SlideShare uma empresa Scribd logo
1 de 10
Baixar para ler offline
Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting
Vol. 4, No. 1 June 2010
Pp 65-73


  Can Audit Prevent Fraudulent Financial Re-
 porting Practices? Study of Some Motivational
   Factors in Two Atlantic Canadian Entities
                                       Mostaq M. Hussain
                                        Patricia Kennedy
                                       Victoria Kierstead
                                       Faculty of Business
                             University of New Brunswick-Saint John
                                             Canada

Abstract

Much as has been written and done to prevent Fraudulent Financial Reporting (FFR) practices
but FFR is still exists in the corporate world. It is common to think about FFR practices in large
companies for its greater amount of consequences, though such practises have negative conse-
quences in small companies as well. FFR practices raise questions about the legitimacy of con-
temporary financial reporting process, roles of auditors, regulators, and analysts in financial
reporting. This empirical study attempts to investigate the motivational factors of the preven-
tion and detection of FFR through the auditing process. The interviewees were carried out
within the entity and proprietary theoretical framework with some accounting related manage-
ment in two medium-sized organizations in Atlantic Canada in winter 2008. The findings of
this research demonstrate that an audit is not enough to prevent and detect FFR. The audit
structure needs to be revised and employees need to be educated in order for them to better
understand their internal control process, and their own role. Companies need to evaluate their
controls and internal audit process instead of relying on the yearly audit. This study found that
the most common methods used for FFR are improper revenue recognition, understatement of
expenses/liabilities, and overstated and misappropriation of assets.

Keywords: Fraudulent Financial Reporting, Audit, Saint John

1. Background                                              fined as intentional misstatements that
                                                           can be classified into two types. The
Auditors Role                                              first is misstatements arising from
                                                           Fraudulent Financial Reporting (FFR)
It is generally held belief that auditors’                 and second misstatements arising from
job to find fraud and error as part of the                 misappropriation of assets. Therefore
scope of the engagement for auditing                       errors are the unintentional acts that
financial statements. Fraud can be de-                     cause financial statements to be mis-

Corresponding author: Mostaq M. Hussain is Associate Professor of Accounting at Faculty of Business University of
New Brunswick-Saint John, Canada. Tel 1506-648-5805, Fax 1506-648-5574, E-mail: mhussain@unb.ca
66    M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73


stated. As Messier and Emby (2004)                        known as the US Treadway Commis-
elicited a number of reasons of FFR.                      sion) did an in depth study on FFR in
They are: (1). Manipulation, falsifica-                   1987. The report outlined ways to pre-
tion, or alteration of accounting records                 vent and detect FFR. “The prevention
or supporting documents from which                        and detection of fraudulent reporting is
financial statements are prepared. (2).                   important because the financial reporting
Misrepresentation in, or intentional                      process relies on the integrity of the re-
omission from, the financial statement of                 ported information.”(Warrick and Riner,
events, transaction, or other significant                 2004). The Treadway Commission iden-
information. (3). Intentional misapplica-                 tifies the control environment, ‘tone at
tion of accounting principles relating to                 the top,’ as the most important factor in
amounts, classification, manner of pres-                  preventing FFR, it will be senior man-
entation, or disclosure. (4). Management                  agement that is the first defense against
override of internal controls that other-                 FFR. Even though senior management
wise may appear to be operating effec-                    is the first defense in many cases it is
tively. However, misappropriation is the                  senior management who is involved in
result of theft of the company’s assets                   FFR. With increasing pressures from
and can include: embezzling cash re-                      shareholders to maximize earnings it is
ceipts, stealing assets, causing the com-                 often senior managers who feel the most
pany to pay for goods or services not                     pressure to make the organization more
received.                                                 profitable. Ernst & Young (2000) issued
                                                          the findings of its general international
Fraud can be committed in a number of                     fraud study (not limited to FFR), which
ways. There are several ‘red flags’ men-                  states that employees committed 82 per-
tioned in Warrick and Riner’s (2004)                      cent of frauds with management being
study. According to Warrick and Riner                     involved in one third of those.
(2004), an auditor should look for a
number of issues when performing an                       In the business environment importance
audit, like: (I) Unusual or complex trans-                should be placed on internal controls as
actions, (II) Emphasis of management                      this is the first defense in preventing
on short term earnings, (III) Pressure to                 fraud on an individual level. Internal
meet stock analyst expectations, (IV).                    controls can be difficult to implement
Accounting estimates for valuing things                   depending on the size of the organiza-
such as warranty expenses, (V). Weak                      tion. Large corporations with hundreds
internal controls, (VI). A weak or non-                   of administrative staff are more likely to
active board of directors, and (VII). In-                 have efficient segregation of duties than
centive compensation plans structured                     an organization that only has a few ad-
on high financial performance.                            ministrative staff. According to COSO,
                                                          fraudulent reporting occurs most often in
According to the Committee of Sponsor-                    smaller corporations. There are five
ing Organizations (COSO, 1999), large                     components of internal control: control
adjusting entries at the end of the quarter               environment, risk assessment, control
or year that involve revenue or asset ac-                 activities, information and communica-
counts should be considered carefully.                    tion, and monitoring. The control envi-
                                                          ronment sets the tone of the organization
The National Commission on FFR (also                      as it is the foundation of all other con-
M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73   67


trols. Several circumstances can affect                    These could include, according to Car-
the risk assessment of a corporation.                      penter (2001): (I). Internal controls as
They include (but are not limited) to:                     the first line of defense. (II). Using inter-
new personnel, rapid growth, new tech-                     nal auditors that report to an audit com-
nology, and foreign operations. Control                    mittee of the board of directors rather
activities are the policies and procedures                 than senior management. (IV). Hold
that help to ensure that the appropriate                   management accountable to the same
measures are taken to address the risks.                   standards of misconduct as non-
The controls can include but are not lim-                  management. (V). Use fraud detection
ited to: segregation of duties, under-                     software. (VI). Effectively communicate
standing of control activities and per-                    ethics and fraud programs to the em-
formance reviews.         Information and                  ployees to ensure that employees per-
communication refers to the information                    ceive the programs to be working.
system relevant to the financial reporting                 Moreover, Warrick and Riner (2004)
objectives and communication is provid-                    suggested the appropriate segregation of
ing an understanding of individual roles                   duties, and the need of performing ratio
and responsibilities. Pre-assumably, a                     analyses on firm account balances.
well operating information system can                      Beasley (2000) argues that audit com-
reduce the risk of material misstatement                   mittees should meet at least quarterly,
when monitoring assesses the quality of                    and according to NCFFR (1987), Audit
internal control over time. During the                     committee members should be of the
course of an audit these and other inter-                  firm.
nal controls will be evaluated by the
auditor to ensure they are sufficient. The                 Understanding why employees commit
auditor will also establish materiality,                   fraud is a key factor in being able to de-
the level of misstatement that will not                    tect fraud. A study by Hollinger and
affect the decision of a reasonable user                   Clark with 12, 000 employees in the
of the financial statements.                               workforce found that nearly 90% en-
                                                           gaged in ‘workplace deviance’, which
Prevention of Fraud                                        included behavior such as goldbricking,
                                                           workplace slowdowns, sick time abuses
The Treadway Commission cited that                         and pilferage. On top of that, an aston-
education as one way of preventing                         ishing one-third of employees actually
fraud by making those who are responsi-                    had stolen money or merchandise on the
ble for the everyday accounting duties                     job. (Wells, 2001) There are three fac-
and making aware of how fraud is com-                      tors that contribute to employees com-
mitted and then educating them about                       mitting fraud they are: pressure, oppor-
detecting procedure. In addition to edu-                   tunity, and rationalization. If employees
cating employees about how to prevent                      feel they are not being treated fairly and
and detect fraud the board of directors                    adequately they are more likely to com-
can play a key role in preventing fraud.                   pensate themselves in the form of
The board should support the ‘tone at                      “wages in kind”. Fraud is also commit-
the top’ or even set the tone of the or-                   ted because of financial pressures. Cres-
ganization. It is the board who can di-                    sey (in Wells, 2001) found that the em-
rect management to have certain preven-                    ployees “must perceive an opportunity
tion and detection controls in place.                      to commit and conceal their crimes, and
68   M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73


