Improving library services for homeless - 2016 keough
1. Improving Library Services for our
Homeless Patrons
(and those facing housing crises)
Delaware
MLA/DLA JOINT STATE CONFERENCE
2016
CATHAY KEOUGH
STATEWIDE COORDINATOR, DELAWARE LIBRARY REFERENCE SERVICE
DELAWARE DIVISION OF LIBRARIES
CATHAY.KEOUGH@LIB.DE.US
2. How widespread this was in Delaware
How it affected library staff
If there was a way I could help staff learn ways to work more
effectively, gain resources and tools, I first needed to know:
3. Assumptions
“Addressing homelessness as librarians can be challenging.
Stereotypes, misinformation or lack of understanding, uncomfortable
personal experiences, and feeling overwhelmed can all contribute to
making this a difficult topic.”
- Julie Ann Winklestein
“Library Services for Patrons Experiencing Homelessness”
4. Questions
Why should libraries be part of the
caring community surrounding those
experiencing homelessness?
What are the barriers to library
service experienced by library users
who are unstably housed? What are
their information needs?
http://proof.nationalgeographic.com/2015/04/24/publ
ic-library-portraits-californias-homeless-connect-in-
a-quiet-place/
5. “Public libraries provide the homeless with a way to connect, and many homeless
say that browsing the stacks and reading a book there eases a weary street-level
perspective of life.”
Edward Rideau reads Statutes and Amendments to the Codes of California at
the Sacramento Public Library Central Branch. With poor eyesight he must
hold the book close enough to be able to read the fine text.
From: http://proof.nationalgeographic.com/2015/04/24/public-library-portraits-
californias-homeless-connect-in-a-quiet-place/
6. How many view this topic
Homeless man in Paris, France
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness
7. “Glen Carney works on a painting in the community room at RedLine Gallery, 2350
Arapahoe St., in Denver. Every Tuesday, the community room — located in the back of
the sprawling gallery — transforms into Reach Studio, a creative melting pot of
homeless and transient people painting, some for the first time. The gallery is headed
by PJ D'Amico, a former shelter worker.”
-Karl Gehring, The Denver Post, 2012
9. 2015 U.S. Point in Time Stats
On a Single Night in January 2015
564,708 people were homeless in
the United States.
PIT Estimates of Homeless, from
http://ldi.upenn.edu/sites/default/files/rte/2
015-AHAR-Part-1.pdf
10. Examining Delaware
A. A. Delaware’s ten year plan and ways to measure success.
B. How many people are we talking about?
C. A look at programs that are already in place and how many of
these are successfully working with libraries.
D. Identifying two types of programs:
1. Addressing the immediate problem with the least amount of effort
(reactive) – primarily working independently.
2. Exploring a long-term approach on a broader scale (proactive) --
working collaboratively.
11. Delaware’s Plan to End Homelessness
Guiding Principles
Compassionate and Consistent.
Persons experiencing homelessness should be treated with dignity and
respect Compassionate and Consistent. All persons experiencing
homelessness are in crisis.
Transparent and Accountable.
In order for systems to work effectively and efficiently they must be
transparent to all stakeholders (providers, consumers, funders, etc.).
Guiding Principles for Delaware’s Homeless Assistance System:
http://www.destatehousing.com/FormsAndInformation/Publications/plan_end_homeless.pdf
12. Milestones
2005: The Delaware Interagency Council on Homelessness (DICH) was created by
Executive Order number 65 in March 2005 by Governor Ruth Ann Minner.
DICH released Breaking the Cycle: Delaware’s Ten Year Plan to End Chronic Homelessness
and Reduce Long-Term Homelessness. The Plan included five major strategies for ending
chronic homelessness:
1. Develop new housing for persons who are chronically homeless or at risk for
chronic homelessness
2. Remove barriers to accessing existing affordable housing
3. Improve discharge and transition planning
4. Improve supportive services for persons who are homeless
5. Enhance data collection and the use of technology
2008: Codified in Delaware law.
