management Architecture for...
Towards an Efficient and Robust Wireless Disaster Management Architecture for...IEEEP Karachi
 
Man made disasters
Man made disastersMan made disasters
Man made disastersgurpreet1111
 
Day 2 for 2018 copyright ver.
Day 2 for 2018 copyright ver.Day 2 for 2018 copyright ver.
Day 2 for 2018 copyright ver.YuriOki
 
Building sector strategies for climate change
Building sector strategies for climate changeBuilding sector strategies for climate change
Building sector strategies for climate changeNils Larsson
 
Building sector strategies for climate change
Building sector strategies for climate changeBuilding sector strategies for climate change
Building sector strategies for climate changeNils Larsson
 
ICLR Friday Forum: Storm surge - lessons from Hurricane Sandy (September 3, 2...
ICLR Friday Forum: Storm surge - lessons from Hurricane Sandy (September 3, 2...ICLR Friday Forum: Storm surge - lessons from Hurricane Sandy (September 3, 2...
ICLR Friday Forum: Storm surge - lessons from Hurricane Sandy (September 3, 2...glennmcgillivray
 
Part5 disaster-management-risk-mitigation
Part5 disaster-management-risk-mitigationPart5 disaster-management-risk-mitigation
Part5 disaster-management-risk-mitigationzaffar abbasi
 
Unicef Training September New York September 2009
Unicef Training September New York September 2009Unicef Training September New York September 2009
Unicef Training September New York September 2009cbachofen
 
Adults - Wildfires - Prevention
Adults - Wildfires - PreventionAdults - Wildfires - Prevention
Adults - Wildfires - PreventionNCC-CCT
 
ROLE OF ENGINEERS IN DISASTER MANAGEMENT
ROLE OF ENGINEERS IN DISASTER MANAGEMENTROLE OF ENGINEERS IN DISASTER MANAGEMENT
ROLE OF ENGINEERS IN DISASTER MANAGEMENTmadalone
 
Disaster management overview
Disaster management overviewDisaster management overview
Disaster management overviewNandeesh Laxetty
 

Mais procurados (20)

Jnu 19 mar16
Jnu 19 mar16Jnu 19 mar16
Jnu 19 mar16
 
Disaster Resilience: A National Imperative - Susan Cutter
Disaster Resilience: A National Imperative - Susan CutterDisaster Resilience: A National Imperative - Susan Cutter
Disaster Resilience: A National Imperative - Susan Cutter
 
DEIR Resiliency Plan San Tim Canyon
DEIR Resiliency Plan San Tim CanyonDEIR Resiliency Plan San Tim Canyon
DEIR Resiliency Plan San Tim Canyon
 
Enhance Community Resilience to Landslide Hazards
Enhance Community Resilience to Landslide HazardsEnhance Community Resilience to Landslide Hazards
Enhance Community Resilience to Landslide Hazards
 
Disaster management 2
Disaster management 2Disaster management 2
Disaster management 2
 
Facing Disasters & Safety Measures Tips
Facing  Disasters & Safety Measures TipsFacing  Disasters & Safety Measures Tips
Facing Disasters & Safety Measures Tips
 
Facing a Disaster & Safety Measures Tips
Facing  a Disaster & Safety Measures TipsFacing  a Disaster & Safety Measures Tips
Facing a Disaster & Safety Measures Tips
 
Towards an Efficient and Robust Wireless Disaster Management Architecture for...
Towards an Efficient and Robust Wireless Disaster Management Architecture for...Towards an Efficient and Robust Wireless Disaster Management Architecture for...
Towards an Efficient and Robust Wireless Disaster Management Architecture for...
 
Man made disasters
Man made disastersMan made disasters
Man made disasters
 
Day 2 for 2018 copyright ver.
Day 2 for 2018 copyright ver.Day 2 for 2018 copyright ver.
Day 2 for 2018 copyright ver.
 
Considerations in the epidemiology of earthquake injuries
Considerations in the epidemiology of earthquake injuriesConsiderations in the epidemiology of earthquake injuries
Considerations in the epidemiology of earthquake injuries
 
Building sector strategies for climate change
Building sector strategies for climate changeBuilding sector strategies for climate change
Building sector strategies for climate change
 
Building sector strategies for climate change
Building sector strategies for climate changeBuilding sector strategies for climate change
Building sector strategies for climate change
 
ICLR Friday Forum: Storm surge - lessons from Hurricane Sandy (September 3, 2...
ICLR Friday Forum: Storm surge - lessons from Hurricane Sandy (September 3, 2...ICLR Friday Forum: Storm surge - lessons from Hurricane Sandy (September 3, 2...
ICLR Friday Forum: Storm surge - lessons from Hurricane Sandy (September 3, 2...
 
Part5 disaster-management-risk-mitigation
Part5 disaster-management-risk-mitigationPart5 disaster-management-risk-mitigation
Part5 disaster-management-risk-mitigation
 
Unicef Training September New York September 2009
Unicef Training September New York September 2009Unicef Training September New York September 2009
Unicef Training September New York September 2009
 
Adults - Wildfires - Prevention
Adults - Wildfires - PreventionAdults - Wildfires - Prevention
Adults - Wildfires - Prevention
 
ROLE OF ENGINEERS IN DISASTER MANAGEMENT
ROLE OF ENGINEERS IN DISASTER MANAGEMENTROLE OF ENGINEERS IN DISASTER MANAGEMENT
ROLE OF ENGINEERS IN DISASTER MANAGEMENT
 
Disaster overview
Disaster overviewDisaster overview
Disaster overview
 
Disaster management overview
Disaster management overviewDisaster management overview
Disaster management overview
 

Destaque

Cassilis Hydro Electric Scheme Slide Presentation August 2006
Cassilis Hydro Electric Scheme Slide Presentation August 2006Cassilis Hydro Electric Scheme Slide Presentation August 2006
Cassilis Hydro Electric Scheme Slide Presentation August 2006Engineers Australia
 
Construction Of The Narrows Bridge
Construction Of The Narrows BridgeConstruction Of The Narrows Bridge
Construction Of The Narrows BridgeEngineers Australia
 
ICWES15 - Sustainability in the Built environment - Common Excuses and Soluti...
ICWES15 - Sustainability in the Built environment - Common Excuses and Soluti...ICWES15 - Sustainability in the Built environment - Common Excuses and Soluti...
ICWES15 - Sustainability in the Built environment - Common Excuses and Soluti...Engineers Australia
 
ICWES15 - Secrets of Successful Women. Presented by Miss Rosaline Ganendra, M...
ICWES15 - Secrets of Successful Women. Presented by Miss Rosaline Ganendra, M...ICWES15 - Secrets of Successful Women. Presented by Miss Rosaline Ganendra, M...
ICWES15 - Secrets of Successful Women. Presented by Miss Rosaline Ganendra, M...Engineers Australia
 
ICWES15 - Engineering Career for Women: An Examination of Orissan Women's Les...
ICWES15 - Engineering Career for Women: An Examination of Orissan Women's Les...ICWES15 - Engineering Career for Women: An Examination of Orissan Women's Les...
ICWES15 - Engineering Career for Women: An Examination of Orissan Women's Les...Engineers Australia
 
