SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 7
Baixar para ler offline
Photo: shutterstock / Diego Cervo




                                                            Allianz SE    www.allianz.com




                                     Issue #
                                                            Allianz
                                     9                      Demographic Pulse
                                     March
                                     2013



                                    “It’s time to Rethink Retirement”
                                    After a decade of pension reforms in Western Europe and the establishment of new systems in Eastern
                                    Europe and Asia, the structure of a retirement income has begun to change. This paper summarizes the
                                    driving forces behind this transformation and describes the new mix of sources of retirement income of
                                    households in selected countries. Second and third pillar plans, income from financial assets and employ-
                                    ment – as well as the rise of the elderly in the workforce – are gaining importance. The changes in the
                                    retirement landscape are challenging for all parties involved – solutions providers, governments and em-
                                    ployees. To achieve at an adequate retirement income for future retirees all parties have to work together
                                    to set up a modern pension system with strong different pillars. “It’s time to Rethink Retirement”, says Jay
                                    Ralph, Chairman of Allianz Asset Management and member of the Board of Management of Allianz SE.

                                                                Rise of Elderly Persons in the Workforce
                                                                 10%      20%   30%   40%   50%   60%
                                             S wede n
                                      S witz erl a n d
                                       s o u t h k o rea
                                                   US A
                                          si n gap o re
                                                     UK
                                            Germa n y
                                      n e therl a n ds
                                                 S pai n
                                        H o n GKo n g*
                                               Gree c e
                                             A u s t ria
                                                 Italy
                                              Poland
                                               F ra n c e                                               2010
                                            h u n gar y                   20%   30%   40%   50%   60%   2000

                                                                                                                                            *Data for 2008 instead of 2010
                                                                       Participation rate of people aged 60 to 64 years.               Sources: Allianz / OECD Eurostat, ILO




                                                                                                         Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9     March 2013   page 1
The process of pension reform                                                                                 This wave of funded pension plans has been introduced across the
Societal aging and the accompanying rise in the old-age dependency                                            board since 2000.4 New funded occupational pension schemes have
ratio has increased the pressure on public finances; particularly on                                          even been introduced in emerging Asia, where aging, industrializa-
the sustainability of pay-as-you-go (PAYG) pension systems. In 2001,                                          tion and urbanization have begun to erode the existing informal
when the European Commission began to make projections on the                                                 family-based retirement model.
cost of aging for the 15 member states of Western Europe1, the cost
of pension systems was expected to increase by 2.9% of the GDP until
2050. In addition, they factored in the expected costs of healthcare                                               “New funded occupational pension schemes have
and long-term care systems. In an effort to ease the pressure, most                                                  even been introduced in emerging Asia, where aging,
countries began introducing pension reforms at the turn of the                                                       industrialization and urbanization has begun to erode
century. Though the latest report shows there has been some                                                          the existing informal family-based retirement model.“
relief on average budgets (2.1% for the Eurozone until 2050),2
there are still large differences between countries.
                                                                                                              In addition to parametric changes, targeted adjustments to the legal
The main components of these reforms were parametric changes in:                                              retirement age are being made to first pillar systems so that they are
                                                                                                              better prepared to meet coming demographic changes – increasing
++Benefit calculation (for instance, lifetime earnings are now used                                           life expectancy, in particular. In addition to increasing the legal retire-
  as a basis for calculation rather than final pay or best years of                                           ment age, many countries are also equalizing the retirement ages
  earnings)                                                                                                   of men and women. Moreover, access to early retirement has been
++Pension indexation rules                                                                                    restricted in several countries over the last couple of years, thereby
++Automatic adjustment to demographic change or actuarial adjust-                                             effectively increasing the retirement age.
  ment mechanisms.
                                                                                                              The effects of all these changes on the pension landscape are
For the most part, these measures led to a decrease in the replace-                                           multifold:
ment rates of the first pillar. Calculations from the Organisation
of Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) show, for                                                     ++Benefits from public pension systems (first pillar) have decreased
example, that lifetime benefits in the 16 OECD countries that in-                                             ++New incentive structures are promoting an accumulation of assets
troduced the most wide-ranging reforms were cut on average                                                      in the second and third pillars
by 22% for men and 25% for women.3                                                                            ++In moving from defined benefit (DB) to defined contribution (DC)
                                                                                                                plans, risk is being transferred away from pension scheme spon-
                                                                                                                sors and to the beneficiary.

     “ ifetime benefits in 16 OECD countries were cut on
      L
                                                                                                              After 10 to 15 years of reform process …
      average by 22% for men and 25% for women.”                                                              With the wave of reforms and the expected decrease in statu-
                                                                                                              tory pension insurance, people are retiring later5 and saving
                                                                                                              more. In the future, the retirement income mix will rest less
As this poses a major change for most people, these declining                                                 on the previously dominant first pillar (state pensions) than
public benefit levels had to be offset. Thus, during the last 10 to 15                                        on the funded elements.
years, many countries have accompanied the reform process in the
first pillar by adding a complementary buildup of pre-funding ele-                                            4	  See overview in Allianz Global Investors, “Pension Systems in a Demographic Transition”, Analysis and
                                                                                                                 Trends 11/2011, p. 8
ments and/or an improvement of existing second and third pillar                                               5	 The younger generation will retire even later due to long term phasing-in processes.


plans by creating incentives for additional private pension savings,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Photo: shutterstock / Pincasso




expanding existing occupational schemes, introducing new second
and third pillar (occupational and private) pension plans and tax
benefits, and even granting direct financial support payments to
encourage people to save more for old age on their own. Some
countries, particularly those in central and Eastern Europe (CEE),
have voted in compulsory systems in order to ensure asset-build-
ing for a wide range of people. Others, like the United States and
United Kingdom, have introduced auto-enrollment strategies or tax
incentives to foster voluntary participation.



1	  Comparison of projection results in: European Commission, 2006: The impact of ageing on public expendi-
   ture: projections for the EU25 Member States on pensions, health care, long-term care, education and
   unemployment transfers (2004-2050), Special Report No. 1/2006, p. 73.
2	 It should be noted that the composition of countries compared differs slightly in these two reports.

3	 Antolin, Pablo and Whitehouse, Edward R., 2009: Filling the Pension Gap: Coverage and value of voluntary

   retirement savings, OECD Social Employment and Migration Working Papers No. 69




                                                                                                                                   Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9                      March 2013   page 2
New Asset Structure


                         96              11                                   96             11                                  96             11                                  01            11
                      19             20                                    19             20                                  19            20                                   20           20
100%                                                                                                                                                                                                            100%
                                                                                                                                                                               11.2%
                   27.8%                                                                                                                                                                    17.2%
                                                                                                                            26.4%        27%                                   7.3%
                                  36%                                   34.8%         38.4%
 80%                                                                                                                                                                                                            80%

                                                                                                                                                                               22.1%
                                                                                                                             8.9%
                                                                                                                                         8.3%                                               36%
 60%               25.1%                                                                                                    10.1%                                                                               60%
                                 20.6%
                                                                        39.7%         32.9%
                   11.2%
 40%                              5.9%                                                                                                                                                                          40%
                                                                                                                                        55.5%                                  57.1%
                                                                                                                              51%
                                                                                                                                                                                           41.6%
                   35.4%                                                 9.9%         10.2%
 20%                             33.4%                                                                                                                                                                          20%

                                                                        13.5%         16.3%

     0%                                                                                                                                                                                                          0%
             West er n Euro pe                                      U n i ted S tates *                                          J apan                                               CEE


      Pension reforms have changed the structure of household financial assets within the last 15 years.
      Worldwide, the claims of private households from provisions at life insurance companies total more than EUR 10 trillion.
                                                                                          * Insurance and pension plans including IRAs (Individual Retirement Accounts); IRAs extracted from other products.
                                                                                                                    Sources: Allianz / Central Banks, National statistical offices, Allianz International Pensions.




… a shift in financial assets                                                                                     society, which has one of the highest old-age dependency ratios in
From a macro perspective, this development has already affected the                                               the world. Under existing policies, new cash inflows barely cover
composition of private financial assets so that, over the past decade,                                            outflows. Even so, the percentage of pension and insurance products
there has been an increase in the percentage of pension and insurance                                             has been stable at around 26.5% over the last 15 years.
assets within the financial portfolio of private households. This is par-
ticularly the case in Western Europe, where reforms ushered in major                                              … people working longer
changes, including funded pension plans and insurance products. As                                                The financial crisis put the changing structures of pension provi-
late as the mid-1990s, pension plans made up only 28% of the financial                                            sioning systems to the test and the reform path is still feeling the
portfolio; by 2011, this share had grown to over 36% in Western                                                   pressure of the debt crisis, high volatility of markets and low interest
Europe. Although this trend is also noticeable in the United States, it                                           rates. The challenges that this environment poses for funded pillars
is not as strong. With a much longer tradition of funded occupational                                             are considerable.
and private pension plans, the shift took place much earlier in the
United States, which is one of the reasons there has not been as dra-                                             The downturn reduced individual retirement assets substantially. In
matic a change in recent years. However, this trend is also attributable                                          countries where the total retirement portfolio consisted of a large
to the financial crisis, as US citizens’ investment preferences resulted                                          number of funded schemes and high equity exposure, people had
in higher losses than for investors who were more risk averse.6 In 2011                                           to compensate: either save more or work longer.
38.4% of the financial assets of private US households were attributed
to retirement products, basically the same as at the turn of the century.                                         In other words, it is not only the increase in retirement ages that
                                                                                                                  has had an influence on the number of people staying longer in
                                                                                                                  the workforce; so have the erosion of pension assets and the need
      “ hether in Europe, Asia or the United States, the
       W                                                                                                          to save longer for retirement. Whether in Europe, Asia or the United
       participation rate of people aged 60 to 64 years has                                                       States, the participation rate of people aged 60 to 64 years has risen
       risen over the last 10 years in most of the countries                                                      over the last 10 years in most of the countries studied in this paper.
       studied in this paper.”
                                                                                                                  In Europe, the biggest increase can be observed in Germany and
                                                                                                                  the Netherlands (see chart page 1), where participation rates
The strongest increase can be observed in the CEE, where reforms                                                  more than doubled. Even so, the levels reached in 2010 were still
introduced new funded pension schemes. Only 7.3% of financial                                                     below those of other European countries like Sweden and Swit-
assets were held in insurance and retirement accounts in 2001, by                                                 zerland where participation rates even in 2000 were higher. High
2011; however this percentage had risen drastically to 17.2%. In con-                                             rates can also be observed in the U.S., Japan, Korea and Singa-
trast to this emerging region, Japan is a good example of an “elderly”                                            pore; there more people aged 60 to 64 stay in the workforce than
6	
                                                                                                                  in most European countries.
      See Allianz Global Investors, 2010: The Global Crunch and its Long-term Impact on US Retirement Invest-
     ing, International Pension Studies No 4/2010


                                                                                                                                      Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9               March 2013   page 3
Photo: shutterstock / Africa Studio