be able to rationalize their offenses as                 likely that the manager will not act in the
something other than criminal activ-                     best interest of the owner.” (Messier and
ity” (Wells, 2001). Wells also lists a                   Emby, 2004) By having the corporation
number of questions. Whenever they are                   audited the auditor adds value to infor-
answered positively, there should be a                   mation by increasing its reliability and
red flag for fraud motivation. The ques-                 credibility.
tions are follows:
    Is management compensation tied                      It is management’s duty to be aware of
    closely to company value?                            the consequences of fraudulent reporting
    Is management dominated by a sin-                    whether it is legal, social or ethical. The
    gle person or a small group?                         news has been dominated in recent years
    Does management display a signifi-                   by many scandalous tales of large corpo-
    cant disregard for regulations or                    rations committing fraud. For example
    controls?                                            Enron has had to restate their financial
    Has management restricted the audi-                  statements for a total of eight billion dol-
    tor’s access to documents or person-                 lars and some of the executives have
    nel?                                                 been charged with committing fraud.
    Has management set unrealistic fi-                   Fraud is not limited to corporations. One
    nancial goals?                                       of the Big Four firms Arthur Anderson,
    Does management have any [past                       “was the auditor for a number if entities
    history of illegal conduct?                          involved in FFR. The effect of Arthur
    Is an employee obviously dissatis-                   Anderson was devastating. Their com-
    fied?                                                plicity with the scandals ultimately de-
    Does that employee have a past his-                  stroyed them.”(Warrick and Riner,
    tory of dishonesty or illegal con-                   2004)
    duct?
    Does that employee have known
    financial pressures, such as exces-                  2. Methodology
    sive debt, bad credit or tax liens?                  Research Method
    Has that employee’s lifestyle or be-
    havior changed significantly?                        To develop a better understanding of the
                                                         motivational factor on fraudulent report-
The growth of the modern corporation                     ing and how an audit can detect and pre-
has given the rise to absentee owners                    vent it from control fraud we turned to a
(shareholders) and the use of managers                   prominent Saint John company (X), and
(agents) to operate the corporation on a                 an accounting firm (Z), in order to have
day-to-day basis. “The agency relation-                  a diversified view. Semi structured in-
ship between an owner and manager                        terviews were conducted with each in-
produces a natural conflict of interest                  terviewee on March 20, 2008 and April
because of the information asymmetry                     4, 2008 respectively. The first inter-
this means that, the manager generally                   viewee is from Company X and the sec-
has more information about the ‘true’                    ond interviewee is from Company Z.
financial position and results of opera-                 These two were selected to evaluate the
tions of the entity than the absentee                    opinion on auditing from the perspective
owner does. If both parties seek to                      of a large corporation and that of firm.
maximize their own self-interest, it is                  The interviews were conducted on site
M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73   69


during an hour long pre-booked appoint-                    tions upon liquidation.
ment. Notes were taken during the inter-
views and organizing the interview re-                     The entity theory is quoted as being
sults immediate after the interviews.                      “income centered”. Any net income or
The first interviewee holds a CA and                       loss of the firm within a given year be-
was chosen because of his extensive                        longs to the firm. In the event that the
knowledge of business practices in large                   firm has a positive net income on the
companies. The second interviewee has                      income statement for the year, will only
her BBA and was selected for her                           be considered income to the sharehold-
knowledge in accounting practices from                     ers if dividends are declared. In this ex-
the perspective of a large firm as well as                 ample the amount of income to the
her previous experiences in the industry.                  shareholders will be the amount of the
Following the interviews, secondary                        dividend that they receive from the
sources of information was scrutinized                     firm. The remaining profit belongs to
in order to find the consistency/                          the firm.
inconsistency of provided information.
However, the exact references of secon-                    It is the entity theory that contributes to
dary source are not elicited here in order                 fraud because when the company is suc-
to not disclose information about the                      cessful, in terms of a positive net in-
names of the organizations interviewed.                    come, money can be distributed to
                                                           shareholders. In this case, if fraudulent
Theoretical Framework: Entity Theory                       reporting occurs then this net income or
                                                           loss has the potential to state in a way
The entity theory is based on the simple                   that goes far away from the truth and
equation that assets are equal to equities                 fairness. More successful a company is
(liabilities plus shareholder’s eq-                        the one that distributed more money to
uity). Assets and liabilities are consid-                  the shareholders. If a company is suc-
ered to be resources and obligations of                    cessful they can raise additional capital
the entity itself, but not the shareholders                based on the past distributions and the
or proprietors. If management is com-                      predicted future distributions. The pro-
mitting fraudulent reporting, the number                   prietary theory can contribute to fraud
within this equation will not be cor-                      on the basis that executives are tempted
rect. Management over valuating one or                     to record assets and liabilities inappro-
several assets can greatly change the                      priately to increase their wealth. Share-
company’s financial statements. The                        holders are also seeking to invest in a
difference between liabilities and share-                  company with an increasing net income
holder’s equity is that rights of the credi-               so that they may receive higher divi-
tors can be determined independently of                    dends. Management may be pressured
other valuations- if the firm is sol-                      by shareholder to show a positive net
vent. The stockholder’s rights are meas-                   income for this reason.
ured by the valuation of the assets origi-
nally invested plus any reinvested earn-
ings and revaluations. The equity hold-                    3. Empirical Findings and Analysis
ers of the firm have the right to receive
dividends and share in net assets in the                   We recently interviewed Kevin Houri-
event that the firm should cease opera-                    han who is a chartered accountant with
70    M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73


Company X and asked him his opinion                       counting functions. Kevin’s opinion in
on the prevention of FFR through audit-                   short is that a company needs to have the
ing. Kevin’s opinion is that “an audit is                 proper controls in place to prevent fraud
not an effective means of detecting or                    and not rely on their audit. Detecting
preventing fraudulent financial reporting                 fraud is not the main goal of the audit.
within a large company” like the one he                   The audit is done primarily to test the
works for. “Audits usually run with the                   financial statements of the company for
assumption that management has integ-                     accuracy but not for investigating fraud.
rity. An auditor would not normally                       If the audit were to test fraud it would be
take a job if they suspected that manage-                 cost prohibitive due to the great deal of
ment was corrupt.” Auditors are more                      time would possibly be involved in it.
looking for errors and omissions that are
honest mistakes. Kevin’s take on the                      A second interview was conducted with
matter is that of course they do look                     Shelly Roy a supervisor with Company
through internal controls to see if the                   Z. We asked for her opinion on whether
company has the proper controls and                       FFR could be prevented through audit.
policies, however if fraud were happen-                   She felt that audit was not an effective
ing it would be very hard for an auditor                  means to prevent FFR. Shelley elabo-
to detect through sampling and testing.                   rates by explaining “the main focus on
                                                          an audit is not to detect or prevent fraud
If the company is large with several em-                  but is to provide reasonable assurance
ployees it should be harder for fraudu-                   that financial statements are free from
lent reporting to occur within the organi-                material misstatements”. Shelley feels it
zation. Large scale companies often                       is the controls that the company has and
have well designed controls which make                    enforces that prevent fraud. She noted
it harder for fraud to occur. Depending                   that “an audit examines evidence that
on how well planned and executed the                      supports the amounts and disclosures in
fraud was (even if the auditor were to                    the financial statements. As part of audit
look at that) the particular entries in-                  procedures, controls are reviewed to de-
volved may not catch fraud. Kevin be-                     velop an understanding of risk that may
lieves that usually when management                       be associated with amounts in the finan-
decides to peruse at fraudulent reporting                 cial statements”. An example of a con-
action, it is generally well planned and                  trol procedure is the Company having
executed which makes it harder for audi-                  segregation of duties for banking. This
tors to detect.                                           means that there are two signing authori-
                                                          ties and those who can prepare cheques
Kevin also points out that it would be                    are not signing authorities. This prevents
very hard for one person to commit                        the individual from issuing an unauthor-
fraud within an organization. An exam-                    ized payment to themselves. During an
ple that he provided us with would be                     audit, if there was not proper segregation
booking a sale. “If an employee booked                    of duties, control risk would be assessed
a nonexistent sale it would most likely                   at an elevated level and more sampling
get noticed by someone in another group                   and testing on cash would be required.
such as collections or banking.” This
would be much easier in a smaller com-                    Well (2002) says, “I don’t think an audi-
pany where one person does many ac-                       tor could uncover fraud if he stepped on
M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73   71


it”. Such opinion may be a negative                        documents. Enron used offshore entities
opinion on our audit system, but accord-                   to create the illusion that they were more
ing to Craig A. Latshaw, in his article on                 profitable than they actually were which
FFR, he mentions that the Government                       drove up the stock price even though
and Accounting Profession React, there                     they were actually losing money. Only
may be some truth to it. The report                        the executives knew of the existence of
highlights that although the Sarbanes-                     these offshore accounts that were actu-
Oxley Act and initiatives that have been                   ally hiding the losses, the investors knew
started by the AICPA attempt to reduce                     nothing about it. At the same time those
fraud but they are not enough. There are                   executives were working on insider in-
still some large issues unresolved as far                  formation and trading millions of dollars
as FFR is concerned. Management can                        worth of Enron stock. This took several
still override internal controls in order to               years to unravel and went undetected by
produce FFR. As started in Latshaw’s                       auditors. The Enron scandal brought to
article “unfortunately, the majority of                    light potential conflicts of interest be-
work carried on by auditors using the                      tween consultancy and auditing work
current system concentrates on the dis-                    and the need for tighter regulation on
covery of unintentional errors which,                      financial derivatives trading. Enron is
with an adequate system of internal con-                   proof that an audit cannot prevent fraud
trol, will be detected by the company’s                    when the accounting firm is in collusion
accounting system” (Latshaw, 2002).                        with the company committing fraud.
After conducting the interviews and
based on the empirical findings both                       After the fall of Enron some of the other
Kevin and Shelly are correct in stating                    companies that Arthur Anderson repre-
that internal controls play a large role in                sented were investigated. Qwest Com-
the prevention of FFR but not the audit.                   munications was subsequently reviewed
It is however evident that when the in-                    and it was found that they had inappro-
ternal controls fail and managements                       priately recognized revenue and four
greed blinds them to their ethical duties,                 executives including the CFO were
auditors should be looking for ‘red flags’                 charged with conspiracy to commit an
even in the most prominent companies.                      offense against the U.S., securities fraud,
The audits preformed by Arthur Ander-                      making false statements, and wire fraud
son did not detect or prevent fraud in                     affecting a financial institution.     An-
many companies but may in fact have                        other communication giant (WorldCom)
contributed to it.                                         also fall victim to fraudulent reporting in
                                                           June of 2002. WorldCom announces that
The Enron financial scandal perhaps the                    they have been over stating profits by
most discussed case of fraudulent report-                  classifying routine expenses as capital
ing revealed in late 2001 which led to its                 expenditures a month later WorldCom
bankruptcy. This scandal also caused                       has filed for bankruptcy. CEO, Bernie
the dissolution of Arthur Anderson, i.e.                   Webbers is tried and convicted of falsi-
Enron’s accounting firm (which at the                      fying regulatory filings with the U.S.
time was one of the world’s top five ac-                   Securities and Exchange Commission in
counting firms), when it was discovered                    2001 and 2002.
that they had destroyed important audit
72    M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73


