SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 25
Of Costs and Consequences: Using Cost-Benefit Analysis in Justice Policymaking  July 28, 2010 Tina Chiu, Director of Technical Assistance Presentation at the NCSL Legislative Summit Issue Forum: A Data-Driven Approach to Reducing Prison Spending
Vera Institute of Justice ,[object Object],[object Object]
Cost-Benefit Analysis Unit (CBAU) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
CBAU Projects ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cost-Benefit Analysis Basics
Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) Is… ,[object Object],[object Object]
Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) Is… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
A Spectrum of Economic Evaluations ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Advantages of CBA ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
CBA in (Roughly) 5 Steps ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
An Educated Consumer Wants to Know… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
CBA Findings Will  Not … ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cost-Benefit Analysis of Justice Policies & Programs
Examples of CBA Application ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cost-Benefit Studies ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cost-Benefit Findings ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cost-Benefit Findings, Example 1 Recidivism impacts for several adult offender programs and their associated benefits in Washington State. Change In  Crime (# of EB Studies) Benefits Minus Costs, per-person, life cycle  ( Probability: you lose $)  Adult Drug Courts -9% (67) $6,264 (<1%) Education Programs, Prison -8% (17) $13,555  (<1%) Cognitive Behavioral Treatment -7% (27)   $12,037  (<1%) ISP: surveillance -2% (23) -$2,174  (≈82%) Drug Treatment in Prison  (TC or out-patient) -6% (21)  $9,588  (<1%) Programs Source: Washington State Institute for Public Policy, Draft 2010 Findings
Cost-Benefit Findings, Example 2 Recidivism impacts for several juvenile programs and their associated benefits in New York State.
Washington State’s CBA Approach ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
What Can You Do to Get Started?  ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cost-Benefit Analysis Resources
Resources ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
More Resources ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Cost-Benefit Knowledge Bank ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Contact Information ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

9054 Cardiff Student Poster final .6.08b
9054 Cardiff Student Poster final .6.08b9054 Cardiff Student Poster final .6.08b
9054 Cardiff Student Poster final .6.08b
Nicola Allen
 
Policy Impact,Evaluation and Change (CoOL J)
Policy Impact,Evaluation and Change (CoOL J)Policy Impact,Evaluation and Change (CoOL J)
Policy Impact,Evaluation and Change (CoOL J)
nida19
 
Methodology behvaiour change luleå
Methodology behvaiour change luleåMethodology behvaiour change luleå
Methodology behvaiour change luleå
Annika Sällström
 
Pres acap2012 apr11_blewett
Pres acap2012 apr11_blewettPres acap2012 apr11_blewett
Pres acap2012 apr11_blewett
soder145
 
Strategic management: a critical element in implementing private medicine ret...
Strategic management: a critical element in implementing private medicine ret...Strategic management: a critical element in implementing private medicine ret...
Strategic management: a critical element in implementing private medicine ret...
CREHS
 
STAKEHOLDERS : their role and influence in public policy
STAKEHOLDERS : their role and influence in public policySTAKEHOLDERS : their role and influence in public policy
STAKEHOLDERS : their role and influence in public policy
Deanne Mitzi Somollo
 

Mais procurados (20)

9054 Cardiff Student Poster final .6.08b
9054 Cardiff Student Poster final .6.08b9054 Cardiff Student Poster final .6.08b
9054 Cardiff Student Poster final .6.08b
 
Linking Performance and Budgeting: A Framework and Current U.S. Practice
Linking Performance and Budgeting: A Framework and Current U.S. PracticeLinking Performance and Budgeting: A Framework and Current U.S. Practice
Linking Performance and Budgeting: A Framework and Current U.S. Practice
 
Revisiting the SCHIP Funding Formula
Revisiting the SCHIP Funding FormulaRevisiting the SCHIP Funding Formula
Revisiting the SCHIP Funding Formula
 
Policy Impact,Evaluation and Change (CoOL J)
Policy Impact,Evaluation and Change (CoOL J)Policy Impact,Evaluation and Change (CoOL J)
Policy Impact,Evaluation and Change (CoOL J)
 
Bridging the hydropower policy implementation gap-bpig (mk11)
Bridging the hydropower policy implementation gap-bpig (mk11)Bridging the hydropower policy implementation gap-bpig (mk11)
Bridging the hydropower policy implementation gap-bpig (mk11)
 
Blewett Ah Shrpig Jun2009
Blewett Ah Shrpig Jun2009Blewett Ah Shrpig Jun2009
Blewett Ah Shrpig Jun2009
 
Evaluating Small Group Employer Participation in New Mexico’s State Coverage ...
Evaluating Small Group Employer Participation in New Mexico’s State Coverage ...Evaluating Small Group Employer Participation in New Mexico’s State Coverage ...
Evaluating Small Group Employer Participation in New Mexico’s State Coverage ...
 