                                                                                                                                              between 20 to 25% of total retirement income was derived from
                                                                                                                                              wages, which might be connected to the total replacement rate they
                                                                                                                                              had achieved taking all income sources together. The relative income
                                                                                                                                              level of people aged 65 and above compared to those under 65 years
                                                                                                                                              of age might give an indication: In Ireland, for example, this ratio
                                                                                                                                              only reached a bit more than 50 and just two thirds in the United
                                                                                                                                              Kingdom compared to 90 in France and 80 in Germany.9

                                                                                                                                              The large share of occupational pension income in the Netherlands
                                                                                                                                              and Switzerland reflects the role these mandatory instruments play
                                                                                                                                              in the old-age provisioning system, just as the high percentage of
                                                                                                                                              public pensions in France and Germany reflects their traditionally
                                                                                                                                              strong role. Finland has a special first pillar model, which com-
                                                                                                                                              prises two components: a residence-based national pension and an
                                                                                                                                              earnings-related pension. The latter is partially funded. The bulk of
                                      “n contrast to continental Europe, the basic philosophy
                                       I                                                                                                      retirement income in Finland comes from this source.
                                       of many Anglo-Saxon countries is to provide a pension
                                       system to protect against old-age poverty.”                                                            Up to around 2010
                                                                                                                                              After more than a decade of reforms, all the developments
                                                                                                                                              described in the first part of the paper have had an impact on
                            Austria, France and Hungary, on the other hand, have very low                                                     the structure of retirement income in many countries, par-
                            participation rates, where the effective retirement age has stayed                                                ticularly in those with major early reforms, and are mirrored
                            below 60 for much longer than other countries, probably due to later                                              in the income mix.
                            adjustments to early retirement schemes. Nevertheless, the trend
                            is similar: within the last 10 years, there has been a distinct increase                                          The portion of income coming from the first pillar has decreased in
                            in participation. These developments are expected to increase the                                                 all the countries considered in this paper except in Ireland, where
                            importance of work in the retirement income mix.                                                                  it is broadly unchanged, and in Finland, where the percentage has
                                                                                                                                              increased from roughly 68 to 75%. Even so, the funded pillar is also
                            … a changed retirement income mix?                                                                                gaining importance in Finland, which may in part be due to the sys-
                                                                                                                                              tem’s mechanism: as residence-based national pensions decrease,
                            Moving from around 2000                                                                                           earnings-related pensions increase.
                            Before reforms were introduced, most pension income was provided
                            by the public PAYG system. Replacement rates in many continental                                                  The importance of (quasi-)mandatory funded systems as a source
                            European countries were designed to keep up with the standard of                                                  of retirement income in mature pension fund markets such as the
                            living achieved at retirement. Additional sources of retirement income                                            Netherlands and Switzerland, has increased quite a bit: in the
                            were primarily important for high income earners whose replacement                                                Netherlands from 31 to 40%, and in Switzerland from 26.6 to 32.8%.
                            rates from the first pillar are low due to contribution limits.                                                   In contrast, people in the United Kingdom and United States have
                                                                                                                                              compensated for decreasing income from funded schemes by taking
                            In contrast to continental Europe, the basic philosophy of many                                                   on additional work. The financial crisis has probably taken its toll,
                            Anglo-Saxon countries is to provide a pension system to protect                                                   particularly in the United States where the percentage of funded
                            against old-age poverty. Using this as the basic premise, ad-                                                     schemes within the total retirement portfolio is high. With little time
                            ditional saving instruments had to be created to help people                                                      to recoup, cohorts approaching retirement were faced with the deci-
                            achieve a reasonable retirement income, which is why coun-                                                        sion of whether to continue working during retirement, or to retire
                            tries like the United Kingdom and United States developed                                                         on substantially less than planned.
                            funded pillars early on and now have mature funded pension
                            markets. That said, the Netherlands and Switzerland were also early                                               In Sweden, Germany and France lower levels from social security
                            to introduce funded second pillar schemes.                                                                        were compensated by a larger share of investment income and
                                                                                                                                              individual plans, as newly introduced plans from the last decade have
                            From a micro perspective, this is reflected in the structure of retire-                                           not yet reached the payout phase. In most countries this compensa-
                            ment income.7 As of 20008, total retirement income in the United                                                  tion was achieved by additional income from work. Compared to the
                            Kingdom and the United States was made up of a mix of sources                                                     level in 2000, this share has gained importance in all countries except
                            of income: state pensions that provide a minimum standard of                                                      France and Ireland.
                            living (40% in the UK and 50% in the US), income from privately
                            funded pillars (30 to 40% from occupational pensions and invest-                                                  This might change in the future as plans reach maturity and
                            ment income) and then topped up from income earned by staying                                                     reforms are phased in. Even so, the bulk of pension income in most
                            in the workforce. This was also the case in Japan and Ireland, where                                              countries will continue to be provided by public schemes. Even the

                            7	  As there are a variety of different sources which also differ according to the situation of a household for   9	   OECD: Database on income distribution and poverty, StatExtracts (stats.oecd.org)
                               example as to the occupation the average incomes only give a broad brush picture. The chart shows the
                               income mix of a couple older than 65 years.
                            8	 The results shown in the chart have slightly differing base years, which range from 1999 in Japan to 2002
                                                                                                                                                                    Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9                     March 2013   page 4
                               in France.
Retirement Income Mix
                                               A Decade of Change: 2000 vs 2010

                                                        2000   38.9%                          28.3%                          12.6%            20.2%
                Un ited k i ngdom
                                                        2010   37.7%                         26.5%                        9.2%        26.5%




                                                        2000   48%                                      31%                               15%                 6%
                    n ether lands
                                                        2010   43%                                40%                                           8%       9%




                                                        2000   49.1%                                      9.7%     19.2%                 22%
                  Un ited st at es
                                                        2010   47.3%                                    8.3%     13.6%         30.8%




                                                        2000   50.8%                                       26.6%                         14.4%               8.2%
                   S wi tzer land
                                                        2010   43.4%                              32.8%                                 14.9%                9%




                                                        2000   56.4%                                             12.2%        6.5% 24.9%
                         Ire land
                                                        2010   57.4%                                              14.6%           8%          20%


                                                                                                                                                              3.4%
                                                        2000   18.1%            50.2%                                         28.3%
                        fi n land *
                                                        2010   13.2%        62.4%                                                       20.7%
                                                                                                                                                              3.7%
                                                                                                                               1.1% 4%
                                                        2000   74.5%                                                                          20.4%
                           japan
                                                        2010   61.4%                                                  10.4%            25.2%.
                                                                                                                                 3%


                                                        2000   77.5%                                                                     16.7%                5.8%
                       swede n* *
                                                        2010   61.4%                                                  19%                     19.6%


                                                                                                                                                              4.2%
                                                        2000   78%                                                                       8.2%         9.5%
                        germa ny
                                                        2010   70%                                                               9%       12%            9%




                                                        2000   80.6%                                                                          8.2%      11.2%
                       franc e * * *
                                                        2010   73.2%                                                                  19.5%                   7.3%

	 *	 first pillar: 18.1% residence based national and
		 50.2% earnings-related pensions 
	 **	 first pillar, incl ATP                                           sta te           occupa tion a l              In v estmen t                       work
	 ***	 first pillar, incl. second-pillar PAYG income.                  pen sion s       pen sion s                   in come /other



                                                                                                Sources: Allianz, National Statistics, Central Banks, Governmental Bodies




                                                                                              Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9                 March 2013   page 5
entering the workforce. Older workers were allowed to decide on
Photo: shutterstock / Andy Dean Photography




                                                                                                                                                                whether or not they wanted to participate, while people close to
                                                                                                                                                                retirement were prohibited from joining as any capital they would be
                                                                                                                                                                able to accumulate would be insufficient to cover retirement bene-
                                                                                                                                                                fits. These regulations are mirrored in the retirement mix. Since older
                                                                                                                                                                employees could not access second pillar pensions, their retirement
                                                                                                                                                                income is primarily a mixture of income from first pillar pensions and
                                                                                                                                                                work, with possibly a modest contribution from capital income.

                                                                                                                                                                Family support still important in Asia
                                                                                                                                                                The challenges of pension reform in several Asian countries have
                                                                                                                                                                been, and still are, to establish well-functioning public pension
                                                                                                                                                                systems and broaden the coverage of existing ones to alleviate a
                                                                                                                                                                worsening demographic situation caused by a substantial increase
                                                                                                                                                                in life expectancy and a drastic fall in once high fertility rates – a
                                              United Kingdom is modifying its system by increasing first pillar                                                 typical consequence of industrialization, rapid economic growth and
                                              pensions.10 The total effect on the income mix remains unclear                                                    urbanization. Until roughly a decade ago, the chief component of
                                              however, due to the possible increase in private pension income                                                   retirement provisioning in emerging Asian countries was its tradi-
                                              from the introduction of auto-enrollment plans and mandatory                                                      tional system of strong family values and social norms in which most
                                              employer contributions.                                                                                           retirees relied largely on family support.

                                              Italy and Austria belong to the group of countries which aimed at
                                              maintaining the standard of living in retirement with their public pen-                                             “According to the World Bank, about 55% of retirement
                                              sion system. In Italy the majority of people rely on public pensions as                                               income in South Korea was provided by the family in
                                              the main source of income.11 The replacement rate of the first pillar                                                 1990. Today, it is about 30%.”
                                              is high, thus the other pillars are still small and the proportion of oc-
                                              cupational pensions within the retirement income mix has been small.
                                              Additional income is generated by investment income and work. After                                               Accompanying this informal system of old-age support was a weak
                                              reforms in early 2000 in Italy and later on in Austria, this might change                                         and limited public pension system. However, socio-economic chang-
                                              in the future when plans mature and reach the payout phase. But in                                                es have put the family support system under pressure and as the
                                              the situation for people entering retirement now, the changes do not                                              need for organized retirement systems dramatically increased, coun-
                                              yet show up. Today about 72% of an average Italian’s income comes                                                 tries began establishing formal pension systems to some degree. At
                                              from public schemes, 4% from capital and 24% from wages, accord-                                                  the same time, Asia began to introduce new occupational pension
                                              ing to the OECD.12 In Austria the proportion of public pensions is even                                           schemes such as the Mandatory Provident Fund in Hong Kong, the
                                              higher and the importance of income from work lower than in Italy.13                                              New Labor Pension Fund in Taiwan and new corporate schemes in
                                                                                                                                                                South Korea. In other words, the entire retirement landscape in Asia
                                              CEE: retirement income from the state – new pension schemes                                                       has changed and is still evolving.
                                              not in the pay-out phase
                                              The current shape of pension systems in the CEE has been formed                                                   Though reforms are in progress, the new systems don’t provide for
                                              by decisions taken after the fall of the Iron Curtain, when former                                                current retirees so that, to a large extent, they still have to rely on
                                              Eastern Bloc countries were faced with the daunting task of reform-                                               family support. This is reflected in our results. A survey in Singapore
                                              ing their outdated pension systems. Under the old regime, pensions                                                revealed that 60% of the elderly still receive the most support from
                                              in the CEE were the exclusive responsibility of the state, and were                                               their families and that only a small portion of their income stems
                                              incompatible with current demographic developments or the new                                                     from the Central Provident Fund, the main pillar in Singapore. In
                                              economic reality. Central and Eastern Europe are ageing fast and are                                              addition, some retirees were able to take out a private pension –
                                              just as sensitive to demographic changes as Western Europe.                                                       probably thanks to Singapore’s economic upswing – and are now
                                              To cope with the enormous financial pressure and secure the solven-                                               drawing income from their accrued private savings.
                                              cy of public pensions, CEE countries initiated similar reforms to their
                                              first pillar pension systems in the 1990s as those in Western Europe.                                             As far as the family support network is concerned, the situation is
                                              Deeper reforms have been made in most of CEE countries.                                                           similar in Thailand and, surprisingly, also in South Korea where
                                              When second pillar plans were first introduced, most of them were                                                 pension reforms were implemented in the late 1980s. According to
                                              offered to younger employees and were mandatory for people just                                                   the World Bank, about 55% of retirement income in South Korea was
                                                                                                                                                                provided by the family in 1990. Today, it is about 30%. Though the
                                              10	 PPI Pensions Policy Institute, March 2010: Retirement income and assets: outlook for the future, PPI Brief-   importance of family support is decreasing, it will take a long time for
                                                 ing note Number 54
                                              11	 Statistics Italy; http://dati.istat.it/?lang=en
                                                                                                                                                                patterns to change completely.
                                              12	 Pensions at a Glance 2011; occupational pensions not separated in the OECD report. Thus it is not quite

