SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 11
What’s All the fuss about Carbon? Explaining the emissions market
World Carbon Markets
Misconceptions About Carbon Markets Existing carbon is not traded. The reduction of carbon emissions into the atmosphere are traded. Primary markets trade between firms in allowances issued by regulatory bodies.  e.g. the auctioning of allowances.  Secondary markets involve the re-sale for profit or loss of carbon derivatives.
Some Background EU ETS allowance market is 75% of the total world carbon market The average value of a single carbon trade is £50,000 (~75,000 USD) In the first half of 2009 €8billion (~11.8 billion USD) worth of allowances were traded ¼ of these trades were on the spot market
EU ETS History
States or companies can achieve their reduction targets without reducing their own emissions.  Acquired emissions certificates can be traded. Flexible mechanisms There are  a broad range of offset projects that could be specifically targeted to improve brand image or competitiveness.   Example:  Duke Energy companies sponsoring local dairies for methane digesters plus solar on roves of their facilities.
Long Delays Halve the Prospects of 2012 CER Deliveries The CDM has been working through the same problems facing the many US protocols. That is….how to make the program climate friendly without making it too onerous. Under HR2454 two billion tons of offsets would allowed to meet emission reduction goals..split evenly between domestic & international sources.
Increased Scrutiny by the CDM EB at Registration
World Carbon Markets
Explaining Emissions Trading

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Destaque

Global warming history
Global warming historyGlobal warming history
Global warming historyEric Bendler
 
Business guide on carbon emission redution and sustainability
Business guide on carbon emission redution and sustainabilityBusiness guide on carbon emission redution and sustainability
Business guide on carbon emission redution and sustainabilityBarney Loehnis
 
The Near Future of CSS
The Near Future of CSSThe Near Future of CSS
The Near Future of CSSRachel Andrew
 
How to Battle Bad Reviews
How to Battle Bad ReviewsHow to Battle Bad Reviews
How to Battle Bad ReviewsGlassdoor
 
Classroom Management Tips for Kids and Adolescents
Classroom Management Tips for Kids and AdolescentsClassroom Management Tips for Kids and Adolescents
Classroom Management Tips for Kids and AdolescentsShelly Sanchez Terrell
 
The Buyer's Journey - by Chris Lema
The Buyer's Journey - by Chris LemaThe Buyer's Journey - by Chris Lema
The Buyer's Journey - by Chris LemaChris Lema
 
The Presentation Come-Back Kid
The Presentation Come-Back KidThe Presentation Come-Back Kid
The Presentation Come-Back KidEthos3
 

Destaque (11)

Global warming history
Global warming historyGlobal warming history
Global warming history
 
carbon emission & carbon credit
carbon emission & carbon creditcarbon emission & carbon credit
carbon emission & carbon credit
 
CCER and Carbon Emission Allowance
CCER and Carbon Emission AllowanceCCER and Carbon Emission Allowance
CCER and Carbon Emission Allowance
 
Carbon emission blog
Carbon emission blogCarbon emission blog
Carbon emission blog
 
Carbon Trading
Carbon TradingCarbon Trading
Carbon Trading
 
Business guide on carbon emission redution and sustainability
Business guide on carbon emission redution and sustainabilityBusiness guide on carbon emission redution and sustainability
Business guide on carbon emission redution and sustainability
 
The Near Future of CSS
The Near Future of CSSThe Near Future of CSS
The Near Future of CSS
 
How to Battle Bad Reviews
How to Battle Bad ReviewsHow to Battle Bad Reviews
How to Battle Bad Reviews
 
Classroom Management Tips for Kids and Adolescents
Classroom Management Tips for Kids and AdolescentsClassroom Management Tips for Kids and Adolescents
Classroom Management Tips for Kids and Adolescents
 
The Buyer's Journey - by Chris Lema
The Buyer's Journey - by Chris LemaThe Buyer's Journey - by Chris Lema
The Buyer's Journey - by Chris Lema
 
The Presentation Come-Back Kid
The Presentation Come-Back KidThe Presentation Come-Back Kid
The Presentation Come-Back Kid
 