Methodology behvaiour change luleå
Methodology behvaiour change luleåMethodology behvaiour change luleå
Methodology behvaiour change luleå
 
Measuring impact of open data: Latest thinking and approaches
Measuring impact of open data: Latest thinking and approachesMeasuring impact of open data: Latest thinking and approaches
Measuring impact of open data: Latest thinking and approaches
 
Pres acap2012 apr11_blewett
Pres acap2012 apr11_blewettPres acap2012 apr11_blewett
Pres acap2012 apr11_blewett
 
Ta4.05 mac gillivray.unwdf_macgillivray_ta4_05
Ta4.05 mac gillivray.unwdf_macgillivray_ta4_05Ta4.05 mac gillivray.unwdf_macgillivray_ta4_05
Ta4.05 mac gillivray.unwdf_macgillivray_ta4_05
 
State Health Access Reform Evaluation
State Health Access Reform EvaluationState Health Access Reform Evaluation
State Health Access Reform Evaluation
 
Strategic management: a critical element in implementing private medicine ret...
Strategic management: a critical element in implementing private medicine ret...Strategic management: a critical element in implementing private medicine ret...
Strategic management: a critical element in implementing private medicine ret...
 
Community Policing
Community PolicingCommunity Policing
Community Policing
 
1. Tax treatment of health insurance premiums; 2. Pooling and a "public" plan
1. Tax treatment of health insurance premiums; 2. Pooling and a "public" plan1. Tax treatment of health insurance premiums; 2. Pooling and a "public" plan
1. Tax treatment of health insurance premiums; 2. Pooling and a "public" plan
 
CBET - Policy Intervention Strategies
CBET - Policy Intervention StrategiesCBET - Policy Intervention Strategies
CBET - Policy Intervention Strategies
 
STAKEHOLDERS : their role and influence in public policy
STAKEHOLDERS : their role and influence in public policySTAKEHOLDERS : their role and influence in public policy
STAKEHOLDERS : their role and influence in public policy
 
Considerations for Citizen Surveys
Considerations for Citizen SurveysConsiderations for Citizen Surveys
Considerations for Citizen Surveys
 
Workshop Proceedings: Embedding Regulatory Policy in Law and Practice
Workshop Proceedings: Embedding Regulatory Policy in Law and PracticeWorkshop Proceedings: Embedding Regulatory Policy in Law and Practice
Workshop Proceedings: Embedding Regulatory Policy in Law and Practice
 
Role of Research in Policy Making (in terms of policy research)
Role of Research in Policy Making (in terms of policy research)Role of Research in Policy Making (in terms of policy research)
Role of Research in Policy Making (in terms of policy research)
 

Destaque

Presentazionebeat generation
Presentazionebeat generationPresentazionebeat generation
Presentazionebeat generation
diletta999
 

Destaque (17)

Paralyzed Man By Tyler, Breanna, Logan
Paralyzed Man By Tyler, Breanna, LoganParalyzed Man By Tyler, Breanna, Logan
Paralyzed Man By Tyler, Breanna, Logan
 
甜點
甜點甜點
甜點
 
The Resurrection Of Jesus By Bethany, Brittany, Cassi
The Resurrection Of Jesus By Bethany, Brittany, CassiThe Resurrection Of Jesus By Bethany, Brittany, Cassi
The Resurrection Of Jesus By Bethany, Brittany, Cassi
 
price-of-jails
price-of-jailsprice-of-jails
price-of-jails
 
Cost-Benefit Analysis and Justice Policy Toolkit
Cost-Benefit Analysis and Justice Policy ToolkitCost-Benefit Analysis and Justice Policy Toolkit
Cost-Benefit Analysis and Justice Policy Toolkit
 
110721 victim costs webinar final
110721 victim costs webinar final110721 victim costs webinar final
110721 victim costs webinar final
 
Part 2, Cost-Benefit Analysis for Justice Policy: A Step-By-Step Guide, Power...
Part 2, Cost-Benefit Analysis for Justice Policy: A Step-By-Step Guide, Power...Part 2, Cost-Benefit Analysis for Justice Policy: A Step-By-Step Guide, Power...
Part 2, Cost-Benefit Analysis for Justice Policy: A Step-By-Step Guide, Power...
 