                                                 comparable to the other results.
                                              13	 STATISTIK AUSTRIA, EU-SILC 2010.




                                                                                                                                                                             Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9     March 2013   page 6
Outlook                                                                                                                        countries indicates that providing flexible retirement alternatives
The retirement income mix has started to change as the role of                                                                 could meet a growing demand: 65% of the European workforce is
funded pensions grows and public pension levels decrease. Nev-                                                                 interested in having the opportunity to combine a part-time job and
ertheless this view does not show whether the complementary                                                                    partial pension as an alternative to full employment.15
pillars are strong enough to compensate for decreasing levels                                                                  However, people will also have to save more in order to generate more
in the first pillars in absolute terms. Thus, the question arises of                                                           income, which could be encouraged by the type of automatic and
whether retirement income is adequate. As the EU commission                                                                    default solutions being introduced in the United Kingdom this year.
points out in its Adequacy Report: “There were great advances
in the sustainability of public pensions, but adequacy outcomes                                                                Eastern Europe will have to strengthen its emphasis on pension re-
are less impressive.”14 For future retirees to achieve retirement                                                              form in order to compensate for the hit their pension systems took
income levels comparable to those of today’s retirees, they will                                                               during the financial and economic crisis. Even so, future retirees
have to change their working and savings behavior.                                                                             can look forward to receiving an income stream from the funded
                                                                                                                               pillars introduced over the last ten years. In Asia, the process of
The challenge for the future is to foster labor market opportunities                                                           broadening pension coverage will lead to a major shift from infor-
so that older employees can continue working. A survey of European                                                             mal to formal systems.

14	   Social Protection Committee of the European Union, May 23, 2012: Pension Adequacy in the European                        15	   European Commission, 2012: Active Ageing, Eurobarometer 378 (special edition)
      Union 2010–2050



                                                               Central banks: flow-of-funds statistics
                                                                                                                             (2004-2050), Special Report no. 1/2006, p. 73                       Singapore Ministry of Community Develop-
Sources                                                                                                                                                                                           ment, Youth and Sports, 2005: National Survey of
                                                               Employee Benefit Research Institute                            European Commission, 2012: Active Ageing,
                                                               (www.ebri.org)                                                 Eurobarometer 378 (special edition)                                 Senior Citizens 2005
Allianz Global Investors, 2010: The Global Crunch
                                                              Federal Republic of Germany: Old-age Security
                                                                                                                             National statistical offices of the Czech Republic,                 Social Protection Committee of the European
and its Long-term Impact on US Retirement Invest-              Reports (Alterssicherungsberichte)                             Finland, France, Ireland, Japan, Korea, Lithuania,                  Union, May 23, 2012: Pension Adequacy in the
ing, International Pension Studies No 4/2010                                                                                  the Netherlands, Slovakia, Sweden, Switzerland                      European Union 2010-2050
                                                               European Commission, November 2010: Prog-
Allianz Global Investors, November 2011:                       ress and key challenges in the delivery of adequate            and Thailand (income data)                                          UK Department for Work and Pensions: The
Pension Systems in a Demographic Transition:                  and sustainable pensions in Europe, European                   OECD: Database on income distribution and                          Pensioners’ Incomes Series 2009–10 (national
 Demographic change puts pressure on pension                   Economy Occupational Papers 71                                 poverty, StatExtracts (stats.oecd.org)                              statistics)
 systems, Analysis and Trends
                                                               European Commission, 2006: The impact of
                                                                                                                             OECD, 2011: Pensions at a Glance
Antolin, Pablo and Whitehouse, Edward R.,                      ageing on public expenditure: projections for the
2009:  illing the Pension Gap: Coverage and value
       F                                                                                                                      Pensions Policy Institute, March 2010: 
                                                               EU25 Member States on pensions, health care, long-             Retirement Income and Assets: Outlook for the
of voluntary retirement savings, OECD Social Em-               term care, education and unemployment transfers
ployment and Migration Working Papers No. 69                                                                                  future, PPI Briefing Note No. 54




Editor: Dr. Renate Finke, Allianz, Senior Economist, International Pensions
Publisher: Allianz SE, Königinstraße 28, 80802 München | Claudia Mohr-Calliet, claudia.mohr-calliet@allianz.com I http://www.allianz.com


       Why does Allianz care about demography?                                         Why does it matter to journalists and the public?                                    What are the benefits of the Allianz Demo-
                                                                                                                                                                            graphic Pulse?
       As a global financial service provider, Allianz believes                        Demographic change is challenging today’s societies
       demographic change to be of crucial importance.                                 in many ways: People are getting older, and this raises                              The Allianz Demographic Pulse is based on the latest
       Identified as one of the major megatrends,                                      the issues of long-term care and dementia, amongst                                   research into various aspects of demographic change.
       demographic change will hold the key to many                                    others. Furthermore, in the future there will be a                                   Conducted and written by Allianz experts, it highlights
       upcoming social challenges, whether with regard to                              significant decline in the workforce in most of the                                  current and globally relevant demographic data and
       health, old-age provision, education, consumption or                            world’s markets, triggering challenges in areas such                                 provides an insight into its impact on worldwide
       capital markets.                                                                as pension funding. Only information, awareness and                                  economies and societies. To ensure up-to-date
                                                                                       discussion on the topic will help to change attitudes,                               coverage of major developments in this field, the
                                                                                       behavior and situations, which can hopefully help                                    Allianz Demographic Pulse is published on a regular
                                                                                       solve urgent issues and come up with innovative                                      basis, thus providing ongoing and detailed
                                                                                       solutions.                                                                           information about a major trend that is shaping the
                                                                                                                                                                            world we live in.



       More publications at:                                                                                                                                                     Do you have any comments,
       Allianz Group Economic Research  Corporate Development                                                                                                                   suggestions or questions? We look
       https://www.allianz.com/en/economic_research/publications/index.html
                                                                                                                                                                                 forward to your feedback!
       International Pensions, Allianz Global Investors
                                                                                                                                                                                 Claudia Mohr-Calliet
       http://publications.allianzgi.com/en/PensionResearch/Pages/PensionResearch.aspx
                                                                                                                                                                                 ++49 89 3800 18797
       Allianz Knowledge Site
                                                                                                                                                                                 claudia.mohr-calliet@allianz.com
       http://knowledge.allianz.com/

These assessments are, as always, subject to the disclaimer provided below.

Cautionary note regarding forward-looking statements: The statements contained herein may include statements                  (iii) the frequency and severity of insured loss events, including from natural catastrophes and including the development
of future expectations and other forward-looking statements that are based on management’s current views and assump-          of loss expenses, (iv) mortality and morbidity levels and trends, (v) persistency levels, (vi) the extent of credit defaults, (vii)
tions and involve known and unknown risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results, performance or events to         interest rate levels, (viii) currency exchange rates including the Euro/U.S. Dollar exchange rate, (ix) changing levels of
differ materially from those expressed or implied in such statements. In addition to statements which are forward-looking     competition, (x) changes in laws and regulations, including monetary convergence and the European Monetary Union,
by reason of context, the words “may”, “will”, “should”, “expects”, “plans”, “intends”, “anticipates”, “believes”, “estima-   (xi) changes in the policies of central banks and/or foreign governments, (xii) the impact of acquisitions, including rela-
tes”, “predicts”, “potential”, or “continue” and similar expressions identify forward-looking statements. Actual results,     ted integration issues, (xiii) reorganization measures, and (xiv) general competitive factors, in each case on a local, regi-
performance or events may differ materially from those in such statements due to, without limitation, (i) general econo-      onal, national and/or global basis. Many of these factors may be more likely to occur, or more pronounced, as a result of
mic conditions, including in particular economic conditions in the Allianz Group’s core business and core markets, (ii)       terrorist activities and their consequences. The company assumes no obligation to update any forward-looking statement.
performance of financial markets, including emerging markets, and including market volatility, liquidity and credit events    No duty to update: The company assumes no obligation to update any information contained herein.