4. Conclusion and Recommendation                          occurred, the company's net worth on
                                                          the financial statements will likely not
Empirical evidence demonstrates that                      be correct. Represented by the equation,
audit cannot solely detect and prevent                    i.e. Assets – Liabilities = Proprietor’s
FFR, or say, an audit is not enough to                    Equity. The proprietor owns the assets
prevent and detect fraudulent reporting.                  and liabilities, and therefore, the liabili-
It appears that although fraud has higher                 ties are negative assets of the proprietor
audit risk and can cause an audit to fail                 making such equation balance sheet cen-
but it still receives the least amount of                 tered. Bookkeeping can be viewed as
attention. Empirical evidence supports                    the proprietor accounting for his own
that the audit structure needs to be re-                  property, and such a view can be
vised in light of the numerous fraud                      adapted to corporations as well because
cases that are being exposed. Employ-                     they are accountable to shareholders for
ees need to be educated so that they can                  the profitability of their investment.
better understand internal controls and                   When the corporation is profitable and
their role in the organizations. Compa-                   retained earnings are high then share-
nies need to evaluate their controls and                  holders are having access to higher
scrutinize their internal audit, or audit                 amount of wealth (as form of dividends).
committees, to ensure that gaps that
cause ‘red flags’ are filled. It is found in              The origins of the proprietary theory
the empirical evidence that companies                     have been traced, in Britain, to Malcomb
should not just simply rely on the yearly                 (1718) who distinguished transactions
audit to detect fraud but should take pre-                that produced profit and subsequently
ventive control measures.                                 increased proprietors’ capital, from
                                                          those which did not. The theory was
The research results, i.e. empirical evi-                 further developed by Stephens (1735)
dence, do not seem to be consistent with                  and Fulton (1800), and was fully fledged
the entity theory but more in line of the                 by Conhelm (1818). He added the alge-
arguments of proprietary theory. Man-                     braic approach to transaction analysis
agement continuously experiences out-                     with transactions affecting the account-
side pressures to increase profits. Such                  ing equation (by increasing or decreas-
pressures mostly come from the share-                     ing capital, assets and liabilities) and this
holders in order to receive the benefits                  study finds the evidence to support that
of their proprietorship/shareholdings,                    notion rather than the consideration of
though a business organization is an in-                  business entity that prevent FFR.
dependent entity. Moreover, competitive
tendency of companies - not just simply
want to maintain their current size but                   References
they want to grow, also creating the
pressure on management to increase and                    Carpenter, Brian, W. (2001) “Analyzing
maintain higher stock value.                                   Organizational Fraud”, The Inter-
                                                               nal Auditor, April : 33-38.
The objective of the proprietary theory is                CBC News. (2006) “The WorldCom
the determination and analysis of the                          Story” CBC News Online. Sep-
proprietor’s net worth. In the case of                         tember 26, http://www.cbc.ca/
fraudulent reporting -if in fact fraud has                     news/background/worldcom/
M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73   73


Latshaw, Craig A. (2003) “Fraudulent                             Accountancy, April, pp. 41-48.
      financial reporting: The govern-                     Ulinski, Michael. (2006) “An Analysis
      ment and accounting profession                             of small company frauds and im-
      react”, Entrpreneur.com Review                             plications for auditors in detecting
      o f       b u s i n e s s .                                frauds”, ASBBS E-Journal Vol. 2,
      www.entrepreneur.com/                                      No. 1. www.asbbs.org
      t r a d e j o u r n a l s /                          Warrick, Shane C., & Riner, H. Sam.
      article/102270927.html                                     “An analysis of business students
Messier, William F., Jr., & Emby, Craig.                         understanding of fraudulent finan-
      (2004) Auditing and Assurance                              cial reporting”, Journal of Busi-
      Services: A Systematic Approach.                           ness Administration Online.
      Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson                               Spring 2004, Vol. 2, No. 2.
      Limited, Vol. 83, pp. 195-207.                             Jabo.atu.edu/spring2004/
The Committee of Sponsoring Organiza-                            wattickJABAOSpring20004.pdf
      tions of the Treadway Commis-                        Weber, Toby. (2003)“Four former Qwest
      sion (1997) “Fraudulent Financial                          execs indicted” Telephonyonline.
      Reporting: 1987-1997-An Analy-                             February 25, . http://
      sis of U.S. Public Companies”.                             telephonyonline.com/finance/web/
      Section I www.cos o.or g/                                  telecom_four_qwest_execs/
      p u b l i c a t i o n s /                            Wells, Joseph T. (2001) “Why Employ-
      e       x     e      c     u     -                          ees Commit Fraud”. Journal of
      tive_summary_fraudulent_financi                             Accountancy Online. February
      al_reporting.htm                                            www.cicpa.org/pubs/jofa/
Thomas, William, C. (2002) “The Rise                              feb2001/wells.htm
      and Fall of Enron”, Journal of
International Journals Call for Paper
The IISTE, a U.S. publisher, is currently hosting the academic journals listed below. The peer review process of the following journals
usually takes LESS THAN 14 business days and IISTE usually publishes a qualified article within 30 days. Authors should
send their full paper to the following email address. More information can be found in the IISTE website : www.iiste.org

Business, Economics, Finance and Management               PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
European Journal of Business and Management               EJBM@iiste.org
Research Journal of Finance and Accounting                RJFA@iiste.org
Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development          JESD@iiste.org
Information and Knowledge Management                      IKM@iiste.org
Developing Country Studies                                DCS@iiste.org
Industrial Engineering Letters                            IEL@iiste.org


Physical Sciences, Mathematics and Chemistry              PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
Journal of Natural Sciences Research                      JNSR@iiste.org
Chemistry and Materials Research                          CMR@iiste.org
Mathematical Theory and Modeling                          MTM@iiste.org
Advances in Physics Theories and Applications             APTA@iiste.org
Chemical and Process Engineering Research                 CPER@iiste.org


Engineering, Technology and Systems                       PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
Computer Engineering and Intelligent Systems              CEIS@iiste.org
Innovative Systems Design and Engineering                 ISDE@iiste.org
Journal of Energy Technologies and Policy                 JETP@iiste.org
Information and Knowledge Management                      IKM@iiste.org
Control Theory and Informatics                            CTI@iiste.org
Journal of Information Engineering and Applications       JIEA@iiste.org
Industrial Engineering Letters                            IEL@iiste.org
Network and Complex Systems                               NCS@iiste.org


Environment, Civil, Materials Sciences                    PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
Journal of Environment and Earth Science                  JEES@iiste.org
Civil and Environmental Research                          CER@iiste.org
Journal of Natural Sciences Research                      JNSR@iiste.org
Civil and Environmental Research                          CER@iiste.org


Life Science, Food and Medical Sciences                   PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
Journal of Natural Sciences Research                      JNSR@iiste.org
Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare            JBAH@iiste.org
Food Science and Quality Management                       FSQM@iiste.org
Chemistry and Materials Research                          CMR@iiste.org


Education, and other Social Sciences                      PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL
Journal of Education and Practice                         JEP@iiste.org
Journal of Law, Policy and Globalization                  JLPG@iiste.org                       Global knowledge sharing:
New Media and Mass Communication                          NMMC@iiste.org                       EBSCO, Index Copernicus, Ulrich's
Journal of Energy Technologies and Policy                 JETP@iiste.org                       Periodicals Directory, JournalTOCS, PKP
Historical Research Letter                                HRL@iiste.org                        Open Archives Harvester, Bielefeld
                                                                                               Academic Search Engine, Elektronische
Public Policy and Administration Research                 PPAR@iiste.org                       Zeitschriftenbibliothek EZB, Open J-Gate,
International Affairs and Global Strategy                 IAGS@iiste.org                       OCLC WorldCat, Universe Digtial Library ,
Research on Humanities and Social Sciences                RHSS@iiste.org                       NewJour, Google Scholar.

Developing Country Studies                                DCS@iiste.org                        IISTE is member of CrossRef. All journals
Arts and Design Studies                                   ADS@iiste.org                        have high IC Impact Factor Values (ICV).