Year of Engineering Leadership 2010
Year of Engineering Leadership 2010Year of Engineering Leadership 2010
Year of Engineering Leadership 2010Engineers Australia
 
Targeting the Speed Limit by Matt Brown
Targeting the Speed Limit by Matt BrownTargeting the Speed Limit by Matt Brown
Targeting the Speed Limit by Matt BrownEngineers Australia
 
Where to From Here - Oil and Gas in WA
Where to From Here - Oil and Gas in WAWhere to From Here - Oil and Gas in WA
Where to From Here - Oil and Gas in WAEngineers Australia
 

Destaque (8)

Cassilis Hydro Electric Scheme Slide Presentation August 2006
Cassilis Hydro Electric Scheme Slide Presentation August 2006Cassilis Hydro Electric Scheme Slide Presentation August 2006
Cassilis Hydro Electric Scheme Slide Presentation August 2006
 
Construction Of The Narrows Bridge
Construction Of The Narrows BridgeConstruction Of The Narrows Bridge
Construction Of The Narrows Bridge
 
ICWES15 - Sustainability in the Built environment - Common Excuses and Soluti...
ICWES15 - Sustainability in the Built environment - Common Excuses and Soluti...ICWES15 - Sustainability in the Built environment - Common Excuses and Soluti...
ICWES15 - Sustainability in the Built environment - Common Excuses and Soluti...
 
ICWES15 - Secrets of Successful Women. Presented by Miss Rosaline Ganendra, M...
ICWES15 - Secrets of Successful Women. Presented by Miss Rosaline Ganendra, M...ICWES15 - Secrets of Successful Women. Presented by Miss Rosaline Ganendra, M...
ICWES15 - Secrets of Successful Women. Presented by Miss Rosaline Ganendra, M...
 
ICWES15 - Engineering Career for Women: An Examination of Orissan Women's Les...
ICWES15 - Engineering Career for Women: An Examination of Orissan Women's Les...ICWES15 - Engineering Career for Women: An Examination of Orissan Women's Les...
ICWES15 - Engineering Career for Women: An Examination of Orissan Women's Les...
 
Year of Engineering Leadership 2010
Year of Engineering Leadership 2010Year of Engineering Leadership 2010
Year of Engineering Leadership 2010
 
Targeting the Speed Limit by Matt Brown
Targeting the Speed Limit by Matt BrownTargeting the Speed Limit by Matt Brown
Targeting the Speed Limit by Matt Brown
 
Where to From Here - Oil and Gas in WA
Where to From Here - Oil and Gas in WAWhere to From Here - Oil and Gas in WA
Where to From Here - Oil and Gas in WA
 

Semelhante a EA / ATSE joint seminar Engineering for Extreme Natural Events

Human Response To Earthquake
Human Response To EarthquakeHuman Response To Earthquake
Human Response To Earthquaketudorgeog
 
Design and disaster mitigation
Design and disaster mitigationDesign and disaster mitigation
Design and disaster mitigationDenise Tuazon
 
Introduction to environmental sustainability
Introduction to environmental sustainabilityIntroduction to environmental sustainability
Introduction to environmental sustainabilityLinda Beamish
 
Let talk about home, hosing and buildings
Let talk about home, hosing and buildingsLet talk about home, hosing and buildings
Let talk about home, hosing and buildingsJasmine John
 
Resilient by Nature - Marco Pluijm June 28 2016
Resilient by Nature - Marco Pluijm June 28 2016Resilient by Nature - Marco Pluijm June 28 2016
Resilient by Nature - Marco Pluijm June 28 2016Marco Pluijm
 
44th engineers day
44th engineers day44th engineers day
44th engineers dayTapu Mon
 
IRJET- A Review on: Amphibious House
IRJET-  	  A Review on: Amphibious HouseIRJET-  	  A Review on: Amphibious House
IRJET- A Review on: Amphibious HouseIRJET Journal
 
Resilient by nature m pluijm june 7 2016
Resilient by nature m pluijm june 7 2016Resilient by nature m pluijm june 7 2016
Resilient by nature m pluijm june 7 2016Marco Pluijm
 
Disaster resistant structure
Disaster resistant structure Disaster resistant structure
Disaster resistant structure AlkaPrakash4
 
Infrastructure Protection from Extreme Natural Hazards: Marine oil terminals
Infrastructure Protection from Extreme Natural Hazards: Marine oil terminalsInfrastructure Protection from Extreme Natural Hazards: Marine oil terminals
Infrastructure Protection from Extreme Natural Hazards: Marine oil terminalsGlobal Risk Forum GRFDavos
 
Disaster Resist house , with stand cyclone and earthquake
Disaster Resist house , with stand cyclone and earthquake Disaster Resist house , with stand cyclone and earthquake
Disaster Resist house , with stand cyclone and earthquake Vanuatu Futsal League
 
Extreme Weather & Infrastructure Interdependencies
Extreme Weather & Infrastructure InterdependenciesExtreme Weather & Infrastructure Interdependencies
Extreme Weather & Infrastructure InterdependenciesThe Climate Institute
 
Climate Change and Infrastructure Summit Synthesis Report
Climate Change and Infrastructure Summit Synthesis ReportClimate Change and Infrastructure Summit Synthesis Report
Climate Change and Infrastructure Summit Synthesis ReportTurlough Guerin GAICD FGIA
 
Science ppt gajendra prasad c.p ed- hc
Science ppt  gajendra prasad c.p ed- hcScience ppt  gajendra prasad c.p ed- hc
Science ppt gajendra prasad c.p ed- hcHussain Anzar
 
natural disaster by IBRAHIM
natural disaster by IBRAHIMnatural disaster by IBRAHIM
natural disaster by IBRAHIMstrandbreton
 
Social by ibrahim
Social by ibrahimSocial by ibrahim
Social by ibrahimRonaldo1904
 
Roles of Technology, Engineering and Academe in Climate Change
Roles of Technology, Engineering and Academe in Climate ChangeRoles of Technology, Engineering and Academe in Climate Change
Roles of Technology, Engineering and Academe in Climate ChangeChristopher Marzan
 
Disaster earth quake rescue and relief assessment
Disaster earth quake rescue and relief assessmentDisaster earth quake rescue and relief assessment
Disaster earth quake rescue and relief assessmentAmit Pokharel
 

Semelhante a EA / ATSE joint seminar Engineering for Extreme Natural Events (20)

Human Response To Earthquake
Human Response To EarthquakeHuman Response To Earthquake
Human Response To Earthquake
 
Design and disaster mitigation
Design and disaster mitigationDesign and disaster mitigation
Design and disaster mitigation
 
Introduction to environmental sustainability
Introduction to environmental sustainabilityIntroduction to environmental sustainability
Introduction to environmental sustainability
 
Let talk about home, hosing and buildings
Let talk about home, hosing and buildingsLet talk about home, hosing and buildings
Let talk about home, hosing and buildings
 