                                                                                                                                                        Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9                                March 2013   page 7

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

Political (In)Stability of Social Security
Political (In)Stability of Social SecurityPolitical (In)Stability of Social Security
Political (In)Stability of Social SecurityGRAPE
 
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WIEM2014
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WIEM2014EmerytGRAPE presentation at WIEM2014
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WIEM2014GRAPE
 
Kiedy warto podnosić wiek emerytalny?
Kiedy warto podnosić wiek emerytalny?Kiedy warto podnosić wiek emerytalny?
Kiedy warto podnosić wiek emerytalny?GRAPE
 
Ageing and productivity growth in OECD regions - Federica Daniele, Taku Honid...
Ageing and productivity growth in OECD regions - Federica Daniele, Taku Honid...Ageing and productivity growth in OECD regions - Federica Daniele, Taku Honid...
Ageing and productivity growth in OECD regions - Federica Daniele, Taku Honid...OECD CFE
 
JKSB Sri Lanka Summary
JKSB Sri Lanka SummaryJKSB Sri Lanka Summary
JKSB Sri Lanka SummaryNithilaT
 
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WES
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WESEmerytGRAPE presentation at WES
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WESGRAPE
 
Welfare effects of the pension system reform
Welfare effects of the pension system reformWelfare effects of the pension system reform
Welfare effects of the pension system reformGRAPE
 
EmerytGRAPE presentation at ICMAIF2014
EmerytGRAPE presentation at ICMAIF2014EmerytGRAPE presentation at ICMAIF2014
EmerytGRAPE presentation at ICMAIF2014GRAPE
 
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systems
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systemsInequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systems
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systemsGRAPE
 
Inequality in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systems
Inequality in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systemsInequality in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systems
Inequality in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systemsGRAPE
 
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneity within cohorts and an oblig...
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneity within cohorts and an oblig...Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneity within cohorts and an oblig...
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneity within cohorts and an oblig...GRAPE
 
Political (In)Stability of Pension System Reforms
Political (In)Stability of Pension System ReformsPolitical (In)Stability of Pension System Reforms
Political (In)Stability of Pension System ReformsGRAPE
 
Political (In)Stability of Pension System Reforms
Political (In)Stability of Pension System ReformsPolitical (In)Stability of Pension System Reforms
Political (In)Stability of Pension System ReformsGRAPE
 
Evaluating welfare and economic effects of raised fertility
Evaluating welfare and economic effects of raised fertilityEvaluating welfare and economic effects of raised fertility
Evaluating welfare and economic effects of raised fertilityGRAPE
 
Welfare effects of fiscal policy in reforming the pension system
Welfare effects of fiscal policy in reforming the pension systemWelfare effects of fiscal policy in reforming the pension system
Welfare effects of fiscal policy in reforming the pension systemGRAPE
 
The shadow of longevity – does social security reform reduce gains from incre...
The shadow of longevity – does social security reform reduce gains from incre...The shadow of longevity – does social security reform reduce gains from incre...
The shadow of longevity – does social security reform reduce gains from incre...GRAPE
 
To the Point, No.4 - April 30, 2012
To the Point, No.4 - April 30, 2012To the Point, No.4 - April 30, 2012
To the Point, No.4 - April 30, 2012Swedbank
 
Efficiency of the pension reform: The welfare effects of various fiscal closures
Efficiency of the pension reform: The welfare effects of various fiscal closuresEfficiency of the pension reform: The welfare effects of various fiscal closures
Efficiency of the pension reform: The welfare effects of various fiscal closuresGRAPE
 
Political (In)Stability of Social Security
Political (In)Stability of Social SecurityPolitical (In)Stability of Social Security
Political (In)Stability of Social SecurityGRAPE
 

Mais procurados (20)

Political (In)Stability of Social Security
Political (In)Stability of Social SecurityPolitical (In)Stability of Social Security
Political (In)Stability of Social Security
 
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WIEM2014
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WIEM2014EmerytGRAPE presentation at WIEM2014
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WIEM2014
 
Kiedy warto podnosić wiek emerytalny?
Kiedy warto podnosić wiek emerytalny?Kiedy warto podnosić wiek emerytalny?
Kiedy warto podnosić wiek emerytalny?
 
Ageing and productivity growth in OECD regions - Federica Daniele, Taku Honid...
Ageing and productivity growth in OECD regions - Federica Daniele, Taku Honid...Ageing and productivity growth in OECD regions - Federica Daniele, Taku Honid...
Ageing and productivity growth in OECD regions - Federica Daniele, Taku Honid...
 
JKSB Sri Lanka Summary
JKSB Sri Lanka SummaryJKSB Sri Lanka Summary
JKSB Sri Lanka Summary
 
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WES
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WESEmerytGRAPE presentation at WES
EmerytGRAPE presentation at WES
 
Welfare effects of the pension system reform
Welfare effects of the pension system reformWelfare effects of the pension system reform
Welfare effects of the pension system reform
 
EmerytGRAPE presentation at ICMAIF2014
EmerytGRAPE presentation at ICMAIF2014EmerytGRAPE presentation at ICMAIF2014
EmerytGRAPE presentation at ICMAIF2014
 
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systems
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systemsInequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systems
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systems
 
Inequality in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systems
Inequality in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systemsInequality in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systems
Inequality in an OLG economy with heterogeneous cohorts and pension systems
 
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneity within cohorts and an oblig...
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneity within cohorts and an oblig...Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneity within cohorts and an oblig...
Inequalities in an OLG economy with heterogeneity within cohorts and an oblig...
 
Political (In)Stability of Pension System Reforms
Political (In)Stability of Pension System ReformsPolitical (In)Stability of Pension System Reforms
Political (In)Stability of Pension System Reforms
 
Political (In)Stability of Pension System Reforms
Political (In)Stability of Pension System ReformsPolitical (In)Stability of Pension System Reforms
Political (In)Stability of Pension System Reforms
 
Evaluating welfare and economic effects of raised fertility
Evaluating welfare and economic effects of raised fertilityEvaluating welfare and economic effects of raised fertility
Evaluating welfare and economic effects of raised fertility
 
OECD Pensions Outlook - 2014 Highlights
OECD Pensions Outlook - 2014 HighlightsOECD Pensions Outlook - 2014 Highlights
OECD Pensions Outlook - 2014 Highlights
 
Welfare effects of fiscal policy in reforming the pension system
Welfare effects of fiscal policy in reforming the pension systemWelfare effects of fiscal policy in reforming the pension system
Welfare effects of fiscal policy in reforming the pension system
 
The shadow of longevity – does social security reform reduce gains from incre...
The shadow of longevity – does social security reform reduce gains from incre...The shadow of longevity – does social security reform reduce gains from incre...
The shadow of longevity – does social security reform reduce gains from incre...
 
To the Point, No.4 - April 30, 2012
To the Point, No.4 - April 30, 2012To the Point, No.4 - April 30, 2012
To the Point, No.4 - April 30, 2012
 
Efficiency of the pension reform: The welfare effects of various fiscal closures
Efficiency of the pension reform: The welfare effects of various fiscal closuresEfficiency of the pension reform: The welfare effects of various fiscal closures
Efficiency of the pension reform: The welfare effects of various fiscal closures
 
Political (In)Stability of Social Security
Political (In)Stability of Social SecurityPolitical (In)Stability of Social Security
Political (In)Stability of Social Security
 

Destaque

ContourGlobal Resumen Ejecutivo
ContourGlobal Resumen EjecutivoContourGlobal Resumen Ejecutivo
ContourGlobal Resumen EjecutivoGlobal Securities
 
Cultura digital en las empresas del siglo XXI
Cultura digital en las empresas del siglo XXICultura digital en las empresas del siglo XXI
Cultura digital en las empresas del siglo XXIJosé Luis Rodríguez
 
Allianz Sustainability: 100 Facts connected
Allianz Sustainability: 100 Facts connectedAllianz Sustainability: 100 Facts connected
Allianz Sustainability: 100 Facts connectedOpen Knowledge
 
Proyecto de título Ignacio Cortina
Proyecto de título Ignacio CortinaProyecto de título Ignacio Cortina
Proyecto de título Ignacio CortinaIgnacio Martinez
 
Cultura organizativa: el caso de Territorio creativo
Cultura organizativa: el caso de Territorio creativoCultura organizativa: el caso de Territorio creativo
Cultura organizativa: el caso de Territorio creativoJosé Luis Rodríguez
 
Allianz Risk Pulse: The Future of Individual Mobility
Allianz Risk Pulse: The Future of Individual MobilityAllianz Risk Pulse: The Future of Individual Mobility
Allianz Risk Pulse: The Future of Individual MobilityOpen Knowledge
 
Can mutual microinsurance improve the living standard of the marginalized gro...
Can mutual microinsurance improve the living standard of the marginalized gro...Can mutual microinsurance improve the living standard of the marginalized gro...
Can mutual microinsurance improve the living standard of the marginalized gro...ICMIF Microinsurance
 
Strategic Planning Product
Strategic Planning ProductStrategic Planning Product
Strategic Planning Productphilhickmon
 
Global insurance industry outlook for 2014
Global insurance industry outlook for 2014Global insurance industry outlook for 2014
Global insurance industry outlook for 2014Prayukth K V
 
Building the Insurance Market
Building the Insurance MarketBuilding the Insurance Market
Building the Insurance MarketA.M. Best Company
 
Las Nuevas Tecnologías y el social media en la distribución de seguros
Las Nuevas Tecnologías y el social media en la distribución de segurosLas Nuevas Tecnologías y el social media en la distribución de seguros
Las Nuevas Tecnologías y el social media en la distribución de segurosJuan Carlos Canon Rodriguez
 
Las seis tendencias del usuario digital en España por Accenture
Las seis tendencias del usuario digital en España por AccentureLas seis tendencias del usuario digital en España por Accenture
Las seis tendencias del usuario digital en España por AccentureANA BASTANTE
 
NooxsWSN arquitectura para proyectos de Smartcity de http://www.nooxs.es
NooxsWSN arquitectura para proyectos de Smartcity de http://www.nooxs.esNooxsWSN arquitectura para proyectos de Smartcity de http://www.nooxs.es
NooxsWSN arquitectura para proyectos de Smartcity de http://www.nooxs.esJuan Jose Fajardo Navarro
 
E Learning En Seguros
E Learning En SegurosE Learning En Seguros
E Learning En SegurosCJBM
 
Allianz Microinsurance Report 2010
Allianz Microinsurance Report 2010Allianz Microinsurance Report 2010
Allianz Microinsurance Report 2010Open Knowledge
 
A Comprehensive Bitcoin Analysis
A Comprehensive Bitcoin Analysis A Comprehensive Bitcoin Analysis
A Comprehensive Bitcoin Analysis Circa Interactive
 

Destaque (20)

ContourGlobal Resumen Ejecutivo
ContourGlobal Resumen EjecutivoContourGlobal Resumen Ejecutivo
ContourGlobal Resumen Ejecutivo
 
Cultura digital en las empresas del siglo XXI
Cultura digital en las empresas del siglo XXICultura digital en las empresas del siglo XXI
Cultura digital en las empresas del siglo XXI
 
Allianz Sustainability: 100 Facts connected
Allianz Sustainability: 100 Facts connectedAllianz Sustainability: 100 Facts connected
Allianz Sustainability: 100 Facts connected
 
Negociar con inversores
Negociar con inversoresNegociar con inversores
Negociar con inversores
 
Proyecto de título Ignacio Cortina
Proyecto de título Ignacio CortinaProyecto de título Ignacio Cortina
Proyecto de título Ignacio Cortina
 
Zenit Seguros
Zenit SegurosZenit Seguros
Zenit Seguros
 
Cultura organizativa: el caso de Territorio creativo
Cultura organizativa: el caso de Territorio creativoCultura organizativa: el caso de Territorio creativo
Cultura organizativa: el caso de Territorio creativo
 
Allianz Risk Pulse: The Future of Individual Mobility
Allianz Risk Pulse: The Future of Individual MobilityAllianz Risk Pulse: The Future of Individual Mobility
Allianz Risk Pulse: The Future of Individual Mobility
 
Can mutual microinsurance improve the living standard of the marginalized gro...
Can mutual microinsurance improve the living standard of the marginalized gro...Can mutual microinsurance improve the living standard of the marginalized gro...
Can mutual microinsurance improve the living standard of the marginalized gro...
 