2011 NCJA presentation
2011 NCJA presentation2011 NCJA presentation
2011 NCJA presentation
 
Baptism Of Jesus By Tenille, Lexi, Sara, Raven
Baptism Of Jesus By Tenille, Lexi, Sara, RavenBaptism Of Jesus By Tenille, Lexi, Sara, Raven
Baptism Of Jesus By Tenille, Lexi, Sara, Raven
 
Sensitivity Analysis for Cost-Benefit Studies of Justice Policies: A Primer
Sensitivity Analysis for Cost-Benefit Studies of Justice Policies: A PrimerSensitivity Analysis for Cost-Benefit Studies of Justice Policies: A Primer
Sensitivity Analysis for Cost-Benefit Studies of Justice Policies: A Primer
 
Part 1, Cost-Benefit Analysis for Justice Policy: A Step-By-Step Guide, Power...
Part 1, Cost-Benefit Analysis for Justice Policy: A Step-By-Step Guide, Power...Part 1, Cost-Benefit Analysis for Justice Policy: A Step-By-Step Guide, Power...
Part 1, Cost-Benefit Analysis for Justice Policy: A Step-By-Step Guide, Power...
 
Presentazionebeat generation
Presentazionebeat generationPresentazionebeat generation
Presentazionebeat generation
 
Imagenes Tridimensionales
Imagenes TridimensionalesImagenes Tridimensionales
Imagenes Tridimensionales
 
甜點
甜點甜點
甜點
 
甜點
甜點甜點
甜點
 
甜點
甜點甜點
甜點
 
甜點
甜點甜點
甜點
 

Semelhante a 2010 NCSL Legislative Summit- Chiu

A-Practical-Guide-to-Understanding-Social-Costs
A-Practical-Guide-to-Understanding-Social-CostsA-Practical-Guide-to-Understanding-Social-Costs
A-Practical-Guide-to-Understanding-Social-Costs
Fabienne Michaux
 
Spf overview(1)
Spf overview(1)Spf overview(1)
Spf overview(1)
progroup
 
NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine,.docx
NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine,.docxNCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine,.docx
NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine,.docx
vannagoforth
 
A Variety of Rigorous Methods for Assessing Program Effectiveness
A Variety of Rigorous Methods for Assessing Program EffectivenessA Variety of Rigorous Methods for Assessing Program Effectiveness
A Variety of Rigorous Methods for Assessing Program Effectiveness
Washington Evaluators
 
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
sodhi3
 
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
fredharris32
 
Fundamental Concepts Scope and Steps in Program Evaluation.     .docx
Fundamental Concepts Scope and Steps in Program Evaluation.     .docxFundamental Concepts Scope and Steps in Program Evaluation.     .docx
Fundamental Concepts Scope and Steps in Program Evaluation.     .docx
starkeykellye
 
06877 Topic Implicit Association TestNumber of Pages 1 (Doub.docx
06877 Topic Implicit Association TestNumber of Pages 1 (Doub.docx06877 Topic Implicit Association TestNumber of Pages 1 (Doub.docx
06877 Topic Implicit Association TestNumber of Pages 1 (Doub.docx
smithhedwards48727
 
Direct Health Care Costs For Health Services Essay
Direct Health Care Costs For Health Services EssayDirect Health Care Costs For Health Services Essay
Direct Health Care Costs For Health Services Essay
Jennifer York
 
Using Goals To Assist In Strategic Planning Jan 09 V4
Using Goals To Assist In Strategic Planning Jan 09 V4Using Goals To Assist In Strategic Planning Jan 09 V4
Using Goals To Assist In Strategic Planning Jan 09 V4
MEASURE Evaluation
 

Semelhante a 2010 NCSL Legislative Summit- Chiu (20)

2010 NASBO Annual Meeting- Forsythe and Jacobson
2010 NASBO Annual Meeting- Forsythe and Jacobson2010 NASBO Annual Meeting- Forsythe and Jacobson
2010 NASBO Annual Meeting- Forsythe and Jacobson
 
Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) and Justice Policy for State Legislators
Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) and Justice Policy for State LegislatorsCost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) and Justice Policy for State Legislators
Cost-Benefit Analysis (CBA) and Justice Policy for State Legislators
 
NCPP Update-July 2010
NCPP Update-July 2010NCPP Update-July 2010
NCPP Update-July 2010
 
Linking Evaluation and Cost-Benefit Analysis in Criminal Justice: A Practical...
Linking Evaluation and Cost-Benefit Analysis in Criminal Justice: A Practical...Linking Evaluation and Cost-Benefit Analysis in Criminal Justice: A Practical...
Linking Evaluation and Cost-Benefit Analysis in Criminal Justice: A Practical...
 