13. 2009: Congress and President Obama signed into law the HEARTH Act
2010: Opening Doors was created (federal strategic plan)
2011: The Delaware Plan to Prevent and End Homelessness was
created
2013: By this date, 19 federal, state and local partners were working
collaboratively – first to address those who have been chronically
homeless (close to 450 units of permanent supportive housing, most
of it targeted to people with disabilities who have long histories of
homelessness)
14. The State of Delaware has a population of 897,934 people (2010 US Census
data) in its three counties, with the most people living in the northern part of
the state in New Castle County.
This is 14.6% increase from the 2000 Census count. At this rate, Delaware’s
population will surpass 1 million before 2020.
Delaware Census
15. Some stats – Homelessness in Delaware
(from the Governor’s office, 2013)
On any given day, there are approximately 1,000 men, women and children
staying in Delaware emergency shelters and transitional housing programs.
Over 8,021 people have at least one episode of homelessness during the
year than those who are homeless at any given point in time.
Over half (51%) of Delaware’s homeless population is Black—a
disproportionate representation of Delaware’s population.
Over half are males (58%).
42% of those experiencing homelessness at any given time are members of
a family with the average size of a family being 3 persons.
19% of Delaware’s homeless population are children under the age of 18
and 6% are between the ages of 18 and 24.
8% report being institutionalized before the age of 18.
16. Code Purple History/Newark
Year # of CP
Nights
Total Guests Avg # of persons
per night
2008-09 28 168 6
2009-10 28 224 8
2010-11 31 403 13
2011-12 4 50 12.5
2012-13 13 196 15
2013-14 34 597 17.5
2014-15 32 688 21.5
2015-16 16 436 27.25
Newark’s population
is 32, 529
and is the location of
the University of
Delaware.
17. A sampling of partnership
programs with libraries
ACA partnerships in place with organizations familiar with health care
resources.
VISTA volunteer organizing partnerships with community college nursing
students to provide blood pressure screening.
Attempts at partnering with social workers in libraries.
Partner listserv, networking with other non-profits .
Kindness Corner
Lazarus Rising Program
http://americanlibrariesmagazine.org/latest-links/manchester-council-bans-homeless-people-from-using-the-library
18. Kindness Corner
Highlights:
Early fall 2015: From connection made through a library staff
training program called ILEAD, a partnership was formed with a
community agency called A.C.E. Peer Center (Mental Health
Association of Southeastern PA)
Sept 2015: Created team with pilot library (Georgetown Public
Library; county seat, Sussex County). Held first planning meeting.
Oct 2015-Jan 2016: Formed guidelines, descriptions, goals of
program. Conducted a survey over two week period.
Accepted by library board.
Feb 1, 2016: Kindness Corner began (4 nights a week, 5-8pm)
As of today, the Kindness Corner is running on a permanent basis
2 nights a week
19. “The Kindness Corner creates a space that
allows various agencies, advocates and
individuals to work together with the local
library to make sure that no one falls through
the cracks of our social support system. We
are all links in a chain of social support and
the local library is a safe and friendly place to
position the "kindness corner" activity within
our community where goodness has a chance
to happen for a person in crisis or in need.
“I think this approach works because we are
building a community who cares for our
vulnerable neighbors who are reaching out to
others for help. It is also the building of
relationships and friendships that help people
not just to survive, but to strive for more and
thrive. “
-Jim Martin, A.C.E Director
A.C.E. (http://www.acepeercenter.org/ and
on FB: https://www.facebook.com/pages/ACE-Peer-Center/116354805189350 )
20. Lazarus Rising
http://www.lazarusrising.org/
Mission:
“Lazarus Rising aims to effectively and efficiently combat homelessness through the
provision of job placement skills. We empower our participants through personalized
resume reviews, mock interviews, and job search portal navigation at absolutely no
cost to either our participants or our community partners.”
21. Goals to Prevent and End Homelessness
Delaware has adopted the same goals as the United States Interagency
Council on Homelessness in Opening Doors: The Federal Strategic Plan
to Prevent and End Homelessness
Finish the Job of Ending Chronic Homelessness by 2015
Prevent and End Veterans Homelessness by 2015
Prevent and End Family Homelessness by 2020
Setting a path to ending all types of homelessness
22. Placing a person in a permanent home and providing the necessary wrap-
around services for that person so they can be integrated in their community
leads to a successful outcome. Delaware must invest in these best practices to
ensure success at preventing and ending homelessness.