Mais conteúdo relacionado

Mais procurados

operational risk managemnt
operational risk managemntoperational risk managemnt
operational risk managemntAshima Thakur
 
Ebook audit case study
Ebook audit case studyEbook audit case study
Ebook audit case studyngocnhian
 
BCSCI Rosenblatt 2017 - Mike Pinedo slides
BCSCI Rosenblatt 2017 - Mike Pinedo slidesBCSCI Rosenblatt 2017 - Mike Pinedo slides
BCSCI Rosenblatt 2017 - Mike Pinedo slidesThe Boeing Center
 
Operational risk-white-paper
Operational risk-white-paperOperational risk-white-paper
Operational risk-white-paperVincenzo Dimase
 
Fraud Prevention, Mitigation and Management Practices In Nigerian Firms
Fraud Prevention, Mitigation and Management Practices In Nigerian FirmsFraud Prevention, Mitigation and Management Practices In Nigerian Firms
Fraud Prevention, Mitigation and Management Practices In Nigerian FirmsIOSR Journals
 
Operational Risk Management Under Basel II & Basel III
Operational Risk Management Under Basel II & Basel IIIOperational Risk Management Under Basel II & Basel III
Operational Risk Management Under Basel II & Basel IIIEneni Oduwole
 
Operational Risk Management in China
Operational Risk Management in ChinaOperational Risk Management in China
Operational Risk Management in ChinaKapronasia
 
Operational Risk Management Oct 4
Operational Risk Management Oct 4Operational Risk Management Oct 4
Operational Risk Management Oct 4av vedpuriswar
 
Risk management basel ii
Risk management basel iiRisk management basel ii
Risk management basel iiUjjwal 'Shanu'
 
Introduction to Operational Risk Management for Bank Junior Officers in India
Introduction to Operational Risk Management for Bank Junior Officers in IndiaIntroduction to Operational Risk Management for Bank Junior Officers in India
Introduction to Operational Risk Management for Bank Junior Officers in Indiamlvenkat
 
Operational risk (by ms.sweta vijuraj)
Operational risk (by ms.sweta vijuraj)Operational risk (by ms.sweta vijuraj)
Operational risk (by ms.sweta vijuraj)Saras Singh
 
Operational Risk Management under BASEL era
Operational Risk Management under BASEL eraOperational Risk Management under BASEL era
Operational Risk Management under BASEL eraTreat Risk
 
Operational risk & incident reporting
Operational risk &  incident reportingOperational risk &  incident reporting
Operational risk & incident reportingShivaLeela Choudary
 
Dubai Nov08 Erm Gs Khoo
Dubai Nov08 Erm Gs KhooDubai Nov08 Erm Gs Khoo
Dubai Nov08 Erm Gs KhooGuan Khoo
 

Mais procurados (19)

operational risk managemnt
operational risk managemntoperational risk managemnt
operational risk managemnt
 
Risk Management Premier
Risk Management PremierRisk Management Premier
Risk Management Premier
 
Market Risk Management
Market Risk ManagementMarket Risk Management
Market Risk Management
 
Ebook audit case study
Ebook audit case studyEbook audit case study
Ebook audit case study
 
BCSCI Rosenblatt 2017 - Mike Pinedo slides
BCSCI Rosenblatt 2017 - Mike Pinedo slidesBCSCI Rosenblatt 2017 - Mike Pinedo slides
BCSCI Rosenblatt 2017 - Mike Pinedo slides
 
Operational risk-white-paper
Operational risk-white-paperOperational risk-white-paper
Operational risk-white-paper
 
Fraud Prevention, Mitigation and Management Practices In Nigerian Firms
Fraud Prevention, Mitigation and Management Practices In Nigerian FirmsFraud Prevention, Mitigation and Management Practices In Nigerian Firms
Fraud Prevention, Mitigation and Management Practices In Nigerian Firms
 
Operation Risk Management 03
Operation Risk Management 03Operation Risk Management 03
Operation Risk Management 03
 
Operational Risk Management Under Basel II & Basel III
Operational Risk Management Under Basel II & Basel IIIOperational Risk Management Under Basel II & Basel III
Operational Risk Management Under Basel II & Basel III
 
Fraud risk assessment
Fraud risk assessmentFraud risk assessment
Fraud risk assessment
 
Operational Risk Management in China
Operational Risk Management in ChinaOperational Risk Management in China
Operational Risk Management in China
 
Operational Risk Management Oct 4
Operational Risk Management Oct 4Operational Risk Management Oct 4
Operational Risk Management Oct 4
 
Risk management basel ii
Risk management basel iiRisk management basel ii
Risk management basel ii
 
Introduction to Operational Risk Management for Bank Junior Officers in India
Introduction to Operational Risk Management for Bank Junior Officers in IndiaIntroduction to Operational Risk Management for Bank Junior Officers in India
Introduction to Operational Risk Management for Bank Junior Officers in India
 
Operational risk (by ms.sweta vijuraj)
Operational risk (by ms.sweta vijuraj)Operational risk (by ms.sweta vijuraj)
Operational risk (by ms.sweta vijuraj)
 
Operational Risk Management under BASEL era
Operational Risk Management under BASEL eraOperational Risk Management under BASEL era
Operational Risk Management under BASEL era
 
Operational risk & incident reporting
Operational risk &  incident reportingOperational risk &  incident reporting
Operational risk & incident reporting
 
Dubai Nov08 Erm Gs Khoo
Dubai Nov08 Erm Gs KhooDubai Nov08 Erm Gs Khoo
Dubai Nov08 Erm Gs Khoo
 
Modern operational risk
Modern operational riskModern operational risk
Modern operational risk
 

Destaque

LờI DạY CủA đứC PhậT Ca DiếP
LờI DạY CủA đứC PhậT Ca DiếPLờI DạY CủA đứC PhậT Ca DiếP
LờI DạY CủA đứC PhậT Ca DiếPtetecehat
 
Apdsi redes sociais e empresas - luis vidigal - maio 2012
Apdsi   redes sociais e empresas - luis vidigal - maio 2012Apdsi   redes sociais e empresas - luis vidigal - maio 2012
Apdsi redes sociais e empresas - luis vidigal - maio 2012Luis Vidigal
 
חדשנות בחוויית לקוח
חדשנות בחוויית לקוחחדשנות בחוויית לקוח
חדשנות בחוויית לקוחassafbk
 
A very splitter christmas 2
A very splitter christmas 2A very splitter christmas 2
A very splitter christmas 2Chris Westfall
 

Destaque (7)

LờI DạY CủA đứC PhậT Ca DiếP
LờI DạY CủA đứC PhậT Ca DiếPLờI DạY CủA đứC PhậT Ca DiếP
LờI DạY CủA đứC PhậT Ca DiếP
 
Customer in control
Customer in controlCustomer in control
Customer in control
 
Greg
GregGreg
Greg
 
Apdsi redes sociais e empresas - luis vidigal - maio 2012
Apdsi   redes sociais e empresas - luis vidigal - maio 2012Apdsi   redes sociais e empresas - luis vidigal - maio 2012
Apdsi redes sociais e empresas - luis vidigal - maio 2012
 
חדשנות בחוויית לקוח
חדשנות בחוויית לקוחחדשנות בחוויית לקוח
חדשנות בחוויית לקוח
 
A very splitter christmas 2
A very splitter christmas 2A very splitter christmas 2
A very splitter christmas 2
 
Testinng
TestinngTestinng
Testinng
 

Semelhante a 11.isea vol 0004www.iiste.org call for paper no 1 pp. 65-73

Accounting Frauds A Review Of Literature
Accounting Frauds  A Review Of LiteratureAccounting Frauds  A Review Of Literature
Accounting Frauds A Review Of LiteratureTony Lisko
 
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G & A U D .docx
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G &  A U D .docxAssessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G &  A U D .docx
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G & A U D .docxdavezstarr61655
 
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G & A U D .docx
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G &  A U D .docxAssessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G &  A U D .docx
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G & A U D .docxfredharris32
 
C492227.pdf
C492227.pdfC492227.pdf
C492227.pdfaijbm
 
1 2Cheat Sheet on Evidence and DocumentationACC491J.docx
1     2Cheat Sheet on Evidence and DocumentationACC491J.docx1     2Cheat Sheet on Evidence and DocumentationACC491J.docx
1 2Cheat Sheet on Evidence and DocumentationACC491J.docxhoney725342
 
Computer aided audit techniques and fraud detection
Computer aided audit techniques and fraud detectionComputer aided audit techniques and fraud detection
Computer aided audit techniques and fraud detectionAlexander Decker
 
Accounting fraud at Worldcom
Accounting fraud at WorldcomAccounting fraud at Worldcom
Accounting fraud at Worldcomjonah1137
 
Designing Effective Financial Controls - Leveraging the Internal Control Fram...
Designing Effective Financial Controls - Leveraging the Internal Control Fram...Designing Effective Financial Controls - Leveraging the Internal Control Fram...
Designing Effective Financial Controls - Leveraging the Internal Control Fram...Stephen G. Lynch
 
Nigerian banking fr
Nigerian banking frNigerian banking fr
Nigerian banking frKinfe Teka
 
Brennan, Niamh and Gray, Sidney J. [2005] The Impact of Materiality: Accounti...
Brennan, Niamh and Gray, Sidney J. [2005] The Impact of Materiality: Accounti...Brennan, Niamh and Gray, Sidney J. [2005] The Impact of Materiality: Accounti...
Brennan, Niamh and Gray, Sidney J. [2005] The Impact of Materiality: Accounti...Prof Niamh M. Brennan
 
Internal Audit And Review Reports
Internal Audit And Review ReportsInternal Audit And Review Reports
Internal Audit And Review ReportsLaura Martin
 
The changing role of internal audit
The changing role of internal auditThe changing role of internal audit
The changing role of internal auditaakash malhotra
 
Auditor Independence And Financial Statements
Auditor Independence And Financial StatementsAuditor Independence And Financial Statements
Auditor Independence And Financial StatementsNatasha Barnett
 
Top Internal Audit Priorities for Financial Services Organizations, 2016
Top Internal Audit Priorities for Financial Services Organizations, 2016Top Internal Audit Priorities for Financial Services Organizations, 2016
Top Internal Audit Priorities for Financial Services Organizations, 2016jennyhollingworth
 