Resilient by Nature - Marco Pluijm June 28 2016
Resilient by Nature - Marco Pluijm June 28 2016Resilient by Nature - Marco Pluijm June 28 2016
Resilient by Nature - Marco Pluijm June 28 2016
 
44th engineers day
44th engineers day44th engineers day
44th engineers day
 
IRJET- A Review on: Amphibious House
IRJET-  	  A Review on: Amphibious HouseIRJET-  	  A Review on: Amphibious House
IRJET- A Review on: Amphibious House
 
Resilient by nature m pluijm june 7 2016
Resilient by nature m pluijm june 7 2016Resilient by nature m pluijm june 7 2016
Resilient by nature m pluijm june 7 2016
 
Disaster resistant structure
Disaster resistant structure Disaster resistant structure
Disaster resistant structure
 
Infrastructure Protection from Extreme Natural Hazards: Marine oil terminals
Infrastructure Protection from Extreme Natural Hazards: Marine oil terminalsInfrastructure Protection from Extreme Natural Hazards: Marine oil terminals
Infrastructure Protection from Extreme Natural Hazards: Marine oil terminals
 
Disaster Resist house , with stand cyclone and earthquake
Disaster Resist house , with stand cyclone and earthquake Disaster Resist house , with stand cyclone and earthquake
Disaster Resist house , with stand cyclone and earthquake
 
Extreme Weather & Infrastructure Interdependencies
Extreme Weather & Infrastructure InterdependenciesExtreme Weather & Infrastructure Interdependencies
Extreme Weather & Infrastructure Interdependencies
 
Climate Change and Infrastructure Summit Synthesis Report
Climate Change and Infrastructure Summit Synthesis ReportClimate Change and Infrastructure Summit Synthesis Report
Climate Change and Infrastructure Summit Synthesis Report
 
Science ppt gajendra prasad c.p ed- hc
Science ppt  gajendra prasad c.p ed- hcScience ppt  gajendra prasad c.p ed- hc
Science ppt gajendra prasad c.p ed- hc
 
natural disaster by IBRAHIM
natural disaster by IBRAHIMnatural disaster by IBRAHIM
natural disaster by IBRAHIM
 
Disaster Recent
Disaster RecentDisaster Recent
Disaster Recent
 
Adaptation in Action; A Cork Example - Dr Valerie Cummins CMRC
Adaptation in Action; A Cork Example - Dr Valerie Cummins CMRCAdaptation in Action; A Cork Example - Dr Valerie Cummins CMRC
Adaptation in Action; A Cork Example - Dr Valerie Cummins CMRC
 
Social by ibrahim
Social by ibrahimSocial by ibrahim
Social by ibrahim
 
Roles of Technology, Engineering and Academe in Climate Change
Roles of Technology, Engineering and Academe in Climate ChangeRoles of Technology, Engineering and Academe in Climate Change
Roles of Technology, Engineering and Academe in Climate Change
 
Disaster earth quake rescue and relief assessment
Disaster earth quake rescue and relief assessmentDisaster earth quake rescue and relief assessment
Disaster earth quake rescue and relief assessment
 

Mais de Engineers Australia

Jacobs Recent changes to transmission line design standards and the impact on...
Jacobs Recent changes to transmission line design standards and the impact on...Jacobs Recent changes to transmission line design standards and the impact on...
Jacobs Recent changes to transmission line design standards and the impact on...Engineers Australia
 
Cyber supply chain risk management ASDE
Cyber supply chain risk management   ASDECyber supply chain risk management   ASDE
Cyber supply chain risk management ASDEEngineers Australia
 
Timber Connections reduced by Geoff Boughton
Timber Connections reduced by Geoff BoughtonTimber Connections reduced by Geoff Boughton
Timber Connections reduced by Geoff BoughtonEngineers Australia
 
Connecting to the future: how transport will shape the City of Fremantle
Connecting to the future: how transport will shape the City of FremantleConnecting to the future: how transport will shape the City of Fremantle
Connecting to the future: how transport will shape the City of FremantleEngineers Australia
 
Green schemes 2012_npe_eo_y lecture perth v9
Green schemes 2012_npe_eo_y lecture perth v9Green schemes 2012_npe_eo_y lecture perth v9
Green schemes 2012_npe_eo_y lecture perth v9Engineers Australia
 
Revised intensity frequency-duration (ifd) design rainfalls estimates for wa ...
Revised intensity frequency-duration (ifd) design rainfalls estimates for wa ...Revised intensity frequency-duration (ifd) design rainfalls estimates for wa ...
Revised intensity frequency-duration (ifd) design rainfalls estimates for wa ...Engineers Australia
 
Pilbara rfa ea presentation v3.2 1
Pilbara rfa ea presentation v3.2 1Pilbara rfa ea presentation v3.2 1
Pilbara rfa ea presentation v3.2 1Engineers Australia
 
Smart grid - Do they fit into real networks ver 1
Smart grid  - Do they fit into real networks ver 1Smart grid  - Do they fit into real networks ver 1
Smart grid - Do they fit into real networks ver 1Engineers Australia
 
Arc flash August 2012 IE Aust JEEP
Arc flash  August 2012   IE Aust JEEPArc flash  August 2012   IE Aust JEEP
Arc flash August 2012 IE Aust JEEPEngineers Australia
 
121108 MD smart grid and renewable energy integration 1
121108 MD smart grid and renewable energy integration 1121108 MD smart grid and renewable energy integration 1
121108 MD smart grid and renewable energy integration 1Engineers Australia
 
Pavement materials and design in western australia by geoffrey cocks
Pavement materials and design in western australia by geoffrey cocksPavement materials and design in western australia by geoffrey cocks
Pavement materials and design in western australia by geoffrey cocksEngineers Australia
 
Design and Analysis of Floating Production Systems
Design and Analysis of Floating Production Systems Design and Analysis of Floating Production Systems
Design and Analysis of Floating Production Systems Engineers Australia
 
The EPCM of writing tenders: How engineers can successfully build compelling ...
The EPCM of writing tenders: How engineers can successfully build compelling ...The EPCM of writing tenders: How engineers can successfully build compelling ...
The EPCM of writing tenders: How engineers can successfully build compelling ...Engineers Australia
 
Bid write presentation engineers australia & spe 7 feb12-1
Bid write presentation   engineers australia & spe 7 feb12-1Bid write presentation   engineers australia & spe 7 feb12-1
Bid write presentation engineers australia & spe 7 feb12-1Engineers Australia
 
Freight and public transport planning initiatives conference 24 november 2011
Freight and public transport planning initiatives conference 24 november 2011Freight and public transport planning initiatives conference 24 november 2011
Freight and public transport planning initiatives conference 24 november 2011Engineers Australia
 
How to write a research paper. By Gareth Forbes, Curtin University and Engine...
How to write a research paper. By Gareth Forbes, Curtin University and Engine...How to write a research paper. By Gareth Forbes, Curtin University and Engine...
How to write a research paper. By Gareth Forbes, Curtin University and Engine...Engineers Australia
 
How to write a research paper. By Mark Bush
How to write a research paper. By Mark BushHow to write a research paper. By Mark Bush
How to write a research paper. By Mark BushEngineers Australia
 
How to write a research paper. By Prof A (Tony) D Lucey, Curtin University an...
How to write a research paper. By Prof A (Tony) D Lucey, Curtin University an...How to write a research paper. By Prof A (Tony) D Lucey, Curtin University an...
How to write a research paper. By Prof A (Tony) D Lucey, Curtin University an...Engineers Australia
 
Ausimm engineers aust presentation 040811 (97-2003 version)
Ausimm engineers aust  presentation 040811 (97-2003 version) Ausimm engineers aust  presentation 040811 (97-2003 version)
Ausimm engineers aust presentation 040811 (97-2003 version) Engineers Australia
 

Mais de Engineers Australia (20)

Jacobs Recent changes to transmission line design standards and the impact on...
Jacobs Recent changes to transmission line design standards and the impact on...Jacobs Recent changes to transmission line design standards and the impact on...
Jacobs Recent changes to transmission line design standards and the impact on...
 