Strategic Planning Product
Strategic Planning ProductStrategic Planning Product
Strategic Planning Product
 
Global insurance industry outlook for 2014
Global insurance industry outlook for 2014Global insurance industry outlook for 2014
Global insurance industry outlook for 2014
 
Building the Insurance Market
Building the Insurance MarketBuilding the Insurance Market
Building the Insurance Market
 
Las Nuevas Tecnologías y el social media en la distribución de seguros
Las Nuevas Tecnologías y el social media en la distribución de segurosLas Nuevas Tecnologías y el social media en la distribución de seguros
Las Nuevas Tecnologías y el social media en la distribución de seguros
 
Las seis tendencias del usuario digital en España por Accenture
Las seis tendencias del usuario digital en España por AccentureLas seis tendencias del usuario digital en España por Accenture
Las seis tendencias del usuario digital en España por Accenture
 
NooxsWSN arquitectura para proyectos de Smartcity de http://www.nooxs.es
NooxsWSN arquitectura para proyectos de Smartcity de http://www.nooxs.esNooxsWSN arquitectura para proyectos de Smartcity de http://www.nooxs.es
NooxsWSN arquitectura para proyectos de Smartcity de http://www.nooxs.es
 
E Learning En Seguros
E Learning En SegurosE Learning En Seguros
E Learning En Seguros
 
Seguros AXA
Seguros AXASeguros AXA
Seguros AXA
 
Prospecto de informacion
Prospecto de informacionProspecto de informacion
Prospecto de informacion
 
Allianz Microinsurance Report 2010
Allianz Microinsurance Report 2010Allianz Microinsurance Report 2010
Allianz Microinsurance Report 2010
 
A Comprehensive Bitcoin Analysis
A Comprehensive Bitcoin Analysis A Comprehensive Bitcoin Analysis
A Comprehensive Bitcoin Analysis
 

Semelhante a Rethinking Retirement: Pension Reforms Transform Income Sources

Pensions Systems India & China
Pensions Systems   India & ChinaPensions Systems   India & China
Pensions Systems India & ChinaAshok Antony
 
Happily ever after... or until we run out of money. Effects of longevity on f...
Happily ever after... or until we run out of money. Effects of longevity on f...Happily ever after... or until we run out of money. Effects of longevity on f...
Happily ever after... or until we run out of money. Effects of longevity on f...GRAPE
 
The Changing Face of Retirement
The Changing Face of RetirementThe Changing Face of Retirement
The Changing Face of RetirementAegon
 
19 - On the influence of unemployment on pension benefits (2017) (ENG)
19 - On the influence of unemployment on pension benefits (2017) (ENG)19 - On the influence of unemployment on pension benefits (2017) (ENG)
19 - On the influence of unemployment on pension benefits (2017) (ENG)InstitutoBBVAdePensiones
 
FSC Future Leaders Award - Stephen Flegg
FSC Future Leaders Award - Stephen FleggFSC Future Leaders Award - Stephen Flegg
FSC Future Leaders Award - Stephen FleggSteve Flegg
 
201510 BN77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities
201510 BN77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities201510 BN77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities
201510 BN77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilitiesSarah Luheshi
 
20151012 PPI Briefing Note 77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities ...
20151012 PPI Briefing Note 77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities ...20151012 PPI Briefing Note 77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities ...
20151012 PPI Briefing Note 77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities ...Sarah Luheshi
 
Pensions in Europe - How Multinational Companies are Preparing Their Pensions...
Pensions in Europe - How Multinational Companies are Preparing Their Pensions...Pensions in Europe - How Multinational Companies are Preparing Their Pensions...
Pensions in Europe - How Multinational Companies are Preparing Their Pensions...Aegon
 
Global Wage Report 2012/13 Executive Summary
Global Wage Report 2012/13 Executive SummaryGlobal Wage Report 2012/13 Executive Summary
Global Wage Report 2012/13 Executive SummaryDr Lendy Spires
 
ForRicherForPoorerRetirementIncomes2WEB
ForRicherForPoorerRetirementIncomes2WEBForRicherForPoorerRetirementIncomes2WEB
ForRicherForPoorerRetirementIncomes2WEBElayne Grace
 
Journal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 19, Number 2—Spring 20.docx
Journal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 19, Number 2—Spring 20.docxJournal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 19, Number 2—Spring 20.docx
Journal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 19, Number 2—Spring 20.docxtawnyataylor528
 
2014.03.18 - NAEC Seminar_Assessing the vulnerabilities of social institution...
2014.03.18 - NAEC Seminar_Assessing the vulnerabilities of social institution...2014.03.18 - NAEC Seminar_Assessing the vulnerabilities of social institution...
2014.03.18 - NAEC Seminar_Assessing the vulnerabilities of social institution...OECD_NAEC
 
14 - Population projections revisited, part 3 (2015) (ENG)
14 - Population projections revisited, part 3 (2015) (ENG)14 - Population projections revisited, part 3 (2015) (ENG)
14 - Population projections revisited, part 3 (2015) (ENG)InstitutoBBVAdePensiones
 
Aon Hewitt Overhaul of the Dutch Pension System
Aon Hewitt  Overhaul of the Dutch Pension SystemAon Hewitt  Overhaul of the Dutch Pension System
Aon Hewitt Overhaul of the Dutch Pension SystemPascal Hogenboom
 
Global 2016 Aegon Retirement Readiness Report
Global 2016 Aegon Retirement Readiness ReportGlobal 2016 Aegon Retirement Readiness Report
Global 2016 Aegon Retirement Readiness ReportAegon
 

Semelhante a Rethinking Retirement: Pension Reforms Transform Income Sources (20)

Redrafting the social contract
Redrafting the social contractRedrafting the social contract
Redrafting the social contract
 
Lyon presentation
Lyon presentationLyon presentation
Lyon presentation
 
Pensions Systems India & China
Pensions Systems   India & ChinaPensions Systems   India & China
Pensions Systems India & China
 
Happily ever after... or until we run out of money. Effects of longevity on f...
Happily ever after... or until we run out of money. Effects of longevity on f...Happily ever after... or until we run out of money. Effects of longevity on f...
Happily ever after... or until we run out of money. Effects of longevity on f...
 
The Changing Face of Retirement
The Changing Face of RetirementThe Changing Face of Retirement
The Changing Face of Retirement
 
Multi page
Multi pageMulti page
Multi page
 
19 - On the influence of unemployment on pension benefits (2017) (ENG)
19 - On the influence of unemployment on pension benefits (2017) (ENG)19 - On the influence of unemployment on pension benefits (2017) (ENG)
19 - On the influence of unemployment on pension benefits (2017) (ENG)
 
FSC Future Leaders Award - Stephen Flegg
FSC Future Leaders Award - Stephen FleggFSC Future Leaders Award - Stephen Flegg
FSC Future Leaders Award - Stephen Flegg
 
201510 BN77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities
201510 BN77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities201510 BN77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities
201510 BN77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities
 
20151012 PPI Briefing Note 77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities ...
20151012 PPI Briefing Note 77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities ...20151012 PPI Briefing Note 77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities ...
20151012 PPI Briefing Note 77 - adequacy under the new pension flexibilities ...
 
Pensions in Europe - How Multinational Companies are Preparing Their Pensions...
Pensions in Europe - How Multinational Companies are Preparing Their Pensions...Pensions in Europe - How Multinational Companies are Preparing Their Pensions...
Pensions in Europe - How Multinational Companies are Preparing Their Pensions...
 
Global Wage Report 2012/13 Executive Summary
Global Wage Report 2012/13 Executive SummaryGlobal Wage Report 2012/13 Executive Summary
Global Wage Report 2012/13 Executive Summary
 
ForRicherForPoorerRetirementIncomes2WEB
ForRicherForPoorerRetirementIncomes2WEBForRicherForPoorerRetirementIncomes2WEB
ForRicherForPoorerRetirementIncomes2WEB
 
Journal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 19, Number 2—Spring 20.docx
Journal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 19, Number 2—Spring 20.docxJournal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 19, Number 2—Spring 20.docx
Journal of Economic Perspectives—Volume 19, Number 2—Spring 20.docx
 
Geoff Mulgan - The Paradoxes of Ageing
Geoff Mulgan - The Paradoxes of AgeingGeoff Mulgan - The Paradoxes of Ageing
Geoff Mulgan - The Paradoxes of Ageing
 
2014.03.18 - NAEC Seminar_Assessing the vulnerabilities of social institution...
2014.03.18 - NAEC Seminar_Assessing the vulnerabilities of social institution...2014.03.18 - NAEC Seminar_Assessing the vulnerabilities of social institution...
2014.03.18 - NAEC Seminar_Assessing the vulnerabilities of social institution...
 
14 - Population projections revisited, part 3 (2015) (ENG)
14 - Population projections revisited, part 3 (2015) (ENG)14 - Population projections revisited, part 3 (2015) (ENG)
14 - Population projections revisited, part 3 (2015) (ENG)
 
Aon Hewitt Overhaul of the Dutch Pension System
Aon Hewitt  Overhaul of the Dutch Pension SystemAon Hewitt  Overhaul of the Dutch Pension System
Aon Hewitt Overhaul of the Dutch Pension System
 
Pensions Core Course 2013: Notional Defined-contribution Schemes
Pensions Core Course 2013: Notional Defined-contribution SchemesPensions Core Course 2013: Notional Defined-contribution Schemes
Pensions Core Course 2013: Notional Defined-contribution Schemes
 
Global 2016 Aegon Retirement Readiness Report
Global 2016 Aegon Retirement Readiness ReportGlobal 2016 Aegon Retirement Readiness Report
Global 2016 Aegon Retirement Readiness Report
 

Mais de Open Knowledge

How declining populations can effect productivity -- PROJECT M
How declining populations can effect productivity -- PROJECT MHow declining populations can effect productivity -- PROJECT M
How declining populations can effect productivity -- PROJECT MOpen Knowledge
 
'Protecting Your Home from Wildfire' - Fireman's Fund Insurance Company
'Protecting Your Home from Wildfire' - Fireman's Fund Insurance Company'Protecting Your Home from Wildfire' - Fireman's Fund Insurance Company
'Protecting Your Home from Wildfire' - Fireman's Fund Insurance CompanyOpen Knowledge
 
Impact of the Euro debt crisis on the investment behavior of 50+ European Inv...
Impact of the Euro debt crisis on the investment behavior of 50+ European Inv...Impact of the Euro debt crisis on the investment behavior of 50+ European Inv...
Impact of the Euro debt crisis on the investment behavior of 50+ European Inv...Open Knowledge
 