-Delaware’s Plan to End and Prevent Homelessness
24. What can you do?
Take a personal interest in learning and helping.
Attend more workshops, webinars and trainings (PLA, InfoPeople/ALA)
Volunteer if you are inclined to really get involved. There are plenty of
opportunities. I find that the more I work directly with various members
of my community, the more I see them for what they are – my neighbors.
Learn from experts online on TED, YouTube, such as from Ryan Dowd (see
bibliography).
Take a Mental Health First Aid course.
Network/ attend meetings and programs that address the homeless
situation in your community.
Read – through ALA: http://www.ala.org/offices/extending-our-reach-
reducing-homelessness-through-library-engagement
Discover how to more effectively collaborate with community partners.
Become an advocate.
25. Purposeful Collaboration
Homeless singers - Wisconsin State Journal, August 16, 2015 by Claire Bitner
System transformation
requires forward
thinking and the
realization that change
occurs when we are all
moving in the same
direction.
26. Collective Impact
… is a framework to tackle deeply entrenched and complex social
problems. It is an innovative and structured approach to making
collaboration work across government, business, philanthropy, non-profit
organizations and citizens to achieve significant and lasting social change.
_______________________________________________________
Collective Impact
by John Kania and Mark Kramer
Stanford Social Innovation Review, 2011
http://ssir.org/images/articles/2011_WI_Feature_Kania.pdf
27. Thank you!
CATHAY KEOUGH
STATEWIDE COORDINATOR, DELAWARE LIBRARY REFERENCE SERVICE
DELAWARE DIVISION OF LIBRARIES
CATHAY.KEOUGH@LIB.DE.US
28. Bibliography
Delaware’s Plan to End and Prevent Homelessness (2013):
http://www.destatehousing.com/FormsAndInformation/Publications/plan_
end_homeless.pdf
State of Delaware/DHSS: Community Health Status Assessment:
http://www.dhss.delaware.gov/dhss/dph/files/shachsa.pdf
Delaware State Housing list of emergency shelters:
http://www.destatehousing.com/FAQs/EmergencyShelters.pdf
Delaware 2-1-1 for Code Purple:
http://www.delaware211.org/newsdetail.php?did=120
____________________________________________________________________
Much of the following bibliography and recommended reading comes from an
extensive source provided with permission by instructor Julie Ann Winklestein
through the four-week course, “Library Services for Patrons Experiencing
Homelessness” (Feb-March 2016)
29. Bibliography
US Dept. of Health and Human Services/Homelessness: http://www.hhs.gov/programs/social-
services/homelessness/index.html#
HUD – Homeless Information for Delaware:
http://portal.hud.gov/hudportal/HUD?src=/states/delaware/homeless
National Alliance to End Homelessness Snapshot of Homelessness:
http://www.endhomelessness.org/pages/snapshot_of_homelessness
National Coalition for Homeless Veterans: http://nchv.org/
Homebase for Housing: Housing Type Definitions:
http://homebaseforhousing.org/Education/Definitions.cshtml
Library Social Worker help homeless seeking quiet refuge (San Francisco) PBS:
http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/library-social-worker-helps-homeless-seeking-quiet-refuge/
National Geographic: PROOF: Picture stories: California's Homeless Find a Quiet
Place (proof.nationalgeographic.com/2015/04/24/public-library-portraits-californias-homeless-
connect-in-a-quiet-place), by Fritz Hoffmann.
30. Bibliography
National Coalition for the Homeless (nationalhomeless.org/about-
homelessness).
Includes issues, reports, publications, links to other resources.
National Association for the Education of Homeless Children and
Youth (www.naehcy.org/about-naehcy/mission).
"NAEHCY is the only professional organization specifically dedicated to
meeting the educational needs of children and youth experiencing
homelessness. We provide professional development, resources, and
training support for anyone and everyone interested in supporting the
academic success of children and youth challenged by homelessness."
National Center for Homeless
Education (center.serve.org/nche/IBT/aw_video.php)
Includes a range of excellent resources on education and homelessness.
Good for public and school librarians. Their video links are excellent, too.