Cyber supply chain risk management ASDE
Cyber supply chain risk management   ASDECyber supply chain risk management   ASDE
Cyber supply chain risk management ASDE
 
Timber Connections reduced by Geoff Boughton
Timber Connections reduced by Geoff BoughtonTimber Connections reduced by Geoff Boughton
Timber Connections reduced by Geoff Boughton
 
Connecting to the future: how transport will shape the City of Fremantle
Connecting to the future: how transport will shape the City of FremantleConnecting to the future: how transport will shape the City of Fremantle
Connecting to the future: how transport will shape the City of Fremantle
 
Green schemes 2012_npe_eo_y lecture perth v9
Green schemes 2012_npe_eo_y lecture perth v9Green schemes 2012_npe_eo_y lecture perth v9
Green schemes 2012_npe_eo_y lecture perth v9
 
Revised intensity frequency-duration (ifd) design rainfalls estimates for wa ...
Revised intensity frequency-duration (ifd) design rainfalls estimates for wa ...Revised intensity frequency-duration (ifd) design rainfalls estimates for wa ...
Revised intensity frequency-duration (ifd) design rainfalls estimates for wa ...
 
Pilbara rfa ea presentation v3.2 1
Pilbara rfa ea presentation v3.2 1Pilbara rfa ea presentation v3.2 1
Pilbara rfa ea presentation v3.2 1
 
Smart grid - Do they fit into real networks ver 1
Smart grid  - Do they fit into real networks ver 1Smart grid  - Do they fit into real networks ver 1
Smart grid - Do they fit into real networks ver 1
 
Arc flash August 2012 IE Aust JEEP
Arc flash  August 2012   IE Aust JEEPArc flash  August 2012   IE Aust JEEP
Arc flash August 2012 IE Aust JEEP
 
121108 MD smart grid and renewable energy integration 1
121108 MD smart grid and renewable energy integration 1121108 MD smart grid and renewable energy integration 1
121108 MD smart grid and renewable energy integration 1
 
Pavement materials and design in western australia by geoffrey cocks
Pavement materials and design in western australia by geoffrey cocksPavement materials and design in western australia by geoffrey cocks
Pavement materials and design in western australia by geoffrey cocks
 
Design and Analysis of Floating Production Systems
Design and Analysis of Floating Production Systems Design and Analysis of Floating Production Systems
Design and Analysis of Floating Production Systems
 
The EPCM of writing tenders: How engineers can successfully build compelling ...
The EPCM of writing tenders: How engineers can successfully build compelling ...The EPCM of writing tenders: How engineers can successfully build compelling ...
The EPCM of writing tenders: How engineers can successfully build compelling ...
 
Bid write presentation engineers australia & spe 7 feb12-1
Bid write presentation   engineers australia & spe 7 feb12-1Bid write presentation   engineers australia & spe 7 feb12-1
Bid write presentation engineers australia & spe 7 feb12-1
 
111125 IChemE Palmer
111125 IChemE Palmer111125 IChemE Palmer
111125 IChemE Palmer
 
Freight and public transport planning initiatives conference 24 november 2011
Freight and public transport planning initiatives conference 24 november 2011Freight and public transport planning initiatives conference 24 november 2011
Freight and public transport planning initiatives conference 24 november 2011
 
How to write a research paper. By Gareth Forbes, Curtin University and Engine...
How to write a research paper. By Gareth Forbes, Curtin University and Engine...How to write a research paper. By Gareth Forbes, Curtin University and Engine...
How to write a research paper. By Gareth Forbes, Curtin University and Engine...
 
How to write a research paper. By Mark Bush
How to write a research paper. By Mark BushHow to write a research paper. By Mark Bush
How to write a research paper. By Mark Bush
 
How to write a research paper. By Prof A (Tony) D Lucey, Curtin University an...
How to write a research paper. By Prof A (Tony) D Lucey, Curtin University an...How to write a research paper. By Prof A (Tony) D Lucey, Curtin University an...
How to write a research paper. By Prof A (Tony) D Lucey, Curtin University an...
 
Ausimm engineers aust presentation 040811 (97-2003 version)
Ausimm engineers aust  presentation 040811 (97-2003 version) Ausimm engineers aust  presentation 040811 (97-2003 version)
Ausimm engineers aust presentation 040811 (97-2003 version)
 

Último

🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘RTylerCroy
 
Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...
Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...
Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...shyamraj55
 
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024The Digital Insurer
 
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivityBoost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivityPrincipled Technologies
 
Google AI Hackathon: LLM based Evaluator for RAG
Google AI Hackathon: LLM based Evaluator for RAGGoogle AI Hackathon: LLM based Evaluator for RAG
Google AI Hackathon: LLM based Evaluator for RAGSujit Pal
 
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhi
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | DelhiFULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhi
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhisoniya singh
 
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time AutomationFrom Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time AutomationSafe Software
 
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024Scott Keck-Warren
 
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreterPresentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreternaman860154
 
Enhancing Worker Digital Experience: A Hands-on Workshop for Partners
Enhancing Worker Digital Experience: A Hands-on Workshop for PartnersEnhancing Worker Digital Experience: A Hands-on Workshop for Partners
Enhancing Worker Digital Experience: A Hands-on Workshop for PartnersThousandEyes
 
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure service
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure serviceWhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure service
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure servicePooja Nehwal
 
How to convert PDF to text with Nanonets
How to convert PDF to text with NanonetsHow to convert PDF to text with Nanonets
How to convert PDF to text with Nanonetsnaman860154
 
Unblocking The Main Thread Solving ANRs and Frozen Frames
Unblocking The Main Thread Solving ANRs and Frozen FramesUnblocking The Main Thread Solving ANRs and Frozen Frames
Unblocking The Main Thread Solving ANRs and Frozen FramesSinan KOZAK
 
#StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024
#StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024#StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024
#StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024BookNet Canada
 
Kalyanpur ) Call Girls in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🍸 8923113531 🎰 Avail...
Kalyanpur ) Call Girls in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🍸 8923113531 🎰 Avail...Kalyanpur ) Call Girls in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🍸 8923113531 🎰 Avail...
Kalyanpur ) Call Girls in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🍸 8923113531 🎰 Avail...gurkirankumar98700
 
Maximizing Board Effectiveness 2024 Webinar.pptx
Maximizing Board Effectiveness 2024 Webinar.pptxMaximizing Board Effectiveness 2024 Webinar.pptx
Maximizing Board Effectiveness 2024 Webinar.pptxOnBoard
 
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024Rafal Los
 
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Service
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of ServiceCNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Service
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Servicegiselly40
 
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt RobisonData Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt RobisonAnna Loughnan Colquhoun
 
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 Presentation
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 PresentationMy Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 Presentation
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 PresentationRidwan Fadjar
 

Último (20)

🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘🐬  The future of MySQL is Postgres   🐘
🐬 The future of MySQL is Postgres 🐘
 
Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...
Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...
Automating Business Process via MuleSoft Composer | Bangalore MuleSoft Meetup...
 