The effect of risk based audit approach on the implementation of internal co...
	The effect of risk based audit approach on the implementation of internal co...	The effect of risk based audit approach on the implementation of internal co...
The effect of risk based audit approach on the implementation of internal co...inventionjournals
 
Evaluation of the effect of monitoring and control activities on fraud detect...
Evaluation of the effect of monitoring and control activities on fraud detect...Evaluation of the effect of monitoring and control activities on fraud detect...
Evaluation of the effect of monitoring and control activities on fraud detect...Alexander Decker
 
Whistle blowing and financial reporting key issues and
Whistle blowing and financial reporting  key issues andWhistle blowing and financial reporting  key issues and
Whistle blowing and financial reporting key issues andSowmya S Gowri S
 

Semelhante a 11.isea vol 0004www.iiste.org call for paper no 1 pp. 65-73 (20)

Accounting Frauds A Review Of Literature
Accounting Frauds  A Review Of LiteratureAccounting Frauds  A Review Of Literature
Accounting Frauds A Review Of Literature
 
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G & A U D .docx
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G &  A U D .docxAssessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G &  A U D .docx
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G & A U D .docx
 
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G & A U D .docx
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G &  A U D .docxAssessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G &  A U D .docx
Assessment of Tone at the TopA C C O U N T I N G & A U D .docx
 
Fraud Deterrence
Fraud DeterrenceFraud Deterrence
Fraud Deterrence
 
Audit Committee
Audit CommitteeAudit Committee
Audit Committee
 
C492227.pdf
C492227.pdfC492227.pdf
C492227.pdf
 
1 2Cheat Sheet on Evidence and DocumentationACC491J.docx
1     2Cheat Sheet on Evidence and DocumentationACC491J.docx1     2Cheat Sheet on Evidence and DocumentationACC491J.docx
1 2Cheat Sheet on Evidence and DocumentationACC491J.docx
 
Computer aided audit techniques and fraud detection
Computer aided audit techniques and fraud detectionComputer aided audit techniques and fraud detection
Computer aided audit techniques and fraud detection
 
Accounting fraud at Worldcom
Accounting fraud at WorldcomAccounting fraud at Worldcom
Accounting fraud at Worldcom
 
Designing Effective Financial Controls - Leveraging the Internal Control Fram...
Designing Effective Financial Controls - Leveraging the Internal Control Fram...Designing Effective Financial Controls - Leveraging the Internal Control Fram...
Designing Effective Financial Controls - Leveraging the Internal Control Fram...
 
Nigerian banking fr
Nigerian banking frNigerian banking fr
Nigerian banking fr
 
Brennan, Niamh and Gray, Sidney J. [2005] The Impact of Materiality: Accounti...
Brennan, Niamh and Gray, Sidney J. [2005] The Impact of Materiality: Accounti...Brennan, Niamh and Gray, Sidney J. [2005] The Impact of Materiality: Accounti...
Brennan, Niamh and Gray, Sidney J. [2005] The Impact of Materiality: Accounti...
 
Internal Audit And Review Reports
Internal Audit And Review ReportsInternal Audit And Review Reports
Internal Audit And Review Reports
 
The changing role of internal audit
The changing role of internal auditThe changing role of internal audit
The changing role of internal audit
 
Auditor Independence And Financial Statements
Auditor Independence And Financial StatementsAuditor Independence And Financial Statements
Auditor Independence And Financial Statements
 
Top Internal Audit Priorities for Financial Services Organizations, 2016
Top Internal Audit Priorities for Financial Services Organizations, 2016Top Internal Audit Priorities for Financial Services Organizations, 2016
Top Internal Audit Priorities for Financial Services Organizations, 2016
 
The effect of risk based audit approach on the implementation of internal co...
	The effect of risk based audit approach on the implementation of internal co...	The effect of risk based audit approach on the implementation of internal co...
The effect of risk based audit approach on the implementation of internal co...
 
Evaluation of the effect of monitoring and control activities on fraud detect...
Evaluation of the effect of monitoring and control activities on fraud detect...Evaluation of the effect of monitoring and control activities on fraud detect...
Evaluation of the effect of monitoring and control activities on fraud detect...
 
Whistle blowing and financial reporting key issues and
Whistle blowing and financial reporting  key issues andWhistle blowing and financial reporting  key issues and
Whistle blowing and financial reporting key issues and
 
Mcclain Plastics
Mcclain PlasticsMcclain Plastics
Mcclain Plastics
 

Mais de Alexander Decker

Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...
Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...
Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...Alexander Decker
 
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale in
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale inA validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale in
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale inAlexander Decker
 
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websites
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websitesA usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websites
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websitesAlexander Decker
 
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksA universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksAlexander Decker
 
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized d
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized dA unique common fixed point theorems in generalized d
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized dAlexander Decker
 
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistance
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistanceA trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistance
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistanceAlexander Decker
 
A transformational generative approach towards understanding al-istifham
A transformational  generative approach towards understanding al-istifhamA transformational  generative approach towards understanding al-istifham
A transformational generative approach towards understanding al-istifhamAlexander Decker
 
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibia
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibiaA time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibia
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibiaAlexander Decker
 
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school children
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school childrenA therapy for physical and mental fitness of school children
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school childrenAlexander Decker
 
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksA theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksAlexander Decker
 
A systematic evaluation of link budget for
A systematic evaluation of link budget forA systematic evaluation of link budget for
A systematic evaluation of link budget forAlexander Decker
 
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjab
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjabA synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjab
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjabAlexander Decker
 
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...Alexander Decker
 
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incremental
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incrementalA survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incremental
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incrementalAlexander Decker
 
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniques
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniquesA survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniques
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniquesAlexander Decker
 
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo db
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo dbA survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo db
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo dbAlexander Decker
 
A survey on challenges to the media cloud
A survey on challenges to the media cloudA survey on challenges to the media cloud
A survey on challenges to the media cloudAlexander Decker
 
A survey of provenance leveraged
A survey of provenance leveragedA survey of provenance leveraged
A survey of provenance leveragedAlexander Decker
 
A survey of private equity investments in kenya
A survey of private equity investments in kenyaA survey of private equity investments in kenya
A survey of private equity investments in kenyaAlexander Decker
 
A study to measures the financial health of
A study to measures the financial health ofA study to measures the financial health of
A study to measures the financial health ofAlexander Decker
 

Mais de Alexander Decker (20)

Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...
Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...
Abnormalities of hormones and inflammatory cytokines in women affected with p...
 
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale in
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale inA validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale in
A validation of the adverse childhood experiences scale in
 
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websites
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websitesA usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websites
A usability evaluation framework for b2 c e commerce websites
 
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksA universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A universal model for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
 
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized d
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized dA unique common fixed point theorems in generalized d
A unique common fixed point theorems in generalized d
 
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistance
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistanceA trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistance
A trends of salmonella and antibiotic resistance
 
A transformational generative approach towards understanding al-istifham
A transformational  generative approach towards understanding al-istifhamA transformational  generative approach towards understanding al-istifham
A transformational generative approach towards understanding al-istifham
 
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibia
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibiaA time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibia
A time series analysis of the determinants of savings in namibia
 
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school children
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school childrenA therapy for physical and mental fitness of school children
A therapy for physical and mental fitness of school children
 
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banksA theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
A theory of efficiency for managing the marketing executives in nigerian banks
 
A systematic evaluation of link budget for
A systematic evaluation of link budget forA systematic evaluation of link budget for
A systematic evaluation of link budget for
 
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjab
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjabA synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjab
A synthetic review of contraceptive supplies in punjab
 
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...
A synthesis of taylor’s and fayol’s management approaches for managing market...
 
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incremental
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incrementalA survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incremental
A survey paper on sequence pattern mining with incremental
 
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniques
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniquesA survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniques
A survey on live virtual machine migrations and its techniques
 
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo db
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo dbA survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo db
A survey on data mining and analysis in hadoop and mongo db
 
A survey on challenges to the media cloud
A survey on challenges to the media cloudA survey on challenges to the media cloud
A survey on challenges to the media cloud
 
A survey of provenance leveraged
A survey of provenance leveragedA survey of provenance leveraged
A survey of provenance leveraged
 
A survey of private equity investments in kenya
A survey of private equity investments in kenyaA survey of private equity investments in kenya
A survey of private equity investments in kenya
 
A study to measures the financial health of
A study to measures the financial health ofA study to measures the financial health of
A study to measures the financial health of
 

Último

How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...
How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...
How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...SOFTTECHHUB
 
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan Dynamics
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan DynamicsWelding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan Dynamics
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan DynamicsIndiaMART InterMESH Limited
 
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024Adnet Communications
 
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxGo for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxRakhi Bazaar
 
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management Team
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management TeamTechnical Leaders - Working with the Management Team
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management TeamArik Fletcher
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deckHajeJanKamps
 
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdfChris Skinner
 
Onemonitar Android Spy App Features: Explore Advanced Monitoring Capabilities
Onemonitar Android Spy App Features: Explore Advanced Monitoring CapabilitiesOnemonitar Android Spy App Features: Explore Advanced Monitoring Capabilities
Onemonitar Android Spy App Features: Explore Advanced Monitoring CapabilitiesOne Monitar
 
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdf
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdftrending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdf
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdfMintel Group
 
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdfGUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdfDanny Diep To
 
Excvation Safety for safety officers reference
Excvation Safety for safety officers referenceExcvation Safety for safety officers reference
Excvation Safety for safety officers referencessuser2c065e
 
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh JiPsychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Jiastral oracle
 
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxAppkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxappkodes
 
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare Newsletter
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare NewsletterHealthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare Newsletter
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare NewsletterJamesConcepcion7
 
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersEUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersPeter Horsten
 
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDFGuide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDFChandresh Chudasama
 
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQM
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQMMemorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQM
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQMVoces Mineras
 
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdfWSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdfJamesConcepcion7
 
The McKinsey 7S Framework: A Holistic Approach to Harmonizing All Parts of th...
The McKinsey 7S Framework: A Holistic Approach to Harmonizing All Parts of th...The McKinsey 7S Framework: A Holistic Approach to Harmonizing All Parts of th...
The McKinsey 7S Framework: A Holistic Approach to Harmonizing All Parts of th...Operational Excellence Consulting
 

Último (20)

How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...
How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...
How To Simplify Your Scheduling with AI Calendarfly The Hassle-Free Online Bo...
 