31. For Further Reading
"Extending Our Reach: Reducing Homelessness Through Library Engagement" is
designed to help librarians and library staff create meaningful library services for
people who are experiencing homelessness: http://www.ala.org/offices/extending-
our-reach-reducing-homelessness-through-library-engagement (American Library
Association) Online resource and downloadable pdf. Includes ALA policy on services
to people experiencing poverty and homelessness.
Byrne, Terri and Plumadore, Julian (2014). Language
Matters (mentalhealthsf.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/16ICHC-A1_C5-
Language-Matters.pdf). Mental Health Association of San Francisco.
Culhane, Dennis (July 11, 2010). Five myths about America's
homeless (www.washingtonpost.com/wp-
dyn/content/article/2010/07/09/AR2010070902357.html). The Washington Post.
Dunlap, Nathan, Rynell, Amy, Young, Melissa, and Warland, Chris (January
2012). Populations Experiencing Homelessness: Diverse Barriers to Employment and
How to Address Them
(http://nationalinitiatives.issuelab.org/resource/populations_experiencing_homeles
sness_diverse_barriers_to_employment_and_how_to_address_them). Working to
END Homelessness.
32. For Further Reading
Warth, Gary (December 30, 2015). Libraries pitch in with homeless
count (www.sandiegouniontribune.com/news/2015/dec/30/homeless-count-
county-libraries). The San Diego Union-Tribune.
The Conversation (2015). Libraries on the front lines of the homelessness crisis in the
United States (theconversation.com/libraries-on-the-front-lines-of-the-
homelessness-crisis-in-the-united-states-44453)
Pateman, John (June 26, 2013). Relationships: The Heart of a Community-Led Library
Service (libr.org/isc/john-pateman-relationships-the-heart-of-a-community-led-
library-service-edmonton-public-library-26-jun-2013) Information for Social Change.
WebJunction (September 26, 2011). Putting the Public Back in Public Libraries:
Community-Led Libraries OCLC
(www.webjunction.org/events/webjunction/Putting_the_Public_Back_in_Public_Libr
aries_Community-Led_Libraries.html)
National Coalition for the Homeless (n.d.). How YOU Can Help End
Homelessness (www.nationalhomeless.org/want_to_help/index.html)
Includes suggestions for anyone who wants to be part of ending homelessness.
Some suggestions could be adopted by libraries.
33. Recommended videos/audio clips
◦ A Librarian's Guide to Homelessness (www.youtube.com/watch?v=FYiEEhhrFh4)
Ryan Dowd. YouTube video (38 minutes)
◦ Bryan Dozier – A Hard Way Home (vimeo.com/90078802)
Video about homelessness and mental health; includes facts and interviews. Focuses on David Pirtle, who now works for the
National Coalition for the Homeless. (Length: 9:47)
◦ National Coalition for the Homeless (www.youtube.com/watch?v=9iV446txbfQ)
Video about their work. Includes facts about what they do, statistics about homelessness, interviews, examples of speaker's bureau
talks. This is definitely a marketing tool for NCH, but provides excellent insights and information. Text with video says: "The National
Coalition for the Homeless, founded in 1982, is a national network of people who are currently experiencing or who have
experienced homelessness, activists and advocates, community-based and faith-based service providers, and others committed to
a single mission. That mission, our common bond, is to end homelessness. We are committed to creating the systemic and
attitudinal changes necessary to prevent and end homelessness. At the same time, we work to meet the immediate needs of
people who are currently experiencing homelessness or who are at risk of doing so. We take as our first principle of practice that
people who are currently experiencing homelessness or have formerly experienced homelessness must be actively involved in all of
our work." (Length: 10:29)
◦ Faces of Homelessness II (www.nationalhomeless.org/faces/video.html)
The second in a series of videos created to introduce presentations given by members of the National Coalition for the Homeless'
Faces of Homelessness Speaker's Bureau. Provides excellent insights into lives of those experiencing homelessness. (Length: 9:42)
◦ American University
Radio (wamu.org/programs/metro_connection/15/02/20/after_years_of_homelessness_former_government_worker_struggles_t
o_maintain_identity)
A government worker talks about losing first his job and then his home. He makes some great points. For example, he didn't know
how to be homeless – where to go, who to contact; he feels like a different person being on the streets. Interviewer met him at the
public library. Very moving. (Length: 4:48)
Editor's Notes
Now that we’ve heard about national data and gained insight about Washington DC and Baltimore, here is information about what’s going on with Delaware.