Semelhante a Explaining Emissions Trading

Introduction to Carbon Markets
Introduction to Carbon Markets Introduction to Carbon Markets
Introduction to Carbon Markets sanjoysanyal
 
M sc. carbon credit
M sc. carbon creditM sc. carbon credit
M sc. carbon creditJosef Ak
 
carbon credits
carbon credits carbon credits
carbon credits AhedDiwan
 
Krishna Dahre presentation 3.pptx
Krishna Dahre presentation 3.pptxKrishna Dahre presentation 3.pptx
Krishna Dahre presentation 3.pptxKrishnaDahre
 
Europe carbon-emissions-trading
Europe carbon-emissions-tradingEurope carbon-emissions-trading
Europe carbon-emissions-tradingKevin A
 
Europe carbon-emissions-trading
Europe carbon-emissions-tradingEurope carbon-emissions-trading
Europe carbon-emissions-tradingAbhishek Kumar
 
Carbon credits
Carbon creditsCarbon credits
Carbon creditsjennna
 
Cs presentation mj april 5th 2013
Cs presentation   mj april 5th 2013Cs presentation   mj april 5th 2013
Cs presentation mj april 5th 2013Madeleine Allcock
 
Policies And Technologies
Policies And TechnologiesPolicies And Technologies
Policies And TechnologiesDavid Hone
 
How To Profit From Carbon Credit Trading
How To Profit From Carbon Credit TradingHow To Profit From Carbon Credit Trading
How To Profit From Carbon Credit TradingNew Advisory
 
Carbon markets and its performance
Carbon markets and its performance Carbon markets and its performance
Carbon markets and its performance shilpapanginikkode
 
Emission Reduction Benefits
Emission Reduction BenefitsEmission Reduction Benefits
Emission Reduction BenefitsAshish Ranjan
 
Cap and Trade Emissions - Carbon Tax or Carbon Pricing - 101
Cap and Trade Emissions - Carbon Tax or Carbon Pricing - 101Cap and Trade Emissions - Carbon Tax or Carbon Pricing - 101
Cap and Trade Emissions - Carbon Tax or Carbon Pricing - 101paul young cpa, cga
 
2n122wei Cai
2n122wei Cai2n122wei Cai
2n122wei Caiwilsonlwc
 

Semelhante a Explaining Emissions Trading (20)

Introduction to Carbon Markets
Introduction to Carbon Markets Introduction to Carbon Markets
Introduction to Carbon Markets
 
Carbon Trading
Carbon TradingCarbon Trading
Carbon Trading
 
Emissions Trading
Emissions TradingEmissions Trading
Emissions Trading
 
M sc. carbon credit
M sc. carbon creditM sc. carbon credit
M sc. carbon credit
 
carbon credits
carbon credits carbon credits
carbon credits
 
Krishna Dahre presentation 3.pptx
Krishna Dahre presentation 3.pptxKrishna Dahre presentation 3.pptx
Krishna Dahre presentation 3.pptx
 
Soniii
SoniiiSoniii
Soniii
 
Europe carbon-emissions-trading
Europe carbon-emissions-tradingEurope carbon-emissions-trading
Europe carbon-emissions-trading
 
Europe carbon-emissions-trading
Europe carbon-emissions-tradingEurope carbon-emissions-trading
Europe carbon-emissions-trading
 
Carbon credits
Carbon creditsCarbon credits
Carbon credits
 
Cs presentation mj april 5th 2013
Cs presentation   mj april 5th 2013Cs presentation   mj april 5th 2013
Cs presentation mj april 5th 2013
 
Carbon credit
Carbon creditCarbon credit
Carbon credit
 
Policies And Technologies
Policies And TechnologiesPolicies And Technologies
Policies And Technologies
 
How To Profit From Carbon Credit Trading
How To Profit From Carbon Credit TradingHow To Profit From Carbon Credit Trading
How To Profit From Carbon Credit Trading
 