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
Finology Group – Insurtech Innovation Award 2024
 
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivityBoost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
Boost PC performance: How more available memory can improve productivity
 
Google AI Hackathon: LLM based Evaluator for RAG
Google AI Hackathon: LLM based Evaluator for RAGGoogle AI Hackathon: LLM based Evaluator for RAG
Google AI Hackathon: LLM based Evaluator for RAG
 
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhi
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | DelhiFULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhi
FULL ENJOY 🔝 8264348440 🔝 Call Girls in Diplomatic Enclave | Delhi
 
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time AutomationFrom Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
From Event to Action: Accelerate Your Decision Making with Real-Time Automation
 
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024
SQL Database Design For Developers at php[tek] 2024
 
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreterPresentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
Presentation on how to chat with PDF using ChatGPT code interpreter
 
Enhancing Worker Digital Experience: A Hands-on Workshop for Partners
Enhancing Worker Digital Experience: A Hands-on Workshop for PartnersEnhancing Worker Digital Experience: A Hands-on Workshop for Partners
Enhancing Worker Digital Experience: A Hands-on Workshop for Partners
 
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure service
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure serviceWhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure service
WhatsApp 9892124323 ✓Call Girls In Kalyan ( Mumbai ) secure service
 
How to convert PDF to text with Nanonets
How to convert PDF to text with NanonetsHow to convert PDF to text with Nanonets
How to convert PDF to text with Nanonets
 
Unblocking The Main Thread Solving ANRs and Frozen Frames
Unblocking The Main Thread Solving ANRs and Frozen FramesUnblocking The Main Thread Solving ANRs and Frozen Frames
Unblocking The Main Thread Solving ANRs and Frozen Frames
 
#StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024
#StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024#StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024
#StandardsGoals for 2024: What’s new for BISAC - Tech Forum 2024
 
Kalyanpur ) Call Girls in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🍸 8923113531 🎰 Avail...
Kalyanpur ) Call Girls in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🍸 8923113531 🎰 Avail...Kalyanpur ) Call Girls in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🍸 8923113531 🎰 Avail...
Kalyanpur ) Call Girls in Lucknow Finest Escorts Service 🍸 8923113531 🎰 Avail...
 
Maximizing Board Effectiveness 2024 Webinar.pptx
Maximizing Board Effectiveness 2024 Webinar.pptxMaximizing Board Effectiveness 2024 Webinar.pptx
Maximizing Board Effectiveness 2024 Webinar.pptx
 
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
The 7 Things I Know About Cyber Security After 25 Years | April 2024
 
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Service
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of ServiceCNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Service
CNv6 Instructor Chapter 6 Quality of Service
 
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt RobisonData Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
Data Cloud, More than a CDP by Matt Robison
 
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 Presentation
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 PresentationMy Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 Presentation
My Hashitalk Indonesia April 2024 Presentation
 