Allianz Risk Pulse: Zukunft der indivduellen Mobilität
Allianz Risk Pulse: Zukunft der indivduellen MobilitätAllianz Risk Pulse: Zukunft der indivduellen Mobilität
Allianz Risk Pulse: Zukunft der indivduellen MobilitätOpen Knowledge
 
Allianz: 100 Fakten zur Nachhaltigkeit
Allianz: 100 Fakten zur NachhaltigkeitAllianz: 100 Fakten zur Nachhaltigkeit
Allianz: 100 Fakten zur NachhaltigkeitOpen Knowledge
 
What's happening in... the Netherlands?
What's happening in... the Netherlands?What's happening in... the Netherlands?
What's happening in... the Netherlands?Open Knowledge
 
121203 whats happening_netherlands
121203 whats happening_netherlands121203 whats happening_netherlands
121203 whats happening_netherlandsOpen Knowledge
 
Allianz Risk Pulse - Business Risks: Country Information
Allianz Risk Pulse - Business Risks: Country InformationAllianz Risk Pulse - Business Risks: Country Information
Allianz Risk Pulse - Business Risks: Country InformationOpen Knowledge
 
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4Open Knowledge
 
10 Key Components of the Fiscal Cliff
10 Key Components of the Fiscal Cliff10 Key Components of the Fiscal Cliff
10 Key Components of the Fiscal CliffOpen Knowledge
 
Fiscal Cliff Obscures Fading Fundamentals
Fiscal Cliff Obscures Fading FundamentalsFiscal Cliff Obscures Fading Fundamentals
Fiscal Cliff Obscures Fading FundamentalsOpen Knowledge
 
Allianz Risk Pulse Mobility & Road Safety
Allianz Risk Pulse Mobility & Road SafetyAllianz Risk Pulse Mobility & Road Safety
Allianz Risk Pulse Mobility & Road SafetyOpen Knowledge
 
PIMCO DC Dialogue - First Manage Your Risk
PIMCO DC Dialogue - First Manage Your RiskPIMCO DC Dialogue - First Manage Your Risk
PIMCO DC Dialogue - First Manage Your RiskOpen Knowledge
 
Allianz Global Wealth Report
Allianz Global Wealth Report Allianz Global Wealth Report
Allianz Global Wealth Report Open Knowledge
 
Allianz Life North America – Reclaiming the Future
Allianz Life North America – Reclaiming the FutureAllianz Life North America – Reclaiming the Future
Allianz Life North America – Reclaiming the FutureOpen Knowledge
 
Allianz Life North America – Rethinking What’s Ahead in Retirement
Allianz Life North America – Rethinking What’s Ahead in RetirementAllianz Life North America – Rethinking What’s Ahead in Retirement
Allianz Life North America – Rethinking What’s Ahead in RetirementOpen Knowledge
 
PIMCO DC Dialogue - It's Your Living Standard
PIMCO DC Dialogue - It's Your Living StandardPIMCO DC Dialogue - It's Your Living Standard
PIMCO DC Dialogue - It's Your Living StandardOpen Knowledge
 
Space Risks: A new generation of challenges
Space Risks: A new generation of challengesSpace Risks: A new generation of challenges
Space Risks: A new generation of challengesOpen Knowledge
 
Global Pension Atlas Germany
Global Pension Atlas GermanyGlobal Pension Atlas Germany
Global Pension Atlas GermanyOpen Knowledge
 

Mais de Open Knowledge (20)

How declining populations can effect productivity -- PROJECT M
How declining populations can effect productivity -- PROJECT MHow declining populations can effect productivity -- PROJECT M
How declining populations can effect productivity -- PROJECT M
 
'Protecting Your Home from Wildfire' - Fireman's Fund Insurance Company
'Protecting Your Home from Wildfire' - Fireman's Fund Insurance Company'Protecting Your Home from Wildfire' - Fireman's Fund Insurance Company
'Protecting Your Home from Wildfire' - Fireman's Fund Insurance Company
 
Impact of the Euro debt crisis on the investment behavior of 50+ European Inv...
Impact of the Euro debt crisis on the investment behavior of 50+ European Inv...Impact of the Euro debt crisis on the investment behavior of 50+ European Inv...
Impact of the Euro debt crisis on the investment behavior of 50+ European Inv...
 
Allianz Risk Pulse: Zukunft der indivduellen Mobilität
Allianz Risk Pulse: Zukunft der indivduellen MobilitätAllianz Risk Pulse: Zukunft der indivduellen Mobilität
Allianz Risk Pulse: Zukunft der indivduellen Mobilität
 
Allianz: 100 Fakten zur Nachhaltigkeit
Allianz: 100 Fakten zur NachhaltigkeitAllianz: 100 Fakten zur Nachhaltigkeit
Allianz: 100 Fakten zur Nachhaltigkeit
 
What's happening in... the Netherlands?
What's happening in... the Netherlands?What's happening in... the Netherlands?
What's happening in... the Netherlands?
 
121203 whats happening_netherlands
121203 whats happening_netherlands121203 whats happening_netherlands
121203 whats happening_netherlands
 
Allianz Risk Pulse - Business Risks: Country Information
Allianz Risk Pulse - Business Risks: Country InformationAllianz Risk Pulse - Business Risks: Country Information
Allianz Risk Pulse - Business Risks: Country Information
 
Euro 2022
Euro 2022Euro 2022
Euro 2022
 
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4
Allianz Global Investors Risk Monitor #4
 
10 Key Components of the Fiscal Cliff
10 Key Components of the Fiscal Cliff10 Key Components of the Fiscal Cliff
10 Key Components of the Fiscal Cliff
 
Fiscal Cliff Obscures Fading Fundamentals
Fiscal Cliff Obscures Fading FundamentalsFiscal Cliff Obscures Fading Fundamentals
Fiscal Cliff Obscures Fading Fundamentals
 
Allianz Risk Pulse Mobility & Road Safety
Allianz Risk Pulse Mobility & Road SafetyAllianz Risk Pulse Mobility & Road Safety
Allianz Risk Pulse Mobility & Road Safety
 
PIMCO DC Dialogue - First Manage Your Risk
PIMCO DC Dialogue - First Manage Your RiskPIMCO DC Dialogue - First Manage Your Risk
PIMCO DC Dialogue - First Manage Your Risk
 
Allianz Global Wealth Report
Allianz Global Wealth Report Allianz Global Wealth Report
Allianz Global Wealth Report
 
Allianz Life North America – Reclaiming the Future
Allianz Life North America – Reclaiming the FutureAllianz Life North America – Reclaiming the Future
Allianz Life North America – Reclaiming the Future
 
Allianz Life North America – Rethinking What’s Ahead in Retirement
Allianz Life North America – Rethinking What’s Ahead in RetirementAllianz Life North America – Rethinking What’s Ahead in Retirement
Allianz Life North America – Rethinking What’s Ahead in Retirement
 
PIMCO DC Dialogue - It's Your Living Standard
PIMCO DC Dialogue - It's Your Living StandardPIMCO DC Dialogue - It's Your Living Standard
PIMCO DC Dialogue - It's Your Living Standard
 
Space Risks: A new generation of challenges
Space Risks: A new generation of challengesSpace Risks: A new generation of challenges
Space Risks: A new generation of challenges
 
Global Pension Atlas Germany
Global Pension Atlas GermanyGlobal Pension Atlas Germany
Global Pension Atlas Germany
 