Carbon markets and its performance
Carbon markets and its performance Carbon markets and its performance
Carbon markets and its performance
 
Emission Reduction Benefits
Emission Reduction BenefitsEmission Reduction Benefits
Emission Reduction Benefits
 
Carbon Credit
Carbon CreditCarbon Credit
Carbon Credit
 
Cap and Trade Emissions - Carbon Tax or Carbon Pricing - 101
Cap and Trade Emissions - Carbon Tax or Carbon Pricing - 101Cap and Trade Emissions - Carbon Tax or Carbon Pricing - 101
Cap and Trade Emissions - Carbon Tax or Carbon Pricing - 101
 
2n122wei Cai
2n122wei Cai2n122wei Cai
2n122wei Cai
 
Carbon Credits
Carbon CreditsCarbon Credits
Carbon Credits
 

Último

Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )
Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )
Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )Pooja Nehwal
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdfGale Pooley
 
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignLog your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignHenry Tapper
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free DeliveryMalad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free DeliveryPooja Nehwal
 
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home Delivery
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home DeliveryPooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home Delivery
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home DeliveryPooja Nehwal
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdfGale Pooley
 
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikHigh Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikCall Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure service
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure serviceCall US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure service
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure servicePooja Nehwal
 
(DIYA) Bhumkar Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(DIYA) Bhumkar Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(DIYA) Bhumkar Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(DIYA) Bhumkar Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...ranjana rawat
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdfGale Pooley
 
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...ssifa0344
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdfGale Pooley
 
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptxFinTech Belgium
 
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of MarketingQuarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of MarketingMaristelaRamos12
 
VVIP Pune Call Girls Katraj (7001035870) Pune Escorts Nearby with Complete Sa...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Katraj (7001035870) Pune Escorts Nearby with Complete Sa...VVIP Pune Call Girls Katraj (7001035870) Pune Escorts Nearby with Complete Sa...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Katraj (7001035870) Pune Escorts Nearby with Complete Sa...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Gomti Nagar Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Gomti Nagar Lucknow best sexual serviceCALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Gomti Nagar Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Gomti Nagar Lucknow best sexual serviceanilsa9823
 
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptxOAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptxhiddenlevers
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School SpiritInstant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spiritegoetzinger
 

Último (20)

Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )
Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )
Vip Call US 📞 7738631006 ✅Call Girls In Sakinaka ( Mumbai )
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 18.pdf
 
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignLog your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
 
Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - April 2024
Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - April 2024Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - April 2024
Commercial Bank Economic Capsule - April 2024
 
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free DeliveryMalad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
 
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home Delivery
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home DeliveryPooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home Delivery
Pooja 9892124323 : Call Girl in Juhu Escorts Service Free Home Delivery
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 21.pdf
 
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service NashikHigh Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
High Class Call Girls Nashik Maya 7001305949 Independent Escort Service Nashik
 
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure service
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure serviceCall US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure service
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure service
 
(DIYA) Bhumkar Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(DIYA) Bhumkar Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...(DIYA) Bhumkar Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
(DIYA) Bhumkar Chowk Call Girls Just Call 7001035870 [ Cash on Delivery ] Pun...
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 20.pdf
 
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
Solution Manual for Financial Accounting, 11th Edition by Robert Libby, Patri...
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 22.pdf
 
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
05_Annelore Lenoir_Docbyte_MeetupDora&Cybersecurity.pptx
 
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of MarketingQuarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
Quarter 4- Module 3 Principles of Marketing
 
VVIP Pune Call Girls Katraj (7001035870) Pune Escorts Nearby with Complete Sa...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Katraj (7001035870) Pune Escorts Nearby with Complete Sa...VVIP Pune Call Girls Katraj (7001035870) Pune Escorts Nearby with Complete Sa...
VVIP Pune Call Girls Katraj (7001035870) Pune Escorts Nearby with Complete Sa...
 