EA / ATSE joint seminar Engineering for Extreme Natural Events

  • 1. Engineers Australia ATSE Joint Seminar Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events Thursday 15th September 2011 1 Western Australia Division
  • 2. Engineers Australia WA Division Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011 Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events Abstract This article describes the purpose, format, content, and recommendations arising from a half-day seminar held to consider the nature, role and future challenges of Engineering for extreme natural events. In particular the seminar concentrated on Engineering related to the four areas of earthquake (earth), high- speed winds (wind), bushfires (fire) and large-amplitude water waves (water). Bringing experts in the different areas together proved to be invaluable, no more so than in the concluding panel session. The interaction with the audience also highlighted areas of concern that had not previously been discussed. Several themes emerged that were general across the four different event areas, most especially the notion of risk and its meaning for different groups from Engineers through to the general public. This leads to the question of whether properties and infrastructure more subject to inundation, fire, seismicity or soil liquefaction have a higher cost for insurance, not be insurable or in some cases be declared unable to be sold. For such deliberations, it was agreed that an increased understanding and level of communication across the many different stakeholders is highly desirable. 1. Introduction 2011 has brought into sharp focus the forms and effects of extreme natural events. Earthquakes in Christchurch and Japan, tropical cyclones in Queensland Australia and the U.S Eastern Seaboard along with a virulent tornado season in the U.S, bushfires both nationally and around Perth, Western Australia, the Japanese tsunami in Sendai province and flooding in Brisbane, Queensland have caused significant fatalities and wrought much damage. The occurrence of extreme natural events seems to be increasing and climate change may be implicated. It is therefore timely that the role of Engineering in safeguarding life and property against the effects of extreme natural events should be considered and assessed. Engineers Australia (EA) and the Australian Academy of Technological Sciences and Engineering (ATSE) combined to host a half-day seminar Earth Wind Fire Water – Engineering for Extreme Events held at Curtin University, Perth on the15 th September 2011. This seminar linked to, and developed from, the seminar City to Cape – 2100 sea-level rise mounted by ATSE, EA and Curtin University on the 22 nd July 2010 and its arising published report [1]. The theme of the seminar reported upon herein was the contributions of Engineering to controlling the adverse effects arising from extreme natural events: earthquake, storm, bushfire and inundation. In tandem, the seminar served to raise awareness of humanitarian engineering, EA‟s 2011 focus, as an crucial arm of Engineering through the preservation of life and property in the face of, and after, devastating natural events. The seminar also sought to communicate the special challenges associated with designing and preparing for extreme natural events. The seminar comprised four main presentations, each focusing on one of the extreme-event sub-themes under the shorthand titles, earth, wind, fire and water. These are reported upon in Section 2. Speakers were asked to establish the nature of the problem; highlight challenges for engineers, scientists, disaster managers and planners; suggest what could be done better; and to include reference to social or management challenges and the special plight of developing communities in such circumstances. While it was not expected that each of the four speakers could address all of these aspects, they were addressed in one form or another through the seminar presentations taken in their totality. The presentations were followed by a panel discussion that drew out common threads, identifying challenges and matters of concern, that apply broadly to Engineering and its role, responsibilities and contributions across all extreme natural events. This discussion and the recommendations that emerged from it are summarised in Section 3. In addition to EA and 2
  • 3. Engineers Australia WA Division Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011 ATSE membership, the target audience of the seminar included people with a professional interest in the impact of the topic and the capacity to act on the subjects of the presentations including State government, local government, planners, academics, business and industry as well as the members of the general public. The overall message that emerges is clear in that engineering education and practice needs to accommodate the prospects of a greater frequency and greater severity of natural disasters. Decision-makers, planners, engineers and architects need to work together to increase the rate of structural survival following earthquakes, cyclones, bushfires, deluges and coastal inundation. Regulators and the insurance industry need to consider limiting risk, recognising the compounding of hazard and frequency, and all parties need to re-embrace the Precautionary Principle, based upon sound data and well-established knowledge. 2. Findings Reported What follows is a summary of key points that emerged from each of the four presentations. Note that the titles and abstracts of the presentation and speaker biographies are presented as Appendix 1, while the slides for each of the presentations and the iLecture (speaker audio synchronised with slides) of the entire seminar are available at [2]. 2.1 Earth – Presenter: Dr David Brunsdon This presentation highlighted the risks of failure, the need for risk management and the role of engineers. „Risk‟ is a function of both likelihood and potential damage. Its management can be summarised by the 4Rs of risk: reduction, readiness, response, recovery. Accounting for risk in design covers the spectrum: avoid, transfer, control, accept. The focus for Engineering is usually upon „control‟ whereas effective risk-management includes all four parts of the spectrum. Accordingly, Engineers need to increase their involvement more widely, especially in communicating and sharing their expertise with other professionals such as planners and architects. Risk-reduction strategies for infrastructure development should be applied at each of three stages, these being (i) „Site yet to be developed‟ (site selection and planning with regard to potential hazards such as liquefaction and fall or collapse of geologic material), (ii) „[Site] Developed, but not built (applying necessary design considerations and building regulations), and (iii) „Built, existing infrastructure‟ (reviewing against standards). It was noted that the appropriate implementation of these strategies is being affected by sea-level rise for coastal developments. The community tends to focus on the consequences of failure, whereas engineers tend to focus on the likelihood (e.g. the 100 year earthquake). These two outlooks need to be combined. For example, a rating of „low seismicity‟ indicates that the average time between events is large but it does not mean that all events are small. The presentation highlighted some of the dilemmas of design for earthquakes. Buildings may need to have good escape systems, but the best way to survive an earthquake is by remaining within a resilient building during the shaking event, as falling masonry often renders the surroundings of the building unsafe. The escape system is needed to exit the damaged building after the event. Building design needs to take into account post-disaster use; design for damage tolerance or design for damage resistance. For example, hospitals, assembly halls and emergency services buildings need to remain in operation after the event. 3
  • 4. Engineers Australia WA Division Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011 Finally, the presentation addressed the role of Engineering in the aftermath of a severe earthquake, in the first instance triaging buildings in the affected area to aid search and rescue operations, assessing the safety of entry to „pancaked‟ buildings and, later, leading engineering work to permit entry to collapsed buildings in the search for survivors. 2.2 Wind – Presenter: Mr Charles Boyle This presentation focused on the need to blend traditional and modern western knowledge to find building solutions for developing countries, using the Solomon Islands as an example. There is a tendency in the Solomon Islands to view European housing as „better‟ as a result of aspirations being set by former colonial administrations or present „Western‟ influences. However, such housing is costly, complex in construction and maintenance, and can be culturally intrusive. Instead, the appropriate use of local materials and techniques combined with western structural-engineering knowledge can produce greatly improved and culturally appropriate outcomes with buildings that are cyclone resistant. Thus, for example, the lack of continuity between the floor, walls and roof of traditional buildings leads to complete loss of the building in high winds. A blended design that utilises corrugated steel roofing tied through the walls to the ground produces a far more resilient building, yet does not alter the traditional floor plan and can make use of many of the local materials (e.g. bamboo). The presentation cautioned against „transitional‟ buildings that comprise an ad-hoc, or ill- considered, combination of local and western materials and designs. Correct hybrid building approaches need to be carefully engineered to yield techniques and material use that realise complementary benefits of the traditional and the modern. Hybrid technology requires a systematic approach that includes the documentation of traditional learning and skills, established wisdoms and local materials that will be trialled or adapted to work effectively with modern materials and techniques. In the subsequent design phase of hybrid buildings, prototyping trials (at all scales, from fixing techniques through to entire building) are essential. The roles of the administrating organisation, most effectively undertaken by NGOs, was emphasised to ensure continuity of process, dissemination and adoption of new hybrid techniques. 2.3 Fire – Presenter: Mr Ralph Smith This presentation communicated the lessons learned from the Roleystone and Toodyay fires of recent years in Western Australia. However, many of the causes of and means to reduce damage are broadly applicable to other regions and situations. In particular, a range of data was presented that demonstrated two main points: Reducing the fuel loads surrounding buildings, both the Building Protection Zone (BPZ) and Hazard Protection Zone (HPZ), by proper property management reduces the energy release rate to a point where the fire can be controlled using water. If this is not done, then the fire cannot be extinguished. Regardless of the main building cladding materials (e.g. brick, iron), buildings are not fire resistant if there are any entry points for embers. The vast majority of houses lost in the fires studied were the result of ember attack some distance away from the main fire. Typical ember entry arises from rooftop evaporative air-conditioners, lack of boxed eaves and, often, a lack of common sense in the identification of vulnerabilities. The risk of fire damage can be significantly reduced by following existing well-developed standards and easy-to-understand guidelines for property owners. A major challenge lies in 4