Rethinking Retirement: Pension Reforms Transform Income Sources

  • 1. Photo: shutterstock / Diego Cervo Allianz SE    www.allianz.com Issue # Allianz 9 Demographic Pulse March 2013 “It’s time to Rethink Retirement” After a decade of pension reforms in Western Europe and the establishment of new systems in Eastern Europe and Asia, the structure of a retirement income has begun to change. This paper summarizes the driving forces behind this transformation and describes the new mix of sources of retirement income of households in selected countries. Second and third pillar plans, income from financial assets and employ- ment – as well as the rise of the elderly in the workforce – are gaining importance. The changes in the retirement landscape are challenging for all parties involved – solutions providers, governments and em- ployees. To achieve at an adequate retirement income for future retirees all parties have to work together to set up a modern pension system with strong different pillars. “It’s time to Rethink Retirement”, says Jay Ralph, Chairman of Allianz Asset Management and member of the Board of Management of Allianz SE. Rise of Elderly Persons in the Workforce 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% S wede n S witz erl a n d s o u t h k o rea US A si n gap o re UK Germa n y n e therl a n ds S pai n H o n GKo n g* Gree c e A u s t ria Italy Poland F ra n c e 2010 h u n gar y 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 2000 *Data for 2008 instead of 2010 Participation rate of people aged 60 to 64 years. Sources: Allianz / OECD Eurostat, ILO Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9   March 2013   page 1
  • 2. The process of pension reform This wave of funded pension plans has been introduced across the Societal aging and the accompanying rise in the old-age dependency board since 2000.4 New funded occupational pension schemes have ratio has increased the pressure on public finances; particularly on even been introduced in emerging Asia, where aging, industrializa- the sustainability of pay-as-you-go (PAYG) pension systems. In 2001, tion and urbanization have begun to erode the existing informal when the European Commission began to make projections on the family-based retirement model. cost of aging for the 15 member states of Western Europe1, the cost of pension systems was expected to increase by 2.9% of the GDP until 2050. In addition, they factored in the expected costs of healthcare “New funded occupational pension schemes have and long-term care systems. In an effort to ease the pressure, most even been introduced in emerging Asia, where aging, countries began introducing pension reforms at the turn of the industrialization and urbanization has begun to erode century. Though the latest report shows there has been some the existing informal family-based retirement model.“ relief on average budgets (2.1% for the Eurozone until 2050),2 there are still large differences between countries. In addition to parametric changes, targeted adjustments to the legal The main components of these reforms were parametric changes in: retirement age are being made to first pillar systems so that they are better prepared to meet coming demographic changes – increasing ++Benefit calculation (for instance, lifetime earnings are now used life expectancy, in particular. In addition to increasing the legal retire- as a basis for calculation rather than final pay or best years of ment age, many countries are also equalizing the retirement ages earnings) of men and women. Moreover, access to early retirement has been ++Pension indexation rules restricted in several countries over the last couple of years, thereby ++Automatic adjustment to demographic change or actuarial adjust- effectively increasing the retirement age. ment mechanisms. The effects of all these changes on the pension landscape are For the most part, these measures led to a decrease in the replace- multifold: ment rates of the first pillar. Calculations from the Organisation of Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) show, for ++Benefits from public pension systems (first pillar) have decreased example, that lifetime benefits in the 16 OECD countries that in- ++New incentive structures are promoting an accumulation of assets troduced the most wide-ranging reforms were cut on average in the second and third pillars by 22% for men and 25% for women.3 ++In moving from defined benefit (DB) to defined contribution (DC) plans, risk is being transferred away from pension scheme spon- sors and to the beneficiary. “ ifetime benefits in 16 OECD countries were cut on L After 10 to 15 years of reform process … average by 22% for men and 25% for women.” With the wave of reforms and the expected decrease in statu- tory pension insurance, people are retiring later5 and saving more. In the future, the retirement income mix will rest less As this poses a major change for most people, these declining on the previously dominant first pillar (state pensions) than public benefit levels had to be offset. Thus, during the last 10 to 15 on the funded elements. years, many countries have accompanied the reform process in the first pillar by adding a complementary buildup of pre-funding ele- 4 See overview in Allianz Global Investors, “Pension Systems in a Demographic Transition”, Analysis and Trends 11/2011, p. 8 ments and/or an improvement of existing second and third pillar 5 The younger generation will retire even later due to long term phasing-in processes. plans by creating incentives for additional private pension savings, Photo: shutterstock / Pincasso expanding existing occupational schemes, introducing new second and third pillar (occupational and private) pension plans and tax benefits, and even granting direct financial support payments to encourage people to save more for old age on their own. Some countries, particularly those in central and Eastern Europe (CEE), have voted in compulsory systems in order to ensure asset-build- ing for a wide range of people. Others, like the United States and United Kingdom, have introduced auto-enrollment strategies or tax incentives to foster voluntary participation. 1 Comparison of projection results in: European Commission, 2006: The impact of ageing on public expendi- ture: projections for the EU25 Member States on pensions, health care, long-term care, education and unemployment transfers (2004-2050), Special Report No. 1/2006, p. 73. 2 It should be noted that the composition of countries compared differs slightly in these two reports. 3 Antolin, Pablo and Whitehouse, Edward R., 2009: Filling the Pension Gap: Coverage and value of voluntary retirement savings, OECD Social Employment and Migration Working Papers No. 69 Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9   March 2013   page 2
  • 3. New Asset Structure 96 11 96 11 96 11 01 11 19 20 19 20 19 20 20 20 100% 100% 11.2% 27.8% 17.2% 26.4% 27% 7.3% 36% 34.8% 38.4% 80% 80% 22.1% 8.9% 8.3% 36% 60% 25.1% 10.1% 60% 20.6% 39.7% 32.9% 11.2% 40% 5.9% 40% 55.5% 57.1% 51% 41.6% 35.4% 9.9% 10.2% 20% 33.4% 20% 13.5% 16.3% 0% 0% West er n Euro pe U n i ted S tates * J apan CEE Pension reforms have changed the structure of household financial assets within the last 15 years. Worldwide, the claims of private households from provisions at life insurance companies total more than EUR 10 trillion. * Insurance and pension plans including IRAs (Individual Retirement Accounts); IRAs extracted from other products. Sources: Allianz / Central Banks, National statistical offices, Allianz International Pensions. … a shift in financial assets society, which has one of the highest old-age dependency ratios in From a macro perspective, this development has already affected the the world. Under existing policies, new cash inflows barely cover composition of private financial assets so that, over the past decade, outflows. Even so, the percentage of pension and insurance products there has been an increase in the percentage of pension and insurance has been stable at around 26.5% over the last 15 years. assets within the financial portfolio of private households. This is par- ticularly the case in Western Europe, where reforms ushered in major … people working longer changes, including funded pension plans and insurance products. As The financial crisis put the changing structures of pension provi- late as the mid-1990s, pension plans made up only 28% of the financial sioning systems to the test and the reform path is still feeling the portfolio; by 2011, this share had grown to over 36% in Western pressure of the debt crisis, high volatility of markets and low interest Europe. Although this trend is also noticeable in the United States, it rates. The challenges that this environment poses for funded pillars is not as strong. With a much longer tradition of funded occupational are considerable. and private pension plans, the shift took place much earlier in the United States, which is one of the reasons there has not been as dra- The downturn reduced individual retirement assets substantially. In matic a change in recent years. However, this trend is also attributable countries where the total retirement portfolio consisted of a large to the financial crisis, as US citizens’ investment preferences resulted number of funded schemes and high equity exposure, people had in higher losses than for investors who were more risk averse.6 In 2011 to compensate: either save more or work longer. 38.4% of the financial assets of private US households were attributed to retirement products, basically the same as at the turn of the century. In other words, it is not only the increase in retirement ages that has had an influence on the number of people staying longer in the workforce; so have the erosion of pension assets and the need “ hether in Europe, Asia or the United States, the W to save longer for retirement. Whether in Europe, Asia or the United participation rate of people aged 60 to 64 years has States, the participation rate of people aged 60 to 64 years has risen risen over the last 10 years in most of the countries over the last 10 years in most of the countries studied in this paper. studied in this paper.” In Europe, the biggest increase can be observed in Germany and the Netherlands (see chart page 1), where participation rates The strongest increase can be observed in the CEE, where reforms more than doubled. Even so, the levels reached in 2010 were still introduced new funded pension schemes. Only 7.3% of financial below those of other European countries like Sweden and Swit- assets were held in insurance and retirement accounts in 2001, by zerland where participation rates even in 2000 were higher. High 2011; however this percentage had risen drastically to 17.2%. In con- rates can also be observed in the U.S., Japan, Korea and Singa- trast to this emerging region, Japan is a good example of an “elderly” pore; there more people aged 60 to 64 stay in the workforce than 6 in most European countries. See Allianz Global Investors, 2010: The Global Crunch and its Long-term Impact on US Retirement Invest- ing, International Pension Studies No 4/2010 Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9   March 2013   page 3
  • 4. Photo: shutterstock / Africa Studio between 20 to 25% of total retirement income was derived from wages, which might be connected to the total replacement rate they had achieved taking all income sources together. The relative income level of people aged 65 and above compared to those under 65 years of age might give an indication: In Ireland, for example, this ratio only reached a bit more than 50 and just two thirds in the United Kingdom compared to 90 in France and 80 in Germany.9 The large share of occupational pension income in the Netherlands and Switzerland reflects the role these mandatory instruments play in the old-age provisioning system, just as the high percentage of public pensions in France and Germany reflects their traditionally strong role. Finland has a special first pillar model, which com- prises two components: a residence-based national pension and an earnings-related pension. The latter is partially funded. The bulk of “n contrast to continental Europe, the basic philosophy I retirement income in Finland comes from this source. of many Anglo-Saxon countries is to provide a pension system to protect against old-age poverty.” Up to around 2010 After more than a decade of reforms, all the developments described in the first part of the paper have had an impact on Austria, France and Hungary, on the other hand, have very low the structure of retirement income in many countries, par- participation rates, where the effective retirement age has stayed ticularly in those with major early reforms, and are mirrored below 60 for much longer than other countries, probably due to later in the income mix. adjustments to early retirement schemes. Nevertheless, the trend is similar: within the last 10 years, there has been a distinct increase The portion of income coming from the first pillar has decreased in in participation. These developments are expected to increase the all the countries considered in this paper except in Ireland, where importance of work in the retirement income mix. it is broadly unchanged, and in Finland, where the percentage has increased from roughly 68 to 75%. Even so, the funded pillar is also … a changed retirement income mix? gaining importance in Finland, which may in part be due to the sys- tem’s mechanism: as residence-based national pensions decrease, Moving from around 2000 earnings-related pensions increase. Before reforms were introduced, most pension income was provided by the public PAYG system. Replacement rates in many continental The importance of (quasi-)mandatory funded systems as a source European countries were designed to keep up with the standard of of retirement income in mature pension fund markets such as the living achieved at retirement. Additional sources of retirement income Netherlands and Switzerland, has increased quite a bit: in the were primarily important for high income earners whose replacement Netherlands from 31 to 40%, and in Switzerland from 26.6 to 32.8%. rates from the first pillar are low due to contribution limits. In contrast, people in the United Kingdom and United States have compensated for decreasing income from funded schemes by taking In contrast to continental Europe, the basic philosophy of many on additional work. The financial crisis has probably taken its toll, Anglo-Saxon countries is to provide a pension system to protect particularly in the United States where the percentage of funded against old-age poverty. Using this as the basic premise, ad- schemes within the total retirement portfolio is high. With little time ditional saving instruments had to be created to help people to recoup, cohorts approaching retirement were faced with the deci- achieve a reasonable retirement income, which is why coun- sion of whether to continue working during retirement, or to retire tries like the United Kingdom and United States developed on substantially less than planned. funded pillars early on and now have mature funded pension markets. That said, the Netherlands and Switzerland were also early In Sweden, Germany and France lower levels from social security to introduce funded second pillar schemes. were compensated by a larger share of investment income and individual plans, as newly introduced plans from the last decade have From a micro perspective, this is reflected in the structure of retire- not yet reached the payout phase. In most countries this compensa- ment income.7 As of 20008, total retirement income in the United tion was achieved by additional income from work. Compared to the Kingdom and the United States was made up of a mix of sources level in 2000, this share has gained importance in all countries except of income: state pensions that provide a minimum standard of France and Ireland. living (40% in the UK and 50% in the US), income from privately funded pillars (30 to 40% from occupational pensions and invest- This might change in the future as plans reach maturity and ment income) and then topped up from income earned by staying reforms are phased in. Even so, the bulk of pension income in most in the workforce. This was also the case in Japan and Ireland, where countries will continue to be provided by public schemes. Even the 7 As there are a variety of different sources which also differ according to the situation of a household for 9 OECD: Database on income distribution and poverty, StatExtracts (stats.oecd.org) example as to the occupation the average incomes only give a broad brush picture. The chart shows the income mix of a couple older than 65 years. 8 The results shown in the chart have slightly differing base years, which range from 1999 in Japan to 2002 Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9   March 2013   page 4 in France.