Because my work centers on supporting library reference and public services, I became directly involved in finding out:
A. How widespread this was in Delaware
B. How it affected staff
And if there was a way I could help staff learn, gain resources or tools to be able to work more effectively
This presentation is a report of this journey over the last year
I then had to answer some questions for myself to combat my own misunderstanding and learning process.
Why libraries should be part of the caring community surrounding those experiencing homelessness.
I also wanted to consider the information needs of those experiencing homelessness, how they're using libraries, and some of the barriers they may be encountering as they do so.
(If time, ask “Why do you think libraries should be involved?” and “What barriers do you see?”)
I then had to answer some questions for myself to combat my own misunderstanding and learning process.
Why libraries should be part of the caring community surrounding those experiencing homelessness.
I also wanted to consider the information needs of those experiencing homelessness, how they're using libraries, and some of the barriers they may be encountering as they do so.
(If time, ask “Why do you think libraries should be involved?” and “What barriers do you see?”)
I began to be seriously involved when I had a conversation with the library director of one of our main city libraries. I was there regarding a library-related workshop we were holding in their meeting room, and said to her that I noticed that there seems to be more people hanging about, waiting to get in and staying all day. She responded saying that she used to know the names of each person, that she had gotten to know them to some degree, and it used to be around 15 or 17 patrons, mostly men. But, she said, the situation has grown so much that she can’t keep track anymore. She has no idea who they are, there are so many. When I asked how many people she meant, she said it was hard to know anymore since so many come and go, not the same faces, but it had at least doubled. It was alarming.
She went on to tell me that this was affecting some key areas of her library: staff was affected (complaints, possibly they also made assumptions), and she was in between trying to keep the library as a welcoming place while being diplomatic to her board, who seemed to be wanting her to take a stand on creating more restrictions for library use.
I learned that this story was not unique to this one library. The more I explored, the more common and widespread this was. Although it seems more prevalent in the urban libraries, it was the same story to some degree in most areas. The face of the growing problem was showing up in different ways, such as reports of more vagrancy, more people sleeping in the libraries, lacking hygiene, using the bathrooms for bathing and washing, and the parallel increase of drug traffic and use in the libraries aand immediate communities.
It's easy to get caught up in the common stereotypes and shorthand language that is used for those who don't have a permanent place to live. This approach can be misleading and can make it difficult to look beyond housing status to see a library patron who has specific needs. For example, if you do an Internet search for the term "homeless," you easily find images like this:
There aren’t as many positive images of people who are experiencing homelessness. But viewing more positive images can really help us begin to see things a bit differently.
You can see that people experiencing homelessness are divided nto different categories: sheltered (staying with various friends/family, in transitional or emergency shelters) and unsheltered (exposed to the elements, living in the open somewhere). They have also broken it down by type of person: individuals, families, and so on. Chronic homelessness is a particular category for individuals who are experiencing homelessness and have a disabling condition, which can be either mental or physical.
On a Single Night in January 2015 • 564,708 people were homeless in the United States. • Nearly 7 in 10 (69%) people experiencing homelessness were staying in sheltered locations, and 31 percent were unsheltered. • Nearly two-thirds of people experiencing homelessness (64% or 358,422 people) were individuals. Of those individuals, 205,616 were staying in emergency shelters or transitional housing programs and 152,806 were counted in unsheltered locations. • The remaining 36 percent, or 206,286 people, were people in homeless families with children. Most (185,824 people) were sheltered, while only 20,462 people in families with children were counted in unsheltered locations such as under bridges, in cars, or in abandoned buildings.
Now let’s turn to Delaware as an example. I wanted to find out about what Delaware had already been doing on various levels: state government, Division of Health and Social Services, community programs, and if libraries had something in place, in partnership with agencies or on their own. I began to notice that there were two types of programs happening – one that addressed an immediate need, almost out of a crisis situation such as patrons’ and library staff complaints regarding how the library’s bathroom was being used as a birdbath (washing up). The other addressed the long-term, more broad approach to solving a wide-spread issue, such as the lack of affordable housing.
Delaware’s Ten Year Plan’s guiding principles; like a good mission statement, it provides a grounding focus.