  • 5. Engineers Australia WA Division Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011 persuading planners to adopt, councils to enforce and the public take the actions that can dramatically mitigate the effects of bush/forest fires. 2.4 Water – Presenter: Prof Chari Pattiaratchi This presentation highlighted the destructive nature of a tsunami and the complicated nature of the phenomenon. Earthquake-induced waves are refracted and reflected by subsea topography and coastlines, leading to enormous variations in the strength of the waves as they strike different parts of the coast. Reflected waves may in fact lead to larger tsunamis that reach a coast many hours after the original incident waves. Understanding the topography of the extended region is therefore a key to identifying potential tsunami events. Meteorological tsunamis can also be induced by storms moving across the surface of the ocean and these can be as important, through their frequency, as the more dramatic geologic tsunamis. Thus, along the coast of Western Australia a meteorological tsunami that generates a wave-height of one metre is very significant when it impacts the southern part of the state for which the tidal range is approximately only 0.5 metres. Clearly, the frequency of such tsunamis increases with the increased frequency of storm events associated with climate change. The presentation described the advanced tsunami prediction models that are currently available to assist in early warning and prediction of the level of likely inundation resulting from tsunamis produced by both geological and storm events. Even with a predictive capability, implementing coastal and beach responses remains complex with appropriate actions depending upon a combination of factors that may be local to each particular region impacted by the tsunami. Modelling and data-analysis also evidences the impact of sea-level rise on increasing the strength and frequency of tsunamis, noting that the current 100 year flooding event may be expected to occur on a monthly basis by 2050 if sea levels continue to rise at the rate they have been doing so over the last 100 years. Accordingly more effective communication to and understanding by planners and decision-makers for coastal regions is essential. 3. Discussion and recommendations Several points were made during the discussions, with a focus on changes needed to the education of scientists and engineers, and of governments and regulators and the general public that utilise their services. Overall the key elements and recommendations are as follows. There is no escape from natural disaster. From city centres to rural communities, from the coast to the mountains, there is the potential for natural disasters in one or more forms, be they inundation, earthquake, fire or storm. The effects of global warming are increasing the likelihood of extreme events related to all but earthquake. The magnitude and frequency of global natural disasters appears to be increasing and whatever the cause we need to engineer to reduce the impact of compounded effects. The problems of designing and preparing for natural disasters cannot be completely solved using existing knowledge. This is true for developed and particularly true in regard to developing nations, where cultural factors and resource limitations may render modern „developed‟ technologies and practices inappropriate. Innovative thinking is needed, and a willingness to understand local techniques and materials, in order to blend effectively traditional and western knowledge. In developed countries, similar considerations may also apply. Throughout, however, the continuing policies of developers and regulators to encourage building of infrastructure close to the water table or a flood plain possibility must be reined in. 5
  • 6. Engineers Australia WA Division Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011 Service to the community is to be encouraged. Apart from the obvious community and humanitarian outcomes, this is an ideal way for engineers, technologists and managers to understand the competing demands and influences that must be addressed in any truly effective solution. Engineers and Scientists are not very well prepared for working with uncertainty. Clients are nearly always looking for the cheapest solution, but decreasing the risk of damage from natural disasters usually increases the costs. Such factors are often not taken into account as a result. Professionals should be more willing to lay out the risks and consequences, and to offer a range of solutions that mitigate risks at different levels. Engineers need to understand and manage the balance between risk and consequence in their design work and decisions, and to broaden their involvement to all stages in the development of infrastructure. Current obstacles that need to be overcome include: Engineers usually communicate through indirect channels that may be insufficiently forceful; it is difficult for Society to understand „risk‟ as a parameter worked with by Engineers; media reporting and language can be misleading - for example, it is preferable to use „intensity‟ instead of „magnitude‟ in earthquake descriptions. Government and insurance industry decisions can have a large impact on disaster mitigation, either by taking firm action to prevent development in areas prone to disaster (e.g. flood plains) or to make prohibitive the cost of insuring in risky situations. 4. Concluding Remarks The design of the seminar proved to be very effective for the delivery of its expected outcomes. Combining sometimes disparate disciplines that separately address Engineering for extreme natural events, and bringing together experts in these areas, served to identify factors, shortcomings and recommendations that cut across the different disciplines and which can perhaps be better tackled at an all-of-Engineering level. Overall, the seminar concluded that extreme natural events are becoming more frequent and that this warrants an increased focus on the concomitant engineering challenges both within developed and developing communities in order to find solutions that are technically effective while also being socially and commercially appropriate. Acknowledgement The authors and organisers of the seminar are grateful for the support of Curtin University for providing the seminar venue and administrative support through Ms Sucy Leong. References [1] R.J. Purdy, A.D. Lucey and R.E. Smith 2010. City to Cape: 2100 Sea-level Rise, Seminar Report, Pub.: The Australian Academy of Technological Sciences and Engineering, ISBN 978 1 921388 17 0. (Also available as a .pdf document at www.atse.org.au) [2] D. Brunsdon, C. Boyle, R. Smith and C. Pattiaratchi, 2011. Presentation slides and iLecture for Earth, Wind, Fire Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events seminar. At: www.engineersaustralia.wa.events and www.atse.org.au 6
  • 7. Engineers Australia WA Division Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011 Appendix 1: Titles and abstracts of speaker presentations and author biographies EARTH Planning and Design for Earthquakes: Consequences and Opportunities Mr Dave Brunsdon New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering Engineers have a key role in reducing the risk to the community from extreme natural hazard events. While it is implicit in much of what professional engineers do on a day to day basis as they apply design codes, the wider context of this risk mitigation work is not always fully appreciated, particularly for complex hazards such as earthquake. The effective mitigation of urban earthquake risk involves consideration of the following elements: Understanding of the components of seismic hazard, and in particular the threat of permanent ground deformation; Conveying seismic risk to urban planners (what the consequences are of developing on at-risk land); Ensuring that building codes provide for an appropriate level of seismic resistance, and function within an effective regulatory framework; Having appropriate arrangements (both technical and regulatory) in place for assessing and strengthening potential at-risk older building stock; Ensuring that both the construction and renewal of infrastructure assets includes seismic resilience considerations A key enabler that sits across these elements is establishing and conveying the consequences of seismic hazards on the built environment. Professional engineers are uniquely placed to undertake this role, and indeed have the responsibility to do so. In the current climate of strong awareness of natural hazard threats, this represents a significant opportunity to make a difference. This presentation will cover each of these earthquake risk mitigation aspects, drawing upon the September 2009 Padang earthquake and the Canterbury earthquake series of 2010/11 as case study examples. Biography Dave is a Fellow and Past-President of the New Zealand Society for Earthquake Engineering, and is a member of the Australian Earthquake Engineering Society and the Institution of Engineers Australia. He is a director of Kestrel Group Ltd, a New Zealand-based consulting practice specialising in strategic emergency management planning for local and central government agencies and infrastructure providers. In 2009, Dave led a team of NZ engineers to assist government agencies following the devastating Padang earthquake in Indonesia. In September last year he co-ordinated the building safety evaluation process immediately following the Darfield, Canterbury earthquake, and in February he led the NZ USAR Engineering team during the response to the Christchurch aftershock. He continues to be closely involved in activities relating to the building recovery process there. WIND Advancing Cyclone Resistant Construction Practices with Local Communities in the Solomon Islands Mr Charles Boyle Architect/Project Manager, Curtin University While engineered timber frame construction can be formally designed quantified and quality controlled, traditional building practices are too varied in both the level of skill and quality of materials to be similarly 7