  • 5. Retirement Income Mix A Decade of Change: 2000 vs 2010 2000 38.9% 28.3% 12.6% 20.2% Un ited k i ngdom 2010 37.7% 26.5% 9.2% 26.5% 2000 48% 31% 15% 6% n ether lands 2010 43% 40% 8% 9% 2000 49.1% 9.7% 19.2% 22% Un ited st at es 2010 47.3% 8.3% 13.6% 30.8% 2000 50.8% 26.6% 14.4% 8.2% S wi tzer land 2010 43.4% 32.8% 14.9% 9% 2000 56.4% 12.2% 6.5% 24.9% Ire land 2010 57.4% 14.6% 8% 20% 3.4% 2000 18.1% 50.2% 28.3% fi n land * 2010 13.2% 62.4% 20.7% 3.7% 1.1% 4% 2000 74.5% 20.4% japan 2010 61.4% 10.4% 25.2%. 3% 2000 77.5% 16.7% 5.8% swede n* * 2010 61.4% 19% 19.6% 4.2% 2000 78% 8.2% 9.5% germa ny 2010 70% 9% 12% 9% 2000 80.6% 8.2% 11.2% franc e * * * 2010 73.2% 19.5% 7.3% * first pillar: 18.1% residence based national and 50.2% earnings-related pensions  ** first pillar, incl ATP  sta te occupa tion a l In v estmen t work *** first pillar, incl. second-pillar PAYG income. pen sion s pen sion s in come /other Sources: Allianz, National Statistics, Central Banks, Governmental Bodies Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9   March 2013   page 5
  • 6. entering the workforce. Older workers were allowed to decide on Photo: shutterstock / Andy Dean Photography whether or not they wanted to participate, while people close to retirement were prohibited from joining as any capital they would be able to accumulate would be insufficient to cover retirement bene- fits. These regulations are mirrored in the retirement mix. Since older employees could not access second pillar pensions, their retirement income is primarily a mixture of income from first pillar pensions and work, with possibly a modest contribution from capital income. Family support still important in Asia The challenges of pension reform in several Asian countries have been, and still are, to establish well-functioning public pension systems and broaden the coverage of existing ones to alleviate a worsening demographic situation caused by a substantial increase in life expectancy and a drastic fall in once high fertility rates – a United Kingdom is modifying its system by increasing first pillar typical consequence of industrialization, rapid economic growth and pensions.10 The total effect on the income mix remains unclear urbanization. Until roughly a decade ago, the chief component of however, due to the possible increase in private pension income retirement provisioning in emerging Asian countries was its tradi- from the introduction of auto-enrollment plans and mandatory tional system of strong family values and social norms in which most employer contributions. retirees relied largely on family support. Italy and Austria belong to the group of countries which aimed at maintaining the standard of living in retirement with their public pen- “According to the World Bank, about 55% of retirement sion system. In Italy the majority of people rely on public pensions as income in South Korea was provided by the family in the main source of income.11 The replacement rate of the first pillar 1990. Today, it is about 30%.” is high, thus the other pillars are still small and the proportion of oc- cupational pensions within the retirement income mix has been small. Additional income is generated by investment income and work. After Accompanying this informal system of old-age support was a weak reforms in early 2000 in Italy and later on in Austria, this might change and limited public pension system. However, socio-economic chang- in the future when plans mature and reach the payout phase. But in es have put the family support system under pressure and as the the situation for people entering retirement now, the changes do not need for organized retirement systems dramatically increased, coun- yet show up. Today about 72% of an average Italian’s income comes tries began establishing formal pension systems to some degree. At from public schemes, 4% from capital and 24% from wages, accord- the same time, Asia began to introduce new occupational pension ing to the OECD.12 In Austria the proportion of public pensions is even schemes such as the Mandatory Provident Fund in Hong Kong, the higher and the importance of income from work lower than in Italy.13 New Labor Pension Fund in Taiwan and new corporate schemes in South Korea. In other words, the entire retirement landscape in Asia CEE: retirement income from the state – new pension schemes has changed and is still evolving. not in the pay-out phase The current shape of pension systems in the CEE has been formed Though reforms are in progress, the new systems don’t provide for by decisions taken after the fall of the Iron Curtain, when former current retirees so that, to a large extent, they still have to rely on Eastern Bloc countries were faced with the daunting task of reform- family support. This is reflected in our results. A survey in Singapore ing their outdated pension systems. Under the old regime, pensions revealed that 60% of the elderly still receive the most support from in the CEE were the exclusive responsibility of the state, and were their families and that only a small portion of their income stems incompatible with current demographic developments or the new from the Central Provident Fund, the main pillar in Singapore. In economic reality. Central and Eastern Europe are ageing fast and are addition, some retirees were able to take out a private pension – just as sensitive to demographic changes as Western Europe. probably thanks to Singapore’s economic upswing – and are now To cope with the enormous financial pressure and secure the solven- drawing income from their accrued private savings. cy of public pensions, CEE countries initiated similar reforms to their first pillar pension systems in the 1990s as those in Western Europe. As far as the family support network is concerned, the situation is Deeper reforms have been made in most of CEE countries. similar in Thailand and, surprisingly, also in South Korea where When second pillar plans were first introduced, most of them were pension reforms were implemented in the late 1980s. According to offered to younger employees and were mandatory for people just the World Bank, about 55% of retirement income in South Korea was provided by the family in 1990. Today, it is about 30%. Though the 10 PPI Pensions Policy Institute, March 2010: Retirement income and assets: outlook for the future, PPI Brief- importance of family support is decreasing, it will take a long time for ing note Number 54 11 Statistics Italy; http://dati.istat.it/?lang=en patterns to change completely. 12 Pensions at a Glance 2011; occupational pensions not separated in the OECD report. Thus it is not quite comparable to the other results. 13 STATISTIK AUSTRIA, EU-SILC 2010. Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9   March 2013   page 6
  • 7. Outlook countries indicates that providing flexible retirement alternatives The retirement income mix has started to change as the role of could meet a growing demand: 65% of the European workforce is funded pensions grows and public pension levels decrease. Nev- interested in having the opportunity to combine a part-time job and ertheless this view does not show whether the complementary partial pension as an alternative to full employment.15 pillars are strong enough to compensate for decreasing levels However, people will also have to save more in order to generate more in the first pillars in absolute terms. Thus, the question arises of income, which could be encouraged by the type of automatic and whether retirement income is adequate. As the EU commission default solutions being introduced in the United Kingdom this year. points out in its Adequacy Report: “There were great advances in the sustainability of public pensions, but adequacy outcomes Eastern Europe will have to strengthen its emphasis on pension re- are less impressive.”14 For future retirees to achieve retirement form in order to compensate for the hit their pension systems took income levels comparable to those of today’s retirees, they will during the financial and economic crisis. Even so, future retirees have to change their working and savings behavior. can look forward to receiving an income stream from the funded pillars introduced over the last ten years. In Asia, the process of The challenge for the future is to foster labor market opportunities broadening pension coverage will lead to a major shift from infor- so that older employees can continue working. A survey of European mal to formal systems. 14 Social Protection Committee of the European Union, May 23, 2012: Pension Adequacy in the European 15 European Commission, 2012: Active Ageing, Eurobarometer 378 (special edition) Union 2010–2050 Central banks: flow-of-funds statistics (2004-2050), Special Report no. 1/2006, p. 73 Singapore Ministry of Community Develop- Sources ment, Youth and Sports, 2005: National Survey of Employee Benefit Research Institute European Commission, 2012: Active Ageing, (www.ebri.org) Eurobarometer 378 (special edition) Senior Citizens 2005 Allianz Global Investors, 2010: The Global Crunch Federal Republic of Germany: Old-age Security National statistical offices of the Czech Republic, Social Protection Committee of the European and its Long-term Impact on US Retirement Invest- Reports (Alterssicherungsberichte) Finland, France, Ireland, Japan, Korea, Lithuania, Union, May 23, 2012: Pension Adequacy in the ing, International Pension Studies No 4/2010 the Netherlands, Slovakia, Sweden, Switzerland European Union 2010-2050 European Commission, November 2010: Prog- Allianz Global Investors, November 2011: ress and key challenges in the delivery of adequate and Thailand (income data) UK Department for Work and Pensions: The Pension Systems in a Demographic Transition: and sustainable pensions in Europe, European OECD: Database on income distribution and Pensioners’ Incomes Series 2009–10 (national Demographic change puts pressure on pension Economy Occupational Papers 71 poverty, StatExtracts (stats.oecd.org) statistics) systems, Analysis and Trends European Commission, 2006: The impact of OECD, 2011: Pensions at a Glance Antolin, Pablo and Whitehouse, Edward R., ageing on public expenditure: projections for the 2009: illing the Pension Gap: Coverage and value F Pensions Policy Institute, March 2010: EU25 Member States on pensions, health care, long- Retirement Income and Assets: Outlook for the of voluntary retirement savings, OECD Social Em- term care, education and unemployment transfers ployment and Migration Working Papers No. 69 future, PPI Briefing Note No. 54 Editor: Dr. Renate Finke, Allianz, Senior Economist, International Pensions Publisher: Allianz SE, Königinstraße 28, 80802 München | Claudia Mohr-Calliet, claudia.mohr-calliet@allianz.com I http://www.allianz.com Why does Allianz care about demography? Why does it matter to journalists and the public? What are the benefits of the Allianz Demo- graphic Pulse? As a global financial service provider, Allianz believes Demographic change is challenging today’s societies demographic change to be of crucial importance. in many ways: People are getting older, and this raises The Allianz Demographic Pulse is based on the latest Identified as one of the major megatrends, the issues of long-term care and dementia, amongst research into various aspects of demographic change. demographic change will hold the key to many others. Furthermore, in the future there will be a Conducted and written by Allianz experts, it highlights upcoming social challenges, whether with regard to significant decline in the workforce in most of the current and globally relevant demographic data and health, old-age provision, education, consumption or world’s markets, triggering challenges in areas such provides an insight into its impact on worldwide capital markets. as pension funding. Only information, awareness and economies and societies. To ensure up-to-date discussion on the topic will help to change attitudes, coverage of major developments in this field, the behavior and situations, which can hopefully help Allianz Demographic Pulse is published on a regular solve urgent issues and come up with innovative basis, thus providing ongoing and detailed solutions. information about a major trend that is shaping the world we live in. More publications at: Do you have any comments, Allianz Group Economic Research Corporate Development suggestions or questions? We look https://www.allianz.com/en/economic_research/publications/index.html forward to your feedback! International Pensions, Allianz Global Investors Claudia Mohr-Calliet http://publications.allianzgi.com/en/PensionResearch/Pages/PensionResearch.aspx ++49 89 3800 18797 Allianz Knowledge Site claudia.mohr-calliet@allianz.com http://knowledge.allianz.com/ These assessments are, as always, subject to the disclaimer provided below. Cautionary note regarding forward-looking statements: The statements contained herein may include statements (iii) the frequency and severity of insured loss events, including from natural catastrophes and including the development of future expectations and other forward-looking statements that are based on management’s current views and assump- of loss expenses, (iv) mortality and morbidity levels and trends, (v) persistency levels, (vi) the extent of credit defaults, (vii) tions and involve known and unknown risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results, performance or events to interest rate levels, (viii) currency exchange rates including the Euro/U.S. Dollar exchange rate, (ix) changing levels of differ materially from those expressed or implied in such statements. In addition to statements which are forward-looking competition, (x) changes in laws and regulations, including monetary convergence and the European Monetary Union, by reason of context, the words “may”, “will”, “should”, “expects”, “plans”, “intends”, “anticipates”, “believes”, “estima- (xi) changes in the policies of central banks and/or foreign governments, (xii) the impact of acquisitions, including rela- tes”, “predicts”, “potential”, or “continue” and similar expressions identify forward-looking statements. Actual results, ted integration issues, (xiii) reorganization measures, and (xiv) general competitive factors, in each case on a local, regi- performance or events may differ materially from those in such statements due to, without limitation, (i) general econo- onal, national and/or global basis. Many of these factors may be more likely to occur, or more pronounced, as a result of mic conditions, including in particular economic conditions in the Allianz Group’s core business and core markets, (ii) terrorist activities and their consequences. The company assumes no obligation to update any forward-looking statement. performance of financial markets, including emerging markets, and including market volatility, liquidity and credit events No duty to update: The company assumes no obligation to update any information contained herein. Allianz Demographic Pulse – Issue # 9   March 2013   page 7