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan Dynamics
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan DynamicsWelding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan Dynamics
Welding Electrode Making Machine By Deccan Dynamics
 
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
TriStar Gold Corporate Presentation - April 2024
 
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptxGo for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
Go for Rakhi Bazaar and Pick the Latest Bhaiya Bhabhi Rakhi.pptx
 
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management Team
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management TeamTechnical Leaders - Working with the Management Team
Technical Leaders - Working with the Management Team
 
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deckPitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deck
Pitch Deck Teardown: Xpanceo's $40M Seed deck
 
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf
20220816-EthicsGrade_Scorecard-JP_Morgan_Chase-Q2-63_57.pdf
 
Onemonitar Android Spy App Features: Explore Advanced Monitoring Capabilities
Onemonitar Android Spy App Features: Explore Advanced Monitoring CapabilitiesOnemonitar Android Spy App Features: Explore Advanced Monitoring Capabilities
Onemonitar Android Spy App Features: Explore Advanced Monitoring Capabilities
 
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdf
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdftrending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdf
trending-flavors-and-ingredients-in-salty-snacks-us-2024_Redacted-V2.pdf
 
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdfGUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
GUIDELINES ON USEFUL FORMS IN FREIGHT FORWARDING (F) Danny Diep Toh MBA.pdf
 
Excvation Safety for safety officers reference
Excvation Safety for safety officers referenceExcvation Safety for safety officers reference
Excvation Safety for safety officers reference
 
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh JiPsychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
Psychic Reading | Spiritual Guidance – Astro Ganesh Ji
 
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptxAppkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
Appkodes Tinder Clone Script with Customisable Solutions.pptx
 
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare Newsletter
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare NewsletterHealthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare Newsletter
Healthcare Feb. & Mar. Healthcare Newsletter
 
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exportersEUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
EUDR Info Meeting Ethiopian coffee exporters
 
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDFGuide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
Guide Complete Set of Residential Architectural Drawings PDF
 
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQM
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQMMemorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQM
Memorándum de Entendimiento (MoU) entre Codelco y SQM
 
WAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdf
WAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdfWAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdf
WAM Corporate Presentation April 12 2024.pdf
 
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdfWSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
WSMM Technology February.March Newsletter_vF.pdf
 
The McKinsey 7S Framework: A Holistic Approach to Harmonizing All Parts of th...
The McKinsey 7S Framework: A Holistic Approach to Harmonizing All Parts of th...The McKinsey 7S Framework: A Holistic Approach to Harmonizing All Parts of th...
The McKinsey 7S Framework: A Holistic Approach to Harmonizing All Parts of th...
 