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Gomti Nagar Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Gomti Nagar Lucknow best sexual serviceCALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Gomti Nagar Lucknow best sexual service
CALL ON ➥8923113531 🔝Call Girls Gomti Nagar Lucknow best sexual service
 
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptxOAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
OAT_RI_Ep19 WeighingTheRisks_Apr24_TheYellowMetal.pptx
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School SpiritInstant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
Instant Issue Debit Cards - High School Spirit
 

Explaining Emissions Trading

  • 1. What’s All the fuss about Carbon? Explaining the emissions market
  • 3. Misconceptions About Carbon Markets Existing carbon is not traded. The reduction of carbon emissions into the atmosphere are traded. Primary markets trade between firms in allowances issued by regulatory bodies. e.g. the auctioning of allowances. Secondary markets involve the re-sale for profit or loss of carbon derivatives.
  • 4. Some Background EU ETS allowance market is 75% of the total world carbon market The average value of a single carbon trade is £50,000 (~75,000 USD) In the first half of 2009 €8billion (~11.8 billion USD) worth of allowances were traded ¼ of these trades were on the spot market
  • 6.
  • 7. States or companies can achieve their reduction targets without reducing their own emissions. Acquired emissions certificates can be traded. Flexible mechanisms There are a broad range of offset projects that could be specifically targeted to improve brand image or competitiveness. Example: Duke Energy companies sponsoring local dairies for methane digesters plus solar on roves of their facilities.
  • 8. Long Delays Halve the Prospects of 2012 CER Deliveries The CDM has been working through the same problems facing the many US protocols. That is….how to make the program climate friendly without making it too onerous. Under HR2454 two billion tons of offsets would allowed to meet emission reduction goals..split evenly between domestic & international sources.
  • 9. Increased Scrutiny by the CDM EB at Registration

Notas do Editor

  1. Insert graphic!£ = British Pounds€ = EurosAn explanation of the spot market comes a little later. We should view this as a learning curve. Mistakes will be made as implementing this cap onto an economy that was built upon the cheap, available, fossil fuel beneath us.
  2. Delete unimportant (most) dates along x-axis. This represents Phase I & Phase II of the EU ETS. Allowances were fully bankable WITHIN each phase. They were not bankable between phases. This is what led to the drop in EUA 2007 volumes/prices. The worldwide economic recession can be seen between the July 2008 and March 2009 periods. This happens simply because individuals and businesses have less cash flow, and require less power. Less power generation creates lower emissions and reduces the demand for carbon credits.
  3. Where’s Norway?United States – Russia – India – Indonesia – Braizil –
  4. Simple illustration of how command and control from the EPA or Supreme Court would compare to cap & trade. Flexibility for firms to find the lower MAC is what separates the market mechanism of emissions trading. Strong internationally? Offset there and meet your requirement here in the US.
  5. Since the inception of the CDM there have been 290 million CERs issued. Point Carbon anticipates 1.78 billion CERs issued by the end of 2012.Consternation: Economic downturn and subsequent credit crunch hurting financing of projects CDM EB regulatory delays and transaction costs Lack of solid worldwide post 2012 policy.
  6. In the US - EPA assessment tells us there is probably only going to be less than 500 million tonnes of domestic offsets available in the next 30 yearsThe UN issued just 1.5 million carbon credits last week, as delays continued to clog the pipeline.. You can see CLEARLY, that the standard of registration has increased over the last 4 years.This could be viewed as a response to those quick to dismiss the CDM as a “right to pollute”. Ok, picture this. The US offset market could require billions of tonnes of offsets. If domestic offsets are insufficient (they WILL be) then the demand for international offsets could be as much as 1.5 billion tonnes. With increasing scrutiny by the CDM (as as stand in for the international standard) there could be a serious bidding-up of offset projects around the world. This will only be increased as other countries mandate a carbon cap on their economies, creating THEIR OWN demand for domestic (international to us) and international offsets. Will there be enough to go around? Will they be fungible? Will they truly be additional? Will the increasingly onerous standards for project development make that 2.5 billion tonne allowance strategic reserve inevitable?If the strategic reserve is enacted repeatedly, will the planet suffer? Will it limit the effectiveness of HR2454 even further than environmental alarmists worry?