A-Practical-Guide-to-Understanding-Social-Costs
A-Practical-Guide-to-Understanding-Social-CostsA-Practical-Guide-to-Understanding-Social-Costs
A-Practical-Guide-to-Understanding-Social-Costs
 
Pesuading Policy Makers: Effective CIT Program Evaluation and Public Relations
Pesuading Policy Makers: Effective CIT Program Evaluation and Public Relations Pesuading Policy Makers: Effective CIT Program Evaluation and Public Relations
Pesuading Policy Makers: Effective CIT Program Evaluation and Public Relations
 
Spf overview(1)
Spf overview(1)Spf overview(1)
Spf overview(1)
 
Wsipp july 2011
Wsipp july 2011Wsipp july 2011
Wsipp july 2011
 
NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine,.docx
NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine,.docxNCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine,.docx
NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine,.docx
 
A Variety of Rigorous Methods for Assessing Program Effectiveness
A Variety of Rigorous Methods for Assessing Program EffectivenessA Variety of Rigorous Methods for Assessing Program Effectiveness
A Variety of Rigorous Methods for Assessing Program Effectiveness
 
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
 
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
7Research and Policy Development Paper.docx
 
Can systematic reviews help identify what works and why?
Can systematic reviews help identify what works and why?Can systematic reviews help identify what works and why?
Can systematic reviews help identify what works and why?
 
Fundamental Concepts Scope and Steps in Program Evaluation.     .docx
Fundamental Concepts Scope and Steps in Program Evaluation.     .docxFundamental Concepts Scope and Steps in Program Evaluation.     .docx
Fundamental Concepts Scope and Steps in Program Evaluation.     .docx
 
06877 Topic Implicit Association TestNumber of Pages 1 (Doub.docx
06877 Topic Implicit Association TestNumber of Pages 1 (Doub.docx06877 Topic Implicit Association TestNumber of Pages 1 (Doub.docx
06877 Topic Implicit Association TestNumber of Pages 1 (Doub.docx
 
Direct Health Care Costs For Health Services Essay
Direct Health Care Costs For Health Services EssayDirect Health Care Costs For Health Services Essay
Direct Health Care Costs For Health Services Essay
 
Using Goals To Assist In Strategic Planning Jan 09 V4
Using Goals To Assist In Strategic Planning Jan 09 V4Using Goals To Assist In Strategic Planning Jan 09 V4
Using Goals To Assist In Strategic Planning Jan 09 V4
 
Tca.6.8.09
Tca.6.8.09Tca.6.8.09
Tca.6.8.09
 
Demonstrating Research Impact: Measuring Return on Investment with an Impact ...
Demonstrating Research Impact: Measuring Return on Investment with an Impact ...Demonstrating Research Impact: Measuring Return on Investment with an Impact ...
Demonstrating Research Impact: Measuring Return on Investment with an Impact ...
 
Review the Center for Court Innovation (Links to an external s
Review the Center for Court Innovation (Links to an external sReview the Center for Court Innovation (Links to an external s
Review the Center for Court Innovation (Links to an external s
 

2010 NCSL Legislative Summit- Chiu

  • 1. Of Costs and Consequences: Using Cost-Benefit Analysis in Justice Policymaking July 28, 2010 Tina Chiu, Director of Technical Assistance Presentation at the NCSL Legislative Summit Issue Forum: A Data-Driven Approach to Reducing Prison Spending
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4.
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9.
  • 10.
  • 11.
  • 12.
  • 13. Cost-Benefit Analysis of Justice Policies & Programs
  • 14.
  • 15.
  • 16.
  • 17. Cost-Benefit Findings, Example 1 Recidivism impacts for several adult offender programs and their associated benefits in Washington State. Change In Crime (# of EB Studies) Benefits Minus Costs, per-person, life cycle ( Probability: you lose $) Adult Drug Courts -9% (67) $6,264 (<1%) Education Programs, Prison -8% (17) $13,555 (<1%) Cognitive Behavioral Treatment -7% (27) $12,037 (<1%) ISP: surveillance -2% (23) -$2,174 (≈82%) Drug Treatment in Prison (TC or out-patient) -6% (21) $9,588 (<1%) Programs Source: Washington State Institute for Public Policy, Draft 2010 Findings
  • 18. Cost-Benefit Findings, Example 2 Recidivism impacts for several juvenile programs and their associated benefits in New York State.
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 22.
  • 23.
  • 24.
  • 25.