11.isea vol 0004www.iiste.org call for paper no 1 pp. 65-73

  • 1. Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting Vol. 4, No. 1 June 2010 Pp 65-73 Can Audit Prevent Fraudulent Financial Re- porting Practices? Study of Some Motivational Factors in Two Atlantic Canadian Entities Mostaq M. Hussain Patricia Kennedy Victoria Kierstead Faculty of Business University of New Brunswick-Saint John Canada Abstract Much as has been written and done to prevent Fraudulent Financial Reporting (FFR) practices but FFR is still exists in the corporate world. It is common to think about FFR practices in large companies for its greater amount of consequences, though such practises have negative conse- quences in small companies as well. FFR practices raise questions about the legitimacy of con- temporary financial reporting process, roles of auditors, regulators, and analysts in financial reporting. This empirical study attempts to investigate the motivational factors of the preven- tion and detection of FFR through the auditing process. The interviewees were carried out within the entity and proprietary theoretical framework with some accounting related manage- ment in two medium-sized organizations in Atlantic Canada in winter 2008. The findings of this research demonstrate that an audit is not enough to prevent and detect FFR. The audit structure needs to be revised and employees need to be educated in order for them to better understand their internal control process, and their own role. Companies need to evaluate their controls and internal audit process instead of relying on the yearly audit. This study found that the most common methods used for FFR are improper revenue recognition, understatement of expenses/liabilities, and overstated and misappropriation of assets. Keywords: Fraudulent Financial Reporting, Audit, Saint John 1. Background fined as intentional misstatements that can be classified into two types. The Auditors Role first is misstatements arising from Fraudulent Financial Reporting (FFR) It is generally held belief that auditors’ and second misstatements arising from job to find fraud and error as part of the misappropriation of assets. Therefore scope of the engagement for auditing errors are the unintentional acts that financial statements. Fraud can be de- cause financial statements to be mis- Corresponding author: Mostaq M. Hussain is Associate Professor of Accounting at Faculty of Business University of New Brunswick-Saint John, Canada. Tel 1506-648-5805, Fax 1506-648-5574, E-mail: mhussain@unb.ca
  • 2. 66 M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73 stated. As Messier and Emby (2004) known as the US Treadway Commis- elicited a number of reasons of FFR. sion) did an in depth study on FFR in They are: (1). Manipulation, falsifica- 1987. The report outlined ways to pre- tion, or alteration of accounting records vent and detect FFR. “The prevention or supporting documents from which and detection of fraudulent reporting is financial statements are prepared. (2). important because the financial reporting Misrepresentation in, or intentional process relies on the integrity of the re- omission from, the financial statement of ported information.”(Warrick and Riner, events, transaction, or other significant 2004). The Treadway Commission iden- information. (3). Intentional misapplica- tifies the control environment, ‘tone at tion of accounting principles relating to the top,’ as the most important factor in amounts, classification, manner of pres- preventing FFR, it will be senior man- entation, or disclosure. (4). Management agement that is the first defense against override of internal controls that other- FFR. Even though senior management wise may appear to be operating effec- is the first defense in many cases it is tively. However, misappropriation is the senior management who is involved in result of theft of the company’s assets FFR. With increasing pressures from and can include: embezzling cash re- shareholders to maximize earnings it is ceipts, stealing assets, causing the com- often senior managers who feel the most pany to pay for goods or services not pressure to make the organization more received. profitable. Ernst & Young (2000) issued the findings of its general international Fraud can be committed in a number of fraud study (not limited to FFR), which ways. There are several ‘red flags’ men- states that employees committed 82 per- tioned in Warrick and Riner’s (2004) cent of frauds with management being study. According to Warrick and Riner involved in one third of those. (2004), an auditor should look for a number of issues when performing an In the business environment importance audit, like: (I) Unusual or complex trans- should be placed on internal controls as actions, (II) Emphasis of management this is the first defense in preventing on short term earnings, (III) Pressure to fraud on an individual level. Internal meet stock analyst expectations, (IV). controls can be difficult to implement Accounting estimates for valuing things depending on the size of the organiza- such as warranty expenses, (V). Weak tion. Large corporations with hundreds internal controls, (VI). A weak or non- of administrative staff are more likely to active board of directors, and (VII). In- have efficient segregation of duties than centive compensation plans structured an organization that only has a few ad- on high financial performance. ministrative staff. According to COSO, fraudulent reporting occurs most often in According to the Committee of Sponsor- smaller corporations. There are five ing Organizations (COSO, 1999), large components of internal control: control adjusting entries at the end of the quarter environment, risk assessment, control or year that involve revenue or asset ac- activities, information and communica- counts should be considered carefully. tion, and monitoring. The control envi- ronment sets the tone of the organization The National Commission on FFR (also as it is the foundation of all other con-
  • 3. M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73 67 trols. Several circumstances can affect These could include, according to Car- the risk assessment of a corporation. penter (2001): (I). Internal controls as They include (but are not limited) to: the first line of defense. (II). Using inter- new personnel, rapid growth, new tech- nal auditors that report to an audit com- nology, and foreign operations. Control mittee of the board of directors rather activities are the policies and procedures than senior management. (IV). Hold that help to ensure that the appropriate management accountable to the same measures are taken to address the risks. standards of misconduct as non- The controls can include but are not lim- management. (V). Use fraud detection ited to: segregation of duties, under- software. (VI). Effectively communicate standing of control activities and per- ethics and fraud programs to the em- formance reviews. Information and ployees to ensure that employees per- communication refers to the information ceive the programs to be working. system relevant to the financial reporting Moreover, Warrick and Riner (2004) objectives and communication is provid- suggested the appropriate segregation of ing an understanding of individual roles duties, and the need of performing ratio and responsibilities. Pre-assumably, a analyses on firm account balances. well operating information system can Beasley (2000) argues that audit com- reduce the risk of material misstatement mittees should meet at least quarterly, when monitoring assesses the quality of and according to NCFFR (1987), Audit internal control over time. During the committee members should be of the course of an audit these and other inter- firm. nal controls will be evaluated by the auditor to ensure they are sufficient. The Understanding why employees commit auditor will also establish materiality, fraud is a key factor in being able to de- the level of misstatement that will not tect fraud. A study by Hollinger and affect the decision of a reasonable user Clark with 12, 000 employees in the of the financial statements. workforce found that nearly 90% en- gaged in ‘workplace deviance’, which Prevention of Fraud included behavior such as goldbricking, workplace slowdowns, sick time abuses The Treadway Commission cited that and pilferage. On top of that, an aston- education as one way of preventing ishing one-third of employees actually fraud by making those who are responsi- had stolen money or merchandise on the ble for the everyday accounting duties job. (Wells, 2001) There are three fac- and making aware of how fraud is com- tors that contribute to employees com- mitted and then educating them about mitting fraud they are: pressure, oppor- detecting procedure. In addition to edu- tunity, and rationalization. If employees cating employees about how to prevent feel they are not being treated fairly and and detect fraud the board of directors adequately they are more likely to com- can play a key role in preventing fraud. pensate themselves in the form of The board should support the ‘tone at “wages in kind”. Fraud is also commit- the top’ or even set the tone of the or- ted because of financial pressures. Cres- ganization. It is the board who can di- sey (in Wells, 2001) found that the em- rect management to have certain preven- ployees “must perceive an opportunity tion and detection controls in place. to commit and conceal their crimes, and
  • 4. 68 M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73 be able to rationalize their offenses as likely that the manager will not act in the something other than criminal activ- best interest of the owner.” (Messier and ity” (Wells, 2001). Wells also lists a Emby, 2004) By having the corporation number of questions. Whenever they are audited the auditor adds value to infor- answered positively, there should be a mation by increasing its reliability and red flag for fraud motivation. The ques- credibility. tions are follows: Is management compensation tied It is management’s duty to be aware of closely to company value? the consequences of fraudulent reporting Is management dominated by a sin- whether it is legal, social or ethical. The gle person or a small group? news has been dominated in recent years Does management display a signifi- by many scandalous tales of large corpo- cant disregard for regulations or rations committing fraud. For example controls? Enron has had to restate their financial Has management restricted the audi- statements for a total of eight billion dol- tor’s access to documents or person- lars and some of the executives have nel? been charged with committing fraud. Has management set unrealistic fi- Fraud is not limited to corporations. One nancial goals? of the Big Four firms Arthur Anderson, Does management have any [past “was the auditor for a number if entities history of illegal conduct? involved in FFR. The effect of Arthur Is an employee obviously dissatis- Anderson was devastating. Their com- fied? plicity with the scandals ultimately de- Does that employee have a past his- stroyed them.”(Warrick and Riner, tory of dishonesty or illegal con- 2004) duct? Does that employee have known financial pressures, such as exces- 2. Methodology sive debt, bad credit or tax liens? Research Method Has that employee’s lifestyle or be- havior changed significantly? To develop a better understanding of the motivational factor on fraudulent report- The growth of the modern corporation ing and how an audit can detect and pre- has given the rise to absentee owners vent it from control fraud we turned to a (shareholders) and the use of managers prominent Saint John company (X), and (agents) to operate the corporation on a an accounting firm (Z), in order to have day-to-day basis. “The agency relation- a diversified view. Semi structured in- ship between an owner and manager terviews were conducted with each in- produces a natural conflict of interest terviewee on March 20, 2008 and April because of the information asymmetry 4, 2008 respectively. The first inter- this means that, the manager generally viewee is from Company X and the sec- has more information about the ‘true’ ond interviewee is from Company Z. financial position and results of opera- These two were selected to evaluate the tions of the entity than the absentee opinion on auditing from the perspective owner does. If both parties seek to of a large corporation and that of firm. maximize their own self-interest, it is The interviews were conducted on site
  • 5. M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73 69 during an hour long pre-booked appoint- tions upon liquidation. ment. Notes were taken during the inter- views and organizing the interview re- The entity theory is quoted as being sults immediate after the interviews. “income centered”. Any net income or The first interviewee holds a CA and loss of the firm within a given year be- was chosen because of his extensive longs to the firm. In the event that the knowledge of business practices in large firm has a positive net income on the companies. The second interviewee has income statement for the year, will only her BBA and was selected for her be considered income to the sharehold- knowledge in accounting practices from ers if dividends are declared. In this ex- the perspective of a large firm as well as ample the amount of income to the her previous experiences in the industry. shareholders will be the amount of the Following the interviews, secondary dividend that they receive from the sources of information was scrutinized firm. The remaining profit belongs to in order to find the consistency/ the firm. inconsistency of provided information. However, the exact references of secon- It is the entity theory that contributes to dary source are not elicited here in order fraud because when the company is suc- to not disclose information about the cessful, in terms of a positive net in- names of the organizations interviewed. come, money can be distributed to shareholders. In this case, if fraudulent Theoretical Framework: Entity Theory reporting occurs then this net income or loss has the potential to state in a way The entity theory is based on the simple that goes far away from the truth and equation that assets are equal to equities fairness. More successful a company is (liabilities plus shareholder’s eq- the one that distributed more money to uity). Assets and liabilities are consid- the shareholders. If a company is suc- ered to be resources and obligations of cessful they can raise additional capital the entity itself, but not the shareholders based on the past distributions and the or proprietors. If management is com- predicted future distributions. The pro- mitting fraudulent reporting, the number prietary theory can contribute to fraud within this equation will not be cor- on the basis that executives are tempted rect. Management over valuating one or to record assets and liabilities inappro- several assets can greatly change the priately to increase their wealth. Share- company’s financial statements. The holders are also seeking to invest in a difference between liabilities and share- company with an increasing net income holder’s equity is that rights of the credi- so that they may receive higher divi- tors can be determined independently of dends. Management may be pressured other valuations- if the firm is sol- by shareholder to show a positive net vent. The stockholder’s rights are meas- income for this reason. ured by the valuation of the assets origi- nally invested plus any reinvested earn- ings and revaluations. The equity hold- 3. Empirical Findings and Analysis ers of the firm have the right to receive dividends and share in net assets in the We recently interviewed Kevin Houri- event that the firm should cease opera- han who is a chartered accountant with