  • 8. Engineers Australia WA Division Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011 assessed. Being as much an issue of social dynamics, anthropology and material culture, the latter falls as much within the domain of the architect as that of the structural engineer. While a high population growth, urban growth, land ownership and general development aspirations have seen Solomon Islanders aspire to better housing, the economic conditions of a country still recovering from what was in effect a civil war constrain affordability and educational opportunity. In the informal housing sector this typically sees traditional materials used to emulate modern timber framed building construction, or the use of modern building materials to traditional construction methods, an approach favoured for re-construction by the government following 1985 cyclone Namu and which stimulated Charles‟ interest in disaster mitigation through better building practice and his work with the Australian Overseas Disaster Response Organisation, Ausaid and UNIDO. The presentation will explore some of the dynamics of housing aspirations in Solomon Islands, and how traditional building methods and modern technology morph into hybrid forms of construction, and the significance this may have on the risks during cyclone events. Starting with a basic inquiry into traditional construction practices in Solomon Islands, Charles will discuss the work of Hybrid Technology, a not-for-profit NGO established in parallel with his own commercial architectural practice and how it developed small disaster-resistant buildings and explored discrete improvements to traditional buildings to successfully enhance cyclone resistance in Solomon Islands. Biography UK trained and registered, Charles took up a position in a small architectural practice in Solomon Islands in the early 1980‟s. Following a major cyclone that killed over 100 people and destroyed several thousand homes, he assisted in the establishment of a local building materials council, and established a not for profit NGO “Hybrid Technology” to research and better understand traditional building practices and develop methods of building using local materials and available skills. FIRE Lessons Learnt from the Recent Bushfires Mr Ralph Smith Branch Manager, Bush Fire & Environmental Protection, Fire & Emergency Services Authority of WA Since 2008 FESA has initiated a process following a bushfire event, were specialist staff analyse why houses were damaged and destroyed while other houses in the vicinity did not suffer any damage. In recent years, FESA has surveyed the bushland and houses in the Parkerville, Toodyay, Lake Clifton and Roleystone / Kelmscott fire affected areas. These surveys have been conducted on houses that were destroyed, houses that were damaged and houses that suffered no damage. The surveys have considered the building construction standards, as prescribed in Australian Standard 3959 Construction of buildings in bushfire-prone areas, the building protection zone (20 metre circle of safety), the hazard separation zone (up to 100 metres from the house) and the landscape zone vegetation, including the fuel load and the fire behaviour. Land use planning and the subsequent developments that occur have a significant effect on the emergency services that are required to try and protect those communities during a period of adversity. Frequently these developments occur in the bushland interface areas where there are continuous bushfire fuels within the landscapes. To assist developers, local government and State government agencies, FESA in partnership with the Department of Planning and the WA Planning Commission have developed and published Planning for Bush Fire Protection Guidelines. The 2010 guidelines have been developed in accordance with clause 6 of State Planning Policy 3.4 Natural Hazards and Disasters (SPP 3.4). The guidelines replace DC 3.7 Fire Planning and the first edition of Planning for Bush Fire Protection (2001), which were released by the WAPC and FESA in December 2001. A current and second edition of the Planning for Bush Fire 8
  • 9. Engineers Australia WA Division Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011 Protection Guidelines, was released in 2010. The guidelines have been linked to Australian Standard 3959 – Construction of buildings in bushfire-prone areas which were published in 1999 and revised in 2009, 2010 and 2011. FESA provides advice on planning developments, separation distances between the house and the vegetation, construction standards, fuel loads and vegetation management. These are all factors in the survivability of houses attacked by a bushfire. The analysis by FESA seeks to identify why the houses are damaged or destroyed, if there are any weaknesses in the advice provided by FESA and how the damage or destruction can be avoided in the future. Biography Ralph commenced working in the mid-1970s as a field officer with the Forests Department. Ralph worked for 26 years with the Forests Department and the Department of Conservation and Land Management. In 2001 Ralph moved to the Fire and Emergency Services Authority as the Manager of Wildfire Prevention. In 2004 Ralph was promoted to the position of Branch Manager of Bush Fire and Environmental Protection within the Fire and Emergency Services Authority. Ralph has extensive knowledge and understanding of bush fire behaviour and the impact that the fire behaviour can have on buildings and the environment. Ralph has served as an Australian Fire and Emergency Services Authorities Council (AFAC) representative on the technical working group for the “Australian Standard 3959 Construction of buildings in bushfire-prone areas”. Ralph has also been a co- author of the planning guidelines document “Planning for Bush Fire Protection” for both the 2001 and 2010 editions. Ralph and his team have undertaken analysis of the complex bush fire behaviour and house loss assessments for all of the recent significant Western Australian bush fire events. Ralph was also invited to work with the Victorian‟s undertaking bush fire investigations during the Black Saturday fires. Ralph‟s work has been recognised with a number of State and National awards for bush fire arson prevention, and the research and publications associated with the “Bush Fire Management Guidelines for Western Australia”. WATER Coastal Hazards and the Design of Coastal Structures Winthrop Professor Charitha Pattiaratchi University of Western Australia The importance and impacts of coastal hazards, particularly extreme events such as tsunamis and storm surges, has been illustrated very graphically through recent events such as the Japanese earthquake in March and Cyclone Yasi. During both of these events, extreme inundation of coastal areas occurred resulting in significant damage to infrastructure. In this presentation, different processes which contribute to coastal sea level variability leading to extreme events will be reviewed with an emphasis on Western Australia. It is shown that these processes occur over a range timescales ranging from seconds to centuries and are subject to long-term variability some of which, such as those due to astronomical tides, may be predicted. The action of the wind on the sea surface generates surface gravity waves with periods of the order of 10s. Although the swell waves are generated in the deeper ocean they have a major influence in coastal regions. Globally, the astronomical forces of the Sun and the Moon result in tidal variability with periods of 12 and 24 hours as well as tidal modulations with periods up to 18.6 years. In many regions, the effects of the tides dominate the water level variability – however, in regions where the tidal effects are small other processes also become important in determining the local water level. In this presentation, sea level data from Fremantle (tidal range ~0.5m), which has one of the longest time series records in the southern hemisphere, and other sea level recoding stations from Western Australia are presented to highlight the different processes ranging from seiches, tsunamis (generated through earthquakes and thunderstorms), tides, storm surges, continental shelf waves, annual and inter-annual variability. As the contribution from each of these processes is of the same order of magnitude they all contribute to the extreme sea levels. 9
  • 10. Engineers Australia WA Division Earth, Wind, Fire, Water: Engineering for Extreme Natural Events 15 Sept 2011 The majority of existing coastal infrastructure in Australia was designed to tolerate or at least survive occasional effects from extreme sea levels (e.g., 1 in 100 or l in 1,000 year prospects of inundation). As a result of coastal hazards, including mean sea level rise due to global warming, these designed tolerances will be exceeded with increasing frequency. The implications for changes in return periods on coastal infrastructure in Western Australia will be discussed. Biography Charitha Pattiaratchi is a Winthrop professor of coastal oceanography at the School of Environmental Systems Engineering, the University of Western Australia. His research interests are in coastal physical oceanography and coastal sediment transport, using field and numerical modelling techniques. He obtained a BSc (joint honours in oceanography and applied mathematics), MSc and PhD (both in oceanography) from the University of Wales, Swansea, UK. He has been at UWA since 1988. Currently his affiliations includes Leader, Australian National Facility for Ocean Gliders, Node leader, West Australian Integrated Marine Observation System (WAIMOS), Chair, Numerical modelling, forecasting and scenario development working group of the Indian Ocean Tsunami Warning System, Chair, Physics of Estuaries and Coastal Seas International conference. He has supervised over 100 honours students and 30 postgraduate students and published over 100 refereed journal articles. Note: Photograph of the speakers (during the panel session) below (L to R): Prof Charitha Pattiaratchi; Mr Ralph Smith; Mr David Brunsdon; Mr Charles Boyle 10
  • 11. Engineers Australia WA Division 712 Murray Street West Perth WA 6005 Phone: (08) 9321 3340 Fax: (08) 9481 4332 Email: wa@engineersaustralia.org.au Web: www.engineersaustralia.org.au/wa Western Australia Division