Let’s quickly look at the highlights of what has been happening on the state level.
The HEARTH Act sets a vision that no person should experience homelessness for longer than 30 days and puts emphasis on creating a system that prevents persons from becoming homeless and moves persons experiencing homelessness into permanent housing as quickly as we can with a connection to wraparound services. In 2010, the first federal strategic plan to prevent and end homelessness, Opening Doors, was created by the U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness.
Now a little about Delaware from the Census, to keep things in perspective. There are close to 900,00 residents, and three counties.
With the exception of a core of households who are homeless for long periods of time, there is a tremendous fluidity of people moving into and out of homelessness – some for the first time, some repeatedly over time. Has this increased? Reporting can be tricky since the definitions for who is considered homeless conflict.
Let’s drill down into some local stats from my hometown of Newark, through my personal experience:
In my community, the number of people who are coming to what we call “Code Purple nights” is steadily increasing. Code Purple is called when the temperature falls below a designated temperature – for some areas, it can be below 32 degrees; for others the marker is 10 degrees. Wind chill is another factor. See http://www.hpcdelaware.org/news/detail/code-purple-shelters-how-to-help-our-homeless-neighbors-as-they-contend-wit
http://www.delaware211.org/newsdetail.php?did=120 (2-1-1)
And
http://www.delawareonline.com/story/news/local/2016/02/12/dangerous-cold-temperatures-open-code-purple-shelters/80289822/
Despite the negative reactions that some libraries may turn to in order to try to deal with the rising number of people who in or near a housing crisis – and with this, the rising issues that seem to ride the same tide: drug abuse, situations in which those with mental illness are involved, crime/vagrancy – libraries are working to add positive elements in collaboration with community agencies and schools. The bottom two, the Kindness Corner and Lazarus Rising programs are fairly new. I’ll briefly describe them.
The team consisted of the community partner’s director and supervisor from the Mental Health Association of Southeastern PA, the library director and lead staff person who was also involved with ILEAD, job center coordinator for the county, and me.
The A.C.E. Peer Center’s mission:
http://www.acepeercenter.org/about-us/
http://www.mhasp.org/services/the-ace-peer-resource-center.html
The A.C.E. Peer Center’s mission:
http://www.acepeercenter.org/about-us/
The library director also seems very pleased with this program and has been talking about it to other libraries in her county.
Another program recently sprang up through our networking is a program targeting people who are in crisis and are in need of finding jobs, but have no computers, Internet, etc. Libraries have much of these resources set up, such as through what was formally called our Job Centers, and are still going strong with helping anyone with resumes, careers, job seeking, applications, etc. Assistance can mean the need to work one-on-one with someone a few times to get that application and cover letter in. The founder, Matt Rojas, and his colleagues are students at UD.
They provide services provide to low-income, homeless members of our community. Their non-profit recruits student volunteers, trains them in many of the “soft” job skills, and works with area shelters and other non-profits to help prepare homeless Delawareans to get a job… making this a natural fit for partnering with libraries. Lazarus Rising sprang up out of a grad student’s interest in helping our community. It now extends to other college/university campuses. Library staff are often very busy, so if there is a way to provide excellent, trained help that you can count on, it works for everyone.
From the ten-year plan – obviously there is still work to be done. We are behind schedule – this was a bit idealistic. But the goals remain and work continues.
From http://www.destatehousing.com/FormsAndInformation/Publications/plan_end_homeless.pdf
What’s next for Delaware – and really, for everywhere?
It really comes down to what you and your library can do. You’re learning some ideas and takeaways from today. Here are a few ideas, and I’ll elaborate on one about collaboration, because that is really the key.
When we work with partners who are already invested in a positive outcome, we can move beyond the helpless feeling that this is too big, that this issue is too hard, too complex and vast.
One exciting way is to read and learn about Collective Impact. This is a way to more effectively collaborate with community partners. Here is the link to the Stanford University’s article about it. There are qualified trainers and leaders in this already helping non-profits learn to think outside the box about how to find common denominators of issues, who we can work with, and how we can make the partnership last.
Much of the following bibliography and recommended reading comes from an extensive source provided with permission by - Julie Ann Winklestein“Library Services for Patrons Experiencing Homelessness”, an online InfoPeople Course (Feb-March 2016)