  • 6. 70 M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73 Company X and asked him his opinion counting functions. Kevin’s opinion in on the prevention of FFR through audit- short is that a company needs to have the ing. Kevin’s opinion is that “an audit is proper controls in place to prevent fraud not an effective means of detecting or and not rely on their audit. Detecting preventing fraudulent financial reporting fraud is not the main goal of the audit. within a large company” like the one he The audit is done primarily to test the works for. “Audits usually run with the financial statements of the company for assumption that management has integ- accuracy but not for investigating fraud. rity. An auditor would not normally If the audit were to test fraud it would be take a job if they suspected that manage- cost prohibitive due to the great deal of ment was corrupt.” Auditors are more time would possibly be involved in it. looking for errors and omissions that are honest mistakes. Kevin’s take on the A second interview was conducted with matter is that of course they do look Shelly Roy a supervisor with Company through internal controls to see if the Z. We asked for her opinion on whether company has the proper controls and FFR could be prevented through audit. policies, however if fraud were happen- She felt that audit was not an effective ing it would be very hard for an auditor means to prevent FFR. Shelley elabo- to detect through sampling and testing. rates by explaining “the main focus on an audit is not to detect or prevent fraud If the company is large with several em- but is to provide reasonable assurance ployees it should be harder for fraudu- that financial statements are free from lent reporting to occur within the organi- material misstatements”. Shelley feels it zation. Large scale companies often is the controls that the company has and have well designed controls which make enforces that prevent fraud. She noted it harder for fraud to occur. Depending that “an audit examines evidence that on how well planned and executed the supports the amounts and disclosures in fraud was (even if the auditor were to the financial statements. As part of audit look at that) the particular entries in- procedures, controls are reviewed to de- volved may not catch fraud. Kevin be- velop an understanding of risk that may lieves that usually when management be associated with amounts in the finan- decides to peruse at fraudulent reporting cial statements”. An example of a con- action, it is generally well planned and trol procedure is the Company having executed which makes it harder for audi- segregation of duties for banking. This tors to detect. means that there are two signing authori- ties and those who can prepare cheques Kevin also points out that it would be are not signing authorities. This prevents very hard for one person to commit the individual from issuing an unauthor- fraud within an organization. An exam- ized payment to themselves. During an ple that he provided us with would be audit, if there was not proper segregation booking a sale. “If an employee booked of duties, control risk would be assessed a nonexistent sale it would most likely at an elevated level and more sampling get noticed by someone in another group and testing on cash would be required. such as collections or banking.” This would be much easier in a smaller com- Well (2002) says, “I don’t think an audi- pany where one person does many ac- tor could uncover fraud if he stepped on
  • 7. M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73 71 it”. Such opinion may be a negative documents. Enron used offshore entities opinion on our audit system, but accord- to create the illusion that they were more ing to Craig A. Latshaw, in his article on profitable than they actually were which FFR, he mentions that the Government drove up the stock price even though and Accounting Profession React, there they were actually losing money. Only may be some truth to it. The report the executives knew of the existence of highlights that although the Sarbanes- these offshore accounts that were actu- Oxley Act and initiatives that have been ally hiding the losses, the investors knew started by the AICPA attempt to reduce nothing about it. At the same time those fraud but they are not enough. There are executives were working on insider in- still some large issues unresolved as far formation and trading millions of dollars as FFR is concerned. Management can worth of Enron stock. This took several still override internal controls in order to years to unravel and went undetected by produce FFR. As started in Latshaw’s auditors. The Enron scandal brought to article “unfortunately, the majority of light potential conflicts of interest be- work carried on by auditors using the tween consultancy and auditing work current system concentrates on the dis- and the need for tighter regulation on covery of unintentional errors which, financial derivatives trading. Enron is with an adequate system of internal con- proof that an audit cannot prevent fraud trol, will be detected by the company’s when the accounting firm is in collusion accounting system” (Latshaw, 2002). with the company committing fraud. After conducting the interviews and based on the empirical findings both After the fall of Enron some of the other Kevin and Shelly are correct in stating companies that Arthur Anderson repre- that internal controls play a large role in sented were investigated. Qwest Com- the prevention of FFR but not the audit. munications was subsequently reviewed It is however evident that when the in- and it was found that they had inappro- ternal controls fail and managements priately recognized revenue and four greed blinds them to their ethical duties, executives including the CFO were auditors should be looking for ‘red flags’ charged with conspiracy to commit an even in the most prominent companies. offense against the U.S., securities fraud, The audits preformed by Arthur Ander- making false statements, and wire fraud son did not detect or prevent fraud in affecting a financial institution. An- many companies but may in fact have other communication giant (WorldCom) contributed to it. also fall victim to fraudulent reporting in June of 2002. WorldCom announces that The Enron financial scandal perhaps the they have been over stating profits by most discussed case of fraudulent report- classifying routine expenses as capital ing revealed in late 2001 which led to its expenditures a month later WorldCom bankruptcy. This scandal also caused has filed for bankruptcy. CEO, Bernie the dissolution of Arthur Anderson, i.e. Webbers is tried and convicted of falsi- Enron’s accounting firm (which at the fying regulatory filings with the U.S. time was one of the world’s top five ac- Securities and Exchange Commission in counting firms), when it was discovered 2001 and 2002. that they had destroyed important audit
  • 8. 72 M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73 4. Conclusion and Recommendation occurred, the company's net worth on the financial statements will likely not Empirical evidence demonstrates that be correct. Represented by the equation, audit cannot solely detect and prevent i.e. Assets – Liabilities = Proprietor’s FFR, or say, an audit is not enough to Equity. The proprietor owns the assets prevent and detect fraudulent reporting. and liabilities, and therefore, the liabili- It appears that although fraud has higher ties are negative assets of the proprietor audit risk and can cause an audit to fail making such equation balance sheet cen- but it still receives the least amount of tered. Bookkeeping can be viewed as attention. Empirical evidence supports the proprietor accounting for his own that the audit structure needs to be re- property, and such a view can be vised in light of the numerous fraud adapted to corporations as well because cases that are being exposed. Employ- they are accountable to shareholders for ees need to be educated so that they can the profitability of their investment. better understand internal controls and When the corporation is profitable and their role in the organizations. Compa- retained earnings are high then share- nies need to evaluate their controls and holders are having access to higher scrutinize their internal audit, or audit amount of wealth (as form of dividends). committees, to ensure that gaps that cause ‘red flags’ are filled. It is found in The origins of the proprietary theory the empirical evidence that companies have been traced, in Britain, to Malcomb should not just simply rely on the yearly (1718) who distinguished transactions audit to detect fraud but should take pre- that produced profit and subsequently ventive control measures. increased proprietors’ capital, from those which did not. The theory was The research results, i.e. empirical evi- further developed by Stephens (1735) dence, do not seem to be consistent with and Fulton (1800), and was fully fledged the entity theory but more in line of the by Conhelm (1818). He added the alge- arguments of proprietary theory. Man- braic approach to transaction analysis agement continuously experiences out- with transactions affecting the account- side pressures to increase profits. Such ing equation (by increasing or decreas- pressures mostly come from the share- ing capital, assets and liabilities) and this holders in order to receive the benefits study finds the evidence to support that of their proprietorship/shareholdings, notion rather than the consideration of though a business organization is an in- business entity that prevent FFR. dependent entity. Moreover, competitive tendency of companies - not just simply want to maintain their current size but References they want to grow, also creating the pressure on management to increase and Carpenter, Brian, W. (2001) “Analyzing maintain higher stock value. Organizational Fraud”, The Inter- nal Auditor, April : 33-38. The objective of the proprietary theory is CBC News. (2006) “The WorldCom the determination and analysis of the Story” CBC News Online. Sep- proprietor’s net worth. In the case of tember 26, http://www.cbc.ca/ fraudulent reporting -if in fact fraud has news/background/worldcom/
  • 9. M. M Hussain, P. Kennedy, V. Kierstead / Issues in Social and Environmental Accounting 1 (2010) 65-73 73 Latshaw, Craig A. (2003) “Fraudulent Accountancy, April, pp. 41-48. financial reporting: The govern- Ulinski, Michael. (2006) “An Analysis ment and accounting profession of small company frauds and im- react”, Entrpreneur.com Review plications for auditors in detecting o f b u s i n e s s . frauds”, ASBBS E-Journal Vol. 2, www.entrepreneur.com/ No. 1. www.asbbs.org t r a d e j o u r n a l s / Warrick, Shane C., & Riner, H. Sam. article/102270927.html “An analysis of business students Messier, William F., Jr., & Emby, Craig. understanding of fraudulent finan- (2004) Auditing and Assurance cial reporting”, Journal of Busi- Services: A Systematic Approach. ness Administration Online. Toronto: McGraw-Hill Ryerson Spring 2004, Vol. 2, No. 2. Limited, Vol. 83, pp. 195-207. Jabo.atu.edu/spring2004/ The Committee of Sponsoring Organiza- wattickJABAOSpring20004.pdf tions of the Treadway Commis- Weber, Toby. (2003)“Four former Qwest sion (1997) “Fraudulent Financial execs indicted” Telephonyonline. Reporting: 1987-1997-An Analy- February 25, . http:// sis of U.S. Public Companies”. telephonyonline.com/finance/web/ Section I www.cos o.or g/ telecom_four_qwest_execs/ p u b l i c a t i o n s / Wells, Joseph T. (2001) “Why Employ- e x e c u - ees Commit Fraud”. Journal of tive_summary_fraudulent_financi Accountancy Online. February al_reporting.htm www.cicpa.org/pubs/jofa/ Thomas, William, C. (2002) “The Rise feb2001/wells.htm and Fall of Enron”, Journal of
  • 10. International Journals Call for Paper The IISTE, a U.S. publisher, is currently hosting the academic journals listed below. The peer review process of the following journals usually takes LESS THAN 14 business days and IISTE usually publishes a qualified article within 30 days. Authors should send their full paper to the following email address. More information can be found in the IISTE website : www.iiste.org Business, Economics, Finance and Management PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL European Journal of Business and Management EJBM@iiste.org Research Journal of Finance and Accounting RJFA@iiste.org Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development JESD@iiste.org Information and Knowledge Management IKM@iiste.org Developing Country Studies DCS@iiste.org Industrial Engineering Letters IEL@iiste.org Physical Sciences, Mathematics and Chemistry PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL Journal of Natural Sciences Research JNSR@iiste.org Chemistry and Materials Research CMR@iiste.org Mathematical Theory and Modeling MTM@iiste.org Advances in Physics Theories and Applications APTA@iiste.org Chemical and Process Engineering Research CPER@iiste.org Engineering, Technology and Systems PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL Computer Engineering and Intelligent Systems CEIS@iiste.org Innovative Systems Design and Engineering ISDE@iiste.org Journal of Energy Technologies and Policy JETP@iiste.org Information and Knowledge Management IKM@iiste.org Control Theory and Informatics CTI@iiste.org Journal of Information Engineering and Applications JIEA@iiste.org Industrial Engineering Letters IEL@iiste.org Network and Complex Systems NCS@iiste.org Environment, Civil, Materials Sciences PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL Journal of Environment and Earth Science JEES@iiste.org Civil and Environmental Research CER@iiste.org Journal of Natural Sciences Research JNSR@iiste.org Civil and Environmental Research CER@iiste.org Life Science, Food and Medical Sciences PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL Journal of Natural Sciences Research JNSR@iiste.org Journal of Biology, Agriculture and Healthcare JBAH@iiste.org Food Science and Quality Management FSQM@iiste.org Chemistry and Materials Research CMR@iiste.org Education, and other Social Sciences PAPER SUBMISSION EMAIL Journal of Education and Practice JEP@iiste.org Journal of Law, Policy and Globalization JLPG@iiste.org Global knowledge sharing: New Media and Mass Communication NMMC@iiste.org EBSCO, Index Copernicus, Ulrich's Journal of Energy Technologies and Policy JETP@iiste.org Periodicals Directory, JournalTOCS, PKP Historical Research Letter HRL@iiste.org Open Archives Harvester, Bielefeld Academic Search Engine, Elektronische Public Policy and Administration Research PPAR@iiste.org Zeitschriftenbibliothek EZB, Open J-Gate, International Affairs and Global Strategy IAGS@iiste.org OCLC WorldCat, Universe Digtial Library , Research on Humanities and Social Sciences RHSS@iiste.org NewJour, Google Scholar. Developing Country Studies DCS@iiste.org IISTE is member of CrossRef. All journals Arts and Design Studies ADS@iiste.org have high IC Impact Factor Values (ICV).